nums
listlengths 4
4
| target
int64 10
100
| search_type
stringclasses 2
values | heuristic
stringclasses 1
value | messages_sos_react
listlengths 2
2
| token_length_sos_react
int64 428
40.6k
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[
98,
76,
43,
91
]
| 70 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [98, 76, 43, 91] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 70. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [98, 76, 43, 91]. Our goal is to produce 70. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 70:[98, 76, 43, 91]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-43=33. \nResulting numbers: [98, 91, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|98-70| + |91-70| + |33-70|)/3 = (28 + 21 + 37)/3 = 28.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 70:[98, 91, 33] Operation: 76-43=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-76=22. \nResulting numbers: [43, 91, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|43-70| + |91-70| + |22-70|)/3 = (27 + 21 + 48)/3 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 70:[43, 91, 22] Operation: 98-76=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-43=55. \nResulting numbers: [76, 91, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|76-70| + |91-70| + |55-70|)/3 = (6 + 21 + 15)/3 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 70:[76, 91, 55] Operation: 98-43=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-91=7. \nResulting numbers: [76, 43, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|76-70| + |43-70| + |7-70|)/3 = (6 + 27 + 63)/3 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 70:[76, 43, 7] Operation: 98-91=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-43=48. \nResulting numbers: [98, 76, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|98-70| + |76-70| + |48-70|)/3 = (28 + 6 + 22)/3 = 18.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 70:[98, 76, 48] Operation: 91-43=48\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 70:[76, 91, 55]. Operations so far : ['98-43=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-55=21. \nResulting numbers: [91, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|91-70| + |21-70|)/2 = (21 + 49)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 70:[91, 21] Operation: 76-55=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-55=36. \nResulting numbers: [76, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|76-70| + |36-70|)/2 = (6 + 34)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 70:[76, 36] Operation: 91-55=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+55=146. \nResulting numbers: [76, 146].\nHeuristic score : (|76-70| + |146-70|)/2 = (6 + 76)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 70:[76, 146] Operation: 91+55=146\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+55=131. \nResulting numbers: [91, 131].\nHeuristic score : (|91-70| + |131-70|)/2 = (21 + 61)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 70:[91, 131] Operation: 76+55=131\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-76=15. \nResulting numbers: [55, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|55-70| + |15-70|)/2 = (15 + 55)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 70:[55, 15] Operation: 91-76=15\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 18.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 70:[98, 76, 48]. Operations so far : ['91-43=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-48=28. \nResulting numbers: [98, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|98-70| + |28-70|)/2 = (28 + 42)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 70:[98, 28] Operation: 76-48=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+48=146. \nResulting numbers: [76, 146].\nHeuristic score : (|76-70| + |146-70|)/2 = (6 + 76)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 70:[76, 146] Operation: 98+48=146\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+48=124. \nResulting numbers: [98, 124].\nHeuristic score : (|98-70| + |124-70|)/2 = (28 + 54)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 70:[98, 124] Operation: 76+48=124\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-48=50. \nResulting numbers: [76, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|76-70| + |50-70|)/2 = (6 + 20)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 70:[76, 50] Operation: 98-48=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-76=22. \nResulting numbers: [48, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|48-70| + |22-70|)/2 = (22 + 48)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 70:[48, 22] Operation: 98-76=22\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 70:[98, 91, 33]. Operations so far : ['76-43=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-33=65. \nResulting numbers: [91, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|91-70| + |65-70|)/2 = (21 + 5)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 70:[91, 65] Operation: 98-33=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-33=58. \nResulting numbers: [98, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|98-70| + |58-70|)/2 = (28 + 12)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 70:[98, 58] Operation: 91-33=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+33=124. \nResulting numbers: [98, 124].\nHeuristic score : (|98-70| + |124-70|)/2 = (28 + 54)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 70:[98, 124] Operation: 91+33=124\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+33=131. \nResulting numbers: [91, 131].\nHeuristic score : (|91-70| + |131-70|)/2 = (21 + 61)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 70:[91, 131] Operation: 98+33=131\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-91=7. \nResulting numbers: [33, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|33-70| + |7-70|)/2 = (37 + 63)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 70:[33, 7] Operation: 98-91=7\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 32.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 70:[43, 91, 22]. Operations so far : ['98-76=22'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+22=113. \nResulting numbers: [43, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|43-70| + |113-70|)/2 = (27 + 43)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 70:[43, 113] Operation: 91+22=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+22=65. \nResulting numbers: [91, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|91-70| + |65-70|)/2 = (21 + 5)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 70:[91, 65] Operation: 43+22=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-22=69. \nResulting numbers: [43, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|43-70| + |69-70|)/2 = (27 + 1)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 70:[43, 69] Operation: 91-22=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-43=48. \nResulting numbers: [22, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|22-70| + |48-70|)/2 = (48 + 22)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 70:[22, 48] Operation: 91-43=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-22=21. \nResulting numbers: [91, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|91-70| + |21-70|)/2 = (21 + 49)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 70:[91, 21] Operation: 43-22=21\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 32.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 70:[76, 43, 7]. Operations so far : ['98-91=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-7=69. \nResulting numbers: [43, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|43-70| + |69-70|)/2 = (27 + 1)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 70:[43, 69] Operation: 76-7=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+7=83. \nResulting numbers: [43, 83].\nHeuristic score : (|43-70| + |83-70|)/2 = (27 + 13)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 70:[43, 83] Operation: 76+7=83\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-7=36. \nResulting numbers: [76, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|76-70| + |36-70|)/2 = (6 + 34)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 70:[76, 36] Operation: 43-7=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+7=50. \nResulting numbers: [76, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|76-70| + |50-70|)/2 = (6 + 20)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 70:[76, 50] Operation: 43+7=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-43=33. \nResulting numbers: [7, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|7-70| + |33-70|)/2 = (63 + 37)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 70:[7, 33] Operation: 76-43=33\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 70:[76, 50]. Operations so far : ['91-43=48', '98-48=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-50=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+50=126. \nResulting numbers: [126].\n126,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*50=3800. \nResulting numbers: [3800].\n3800,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 70:[91, 65]. Operations so far : ['76-43=33', '98-33=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-65=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+65=156. \nResulting numbers: [156].\n156,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91*65=5915. \nResulting numbers: [5915].\n5915,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 70:[76, 50]. Operations so far : ['98-91=7', '43+7=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*50=3800. \nResulting numbers: [3800].\n3800,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-50=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+50=126. \nResulting numbers: [126].\n126,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 70:[91, 65]. Operations so far : ['98-76=22', '43+22=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-65=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+65=156. \nResulting numbers: [156].\n156,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91*65=5915. \nResulting numbers: [5915].\n5915,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 70:[43, 69]. Operations so far : ['98-91=7', '76-7=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-43=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+69=112. \nResulting numbers: [112].\n112,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43*69=2967. \nResulting numbers: [2967].\n2967,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 70:[43, 69]. Operations so far : ['98-76=22', '91-22=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43*69=2967. \nResulting numbers: [2967].\n2967,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-43=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+69=112. \nResulting numbers: [112].\n112,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 70:[76, 36]. Operations so far : ['98-43=55', '91-55=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*36=2736. \nResulting numbers: [2736].\n2736,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-36=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+36=112. \nResulting numbers: [112].\n112,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 70:[98, 58]. Operations so far : ['76-43=33', '91-33=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+58=156. \nResulting numbers: [156].\n156,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98*58=5684. \nResulting numbers: [5684].\n5684,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-58=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 70:[76, 36]. Operations so far : ['98-91=7', '43-7=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-36=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+36=112. \nResulting numbers: [112].\n112,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*36=2736. \nResulting numbers: [2736].\n2736,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 70:[43, 83]. Operations so far : ['98-91=7', '76+7=83'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+83=126. \nResulting numbers: [126].\n126,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43*83=3569. \nResulting numbers: [3569].\n3569,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-43=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,2,1,1: 70:[40]. Operations so far : ['98-43=55', '91-55=36', '76-36=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,0,1,2: 70:[40]. Operations so far : ['76-43=33', '91-33=58', '98-58=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,3,2,0: 70:[40]. Operations so far : ['98-91=7', '43-7=36', '76-36=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,3,1,2: 70:[40]. Operations so far : ['98-91=7', '76+7=83', '83-43=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 70:[91, 21]. Operations so far : ['98-76=22', '43-22=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-21=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,70 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['98-76=22', '43-22=21', '91-21=70']\nRESULT: 70\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 6,469 |
[
27,
4,
85,
8
]
| 90 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [27, 4, 85, 8] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 90. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [27, 4, 85, 8]. Our goal is to produce 90. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 90:[27, 4, 85, 8]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27*4=108. \nResulting numbers: [85, 8, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|85-90| + |8-90| + |108-90|)/3 = (5 + 82 + 18)/3 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 90:[85, 8, 108] Operation: 27*4=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+8=35. \nResulting numbers: [4, 85, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|4-90| + |85-90| + |35-90|)/3 = (86 + 5 + 55)/3 = 48.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 90:[4, 85, 35] Operation: 27+8=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*8=32. \nResulting numbers: [27, 85, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|27-90| + |85-90| + |32-90|)/3 = (63 + 5 + 58)/3 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 90:[27, 85, 32] Operation: 4*8=32\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+85=89. \nResulting numbers: [27, 8, 89].\nHeuristic score : (|27-90| + |8-90| + |89-90|)/3 = (63 + 82 + 1)/3 = 48.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 90:[27, 8, 89] Operation: 4+85=89\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+4=31. \nResulting numbers: [85, 8, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|85-90| + |8-90| + |31-90|)/3 = (5 + 82 + 59)/3 = 48.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 90:[85, 8, 31] Operation: 27+4=31\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 90:[85, 8, 108]. Operations so far : ['27*4=108'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+108=116. \nResulting numbers: [85, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|85-90| + |116-90|)/2 = (5 + 26)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 90:[85, 116] Operation: 8+108=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-8=100. \nResulting numbers: [85, 100].\nHeuristic score : (|85-90| + |100-90|)/2 = (5 + 10)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 90:[85, 100] Operation: 108-8=100\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-8=77. \nResulting numbers: [108, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|108-90| + |77-90|)/2 = (18 + 13)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 90:[108, 77] Operation: 85-8=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+8=93. \nResulting numbers: [108, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|108-90| + |93-90|)/2 = (18 + 3)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 90:[108, 93] Operation: 85+8=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-85=23. \nResulting numbers: [8, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|8-90| + |23-90|)/2 = (82 + 67)/2 = 74.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 90:[8, 23] Operation: 108-85=23\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 42.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 90:[27, 85, 32]. Operations so far : ['4*8=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-27=5. \nResulting numbers: [85, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|85-90| + |5-90|)/2 = (5 + 85)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 90:[85, 5] Operation: 32-27=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+32=117. \nResulting numbers: [27, 117].\nHeuristic score : (|27-90| + |117-90|)/2 = (63 + 27)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 90:[27, 117] Operation: 85+32=117\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+32=59. \nResulting numbers: [85, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|85-90| + |59-90|)/2 = (5 + 31)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 90:[85, 59] Operation: 27+32=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+85=112. \nResulting numbers: [32, 112].\nHeuristic score : (|32-90| + |112-90|)/2 = (58 + 22)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 90:[32, 112] Operation: 27+85=112\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-27=58. \nResulting numbers: [32, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|32-90| + |58-90|)/2 = (58 + 32)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 90:[32, 58] Operation: 85-27=58\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 48.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 90:[4, 85, 35]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-4=31. \nResulting numbers: [85, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|85-90| + |31-90|)/2 = (5 + 59)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 90:[85, 31] Operation: 35-4=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*35=140. \nResulting numbers: [85, 140].\nHeuristic score : (|85-90| + |140-90|)/2 = (5 + 50)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 90:[85, 140] Operation: 4*35=140\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+85=89. \nResulting numbers: [35, 89].\nHeuristic score : (|35-90| + |89-90|)/2 = (55 + 1)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 90:[35, 89] Operation: 4+85=89\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-4=81. \nResulting numbers: [35, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|35-90| + |81-90|)/2 = (55 + 9)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 90:[35, 81] Operation: 85-4=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+35=39. \nResulting numbers: [85, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|85-90| + |39-90|)/2 = (5 + 51)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 90:[85, 39] Operation: 4+35=39\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 48.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 90:[27, 8, 89]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27-8=19. \nResulting numbers: [89, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|89-90| + |19-90|)/2 = (1 + 71)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 90:[89, 19] Operation: 27-8=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+8=35. \nResulting numbers: [89, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|89-90| + |35-90|)/2 = (1 + 55)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 90:[89, 35] Operation: 27+8=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-8=81. \nResulting numbers: [27, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|27-90| + |81-90|)/2 = (63 + 9)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 90:[27, 81] Operation: 89-8=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+89=97. \nResulting numbers: [27, 97].\nHeuristic score : (|27-90| + |97-90|)/2 = (63 + 7)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 90:[27, 97] Operation: 8+89=97\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+89=116. \nResulting numbers: [8, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|8-90| + |116-90|)/2 = (82 + 26)/2 = 54.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 90:[8, 116] Operation: 27+89=116\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 48.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 90:[85, 8, 31]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+31=39. \nResulting numbers: [85, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|85-90| + |39-90|)/2 = (5 + 51)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 90:[85, 39] Operation: 8+31=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31-8=23. \nResulting numbers: [85, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|85-90| + |23-90|)/2 = (5 + 67)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 90:[85, 23] Operation: 31-8=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+8=93. \nResulting numbers: [31, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|31-90| + |93-90|)/2 = (59 + 3)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 90:[31, 93] Operation: 85+8=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-8=77. \nResulting numbers: [31, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|31-90| + |77-90|)/2 = (59 + 13)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 90:[31, 77] Operation: 85-8=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+31=116. \nResulting numbers: [8, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|8-90| + |116-90|)/2 = (82 + 26)/2 = 54.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 90:[8, 116] Operation: 85+31=116\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 90:[85, 100]. Operations so far : ['27*4=108', '108-8=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-85=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*100=8500. \nResulting numbers: [8500].\n8500,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+100=185. \nResulting numbers: [185].\n185,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 90:[108, 93]. Operations so far : ['27*4=108', '85+8=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108*93=10044. \nResulting numbers: [10044].\n10044,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-93=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108+93=201. \nResulting numbers: [201].\n201,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 15.5\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 90:[85, 116]. Operations so far : ['27*4=108', '8+108=116'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+116=201. \nResulting numbers: [201].\n201,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*116=9860. \nResulting numbers: [9860].\n9860,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-85=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 15.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 90:[108, 77]. Operations so far : ['27*4=108', '85-8=77'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-77=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108+77=185. \nResulting numbers: [185].\n185,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108*77=8316. \nResulting numbers: [8316].\n8316,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 90:[85, 59]. Operations so far : ['4*8=32', '27+32=59'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*59=5015. \nResulting numbers: [5015].\n5015,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-59=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+59=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.5\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 90:[85, 140]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '4*35=140'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*140=11900. \nResulting numbers: [11900].\n11900,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+140=225. \nResulting numbers: [225].\n225,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 140-85=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 90:[85, 39]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '4+35=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*39=3315. \nResulting numbers: [3315].\n3315,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-39=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+39=124. \nResulting numbers: [124].\n124,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 90:[35, 89]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '4+85=89'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+89=124. \nResulting numbers: [124].\n124,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-35=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*89=3115. \nResulting numbers: [3115].\n3115,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 90:[85, 39]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31', '8+31=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*39=3315. \nResulting numbers: [3315].\n3315,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+39=124. \nResulting numbers: [124].\n124,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-39=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 90:[89, 35]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89', '27+8=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+35=124. \nResulting numbers: [124].\n124,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-35=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89*35=3115. \nResulting numbers: [3115].\n3115,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 90:[31, 93]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31', '85+8=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-31=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31*93=2883. \nResulting numbers: [2883].\n2883,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93/31=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31+93=124. \nResulting numbers: [124].\n124,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 32.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 90:[85, 31]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '35-4=31'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*31=2635. \nResulting numbers: [2635].\n2635,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+31=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-31=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 32.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 90:[35, 81]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '85-4=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-35=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*81=2835. \nResulting numbers: [2835].\n2835,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+81=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,1,4,2: 90:[124]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '4+35=39', '85+39=124'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,4,0,1: 90:[124]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31', '8+31=39', '85+39=124'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 26\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 90:[116]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '35-4=31', '85+31=116'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 26\nCurrent State #0,1,3,2: 90:[116]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '85-4=81', '35+81=116'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 28\nCurrent State #0,4,2,0: 90:[62]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31', '85+8=93', '93-31=62'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,3,1,0: 90:[124]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89', '27+8=35', '89+35=124'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,1,2,0: 90:[124]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '4+85=89', '35+89=124'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,4,2,3: 90:[124]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31', '85+8=93', '31+93=124'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 35\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 90:[55]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '4*35=140', '140-85=55'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 90:[27, 97]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89', '8+89=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27*97=2619. \nResulting numbers: [2619].\n2619,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-27=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+97=124. \nResulting numbers: [124].\n124,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 36.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 90:[31, 77]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31', '85-8=77'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31+77=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31*77=2387. \nResulting numbers: [2387].\n2387,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-31=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 36\nCurrent State #0,1,0,2: 90:[54]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '35-4=31', '85-31=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,4,3,0: 90:[108]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31', '85-8=77', '31+77=108'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 20\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 90:[70]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89', '8+89=97', '97-27=70'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,3,3,2: 90:[124]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89', '8+89=97', '27+97=124'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 36\nCurrent State #0,3,1,1: 90:[54]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89', '27+8=35', '89-35=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 36.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 90:[85, 23]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31', '31-8=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-23=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*23=1955. \nResulting numbers: [1955].\n1955,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+23=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,4,1,2: 90:[108]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31', '31-8=23', '85+23=108'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 28\nCurrent State #0,4,1,0: 90:[62]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31', '31-8=23', '85-23=62'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 36\nCurrent State #0,1,2,1: 90:[54]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '4+85=89', '89-35=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 36.0\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 90:[27, 81]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89', '89-8=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27*81=2187. \nResulting numbers: [2187].\n2187,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81/27=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+81=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-27=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 36.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 90:[89, 19]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89', '27-8=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+19=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89*19=1691. \nResulting numbers: [1691].\n1691,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-19=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,3,2,2: 90:[108]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89', '89-8=81', '27+81=108'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,3,0,0: 90:[108]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89', '27-8=19', '89+19=108'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 20\nCurrent State #0,3,0,2: 90:[70]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89', '27-8=19', '89-19=70'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 36\nCurrent State #0,3,2,3: 90:[54]. Operations so far : ['4+85=89', '89-8=81', '81-27=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 40.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 90:[32, 112]. Operations so far : ['4*8=32', '27+85=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*112=3584. \nResulting numbers: [3584].\n3584,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+112=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112-32=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,90 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 90:[80]. Operations so far : ['4*8=32', '27+85=112', '112-32=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,1,3,0: 90:[46]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '85-4=81', '81-35=46'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,4,3,2: 90:[46]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31', '85-8=77', '77-31=46'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,4,0,2: 90:[46]. Operations so far : ['27+4=31', '8+31=39', '85-39=46'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,1,4,1: 90:[46]. Operations so far : ['27+8=35', '4+35=39', '85-39=46'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 45.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 90:[32, 58]. Operations so far : ['4*8=32', '85-27=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58-32=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*58=1856. \nResulting numbers: [1856].\n1856,90 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+58=90. \nResulting numbers: [90].\n90,90 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['4*8=32', '85-27=58', '58-32=26']\nRESULT: 26\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 10,662 |
[
51,
74,
53,
17
]
| 13 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [51, 74, 53, 17] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 13. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [51, 74, 53, 17]. Our goal is to produce 13. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 13:[51, 74, 53, 17]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-53=21. \nResulting numbers: [51, 17, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|51-13| + |17-13| + |21-13|)/3 = (38 + 4 + 8)/3 = 16.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 13:[51, 17, 21] Operation: 74-53=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51/17=3. \nResulting numbers: [74, 53, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|74-13| + |53-13| + |3-13|)/3 = (61 + 40 + 10)/3 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 13:[74, 53, 3] Operation: 51/17=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-17=34. \nResulting numbers: [74, 53, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|74-13| + |53-13| + |34-13|)/3 = (61 + 40 + 21)/3 = 40.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 13:[74, 53, 34] Operation: 51-17=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-51=23. \nResulting numbers: [53, 17, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|53-13| + |17-13| + |23-13|)/3 = (40 + 4 + 10)/3 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 13:[53, 17, 23] Operation: 74-51=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-51=2. \nResulting numbers: [74, 17, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|74-13| + |17-13| + |2-13|)/3 = (61 + 4 + 11)/3 = 25.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 13:[74, 17, 2] Operation: 53-51=2\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 13:[51, 17, 21]. Operations so far : ['74-53=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+17=68. \nResulting numbers: [21, 68].\nHeuristic score : (|21-13| + |68-13|)/2 = (8 + 55)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 13:[21, 68] Operation: 51+17=68\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51/17=3. \nResulting numbers: [21, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|21-13| + |3-13|)/2 = (8 + 10)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 13:[21, 3] Operation: 51/17=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-17=34. \nResulting numbers: [21, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|21-13| + |34-13|)/2 = (8 + 21)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 13:[21, 34] Operation: 51-17=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21-17=4. \nResulting numbers: [51, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|51-13| + |4-13|)/2 = (38 + 9)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 13:[51, 4] Operation: 21-17=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-21=30. \nResulting numbers: [17, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|17-13| + |30-13|)/2 = (4 + 17)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 13:[17, 30] Operation: 51-21=30\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 13:[53, 17, 23]. Operations so far : ['74-51=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+23=76. \nResulting numbers: [17, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|17-13| + |76-13|)/2 = (4 + 63)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 13:[17, 76] Operation: 53+23=76\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23-17=6. \nResulting numbers: [53, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|53-13| + |6-13|)/2 = (40 + 7)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 13:[53, 6] Operation: 23-17=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+17=70. \nResulting numbers: [23, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|23-13| + |70-13|)/2 = (10 + 57)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 13:[23, 70] Operation: 53+17=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-17=36. \nResulting numbers: [23, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|23-13| + |36-13|)/2 = (10 + 23)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 13:[23, 36] Operation: 53-17=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-23=30. \nResulting numbers: [17, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|17-13| + |30-13|)/2 = (4 + 17)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 13:[17, 30] Operation: 53-23=30\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 13:[74, 17, 2]. Operations so far : ['53-51=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17-2=15. \nResulting numbers: [74, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|74-13| + |15-13|)/2 = (61 + 2)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 13:[74, 15] Operation: 17-2=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74/2=37. \nResulting numbers: [17, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|17-13| + |37-13|)/2 = (4 + 24)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 13:[17, 37] Operation: 74/2=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+2=76. \nResulting numbers: [17, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|17-13| + |76-13|)/2 = (4 + 63)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 13:[17, 76] Operation: 74+2=76\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-17=57. \nResulting numbers: [2, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|2-13| + |57-13|)/2 = (11 + 44)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 13:[2, 57] Operation: 74-17=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-2=72. \nResulting numbers: [17, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|17-13| + |72-13|)/2 = (4 + 59)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 13:[17, 72] Operation: 74-2=72\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 37.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 13:[74, 53, 3]. Operations so far : ['51/17=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+3=77. \nResulting numbers: [53, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|53-13| + |77-13|)/2 = (40 + 64)/2 = 52.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 13:[53, 77] Operation: 74+3=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-3=71. \nResulting numbers: [53, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|53-13| + |71-13|)/2 = (40 + 58)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 13:[53, 71] Operation: 74-3=71\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-3=50. \nResulting numbers: [74, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|74-13| + |50-13|)/2 = (61 + 37)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 13:[74, 50] Operation: 53-3=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-53=21. \nResulting numbers: [3, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|3-13| + |21-13|)/2 = (10 + 8)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 13:[3, 21] Operation: 74-53=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+3=56. \nResulting numbers: [74, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|74-13| + |56-13|)/2 = (61 + 43)/2 = 52.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 13:[74, 56] Operation: 53+3=56\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 40.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,2: 13:[74, 53, 34]. Operations so far : ['51-17=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-34=19. \nResulting numbers: [74, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|74-13| + |19-13|)/2 = (61 + 6)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 13:[74, 19] Operation: 53-34=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+53=127. \nResulting numbers: [34, 127].\nHeuristic score : (|34-13| + |127-13|)/2 = (21 + 114)/2 = 67.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 13:[34, 127] Operation: 74+53=127\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+34=108. \nResulting numbers: [53, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|53-13| + |108-13|)/2 = (40 + 95)/2 = 67.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 13:[53, 108] Operation: 74+34=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-53=21. \nResulting numbers: [34, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|34-13| + |21-13|)/2 = (21 + 8)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 13:[34, 21] Operation: 74-53=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-34=40. \nResulting numbers: [53, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|53-13| + |40-13|)/2 = (40 + 27)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 13:[53, 40] Operation: 74-34=40\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 13:[21, 3]. Operations so far : ['74-53=21', '51/17=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21*3=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,13 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21/3=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,13 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+3=24. \nResulting numbers: [24].\n24,13 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21-3=18. \nResulting numbers: [18].\n18,13 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 13:[3, 21]. Operations so far : ['51/17=3', '74-53=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21-3=18. \nResulting numbers: [18].\n18,13 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3*21=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,13 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21/3=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,13 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+21=24. \nResulting numbers: [24].\n24,13 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 13:[17, 30]. Operations so far : ['74-51=23', '53-23=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+30=47. \nResulting numbers: [47].\n47,13 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17*30=510. \nResulting numbers: [510].\n510,13 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-17=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,13 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['74-51=23', '53-23=30', '30-17=13']\nRESULT: 13\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 4,415 |
[
16,
77,
57,
62
]
| 56 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [16, 77, 57, 62] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 56. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [16, 77, 57, 62]. Our goal is to produce 56. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 56:[16, 77, 57, 62]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-16=41. \nResulting numbers: [77, 62, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|77-56| + |62-56| + |41-56|)/3 = (21 + 6 + 15)/3 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 56:[77, 62, 41] Operation: 57-16=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16+57=73. \nResulting numbers: [77, 62, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|77-56| + |62-56| + |73-56|)/3 = (21 + 6 + 17)/3 = 14.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 56:[77, 62, 73] Operation: 16+57=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-16=61. \nResulting numbers: [57, 62, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|57-56| + |62-56| + |61-56|)/3 = (1 + 6 + 5)/3 = 4.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 56:[57, 62, 61] Operation: 77-16=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-16=46. \nResulting numbers: [77, 57, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|77-56| + |57-56| + |46-56|)/3 = (21 + 1 + 10)/3 = 10.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 56:[77, 57, 46] Operation: 62-16=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16+77=93. \nResulting numbers: [57, 62, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|57-56| + |62-56| + |93-56|)/3 = (1 + 6 + 37)/3 = 14.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 56:[57, 62, 93] Operation: 16+77=93\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 4.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 56:[57, 62, 61]. Operations so far : ['77-16=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-57=4. \nResulting numbers: [62, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|62-56| + |4-56|)/2 = (6 + 52)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 56:[62, 4] Operation: 61-57=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+62=119. \nResulting numbers: [61, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|61-56| + |119-56|)/2 = (5 + 63)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 56:[61, 119] Operation: 57+62=119\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-61=1. \nResulting numbers: [57, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|57-56| + |1-56|)/2 = (1 + 55)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 56:[57, 1] Operation: 62-61=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-57=5. \nResulting numbers: [61, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|61-56| + |5-56|)/2 = (5 + 51)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 56:[61, 5] Operation: 62-57=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+61=118. \nResulting numbers: [62, 118].\nHeuristic score : (|62-56| + |118-56|)/2 = (6 + 62)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 56:[62, 118] Operation: 57+61=118\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,3: 56:[77, 57, 46]. Operations so far : ['62-16=46'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-46=31. \nResulting numbers: [57, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|57-56| + |31-56|)/2 = (1 + 25)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 56:[57, 31] Operation: 77-46=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+46=103. \nResulting numbers: [77, 103].\nHeuristic score : (|77-56| + |103-56|)/2 = (21 + 47)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 56:[77, 103] Operation: 57+46=103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+46=123. \nResulting numbers: [57, 123].\nHeuristic score : (|57-56| + |123-56|)/2 = (1 + 67)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 56:[57, 123] Operation: 77+46=123\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-46=11. \nResulting numbers: [77, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|77-56| + |11-56|)/2 = (21 + 45)/2 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 56:[77, 11] Operation: 57-46=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-57=20. \nResulting numbers: [46, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|46-56| + |20-56|)/2 = (10 + 36)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 56:[46, 20] Operation: 77-57=20\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 56:[77, 62, 41]. Operations so far : ['57-16=41'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-41=36. \nResulting numbers: [62, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|62-56| + |36-56|)/2 = (6 + 20)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 56:[62, 36] Operation: 77-41=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+41=103. \nResulting numbers: [77, 103].\nHeuristic score : (|77-56| + |103-56|)/2 = (21 + 47)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 56:[77, 103] Operation: 62+41=103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+41=118. \nResulting numbers: [62, 118].\nHeuristic score : (|62-56| + |118-56|)/2 = (6 + 62)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 56:[62, 118] Operation: 77+41=118\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-41=21. \nResulting numbers: [77, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|77-56| + |21-56|)/2 = (21 + 35)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 56:[77, 21] Operation: 62-41=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-62=15. \nResulting numbers: [41, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|41-56| + |15-56|)/2 = (15 + 41)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 56:[41, 15] Operation: 77-62=15\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 14.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,1: 56:[77, 62, 73]. Operations so far : ['16+57=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-62=15. \nResulting numbers: [73, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|73-56| + |15-56|)/2 = (17 + 41)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 56:[73, 15] Operation: 77-62=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-62=11. \nResulting numbers: [77, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|77-56| + |11-56|)/2 = (21 + 45)/2 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 56:[77, 11] Operation: 73-62=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-73=4. \nResulting numbers: [62, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|62-56| + |4-56|)/2 = (6 + 52)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 56:[62, 4] Operation: 77-73=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+62=139. \nResulting numbers: [73, 139].\nHeuristic score : (|73-56| + |139-56|)/2 = (17 + 83)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 56:[73, 139] Operation: 77+62=139\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+73=150. \nResulting numbers: [62, 150].\nHeuristic score : (|62-56| + |150-56|)/2 = (6 + 94)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 56:[62, 150] Operation: 77+73=150\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 14.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,4: 56:[57, 62, 93]. Operations so far : ['16+77=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+62=119. \nResulting numbers: [93, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|93-56| + |119-56|)/2 = (37 + 63)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 56:[93, 119] Operation: 57+62=119\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-57=36. \nResulting numbers: [62, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|62-56| + |36-56|)/2 = (6 + 20)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 56:[62, 36] Operation: 93-57=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-62=31. \nResulting numbers: [57, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|57-56| + |31-56|)/2 = (1 + 25)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 56:[57, 31] Operation: 93-62=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-57=5. \nResulting numbers: [93, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|93-56| + |5-56|)/2 = (37 + 51)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 56:[93, 5] Operation: 62-57=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+93=150. \nResulting numbers: [62, 150].\nHeuristic score : (|62-56| + |150-56|)/2 = (6 + 94)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 56:[62, 150] Operation: 57+93=150\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 56:[57, 31]. Operations so far : ['62-16=46', '77-46=31'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-31=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,56 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+31=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,56 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*31=1767. \nResulting numbers: [1767].\n1767,56 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 56:[62, 36]. Operations so far : ['57-16=41', '77-41=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-36=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,56 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62*36=2232. \nResulting numbers: [2232].\n2232,56 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+36=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,56 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 56:[62, 36]. Operations so far : ['16+77=93', '93-57=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-36=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,56 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+36=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,56 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62*36=2232. \nResulting numbers: [2232].\n2232,56 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 56:[57, 31]. Operations so far : ['16+77=93', '93-62=31'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-31=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,56 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*31=1767. \nResulting numbers: [1767].\n1767,56 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+31=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,56 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 23.0\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 56:[46, 20]. Operations so far : ['62-16=46', '77-57=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+20=66. \nResulting numbers: [66].\n66,56 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46-20=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,56 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46*20=920. \nResulting numbers: [920].\n920,56 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,3,4,0: 56:[66]. Operations so far : ['62-16=46', '77-57=20', '46+20=66'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 56:[77, 21]. Operations so far : ['57-16=41', '62-41=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+21=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,56 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*21=1617. \nResulting numbers: [1617].\n1617,56 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-21=56. \nResulting numbers: [56].\n56,56 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['57-16=41', '62-41=21', '77-21=56']\nRESULT: 56\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 5,124 |
[
57,
97,
82,
40
]
| 82 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [57, 97, 82, 40] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 82. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [57, 97, 82, 40]. Our goal is to produce 82. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 82:[57, 97, 82, 40]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-40=17. \nResulting numbers: [97, 82, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|97-82| + |82-82| + |17-82|)/3 = (15 + 0 + 65)/3 = 26.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 82:[97, 82, 17] Operation: 57-40=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+40=122. \nResulting numbers: [57, 97, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|57-82| + |97-82| + |122-82|)/3 = (25 + 15 + 40)/3 = 26.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 82:[57, 97, 122] Operation: 82+40=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97+40=137. \nResulting numbers: [57, 82, 137].\nHeuristic score : (|57-82| + |82-82| + |137-82|)/3 = (25 + 0 + 55)/3 = 26.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 82:[57, 82, 137] Operation: 97+40=137\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+40=97. \nResulting numbers: [97, 82, 97].\nHeuristic score : (|97-82| + |82-82| + |97-82|)/3 = (15 + 0 + 15)/3 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 82:[97, 82, 97] Operation: 57+40=97\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-40=57. \nResulting numbers: [57, 82, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|57-82| + |82-82| + |57-82|)/3 = (25 + 0 + 25)/3 = 16.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 82:[57, 82, 57] Operation: 97-40=57\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 82:[97, 82, 97]. Operations so far : ['57+40=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-82=15. \nResulting numbers: [97, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|97-82| + |15-82|)/2 = (15 + 67)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 82:[97, 15] Operation: 97-82=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-97=0. \nResulting numbers: [82, 0].\nHeuristic score : (|82-82| + |0-82|)/2 = (0 + 82)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 82:[82, 0] Operation: 97-97=0\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97/97=1. \nResulting numbers: [82, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|82-82| + |1-82|)/2 = (0 + 81)/2 = 40.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 82:[82, 1] Operation: 97/97=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-82=15. \nResulting numbers: [97, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|97-82| + |15-82|)/2 = (15 + 67)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 82:[97, 15] Operation: 97-82=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97+82=179. \nResulting numbers: [97, 179].\nHeuristic score : (|97-82| + |179-82|)/2 = (15 + 97)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 82:[97, 179] Operation: 97+82=179\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 16.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 82:[57, 82, 57]. Operations so far : ['97-40=57'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+82=139. \nResulting numbers: [57, 139].\nHeuristic score : (|57-82| + |139-82|)/2 = (25 + 57)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 82:[57, 139] Operation: 57+82=139\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-57=25. \nResulting numbers: [57, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|57-82| + |25-82|)/2 = (25 + 57)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 82:[57, 25] Operation: 82-57=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57/57=1. \nResulting numbers: [82, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|82-82| + |1-82|)/2 = (0 + 81)/2 = 40.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 82:[82, 1] Operation: 57/57=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-57=0. \nResulting numbers: [82, 0].\nHeuristic score : (|82-82| + |0-82|)/2 = (0 + 82)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 82:[82, 0] Operation: 57-57=0\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+57=114. \nResulting numbers: [82, 114].\nHeuristic score : (|82-82| + |114-82|)/2 = (0 + 32)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 82:[82, 114] Operation: 57+57=114\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 26.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 82:[97, 82, 17]. Operations so far : ['57-40=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-82=15. \nResulting numbers: [17, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|17-82| + |15-82|)/2 = (65 + 67)/2 = 66.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 82:[17, 15] Operation: 97-82=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97+17=114. \nResulting numbers: [82, 114].\nHeuristic score : (|82-82| + |114-82|)/2 = (0 + 32)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 82:[82, 114] Operation: 97+17=114\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+17=99. \nResulting numbers: [97, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|97-82| + |99-82|)/2 = (15 + 17)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 82:[97, 99] Operation: 82+17=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-17=80. \nResulting numbers: [82, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|82-82| + |80-82|)/2 = (0 + 2)/2 = 1.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 82:[82, 80] Operation: 97-17=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-17=65. \nResulting numbers: [97, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|97-82| + |65-82|)/2 = (15 + 17)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 82:[97, 65] Operation: 82-17=65\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 26.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 82:[57, 97, 122]. Operations so far : ['82+40=122'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+122=179. \nResulting numbers: [97, 179].\nHeuristic score : (|97-82| + |179-82|)/2 = (15 + 97)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 82:[97, 179] Operation: 57+122=179\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+97=154. \nResulting numbers: [122, 154].\nHeuristic score : (|122-82| + |154-82|)/2 = (40 + 72)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 82:[122, 154] Operation: 57+97=154\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-57=40. \nResulting numbers: [122, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|122-82| + |40-82|)/2 = (40 + 42)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 82:[122, 40] Operation: 97-57=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-57=65. \nResulting numbers: [97, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|97-82| + |65-82|)/2 = (15 + 17)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 82:[97, 65] Operation: 122-57=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-97=25. \nResulting numbers: [57, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|57-82| + |25-82|)/2 = (25 + 57)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 82:[57, 25] Operation: 122-97=25\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 82:[57, 82, 137]. Operations so far : ['97+40=137'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 137-57=80. \nResulting numbers: [82, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|82-82| + |80-82|)/2 = (0 + 2)/2 = 1.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 82:[82, 80] Operation: 137-57=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+137=194. \nResulting numbers: [82, 194].\nHeuristic score : (|82-82| + |194-82|)/2 = (0 + 112)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 82:[82, 194] Operation: 57+137=194\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 137-82=55. \nResulting numbers: [57, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|57-82| + |55-82|)/2 = (25 + 27)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 82:[57, 55] Operation: 137-82=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-57=25. \nResulting numbers: [137, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|137-82| + |25-82|)/2 = (55 + 57)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 82:[137, 25] Operation: 82-57=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+82=139. \nResulting numbers: [137, 139].\nHeuristic score : (|137-82| + |139-82|)/2 = (55 + 57)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 82:[137, 139] Operation: 57+82=139\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 1.0\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 82:[82, 80]. Operations so far : ['57-40=17', '97-17=80'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82*80=6560. \nResulting numbers: [6560].\n6560,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-80=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+80=162. \nResulting numbers: [162].\n162,82 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 1.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 82:[82, 80]. Operations so far : ['97+40=137', '137-57=80'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+80=162. \nResulting numbers: [162].\n162,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82*80=6560. \nResulting numbers: [6560].\n6560,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-80=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,82 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 82:[82, 114]. Operations so far : ['57-40=17', '97+17=114'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82*114=9348. \nResulting numbers: [9348].\n9348,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+114=196. \nResulting numbers: [196].\n196,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 114-82=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,82 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 82:[97, 65]. Operations so far : ['57-40=17', '82-17=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97+65=162. \nResulting numbers: [162].\n162,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97*65=6305. \nResulting numbers: [6305].\n6305,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-65=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,82 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 82:[97, 99]. Operations so far : ['57-40=17', '82+17=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-97=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97+99=196. \nResulting numbers: [196].\n196,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97*99=9603. \nResulting numbers: [9603].\n9603,82 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 82:[82, 114]. Operations so far : ['97-40=57', '57+57=114'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 114-82=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+114=196. \nResulting numbers: [196].\n196,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82*114=9348. \nResulting numbers: [9348].\n9348,82 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 82:[97, 65]. Operations so far : ['82+40=122', '122-57=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97+65=162. \nResulting numbers: [162].\n162,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-65=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97*65=6305. \nResulting numbers: [6305].\n6305,82 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 82:[57, 55]. Operations so far : ['97+40=137', '137-82=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-55=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+55=112. \nResulting numbers: [112].\n112,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*55=3135. \nResulting numbers: [3135].\n3135,82 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 40.5\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 82:[82, 1]. Operations so far : ['97-40=57', '57/57=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-1=81. \nResulting numbers: [81].\n81,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+1=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,82 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82/1=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,82 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['97-40=57', '57/57=1', '82/1=82']\nRESULT: 82\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 5,765 |
[
33,
51,
53,
49
]
| 80 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [33, 51, 53, 49] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 80. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [33, 51, 53, 49]. Our goal is to produce 80. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 80:[33, 51, 53, 49]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+49=82. \nResulting numbers: [51, 53, 82].\nHeuristic score : (|51-80| + |53-80| + |82-80|)/3 = (29 + 27 + 2)/3 = 19.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 80:[51, 53, 82] Operation: 33+49=82\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+49=102. \nResulting numbers: [33, 51, 102].\nHeuristic score : (|33-80| + |51-80| + |102-80|)/3 = (47 + 29 + 22)/3 = 32.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 80:[33, 51, 102] Operation: 53+49=102\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+53=86. \nResulting numbers: [51, 49, 86].\nHeuristic score : (|51-80| + |49-80| + |86-80|)/3 = (29 + 31 + 6)/3 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 80:[51, 49, 86] Operation: 33+53=86\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+51=84. \nResulting numbers: [53, 49, 84].\nHeuristic score : (|53-80| + |49-80| + |84-80|)/3 = (27 + 31 + 4)/3 = 20.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 80:[53, 49, 84] Operation: 33+51=84\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+49=100. \nResulting numbers: [33, 53, 100].\nHeuristic score : (|33-80| + |53-80| + |100-80|)/3 = (47 + 27 + 20)/3 = 31.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 80:[33, 53, 100] Operation: 51+49=100\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 80:[51, 53, 82]. Operations so far : ['33+49=82'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-53=29. \nResulting numbers: [51, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|51-80| + |29-80|)/2 = (29 + 51)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 80:[51, 29] Operation: 82-53=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-51=2. \nResulting numbers: [82, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|82-80| + |2-80|)/2 = (2 + 78)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 80:[82, 2] Operation: 53-51=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-51=31. \nResulting numbers: [53, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|53-80| + |31-80|)/2 = (27 + 49)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 80:[53, 31] Operation: 82-51=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+82=133. \nResulting numbers: [53, 133].\nHeuristic score : (|53-80| + |133-80|)/2 = (27 + 53)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 80:[53, 133] Operation: 51+82=133\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+53=104. \nResulting numbers: [82, 104].\nHeuristic score : (|82-80| + |104-80|)/2 = (2 + 24)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 80:[82, 104] Operation: 51+53=104\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 20.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 80:[53, 49, 84]. Operations so far : ['33+51=84'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-49=4. \nResulting numbers: [84, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|84-80| + |4-80|)/2 = (4 + 76)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 80:[84, 4] Operation: 53-49=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49+84=133. \nResulting numbers: [53, 133].\nHeuristic score : (|53-80| + |133-80|)/2 = (27 + 53)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 80:[53, 133] Operation: 49+84=133\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-53=31. \nResulting numbers: [49, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|49-80| + |31-80|)/2 = (31 + 49)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 80:[49, 31] Operation: 84-53=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-49=35. \nResulting numbers: [53, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|53-80| + |35-80|)/2 = (27 + 45)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 80:[53, 35] Operation: 84-49=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+49=102. \nResulting numbers: [84, 102].\nHeuristic score : (|84-80| + |102-80|)/2 = (4 + 22)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 80:[84, 102] Operation: 53+49=102\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 80:[51, 49, 86]. Operations so far : ['33+53=86'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86-49=37. \nResulting numbers: [51, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|51-80| + |37-80|)/2 = (29 + 43)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 80:[51, 37] Operation: 86-49=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86-51=35. \nResulting numbers: [49, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|49-80| + |35-80|)/2 = (31 + 45)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 80:[49, 35] Operation: 86-51=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49+86=135. \nResulting numbers: [51, 135].\nHeuristic score : (|51-80| + |135-80|)/2 = (29 + 55)/2 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 80:[51, 135] Operation: 49+86=135\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+49=100. \nResulting numbers: [86, 100].\nHeuristic score : (|86-80| + |100-80|)/2 = (6 + 20)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 80:[86, 100] Operation: 51+49=100\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-49=2. \nResulting numbers: [86, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|86-80| + |2-80|)/2 = (6 + 78)/2 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 80:[86, 2] Operation: 51-49=2\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 80:[33, 53, 100]. Operations so far : ['51+49=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-53=47. \nResulting numbers: [33, 47].\nHeuristic score : (|33-80| + |47-80|)/2 = (47 + 33)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 80:[33, 47] Operation: 100-53=47\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+100=133. \nResulting numbers: [53, 133].\nHeuristic score : (|53-80| + |133-80|)/2 = (27 + 53)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 80:[53, 133] Operation: 33+100=133\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+53=86. \nResulting numbers: [100, 86].\nHeuristic score : (|100-80| + |86-80|)/2 = (20 + 6)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 80:[100, 86] Operation: 33+53=86\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-33=67. \nResulting numbers: [53, 67].\nHeuristic score : (|53-80| + |67-80|)/2 = (27 + 13)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 80:[53, 67] Operation: 100-33=67\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-33=20. \nResulting numbers: [100, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|100-80| + |20-80|)/2 = (20 + 60)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 80:[100, 20] Operation: 53-33=20\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 80:[33, 51, 102]. Operations so far : ['53+49=102'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+51=84. \nResulting numbers: [102, 84].\nHeuristic score : (|102-80| + |84-80|)/2 = (22 + 4)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 80:[102, 84] Operation: 33+51=84\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102-33=69. \nResulting numbers: [51, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|51-80| + |69-80|)/2 = (29 + 11)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 80:[51, 69] Operation: 102-33=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102-51=51. \nResulting numbers: [33, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|33-80| + |51-80|)/2 = (47 + 29)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 80:[33, 51] Operation: 102-51=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+102=135. \nResulting numbers: [51, 135].\nHeuristic score : (|51-80| + |135-80|)/2 = (29 + 55)/2 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 80:[51, 135] Operation: 33+102=135\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-33=18. \nResulting numbers: [102, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|102-80| + |18-80|)/2 = (22 + 62)/2 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 80:[102, 18] Operation: 51-33=18\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 80:[82, 104]. Operations so far : ['33+49=82', '51+53=104'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82*104=8528. \nResulting numbers: [8528].\n8528,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+104=186. \nResulting numbers: [186].\n186,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104-82=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,80 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 80:[84, 102]. Operations so far : ['33+51=84', '53+49=102'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102-84=18. \nResulting numbers: [18].\n18,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84*102=8568. \nResulting numbers: [8568].\n8568,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84+102=186. \nResulting numbers: [186].\n186,80 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 80:[86, 100]. Operations so far : ['33+53=86', '51+49=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-86=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86*100=8600. \nResulting numbers: [8600].\n8600,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86+100=186. \nResulting numbers: [186].\n186,80 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 80:[102, 84]. Operations so far : ['53+49=102', '33+51=84'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102-84=18. \nResulting numbers: [18].\n18,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102*84=8568. \nResulting numbers: [8568].\n8568,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102+84=186. \nResulting numbers: [186].\n186,80 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 80:[100, 86]. Operations so far : ['51+49=100', '33+53=86'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100+86=186. \nResulting numbers: [186].\n186,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-86=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100*86=8600. \nResulting numbers: [8600].\n8600,80 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 80:[51, 69]. Operations so far : ['53+49=102', '102-33=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*69=3519. \nResulting numbers: [3519].\n3519,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-51=18. \nResulting numbers: [18].\n18,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+69=120. \nResulting numbers: [120].\n120,80 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 80:[53, 67]. Operations so far : ['51+49=100', '100-33=67'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+67=120. \nResulting numbers: [120].\n120,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-53=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53*67=3551. \nResulting numbers: [3551].\n3551,80 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 36.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 80:[53, 35]. Operations so far : ['33+51=84', '84-49=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+35=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-35=18. \nResulting numbers: [18].\n18,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53*35=1855. \nResulting numbers: [1855].\n1855,80 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 36.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 80:[51, 37]. Operations so far : ['33+53=86', '86-49=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-37=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+37=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*37=1887. \nResulting numbers: [1887].\n1887,80 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 38.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 80:[49, 35]. Operations so far : ['33+53=86', '86-51=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49*35=1715. \nResulting numbers: [1715].\n1715,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49+35=84. \nResulting numbers: [84].\n84,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-35=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,80 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,1,1: 80:[84]. Operations so far : ['33+53=86', '86-51=35', '49+35=84'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,3,3,0: 80:[88]. Operations so far : ['33+51=84', '84-49=35', '53+35=88'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,2,0,1: 80:[88]. Operations so far : ['33+53=86', '86-49=37', '51+37=88'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 38.0\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 80:[33, 51]. Operations so far : ['53+49=102', '102-51=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+51=84. \nResulting numbers: [84].\n84,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33*51=1683. \nResulting numbers: [1683].\n1683,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-33=18. \nResulting numbers: [18].\n18,80 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 38.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 80:[53, 31]. Operations so far : ['33+49=82', '82-51=31'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-31=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53*31=1643. \nResulting numbers: [1643].\n1643,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+31=84. \nResulting numbers: [84].\n84,80 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,1,2,0: 80:[84]. Operations so far : ['53+49=102', '102-51=51', '33+51=84'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 80:[84]. Operations so far : ['33+49=82', '82-51=31', '53+31=84'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 40\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 80:[120]. Operations so far : ['53+49=102', '102-33=69', '51+69=120'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 40.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 80:[51, 29]. Operations so far : ['33+49=82', '82-53=29'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*29=1479. \nResulting numbers: [1479].\n1479,80 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+29=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,80 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['33+49=82', '82-53=29', '51-29=22']\nRESULT: 22\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,176 |
[
6,
72,
81,
77
]
| 74 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [6, 72, 81, 77] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 74. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [6, 72, 81, 77]. Our goal is to produce 74. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 74:[6, 72, 81, 77]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-6=71. \nResulting numbers: [72, 81, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|72-74| + |81-74| + |71-74|)/3 = (2 + 7 + 3)/3 = 4.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 74:[72, 81, 71] Operation: 77-6=71\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+72=78. \nResulting numbers: [81, 77, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|81-74| + |77-74| + |78-74|)/3 = (7 + 3 + 4)/3 = 4.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 74:[81, 77, 78] Operation: 6+72=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-6=66. \nResulting numbers: [81, 77, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|81-74| + |77-74| + |66-74|)/3 = (7 + 3 + 8)/3 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 74:[81, 77, 66] Operation: 72-6=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+81=87. \nResulting numbers: [72, 77, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|72-74| + |77-74| + |87-74|)/3 = (2 + 3 + 13)/3 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 74:[72, 77, 87] Operation: 6+81=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-6=75. \nResulting numbers: [72, 77, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|72-74| + |77-74| + |75-74|)/3 = (2 + 3 + 1)/3 = 2.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 74:[72, 77, 75] Operation: 81-6=75\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 2.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 74:[72, 77, 75]. Operations so far : ['81-6=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+75=147. \nResulting numbers: [77, 147].\nHeuristic score : (|77-74| + |147-74|)/2 = (3 + 73)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 74:[77, 147] Operation: 72+75=147\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-72=3. \nResulting numbers: [77, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|77-74| + |3-74|)/2 = (3 + 71)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 74:[77, 3] Operation: 75-72=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-75=2. \nResulting numbers: [72, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|72-74| + |2-74|)/2 = (2 + 72)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 74:[72, 2] Operation: 77-75=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+77=149. \nResulting numbers: [75, 149].\nHeuristic score : (|75-74| + |149-74|)/2 = (1 + 75)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 74:[75, 149] Operation: 72+77=149\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-72=5. \nResulting numbers: [75, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|75-74| + |5-74|)/2 = (1 + 69)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 74:[75, 5] Operation: 77-72=5\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 4.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 74:[72, 81, 71]. Operations so far : ['77-6=71'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-71=1. \nResulting numbers: [81, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|81-74| + |1-74|)/2 = (7 + 73)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 74:[81, 1] Operation: 72-71=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+71=143. \nResulting numbers: [81, 143].\nHeuristic score : (|81-74| + |143-74|)/2 = (7 + 69)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 74:[81, 143] Operation: 72+71=143\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-72=9. \nResulting numbers: [71, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|71-74| + |9-74|)/2 = (3 + 65)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 74:[71, 9] Operation: 81-72=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+71=152. \nResulting numbers: [72, 152].\nHeuristic score : (|72-74| + |152-74|)/2 = (2 + 78)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 74:[72, 152] Operation: 81+71=152\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-71=10. \nResulting numbers: [72, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|72-74| + |10-74|)/2 = (2 + 64)/2 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 74:[72, 10] Operation: 81-71=10\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 4.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,1: 74:[81, 77, 78]. Operations so far : ['6+72=78'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-77=1. \nResulting numbers: [81, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|81-74| + |1-74|)/2 = (7 + 73)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 74:[81, 1] Operation: 78-77=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-77=4. \nResulting numbers: [78, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|78-74| + |4-74|)/2 = (4 + 70)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 74:[78, 4] Operation: 81-77=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+77=158. \nResulting numbers: [78, 158].\nHeuristic score : (|78-74| + |158-74|)/2 = (4 + 84)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 74:[78, 158] Operation: 81+77=158\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+78=159. \nResulting numbers: [77, 159].\nHeuristic score : (|77-74| + |159-74|)/2 = (3 + 85)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 74:[77, 159] Operation: 81+78=159\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-78=3. \nResulting numbers: [77, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|77-74| + |3-74|)/2 = (3 + 71)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 74:[77, 3] Operation: 81-78=3\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 74:[81, 77, 66]. Operations so far : ['72-6=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+66=147. \nResulting numbers: [77, 147].\nHeuristic score : (|77-74| + |147-74|)/2 = (3 + 73)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 74:[77, 147] Operation: 81+66=147\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-66=11. \nResulting numbers: [81, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|81-74| + |11-74|)/2 = (7 + 63)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 74:[81, 11] Operation: 77-66=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+66=143. \nResulting numbers: [81, 143].\nHeuristic score : (|81-74| + |143-74|)/2 = (7 + 69)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 74:[81, 143] Operation: 77+66=143\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-66=15. \nResulting numbers: [77, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|77-74| + |15-74|)/2 = (3 + 59)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 74:[77, 15] Operation: 81-66=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-77=4. \nResulting numbers: [66, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|66-74| + |4-74|)/2 = (8 + 70)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 74:[66, 4] Operation: 81-77=4\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 74:[72, 77, 87]. Operations so far : ['6+81=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-72=5. \nResulting numbers: [87, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|87-74| + |5-74|)/2 = (13 + 69)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 74:[87, 5] Operation: 77-72=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-77=10. \nResulting numbers: [72, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|72-74| + |10-74|)/2 = (2 + 64)/2 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 74:[72, 10] Operation: 87-77=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+87=159. \nResulting numbers: [77, 159].\nHeuristic score : (|77-74| + |159-74|)/2 = (3 + 85)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 74:[77, 159] Operation: 72+87=159\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+77=149. \nResulting numbers: [87, 149].\nHeuristic score : (|87-74| + |149-74|)/2 = (13 + 75)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 74:[87, 149] Operation: 72+77=149\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-72=15. \nResulting numbers: [77, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|77-74| + |15-74|)/2 = (3 + 59)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 74:[77, 15] Operation: 87-72=15\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 74:[77, 15]. Operations so far : ['72-6=66', '81-66=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+15=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*15=1155. \nResulting numbers: [1155].\n1155,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-15=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,74 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 74:[77, 15]. Operations so far : ['6+81=87', '87-72=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+15=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*15=1155. \nResulting numbers: [1155].\n1155,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-15=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,74 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 33.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 74:[72, 10]. Operations so far : ['77-6=71', '81-71=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72*10=720. \nResulting numbers: [720].\n720,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+10=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-10=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,74 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 74:[72, 10]. Operations so far : ['6+81=87', '87-77=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-10=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72*10=720. \nResulting numbers: [720].\n720,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+10=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,74 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 34.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 74:[71, 9]. Operations so far : ['77-6=71', '81-72=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71*9=639. \nResulting numbers: [639].\n639,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+9=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-9=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,74 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 6\nCurrent State #0,0,2,1: 74:[80]. Operations so far : ['77-6=71', '81-72=9', '71+9=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,3,1,2: 74:[82]. Operations so far : ['6+81=87', '87-77=10', '72+10=82'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,0,4,1: 74:[82]. Operations so far : ['77-6=71', '81-71=10', '72+10=82'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 74:[62]. Operations so far : ['72-6=66', '81-66=15', '77-15=62'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,0,4,2: 74:[62]. Operations so far : ['77-6=71', '81-71=10', '72-10=62'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,3,1,0: 74:[62]. Operations so far : ['6+81=87', '87-77=10', '72-10=62'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,3,4,2: 74:[62]. Operations so far : ['6+81=87', '87-72=15', '77-15=62'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 74:[62]. Operations so far : ['77-6=71', '81-72=9', '71-9=62'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,3,4,0: 74:[92]. Operations so far : ['6+81=87', '87-72=15', '77+15=92'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,2,3,0: 74:[92]. Operations so far : ['72-6=66', '81-66=15', '77+15=92'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 74:[75, 5]. Operations so far : ['81-6=75', '77-72=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*5=375. \nResulting numbers: [375].\n375,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75/5=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+5=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-5=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,74 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 74:[81, 11]. Operations so far : ['72-6=66', '77-66=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*11=891. \nResulting numbers: [891].\n891,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-11=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+11=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,74 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 37.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 74:[72, 2]. Operations so far : ['81-6=75', '77-75=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72/2=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,74 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+2=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,74 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['81-6=75', '77-75=2', '72/2=36']\nRESULT: 36\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 6,328 |
[
88,
70,
84,
33
]
| 66 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [88, 70, 84, 33] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 66. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [88, 70, 84, 33]. Our goal is to produce 66. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 66:[88, 70, 84, 33]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-33=55. \nResulting numbers: [70, 84, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|70-66| + |84-66| + |55-66|)/3 = (4 + 18 + 11)/3 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 66:[70, 84, 55] Operation: 88-33=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-55=29. \nResulting numbers: [70, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|70-66| + |29-66|)/2 = (4 + 37)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 66:[70, 29] Operation: 84-55=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-29=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,66 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 66:[70, 84, 55]. Operations so far : ['88-33=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-70=14. \nResulting numbers: [55, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|55-66| + |14-66|)/2 = (11 + 52)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 66:[55, 14] Operation: 84-70=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+14=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,66 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 66:[70, 84, 55]. Operations so far : ['88-33=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-55=15. \nResulting numbers: [84, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|84-66| + |15-66|)/2 = (18 + 51)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 66:[84, 15] Operation: 70-55=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-15=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,66 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 66:[70, 84, 55]. Operations so far : ['88-33=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+55=125. \nResulting numbers: [84, 125].\nHeuristic score : (|84-66| + |125-66|)/2 = (18 + 59)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 66:[84, 125] Operation: 70+55=125\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 125-84=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,66 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 66:[70, 84, 55]. Operations so far : ['88-33=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84+55=139. \nResulting numbers: [70, 139].\nHeuristic score : (|70-66| + |139-66|)/2 = (4 + 73)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 66:[70, 139] Operation: 84+55=139\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 139-70=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,66 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 66:[70, 84, 55]. Operations so far : ['88-33=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+84=154. \nResulting numbers: [55, 154].\nHeuristic score : (|55-66| + |154-66|)/2 = (11 + 88)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 66:[55, 154] Operation: 70+84=154\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 154-55=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,66 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 66:[70, 84, 55]. Operations so far : ['88-33=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*55=3850. \nResulting numbers: [84, 3850].\nHeuristic score : (|84-66| + |3850-66|)/2 = (18 + 3784)/2 = 1901.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 66:[84, 3850] Operation: 70*55=3850\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3850-84=3766. \nResulting numbers: [3766].\n3766,66 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 66:[70, 84, 55]. Operations so far : ['88-33=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84*55=4620. \nResulting numbers: [70, 4620].\nHeuristic score : (|70-66| + |4620-66|)/2 = (4 + 4554)/2 = 2279.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 66:[70, 4620] Operation: 84*55=4620\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4620/70=66. \nResulting numbers: [66].\n66,66 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['88-33=55', '84*55=4620', '4620/70=66']\nRESULT: 66\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 1,968 |
[
80,
35,
7,
35
]
| 15 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [80, 35, 7, 35] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 15. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [80, 35, 7, 35]. Our goal is to produce 15. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [7, 35, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |35-15| + |45-15|)/3 = (8 + 20 + 30)/3 = 19.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 15:[7, 35, 45] Operation: 80-35=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-35=10. \nResulting numbers: [7, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |10-15|)/2 = (8 + 5)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 15:[7, 10] Operation: 45-35=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+10=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 15:[7, 35, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35/7=5. \nResulting numbers: [45, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|45-15| + |5-15|)/2 = (30 + 10)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 15:[45, 5] Operation: 35/7=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45/5=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 15:[7, 35, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-7=28. \nResulting numbers: [45, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|45-15| + |28-15|)/2 = (30 + 13)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 15:[45, 28] Operation: 35-7=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-28=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 15:[7, 35, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-7=38. \nResulting numbers: [35, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |38-15|)/2 = (20 + 23)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 15:[35, 38] Operation: 45-7=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-35=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 15:[7, 35, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+35=42. \nResulting numbers: [45, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|45-15| + |42-15|)/2 = (30 + 27)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 15:[45, 42] Operation: 7+35=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-42=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 15:[7, 35, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+45=52. \nResulting numbers: [35, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |52-15|)/2 = (20 + 37)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 15:[35, 52] Operation: 7+45=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-35=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 15:[7, 35, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+45=80. \nResulting numbers: [7, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |80-15|)/2 = (8 + 65)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 15:[7, 80] Operation: 35+45=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 15:[7, 35, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*35=245. \nResulting numbers: [45, 245].\nHeuristic score : (|45-15| + |245-15|)/2 = (30 + 230)/2 = 130.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 15:[45, 245] Operation: 7*35=245\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245-45=200. \nResulting numbers: [200].\n200,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 15:[7, 35, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*45=315. \nResulting numbers: [35, 315].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |315-15|)/2 = (20 + 300)/2 = 160.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 15:[35, 315] Operation: 7*45=315\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 315/35=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 15:[7, 35, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*45=1575. \nResulting numbers: [7, 1575].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |1575-15|)/2 = (8 + 1560)/2 = 784.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,9: 15:[7, 1575] Operation: 35*45=1575\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1575/7=225. \nResulting numbers: [225].\n225,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [35, 7, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |7-15| + |45-15|)/3 = (20 + 8 + 30)/3 = 19.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 15:[35, 7, 45] Operation: 80-35=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-35=10. \nResulting numbers: [7, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |10-15|)/2 = (8 + 5)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 15:[7, 10] Operation: 45-35=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+10=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 15:[35, 7, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35/7=5. \nResulting numbers: [45, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|45-15| + |5-15|)/2 = (30 + 10)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 15:[45, 5] Operation: 35/7=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45/5=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 15:[35, 7, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-7=28. \nResulting numbers: [45, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|45-15| + |28-15|)/2 = (30 + 13)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 15:[45, 28] Operation: 35-7=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-28=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 15:[35, 7, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-7=38. \nResulting numbers: [35, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |38-15|)/2 = (20 + 23)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 15:[35, 38] Operation: 45-7=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-35=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 15:[35, 7, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+7=42. \nResulting numbers: [45, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|45-15| + |42-15|)/2 = (30 + 27)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 15:[45, 42] Operation: 35+7=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-42=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 15:[35, 7, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+45=52. \nResulting numbers: [35, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |52-15|)/2 = (20 + 37)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 15:[35, 52] Operation: 7+45=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-35=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 15:[35, 7, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+45=80. \nResulting numbers: [7, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |80-15|)/2 = (8 + 65)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 15:[7, 80] Operation: 35+45=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 15:[35, 7, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*7=245. \nResulting numbers: [45, 245].\nHeuristic score : (|45-15| + |245-15|)/2 = (30 + 230)/2 = 130.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 15:[45, 245] Operation: 35*7=245\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245-45=200. \nResulting numbers: [200].\n200,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 15:[35, 7, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*45=315. \nResulting numbers: [35, 315].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |315-15|)/2 = (20 + 300)/2 = 160.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 15:[35, 315] Operation: 7*45=315\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 315/35=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 15:[35, 7, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*45=1575. \nResulting numbers: [7, 1575].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |1575-15|)/2 = (8 + 1560)/2 = 784.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,9: 15:[7, 1575] Operation: 35*45=1575\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1575/7=225. \nResulting numbers: [225].\n225,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35/35=1. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15| + |1-15|)/3 = (65 + 8 + 14)/3 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 15:[80, 7, 1] Operation: 35/35=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [1, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|1-15| + |73-15|)/2 = (14 + 58)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 15:[1, 73] Operation: 80-7=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-1=72. \nResulting numbers: [72].\n72,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 15:[80, 7, 1]. Operations so far : ['35/35=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-1=79. \nResulting numbers: [7, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |79-15|)/2 = (8 + 64)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 15:[7, 79] Operation: 80-1=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-7=72. \nResulting numbers: [72].\n72,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 15:[80, 7, 1]. Operations so far : ['35/35=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+1=8. \nResulting numbers: [80, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |8-15|)/2 = (65 + 7)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 15:[80, 8] Operation: 7+1=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/8=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 15:[80, 7, 1]. Operations so far : ['35/35=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*1=80. \nResulting numbers: [7, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |80-15|)/2 = (8 + 65)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 15:[7, 80] Operation: 80*1=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 15:[80, 7, 1]. Operations so far : ['35/35=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/1=80. \nResulting numbers: [7, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |80-15|)/2 = (8 + 65)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 15:[7, 80] Operation: 80/1=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 15:[80, 7, 1]. Operations so far : ['35/35=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*1=7. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15|)/2 = (65 + 8)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 15:[80, 7] Operation: 7*1=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 15:[80, 7, 1]. Operations so far : ['35/35=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7/1=7. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15|)/2 = (65 + 8)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 15:[80, 7] Operation: 7/1=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 15:[80, 7, 1]. Operations so far : ['35/35=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+1=81. \nResulting numbers: [7, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |81-15|)/2 = (8 + 66)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 15:[7, 81] Operation: 80+1=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-7=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 15:[80, 7, 1]. Operations so far : ['35/35=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7-1=6. \nResulting numbers: [80, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |6-15|)/2 = (65 + 9)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 15:[80, 6] Operation: 7-1=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-6=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 15:[80, 7, 1]. Operations so far : ['35/35=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+7=87. \nResulting numbers: [1, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|1-15| + |87-15|)/2 = (14 + 72)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,9: 15:[1, 87] Operation: 80+7=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-1=86. \nResulting numbers: [86].\n86,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 15:[80, 7, 1]. Operations so far : ['35/35=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 11th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*7=560. \nResulting numbers: [1, 560].\nHeuristic score : (|1-15| + |560-15|)/2 = (14 + 545)/2 = 279.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,10: 15:[1, 560] Operation: 80*7=560\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,10’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 560-1=559. \nResulting numbers: [559].\n559,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-35=0. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7, 0].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15| + |0-15|)/3 = (65 + 8 + 15)/3 = 29.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 15:[80, 7, 0] Operation: 35-35=0\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*0=0. \nResulting numbers: [7, 0].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |0-15|)/2 = (8 + 15)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 15:[7, 0] Operation: 80*0=0\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+0=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 29.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 15:[80, 7, 0]. Operations so far : ['35-35=0'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [0, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|0-15| + |73-15|)/2 = (15 + 58)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 15:[0, 73] Operation: 80-7=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 0*73=0. \nResulting numbers: [0].\n0,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 29.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 15:[80, 7, 0]. Operations so far : ['35-35=0'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+0=80. \nResulting numbers: [7, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |80-15|)/2 = (8 + 65)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 15:[7, 80] Operation: 80+0=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 29.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 15:[80, 7, 0]. Operations so far : ['35-35=0'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-0=80. \nResulting numbers: [7, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |80-15|)/2 = (8 + 65)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 15:[7, 80] Operation: 80-0=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 29.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 15:[80, 7, 0]. Operations so far : ['35-35=0'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+0=7. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15|)/2 = (65 + 8)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 15:[80, 7] Operation: 7+0=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 29.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 15:[80, 7, 0]. Operations so far : ['35-35=0'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7-0=7. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15|)/2 = (65 + 8)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 15:[80, 7] Operation: 7-0=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 29.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 15:[80, 7, 0]. Operations so far : ['35-35=0'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*0=0. \nResulting numbers: [80, 0].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |0-15|)/2 = (65 + 15)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 15:[80, 0] Operation: 7*0=0\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*0=0. \nResulting numbers: [0].\n0,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 29.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 15:[80, 7, 0]. Operations so far : ['35-35=0'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+7=87. \nResulting numbers: [0, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|0-15| + |87-15|)/2 = (15 + 72)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 15:[0, 87] Operation: 80+7=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 0*87=0. \nResulting numbers: [0].\n0,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 29.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 15:[80, 7, 0]. Operations so far : ['35-35=0'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*7=560. \nResulting numbers: [0, 560].\nHeuristic score : (|0-15| + |560-15|)/2 = (15 + 545)/2 = 280.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 15:[0, 560] Operation: 80*7=560\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 0*560=0. \nResulting numbers: [0].\n0,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35/7=5. \nResulting numbers: [80, 35, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |35-15| + |5-15|)/3 = (65 + 20 + 10)/3 = 31.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 15:[80, 35, 5] Operation: 35/7=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/5=16. \nResulting numbers: [35, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |16-15|)/2 = (20 + 1)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 15:[35, 16] Operation: 80/5=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-16=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [5, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|5-15| + |45-15|)/2 = (10 + 30)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 15:[5, 45] Operation: 80-35=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45/5=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35/5=7. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15|)/2 = (65 + 8)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 15:[80, 7] Operation: 35/5=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-5=75. \nResulting numbers: [35, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |75-15|)/2 = (20 + 60)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 15:[35, 75] Operation: 80-5=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-35=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-5=30. \nResulting numbers: [80, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |30-15|)/2 = (65 + 15)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 15:[80, 30] Operation: 35-5=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-30=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+5=85. \nResulting numbers: [35, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |85-15|)/2 = (20 + 70)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 15:[35, 85] Operation: 80+5=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-35=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+5=40. \nResulting numbers: [80, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |40-15|)/2 = (65 + 25)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 15:[80, 40] Operation: 35+5=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/40=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [5, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|5-15| + |115-15|)/2 = (10 + 100)/2 = 55.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 15:[5, 115] Operation: 80+35=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115/5=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*5=175. \nResulting numbers: [80, 175].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |175-15|)/2 = (65 + 160)/2 = 112.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 15:[80, 175] Operation: 35*5=175\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 175-80=95. \nResulting numbers: [95].\n95,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*5=400. \nResulting numbers: [35, 400].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |400-15|)/2 = (20 + 385)/2 = 202.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,9: 15:[35, 400] Operation: 80*5=400\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 400-35=365. \nResulting numbers: [365].\n365,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 11th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*35=2800. \nResulting numbers: [5, 2800].\nHeuristic score : (|5-15| + |2800-15|)/2 = (10 + 2785)/2 = 1397.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,10: 15:[5, 2800] Operation: 80*35=2800\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,10’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2800/5=560. \nResulting numbers: [560].\n560,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35/7=5. \nResulting numbers: [80, 35, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |35-15| + |5-15|)/3 = (65 + 20 + 10)/3 = 31.67\nGenerated Node #0,5: 15:[80, 35, 5] Operation: 35/7=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/5=16. \nResulting numbers: [35, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |16-15|)/2 = (20 + 1)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 15:[35, 16] Operation: 80/5=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-16=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [5, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|5-15| + |45-15|)/2 = (10 + 30)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 15:[5, 45] Operation: 80-35=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45/5=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35/5=7. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15|)/2 = (65 + 8)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 15:[80, 7] Operation: 35/5=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-5=75. \nResulting numbers: [35, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |75-15|)/2 = (20 + 60)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,3: 15:[35, 75] Operation: 80-5=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-35=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-5=30. \nResulting numbers: [80, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |30-15|)/2 = (65 + 15)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,4: 15:[80, 30] Operation: 35-5=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-30=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+5=85. \nResulting numbers: [35, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |85-15|)/2 = (20 + 70)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,5: 15:[35, 85] Operation: 80+5=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-35=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+5=40. \nResulting numbers: [80, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |40-15|)/2 = (65 + 25)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,6: 15:[80, 40] Operation: 35+5=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/40=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [5, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|5-15| + |115-15|)/2 = (10 + 100)/2 = 55.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,7: 15:[5, 115] Operation: 80+35=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115/5=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*5=175. \nResulting numbers: [80, 175].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |175-15|)/2 = (65 + 160)/2 = 112.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,8: 15:[80, 175] Operation: 35*5=175\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 175-80=95. \nResulting numbers: [95].\n95,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*5=400. \nResulting numbers: [35, 400].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |400-15|)/2 = (20 + 385)/2 = 202.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,9: 15:[35, 400] Operation: 80*5=400\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 400-35=365. \nResulting numbers: [365].\n365,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 15:[80, 35, 5]. Operations so far : ['35/7=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 11th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*35=2800. \nResulting numbers: [5, 2800].\nHeuristic score : (|5-15| + |2800-15|)/2 = (10 + 2785)/2 = 1397.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,10: 15:[5, 2800] Operation: 80*35=2800\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,10’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2800/5=560. \nResulting numbers: [560].\n560,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [35, 35, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |35-15| + |73-15|)/3 = (20 + 20 + 58)/3 = 32.67\nGenerated Node #0,6: 15:[35, 35, 73] Operation: 80-7=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-35=38. \nResulting numbers: [35, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |38-15|)/2 = (20 + 23)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,0: 15:[35, 38] Operation: 73-35=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-35=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 15:[35, 35, 73]. Operations so far : ['80-7=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-35=38. \nResulting numbers: [35, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |38-15|)/2 = (20 + 23)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,1: 15:[35, 38] Operation: 73-35=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-35=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 15:[35, 35, 73]. Operations so far : ['80-7=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35/35=1. \nResulting numbers: [73, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|73-15| + |1-15|)/2 = (58 + 14)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,2: 15:[73, 1] Operation: 35/35=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-1=72. \nResulting numbers: [72].\n72,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 15:[35, 35, 73]. Operations so far : ['80-7=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-35=0. \nResulting numbers: [73, 0].\nHeuristic score : (|73-15| + |0-15|)/2 = (58 + 15)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,3: 15:[73, 0] Operation: 35-35=0\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73*0=0. \nResulting numbers: [0].\n0,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 15:[35, 35, 73]. Operations so far : ['80-7=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+35=70. \nResulting numbers: [73, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|73-15| + |70-15|)/2 = (58 + 55)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,4: 15:[73, 70] Operation: 35+35=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-70=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 15:[35, 35, 73]. Operations so far : ['80-7=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+73=108. \nResulting numbers: [35, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |108-15|)/2 = (20 + 93)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,5: 15:[35, 108] Operation: 35+73=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-35=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 15:[35, 35, 73]. Operations so far : ['80-7=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+73=108. \nResulting numbers: [35, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |108-15|)/2 = (20 + 93)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,6: 15:[35, 108] Operation: 35+73=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-35=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 15:[35, 35, 73]. Operations so far : ['80-7=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*35=1225. \nResulting numbers: [73, 1225].\nHeuristic score : (|73-15| + |1225-15|)/2 = (58 + 1210)/2 = 634.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,7: 15:[73, 1225] Operation: 35*35=1225\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1225-73=1152. \nResulting numbers: [1152].\n1152,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 15:[35, 35, 73]. Operations so far : ['80-7=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*73=2555. \nResulting numbers: [35, 2555].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |2555-15|)/2 = (20 + 2540)/2 = 1280.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,8: 15:[35, 2555] Operation: 35*73=2555\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2555/35=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 15:[35, 35, 73]. Operations so far : ['80-7=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*73=2555. \nResulting numbers: [35, 2555].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |2555-15|)/2 = (20 + 2540)/2 = 1280.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,9: 15:[35, 2555] Operation: 35*73=2555\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2555/35=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-7=28. \nResulting numbers: [80, 35, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |35-15| + |28-15|)/3 = (65 + 20 + 13)/3 = 32.67\nGenerated Node #0,7: 15:[80, 35, 28] Operation: 35-7=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [28, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|28-15| + |45-15|)/2 = (13 + 30)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,0: 15:[28, 45] Operation: 80-35=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-28=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-28=52. \nResulting numbers: [35, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |52-15|)/2 = (20 + 37)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,1: 15:[35, 52] Operation: 80-28=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-35=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-28=7. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15|)/2 = (65 + 8)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,2: 15:[80, 7] Operation: 35-28=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [28, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|28-15| + |115-15|)/2 = (13 + 100)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,3: 15:[28, 115] Operation: 80+35=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-28=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+28=108. \nResulting numbers: [35, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |108-15|)/2 = (20 + 93)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,4: 15:[35, 108] Operation: 80+28=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-35=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+28=63. \nResulting numbers: [80, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |63-15|)/2 = (65 + 48)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,5: 15:[80, 63] Operation: 35+28=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-63=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*28=980. \nResulting numbers: [80, 980].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |980-15|)/2 = (65 + 965)/2 = 515.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,6: 15:[80, 980] Operation: 35*28=980\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 980-80=900. \nResulting numbers: [900].\n900,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*28=2240. \nResulting numbers: [35, 2240].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |2240-15|)/2 = (20 + 2225)/2 = 1122.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,7: 15:[35, 2240] Operation: 80*28=2240\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2240/35=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*35=2800. \nResulting numbers: [28, 2800].\nHeuristic score : (|28-15| + |2800-15|)/2 = (13 + 2785)/2 = 1399.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,8: 15:[28, 2800] Operation: 80*35=2800\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2800/28=100. \nResulting numbers: [100].\n100,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-7=28. \nResulting numbers: [80, 35, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |35-15| + |28-15|)/3 = (65 + 20 + 13)/3 = 32.67\nGenerated Node #0,8: 15:[80, 35, 28] Operation: 35-7=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [28, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|28-15| + |45-15|)/2 = (13 + 30)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,0: 15:[28, 45] Operation: 80-35=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-28=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-28=52. \nResulting numbers: [35, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |52-15|)/2 = (20 + 37)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,1: 15:[35, 52] Operation: 80-28=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-35=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-28=7. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15|)/2 = (65 + 8)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,2: 15:[80, 7] Operation: 35-28=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [28, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|28-15| + |115-15|)/2 = (13 + 100)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,3: 15:[28, 115] Operation: 80+35=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-28=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+28=108. \nResulting numbers: [35, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |108-15|)/2 = (20 + 93)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,4: 15:[35, 108] Operation: 80+28=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-35=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+28=63. \nResulting numbers: [80, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |63-15|)/2 = (65 + 48)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,5: 15:[80, 63] Operation: 35+28=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-63=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*28=980. \nResulting numbers: [80, 980].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |980-15|)/2 = (65 + 965)/2 = 515.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,6: 15:[80, 980] Operation: 35*28=980\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 980-80=900. \nResulting numbers: [900].\n900,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*28=2240. \nResulting numbers: [35, 2240].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |2240-15|)/2 = (20 + 2225)/2 = 1122.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,7: 15:[35, 2240] Operation: 80*28=2240\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2240/35=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 15:[80, 35, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*35=2800. \nResulting numbers: [28, 2800].\nHeuristic score : (|28-15| + |2800-15|)/2 = (13 + 2785)/2 = 1399.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,8: 15:[28, 2800] Operation: 80*35=2800\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2800/28=100. \nResulting numbers: [100].\n100,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+7=87. \nResulting numbers: [35, 35, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |35-15| + |87-15|)/3 = (20 + 20 + 72)/3 = 37.33\nGenerated Node #0,9: 15:[35, 35, 87] Operation: 80+7=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-35=52. \nResulting numbers: [35, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |52-15|)/2 = (20 + 37)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,0: 15:[35, 52] Operation: 87-35=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-35=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 15:[35, 35, 87]. Operations so far : ['80+7=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-35=52. \nResulting numbers: [35, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |52-15|)/2 = (20 + 37)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,1: 15:[35, 52] Operation: 87-35=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-35=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 15:[35, 35, 87]. Operations so far : ['80+7=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35/35=1. \nResulting numbers: [87, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|87-15| + |1-15|)/2 = (72 + 14)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,9,2: 15:[87, 1] Operation: 35/35=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-1=86. \nResulting numbers: [86].\n86,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 15:[35, 35, 87]. Operations so far : ['80+7=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-35=0. \nResulting numbers: [87, 0].\nHeuristic score : (|87-15| + |0-15|)/2 = (72 + 15)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,3: 15:[87, 0] Operation: 35-35=0\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87*0=0. \nResulting numbers: [0].\n0,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 15:[35, 35, 87]. Operations so far : ['80+7=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+35=70. \nResulting numbers: [87, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|87-15| + |70-15|)/2 = (72 + 55)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,4: 15:[87, 70] Operation: 35+35=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-70=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 15:[35, 35, 87]. Operations so far : ['80+7=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+87=122. \nResulting numbers: [35, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |122-15|)/2 = (20 + 107)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,5: 15:[35, 122] Operation: 35+87=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-35=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 15:[35, 35, 87]. Operations so far : ['80+7=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+87=122. \nResulting numbers: [35, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |122-15|)/2 = (20 + 107)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,6: 15:[35, 122] Operation: 35+87=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-35=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 15:[35, 35, 87]. Operations so far : ['80+7=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*35=1225. \nResulting numbers: [87, 1225].\nHeuristic score : (|87-15| + |1225-15|)/2 = (72 + 1210)/2 = 641.00\nGenerated Node #0,9,7: 15:[87, 1225] Operation: 35*35=1225\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1225-87=1138. \nResulting numbers: [1138].\n1138,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 15:[35, 35, 87]. Operations so far : ['80+7=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*87=3045. \nResulting numbers: [35, 3045].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |3045-15|)/2 = (20 + 3030)/2 = 1525.00\nGenerated Node #0,9,8: 15:[35, 3045] Operation: 35*87=3045\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3045/35=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 15:[35, 35, 87]. Operations so far : ['80+7=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*87=3045. \nResulting numbers: [35, 3045].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |3045-15|)/2 = (20 + 3030)/2 = 1525.00\nGenerated Node #0,9,9: 15:[35, 3045] Operation: 35*87=3045\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3045/35=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 11th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+7=42. \nResulting numbers: [80, 35, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |35-15| + |42-15|)/3 = (65 + 20 + 27)/3 = 37.33\nGenerated Node #0,10: 15:[80, 35, 42] Operation: 35+7=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-42=38. \nResulting numbers: [35, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |38-15|)/2 = (20 + 23)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,10,0: 15:[35, 38] Operation: 80-42=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-35=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [42, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|42-15| + |45-15|)/2 = (27 + 30)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,10,1: 15:[42, 45] Operation: 80-35=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-42=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-35=7. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15|)/2 = (65 + 8)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,10,2: 15:[80, 7] Operation: 42-35=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [42, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|42-15| + |115-15|)/2 = (27 + 100)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,10,3: 15:[42, 115] Operation: 80+35=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-42=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+42=122. \nResulting numbers: [35, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |122-15|)/2 = (20 + 107)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,10,4: 15:[35, 122] Operation: 80+42=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-35=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+42=77. \nResulting numbers: [80, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |77-15|)/2 = (65 + 62)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,10,5: 15:[80, 77] Operation: 35+42=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-77=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*42=1470. \nResulting numbers: [80, 1470].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |1470-15|)/2 = (65 + 1455)/2 = 760.00\nGenerated Node #0,10,6: 15:[80, 1470] Operation: 35*42=1470\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1470-80=1390. \nResulting numbers: [1390].\n1390,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*35=2800. \nResulting numbers: [42, 2800].\nHeuristic score : (|42-15| + |2800-15|)/2 = (27 + 2785)/2 = 1406.00\nGenerated Node #0,10,7: 15:[42, 2800] Operation: 80*35=2800\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2800-42=2758. \nResulting numbers: [2758].\n2758,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*42=3360. \nResulting numbers: [35, 3360].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |3360-15|)/2 = (20 + 3345)/2 = 1682.50\nGenerated Node #0,10,8: 15:[35, 3360] Operation: 80*42=3360\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3360/35=96. \nResulting numbers: [96].\n96,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 12th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+35=42. \nResulting numbers: [80, 35, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |35-15| + |42-15|)/3 = (65 + 20 + 27)/3 = 37.33\nGenerated Node #0,11: 15:[80, 35, 42] Operation: 7+35=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-42=38. \nResulting numbers: [35, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |38-15|)/2 = (20 + 23)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,11,0: 15:[35, 38] Operation: 80-42=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-35=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,11 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,11: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['7+35=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [42, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|42-15| + |45-15|)/2 = (27 + 30)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,11,1: 15:[42, 45] Operation: 80-35=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-42=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,11 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,11: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['7+35=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-35=7. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15|)/2 = (65 + 8)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,11,2: 15:[80, 7] Operation: 42-35=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,11 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,11: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['7+35=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [42, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|42-15| + |115-15|)/2 = (27 + 100)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,11,3: 15:[42, 115] Operation: 80+35=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-42=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,11 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,11: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['7+35=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+42=122. \nResulting numbers: [35, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |122-15|)/2 = (20 + 107)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,11,4: 15:[35, 122] Operation: 80+42=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-35=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,11 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,11: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['7+35=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+42=77. \nResulting numbers: [80, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |77-15|)/2 = (65 + 62)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,11,5: 15:[80, 77] Operation: 35+42=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-77=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,11 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,11: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['7+35=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*42=1470. \nResulting numbers: [80, 1470].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |1470-15|)/2 = (65 + 1455)/2 = 760.00\nGenerated Node #0,11,6: 15:[80, 1470] Operation: 35*42=1470\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1470-80=1390. \nResulting numbers: [1390].\n1390,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,11 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,11: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['7+35=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*35=2800. \nResulting numbers: [42, 2800].\nHeuristic score : (|42-15| + |2800-15|)/2 = (27 + 2785)/2 = 1406.00\nGenerated Node #0,11,7: 15:[42, 2800] Operation: 80*35=2800\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2800-42=2758. \nResulting numbers: [2758].\n2758,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,11 with lowest heuristic value 37.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,11: 15:[80, 35, 42]. Operations so far : ['7+35=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*42=3360. \nResulting numbers: [35, 3360].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |3360-15|)/2 = (20 + 3345)/2 = 1682.50\nGenerated Node #0,11,8: 15:[35, 3360] Operation: 80*42=3360\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3360/35=96. \nResulting numbers: [96].\n96,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 13th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [7, 35, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |35-15| + |115-15|)/3 = (8 + 20 + 100)/3 = 42.67\nGenerated Node #0,12: 15:[7, 35, 115] Operation: 80+35=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-35=80. \nResulting numbers: [7, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |80-15|)/2 = (8 + 65)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,12,0: 15:[7, 80] Operation: 115-35=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,12 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,12: 15:[7, 35, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35/7=5. \nResulting numbers: [115, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|115-15| + |5-15|)/2 = (100 + 10)/2 = 55.00\nGenerated Node #0,12,1: 15:[115, 5] Operation: 35/7=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115/5=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,12 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,12: 15:[7, 35, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-7=28. \nResulting numbers: [115, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|115-15| + |28-15|)/2 = (100 + 13)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,12,2: 15:[115, 28] Operation: 35-7=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-28=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,12 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,12: 15:[7, 35, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-7=108. \nResulting numbers: [35, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |108-15|)/2 = (20 + 93)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,12,3: 15:[35, 108] Operation: 115-7=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-35=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,12 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,12: 15:[7, 35, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+35=42. \nResulting numbers: [115, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|115-15| + |42-15|)/2 = (100 + 27)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,12,4: 15:[115, 42] Operation: 7+35=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-42=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,12 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,12: 15:[7, 35, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+115=122. \nResulting numbers: [35, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |122-15|)/2 = (20 + 107)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,12,5: 15:[35, 122] Operation: 7+115=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-35=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,12 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,12: 15:[7, 35, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+115=150. \nResulting numbers: [7, 150].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |150-15|)/2 = (8 + 135)/2 = 71.50\nGenerated Node #0,12,6: 15:[7, 150] Operation: 35+115=150\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 150-7=143. \nResulting numbers: [143].\n143,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,12 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,12: 15:[7, 35, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*35=245. \nResulting numbers: [115, 245].\nHeuristic score : (|115-15| + |245-15|)/2 = (100 + 230)/2 = 165.00\nGenerated Node #0,12,7: 15:[115, 245] Operation: 7*35=245\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245-115=130. \nResulting numbers: [130].\n130,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,12 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,12: 15:[7, 35, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*115=805. \nResulting numbers: [35, 805].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |805-15|)/2 = (20 + 790)/2 = 405.00\nGenerated Node #0,12,8: 15:[35, 805] Operation: 7*115=805\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 805/35=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,12 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,12: 15:[7, 35, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*115=4025. \nResulting numbers: [7, 4025].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |4025-15|)/2 = (8 + 4010)/2 = 2009.00\nGenerated Node #0,12,9: 15:[7, 4025] Operation: 35*115=4025\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,12,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4025/7=575. \nResulting numbers: [575].\n575,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 14th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [35, 7, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |7-15| + |115-15|)/3 = (20 + 8 + 100)/3 = 42.67\nGenerated Node #0,13: 15:[35, 7, 115] Operation: 80+35=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-35=80. \nResulting numbers: [7, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |80-15|)/2 = (8 + 65)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,13,0: 15:[7, 80] Operation: 115-35=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,13 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,13: 15:[35, 7, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35/7=5. \nResulting numbers: [115, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|115-15| + |5-15|)/2 = (100 + 10)/2 = 55.00\nGenerated Node #0,13,1: 15:[115, 5] Operation: 35/7=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115/5=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,13 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,13: 15:[35, 7, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-7=28. \nResulting numbers: [115, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|115-15| + |28-15|)/2 = (100 + 13)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,13,2: 15:[115, 28] Operation: 35-7=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-28=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,13 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,13: 15:[35, 7, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-7=108. \nResulting numbers: [35, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |108-15|)/2 = (20 + 93)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,13,3: 15:[35, 108] Operation: 115-7=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-35=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,13 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,13: 15:[35, 7, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+7=42. \nResulting numbers: [115, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|115-15| + |42-15|)/2 = (100 + 27)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,13,4: 15:[115, 42] Operation: 35+7=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-42=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,13 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,13: 15:[35, 7, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+115=122. \nResulting numbers: [35, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |122-15|)/2 = (20 + 107)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,13,5: 15:[35, 122] Operation: 7+115=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-35=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,13 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,13: 15:[35, 7, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+115=150. \nResulting numbers: [7, 150].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |150-15|)/2 = (8 + 135)/2 = 71.50\nGenerated Node #0,13,6: 15:[7, 150] Operation: 35+115=150\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 150-7=143. \nResulting numbers: [143].\n143,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,13 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,13: 15:[35, 7, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*7=245. \nResulting numbers: [115, 245].\nHeuristic score : (|115-15| + |245-15|)/2 = (100 + 230)/2 = 165.00\nGenerated Node #0,13,7: 15:[115, 245] Operation: 35*7=245\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245-115=130. \nResulting numbers: [130].\n130,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,13 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,13: 15:[35, 7, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*115=805. \nResulting numbers: [35, 805].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |805-15|)/2 = (20 + 790)/2 = 405.00\nGenerated Node #0,13,8: 15:[35, 805] Operation: 7*115=805\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 805/35=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,13 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,13: 15:[35, 7, 115]. Operations so far : ['80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*115=4025. \nResulting numbers: [7, 4025].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |4025-15|)/2 = (8 + 4010)/2 = 2009.00\nGenerated Node #0,13,9: 15:[7, 4025] Operation: 35*115=4025\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,13,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4025/7=575. \nResulting numbers: [575].\n575,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 15th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+35=70. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15| + |70-15|)/3 = (65 + 8 + 55)/3 = 42.67\nGenerated Node #0,14: 15:[80, 7, 70] Operation: 35+35=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-70=10. \nResulting numbers: [7, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |10-15|)/2 = (8 + 5)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,14,0: 15:[7, 10] Operation: 80-70=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+10=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,14 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,14: 15:[80, 7, 70]. Operations so far : ['35+35=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70/7=10. \nResulting numbers: [80, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |10-15|)/2 = (65 + 5)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,14,1: 15:[80, 10] Operation: 70/7=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/10=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,14 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,14: 15:[80, 7, 70]. Operations so far : ['35+35=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [70, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|70-15| + |73-15|)/2 = (55 + 58)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,14,2: 15:[70, 73] Operation: 80-7=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-70=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,14 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,14: 15:[80, 7, 70]. Operations so far : ['35+35=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-7=63. \nResulting numbers: [80, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |63-15|)/2 = (65 + 48)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,14,3: 15:[80, 63] Operation: 70-7=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-63=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,14 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,14: 15:[80, 7, 70]. Operations so far : ['35+35=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+7=87. \nResulting numbers: [70, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|70-15| + |87-15|)/2 = (55 + 72)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,14,4: 15:[70, 87] Operation: 80+7=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-70=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,14 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,14: 15:[80, 7, 70]. Operations so far : ['35+35=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+70=77. \nResulting numbers: [80, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |77-15|)/2 = (65 + 62)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,14,5: 15:[80, 77] Operation: 7+70=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-77=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,14 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,14: 15:[80, 7, 70]. Operations so far : ['35+35=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+70=150. \nResulting numbers: [7, 150].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |150-15|)/2 = (8 + 135)/2 = 71.50\nGenerated Node #0,14,6: 15:[7, 150] Operation: 80+70=150\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 150-7=143. \nResulting numbers: [143].\n143,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,14 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,14: 15:[80, 7, 70]. Operations so far : ['35+35=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*70=490. \nResulting numbers: [80, 490].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |490-15|)/2 = (65 + 475)/2 = 270.00\nGenerated Node #0,14,7: 15:[80, 490] Operation: 7*70=490\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 490-80=410. \nResulting numbers: [410].\n410,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,14 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,14: 15:[80, 7, 70]. Operations so far : ['35+35=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*7=560. \nResulting numbers: [70, 560].\nHeuristic score : (|70-15| + |560-15|)/2 = (55 + 545)/2 = 300.00\nGenerated Node #0,14,8: 15:[70, 560] Operation: 80*7=560\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 560/70=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,14 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,14: 15:[80, 7, 70]. Operations so far : ['35+35=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*70=5600. \nResulting numbers: [7, 5600].\nHeuristic score : (|7-15| + |5600-15|)/2 = (8 + 5585)/2 = 2796.50\nGenerated Node #0,14,9: 15:[7, 5600] Operation: 80*70=5600\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,14,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5600/7=800. \nResulting numbers: [800].\n800,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 16th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*7=245. \nResulting numbers: [80, 35, 245].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |35-15| + |245-15|)/3 = (65 + 20 + 230)/3 = 105.00\nGenerated Node #0,15: 15:[80, 35, 245] Operation: 35*7=245\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245/35=7. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15|)/2 = (65 + 8)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,15,0: 15:[80, 7] Operation: 245/35=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,15 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,15: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['35*7=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245-80=165. \nResulting numbers: [35, 165].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |165-15|)/2 = (20 + 150)/2 = 85.00\nGenerated Node #0,15,1: 15:[35, 165] Operation: 245-80=165\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 165-35=130. \nResulting numbers: [130].\n130,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,15 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,15: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['35*7=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [245, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|245-15| + |45-15|)/2 = (230 + 30)/2 = 130.00\nGenerated Node #0,15,2: 15:[245, 45] Operation: 80-35=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245-45=200. \nResulting numbers: [200].\n200,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,15 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,15: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['35*7=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245-35=210. \nResulting numbers: [80, 210].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |210-15|)/2 = (65 + 195)/2 = 130.00\nGenerated Node #0,15,3: 15:[80, 210] Operation: 245-35=210\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 210-80=130. \nResulting numbers: [130].\n130,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,15 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,15: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['35*7=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [245, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|245-15| + |115-15|)/2 = (230 + 100)/2 = 165.00\nGenerated Node #0,15,4: 15:[245, 115] Operation: 80+35=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245-115=130. \nResulting numbers: [130].\n130,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,15 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,15: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['35*7=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+245=325. \nResulting numbers: [35, 325].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |325-15|)/2 = (20 + 310)/2 = 165.00\nGenerated Node #0,15,5: 15:[35, 325] Operation: 80+245=325\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 325-35=290. \nResulting numbers: [290].\n290,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,15 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,15: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['35*7=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+245=280. \nResulting numbers: [80, 280].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |280-15|)/2 = (65 + 265)/2 = 165.00\nGenerated Node #0,15,6: 15:[80, 280] Operation: 35+245=280\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 280-80=200. \nResulting numbers: [200].\n200,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,15 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,15: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['35*7=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*35=2800. \nResulting numbers: [245, 2800].\nHeuristic score : (|245-15| + |2800-15|)/2 = (230 + 2785)/2 = 1507.50\nGenerated Node #0,15,7: 15:[245, 2800] Operation: 80*35=2800\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2800-245=2555. \nResulting numbers: [2555].\n2555,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,15 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,15: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['35*7=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*245=8575. \nResulting numbers: [80, 8575].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |8575-15|)/2 = (65 + 8560)/2 = 4312.50\nGenerated Node #0,15,8: 15:[80, 8575] Operation: 35*245=8575\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8575-80=8495. \nResulting numbers: [8495].\n8495,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,15 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,15: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['35*7=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*245=19600. \nResulting numbers: [35, 19600].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |19600-15|)/2 = (20 + 19585)/2 = 9802.50\nGenerated Node #0,15,9: 15:[35, 19600] Operation: 80*245=19600\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,15,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 19600/35=560. \nResulting numbers: [560].\n560,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 17th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*35=245. \nResulting numbers: [80, 35, 245].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |35-15| + |245-15|)/3 = (65 + 20 + 230)/3 = 105.00\nGenerated Node #0,16: 15:[80, 35, 245] Operation: 7*35=245\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245/35=7. \nResulting numbers: [80, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |7-15|)/2 = (65 + 8)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,16,0: 15:[80, 7] Operation: 245/35=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-7=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,16 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,16: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['7*35=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245-80=165. \nResulting numbers: [35, 165].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |165-15|)/2 = (20 + 150)/2 = 85.00\nGenerated Node #0,16,1: 15:[35, 165] Operation: 245-80=165\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 165-35=130. \nResulting numbers: [130].\n130,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,16 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,16: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['7*35=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [245, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|245-15| + |45-15|)/2 = (230 + 30)/2 = 130.00\nGenerated Node #0,16,2: 15:[245, 45] Operation: 80-35=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245-45=200. \nResulting numbers: [200].\n200,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,16 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,16: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['7*35=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245-35=210. \nResulting numbers: [80, 210].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |210-15|)/2 = (65 + 195)/2 = 130.00\nGenerated Node #0,16,3: 15:[80, 210] Operation: 245-35=210\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 210-80=130. \nResulting numbers: [130].\n130,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,16 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,16: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['7*35=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [245, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|245-15| + |115-15|)/2 = (230 + 100)/2 = 165.00\nGenerated Node #0,16,4: 15:[245, 115] Operation: 80+35=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245-115=130. \nResulting numbers: [130].\n130,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,16 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,16: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['7*35=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+245=325. \nResulting numbers: [35, 325].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |325-15|)/2 = (20 + 310)/2 = 165.00\nGenerated Node #0,16,5: 15:[35, 325] Operation: 80+245=325\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 325-35=290. \nResulting numbers: [290].\n290,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,16 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,16: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['7*35=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+245=280. \nResulting numbers: [80, 280].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |280-15|)/2 = (65 + 265)/2 = 165.00\nGenerated Node #0,16,6: 15:[80, 280] Operation: 35+245=280\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 280-80=200. \nResulting numbers: [200].\n200,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,16 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,16: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['7*35=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*35=2800. \nResulting numbers: [245, 2800].\nHeuristic score : (|245-15| + |2800-15|)/2 = (230 + 2785)/2 = 1507.50\nGenerated Node #0,16,7: 15:[245, 2800] Operation: 80*35=2800\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2800-245=2555. \nResulting numbers: [2555].\n2555,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,16 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,16: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['7*35=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*245=8575. \nResulting numbers: [80, 8575].\nHeuristic score : (|80-15| + |8575-15|)/2 = (65 + 8560)/2 = 4312.50\nGenerated Node #0,16,8: 15:[80, 8575] Operation: 35*245=8575\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8575-80=8495. \nResulting numbers: [8495].\n8495,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,16 with lowest heuristic value 105.0\nCurrent State #0,16: 15:[80, 35, 245]. Operations so far : ['7*35=245'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*245=19600. \nResulting numbers: [35, 19600].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |19600-15|)/2 = (20 + 19585)/2 = 9802.50\nGenerated Node #0,16,9: 15:[35, 19600] Operation: 80*245=19600\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,16,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 19600/35=560. \nResulting numbers: [560].\n560,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.25\nCurrent State #0: 15:[80, 35, 7, 35]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 18th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*7=560. \nResulting numbers: [35, 35, 560].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |35-15| + |560-15|)/3 = (20 + 20 + 545)/3 = 195.00\nGenerated Node #0,17: 15:[35, 35, 560] Operation: 80*7=560\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,17’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 560/35=16. \nResulting numbers: [35, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |16-15|)/2 = (20 + 1)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,17,0: 15:[35, 16] Operation: 560/35=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,17,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-16=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,17 with lowest heuristic value 195.0\nCurrent State #0,17: 15:[35, 35, 560]. Operations so far : ['80*7=560'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,17’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 560/35=16. \nResulting numbers: [35, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |16-15|)/2 = (20 + 1)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,17,1: 15:[35, 16] Operation: 560/35=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,17,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-16=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,15 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,17 with lowest heuristic value 195.0\nCurrent State #0,17: 15:[35, 35, 560]. Operations so far : ['80*7=560'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,17’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 560-35=525. \nResulting numbers: [35, 525].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |525-15|)/2 = (20 + 510)/2 = 265.00\nGenerated Node #0,17,2: 15:[35, 525] Operation: 560-35=525\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,17,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 525/35=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,15 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['80*7=560', '560-35=525', '525/35=15']\nRESULT: 15\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 39,851 |
[
2,
47,
56,
8
]
| 93 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [2, 47, 56, 8] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 93. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [2, 47, 56, 8]. Our goal is to produce 93. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 93:[2, 47, 56, 8]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2*47=94. \nResulting numbers: [56, 8, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|56-93| + |8-93| + |94-93|)/3 = (37 + 85 + 1)/3 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 93:[56, 8, 94] Operation: 2*47=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+8=64. \nResulting numbers: [94, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|94-93| + |64-93|)/2 = (1 + 29)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 93:[94, 64] Operation: 56+8=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-64=30. \nResulting numbers: [30].\n30,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 41.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[56, 8, 94]. Operations so far : ['2*47=94'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-8=86. \nResulting numbers: [56, 86].\nHeuristic score : (|56-93| + |86-93|)/2 = (37 + 7)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 93:[56, 86] Operation: 94-8=86\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+86=142. \nResulting numbers: [142].\n142,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 41.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[56, 8, 94]. Operations so far : ['2*47=94'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-8=48. \nResulting numbers: [94, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|94-93| + |48-93|)/2 = (1 + 45)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 93:[94, 48] Operation: 56-8=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-48=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 41.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[56, 8, 94]. Operations so far : ['2*47=94'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+94=102. \nResulting numbers: [56, 102].\nHeuristic score : (|56-93| + |102-93|)/2 = (37 + 9)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 93:[56, 102] Operation: 8+94=102\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102-56=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 41.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[56, 8, 94]. Operations so far : ['2*47=94'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56/8=7. \nResulting numbers: [94, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|94-93| + |7-93|)/2 = (1 + 86)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 93:[94, 7] Operation: 56/8=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-7=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 41.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[56, 8, 94]. Operations so far : ['2*47=94'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-56=38. \nResulting numbers: [8, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|8-93| + |38-93|)/2 = (85 + 55)/2 = 70.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 93:[8, 38] Operation: 94-56=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+38=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 41.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[56, 8, 94]. Operations so far : ['2*47=94'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+94=150. \nResulting numbers: [8, 150].\nHeuristic score : (|8-93| + |150-93|)/2 = (85 + 57)/2 = 71.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 93:[8, 150] Operation: 56+94=150\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 150-8=142. \nResulting numbers: [142].\n142,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 41.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[56, 8, 94]. Operations so far : ['2*47=94'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*8=448. \nResulting numbers: [94, 448].\nHeuristic score : (|94-93| + |448-93|)/2 = (1 + 355)/2 = 178.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 93:[94, 448] Operation: 56*8=448\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 448-94=354. \nResulting numbers: [354].\n354,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 41.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[56, 8, 94]. Operations so far : ['2*47=94'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*94=752. \nResulting numbers: [56, 752].\nHeuristic score : (|56-93| + |752-93|)/2 = (37 + 659)/2 = 348.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 93:[56, 752] Operation: 8*94=752\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 752-56=696. \nResulting numbers: [696].\n696,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 41.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[56, 8, 94]. Operations so far : ['2*47=94'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*94=5264. \nResulting numbers: [8, 5264].\nHeuristic score : (|8-93| + |5264-93|)/2 = (85 + 5171)/2 = 2628.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,9: 93:[8, 5264] Operation: 56*94=5264\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5264/8=658. \nResulting numbers: [658].\n658,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 64.75\nCurrent State #0: 93:[2, 47, 56, 8]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2*56=112. \nResulting numbers: [47, 8, 112].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |8-93| + |112-93|)/3 = (46 + 85 + 19)/3 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 93:[47, 8, 112] Operation: 2*56=112\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+8=55. \nResulting numbers: [112, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|112-93| + |55-93|)/2 = (19 + 38)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 93:[112, 55] Operation: 47+8=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112-55=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 50.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 93:[47, 8, 112]. Operations so far : ['2*56=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112-8=104. \nResulting numbers: [47, 104].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |104-93|)/2 = (46 + 11)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 93:[47, 104] Operation: 112-8=104\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104-47=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 50.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 93:[47, 8, 112]. Operations so far : ['2*56=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-8=39. \nResulting numbers: [112, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|112-93| + |39-93|)/2 = (19 + 54)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 93:[112, 39] Operation: 47-8=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112-39=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 50.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 93:[47, 8, 112]. Operations so far : ['2*56=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+112=120. \nResulting numbers: [47, 120].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |120-93|)/2 = (46 + 27)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 93:[47, 120] Operation: 8+112=120\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 120-47=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 50.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 93:[47, 8, 112]. Operations so far : ['2*56=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112-47=65. \nResulting numbers: [8, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|8-93| + |65-93|)/2 = (85 + 28)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 93:[8, 65] Operation: 112-47=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+65=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 50.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 93:[47, 8, 112]. Operations so far : ['2*56=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112/8=14. \nResulting numbers: [47, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |14-93|)/2 = (46 + 79)/2 = 62.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 93:[47, 14] Operation: 112/8=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+14=61. \nResulting numbers: [61].\n61,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 50.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 93:[47, 8, 112]. Operations so far : ['2*56=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+112=159. \nResulting numbers: [8, 159].\nHeuristic score : (|8-93| + |159-93|)/2 = (85 + 66)/2 = 75.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 93:[8, 159] Operation: 47+112=159\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 159-8=151. \nResulting numbers: [151].\n151,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 50.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 93:[47, 8, 112]. Operations so far : ['2*56=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*8=376. \nResulting numbers: [112, 376].\nHeuristic score : (|112-93| + |376-93|)/2 = (19 + 283)/2 = 151.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 93:[112, 376] Operation: 47*8=376\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 376-112=264. \nResulting numbers: [264].\n264,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 50.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 93:[47, 8, 112]. Operations so far : ['2*56=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*112=896. \nResulting numbers: [47, 896].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |896-93|)/2 = (46 + 803)/2 = 424.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 93:[47, 896] Operation: 8*112=896\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 896-47=849. \nResulting numbers: [849].\n849,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 50.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 93:[47, 8, 112]. Operations so far : ['2*56=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*112=5264. \nResulting numbers: [8, 5264].\nHeuristic score : (|8-93| + |5264-93|)/2 = (85 + 5171)/2 = 2628.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,9: 93:[8, 5264] Operation: 47*112=5264\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5264/8=658. \nResulting numbers: [658].\n658,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 64.75\nCurrent State #0: 93:[2, 47, 56, 8]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2*8=16. \nResulting numbers: [47, 56, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |56-93| + |16-93|)/3 = (46 + 37 + 77)/3 = 53.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 93:[47, 56, 16] Operation: 2*8=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+16=63. \nResulting numbers: [56, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|56-93| + |63-93|)/2 = (37 + 30)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 93:[56, 63] Operation: 47+16=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+63=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 93:[47, 56, 16]. Operations so far : ['2*8=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+16=72. \nResulting numbers: [47, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |72-93|)/2 = (46 + 21)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 93:[47, 72] Operation: 56+16=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+72=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 93:[47, 56, 16]. Operations so far : ['2*8=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+56=103. \nResulting numbers: [16, 103].\nHeuristic score : (|16-93| + |103-93|)/2 = (77 + 10)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 93:[16, 103] Operation: 47+56=103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 103-16=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 93:[47, 56, 16]. Operations so far : ['2*8=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-16=31. \nResulting numbers: [56, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|56-93| + |31-93|)/2 = (37 + 62)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 93:[56, 31] Operation: 47-16=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+31=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 93:[47, 56, 16]. Operations so far : ['2*8=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-16=40. \nResulting numbers: [47, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |40-93|)/2 = (46 + 53)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 93:[47, 40] Operation: 56-16=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+40=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 93:[47, 56, 16]. Operations so far : ['2*8=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-47=9. \nResulting numbers: [16, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|16-93| + |9-93|)/2 = (77 + 84)/2 = 80.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 93:[16, 9] Operation: 56-47=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16*9=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 93:[47, 56, 16]. Operations so far : ['2*8=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*16=752. \nResulting numbers: [56, 752].\nHeuristic score : (|56-93| + |752-93|)/2 = (37 + 659)/2 = 348.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 93:[56, 752] Operation: 47*16=752\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 752-56=696. \nResulting numbers: [696].\n696,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 93:[47, 56, 16]. Operations so far : ['2*8=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*16=896. \nResulting numbers: [47, 896].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |896-93|)/2 = (46 + 803)/2 = 424.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 93:[47, 896] Operation: 56*16=896\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 896-47=849. \nResulting numbers: [849].\n849,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 93:[47, 56, 16]. Operations so far : ['2*8=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*56=2632. \nResulting numbers: [16, 2632].\nHeuristic score : (|16-93| + |2632-93|)/2 = (77 + 2539)/2 = 1308.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 93:[16, 2632] Operation: 47*56=2632\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2632-16=2616. \nResulting numbers: [2616].\n2616,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 64.75\nCurrent State #0: 93:[2, 47, 56, 8]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2+47=49. \nResulting numbers: [56, 8, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|56-93| + |8-93| + |49-93|)/3 = (37 + 85 + 44)/3 = 55.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 93:[56, 8, 49] Operation: 2+47=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+8=64. \nResulting numbers: [49, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|49-93| + |64-93|)/2 = (44 + 29)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 93:[49, 64] Operation: 56+8=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49+64=113. \nResulting numbers: [113].\n113,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,3: 93:[56, 8, 49]. Operations so far : ['2+47=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+49=57. \nResulting numbers: [56, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|56-93| + |57-93|)/2 = (37 + 36)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 93:[56, 57] Operation: 8+49=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+57=113. \nResulting numbers: [113].\n113,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,3: 93:[56, 8, 49]. Operations so far : ['2+47=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-8=48. \nResulting numbers: [49, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|49-93| + |48-93|)/2 = (44 + 45)/2 = 44.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 93:[49, 48] Operation: 56-8=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49+48=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,3: 93:[56, 8, 49]. Operations so far : ['2+47=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-8=41. \nResulting numbers: [56, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|56-93| + |41-93|)/2 = (37 + 52)/2 = 44.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 93:[56, 41] Operation: 49-8=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+41=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,3: 93:[56, 8, 49]. Operations so far : ['2+47=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+49=105. \nResulting numbers: [8, 105].\nHeuristic score : (|8-93| + |105-93|)/2 = (85 + 12)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 93:[8, 105] Operation: 56+49=105\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 105-8=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,3: 93:[56, 8, 49]. Operations so far : ['2+47=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56/8=7. \nResulting numbers: [49, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|49-93| + |7-93|)/2 = (44 + 86)/2 = 65.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 93:[49, 7] Operation: 56/8=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49+7=56. \nResulting numbers: [56].\n56,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,3: 93:[56, 8, 49]. Operations so far : ['2+47=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-49=7. \nResulting numbers: [8, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|8-93| + |7-93|)/2 = (85 + 86)/2 = 85.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 93:[8, 7] Operation: 56-49=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*7=56. \nResulting numbers: [56].\n56,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,3: 93:[56, 8, 49]. Operations so far : ['2+47=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*49=392. \nResulting numbers: [56, 392].\nHeuristic score : (|56-93| + |392-93|)/2 = (37 + 299)/2 = 168.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 93:[56, 392] Operation: 8*49=392\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 392/56=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,3: 93:[56, 8, 49]. Operations so far : ['2+47=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*8=448. \nResulting numbers: [49, 448].\nHeuristic score : (|49-93| + |448-93|)/2 = (44 + 355)/2 = 199.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 93:[49, 448] Operation: 56*8=448\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 448-49=399. \nResulting numbers: [399].\n399,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,3: 93:[56, 8, 49]. Operations so far : ['2+47=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*49=2744. \nResulting numbers: [8, 2744].\nHeuristic score : (|8-93| + |2744-93|)/2 = (85 + 2651)/2 = 1368.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,9: 93:[8, 2744] Operation: 56*49=2744\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2744/8=343. \nResulting numbers: [343].\n343,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 64.75\nCurrent State #0: 93:[2, 47, 56, 8]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2+56=58. \nResulting numbers: [47, 8, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |8-93| + |58-93|)/3 = (46 + 85 + 35)/3 = 55.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 93:[47, 8, 58] Operation: 2+56=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+8=55. \nResulting numbers: [58, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|58-93| + |55-93|)/2 = (35 + 38)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 93:[58, 55] Operation: 47+8=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58+55=113. \nResulting numbers: [113].\n113,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,4: 93:[47, 8, 58]. Operations so far : ['2+56=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+58=66. \nResulting numbers: [47, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |66-93|)/2 = (46 + 27)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 93:[47, 66] Operation: 8+58=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+66=113. \nResulting numbers: [113].\n113,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,4: 93:[47, 8, 58]. Operations so far : ['2+56=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-8=39. \nResulting numbers: [58, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|58-93| + |39-93|)/2 = (35 + 54)/2 = 44.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 93:[58, 39] Operation: 47-8=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58+39=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,4: 93:[47, 8, 58]. Operations so far : ['2+56=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58-8=50. \nResulting numbers: [47, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |50-93|)/2 = (46 + 43)/2 = 44.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 93:[47, 50] Operation: 58-8=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+50=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,4: 93:[47, 8, 58]. Operations so far : ['2+56=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+58=105. \nResulting numbers: [8, 105].\nHeuristic score : (|8-93| + |105-93|)/2 = (85 + 12)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 93:[8, 105] Operation: 47+58=105\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 105-8=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,4: 93:[47, 8, 58]. Operations so far : ['2+56=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58-47=11. \nResulting numbers: [8, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|8-93| + |11-93|)/2 = (85 + 82)/2 = 83.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 93:[8, 11] Operation: 58-47=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*11=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,4: 93:[47, 8, 58]. Operations so far : ['2+56=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*8=376. \nResulting numbers: [58, 376].\nHeuristic score : (|58-93| + |376-93|)/2 = (35 + 283)/2 = 159.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 93:[58, 376] Operation: 47*8=376\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 376-58=318. \nResulting numbers: [318].\n318,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,4: 93:[47, 8, 58]. Operations so far : ['2+56=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*58=464. \nResulting numbers: [47, 464].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |464-93|)/2 = (46 + 371)/2 = 208.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 93:[47, 464] Operation: 8*58=464\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 464-47=417. \nResulting numbers: [417].\n417,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,4: 93:[47, 8, 58]. Operations so far : ['2+56=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*58=2726. \nResulting numbers: [8, 2726].\nHeuristic score : (|8-93| + |2726-93|)/2 = (85 + 2633)/2 = 1359.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 93:[8, 2726] Operation: 47*58=2726\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2726-8=2718. \nResulting numbers: [2718].\n2718,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 64.75\nCurrent State #0: 93:[2, 47, 56, 8]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2+8=10. \nResulting numbers: [47, 56, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |56-93| + |10-93|)/3 = (46 + 37 + 83)/3 = 55.33\nGenerated Node #0,5: 93:[47, 56, 10] Operation: 2+8=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+10=57. \nResulting numbers: [56, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|56-93| + |57-93|)/2 = (37 + 36)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 93:[56, 57] Operation: 47+10=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+57=113. \nResulting numbers: [113].\n113,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,5: 93:[47, 56, 10]. Operations so far : ['2+8=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+10=66. \nResulting numbers: [47, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |66-93|)/2 = (46 + 27)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 93:[47, 66] Operation: 56+10=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+66=113. \nResulting numbers: [113].\n113,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 55.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,5: 93:[47, 56, 10]. Operations so far : ['2+8=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+56=103. \nResulting numbers: [10, 103].\nHeuristic score : (|10-93| + |103-93|)/2 = (83 + 10)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 93:[10, 103] Operation: 47+56=103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 103-10=93. \nResulting numbers: [93].\n93,93 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['2+8=10', '47+56=103', '103-10=93']\nRESULT: 93\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 11,957 |
[
32,
50,
3,
72
]
| 51 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [32, 50, 3, 72] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 51. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [32, 50, 3, 72]. Our goal is to produce 51. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 51:[32, 50, 3, 72]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+3=35. \nResulting numbers: [50, 72, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|50-51| + |72-51| + |35-51|)/3 = (1 + 21 + 16)/3 = 12.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 51:[50, 72, 35] Operation: 32+3=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-35=37. \nResulting numbers: [50, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|50-51| + |37-51|)/2 = (1 + 14)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 51:[50, 37] Operation: 72-35=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+37=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,51 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 51:[50, 72, 35]. Operations so far : ['32+3=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-50=22. \nResulting numbers: [35, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|35-51| + |22-51|)/2 = (16 + 29)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 51:[35, 22] Operation: 72-50=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+22=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,51 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 51:[50, 72, 35]. Operations so far : ['32+3=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+35=85. \nResulting numbers: [72, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|72-51| + |85-51|)/2 = (21 + 34)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 51:[72, 85] Operation: 50+35=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-72=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,51 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 51:[50, 72, 35]. Operations so far : ['32+3=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-35=15. \nResulting numbers: [72, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|72-51| + |15-51|)/2 = (21 + 36)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 51:[72, 15] Operation: 50-35=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-15=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,51 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 51:[50, 72, 35]. Operations so far : ['32+3=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+35=107. \nResulting numbers: [50, 107].\nHeuristic score : (|50-51| + |107-51|)/2 = (1 + 56)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 51:[50, 107] Operation: 72+35=107\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 107-50=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,51 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 51:[50, 72, 35]. Operations so far : ['32+3=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+72=122. \nResulting numbers: [35, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|35-51| + |122-51|)/2 = (16 + 71)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 51:[35, 122] Operation: 50+72=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-35=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,51 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 51:[50, 72, 35]. Operations so far : ['32+3=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*35=1750. \nResulting numbers: [72, 1750].\nHeuristic score : (|72-51| + |1750-51|)/2 = (21 + 1699)/2 = 860.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 51:[72, 1750] Operation: 50*35=1750\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1750-72=1678. \nResulting numbers: [1678].\n1678,51 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 51:[50, 72, 35]. Operations so far : ['32+3=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72*35=2520. \nResulting numbers: [50, 2520].\nHeuristic score : (|50-51| + |2520-51|)/2 = (1 + 2469)/2 = 1235.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 51:[50, 2520] Operation: 72*35=2520\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2520-50=2470. \nResulting numbers: [2470].\n2470,51 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 51:[50, 72, 35]. Operations so far : ['32+3=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*72=3600. \nResulting numbers: [35, 3600].\nHeuristic score : (|35-51| + |3600-51|)/2 = (16 + 3549)/2 = 1782.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 51:[35, 3600] Operation: 50*72=3600\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3600-35=3565. \nResulting numbers: [3565].\n3565,51 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 22.25\nCurrent State #0: 51:[32, 50, 3, 72]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-3=69. \nResulting numbers: [32, 50, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|32-51| + |50-51| + |69-51|)/3 = (19 + 1 + 18)/3 = 12.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 51:[32, 50, 69] Operation: 72-3=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-32=37. \nResulting numbers: [50, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|50-51| + |37-51|)/2 = (1 + 14)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 51:[50, 37] Operation: 69-32=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+37=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,51 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 12.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,1: 51:[32, 50, 69]. Operations so far : ['72-3=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+50=82. \nResulting numbers: [69, 82].\nHeuristic score : (|69-51| + |82-51|)/2 = (18 + 31)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 51:[69, 82] Operation: 32+50=82\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-69=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,51 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 12.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,1: 51:[32, 50, 69]. Operations so far : ['72-3=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-32=18. \nResulting numbers: [69, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|69-51| + |18-51|)/2 = (18 + 33)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 51:[69, 18] Operation: 50-32=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-18=51. \nResulting numbers: [51].\n51,51 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['72-3=69', '50-32=18', '69-18=51']\nRESULT: 51\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 2,992 |
[
75,
81,
25,
63
]
| 54 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [75, 81, 25, 63] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 54. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [75, 81, 25, 63]. Our goal is to produce 54. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 54:[75, 81, 25, 63]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-25=56. \nResulting numbers: [75, 63, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |63-54| + |56-54|)/3 = (21 + 9 + 2)/3 = 10.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 54:[75, 63, 56] Operation: 81-25=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-63=12. \nResulting numbers: [56, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|56-54| + |12-54|)/2 = (2 + 42)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 54:[56, 12] Operation: 75-63=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-12=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 54:[75, 63, 56]. Operations so far : ['81-25=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-56=19. \nResulting numbers: [63, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |19-54|)/2 = (9 + 35)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 54:[63, 19] Operation: 75-56=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-19=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 54:[75, 63, 56]. Operations so far : ['81-25=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-56=7. \nResulting numbers: [75, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |7-54|)/2 = (21 + 47)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 54:[75, 7] Operation: 63-56=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-7=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 54:[75, 63, 56]. Operations so far : ['81-25=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+63=138. \nResulting numbers: [56, 138].\nHeuristic score : (|56-54| + |138-54|)/2 = (2 + 84)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 54:[56, 138] Operation: 75+63=138\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 138-56=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 54:[75, 63, 56]. Operations so far : ['81-25=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+56=131. \nResulting numbers: [63, 131].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |131-54|)/2 = (9 + 77)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 54:[63, 131] Operation: 75+56=131\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 131-63=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 54:[75, 63, 56]. Operations so far : ['81-25=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+56=119. \nResulting numbers: [75, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |119-54|)/2 = (21 + 65)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 54:[75, 119] Operation: 63+56=119\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 119-75=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 54:[75, 63, 56]. Operations so far : ['81-25=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63*56=3528. \nResulting numbers: [75, 3528].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |3528-54|)/2 = (21 + 3474)/2 = 1747.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 54:[75, 3528] Operation: 63*56=3528\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3528-75=3453. \nResulting numbers: [3453].\n3453,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 54:[75, 63, 56]. Operations so far : ['81-25=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*56=4200. \nResulting numbers: [63, 4200].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |4200-54|)/2 = (9 + 4146)/2 = 2077.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 54:[63, 4200] Operation: 75*56=4200\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4200-63=4137. \nResulting numbers: [4137].\n4137,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 54:[75, 63, 56]. Operations so far : ['81-25=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*63=4725. \nResulting numbers: [56, 4725].\nHeuristic score : (|56-54| + |4725-54|)/2 = (2 + 4671)/2 = 2336.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 54:[56, 4725] Operation: 75*63=4725\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4725-56=4669. \nResulting numbers: [4669].\n4669,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0: 54:[75, 81, 25, 63]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-25=50. \nResulting numbers: [81, 63, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |63-54| + |50-54|)/3 = (27 + 9 + 4)/3 = 13.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 54:[81, 63, 50] Operation: 75-25=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-50=31. \nResulting numbers: [63, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |31-54|)/2 = (9 + 23)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 54:[63, 31] Operation: 81-50=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-31=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 54:[81, 63, 50]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-63=18. \nResulting numbers: [50, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|50-54| + |18-54|)/2 = (4 + 36)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 54:[50, 18] Operation: 81-63=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+18=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 54:[81, 63, 50]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-50=13. \nResulting numbers: [81, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |13-54|)/2 = (27 + 41)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 54:[81, 13] Operation: 63-50=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-13=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 54:[81, 63, 50]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+50=131. \nResulting numbers: [63, 131].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |131-54|)/2 = (9 + 77)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 54:[63, 131] Operation: 81+50=131\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 131-63=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 54:[81, 63, 50]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+50=113. \nResulting numbers: [81, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |113-54|)/2 = (27 + 59)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 54:[81, 113] Operation: 63+50=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-81=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 54:[81, 63, 50]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+63=144. \nResulting numbers: [50, 144].\nHeuristic score : (|50-54| + |144-54|)/2 = (4 + 90)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 54:[50, 144] Operation: 81+63=144\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 144-50=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 54:[81, 63, 50]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63*50=3150. \nResulting numbers: [81, 3150].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |3150-54|)/2 = (27 + 3096)/2 = 1561.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 54:[81, 3150] Operation: 63*50=3150\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3150-81=3069. \nResulting numbers: [3069].\n3069,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 54:[81, 63, 50]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*50=4050. \nResulting numbers: [63, 4050].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |4050-54|)/2 = (9 + 3996)/2 = 2002.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 54:[63, 4050] Operation: 81*50=4050\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4050-63=3987. \nResulting numbers: [3987].\n3987,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 54:[81, 63, 50]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*63=5103. \nResulting numbers: [50, 5103].\nHeuristic score : (|50-54| + |5103-54|)/2 = (4 + 5049)/2 = 2526.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 54:[50, 5103] Operation: 81*63=5103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5103-50=5053. \nResulting numbers: [5053].\n5053,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0: 54:[75, 81, 25, 63]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-25=38. \nResulting numbers: [75, 81, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |81-54| + |38-54|)/3 = (21 + 27 + 16)/3 = 21.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 54:[75, 81, 38] Operation: 63-25=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-38=43. \nResulting numbers: [75, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |43-54|)/2 = (21 + 11)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 54:[75, 43] Operation: 81-38=43\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-43=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 54:[75, 81, 38]. Operations so far : ['63-25=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-38=37. \nResulting numbers: [81, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |37-54|)/2 = (27 + 17)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 54:[81, 37] Operation: 75-38=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-37=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 54:[75, 81, 38]. Operations so far : ['63-25=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-75=6. \nResulting numbers: [38, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|38-54| + |6-54|)/2 = (16 + 48)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 54:[38, 6] Operation: 81-75=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+6=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 54:[75, 81, 38]. Operations so far : ['63-25=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+38=113. \nResulting numbers: [81, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |113-54|)/2 = (27 + 59)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 54:[81, 113] Operation: 75+38=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-81=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 54:[75, 81, 38]. Operations so far : ['63-25=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+38=119. \nResulting numbers: [75, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |119-54|)/2 = (21 + 65)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 54:[75, 119] Operation: 81+38=119\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 119-75=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 54:[75, 81, 38]. Operations so far : ['63-25=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+81=156. \nResulting numbers: [38, 156].\nHeuristic score : (|38-54| + |156-54|)/2 = (16 + 102)/2 = 59.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 54:[38, 156] Operation: 75+81=156\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 156-38=118. \nResulting numbers: [118].\n118,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 54:[75, 81, 38]. Operations so far : ['63-25=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*38=2850. \nResulting numbers: [81, 2850].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |2850-54|)/2 = (27 + 2796)/2 = 1411.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 54:[81, 2850] Operation: 75*38=2850\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2850-81=2769. \nResulting numbers: [2769].\n2769,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 54:[75, 81, 38]. Operations so far : ['63-25=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*38=3078. \nResulting numbers: [75, 3078].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |3078-54|)/2 = (21 + 3024)/2 = 1522.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 54:[75, 3078] Operation: 81*38=3078\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3078-75=3003. \nResulting numbers: [3003].\n3003,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 54:[75, 81, 38]. Operations so far : ['63-25=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*81=6075. \nResulting numbers: [38, 6075].\nHeuristic score : (|38-54| + |6075-54|)/2 = (16 + 6021)/2 = 3018.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 54:[38, 6075] Operation: 75*81=6075\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6075-38=6037. \nResulting numbers: [6037].\n6037,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0: 54:[75, 81, 25, 63]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+25=100. \nResulting numbers: [81, 63, 100].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |63-54| + |100-54|)/3 = (27 + 9 + 46)/3 = 27.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 54:[81, 63, 100] Operation: 75+25=100\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-81=19. \nResulting numbers: [63, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |19-54|)/2 = (9 + 35)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 54:[63, 19] Operation: 100-81=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-19=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 54:[81, 63, 100]. Operations so far : ['75+25=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-63=37. \nResulting numbers: [81, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |37-54|)/2 = (27 + 17)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 54:[81, 37] Operation: 100-63=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-37=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 54:[81, 63, 100]. Operations so far : ['75+25=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-63=18. \nResulting numbers: [100, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|100-54| + |18-54|)/2 = (46 + 36)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 54:[100, 18] Operation: 81-63=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-18=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 54:[81, 63, 100]. Operations so far : ['75+25=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+63=144. \nResulting numbers: [100, 144].\nHeuristic score : (|100-54| + |144-54|)/2 = (46 + 90)/2 = 68.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 54:[100, 144] Operation: 81+63=144\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 144-100=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 54:[81, 63, 100]. Operations so far : ['75+25=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+100=181. \nResulting numbers: [63, 181].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |181-54|)/2 = (9 + 127)/2 = 68.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 54:[63, 181] Operation: 81+100=181\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 181-63=118. \nResulting numbers: [118].\n118,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 54:[81, 63, 100]. Operations so far : ['75+25=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+100=163. \nResulting numbers: [81, 163].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |163-54|)/2 = (27 + 109)/2 = 68.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 54:[81, 163] Operation: 63+100=163\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 163-81=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 54:[81, 63, 100]. Operations so far : ['75+25=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*63=5103. \nResulting numbers: [100, 5103].\nHeuristic score : (|100-54| + |5103-54|)/2 = (46 + 5049)/2 = 2547.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 54:[100, 5103] Operation: 81*63=5103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5103-100=5003. \nResulting numbers: [5003].\n5003,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 54:[81, 63, 100]. Operations so far : ['75+25=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63*100=6300. \nResulting numbers: [81, 6300].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |6300-54|)/2 = (27 + 6246)/2 = 3136.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 54:[81, 6300] Operation: 63*100=6300\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6300-81=6219. \nResulting numbers: [6219].\n6219,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 54:[81, 63, 100]. Operations so far : ['75+25=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*100=8100. \nResulting numbers: [63, 8100].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |8100-54|)/2 = (9 + 8046)/2 = 4027.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 54:[63, 8100] Operation: 81*100=8100\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8100-63=8037. \nResulting numbers: [8037].\n8037,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0: 54:[75, 81, 25, 63]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+25=106. \nResulting numbers: [75, 63, 106].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |63-54| + |106-54|)/3 = (21 + 9 + 52)/3 = 27.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 54:[75, 63, 106] Operation: 81+25=106\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 106-75=31. \nResulting numbers: [63, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |31-54|)/2 = (9 + 23)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 54:[63, 31] Operation: 106-75=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-31=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 54:[75, 63, 106]. Operations so far : ['81+25=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 106-63=43. \nResulting numbers: [75, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |43-54|)/2 = (21 + 11)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 54:[75, 43] Operation: 106-63=43\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-43=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 54:[75, 63, 106]. Operations so far : ['81+25=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-63=12. \nResulting numbers: [106, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|106-54| + |12-54|)/2 = (52 + 42)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 54:[106, 12] Operation: 75-63=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 106-12=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 54:[75, 63, 106]. Operations so far : ['81+25=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+63=138. \nResulting numbers: [106, 138].\nHeuristic score : (|106-54| + |138-54|)/2 = (52 + 84)/2 = 68.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 54:[106, 138] Operation: 75+63=138\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 138-106=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 54:[75, 63, 106]. Operations so far : ['81+25=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+106=181. \nResulting numbers: [63, 181].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |181-54|)/2 = (9 + 127)/2 = 68.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 54:[63, 181] Operation: 75+106=181\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 181-63=118. \nResulting numbers: [118].\n118,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 54:[75, 63, 106]. Operations so far : ['81+25=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+106=169. \nResulting numbers: [75, 169].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |169-54|)/2 = (21 + 115)/2 = 68.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 54:[75, 169] Operation: 63+106=169\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 169-75=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 54:[75, 63, 106]. Operations so far : ['81+25=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*63=4725. \nResulting numbers: [106, 4725].\nHeuristic score : (|106-54| + |4725-54|)/2 = (52 + 4671)/2 = 2361.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 54:[106, 4725] Operation: 75*63=4725\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4725-106=4619. \nResulting numbers: [4619].\n4619,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 54:[75, 63, 106]. Operations so far : ['81+25=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63*106=6678. \nResulting numbers: [75, 6678].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |6678-54|)/2 = (21 + 6624)/2 = 3322.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 54:[75, 6678] Operation: 63*106=6678\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6678-75=6603. \nResulting numbers: [6603].\n6603,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 54:[75, 63, 106]. Operations so far : ['81+25=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*106=7950. \nResulting numbers: [63, 7950].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |7950-54|)/2 = (9 + 7896)/2 = 3952.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 54:[63, 7950] Operation: 75*106=7950\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7950-63=7887. \nResulting numbers: [7887].\n7887,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0: 54:[75, 81, 25, 63]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+63=88. \nResulting numbers: [75, 81, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |81-54| + |88-54|)/3 = (21 + 27 + 34)/3 = 27.33\nGenerated Node #0,5: 54:[75, 81, 88] Operation: 25+63=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-75=13. \nResulting numbers: [81, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |13-54|)/2 = (27 + 41)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 54:[81, 13] Operation: 88-75=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-13=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 54:[75, 81, 88]. Operations so far : ['25+63=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-81=7. \nResulting numbers: [75, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |7-54|)/2 = (21 + 47)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 54:[75, 7] Operation: 88-81=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-7=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 54:[75, 81, 88]. Operations so far : ['25+63=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-75=6. \nResulting numbers: [88, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|88-54| + |6-54|)/2 = (34 + 48)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 54:[88, 6] Operation: 81-75=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-6=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 54:[75, 81, 88]. Operations so far : ['25+63=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+81=156. \nResulting numbers: [88, 156].\nHeuristic score : (|88-54| + |156-54|)/2 = (34 + 102)/2 = 68.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,3: 54:[88, 156] Operation: 75+81=156\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 156-88=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 54:[75, 81, 88]. Operations so far : ['25+63=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+88=163. \nResulting numbers: [81, 163].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |163-54|)/2 = (27 + 109)/2 = 68.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,4: 54:[81, 163] Operation: 75+88=163\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 163-81=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 54:[75, 81, 88]. Operations so far : ['25+63=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+88=169. \nResulting numbers: [75, 169].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |169-54|)/2 = (21 + 115)/2 = 68.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,5: 54:[75, 169] Operation: 81+88=169\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 169-75=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 54:[75, 81, 88]. Operations so far : ['25+63=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*81=6075. \nResulting numbers: [88, 6075].\nHeuristic score : (|88-54| + |6075-54|)/2 = (34 + 6021)/2 = 3027.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,6: 54:[88, 6075] Operation: 75*81=6075\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6075-88=5987. \nResulting numbers: [5987].\n5987,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 54:[75, 81, 88]. Operations so far : ['25+63=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*88=6600. \nResulting numbers: [81, 6600].\nHeuristic score : (|81-54| + |6600-54|)/2 = (27 + 6546)/2 = 3286.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,7: 54:[81, 6600] Operation: 75*88=6600\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6600-81=6519. \nResulting numbers: [6519].\n6519,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 54:[75, 81, 88]. Operations so far : ['25+63=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*88=7128. \nResulting numbers: [75, 7128].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |7128-54|)/2 = (21 + 7074)/2 = 3547.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,8: 54:[75, 7128] Operation: 81*88=7128\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7128-75=7053. \nResulting numbers: [7053].\n7053,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0: 54:[75, 81, 25, 63]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-75=6. \nResulting numbers: [25, 63, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|25-54| + |63-54| + |6-54|)/3 = (29 + 9 + 48)/3 = 28.67\nGenerated Node #0,6: 54:[25, 63, 6] Operation: 81-75=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+6=31. \nResulting numbers: [63, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |31-54|)/2 = (9 + 23)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,0: 54:[63, 31] Operation: 25+6=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-31=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 54:[25, 63, 6]. Operations so far : ['81-75=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-6=57. \nResulting numbers: [25, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|25-54| + |57-54|)/2 = (29 + 3)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,1: 54:[25, 57] Operation: 63-6=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-25=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 54:[25, 63, 6]. Operations so far : ['81-75=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25-6=19. \nResulting numbers: [63, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |19-54|)/2 = (9 + 35)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,2: 54:[63, 19] Operation: 25-6=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-19=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 54:[25, 63, 6]. Operations so far : ['81-75=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+6=69. \nResulting numbers: [25, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|25-54| + |69-54|)/2 = (29 + 15)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,3: 54:[25, 69] Operation: 63+6=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-25=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 54:[25, 63, 6]. Operations so far : ['81-75=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-25=38. \nResulting numbers: [6, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|6-54| + |38-54|)/2 = (48 + 16)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,4: 54:[6, 38] Operation: 63-25=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+38=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 54:[25, 63, 6]. Operations so far : ['81-75=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+63=88. \nResulting numbers: [6, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|6-54| + |88-54|)/2 = (48 + 34)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,5: 54:[6, 88] Operation: 25+63=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-6=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 54:[25, 63, 6]. Operations so far : ['81-75=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*6=150. \nResulting numbers: [63, 150].\nHeuristic score : (|63-54| + |150-54|)/2 = (9 + 96)/2 = 52.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,6: 54:[63, 150] Operation: 25*6=150\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 150-63=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 54:[25, 63, 6]. Operations so far : ['81-75=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63*6=378. \nResulting numbers: [25, 378].\nHeuristic score : (|25-54| + |378-54|)/2 = (29 + 324)/2 = 176.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,7: 54:[25, 378] Operation: 63*6=378\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 378-25=353. \nResulting numbers: [353].\n353,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 54:[25, 63, 6]. Operations so far : ['81-75=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*63=1575. \nResulting numbers: [6, 1575].\nHeuristic score : (|6-54| + |1575-54|)/2 = (48 + 1521)/2 = 784.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,8: 54:[6, 1575] Operation: 25*63=1575\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1575-6=1569. \nResulting numbers: [1569].\n1569,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0: 54:[75, 81, 25, 63]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-63=18. \nResulting numbers: [75, 25, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |25-54| + |18-54|)/3 = (21 + 29 + 36)/3 = 28.67\nGenerated Node #0,7: 54:[75, 25, 18] Operation: 81-63=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-18=57. \nResulting numbers: [25, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|25-54| + |57-54|)/2 = (29 + 3)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,0: 54:[25, 57] Operation: 75-18=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-25=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,7: 54:[75, 25, 18]. Operations so far : ['81-63=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+18=43. \nResulting numbers: [75, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |43-54|)/2 = (21 + 11)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,1: 54:[75, 43] Operation: 25+18=43\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-43=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,7: 54:[75, 25, 18]. Operations so far : ['81-63=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-25=50. \nResulting numbers: [18, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|18-54| + |50-54|)/2 = (36 + 4)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,2: 54:[18, 50] Operation: 75-25=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 18+50=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,7: 54:[75, 25, 18]. Operations so far : ['81-63=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+18=93. \nResulting numbers: [25, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|25-54| + |93-54|)/2 = (29 + 39)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,3: 54:[25, 93] Operation: 75+18=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-25=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,7: 54:[75, 25, 18]. Operations so far : ['81-63=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25-18=7. \nResulting numbers: [75, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|75-54| + |7-54|)/2 = (21 + 47)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,4: 54:[75, 7] Operation: 25-18=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-7=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,7: 54:[75, 25, 18]. Operations so far : ['81-63=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+25=100. \nResulting numbers: [18, 100].\nHeuristic score : (|18-54| + |100-54|)/2 = (36 + 46)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,5: 54:[18, 100] Operation: 75+25=100\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-18=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,54 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,7: 54:[75, 25, 18]. Operations so far : ['81-63=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75/25=3. \nResulting numbers: [18, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|18-54| + |3-54|)/2 = (36 + 51)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,6: 54:[18, 3] Operation: 75/25=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 18*3=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,54 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['81-63=18', '75/25=3', '18*3=54']\nRESULT: 54\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 16,592 |
[
40,
26,
28,
22
]
| 72 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [40, 26, 28, 22] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 72. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [40, 26, 28, 22]. Our goal is to produce 72. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 72:[40, 26, 28, 22]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+28=54. \nResulting numbers: [40, 22, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|40-72| + |22-72| + |54-72|)/3 = (32 + 50 + 18)/3 = 33.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 72:[40, 22, 54] Operation: 26+28=54\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+22=62. \nResulting numbers: [26, 28, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|26-72| + |28-72| + |62-72|)/3 = (46 + 44 + 10)/3 = 33.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 72:[26, 28, 62] Operation: 40+22=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+26=66. \nResulting numbers: [28, 22, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|28-72| + |22-72| + |66-72|)/3 = (44 + 50 + 6)/3 = 33.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 72:[28, 22, 66] Operation: 40+26=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+28=68. \nResulting numbers: [26, 22, 68].\nHeuristic score : (|26-72| + |22-72| + |68-72|)/3 = (46 + 50 + 4)/3 = 33.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 72:[26, 22, 68] Operation: 40+28=68\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+22=48. \nResulting numbers: [40, 28, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|40-72| + |28-72| + |48-72|)/3 = (32 + 44 + 24)/3 = 33.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 72:[40, 28, 48] Operation: 26+22=48\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 72:[40, 22, 54]. Operations so far : ['26+28=54'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+54=76. \nResulting numbers: [40, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|40-72| + |76-72|)/2 = (32 + 4)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 72:[40, 76] Operation: 22+54=76\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-22=18. \nResulting numbers: [54, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|54-72| + |18-72|)/2 = (18 + 54)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 72:[54, 18] Operation: 40-22=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+22=62. \nResulting numbers: [54, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|54-72| + |62-72|)/2 = (18 + 10)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 72:[54, 62] Operation: 40+22=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+54=94. \nResulting numbers: [22, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|22-72| + |94-72|)/2 = (50 + 22)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 72:[22, 94] Operation: 40+54=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-22=32. \nResulting numbers: [40, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|40-72| + |32-72|)/2 = (32 + 40)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 72:[40, 32] Operation: 54-22=32\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 72:[28, 22, 66]. Operations so far : ['40+26=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-22=44. \nResulting numbers: [28, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|28-72| + |44-72|)/2 = (44 + 28)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 72:[28, 44] Operation: 66-22=44\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-22=6. \nResulting numbers: [66, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|66-72| + |6-72|)/2 = (6 + 66)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 72:[66, 6] Operation: 28-22=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+22=50. \nResulting numbers: [66, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|66-72| + |50-72|)/2 = (6 + 22)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 72:[66, 50] Operation: 28+22=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+66=88. \nResulting numbers: [28, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|28-72| + |88-72|)/2 = (44 + 16)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 72:[28, 88] Operation: 22+66=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+66=94. \nResulting numbers: [22, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|22-72| + |94-72|)/2 = (50 + 22)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 72:[22, 94] Operation: 28+66=94\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,4: 72:[40, 28, 48]. Operations so far : ['26+22=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+48=88. \nResulting numbers: [28, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|28-72| + |88-72|)/2 = (44 + 16)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 72:[28, 88] Operation: 40+48=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-28=20. \nResulting numbers: [40, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|40-72| + |20-72|)/2 = (32 + 52)/2 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 72:[40, 20] Operation: 48-28=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+48=76. \nResulting numbers: [40, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|40-72| + |76-72|)/2 = (32 + 4)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 72:[40, 76] Operation: 28+48=76\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+28=68. \nResulting numbers: [48, 68].\nHeuristic score : (|48-72| + |68-72|)/2 = (24 + 4)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 72:[48, 68] Operation: 40+28=68\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-28=12. \nResulting numbers: [48, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|48-72| + |12-72|)/2 = (24 + 60)/2 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 72:[48, 12] Operation: 40-28=12\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 72:[26, 28, 62]. Operations so far : ['40+22=62'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-26=2. \nResulting numbers: [62, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|62-72| + |2-72|)/2 = (10 + 70)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 72:[62, 2] Operation: 28-26=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+62=88. \nResulting numbers: [28, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|28-72| + |88-72|)/2 = (44 + 16)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 72:[28, 88] Operation: 26+62=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-26=36. \nResulting numbers: [28, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|28-72| + |36-72|)/2 = (44 + 36)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 72:[28, 36] Operation: 62-26=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+62=90. \nResulting numbers: [26, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|26-72| + |90-72|)/2 = (46 + 18)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 72:[26, 90] Operation: 28+62=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+28=54. \nResulting numbers: [62, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|62-72| + |54-72|)/2 = (10 + 18)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 72:[62, 54] Operation: 26+28=54\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,3: 72:[26, 22, 68]. Operations so far : ['40+28=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+68=94. \nResulting numbers: [22, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|22-72| + |94-72|)/2 = (50 + 22)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 72:[22, 94] Operation: 26+68=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-22=46. \nResulting numbers: [26, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|26-72| + |46-72|)/2 = (46 + 26)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 72:[26, 46] Operation: 68-22=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+68=90. \nResulting numbers: [26, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|26-72| + |90-72|)/2 = (46 + 18)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 72:[26, 90] Operation: 22+68=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+22=48. \nResulting numbers: [68, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|68-72| + |48-72|)/2 = (4 + 24)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 72:[68, 48] Operation: 26+22=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26-22=4. \nResulting numbers: [68, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|68-72| + |4-72|)/2 = (4 + 68)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 72:[68, 4] Operation: 26-22=4\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 72:[54, 62]. Operations so far : ['26+28=54', '40+22=62'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-54=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+62=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54*62=3348. \nResulting numbers: [3348].\n3348,72 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 72:[66, 50]. Operations so far : ['40+26=66', '28+22=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+50=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66*50=3300. \nResulting numbers: [3300].\n3300,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-50=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,72 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 72:[48, 68]. Operations so far : ['26+22=48', '40+28=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-48=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48*68=3264. \nResulting numbers: [3264].\n3264,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+68=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,72 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 72:[68, 48]. Operations so far : ['40+28=68', '26+22=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+48=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-48=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*48=3264. \nResulting numbers: [3264].\n3264,72 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 72:[62, 54]. Operations so far : ['40+22=62', '26+28=54'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62*54=3348. \nResulting numbers: [3348].\n3348,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-54=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+54=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,72 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 72:[40, 76]. Operations so far : ['26+22=48', '28+48=76'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+76=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-40=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*76=3040. \nResulting numbers: [3040].\n3040,72 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 72:[40, 76]. Operations so far : ['26+28=54', '22+54=76'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+76=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*76=3040. \nResulting numbers: [3040].\n3040,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-40=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,72 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 72:[28, 88]. Operations so far : ['40+26=66', '22+66=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-28=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28*88=2464. \nResulting numbers: [2464].\n2464,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+88=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,72 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 72:[28, 88]. Operations so far : ['26+22=48', '40+48=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28*88=2464. \nResulting numbers: [2464].\n2464,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+88=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-28=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,72 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 72:[28, 88]. Operations so far : ['40+22=62', '26+62=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28*88=2464. \nResulting numbers: [2464].\n2464,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-28=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+88=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,72 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,2,3,0: 72:[60]. Operations so far : ['40+26=66', '22+66=88', '88-28=60'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,4,0,2: 72:[60]. Operations so far : ['26+22=48', '40+48=88', '88-28=60'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,1,1,1: 72:[60]. Operations so far : ['40+22=62', '26+62=88', '88-28=60'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 32.0\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 72:[26, 90]. Operations so far : ['40+28=68', '22+68=90'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-26=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26*90=2340. \nResulting numbers: [2340].\n2340,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+90=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,72 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 32.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 72:[26, 90]. Operations so far : ['40+22=62', '28+62=90'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+90=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26*90=2340. \nResulting numbers: [2340].\n2340,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-26=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,72 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,3,2,0: 72:[64]. Operations so far : ['40+28=68', '22+68=90', '90-26=64'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,1,3,2: 72:[64]. Operations so far : ['40+22=62', '28+62=90', '90-26=64'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 36\nCurrent State #0,4,2,1: 72:[36]. Operations so far : ['26+22=48', '28+48=76', '76-40=36'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 36.0\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 72:[68, 4]. Operations so far : ['40+28=68', '26-22=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-4=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,72 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+4=72. \nResulting numbers: [72].\n72,72 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['40+28=68', '26-22=4', '68/4=17']\nRESULT: 17\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,177 |
[
48,
54,
84,
42
]
| 42 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [48, 54, 84, 42] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 42. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [48, 54, 84, 42]. Our goal is to produce 42. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 42:[48, 54, 84, 42]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-48=36. \nResulting numbers: [54, 42, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|54-42| + |42-42| + |36-42|)/3 = (12 + 0 + 6)/3 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 42:[54, 42, 36] Operation: 84-48=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-36=18. \nResulting numbers: [42, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|42-42| + |18-42|)/2 = (0 + 24)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 42:[42, 18] Operation: 54-36=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42+18=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[54, 42, 36]. Operations so far : ['84-48=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-42=12. \nResulting numbers: [36, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|36-42| + |12-42|)/2 = (6 + 30)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 42:[36, 12] Operation: 54-42=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+12=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[54, 42, 36]. Operations so far : ['84-48=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+36=90. \nResulting numbers: [42, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|42-42| + |90-42|)/2 = (0 + 48)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 42:[42, 90] Operation: 54+36=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-42=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[54, 42, 36]. Operations so far : ['84-48=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42+36=78. \nResulting numbers: [54, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|54-42| + |78-42|)/2 = (12 + 36)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 42:[54, 78] Operation: 42+36=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-54=24. \nResulting numbers: [24].\n24,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[54, 42, 36]. Operations so far : ['84-48=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-36=6. \nResulting numbers: [54, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|54-42| + |6-42|)/2 = (12 + 36)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 42:[54, 6] Operation: 42-36=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-6=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[54, 42, 36]. Operations so far : ['84-48=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+42=96. \nResulting numbers: [36, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|36-42| + |96-42|)/2 = (6 + 54)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 42:[36, 96] Operation: 54+42=96\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-36=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[54, 42, 36]. Operations so far : ['84-48=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42*36=1512. \nResulting numbers: [54, 1512].\nHeuristic score : (|54-42| + |1512-42|)/2 = (12 + 1470)/2 = 741.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 42:[54, 1512] Operation: 42*36=1512\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1512/54=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[54, 42, 36]. Operations so far : ['84-48=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54*36=1944. \nResulting numbers: [42, 1944].\nHeuristic score : (|42-42| + |1944-42|)/2 = (0 + 1902)/2 = 951.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 42:[42, 1944] Operation: 54*36=1944\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1944-42=1902. \nResulting numbers: [1902].\n1902,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[54, 42, 36]. Operations so far : ['84-48=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54*42=2268. \nResulting numbers: [36, 2268].\nHeuristic score : (|36-42| + |2268-42|)/2 = (6 + 2226)/2 = 1116.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 42:[36, 2268] Operation: 54*42=2268\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2268/36=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0: 42:[48, 54, 84, 42]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-54=30. \nResulting numbers: [48, 42, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|48-42| + |42-42| + |30-42|)/3 = (6 + 0 + 12)/3 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 42:[48, 42, 30] Operation: 84-54=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-30=18. \nResulting numbers: [42, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|42-42| + |18-42|)/2 = (0 + 24)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 42:[42, 18] Operation: 48-30=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42+18=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[48, 42, 30]. Operations so far : ['84-54=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+30=78. \nResulting numbers: [42, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|42-42| + |78-42|)/2 = (0 + 36)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 42:[42, 78] Operation: 48+30=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-42=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[48, 42, 30]. Operations so far : ['84-54=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42+30=72. \nResulting numbers: [48, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|48-42| + |72-42|)/2 = (6 + 30)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 42:[48, 72] Operation: 42+30=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-48=24. \nResulting numbers: [24].\n24,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[48, 42, 30]. Operations so far : ['84-54=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-30=12. \nResulting numbers: [48, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|48-42| + |12-42|)/2 = (6 + 30)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 42:[48, 12] Operation: 42-30=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-12=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[48, 42, 30]. Operations so far : ['84-54=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-42=6. \nResulting numbers: [30, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|30-42| + |6-42|)/2 = (12 + 36)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 42:[30, 6] Operation: 48-42=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+6=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[48, 42, 30]. Operations so far : ['84-54=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+42=90. \nResulting numbers: [30, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|30-42| + |90-42|)/2 = (12 + 48)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 42:[30, 90] Operation: 48+42=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-30=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[48, 42, 30]. Operations so far : ['84-54=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42*30=1260. \nResulting numbers: [48, 1260].\nHeuristic score : (|48-42| + |1260-42|)/2 = (6 + 1218)/2 = 612.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 42:[48, 1260] Operation: 42*30=1260\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1260-48=1212. \nResulting numbers: [1212].\n1212,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[48, 42, 30]. Operations so far : ['84-54=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48*30=1440. \nResulting numbers: [42, 1440].\nHeuristic score : (|42-42| + |1440-42|)/2 = (0 + 1398)/2 = 699.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 42:[42, 1440] Operation: 48*30=1440\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1440-42=1398. \nResulting numbers: [1398].\n1398,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[48, 42, 30]. Operations so far : ['84-54=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48*42=2016. \nResulting numbers: [30, 2016].\nHeuristic score : (|30-42| + |2016-42|)/2 = (12 + 1974)/2 = 993.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 42:[30, 2016] Operation: 48*42=2016\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2016-30=1986. \nResulting numbers: [1986].\n1986,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0: 42:[48, 54, 84, 42]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-42=42. \nResulting numbers: [48, 54, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|48-42| + |54-42| + |42-42|)/3 = (6 + 12 + 0)/3 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 42:[48, 54, 42] Operation: 84-42=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-48=6. \nResulting numbers: [42, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|42-42| + |6-42|)/2 = (0 + 36)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 42:[42, 6] Operation: 54-48=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42+6=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 42:[48, 54, 42]. Operations so far : ['84-42=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-42=12. \nResulting numbers: [48, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|48-42| + |12-42|)/2 = (6 + 30)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 42:[48, 12] Operation: 54-42=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-12=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 42:[48, 54, 42]. Operations so far : ['84-42=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-42=6. \nResulting numbers: [54, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|54-42| + |6-42|)/2 = (12 + 36)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 42:[54, 6] Operation: 48-42=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-6=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 42:[48, 54, 42]. Operations so far : ['84-42=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+54=102. \nResulting numbers: [42, 102].\nHeuristic score : (|42-42| + |102-42|)/2 = (0 + 60)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 42:[42, 102] Operation: 48+54=102\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102-42=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 42:[48, 54, 42]. Operations so far : ['84-42=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+42=90. \nResulting numbers: [54, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|54-42| + |90-42|)/2 = (12 + 48)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 42:[54, 90] Operation: 48+42=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-54=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 42:[48, 54, 42]. Operations so far : ['84-42=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+42=96. \nResulting numbers: [48, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|48-42| + |96-42|)/2 = (6 + 54)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 42:[48, 96] Operation: 54+42=96\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-48=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 42:[48, 54, 42]. Operations so far : ['84-42=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48*42=2016. \nResulting numbers: [54, 2016].\nHeuristic score : (|54-42| + |2016-42|)/2 = (12 + 1974)/2 = 993.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 42:[54, 2016] Operation: 48*42=2016\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2016-54=1962. \nResulting numbers: [1962].\n1962,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 42:[48, 54, 42]. Operations so far : ['84-42=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54*42=2268. \nResulting numbers: [48, 2268].\nHeuristic score : (|48-42| + |2268-42|)/2 = (6 + 2226)/2 = 1116.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 42:[48, 2268] Operation: 54*42=2268\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2268-48=2220. \nResulting numbers: [2220].\n2220,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 42:[48, 54, 42]. Operations so far : ['84-42=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48*54=2592. \nResulting numbers: [42, 2592].\nHeuristic score : (|42-42| + |2592-42|)/2 = (0 + 2550)/2 = 1275.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 42:[42, 2592] Operation: 48*54=2592\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2592-42=2550. \nResulting numbers: [2550].\n2550,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0: 42:[48, 54, 84, 42]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84/42=2. \nResulting numbers: [48, 54, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|48-42| + |54-42| + |2-42|)/3 = (6 + 12 + 40)/3 = 19.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 42:[48, 54, 2] Operation: 84/42=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-2=46. \nResulting numbers: [54, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|54-42| + |46-42|)/2 = (12 + 4)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 42:[54, 46] Operation: 48-2=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-46=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 42:[48, 54, 2]. Operations so far : ['84/42=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-2=52. \nResulting numbers: [48, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|48-42| + |52-42|)/2 = (6 + 10)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 42:[48, 52] Operation: 54-2=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-48=4. \nResulting numbers: [4].\n4,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 42:[48, 54, 2]. Operations so far : ['84/42=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+2=50. \nResulting numbers: [54, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|54-42| + |50-42|)/2 = (12 + 8)/2 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 42:[54, 50] Operation: 48+2=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-50=4. \nResulting numbers: [4].\n4,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 42:[48, 54, 2]. Operations so far : ['84/42=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+2=56. \nResulting numbers: [48, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|48-42| + |56-42|)/2 = (6 + 14)/2 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 42:[48, 56] Operation: 54+2=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-48=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 42:[48, 54, 2]. Operations so far : ['84/42=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54/2=27. \nResulting numbers: [48, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|48-42| + |27-42|)/2 = (6 + 15)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 42:[48, 27] Operation: 54/2=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-27=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 42:[48, 54, 2]. Operations so far : ['84/42=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48/2=24. \nResulting numbers: [54, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|54-42| + |24-42|)/2 = (12 + 18)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 42:[54, 24] Operation: 48/2=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-24=30. \nResulting numbers: [30].\n30,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 42:[48, 54, 2]. Operations so far : ['84/42=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48*2=96. \nResulting numbers: [54, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|54-42| + |96-42|)/2 = (12 + 54)/2 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 42:[54, 96] Operation: 48*2=96\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-54=42. \nResulting numbers: [42].\n42,42 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['84/42=2', '48*2=96', '96-54=42']\nRESULT: 42\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 8,015 |
[
79,
6,
94,
81
]
| 11 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [79, 6, 94, 81] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 11. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [79, 6, 94, 81]. Our goal is to produce 11. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 11:[79, 6, 94, 81]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-81=13. \nResulting numbers: [79, 6, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|79-11| + |6-11| + |13-11|)/3 = (68 + 5 + 2)/3 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 11:[79, 6, 13] Operation: 94-81=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-13=66. \nResulting numbers: [6, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|6-11| + |66-11|)/2 = (5 + 55)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 11:[6, 66] Operation: 79-13=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66/6=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,11 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['94-81=13', '79-13=66', '66/6=11']\nRESULT: 11\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 428 |
[
32,
5,
4,
60
]
| 20 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [32, 5, 4, 60] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 20. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [32, 5, 4, 60]. Our goal is to produce 20. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 20:[32, 5, 4, 60]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5*4=20. \nResulting numbers: [32, 60, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|32-20| + |60-20| + |20-20|)/3 = (12 + 40 + 0)/3 = 17.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 20:[32, 60, 20] Operation: 5*4=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-32=28. \nResulting numbers: [5, 4, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|5-20| + |4-20| + |28-20|)/3 = (15 + 16 + 8)/3 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 20:[5, 4, 28] Operation: 60-32=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/5=12. \nResulting numbers: [32, 4, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|32-20| + |4-20| + |12-20|)/3 = (12 + 16 + 8)/3 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 20:[32, 4, 12] Operation: 60/5=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-5=27. \nResulting numbers: [4, 60, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|4-20| + |60-20| + |27-20|)/3 = (16 + 40 + 7)/3 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 20:[4, 60, 27] Operation: 32-5=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/4=15. \nResulting numbers: [32, 5, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|32-20| + |5-20| + |15-20|)/3 = (12 + 15 + 5)/3 = 10.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 20:[32, 5, 15] Operation: 60/4=15\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,4: 20:[32, 5, 15]. Operations so far : ['60/4=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+5=37. \nResulting numbers: [15, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|15-20| + |37-20|)/2 = (5 + 17)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 20:[15, 37] Operation: 32+5=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-15=17. \nResulting numbers: [5, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|5-20| + |17-20|)/2 = (15 + 3)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 20:[5, 17] Operation: 32-15=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 15-5=10. \nResulting numbers: [32, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|32-20| + |10-20|)/2 = (12 + 10)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 20:[32, 10] Operation: 15-5=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5+15=20. \nResulting numbers: [32, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|32-20| + |20-20|)/2 = (12 + 0)/2 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 20:[32, 20] Operation: 5+15=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-5=27. \nResulting numbers: [15, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|15-20| + |27-20|)/2 = (5 + 7)/2 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 20:[15, 27] Operation: 32-5=27\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 20:[32, 4, 12]. Operations so far : ['60/5=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+4=36. \nResulting numbers: [12, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|12-20| + |36-20|)/2 = (8 + 16)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 20:[12, 36] Operation: 32+4=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+12=16. \nResulting numbers: [32, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|32-20| + |16-20|)/2 = (12 + 4)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 20:[32, 16] Operation: 4+12=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-4=28. \nResulting numbers: [12, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|12-20| + |28-20|)/2 = (8 + 8)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 20:[12, 28] Operation: 32-4=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-12=20. \nResulting numbers: [4, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|4-20| + |20-20|)/2 = (16 + 0)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 20:[4, 20] Operation: 32-12=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32/4=8. \nResulting numbers: [12, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|12-20| + |8-20|)/2 = (8 + 12)/2 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 20:[12, 8] Operation: 32/4=8\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 20:[5, 4, 28]. Operations so far : ['60-32=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-4=24. \nResulting numbers: [5, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|5-20| + |24-20|)/2 = (15 + 4)/2 = 9.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 20:[5, 24] Operation: 28-4=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5*4=20. \nResulting numbers: [28, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|28-20| + |20-20|)/2 = (8 + 0)/2 = 4.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 20:[28, 20] Operation: 5*4=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5-4=1. \nResulting numbers: [28, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|28-20| + |1-20|)/2 = (8 + 19)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 20:[28, 1] Operation: 5-4=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5+4=9. \nResulting numbers: [28, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|28-20| + |9-20|)/2 = (8 + 11)/2 = 9.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 20:[28, 9] Operation: 5+4=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-5=23. \nResulting numbers: [4, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|4-20| + |23-20|)/2 = (16 + 3)/2 = 9.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 20:[4, 23] Operation: 28-5=23\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 20:[32, 60, 20]. Operations so far : ['5*4=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-20=40. \nResulting numbers: [32, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|32-20| + |40-20|)/2 = (12 + 20)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 20:[32, 40] Operation: 60-20=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+60=92. \nResulting numbers: [20, 92].\nHeuristic score : (|20-20| + |92-20|)/2 = (0 + 72)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 20:[20, 92] Operation: 32+60=92\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-20=12. \nResulting numbers: [60, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|60-20| + |12-20|)/2 = (40 + 8)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 20:[60, 12] Operation: 32-20=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-32=28. \nResulting numbers: [20, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|20-20| + |28-20|)/2 = (0 + 8)/2 = 4.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 20:[20, 28] Operation: 60-32=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/20=3. \nResulting numbers: [32, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|32-20| + |3-20|)/2 = (12 + 17)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 20:[32, 3] Operation: 60/20=3\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 20:[4, 60, 27]. Operations so far : ['32-5=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/4=15. \nResulting numbers: [27, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|27-20| + |15-20|)/2 = (7 + 5)/2 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 20:[27, 15] Operation: 60/4=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+60=64. \nResulting numbers: [27, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|27-20| + |64-20|)/2 = (7 + 44)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 20:[27, 64] Operation: 4+60=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-27=33. \nResulting numbers: [4, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|4-20| + |33-20|)/2 = (16 + 13)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 20:[4, 33] Operation: 60-27=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-4=56. \nResulting numbers: [27, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|27-20| + |56-20|)/2 = (7 + 36)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 20:[27, 56] Operation: 60-4=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27-4=23. \nResulting numbers: [60, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|60-20| + |23-20|)/2 = (40 + 3)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 20:[60, 23] Operation: 27-4=23\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 4.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 20:[28, 20]. Operations so far : ['60-32=28', '5*4=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28*20=560. \nResulting numbers: [560].\n560,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-20=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+20=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,20 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 4.0\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 20:[20, 28]. Operations so far : ['5*4=20', '60-32=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-20=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+28=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20*28=560. \nResulting numbers: [560].\n560,20 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 20:[15, 27]. Operations so far : ['60/4=15', '32-5=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 15+27=42. \nResulting numbers: [42].\n42,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27-15=12. \nResulting numbers: [12].\n12,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 15*27=405. \nResulting numbers: [405].\n405,20 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 20:[27, 15]. Operations so far : ['32-5=27', '60/4=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27-15=12. \nResulting numbers: [12].\n12,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+15=42. \nResulting numbers: [42].\n42,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27*15=405. \nResulting numbers: [405].\n405,20 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 20:[32, 20]. Operations so far : ['60/4=15', '5+15=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+20=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*20=640. \nResulting numbers: [640].\n640,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-20=12. \nResulting numbers: [12].\n12,20 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 8.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 20:[32, 16]. Operations so far : ['60/5=12', '4+12=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32/16=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-16=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+16=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*16=512. \nResulting numbers: [512].\n512,20 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 8.0\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 20:[12, 28]. Operations so far : ['60/5=12', '32-4=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-12=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12+28=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12*28=336. \nResulting numbers: [336].\n336,20 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,3,0,0: 20:[12]. Operations so far : ['32-5=27', '60/4=15', '27-15=12'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,4,4,1: 20:[12]. Operations so far : ['60/4=15', '32-5=27', '27-15=12'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 8.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 20:[4, 20]. Operations so far : ['60/5=12', '32-12=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20/4=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*20=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+20=24. \nResulting numbers: [24].\n24,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20-4=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,20 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,1,1: 20:[16]. Operations so far : ['60/5=12', '4+12=16', '32-16=16'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,2,0: 20:[16]. Operations so far : ['60/5=12', '32-4=28', '28-12=16'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 20:[24]. Operations so far : ['60/5=12', '32-12=20', '4+20=24'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,3,3: 20:[16]. Operations so far : ['60/5=12', '32-12=20', '20-4=16'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,4,3,2: 20:[12]. Operations so far : ['60/4=15', '5+15=20', '32-20=12'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 20:[5, 17]. Operations so far : ['60/4=15', '32-15=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5*17=85. \nResulting numbers: [85].\n85,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17-5=12. \nResulting numbers: [12].\n12,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5+17=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,20 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 9.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 20:[4, 23]. Operations so far : ['60-32=28', '28-5=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23-4=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+23=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*23=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,20 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 9.5\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 20:[28, 9]. Operations so far : ['60-32=28', '5+4=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28*9=252. \nResulting numbers: [252].\n252,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+9=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-9=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,20 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 9.5\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 20:[5, 24]. Operations so far : ['60-32=28', '28-4=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5+24=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5*24=120. \nResulting numbers: [120].\n120,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24-5=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,20 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 20:[12, 8]. Operations so far : ['60/5=12', '32/4=8'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12-8=4. \nResulting numbers: [4].\n4,20 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12+8=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,20 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['60/5=12', '32/4=8', '12-8=4']\nRESULT: 4\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,312 |
[
22,
13,
37,
18
]
| 16 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [22, 13, 37, 18] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 16. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [22, 13, 37, 18]. Our goal is to produce 16. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 16:[22, 13, 37, 18]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-22=15. \nResulting numbers: [13, 18, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|13-16| + |18-16| + |15-16|)/3 = (3 + 2 + 1)/3 = 2.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 16:[13, 18, 15] Operation: 37-22=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 18-13=5. \nResulting numbers: [15, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|15-16| + |5-16|)/2 = (1 + 11)/2 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 16:[15, 5] Operation: 18-13=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 15+5=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,16 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 2.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 16:[13, 18, 15]. Operations so far : ['37-22=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13+15=28. \nResulting numbers: [18, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|18-16| + |28-16|)/2 = (2 + 12)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 16:[18, 28] Operation: 13+15=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-18=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,16 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 2.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 16:[13, 18, 15]. Operations so far : ['37-22=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13+18=31. \nResulting numbers: [15, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|15-16| + |31-16|)/2 = (1 + 15)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 16:[15, 31] Operation: 13+18=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31-15=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,16 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['37-22=15', '13+18=31', '31-15=16']\nRESULT: 16\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 862 |
[
50,
57,
98,
8
]
| 83 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [50, 57, 98, 8] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 83. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [50, 57, 98, 8]. Our goal is to produce 83. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 83:[50, 57, 98, 8]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-8=90. \nResulting numbers: [50, 57, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|50-83| + |57-83| + |90-83|)/3 = (33 + 26 + 7)/3 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 83:[50, 57, 90] Operation: 98-8=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-8=42. \nResulting numbers: [57, 98, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|57-83| + |98-83| + |42-83|)/3 = (26 + 15 + 41)/3 = 27.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 83:[57, 98, 42] Operation: 50-8=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+8=65. \nResulting numbers: [50, 98, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|50-83| + |98-83| + |65-83|)/3 = (33 + 15 + 18)/3 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 83:[50, 98, 65] Operation: 57+8=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-8=49. \nResulting numbers: [50, 98, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|50-83| + |98-83| + |49-83|)/3 = (33 + 15 + 34)/3 = 27.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 83:[50, 98, 49] Operation: 57-8=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+8=58. \nResulting numbers: [57, 98, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|57-83| + |98-83| + |58-83|)/3 = (26 + 15 + 25)/3 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 83:[57, 98, 58] Operation: 50+8=58\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[50, 57, 90]. Operations so far : ['98-8=90'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+57=107. \nResulting numbers: [90, 107].\nHeuristic score : (|90-83| + |107-83|)/2 = (7 + 24)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 83:[90, 107] Operation: 50+57=107\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+90=140. \nResulting numbers: [57, 140].\nHeuristic score : (|57-83| + |140-83|)/2 = (26 + 57)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 83:[57, 140] Operation: 50+90=140\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-50=40. \nResulting numbers: [57, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|57-83| + |40-83|)/2 = (26 + 43)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 83:[57, 40] Operation: 90-50=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-50=7. \nResulting numbers: [90, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|90-83| + |7-83|)/2 = (7 + 76)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 83:[90, 7] Operation: 57-50=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-57=33. \nResulting numbers: [50, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|50-83| + |33-83|)/2 = (33 + 50)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 83:[50, 33] Operation: 90-57=33\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[57, 98, 58]. Operations so far : ['50+8=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-58=40. \nResulting numbers: [57, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|57-83| + |40-83|)/2 = (26 + 43)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 83:[57, 40] Operation: 98-58=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-57=41. \nResulting numbers: [58, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|58-83| + |41-83|)/2 = (25 + 42)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 83:[58, 41] Operation: 98-57=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+58=115. \nResulting numbers: [98, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|98-83| + |115-83|)/2 = (15 + 32)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 83:[98, 115] Operation: 57+58=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+98=155. \nResulting numbers: [58, 155].\nHeuristic score : (|58-83| + |155-83|)/2 = (25 + 72)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 83:[58, 155] Operation: 57+98=155\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58-57=1. \nResulting numbers: [98, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|98-83| + |1-83|)/2 = (15 + 82)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 83:[98, 1] Operation: 58-57=1\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[50, 98, 65]. Operations so far : ['57+8=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-50=48. \nResulting numbers: [65, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |48-83|)/2 = (18 + 35)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 83:[65, 48] Operation: 98-50=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+65=115. \nResulting numbers: [98, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|98-83| + |115-83|)/2 = (15 + 32)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 83:[98, 115] Operation: 50+65=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-50=15. \nResulting numbers: [98, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|98-83| + |15-83|)/2 = (15 + 68)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 83:[98, 15] Operation: 65-50=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+98=148. \nResulting numbers: [65, 148].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |148-83|)/2 = (18 + 65)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 83:[65, 148] Operation: 50+98=148\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-65=33. \nResulting numbers: [50, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|50-83| + |33-83|)/2 = (33 + 50)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 83:[50, 33] Operation: 98-65=33\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[57, 98, 42]. Operations so far : ['50-8=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+42=140. \nResulting numbers: [57, 140].\nHeuristic score : (|57-83| + |140-83|)/2 = (26 + 57)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 83:[57, 140] Operation: 98+42=140\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-57=41. \nResulting numbers: [42, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|42-83| + |41-83|)/2 = (41 + 42)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 83:[42, 41] Operation: 98-57=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-42=15. \nResulting numbers: [98, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|98-83| + |15-83|)/2 = (15 + 68)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 83:[98, 15] Operation: 57-42=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+42=99. \nResulting numbers: [98, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|98-83| + |99-83|)/2 = (15 + 16)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 83:[98, 99] Operation: 57+42=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-42=56. \nResulting numbers: [57, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|57-83| + |56-83|)/2 = (26 + 27)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 83:[57, 56] Operation: 98-42=56\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[50, 98, 49]. Operations so far : ['57-8=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-50=48. \nResulting numbers: [49, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|49-83| + |48-83|)/2 = (34 + 35)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 83:[49, 48] Operation: 98-50=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-49=49. \nResulting numbers: [50, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|50-83| + |49-83|)/2 = (33 + 34)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 83:[50, 49] Operation: 98-49=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+49=147. \nResulting numbers: [50, 147].\nHeuristic score : (|50-83| + |147-83|)/2 = (33 + 64)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 83:[50, 147] Operation: 98+49=147\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+49=99. \nResulting numbers: [98, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|98-83| + |99-83|)/2 = (15 + 16)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 83:[98, 99] Operation: 50+49=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-49=1. \nResulting numbers: [98, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|98-83| + |1-83|)/2 = (15 + 82)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 83:[98, 1] Operation: 50-49=1\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 15.5\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 83:[90, 107]. Operations so far : ['98-8=90', '50+57=107'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 107-90=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90+107=197. \nResulting numbers: [197].\n197,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90*107=9630. \nResulting numbers: [9630].\n9630,83 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 15.5\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 83:[98, 99]. Operations so far : ['50-8=42', '57+42=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-98=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98*99=9702. \nResulting numbers: [9702].\n9702,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+99=197. \nResulting numbers: [197].\n197,83 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 15.5\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 83:[98, 99]. Operations so far : ['57-8=49', '50+49=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98*99=9702. \nResulting numbers: [9702].\n9702,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-98=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+99=197. \nResulting numbers: [197].\n197,83 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 23.5\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 83:[98, 115]. Operations so far : ['50+8=58', '57+58=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-98=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+115=213. \nResulting numbers: [213].\n213,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98*115=11270. \nResulting numbers: [11270].\n11270,83 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 23.5\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 83:[98, 115]. Operations so far : ['57+8=65', '50+65=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-98=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+115=213. \nResulting numbers: [213].\n213,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98*115=11270. \nResulting numbers: [11270].\n11270,83 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 26.5\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 83:[65, 48]. Operations so far : ['57+8=65', '98-50=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*48=3120. \nResulting numbers: [3120].\n3120,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-48=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+48=113. \nResulting numbers: [113].\n113,83 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 26.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 83:[57, 56]. Operations so far : ['50-8=42', '98-42=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+56=113. \nResulting numbers: [113].\n113,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-56=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*56=3192. \nResulting numbers: [3192].\n3192,83 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.5\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 83:[58, 41]. Operations so far : ['50+8=58', '98-57=41'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58-41=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58+41=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58*41=2378. \nResulting numbers: [2378].\n2378,83 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.5\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 83:[50, 49]. Operations so far : ['57-8=49', '98-49=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+49=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-49=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*49=2450. \nResulting numbers: [2450].\n2450,83 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 83:[49, 48]. Operations so far : ['57-8=49', '98-50=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49+48=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49*48=2352. \nResulting numbers: [2352].\n2352,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-48=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,83 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,3,0,0: 83:[97]. Operations so far : ['57-8=49', '98-50=48', '49+48=97'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,4,1,1: 83:[99]. Operations so far : ['50+8=58', '98-57=41', '58+41=99'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,3,1,0: 83:[99]. Operations so far : ['57-8=49', '98-49=49', '50+49=99'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,2,0,2: 83:[113]. Operations so far : ['57+8=65', '98-50=48', '65+48=113'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,1,4,0: 83:[113]. Operations so far : ['50-8=42', '98-42=56', '57+56=113'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 83:[57, 40]. Operations so far : ['98-8=90', '90-50=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+40=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*40=2280. \nResulting numbers: [2280].\n2280,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-40=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,83 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 83:[57, 40]. Operations so far : ['50+8=58', '98-58=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-40=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*40=2280. \nResulting numbers: [2280].\n2280,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+40=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,83 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 41.5\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 83:[50, 33]. Operations so far : ['57+8=65', '98-65=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*33=1650. \nResulting numbers: [1650].\n1650,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-33=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,83 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+33=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,83 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['57+8=65', '98-65=33', '50-33=17']\nRESULT: 17\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,135 |
[
64,
50,
40,
43
]
| 42 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [64, 50, 40, 43] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 42. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [64, 50, 40, 43]. Our goal is to produce 42. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 42:[64, 50, 40, 43]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-40=24. \nResulting numbers: [50, 43, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|50-42| + |43-42| + |24-42|)/3 = (8 + 1 + 18)/3 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 42:[50, 43, 24] Operation: 64-40=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-24=26. \nResulting numbers: [43, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|43-42| + |26-42|)/2 = (1 + 16)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 42:[43, 26] Operation: 50-24=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-26=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[50, 43, 24]. Operations so far : ['64-40=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-24=19. \nResulting numbers: [50, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|50-42| + |19-42|)/2 = (8 + 23)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 42:[50, 19] Operation: 43-24=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-19=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[50, 43, 24]. Operations so far : ['64-40=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+24=74. \nResulting numbers: [43, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|43-42| + |74-42|)/2 = (1 + 32)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 42:[43, 74] Operation: 50+24=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-43=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[50, 43, 24]. Operations so far : ['64-40=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+24=67. \nResulting numbers: [50, 67].\nHeuristic score : (|50-42| + |67-42|)/2 = (8 + 25)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 42:[50, 67] Operation: 43+24=67\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-50=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[50, 43, 24]. Operations so far : ['64-40=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-43=7. \nResulting numbers: [24, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|24-42| + |7-42|)/2 = (18 + 35)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 42:[24, 7] Operation: 50-43=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+7=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[50, 43, 24]. Operations so far : ['64-40=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+43=93. \nResulting numbers: [24, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|24-42| + |93-42|)/2 = (18 + 51)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 42:[24, 93] Operation: 50+43=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-24=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[50, 43, 24]. Operations so far : ['64-40=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43*24=1032. \nResulting numbers: [50, 1032].\nHeuristic score : (|50-42| + |1032-42|)/2 = (8 + 990)/2 = 499.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 42:[50, 1032] Operation: 43*24=1032\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1032-50=982. \nResulting numbers: [982].\n982,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[50, 43, 24]. Operations so far : ['64-40=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*24=1200. \nResulting numbers: [43, 1200].\nHeuristic score : (|43-42| + |1200-42|)/2 = (1 + 1158)/2 = 579.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 42:[43, 1200] Operation: 50*24=1200\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1200-43=1157. \nResulting numbers: [1157].\n1157,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[50, 43, 24]. Operations so far : ['64-40=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*43=2150. \nResulting numbers: [24, 2150].\nHeuristic score : (|24-42| + |2150-42|)/2 = (18 + 2108)/2 = 1063.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 42:[24, 2150] Operation: 50*43=2150\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2150-24=2126. \nResulting numbers: [2126].\n2126,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 8.25\nCurrent State #0: 42:[64, 50, 40, 43]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-50=14. \nResulting numbers: [40, 43, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|40-42| + |43-42| + |14-42|)/3 = (2 + 1 + 28)/3 = 10.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 42:[40, 43, 14] Operation: 64-50=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+14=54. \nResulting numbers: [43, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|43-42| + |54-42|)/2 = (1 + 12)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 42:[43, 54] Operation: 40+14=54\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-43=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 10.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[40, 43, 14]. Operations so far : ['64-50=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-14=29. \nResulting numbers: [40, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|40-42| + |29-42|)/2 = (2 + 13)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 42:[40, 29] Operation: 43-14=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+29=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 10.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[40, 43, 14]. Operations so far : ['64-50=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-14=26. \nResulting numbers: [43, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|43-42| + |26-42|)/2 = (1 + 16)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 42:[43, 26] Operation: 40-14=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-26=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 10.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[40, 43, 14]. Operations so far : ['64-50=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+14=57. \nResulting numbers: [40, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|40-42| + |57-42|)/2 = (2 + 15)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 42:[40, 57] Operation: 43+14=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-40=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 10.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[40, 43, 14]. Operations so far : ['64-50=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-40=3. \nResulting numbers: [14, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|14-42| + |3-42|)/2 = (28 + 39)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 42:[14, 3] Operation: 43-40=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14*3=42. \nResulting numbers: [42].\n42,42 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['64-50=14', '43-40=3', '14*3=42']\nRESULT: 42\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 3,397 |
[
54,
96,
40,
76
]
| 78 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [54, 96, 40, 76] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 78. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [54, 96, 40, 76]. Our goal is to produce 78. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 78:[54, 96, 40, 76]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+40=94. \nResulting numbers: [96, 76, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|96-78| + |76-78| + |94-78|)/3 = (18 + 2 + 16)/3 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 78:[96, 76, 94] Operation: 54+40=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+76=116. \nResulting numbers: [54, 96, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|54-78| + |96-78| + |116-78|)/3 = (24 + 18 + 38)/3 = 26.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 78:[54, 96, 116] Operation: 40+76=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-54=42. \nResulting numbers: [40, 76, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|40-78| + |76-78| + |42-78|)/3 = (38 + 2 + 36)/3 = 25.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 78:[40, 76, 42] Operation: 96-54=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-40=56. \nResulting numbers: [54, 76, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|54-78| + |76-78| + |56-78|)/3 = (24 + 2 + 22)/3 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 78:[54, 76, 56] Operation: 96-40=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-40=14. \nResulting numbers: [96, 76, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|96-78| + |76-78| + |14-78|)/3 = (18 + 2 + 64)/3 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 78:[96, 76, 14] Operation: 54-40=14\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 78:[96, 76, 94]. Operations so far : ['54+40=94'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+94=170. \nResulting numbers: [96, 170].\nHeuristic score : (|96-78| + |170-78|)/2 = (18 + 92)/2 = 55.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 78:[96, 170] Operation: 76+94=170\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-76=18. \nResulting numbers: [96, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|96-78| + |18-78|)/2 = (18 + 60)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 78:[96, 18] Operation: 94-76=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-76=20. \nResulting numbers: [94, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|94-78| + |20-78|)/2 = (16 + 58)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 78:[94, 20] Operation: 96-76=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+76=172. \nResulting numbers: [94, 172].\nHeuristic score : (|94-78| + |172-78|)/2 = (16 + 94)/2 = 55.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 78:[94, 172] Operation: 96+76=172\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-94=2. \nResulting numbers: [76, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|76-78| + |2-78|)/2 = (2 + 76)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 78:[76, 2] Operation: 96-94=2\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 78:[54, 76, 56]. Operations so far : ['96-40=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+56=132. \nResulting numbers: [54, 132].\nHeuristic score : (|54-78| + |132-78|)/2 = (24 + 54)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 78:[54, 132] Operation: 76+56=132\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+56=110. \nResulting numbers: [76, 110].\nHeuristic score : (|76-78| + |110-78|)/2 = (2 + 32)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 78:[76, 110] Operation: 54+56=110\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-54=2. \nResulting numbers: [76, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|76-78| + |2-78|)/2 = (2 + 76)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 78:[76, 2] Operation: 56-54=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-54=22. \nResulting numbers: [56, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|56-78| + |22-78|)/2 = (22 + 56)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 78:[56, 22] Operation: 76-54=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+76=130. \nResulting numbers: [56, 130].\nHeuristic score : (|56-78| + |130-78|)/2 = (22 + 52)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 78:[56, 130] Operation: 54+76=130\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 78:[40, 76, 42]. Operations so far : ['96-54=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-40=36. \nResulting numbers: [42, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|42-78| + |36-78|)/2 = (36 + 42)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 78:[42, 36] Operation: 76-40=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+42=118. \nResulting numbers: [40, 118].\nHeuristic score : (|40-78| + |118-78|)/2 = (38 + 40)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 78:[40, 118] Operation: 76+42=118\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+42=82. \nResulting numbers: [76, 82].\nHeuristic score : (|76-78| + |82-78|)/2 = (2 + 4)/2 = 3.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 78:[76, 82] Operation: 40+42=82\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+76=116. \nResulting numbers: [42, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|42-78| + |116-78|)/2 = (36 + 38)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 78:[42, 116] Operation: 40+76=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-40=2. \nResulting numbers: [76, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|76-78| + |2-78|)/2 = (2 + 76)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 78:[76, 2] Operation: 42-40=2\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 26.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 78:[54, 96, 116]. Operations so far : ['40+76=116'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+96=150. \nResulting numbers: [116, 150].\nHeuristic score : (|116-78| + |150-78|)/2 = (38 + 72)/2 = 55.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 78:[116, 150] Operation: 54+96=150\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-54=42. \nResulting numbers: [116, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|116-78| + |42-78|)/2 = (38 + 36)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 78:[116, 42] Operation: 96-54=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-96=20. \nResulting numbers: [54, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|54-78| + |20-78|)/2 = (24 + 58)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 78:[54, 20] Operation: 116-96=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-54=62. \nResulting numbers: [96, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|96-78| + |62-78|)/2 = (18 + 16)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 78:[96, 62] Operation: 116-54=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+116=170. \nResulting numbers: [96, 170].\nHeuristic score : (|96-78| + |170-78|)/2 = (18 + 92)/2 = 55.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 78:[96, 170] Operation: 54+116=170\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 78:[96, 76, 14]. Operations so far : ['54-40=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+14=110. \nResulting numbers: [76, 110].\nHeuristic score : (|76-78| + |110-78|)/2 = (2 + 32)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 78:[76, 110] Operation: 96+14=110\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-14=82. \nResulting numbers: [76, 82].\nHeuristic score : (|76-78| + |82-78|)/2 = (2 + 4)/2 = 3.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 78:[76, 82] Operation: 96-14=82\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-76=20. \nResulting numbers: [14, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |20-78|)/2 = (64 + 58)/2 = 61.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 78:[14, 20] Operation: 96-76=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-14=62. \nResulting numbers: [96, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|96-78| + |62-78|)/2 = (18 + 16)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 78:[96, 62] Operation: 76-14=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+14=90. \nResulting numbers: [96, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|96-78| + |90-78|)/2 = (18 + 12)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 78:[96, 90] Operation: 76+14=90\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 3.0\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 78:[76, 82]. Operations so far : ['96-54=42', '40+42=82'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-76=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*82=6232. \nResulting numbers: [6232].\n6232,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+82=158. \nResulting numbers: [158].\n158,78 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 3.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 78:[76, 82]. Operations so far : ['54-40=14', '96-14=82'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-76=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+82=158. \nResulting numbers: [158].\n158,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*82=6232. \nResulting numbers: [6232].\n6232,78 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 78:[96, 90]. Operations so far : ['54-40=14', '76+14=90'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+90=186. \nResulting numbers: [186].\n186,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*90=8640. \nResulting numbers: [8640].\n8640,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-90=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,78 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 78:[96, 62]. Operations so far : ['54-40=14', '76-14=62'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+62=158. \nResulting numbers: [158].\n158,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-62=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*62=5952. \nResulting numbers: [5952].\n5952,78 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 78:[76, 110]. Operations so far : ['96-40=56', '54+56=110'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 110-76=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*110=8360. \nResulting numbers: [8360].\n8360,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+110=186. \nResulting numbers: [186].\n186,78 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 78:[76, 110]. Operations so far : ['54-40=14', '96+14=110'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+110=186. \nResulting numbers: [186].\n186,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 110-76=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*110=8360. \nResulting numbers: [8360].\n8360,78 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 78:[96, 62]. Operations so far : ['40+76=116', '116-54=62'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+62=158. \nResulting numbers: [158].\n158,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*62=5952. \nResulting numbers: [5952].\n5952,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-62=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,78 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.0\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 78:[56, 130]. Operations so far : ['96-40=56', '54+76=130'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 130-56=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*130=7280. \nResulting numbers: [7280].\n7280,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+130=186. \nResulting numbers: [186].\n186,78 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 37.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 78:[94, 20]. Operations so far : ['54+40=94', '96-76=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-20=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94*20=1880. \nResulting numbers: [1880].\n1880,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94+20=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,78 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 37.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 78:[42, 116]. Operations so far : ['96-54=42', '40+76=116'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42+116=158. \nResulting numbers: [158].\n158,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-42=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42*116=4872. \nResulting numbers: [4872].\n4872,78 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,3,4,0: 78:[74]. Operations so far : ['96-40=56', '54+76=130', '130-56=74'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,0,2,0: 78:[74]. Operations so far : ['54+40=94', '96-76=20', '94-20=74'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 78:[74]. Operations so far : ['96-54=42', '40+76=116', '116-42=74'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 36\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 78:[114]. Operations so far : ['54+40=94', '96-76=20', '94+20=114'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 37.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 78:[116, 42]. Operations so far : ['40+76=116', '96-54=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116*42=4872. \nResulting numbers: [4872].\n4872,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-42=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116+42=158. \nResulting numbers: [158].\n158,78 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,1,1,1: 78:[74]. Operations so far : ['40+76=116', '96-54=42', '116-42=74'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 39.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 78:[40, 118]. Operations so far : ['96-54=42', '76+42=118'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*118=4720. \nResulting numbers: [4720].\n4720,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+118=158. \nResulting numbers: [158].\n158,78 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 118-40=78. \nResulting numbers: [78].\n78,78 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['96-54=42', '76+42=118', '118-40=78']\nRESULT: 78\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 6,895 |
[
3,
39,
54,
69
]
| 51 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [3, 39, 54, 69] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 51. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [3, 39, 54, 69]. Our goal is to produce 51. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 51:[3, 39, 54, 69]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+39=42. \nResulting numbers: [54, 69, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|54-51| + |69-51| + |42-51|)/3 = (3 + 18 + 9)/3 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 51:[54, 69, 42] Operation: 3+39=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-3=66. \nResulting numbers: [39, 54, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|39-51| + |54-51| + |66-51|)/3 = (12 + 3 + 15)/3 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 51:[39, 54, 66] Operation: 69-3=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-3=36. \nResulting numbers: [54, 69, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|54-51| + |69-51| + |36-51|)/3 = (3 + 18 + 15)/3 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 51:[54, 69, 36] Operation: 39-3=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-3=51. \nResulting numbers: [39, 69, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|39-51| + |69-51| + |51-51|)/3 = (12 + 18 + 0)/3 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 51:[39, 69, 51] Operation: 54-3=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+54=57. \nResulting numbers: [39, 69, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|39-51| + |69-51| + |57-51|)/3 = (12 + 18 + 6)/3 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 51:[39, 69, 57] Operation: 3+54=57\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 51:[54, 69, 42]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+42=96. \nResulting numbers: [69, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|69-51| + |96-51|)/2 = (18 + 45)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 51:[69, 96] Operation: 54+42=96\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+42=111. \nResulting numbers: [54, 111].\nHeuristic score : (|54-51| + |111-51|)/2 = (3 + 60)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 51:[54, 111] Operation: 69+42=111\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-54=15. \nResulting numbers: [42, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|42-51| + |15-51|)/2 = (9 + 36)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 51:[42, 15] Operation: 69-54=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-42=12. \nResulting numbers: [69, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|69-51| + |12-51|)/2 = (18 + 39)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 51:[69, 12] Operation: 54-42=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-42=27. \nResulting numbers: [54, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|54-51| + |27-51|)/2 = (3 + 24)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 51:[54, 27] Operation: 69-42=27\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 51:[39, 69, 51]. Operations so far : ['54-3=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-51=18. \nResulting numbers: [39, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|39-51| + |18-51|)/2 = (12 + 33)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 51:[39, 18] Operation: 69-51=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+51=90. \nResulting numbers: [69, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|69-51| + |90-51|)/2 = (18 + 39)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 51:[69, 90] Operation: 39+51=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-39=12. \nResulting numbers: [69, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|69-51| + |12-51|)/2 = (18 + 39)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 51:[69, 12] Operation: 51-39=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-39=30. \nResulting numbers: [51, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|51-51| + |30-51|)/2 = (0 + 21)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 51:[51, 30] Operation: 69-39=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+69=108. \nResulting numbers: [51, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|51-51| + |108-51|)/2 = (0 + 57)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 51:[51, 108] Operation: 39+69=108\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 51:[39, 54, 66]. Operations so far : ['69-3=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+66=105. \nResulting numbers: [54, 105].\nHeuristic score : (|54-51| + |105-51|)/2 = (3 + 54)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 51:[54, 105] Operation: 39+66=105\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-39=15. \nResulting numbers: [66, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|66-51| + |15-51|)/2 = (15 + 36)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 51:[66, 15] Operation: 54-39=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-54=12. \nResulting numbers: [39, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|39-51| + |12-51|)/2 = (12 + 39)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 51:[39, 12] Operation: 66-54=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+54=93. \nResulting numbers: [66, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|66-51| + |93-51|)/2 = (15 + 42)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 51:[66, 93] Operation: 39+54=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-39=27. \nResulting numbers: [54, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|54-51| + |27-51|)/2 = (3 + 24)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 51:[54, 27] Operation: 66-39=27\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 51:[54, 69, 36]. Operations so far : ['39-3=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-54=15. \nResulting numbers: [36, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|36-51| + |15-51|)/2 = (15 + 36)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 51:[36, 15] Operation: 69-54=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+36=105. \nResulting numbers: [54, 105].\nHeuristic score : (|54-51| + |105-51|)/2 = (3 + 54)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 51:[54, 105] Operation: 69+36=105\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-36=18. \nResulting numbers: [69, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|69-51| + |18-51|)/2 = (18 + 33)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 51:[69, 18] Operation: 54-36=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+36=90. \nResulting numbers: [69, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|69-51| + |90-51|)/2 = (18 + 39)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 51:[69, 90] Operation: 54+36=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-36=33. \nResulting numbers: [54, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|54-51| + |33-51|)/2 = (3 + 18)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 51:[54, 33] Operation: 69-36=33\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 12.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 51:[39, 69, 57]. Operations so far : ['3+54=57'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+69=108. \nResulting numbers: [57, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|57-51| + |108-51|)/2 = (6 + 57)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 51:[57, 108] Operation: 39+69=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-39=30. \nResulting numbers: [57, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|57-51| + |30-51|)/2 = (6 + 21)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 51:[57, 30] Operation: 69-39=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-57=12. \nResulting numbers: [39, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|39-51| + |12-51|)/2 = (12 + 39)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 51:[39, 12] Operation: 69-57=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-39=18. \nResulting numbers: [69, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|69-51| + |18-51|)/2 = (18 + 33)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 51:[69, 18] Operation: 57-39=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+57=96. \nResulting numbers: [69, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|69-51| + |96-51|)/2 = (18 + 45)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 51:[69, 96] Operation: 39+57=96\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 51:[51, 30]. Operations so far : ['54-3=51', '69-39=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+30=81. \nResulting numbers: [81].\n81,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-30=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*30=1530. \nResulting numbers: [1530].\n1530,51 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 51:[54, 33]. Operations so far : ['39-3=36', '69-36=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-33=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54*33=1782. \nResulting numbers: [1782].\n1782,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+33=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,51 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 13.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 51:[54, 27]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42', '69-42=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54/27=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-27=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54*27=1458. \nResulting numbers: [1458].\n1458,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+27=81. \nResulting numbers: [81].\n81,51 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.5\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 51:[57, 30]. Operations so far : ['3+54=57', '69-39=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-30=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*30=1710. \nResulting numbers: [1710].\n1710,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+30=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,51 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 13.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 51:[54, 27]. Operations so far : ['69-3=66', '66-39=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54/27=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-27=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+27=81. \nResulting numbers: [81].\n81,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54*27=1458. \nResulting numbers: [1458].\n1458,51 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 51:[39, 18]. Operations so far : ['54-3=51', '69-51=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39*18=702. \nResulting numbers: [702].\n702,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-18=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+18=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,51 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 51:[42, 15]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42', '69-54=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42*15=630. \nResulting numbers: [630].\n630,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-15=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,51 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42+15=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,51 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,0,4,1: 51:[27]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42', '69-42=27', '54-27=27'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,4,1,0: 51:[27]. Operations so far : ['3+54=57', '69-39=30', '57-30=27'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,1,4,1: 51:[27]. Operations so far : ['69-3=66', '66-39=27', '54-27=27'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 6\nCurrent State #0,3,0,2: 51:[57]. Operations so far : ['54-3=51', '69-51=18', '39+18=57'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 6\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 51:[57]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42', '69-54=15', '42+15=57'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,0,2,1: 51:[27]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42', '69-54=15', '42-15=27'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.5\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 51:[39, 12]. Operations so far : ['69-3=66', '66-54=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+12=51. \nResulting numbers: [51].\n51,51 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['69-3=66', '66-54=12', '39-12=27']\nRESULT: 27\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 6,001 |
[
81,
3,
30,
60
]
| 17 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [81, 3, 30, 60] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 17. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [81, 3, 30, 60]. Our goal is to produce 17. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 17:[81, 3, 30, 60]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-60=21. \nResulting numbers: [3, 30, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|3-17| + |30-17| + |21-17|)/3 = (14 + 13 + 4)/3 = 10.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 17:[3, 30, 21] Operation: 81-60=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30/3=10. \nResulting numbers: [21, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|21-17| + |10-17|)/2 = (4 + 7)/2 = 5.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 17:[21, 10] Operation: 30/3=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21-10=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,17 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 17:[3, 30, 21]. Operations so far : ['81-60=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-3=27. \nResulting numbers: [21, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|21-17| + |27-17|)/2 = (4 + 10)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 17:[21, 27] Operation: 30-3=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27-21=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,17 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 17:[3, 30, 21]. Operations so far : ['81-60=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21-3=18. \nResulting numbers: [30, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|30-17| + |18-17|)/2 = (13 + 1)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 17:[30, 18] Operation: 21-3=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-18=12. \nResulting numbers: [12].\n12,17 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 17:[3, 30, 21]. Operations so far : ['81-60=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+30=33. \nResulting numbers: [21, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|21-17| + |33-17|)/2 = (4 + 16)/2 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 17:[21, 33] Operation: 3+30=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-21=12. \nResulting numbers: [12].\n12,17 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 17:[3, 30, 21]. Operations so far : ['81-60=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+21=24. \nResulting numbers: [30, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|30-17| + |24-17|)/2 = (13 + 7)/2 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 17:[30, 24] Operation: 3+21=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-24=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,17 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 17:[3, 30, 21]. Operations so far : ['81-60=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-21=9. \nResulting numbers: [3, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|3-17| + |9-17|)/2 = (14 + 8)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 17:[3, 9] Operation: 30-21=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+9=12. \nResulting numbers: [12].\n12,17 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 17:[3, 30, 21]. Operations so far : ['81-60=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21/3=7. \nResulting numbers: [30, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|30-17| + |7-17|)/2 = (13 + 10)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 17:[30, 7] Operation: 21/3=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-7=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,17 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 17:[3, 30, 21]. Operations so far : ['81-60=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+21=51. \nResulting numbers: [3, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|3-17| + |51-17|)/2 = (14 + 34)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 17:[3, 51] Operation: 30+21=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51/3=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,17 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['81-60=21', '30+21=51', '51/3=17']\nRESULT: 17\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 1,975 |
[
12,
74,
85,
41
]
| 42 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [12, 74, 85, 41] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 42. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [12, 74, 85, 41]. Our goal is to produce 42. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 42:[12, 74, 85, 41]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-74=11. \nResulting numbers: [12, 41, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|12-42| + |41-42| + |11-42|)/3 = (30 + 1 + 31)/3 = 20.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 42:[12, 41, 11] Operation: 85-74=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12+11=23. \nResulting numbers: [41, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|41-42| + |23-42|)/2 = (1 + 19)/2 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 42:[41, 23] Operation: 12+11=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+23=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[12, 41, 11]. Operations so far : ['85-74=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+11=52. \nResulting numbers: [12, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|12-42| + |52-42|)/2 = (30 + 10)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 42:[12, 52] Operation: 41+11=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-12=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,42 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[12, 41, 11]. Operations so far : ['85-74=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12+41=53. \nResulting numbers: [11, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|11-42| + |53-42|)/2 = (31 + 11)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 42:[11, 53] Operation: 12+41=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-11=42. \nResulting numbers: [42].\n42,42 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['85-74=11', '12+41=53', '53-11=42']\nRESULT: 42\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 870 |
[
80,
12,
22,
91
]
| 83 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [80, 12, 22, 91] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 83. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [80, 12, 22, 91]. Our goal is to produce 83. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 83:[80, 12, 22, 91]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12+22=34. \nResulting numbers: [80, 91, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|80-83| + |91-83| + |34-83|)/3 = (3 + 8 + 49)/3 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 83:[80, 91, 34] Operation: 12+22=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-34=57. \nResulting numbers: [80, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|80-83| + |57-83|)/2 = (3 + 26)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 83:[80, 57] Operation: 91-34=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+57=137. \nResulting numbers: [137].\n137,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[80, 91, 34]. Operations so far : ['12+22=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+34=114. \nResulting numbers: [91, 114].\nHeuristic score : (|91-83| + |114-83|)/2 = (8 + 31)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 83:[91, 114] Operation: 80+34=114\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 114-91=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[80, 91, 34]. Operations so far : ['12+22=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-34=46. \nResulting numbers: [91, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|91-83| + |46-83|)/2 = (8 + 37)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 83:[91, 46] Operation: 80-34=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-46=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[80, 91, 34]. Operations so far : ['12+22=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+34=125. \nResulting numbers: [80, 125].\nHeuristic score : (|80-83| + |125-83|)/2 = (3 + 42)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 83:[80, 125] Operation: 91+34=125\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 125-80=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[80, 91, 34]. Operations so far : ['12+22=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-80=11. \nResulting numbers: [34, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |11-83|)/2 = (49 + 72)/2 = 60.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 83:[34, 11] Operation: 91-80=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+11=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[80, 91, 34]. Operations so far : ['12+22=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+91=171. \nResulting numbers: [34, 171].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |171-83|)/2 = (49 + 88)/2 = 68.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 83:[34, 171] Operation: 80+91=171\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 171-34=137. \nResulting numbers: [137].\n137,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[80, 91, 34]. Operations so far : ['12+22=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*34=2720. \nResulting numbers: [91, 2720].\nHeuristic score : (|91-83| + |2720-83|)/2 = (8 + 2637)/2 = 1322.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 83:[91, 2720] Operation: 80*34=2720\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2720-91=2629. \nResulting numbers: [2629].\n2629,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[80, 91, 34]. Operations so far : ['12+22=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91*34=3094. \nResulting numbers: [80, 3094].\nHeuristic score : (|80-83| + |3094-83|)/2 = (3 + 3011)/2 = 1507.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 83:[80, 3094] Operation: 91*34=3094\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3094-80=3014. \nResulting numbers: [3014].\n3014,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[80, 91, 34]. Operations so far : ['12+22=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*91=7280. \nResulting numbers: [34, 7280].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |7280-83|)/2 = (49 + 7197)/2 = 3623.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 83:[34, 7280] Operation: 80*91=7280\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7280-34=7246. \nResulting numbers: [7246].\n7246,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 35.75\nCurrent State #0: 83:[80, 12, 22, 91]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-12=79. \nResulting numbers: [80, 22, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|80-83| + |22-83| + |79-83|)/3 = (3 + 61 + 4)/3 = 22.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 83:[80, 22, 79] Operation: 91-12=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+79=101. \nResulting numbers: [80, 101].\nHeuristic score : (|80-83| + |101-83|)/2 = (3 + 18)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 83:[80, 101] Operation: 22+79=101\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-80=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[80, 22, 79]. Operations so far : ['91-12=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+22=102. \nResulting numbers: [79, 102].\nHeuristic score : (|79-83| + |102-83|)/2 = (4 + 19)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 83:[79, 102] Operation: 80+22=102\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102-79=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[80, 22, 79]. Operations so far : ['91-12=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-22=58. \nResulting numbers: [79, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|79-83| + |58-83|)/2 = (4 + 25)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 83:[79, 58] Operation: 80-22=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+58=137. \nResulting numbers: [137].\n137,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[80, 22, 79]. Operations so far : ['91-12=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-22=57. \nResulting numbers: [80, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|80-83| + |57-83|)/2 = (3 + 26)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 83:[80, 57] Operation: 79-22=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+57=137. \nResulting numbers: [137].\n137,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[80, 22, 79]. Operations so far : ['91-12=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+79=159. \nResulting numbers: [22, 159].\nHeuristic score : (|22-83| + |159-83|)/2 = (61 + 76)/2 = 68.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 83:[22, 159] Operation: 80+79=159\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 159-22=137. \nResulting numbers: [137].\n137,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[80, 22, 79]. Operations so far : ['91-12=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-79=1. \nResulting numbers: [22, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|22-83| + |1-83|)/2 = (61 + 82)/2 = 71.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 83:[22, 1] Operation: 80-79=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+1=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[80, 22, 79]. Operations so far : ['91-12=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22*79=1738. \nResulting numbers: [80, 1738].\nHeuristic score : (|80-83| + |1738-83|)/2 = (3 + 1655)/2 = 829.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 83:[80, 1738] Operation: 22*79=1738\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1738-80=1658. \nResulting numbers: [1658].\n1658,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[80, 22, 79]. Operations so far : ['91-12=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*22=1760. \nResulting numbers: [79, 1760].\nHeuristic score : (|79-83| + |1760-83|)/2 = (4 + 1677)/2 = 840.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 83:[79, 1760] Operation: 80*22=1760\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1760-79=1681. \nResulting numbers: [1681].\n1681,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[80, 22, 79]. Operations so far : ['91-12=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*79=6320. \nResulting numbers: [22, 6320].\nHeuristic score : (|22-83| + |6320-83|)/2 = (61 + 6237)/2 = 3149.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 83:[22, 6320] Operation: 80*79=6320\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6320-22=6298. \nResulting numbers: [6298].\n6298,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 35.75\nCurrent State #0: 83:[80, 12, 22, 91]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+12=92. \nResulting numbers: [22, 91, 92].\nHeuristic score : (|22-83| + |91-83| + |92-83|)/3 = (61 + 8 + 9)/3 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 83:[22, 91, 92] Operation: 80+12=92\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-22=70. \nResulting numbers: [91, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|91-83| + |70-83|)/2 = (8 + 13)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 83:[91, 70] Operation: 92-22=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-70=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[22, 91, 92]. Operations so far : ['80+12=92'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-22=69. \nResulting numbers: [92, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|92-83| + |69-83|)/2 = (9 + 14)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 83:[92, 69] Operation: 91-22=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-69=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[22, 91, 92]. Operations so far : ['80+12=92'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+91=113. \nResulting numbers: [92, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|92-83| + |113-83|)/2 = (9 + 30)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 83:[92, 113] Operation: 22+91=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-92=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[22, 91, 92]. Operations so far : ['80+12=92'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+92=114. \nResulting numbers: [91, 114].\nHeuristic score : (|91-83| + |114-83|)/2 = (8 + 31)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 83:[91, 114] Operation: 22+92=114\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 114-91=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[22, 91, 92]. Operations so far : ['80+12=92'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-91=1. \nResulting numbers: [22, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|22-83| + |1-83|)/2 = (61 + 82)/2 = 71.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 83:[22, 1] Operation: 92-91=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+1=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[22, 91, 92]. Operations so far : ['80+12=92'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+92=183. \nResulting numbers: [22, 183].\nHeuristic score : (|22-83| + |183-83|)/2 = (61 + 100)/2 = 80.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 83:[22, 183] Operation: 91+92=183\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 183-22=161. \nResulting numbers: [161].\n161,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[22, 91, 92]. Operations so far : ['80+12=92'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22*91=2002. \nResulting numbers: [92, 2002].\nHeuristic score : (|92-83| + |2002-83|)/2 = (9 + 1919)/2 = 964.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 83:[92, 2002] Operation: 22*91=2002\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2002-92=1910. \nResulting numbers: [1910].\n1910,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[22, 91, 92]. Operations so far : ['80+12=92'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22*92=2024. \nResulting numbers: [91, 2024].\nHeuristic score : (|91-83| + |2024-83|)/2 = (8 + 1941)/2 = 974.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 83:[91, 2024] Operation: 22*92=2024\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2024-91=1933. \nResulting numbers: [1933].\n1933,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[22, 91, 92]. Operations so far : ['80+12=92'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91*92=8372. \nResulting numbers: [22, 8372].\nHeuristic score : (|22-83| + |8372-83|)/2 = (61 + 8289)/2 = 4175.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 83:[22, 8372] Operation: 91*92=8372\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8372-22=8350. \nResulting numbers: [8350].\n8350,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 35.75\nCurrent State #0: 83:[80, 12, 22, 91]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-12=68. \nResulting numbers: [22, 91, 68].\nHeuristic score : (|22-83| + |91-83| + |68-83|)/3 = (61 + 8 + 15)/3 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 83:[22, 91, 68] Operation: 80-12=68\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+68=90. \nResulting numbers: [91, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|91-83| + |90-83|)/2 = (8 + 7)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 83:[91, 90] Operation: 22+68=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-90=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[22, 91, 68]. Operations so far : ['80-12=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-22=69. \nResulting numbers: [68, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|68-83| + |69-83|)/2 = (15 + 14)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 83:[68, 69] Operation: 91-22=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+69=137. \nResulting numbers: [137].\n137,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[22, 91, 68]. Operations so far : ['80-12=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+91=113. \nResulting numbers: [68, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|68-83| + |113-83|)/2 = (15 + 30)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 83:[68, 113] Operation: 22+91=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-68=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[22, 91, 68]. Operations so far : ['80-12=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-22=46. \nResulting numbers: [91, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|91-83| + |46-83|)/2 = (8 + 37)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 83:[91, 46] Operation: 68-22=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-46=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[22, 91, 68]. Operations so far : ['80-12=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-68=23. \nResulting numbers: [22, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|22-83| + |23-83|)/2 = (61 + 60)/2 = 60.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 83:[22, 23] Operation: 91-68=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+23=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[22, 91, 68]. Operations so far : ['80-12=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+68=159. \nResulting numbers: [22, 159].\nHeuristic score : (|22-83| + |159-83|)/2 = (61 + 76)/2 = 68.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 83:[22, 159] Operation: 91+68=159\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 159-22=137. \nResulting numbers: [137].\n137,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[22, 91, 68]. Operations so far : ['80-12=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22*68=1496. \nResulting numbers: [91, 1496].\nHeuristic score : (|91-83| + |1496-83|)/2 = (8 + 1413)/2 = 710.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 83:[91, 1496] Operation: 22*68=1496\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1496-91=1405. \nResulting numbers: [1405].\n1405,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[22, 91, 68]. Operations so far : ['80-12=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22*91=2002. \nResulting numbers: [68, 2002].\nHeuristic score : (|68-83| + |2002-83|)/2 = (15 + 1919)/2 = 967.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 83:[68, 2002] Operation: 22*91=2002\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2002-68=1934. \nResulting numbers: [1934].\n1934,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[22, 91, 68]. Operations so far : ['80-12=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91*68=6188. \nResulting numbers: [22, 6188].\nHeuristic score : (|22-83| + |6188-83|)/2 = (61 + 6105)/2 = 3083.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 83:[22, 6188] Operation: 91*68=6188\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6188-22=6166. \nResulting numbers: [6166].\n6166,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 35.75\nCurrent State #0: 83:[80, 12, 22, 91]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22-12=10. \nResulting numbers: [80, 91, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|80-83| + |91-83| + |10-83|)/3 = (3 + 8 + 73)/3 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 83:[80, 91, 10] Operation: 22-12=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-10=81. \nResulting numbers: [80, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|80-83| + |81-83|)/2 = (3 + 2)/2 = 2.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 83:[80, 81] Operation: 91-10=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+81=161. \nResulting numbers: [161].\n161,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[80, 91, 10]. Operations so far : ['22-12=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+10=90. \nResulting numbers: [91, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|91-83| + |90-83|)/2 = (8 + 7)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 83:[91, 90] Operation: 80+10=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-90=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[80, 91, 10]. Operations so far : ['22-12=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-10=70. \nResulting numbers: [91, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|91-83| + |70-83|)/2 = (8 + 13)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 83:[91, 70] Operation: 80-10=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-70=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[80, 91, 10]. Operations so far : ['22-12=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+10=101. \nResulting numbers: [80, 101].\nHeuristic score : (|80-83| + |101-83|)/2 = (3 + 18)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 83:[80, 101] Operation: 91+10=101\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-80=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[80, 91, 10]. Operations so far : ['22-12=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/10=8. \nResulting numbers: [91, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|91-83| + |8-83|)/2 = (8 + 75)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 83:[91, 8] Operation: 80/10=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-8=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,83 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['22-12=10', '80/10=8', '91-8=83']\nRESULT: 83\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 9,686 |
[
53,
80,
37,
38
]
| 27 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [53, 80, 37, 38] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 27. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [53, 80, 37, 38]. Our goal is to produce 27. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 27:[53, 80, 37, 38]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-53=27. \nResulting numbers: [37, 38, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|37-27| + |38-27| + |27-27|)/3 = (10 + 11 + 0)/3 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 27:[37, 38, 27] Operation: 80-53=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-38=42. \nResulting numbers: [53, 37, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|53-27| + |37-27| + |42-27|)/3 = (26 + 10 + 15)/3 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 27:[53, 37, 42] Operation: 80-38=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-37=16. \nResulting numbers: [80, 38, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|80-27| + |38-27| + |16-27|)/3 = (53 + 11 + 11)/3 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 27:[80, 38, 16] Operation: 53-37=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-38=15. \nResulting numbers: [80, 37, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|80-27| + |37-27| + |15-27|)/3 = (53 + 10 + 12)/3 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 27:[80, 37, 15] Operation: 53-38=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-37=43. \nResulting numbers: [53, 38, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|53-27| + |38-27| + |43-27|)/3 = (26 + 11 + 16)/3 = 17.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 27:[53, 38, 43] Operation: 80-37=43\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 27:[37, 38, 27]. Operations so far : ['80-53=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-27=11. \nResulting numbers: [37, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|37-27| + |11-27|)/2 = (10 + 16)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 27:[37, 11] Operation: 38-27=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-37=1. \nResulting numbers: [27, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|27-27| + |1-27|)/2 = (0 + 26)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 27:[27, 1] Operation: 38-37=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+38=75. \nResulting numbers: [27, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|27-27| + |75-27|)/2 = (0 + 48)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 27:[27, 75] Operation: 37+38=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-27=10. \nResulting numbers: [38, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|38-27| + |10-27|)/2 = (11 + 17)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 27:[38, 10] Operation: 37-27=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+27=64. \nResulting numbers: [38, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|38-27| + |64-27|)/2 = (11 + 37)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 27:[38, 64] Operation: 37+27=64\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 27:[53, 37, 42]. Operations so far : ['80-38=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+37=90. \nResulting numbers: [42, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|42-27| + |90-27|)/2 = (15 + 63)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 27:[42, 90] Operation: 53+37=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-42=11. \nResulting numbers: [37, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|37-27| + |11-27|)/2 = (10 + 16)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 27:[37, 11] Operation: 53-42=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+42=95. \nResulting numbers: [37, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|37-27| + |95-27|)/2 = (10 + 68)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 27:[37, 95] Operation: 53+42=95\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-37=5. \nResulting numbers: [53, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|53-27| + |5-27|)/2 = (26 + 22)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 27:[53, 5] Operation: 42-37=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-37=16. \nResulting numbers: [42, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|42-27| + |16-27|)/2 = (15 + 11)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 27:[42, 16] Operation: 53-37=16\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 27:[53, 38, 43]. Operations so far : ['80-37=43'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-38=15. \nResulting numbers: [43, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|43-27| + |15-27|)/2 = (16 + 12)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 27:[43, 15] Operation: 53-38=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-43=10. \nResulting numbers: [38, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|38-27| + |10-27|)/2 = (11 + 17)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 27:[38, 10] Operation: 53-43=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-38=5. \nResulting numbers: [53, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|53-27| + |5-27|)/2 = (26 + 22)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 27:[53, 5] Operation: 43-38=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+43=96. \nResulting numbers: [38, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|38-27| + |96-27|)/2 = (11 + 69)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 27:[38, 96] Operation: 53+43=96\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+38=91. \nResulting numbers: [43, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|43-27| + |91-27|)/2 = (16 + 64)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 27:[43, 91] Operation: 53+38=91\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 27:[80, 38, 16]. Operations so far : ['53-37=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/16=5. \nResulting numbers: [38, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|38-27| + |5-27|)/2 = (11 + 22)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 27:[38, 5] Operation: 80/16=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-16=22. \nResulting numbers: [80, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|80-27| + |22-27|)/2 = (53 + 5)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 27:[80, 22] Operation: 38-16=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+16=96. \nResulting numbers: [38, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|38-27| + |96-27|)/2 = (11 + 69)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 27:[38, 96] Operation: 80+16=96\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-38=42. \nResulting numbers: [16, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|16-27| + |42-27|)/2 = (11 + 15)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 27:[16, 42] Operation: 80-38=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-16=64. \nResulting numbers: [38, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|38-27| + |64-27|)/2 = (11 + 37)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 27:[38, 64] Operation: 80-16=64\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 27:[80, 37, 15]. Operations so far : ['53-38=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+15=52. \nResulting numbers: [80, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|80-27| + |52-27|)/2 = (53 + 25)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 27:[80, 52] Operation: 37+15=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-37=43. \nResulting numbers: [15, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|15-27| + |43-27|)/2 = (12 + 16)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 27:[15, 43] Operation: 80-37=43\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-15=65. \nResulting numbers: [37, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|37-27| + |65-27|)/2 = (10 + 38)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 27:[37, 65] Operation: 80-15=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+15=95. \nResulting numbers: [37, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|37-27| + |95-27|)/2 = (10 + 68)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 27:[37, 95] Operation: 80+15=95\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-15=22. \nResulting numbers: [80, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|80-27| + |22-27|)/2 = (53 + 5)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 27:[80, 22] Operation: 37-15=22\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 27:[37, 11]. Operations so far : ['80-53=27', '38-27=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-11=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,27 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+11=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,27 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*11=407. \nResulting numbers: [407].\n407,27 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 27:[37, 11]. Operations so far : ['80-38=42', '53-42=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+11=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,27 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-11=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,27 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*11=407. \nResulting numbers: [407].\n407,27 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 27:[42, 16]. Operations so far : ['80-38=42', '53-37=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-16=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,27 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42*16=672. \nResulting numbers: [672].\n672,27 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42+16=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,27 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 27:[27, 1]. Operations so far : ['80-53=27', '38-37=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27/1=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,27 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['80-53=27', '38-37=1', '27/1=27']\nRESULT: 27\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 4,444 |
[
12,
53,
81,
2
]
| 32 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [12, 53, 81, 2] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 32. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [12, 53, 81, 2]. Our goal is to produce 32. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 32:[12, 53, 81, 2]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-53=28. \nResulting numbers: [12, 2, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|12-32| + |2-32| + |28-32|)/3 = (20 + 30 + 4)/3 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 32:[12, 2, 28] Operation: 81-53=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12*2=24. \nResulting numbers: [28, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|28-32| + |24-32|)/2 = (4 + 8)/2 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 32:[28, 24] Operation: 12*2=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+24=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,32 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 32:[12, 2, 28]. Operations so far : ['81-53=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12+2=14. \nResulting numbers: [28, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|28-32| + |14-32|)/2 = (4 + 18)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 32:[28, 14] Operation: 12+2=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+14=42. \nResulting numbers: [42].\n42,32 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 32:[12, 2, 28]. Operations so far : ['81-53=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2+28=30. \nResulting numbers: [12, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|12-32| + |30-32|)/2 = (20 + 2)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 32:[12, 30] Operation: 2+28=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12+30=42. \nResulting numbers: [42].\n42,32 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 32:[12, 2, 28]. Operations so far : ['81-53=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12-2=10. \nResulting numbers: [28, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|28-32| + |10-32|)/2 = (4 + 22)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 32:[28, 10] Operation: 12-2=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+10=38. \nResulting numbers: [38].\n38,32 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 32:[12, 2, 28]. Operations so far : ['81-53=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-2=26. \nResulting numbers: [12, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|12-32| + |26-32|)/2 = (20 + 6)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 32:[12, 26] Operation: 28-2=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12+26=38. \nResulting numbers: [38].\n38,32 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 32:[12, 2, 28]. Operations so far : ['81-53=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12/2=6. \nResulting numbers: [28, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|28-32| + |6-32|)/2 = (4 + 26)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 32:[28, 6] Operation: 12/2=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+6=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,32 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 32:[12, 2, 28]. Operations so far : ['81-53=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12+28=40. \nResulting numbers: [2, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|2-32| + |40-32|)/2 = (30 + 8)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 32:[2, 40] Operation: 12+28=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-2=38. \nResulting numbers: [38].\n38,32 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 32:[12, 2, 28]. Operations so far : ['81-53=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28/2=14. \nResulting numbers: [12, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|12-32| + |14-32|)/2 = (20 + 18)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 32:[12, 14] Operation: 28/2=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12+14=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,32 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 32:[12, 2, 28]. Operations so far : ['81-53=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2*28=56. \nResulting numbers: [12, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|12-32| + |56-32|)/2 = (20 + 24)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 32:[12, 56] Operation: 2*28=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-12=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,32 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 32:[12, 2, 28]. Operations so far : ['81-53=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-12=16. \nResulting numbers: [2, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|2-32| + |16-32|)/2 = (30 + 16)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,9: 32:[2, 16] Operation: 28-12=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2*16=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,32 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['81-53=28', '28-12=16', '2*16=32']\nRESULT: 32\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 2,381 |
[
21,
30,
5,
36
]
| 32 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [21, 30, 5, 36] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 32. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [21, 30, 5, 36]. Our goal is to produce 32. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 32:[21, 30, 5, 36]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+5=35. \nResulting numbers: [21, 36, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|21-32| + |36-32| + |35-32|)/3 = (11 + 4 + 3)/3 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 32:[21, 36, 35] Operation: 30+5=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-5=31. \nResulting numbers: [21, 30, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|21-32| + |30-32| + |31-32|)/3 = (11 + 2 + 1)/3 = 4.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 32:[21, 30, 31] Operation: 36-5=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21-5=16. \nResulting numbers: [30, 36, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|30-32| + |36-32| + |16-32|)/3 = (2 + 4 + 16)/3 = 7.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 32:[30, 36, 16] Operation: 21-5=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-5=25. \nResulting numbers: [21, 36, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|21-32| + |36-32| + |25-32|)/3 = (11 + 4 + 7)/3 = 7.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 32:[21, 36, 25] Operation: 30-5=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+5=26. \nResulting numbers: [30, 36, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|30-32| + |36-32| + |26-32|)/3 = (2 + 4 + 6)/3 = 4.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 32:[30, 36, 26] Operation: 21+5=26\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 4.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 32:[30, 36, 26]. Operations so far : ['21+5=26'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-26=10. \nResulting numbers: [30, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|30-32| + |10-32|)/2 = (2 + 22)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 32:[30, 10] Operation: 36-26=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+26=56. \nResulting numbers: [36, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|36-32| + |56-32|)/2 = (4 + 24)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 32:[36, 56] Operation: 30+26=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-26=4. \nResulting numbers: [36, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|36-32| + |4-32|)/2 = (4 + 28)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 32:[36, 4] Operation: 30-26=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-30=6. \nResulting numbers: [26, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|26-32| + |6-32|)/2 = (6 + 26)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 32:[26, 6] Operation: 36-30=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+26=62. \nResulting numbers: [30, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|30-32| + |62-32|)/2 = (2 + 30)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 32:[30, 62] Operation: 36+26=62\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 4.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,1: 32:[21, 30, 31]. Operations so far : ['36-5=31'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-21=9. \nResulting numbers: [31, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|31-32| + |9-32|)/2 = (1 + 23)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 32:[31, 9] Operation: 30-21=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+31=52. \nResulting numbers: [30, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|30-32| + |52-32|)/2 = (2 + 20)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 32:[30, 52] Operation: 21+31=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31-21=10. \nResulting numbers: [30, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|30-32| + |10-32|)/2 = (2 + 22)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 32:[30, 10] Operation: 31-21=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+31=61. \nResulting numbers: [21, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|21-32| + |61-32|)/2 = (11 + 29)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 32:[21, 61] Operation: 30+31=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+30=51. \nResulting numbers: [31, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|31-32| + |51-32|)/2 = (1 + 19)/2 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 32:[31, 51] Operation: 21+30=51\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 32:[21, 36, 35]. Operations so far : ['30+5=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-21=15. \nResulting numbers: [35, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|35-32| + |15-32|)/2 = (3 + 17)/2 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 32:[35, 15] Operation: 36-21=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+36=57. \nResulting numbers: [35, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|35-32| + |57-32|)/2 = (3 + 25)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 32:[35, 57] Operation: 21+36=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-35=1. \nResulting numbers: [21, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|21-32| + |1-32|)/2 = (11 + 31)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 32:[21, 1] Operation: 36-35=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-21=14. \nResulting numbers: [36, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|36-32| + |14-32|)/2 = (4 + 18)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 32:[36, 14] Operation: 35-21=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+35=56. \nResulting numbers: [36, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|36-32| + |56-32|)/2 = (4 + 24)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 32:[36, 56] Operation: 21+35=56\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 7.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,2: 32:[30, 36, 16]. Operations so far : ['21-5=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-16=20. \nResulting numbers: [30, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|30-32| + |20-32|)/2 = (2 + 12)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 32:[30, 20] Operation: 36-16=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-16=14. \nResulting numbers: [36, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|36-32| + |14-32|)/2 = (4 + 18)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 32:[36, 14] Operation: 30-16=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-30=6. \nResulting numbers: [16, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|16-32| + |6-32|)/2 = (16 + 26)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 32:[16, 6] Operation: 36-30=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+16=52. \nResulting numbers: [30, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|30-32| + |52-32|)/2 = (2 + 20)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 32:[30, 52] Operation: 36+16=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+16=46. \nResulting numbers: [36, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|36-32| + |46-32|)/2 = (4 + 14)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 32:[36, 46] Operation: 30+16=46\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 7.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,3: 32:[21, 36, 25]. Operations so far : ['30-5=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-25=11. \nResulting numbers: [21, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|21-32| + |11-32|)/2 = (11 + 21)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 32:[21, 11] Operation: 36-25=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-21=15. \nResulting numbers: [25, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|25-32| + |15-32|)/2 = (7 + 17)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 32:[25, 15] Operation: 36-21=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+25=46. \nResulting numbers: [36, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|36-32| + |46-32|)/2 = (4 + 14)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 32:[36, 46] Operation: 21+25=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+36=57. \nResulting numbers: [25, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|25-32| + |57-32|)/2 = (7 + 25)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 32:[25, 57] Operation: 21+36=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25-21=4. \nResulting numbers: [36, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|36-32| + |4-32|)/2 = (4 + 28)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 32:[36, 4] Operation: 25-21=4\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 32:[30, 20]. Operations so far : ['21-5=16', '36-16=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+20=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-20=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*20=600. \nResulting numbers: [600].\n600,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 32:[36, 46]. Operations so far : ['21-5=16', '30+16=46'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46-36=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+46=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*46=1656. \nResulting numbers: [1656].\n1656,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 32:[36, 46]. Operations so far : ['30-5=25', '21+25=46'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*46=1656. \nResulting numbers: [1656].\n1656,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+46=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46-36=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 32:[31, 51]. Operations so far : ['36-5=31', '21+30=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-31=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31*51=1581. \nResulting numbers: [1581].\n1581,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31+51=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 32:[35, 15]. Operations so far : ['30+5=35', '36-21=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-15=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+15=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*15=525. \nResulting numbers: [525].\n525,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 32:[30, 52]. Operations so far : ['36-5=31', '21+31=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*52=1560. \nResulting numbers: [1560].\n1560,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+52=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-30=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 32:[36, 14]. Operations so far : ['30+5=35', '35-21=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+14=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*14=504. \nResulting numbers: [504].\n504,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-14=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 32:[36, 14]. Operations so far : ['21-5=16', '30-16=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*14=504. \nResulting numbers: [504].\n504,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-14=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+14=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 32:[30, 52]. Operations so far : ['21-5=16', '36+16=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+52=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*52=1560. \nResulting numbers: [1560].\n1560,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-30=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 32:[30, 10]. Operations so far : ['21+5=26', '36-26=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*10=300. \nResulting numbers: [300].\n300,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+10=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-10=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30/10=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,4,0,1: 32:[40]. Operations so far : ['21+5=26', '36-26=10', '30+10=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 32:[22]. Operations so far : ['36-5=31', '21+31=52', '52-30=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,0,3,2: 32:[22]. Operations so far : ['30+5=35', '35-21=14', '36-14=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 32:[22]. Operations so far : ['21-5=16', '36+16=52', '52-30=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,2,1,1: 32:[22]. Operations so far : ['21-5=16', '30-16=14', '36-14=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,1,4,0: 32:[20]. Operations so far : ['36-5=31', '21+30=51', '51-31=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,4,0,2: 32:[20]. Operations so far : ['21+5=26', '36-26=10', '30-10=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 32:[31, 9]. Operations so far : ['36-5=31', '30-21=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31-9=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31+9=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31*9=279. \nResulting numbers: [279].\n279,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 12.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 32:[25, 15]. Operations so far : ['30-5=25', '36-21=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+15=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*15=375. \nResulting numbers: [375].\n375,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25-15=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 12.0\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 32:[30, 10]. Operations so far : ['36-5=31', '31-21=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+10=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-10=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*10=300. \nResulting numbers: [300].\n300,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30/10=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 32:[40]. Operations so far : ['36-5=31', '30-21=9', '31+9=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,3,1,0: 32:[40]. Operations so far : ['30-5=25', '36-21=15', '25+15=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,1,2,0: 32:[40]. Operations so far : ['36-5=31', '31-21=10', '30+10=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,1,0,0: 32:[22]. Operations so far : ['36-5=31', '30-21=9', '31-9=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,1,2,1: 32:[20]. Operations so far : ['36-5=31', '31-21=10', '30-10=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,0,0,0: 32:[20]. Operations so far : ['30+5=35', '36-21=15', '35-15=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 32:[36, 56]. Operations so far : ['30+5=35', '21+35=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+56=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*56=2016. \nResulting numbers: [2016].\n2016,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-36=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 32:[35, 57]. Operations so far : ['30+5=35', '21+36=57'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+57=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-35=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*57=1995. \nResulting numbers: [1995].\n1995,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 32:[36, 56]. Operations so far : ['21+5=26', '30+26=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-36=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+56=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,32 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*56=2016. \nResulting numbers: [2016].\n2016,32 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 32:[36, 4]. Operations so far : ['21+5=26', '30-26=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-4=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,32 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['21+5=26', '30-26=4', '36/4=9']\nRESULT: 9\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 8,736 |
[
51,
45,
16,
60
]
| 50 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [51, 45, 16, 60] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 50. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [51, 45, 16, 60]. Our goal is to produce 50. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 50:[51, 45, 16, 60]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-16=44. \nResulting numbers: [51, 45, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|51-50| + |45-50| + |44-50|)/3 = (1 + 5 + 6)/3 = 4.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 50:[51, 45, 44] Operation: 60-16=44\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+44=89. \nResulting numbers: [51, 89].\nHeuristic score : (|51-50| + |89-50|)/2 = (1 + 39)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 50:[51, 89] Operation: 45+44=89\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-51=38. \nResulting numbers: [38].\n38,50 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 4.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 50:[51, 45, 44]. Operations so far : ['60-16=44'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-44=7. \nResulting numbers: [45, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|45-50| + |7-50|)/2 = (5 + 43)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 50:[45, 7] Operation: 51-44=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+7=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,50 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 4.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 50:[51, 45, 44]. Operations so far : ['60-16=44'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-45=6. \nResulting numbers: [44, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|44-50| + |6-50|)/2 = (6 + 44)/2 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 50:[44, 6] Operation: 51-45=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+6=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,50 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['60-16=44', '51-45=6', '44+6=50']\nRESULT: 50\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 862 |
[
3,
77,
39,
14
]
| 78 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [3, 77, 39, 14] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 78. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [3, 77, 39, 14]. Our goal is to produce 78. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 78:[3, 77, 39, 14]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3*14=42. \nResulting numbers: [77, 39, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |39-78| + |42-78|)/3 = (1 + 39 + 36)/3 = 25.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 78:[77, 39, 42] Operation: 3*14=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+42=81. \nResulting numbers: [77, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |81-78|)/2 = (1 + 3)/2 = 2.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 78:[77, 81] Operation: 39+42=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-77=4. \nResulting numbers: [4].\n4,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 78:[77, 39, 42]. Operations so far : ['3*14=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+39=116. \nResulting numbers: [42, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|42-78| + |116-78|)/2 = (36 + 38)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 78:[42, 116] Operation: 77+39=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-42=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 78:[77, 39, 42]. Operations so far : ['3*14=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-39=38. \nResulting numbers: [42, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|42-78| + |38-78|)/2 = (36 + 40)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 78:[42, 38] Operation: 77-39=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42+38=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 78:[77, 39, 42]. Operations so far : ['3*14=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-39=3. \nResulting numbers: [77, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |3-78|)/2 = (1 + 75)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 78:[77, 3] Operation: 42-39=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+3=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 78:[77, 39, 42]. Operations so far : ['3*14=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+42=119. \nResulting numbers: [39, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |119-78|)/2 = (39 + 41)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 78:[39, 119] Operation: 77+42=119\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 119-39=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 78:[77, 39, 42]. Operations so far : ['3*14=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-42=35. \nResulting numbers: [39, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |35-78|)/2 = (39 + 43)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 78:[39, 35] Operation: 77-42=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+35=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 78:[77, 39, 42]. Operations so far : ['3*14=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39*42=1638. \nResulting numbers: [77, 1638].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |1638-78|)/2 = (1 + 1560)/2 = 780.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 78:[77, 1638] Operation: 39*42=1638\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1638-77=1561. \nResulting numbers: [1561].\n1561,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 78:[77, 39, 42]. Operations so far : ['3*14=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*39=3003. \nResulting numbers: [42, 3003].\nHeuristic score : (|42-78| + |3003-78|)/2 = (36 + 2925)/2 = 1480.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 78:[42, 3003] Operation: 77*39=3003\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3003-42=2961. \nResulting numbers: [2961].\n2961,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 78:[77, 39, 42]. Operations so far : ['3*14=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*42=3234. \nResulting numbers: [39, 3234].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |3234-78|)/2 = (39 + 3156)/2 = 1597.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 78:[39, 3234] Operation: 77*42=3234\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3234-39=3195. \nResulting numbers: [3195].\n3195,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 44.75\nCurrent State #0: 78:[3, 77, 39, 14]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+39=42. \nResulting numbers: [77, 14, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |14-78| + |42-78|)/3 = (1 + 64 + 36)/3 = 33.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 78:[77, 14, 42] Operation: 3+39=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+42=56. \nResulting numbers: [77, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |56-78|)/2 = (1 + 22)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 78:[77, 56] Operation: 14+42=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+56=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 78:[77, 14, 42]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+14=91. \nResulting numbers: [42, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|42-78| + |91-78|)/2 = (36 + 13)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 78:[42, 91] Operation: 77+14=91\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-42=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 78:[77, 14, 42]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-14=63. \nResulting numbers: [42, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|42-78| + |63-78|)/2 = (36 + 15)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 78:[42, 63] Operation: 77-14=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42+63=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 78:[77, 14, 42]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-14=28. \nResulting numbers: [77, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |28-78|)/2 = (1 + 50)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 78:[77, 28] Operation: 42-14=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+28=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 78:[77, 14, 42]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42/14=3. \nResulting numbers: [77, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |3-78|)/2 = (1 + 75)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 78:[77, 3] Operation: 42/14=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+3=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 78:[77, 14, 42]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+42=119. \nResulting numbers: [14, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |119-78|)/2 = (64 + 41)/2 = 52.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 78:[14, 119] Operation: 77+42=119\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 119-14=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 78:[77, 14, 42]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-42=35. \nResulting numbers: [14, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |35-78|)/2 = (64 + 43)/2 = 53.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 78:[14, 35] Operation: 77-42=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+35=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 78:[77, 14, 42]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14*42=588. \nResulting numbers: [77, 588].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |588-78|)/2 = (1 + 510)/2 = 255.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 78:[77, 588] Operation: 14*42=588\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 588-77=511. \nResulting numbers: [511].\n511,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 78:[77, 14, 42]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*14=1078. \nResulting numbers: [42, 1078].\nHeuristic score : (|42-78| + |1078-78|)/2 = (36 + 1000)/2 = 518.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 78:[42, 1078] Operation: 77*14=1078\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1078-42=1036. \nResulting numbers: [1036].\n1036,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 78:[77, 14, 42]. Operations so far : ['3+39=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*42=3234. \nResulting numbers: [14, 3234].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |3234-78|)/2 = (64 + 3156)/2 = 1610.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,9: 78:[14, 3234] Operation: 77*42=3234\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3234/14=231. \nResulting numbers: [231].\n231,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 44.75\nCurrent State #0: 78:[3, 77, 39, 14]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+14=17. \nResulting numbers: [77, 39, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |39-78| + |17-78|)/3 = (1 + 39 + 61)/3 = 33.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 78:[77, 39, 17] Operation: 3+14=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+17=56. \nResulting numbers: [77, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |56-78|)/2 = (1 + 22)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 78:[77, 56] Operation: 39+17=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+56=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,2: 78:[77, 39, 17]. Operations so far : ['3+14=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+17=94. \nResulting numbers: [39, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |94-78|)/2 = (39 + 16)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 78:[39, 94] Operation: 77+17=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-39=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,2: 78:[77, 39, 17]. Operations so far : ['3+14=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-17=60. \nResulting numbers: [39, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |60-78|)/2 = (39 + 18)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 78:[39, 60] Operation: 77-17=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+60=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,2: 78:[77, 39, 17]. Operations so far : ['3+14=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-17=22. \nResulting numbers: [77, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |22-78|)/2 = (1 + 56)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 78:[77, 22] Operation: 39-17=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+22=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,2: 78:[77, 39, 17]. Operations so far : ['3+14=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+39=116. \nResulting numbers: [17, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|17-78| + |116-78|)/2 = (61 + 38)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 78:[17, 116] Operation: 77+39=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-17=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,2: 78:[77, 39, 17]. Operations so far : ['3+14=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-39=38. \nResulting numbers: [17, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|17-78| + |38-78|)/2 = (61 + 40)/2 = 50.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 78:[17, 38] Operation: 77-39=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+38=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,2: 78:[77, 39, 17]. Operations so far : ['3+14=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39*17=663. \nResulting numbers: [77, 663].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |663-78|)/2 = (1 + 585)/2 = 293.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 78:[77, 663] Operation: 39*17=663\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 663-77=586. \nResulting numbers: [586].\n586,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,2: 78:[77, 39, 17]. Operations so far : ['3+14=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*17=1309. \nResulting numbers: [39, 1309].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |1309-78|)/2 = (39 + 1231)/2 = 635.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 78:[39, 1309] Operation: 77*17=1309\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1309-39=1270. \nResulting numbers: [1270].\n1270,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,2: 78:[77, 39, 17]. Operations so far : ['3+14=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*39=3003. \nResulting numbers: [17, 3003].\nHeuristic score : (|17-78| + |3003-78|)/2 = (61 + 2925)/2 = 1493.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 78:[17, 3003] Operation: 77*39=3003\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3003-17=2986. \nResulting numbers: [2986].\n2986,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 44.75\nCurrent State #0: 78:[3, 77, 39, 14]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+14=53. \nResulting numbers: [3, 77, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|3-78| + |77-78| + |53-78|)/3 = (75 + 1 + 25)/3 = 33.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 78:[3, 77, 53] Operation: 39+14=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+53=56. \nResulting numbers: [77, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |56-78|)/2 = (1 + 22)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 78:[77, 56] Operation: 3+53=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+56=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 78:[3, 77, 53]. Operations so far : ['39+14=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+77=80. \nResulting numbers: [53, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|53-78| + |80-78|)/2 = (25 + 2)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 78:[53, 80] Operation: 3+77=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-53=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 78:[3, 77, 53]. Operations so far : ['39+14=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-3=74. \nResulting numbers: [53, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|53-78| + |74-78|)/2 = (25 + 4)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 78:[53, 74] Operation: 77-3=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+74=127. \nResulting numbers: [127].\n127,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 78:[3, 77, 53]. Operations so far : ['39+14=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-3=50. \nResulting numbers: [77, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |50-78|)/2 = (1 + 28)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 78:[77, 50] Operation: 53-3=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+50=127. \nResulting numbers: [127].\n127,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 78:[3, 77, 53]. Operations so far : ['39+14=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3*53=159. \nResulting numbers: [77, 159].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |159-78|)/2 = (1 + 81)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 78:[77, 159] Operation: 3*53=159\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 159-77=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 78:[3, 77, 53]. Operations so far : ['39+14=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+53=130. \nResulting numbers: [3, 130].\nHeuristic score : (|3-78| + |130-78|)/2 = (75 + 52)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 78:[3, 130] Operation: 77+53=130\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 130-3=127. \nResulting numbers: [127].\n127,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 78:[3, 77, 53]. Operations so far : ['39+14=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-53=24. \nResulting numbers: [3, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|3-78| + |24-78|)/2 = (75 + 54)/2 = 64.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 78:[3, 24] Operation: 77-53=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3*24=72. \nResulting numbers: [72].\n72,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 78:[3, 77, 53]. Operations so far : ['39+14=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3*77=231. \nResulting numbers: [53, 231].\nHeuristic score : (|53-78| + |231-78|)/2 = (25 + 153)/2 = 89.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 78:[53, 231] Operation: 3*77=231\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 231-53=178. \nResulting numbers: [178].\n178,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 33.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 78:[3, 77, 53]. Operations so far : ['39+14=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*53=4081. \nResulting numbers: [3, 4081].\nHeuristic score : (|3-78| + |4081-78|)/2 = (75 + 4003)/2 = 2039.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 78:[3, 4081] Operation: 77*53=4081\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4081-3=4078. \nResulting numbers: [4078].\n4078,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 44.75\nCurrent State #0: 78:[3, 77, 39, 14]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3*39=117. \nResulting numbers: [77, 14, 117].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |14-78| + |117-78|)/3 = (1 + 64 + 39)/3 = 34.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 78:[77, 14, 117] Operation: 3*39=117\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 117-14=103. \nResulting numbers: [77, 103].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |103-78|)/2 = (1 + 25)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 78:[77, 103] Operation: 117-14=103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 103-77=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 34.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 78:[77, 14, 117]. Operations so far : ['3*39=117'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+14=91. \nResulting numbers: [117, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|117-78| + |91-78|)/2 = (39 + 13)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 78:[117, 91] Operation: 77+14=91\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 117-91=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 34.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 78:[77, 14, 117]. Operations so far : ['3*39=117'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-14=63. \nResulting numbers: [117, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|117-78| + |63-78|)/2 = (39 + 15)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 78:[117, 63] Operation: 77-14=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 117-63=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 34.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 78:[77, 14, 117]. Operations so far : ['3*39=117'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+117=131. \nResulting numbers: [77, 131].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |131-78|)/2 = (1 + 53)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 78:[77, 131] Operation: 14+117=131\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 131-77=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 34.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 78:[77, 14, 117]. Operations so far : ['3*39=117'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 117-77=40. \nResulting numbers: [14, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |40-78|)/2 = (64 + 38)/2 = 51.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 78:[14, 40] Operation: 117-77=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+40=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 34.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 78:[77, 14, 117]. Operations so far : ['3*39=117'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+117=194. \nResulting numbers: [14, 194].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |194-78|)/2 = (64 + 116)/2 = 90.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 78:[14, 194] Operation: 77+117=194\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 194-14=180. \nResulting numbers: [180].\n180,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 34.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 78:[77, 14, 117]. Operations so far : ['3*39=117'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*14=1078. \nResulting numbers: [117, 1078].\nHeuristic score : (|117-78| + |1078-78|)/2 = (39 + 1000)/2 = 519.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 78:[117, 1078] Operation: 77*14=1078\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1078-117=961. \nResulting numbers: [961].\n961,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 34.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 78:[77, 14, 117]. Operations so far : ['3*39=117'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14*117=1638. \nResulting numbers: [77, 1638].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |1638-78|)/2 = (1 + 1560)/2 = 780.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 78:[77, 1638] Operation: 14*117=1638\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1638-77=1561. \nResulting numbers: [1561].\n1561,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 34.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 78:[77, 14, 117]. Operations so far : ['3*39=117'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*117=9009. \nResulting numbers: [14, 9009].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |9009-78|)/2 = (64 + 8931)/2 = 4497.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 78:[14, 9009] Operation: 77*117=9009\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9009-14=8995. \nResulting numbers: [8995].\n8995,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 44.75\nCurrent State #0: 78:[3, 77, 39, 14]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+77=80. \nResulting numbers: [39, 14, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |14-78| + |80-78|)/3 = (39 + 64 + 2)/3 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,5: 78:[39, 14, 80] Operation: 3+77=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+14=53. \nResulting numbers: [80, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|80-78| + |53-78|)/2 = (2 + 25)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 78:[80, 53] Operation: 39+14=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-53=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 78:[39, 14, 80]. Operations so far : ['3+77=80'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-14=66. \nResulting numbers: [39, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |66-78|)/2 = (39 + 12)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 78:[39, 66] Operation: 80-14=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+66=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 78:[39, 14, 80]. Operations so far : ['3+77=80'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-14=25. \nResulting numbers: [80, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|80-78| + |25-78|)/2 = (2 + 53)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 78:[80, 25] Operation: 39-14=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-25=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 78:[39, 14, 80]. Operations so far : ['3+77=80'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+80=94. \nResulting numbers: [39, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |94-78|)/2 = (39 + 16)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,3: 78:[39, 94] Operation: 14+80=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-39=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 78:[39, 14, 80]. Operations so far : ['3+77=80'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-39=41. \nResulting numbers: [14, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |41-78|)/2 = (64 + 37)/2 = 50.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,4: 78:[14, 41] Operation: 80-39=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+41=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 78:[39, 14, 80]. Operations so far : ['3+77=80'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+80=119. \nResulting numbers: [14, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |119-78|)/2 = (64 + 41)/2 = 52.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,5: 78:[14, 119] Operation: 39+80=119\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 119-14=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 78:[39, 14, 80]. Operations so far : ['3+77=80'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39*14=546. \nResulting numbers: [80, 546].\nHeuristic score : (|80-78| + |546-78|)/2 = (2 + 468)/2 = 235.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,6: 78:[80, 546] Operation: 39*14=546\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 546-80=466. \nResulting numbers: [466].\n466,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 78:[39, 14, 80]. Operations so far : ['3+77=80'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14*80=1120. \nResulting numbers: [39, 1120].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |1120-78|)/2 = (39 + 1042)/2 = 540.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,7: 78:[39, 1120] Operation: 14*80=1120\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1120-39=1081. \nResulting numbers: [1081].\n1081,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 78:[39, 14, 80]. Operations so far : ['3+77=80'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39*80=3120. \nResulting numbers: [14, 3120].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |3120-78|)/2 = (64 + 3042)/2 = 1553.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,8: 78:[14, 3120] Operation: 39*80=3120\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3120-14=3106. \nResulting numbers: [3106].\n3106,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 44.75\nCurrent State #0: 78:[3, 77, 39, 14]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-3=74. \nResulting numbers: [39, 14, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |14-78| + |74-78|)/3 = (39 + 64 + 4)/3 = 35.67\nGenerated Node #0,6: 78:[39, 14, 74] Operation: 77-3=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+14=53. \nResulting numbers: [74, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|74-78| + |53-78|)/2 = (4 + 25)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,0: 78:[74, 53] Operation: 39+14=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+53=127. \nResulting numbers: [127].\n127,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 78:[39, 14, 74]. Operations so far : ['77-3=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+74=88. \nResulting numbers: [39, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |88-78|)/2 = (39 + 10)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,1: 78:[39, 88] Operation: 14+74=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-39=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 78:[39, 14, 74]. Operations so far : ['77-3=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-14=25. \nResulting numbers: [74, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|74-78| + |25-78|)/2 = (4 + 53)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,2: 78:[74, 25] Operation: 39-14=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+25=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 78:[39, 14, 74]. Operations so far : ['77-3=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-14=60. \nResulting numbers: [39, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |60-78|)/2 = (39 + 18)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,3: 78:[39, 60] Operation: 74-14=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+60=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 78:[39, 14, 74]. Operations so far : ['77-3=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+74=113. \nResulting numbers: [14, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |113-78|)/2 = (64 + 35)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,4: 78:[14, 113] Operation: 39+74=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-14=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 78:[39, 14, 74]. Operations so far : ['77-3=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-39=35. \nResulting numbers: [14, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |35-78|)/2 = (64 + 43)/2 = 53.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,5: 78:[14, 35] Operation: 74-39=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+35=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 78:[39, 14, 74]. Operations so far : ['77-3=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39*14=546. \nResulting numbers: [74, 546].\nHeuristic score : (|74-78| + |546-78|)/2 = (4 + 468)/2 = 236.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,6: 78:[74, 546] Operation: 39*14=546\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 546-74=472. \nResulting numbers: [472].\n472,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 78:[39, 14, 74]. Operations so far : ['77-3=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14*74=1036. \nResulting numbers: [39, 1036].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |1036-78|)/2 = (39 + 958)/2 = 498.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,7: 78:[39, 1036] Operation: 14*74=1036\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1036-39=997. \nResulting numbers: [997].\n997,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 78:[39, 14, 74]. Operations so far : ['77-3=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39*74=2886. \nResulting numbers: [14, 2886].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |2886-78|)/2 = (64 + 2808)/2 = 1436.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,8: 78:[14, 2886] Operation: 39*74=2886\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2886-14=2872. \nResulting numbers: [2872].\n2872,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 44.75\nCurrent State #0: 78:[3, 77, 39, 14]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-3=36. \nResulting numbers: [77, 14, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |14-78| + |36-78|)/3 = (1 + 64 + 42)/3 = 35.67\nGenerated Node #0,7: 78:[77, 14, 36] Operation: 39-3=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+36=50. \nResulting numbers: [77, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |50-78|)/2 = (1 + 28)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,0: 78:[77, 50] Operation: 14+36=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+50=127. \nResulting numbers: [127].\n127,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 78:[77, 14, 36]. Operations so far : ['39-3=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+14=91. \nResulting numbers: [36, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|36-78| + |91-78|)/2 = (42 + 13)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,1: 78:[36, 91] Operation: 77+14=91\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-36=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 78:[77, 14, 36]. Operations so far : ['39-3=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-14=63. \nResulting numbers: [36, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|36-78| + |63-78|)/2 = (42 + 15)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,2: 78:[36, 63] Operation: 77-14=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+63=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 78:[77, 14, 36]. Operations so far : ['39-3=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-14=22. \nResulting numbers: [77, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |22-78|)/2 = (1 + 56)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,3: 78:[77, 22] Operation: 36-14=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+22=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 78:[77, 14, 36]. Operations so far : ['39-3=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+36=113. \nResulting numbers: [14, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |113-78|)/2 = (64 + 35)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,4: 78:[14, 113] Operation: 77+36=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-14=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 78:[77, 14, 36]. Operations so far : ['39-3=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-36=41. \nResulting numbers: [14, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |41-78|)/2 = (64 + 37)/2 = 50.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,5: 78:[14, 41] Operation: 77-36=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+41=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 78:[77, 14, 36]. Operations so far : ['39-3=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14*36=504. \nResulting numbers: [77, 504].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |504-78|)/2 = (1 + 426)/2 = 213.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,6: 78:[77, 504] Operation: 14*36=504\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 504-77=427. \nResulting numbers: [427].\n427,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 78:[77, 14, 36]. Operations so far : ['39-3=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*14=1078. \nResulting numbers: [36, 1078].\nHeuristic score : (|36-78| + |1078-78|)/2 = (42 + 1000)/2 = 521.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,7: 78:[36, 1078] Operation: 77*14=1078\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1078-36=1042. \nResulting numbers: [1042].\n1042,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 78:[77, 14, 36]. Operations so far : ['39-3=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*36=2772. \nResulting numbers: [14, 2772].\nHeuristic score : (|14-78| + |2772-78|)/2 = (64 + 2694)/2 = 1379.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,8: 78:[14, 2772] Operation: 77*36=2772\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2772/14=198. \nResulting numbers: [198].\n198,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 44.75\nCurrent State #0: 78:[3, 77, 39, 14]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14-3=11. \nResulting numbers: [77, 39, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |39-78| + |11-78|)/3 = (1 + 39 + 67)/3 = 35.67\nGenerated Node #0,8: 78:[77, 39, 11] Operation: 14-3=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+11=50. \nResulting numbers: [77, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |50-78|)/2 = (1 + 28)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,0: 78:[77, 50] Operation: 39+11=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+50=127. \nResulting numbers: [127].\n127,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 78:[77, 39, 11]. Operations so far : ['14-3=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+11=88. \nResulting numbers: [39, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |88-78|)/2 = (39 + 10)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,1: 78:[39, 88] Operation: 77+11=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-39=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 78:[77, 39, 11]. Operations so far : ['14-3=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-11=66. \nResulting numbers: [39, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |66-78|)/2 = (39 + 12)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,2: 78:[39, 66] Operation: 77-11=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+66=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 78:[77, 39, 11]. Operations so far : ['14-3=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-11=28. \nResulting numbers: [77, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |28-78|)/2 = (1 + 50)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,3: 78:[77, 28] Operation: 39-11=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+28=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 78:[77, 39, 11]. Operations so far : ['14-3=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+39=116. \nResulting numbers: [11, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|11-78| + |116-78|)/2 = (67 + 38)/2 = 52.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,4: 78:[11, 116] Operation: 77+39=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-11=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 78:[77, 39, 11]. Operations so far : ['14-3=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-39=38. \nResulting numbers: [11, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|11-78| + |38-78|)/2 = (67 + 40)/2 = 53.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,5: 78:[11, 38] Operation: 77-39=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+38=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 78:[77, 39, 11]. Operations so far : ['14-3=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77/11=7. \nResulting numbers: [39, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |7-78|)/2 = (39 + 71)/2 = 55.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,6: 78:[39, 7] Operation: 77/11=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+7=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 78:[77, 39, 11]. Operations so far : ['14-3=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39*11=429. \nResulting numbers: [77, 429].\nHeuristic score : (|77-78| + |429-78|)/2 = (1 + 351)/2 = 176.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,7: 78:[77, 429] Operation: 39*11=429\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 429-77=352. \nResulting numbers: [352].\n352,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 78:[77, 39, 11]. Operations so far : ['14-3=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*11=847. \nResulting numbers: [39, 847].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |847-78|)/2 = (39 + 769)/2 = 404.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,8: 78:[39, 847] Operation: 77*11=847\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 847-39=808. \nResulting numbers: [808].\n808,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 78:[77, 39, 11]. Operations so far : ['14-3=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*39=3003. \nResulting numbers: [11, 3003].\nHeuristic score : (|11-78| + |3003-78|)/2 = (67 + 2925)/2 = 1496.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,9: 78:[11, 3003] Operation: 77*39=3003\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3003/11=273. \nResulting numbers: [273].\n273,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 44.75\nCurrent State #0: 78:[3, 77, 39, 14]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+14=91. \nResulting numbers: [3, 39, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|3-78| + |39-78| + |91-78|)/3 = (75 + 39 + 13)/3 = 42.33\nGenerated Node #0,9: 78:[3, 39, 91] Operation: 77+14=91\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+39=42. \nResulting numbers: [91, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|91-78| + |42-78|)/2 = (13 + 36)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,0: 78:[91, 42] Operation: 3+39=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-42=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 42.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 78:[3, 39, 91]. Operations so far : ['77+14=91'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-3=88. \nResulting numbers: [39, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |88-78|)/2 = (39 + 10)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,1: 78:[39, 88] Operation: 91-3=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-39=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 42.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 78:[3, 39, 91]. Operations so far : ['77+14=91'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3*39=117. \nResulting numbers: [91, 117].\nHeuristic score : (|91-78| + |117-78|)/2 = (13 + 39)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,9,2: 78:[91, 117] Operation: 3*39=117\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 117-91=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 42.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 78:[3, 39, 91]. Operations so far : ['77+14=91'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-3=36. \nResulting numbers: [91, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|91-78| + |36-78|)/2 = (13 + 42)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,3: 78:[91, 36] Operation: 39-3=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-36=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 42.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 78:[3, 39, 91]. Operations so far : ['77+14=91'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+91=94. \nResulting numbers: [39, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|39-78| + |94-78|)/2 = (39 + 16)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,4: 78:[39, 94] Operation: 3+91=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-39=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,78 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 42.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 78:[3, 39, 91]. Operations so far : ['77+14=91'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39/3=13. \nResulting numbers: [91, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|91-78| + |13-78|)/2 = (13 + 65)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,9,5: 78:[91, 13] Operation: 39/3=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-13=78. \nResulting numbers: [78].\n78,78 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['77+14=91', '39/3=13', '91-13=78']\nRESULT: 78\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 20,927 |
[
65,
41,
34,
4
]
| 83 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [65, 41, 34, 4] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 83. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [65, 41, 34, 4]. Our goal is to produce 83. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 83:[65, 41, 34, 4]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+4=69. \nResulting numbers: [41, 34, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |34-83| + |69-83|)/3 = (42 + 49 + 14)/3 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 83:[41, 34, 69] Operation: 65+4=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+34=75. \nResulting numbers: [69, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|69-83| + |75-83|)/2 = (14 + 8)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 83:[69, 75] Operation: 41+34=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+75=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[41, 34, 69]. Operations so far : ['65+4=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+69=103. \nResulting numbers: [41, 103].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |103-83|)/2 = (42 + 20)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 83:[41, 103] Operation: 34+69=103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 103-41=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[41, 34, 69]. Operations so far : ['65+4=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+69=110. \nResulting numbers: [34, 110].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |110-83|)/2 = (49 + 27)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 83:[34, 110] Operation: 41+69=110\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 110-34=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[41, 34, 69]. Operations so far : ['65+4=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41-34=7. \nResulting numbers: [69, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|69-83| + |7-83|)/2 = (14 + 76)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 83:[69, 7] Operation: 41-34=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+7=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[41, 34, 69]. Operations so far : ['65+4=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-34=35. \nResulting numbers: [41, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |35-83|)/2 = (42 + 48)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 83:[41, 35] Operation: 69-34=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+35=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[41, 34, 69]. Operations so far : ['65+4=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-41=28. \nResulting numbers: [34, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |28-83|)/2 = (49 + 55)/2 = 52.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 83:[34, 28] Operation: 69-41=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+28=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[41, 34, 69]. Operations so far : ['65+4=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41*34=1394. \nResulting numbers: [69, 1394].\nHeuristic score : (|69-83| + |1394-83|)/2 = (14 + 1311)/2 = 662.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 83:[69, 1394] Operation: 41*34=1394\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1394-69=1325. \nResulting numbers: [1325].\n1325,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[41, 34, 69]. Operations so far : ['65+4=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34*69=2346. \nResulting numbers: [41, 2346].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |2346-83|)/2 = (42 + 2263)/2 = 1152.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 83:[41, 2346] Operation: 34*69=2346\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2346-41=2305. \nResulting numbers: [2305].\n2305,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 83:[41, 34, 69]. Operations so far : ['65+4=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41*69=2829. \nResulting numbers: [34, 2829].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |2829-83|)/2 = (49 + 2746)/2 = 1397.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 83:[34, 2829] Operation: 41*69=2829\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2829-34=2795. \nResulting numbers: [2795].\n2795,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0: 83:[65, 41, 34, 4]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+34=75. \nResulting numbers: [65, 4, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |4-83| + |75-83|)/3 = (18 + 79 + 8)/3 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 83:[65, 4, 75] Operation: 41+34=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+4=69. \nResulting numbers: [75, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|75-83| + |69-83|)/2 = (8 + 14)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 83:[75, 69] Operation: 65+4=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+69=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[65, 4, 75]. Operations so far : ['41+34=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+75=79. \nResulting numbers: [65, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |79-83|)/2 = (18 + 4)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 83:[65, 79] Operation: 4+75=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+79=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[65, 4, 75]. Operations so far : ['41+34=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-4=61. \nResulting numbers: [75, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|75-83| + |61-83|)/2 = (8 + 22)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 83:[75, 61] Operation: 65-4=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+61=136. \nResulting numbers: [136].\n136,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[65, 4, 75]. Operations so far : ['41+34=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-4=71. \nResulting numbers: [65, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |71-83|)/2 = (18 + 12)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 83:[65, 71] Operation: 75-4=71\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+71=136. \nResulting numbers: [136].\n136,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[65, 4, 75]. Operations so far : ['41+34=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+75=140. \nResulting numbers: [4, 140].\nHeuristic score : (|4-83| + |140-83|)/2 = (79 + 57)/2 = 68.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 83:[4, 140] Operation: 65+75=140\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 140/4=35. \nResulting numbers: [35].\n35,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[65, 4, 75]. Operations so far : ['41+34=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-65=10. \nResulting numbers: [4, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|4-83| + |10-83|)/2 = (79 + 73)/2 = 76.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 83:[4, 10] Operation: 75-65=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*10=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[65, 4, 75]. Operations so far : ['41+34=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*4=260. \nResulting numbers: [75, 260].\nHeuristic score : (|75-83| + |260-83|)/2 = (8 + 177)/2 = 92.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 83:[75, 260] Operation: 65*4=260\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 260-75=185. \nResulting numbers: [185].\n185,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[65, 4, 75]. Operations so far : ['41+34=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*75=300. \nResulting numbers: [65, 300].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |300-83|)/2 = (18 + 217)/2 = 117.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 83:[65, 300] Operation: 4*75=300\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 300-65=235. \nResulting numbers: [235].\n235,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 83:[65, 4, 75]. Operations so far : ['41+34=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*75=4875. \nResulting numbers: [4, 4875].\nHeuristic score : (|4-83| + |4875-83|)/2 = (79 + 4792)/2 = 2435.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 83:[4, 4875] Operation: 65*75=4875\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4875-4=4871. \nResulting numbers: [4871].\n4871,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0: 83:[65, 41, 34, 4]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+4=45. \nResulting numbers: [65, 34, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |34-83| + |45-83|)/3 = (18 + 49 + 38)/3 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 83:[65, 34, 45] Operation: 41+4=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+45=79. \nResulting numbers: [65, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |79-83|)/2 = (18 + 4)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 83:[65, 79] Operation: 34+45=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+79=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[65, 34, 45]. Operations so far : ['41+4=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+34=99. \nResulting numbers: [45, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|45-83| + |99-83|)/2 = (38 + 16)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 83:[45, 99] Operation: 65+34=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-45=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[65, 34, 45]. Operations so far : ['41+4=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+45=110. \nResulting numbers: [34, 110].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |110-83|)/2 = (49 + 27)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 83:[34, 110] Operation: 65+45=110\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 110-34=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[65, 34, 45]. Operations so far : ['41+4=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-34=31. \nResulting numbers: [45, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|45-83| + |31-83|)/2 = (38 + 52)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 83:[45, 31] Operation: 65-34=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+31=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[65, 34, 45]. Operations so far : ['41+4=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-34=11. \nResulting numbers: [65, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |11-83|)/2 = (18 + 72)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 83:[65, 11] Operation: 45-34=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+11=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[65, 34, 45]. Operations so far : ['41+4=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-45=20. \nResulting numbers: [34, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |20-83|)/2 = (49 + 63)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 83:[34, 20] Operation: 65-45=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+20=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[65, 34, 45]. Operations so far : ['41+4=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34*45=1530. \nResulting numbers: [65, 1530].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |1530-83|)/2 = (18 + 1447)/2 = 732.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 83:[65, 1530] Operation: 34*45=1530\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1530-65=1465. \nResulting numbers: [1465].\n1465,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[65, 34, 45]. Operations so far : ['41+4=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*34=2210. \nResulting numbers: [45, 2210].\nHeuristic score : (|45-83| + |2210-83|)/2 = (38 + 2127)/2 = 1082.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 83:[45, 2210] Operation: 65*34=2210\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2210-45=2165. \nResulting numbers: [2165].\n2165,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 83:[65, 34, 45]. Operations so far : ['41+4=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*45=2925. \nResulting numbers: [34, 2925].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |2925-83|)/2 = (49 + 2842)/2 = 1445.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 83:[34, 2925] Operation: 65*45=2925\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2925-34=2891. \nResulting numbers: [2891].\n2891,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0: 83:[65, 41, 34, 4]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+4=38. \nResulting numbers: [65, 41, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |41-83| + |38-83|)/3 = (18 + 42 + 45)/3 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 83:[65, 41, 38] Operation: 34+4=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+38=79. \nResulting numbers: [65, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |79-83|)/2 = (18 + 4)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 83:[65, 79] Operation: 41+38=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+79=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[65, 41, 38]. Operations so far : ['34+4=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+38=103. \nResulting numbers: [41, 103].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |103-83|)/2 = (42 + 20)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 83:[41, 103] Operation: 65+38=103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 103-41=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[65, 41, 38]. Operations so far : ['34+4=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+41=106. \nResulting numbers: [38, 106].\nHeuristic score : (|38-83| + |106-83|)/2 = (45 + 23)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 83:[38, 106] Operation: 65+41=106\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 106-38=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[65, 41, 38]. Operations so far : ['34+4=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-38=27. \nResulting numbers: [41, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |27-83|)/2 = (42 + 56)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 83:[41, 27] Operation: 65-38=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+27=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[65, 41, 38]. Operations so far : ['34+4=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41-38=3. \nResulting numbers: [65, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |3-83|)/2 = (18 + 80)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 83:[65, 3] Operation: 41-38=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+3=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[65, 41, 38]. Operations so far : ['34+4=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-41=24. \nResulting numbers: [38, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|38-83| + |24-83|)/2 = (45 + 59)/2 = 52.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 83:[38, 24] Operation: 65-41=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+24=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[65, 41, 38]. Operations so far : ['34+4=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41*38=1558. \nResulting numbers: [65, 1558].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |1558-83|)/2 = (18 + 1475)/2 = 746.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 83:[65, 1558] Operation: 41*38=1558\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1558-65=1493. \nResulting numbers: [1493].\n1493,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[65, 41, 38]. Operations so far : ['34+4=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*38=2470. \nResulting numbers: [41, 2470].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |2470-83|)/2 = (42 + 2387)/2 = 1214.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 83:[41, 2470] Operation: 65*38=2470\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2470-41=2429. \nResulting numbers: [2429].\n2429,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 83:[65, 41, 38]. Operations so far : ['34+4=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*41=2665. \nResulting numbers: [38, 2665].\nHeuristic score : (|38-83| + |2665-83|)/2 = (45 + 2582)/2 = 1313.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 83:[38, 2665] Operation: 65*41=2665\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2665-38=2627. \nResulting numbers: [2627].\n2627,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0: 83:[65, 41, 34, 4]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-4=61. \nResulting numbers: [41, 34, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |34-83| + |61-83|)/3 = (42 + 49 + 22)/3 = 37.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 83:[41, 34, 61] Operation: 65-4=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+34=75. \nResulting numbers: [61, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|61-83| + |75-83|)/2 = (22 + 8)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 83:[61, 75] Operation: 41+34=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+75=136. \nResulting numbers: [136].\n136,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[41, 34, 61]. Operations so far : ['65-4=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+61=95. \nResulting numbers: [41, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |95-83|)/2 = (42 + 12)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 83:[41, 95] Operation: 34+61=95\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-41=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[41, 34, 61]. Operations so far : ['65-4=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+61=102. \nResulting numbers: [34, 102].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |102-83|)/2 = (49 + 19)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 83:[34, 102] Operation: 41+61=102\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102-34=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[41, 34, 61]. Operations so far : ['65-4=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41-34=7. \nResulting numbers: [61, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|61-83| + |7-83|)/2 = (22 + 76)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 83:[61, 7] Operation: 41-34=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+7=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[41, 34, 61]. Operations so far : ['65-4=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-34=27. \nResulting numbers: [41, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |27-83|)/2 = (42 + 56)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 83:[41, 27] Operation: 61-34=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+27=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[41, 34, 61]. Operations so far : ['65-4=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-41=20. \nResulting numbers: [34, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |20-83|)/2 = (49 + 63)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 83:[34, 20] Operation: 61-41=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+20=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[41, 34, 61]. Operations so far : ['65-4=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41*34=1394. \nResulting numbers: [61, 1394].\nHeuristic score : (|61-83| + |1394-83|)/2 = (22 + 1311)/2 = 666.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 83:[61, 1394] Operation: 41*34=1394\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1394-61=1333. \nResulting numbers: [1333].\n1333,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[41, 34, 61]. Operations so far : ['65-4=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34*61=2074. \nResulting numbers: [41, 2074].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |2074-83|)/2 = (42 + 1991)/2 = 1016.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 83:[41, 2074] Operation: 34*61=2074\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2074-41=2033. \nResulting numbers: [2033].\n2033,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 83:[41, 34, 61]. Operations so far : ['65-4=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41*61=2501. \nResulting numbers: [34, 2501].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |2501-83|)/2 = (49 + 2418)/2 = 1233.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 83:[34, 2501] Operation: 41*61=2501\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2501-34=2467. \nResulting numbers: [2467].\n2467,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0: 83:[65, 41, 34, 4]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41-4=37. \nResulting numbers: [65, 34, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |34-83| + |37-83|)/3 = (18 + 49 + 46)/3 = 37.67\nGenerated Node #0,5: 83:[65, 34, 37] Operation: 41-4=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+37=71. \nResulting numbers: [65, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |71-83|)/2 = (18 + 12)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 83:[65, 71] Operation: 34+37=71\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+71=136. \nResulting numbers: [136].\n136,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 83:[65, 34, 37]. Operations so far : ['41-4=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+34=99. \nResulting numbers: [37, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|37-83| + |99-83|)/2 = (46 + 16)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 83:[37, 99] Operation: 65+34=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-37=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 83:[65, 34, 37]. Operations so far : ['41-4=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+37=102. \nResulting numbers: [34, 102].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |102-83|)/2 = (49 + 19)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 83:[34, 102] Operation: 65+37=102\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102-34=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 83:[65, 34, 37]. Operations so far : ['41-4=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-34=31. \nResulting numbers: [37, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|37-83| + |31-83|)/2 = (46 + 52)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,3: 83:[37, 31] Operation: 65-34=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+31=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 83:[65, 34, 37]. Operations so far : ['41-4=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-34=3. \nResulting numbers: [65, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |3-83|)/2 = (18 + 80)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,4: 83:[65, 3] Operation: 37-34=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+3=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 83:[65, 34, 37]. Operations so far : ['41-4=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-37=28. \nResulting numbers: [34, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |28-83|)/2 = (49 + 55)/2 = 52.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,5: 83:[34, 28] Operation: 65-37=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+28=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 83:[65, 34, 37]. Operations so far : ['41-4=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34*37=1258. \nResulting numbers: [65, 1258].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |1258-83|)/2 = (18 + 1175)/2 = 596.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,6: 83:[65, 1258] Operation: 34*37=1258\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1258-65=1193. \nResulting numbers: [1193].\n1193,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 83:[65, 34, 37]. Operations so far : ['41-4=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*34=2210. \nResulting numbers: [37, 2210].\nHeuristic score : (|37-83| + |2210-83|)/2 = (46 + 2127)/2 = 1086.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,7: 83:[37, 2210] Operation: 65*34=2210\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2210-37=2173. \nResulting numbers: [2173].\n2173,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 83:[65, 34, 37]. Operations so far : ['41-4=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*37=2405. \nResulting numbers: [34, 2405].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |2405-83|)/2 = (49 + 2322)/2 = 1185.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,8: 83:[34, 2405] Operation: 65*37=2405\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2405-34=2371. \nResulting numbers: [2371].\n2371,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0: 83:[65, 41, 34, 4]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34*4=136. \nResulting numbers: [65, 41, 136].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |41-83| + |136-83|)/3 = (18 + 42 + 53)/3 = 37.67\nGenerated Node #0,6: 83:[65, 41, 136] Operation: 34*4=136\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 136-41=95. \nResulting numbers: [65, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |95-83|)/2 = (18 + 12)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,0: 83:[65, 95] Operation: 136-41=95\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-65=30. \nResulting numbers: [30].\n30,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 83:[65, 41, 136]. Operations so far : ['34*4=136'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 136-65=71. \nResulting numbers: [41, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |71-83|)/2 = (42 + 12)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,1: 83:[41, 71] Operation: 136-65=71\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+71=112. \nResulting numbers: [112].\n112,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 83:[65, 41, 136]. Operations so far : ['34*4=136'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+41=106. \nResulting numbers: [136, 106].\nHeuristic score : (|136-83| + |106-83|)/2 = (53 + 23)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,2: 83:[136, 106] Operation: 65+41=106\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 136-106=30. \nResulting numbers: [30].\n30,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 83:[65, 41, 136]. Operations so far : ['34*4=136'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-41=24. \nResulting numbers: [136, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|136-83| + |24-83|)/2 = (53 + 59)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,3: 83:[136, 24] Operation: 65-41=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 136-24=112. \nResulting numbers: [112].\n112,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 83:[65, 41, 136]. Operations so far : ['34*4=136'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+136=177. \nResulting numbers: [65, 177].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |177-83|)/2 = (18 + 94)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,4: 83:[65, 177] Operation: 41+136=177\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 177-65=112. \nResulting numbers: [112].\n112,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 83:[65, 41, 136]. Operations so far : ['34*4=136'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+136=201. \nResulting numbers: [41, 201].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |201-83|)/2 = (42 + 118)/2 = 80.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,5: 83:[41, 201] Operation: 65+136=201\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 201-41=160. \nResulting numbers: [160].\n160,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 83:[65, 41, 136]. Operations so far : ['34*4=136'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*41=2665. \nResulting numbers: [136, 2665].\nHeuristic score : (|136-83| + |2665-83|)/2 = (53 + 2582)/2 = 1317.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,6: 83:[136, 2665] Operation: 65*41=2665\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2665-136=2529. \nResulting numbers: [2529].\n2529,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 83:[65, 41, 136]. Operations so far : ['34*4=136'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41*136=5576. \nResulting numbers: [65, 5576].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |5576-83|)/2 = (18 + 5493)/2 = 2755.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,7: 83:[65, 5576] Operation: 41*136=5576\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5576-65=5511. \nResulting numbers: [5511].\n5511,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 83:[65, 41, 136]. Operations so far : ['34*4=136'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*136=8840. \nResulting numbers: [41, 8840].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |8840-83|)/2 = (42 + 8757)/2 = 4399.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,8: 83:[41, 8840] Operation: 65*136=8840\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8840-41=8799. \nResulting numbers: [8799].\n8799,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0: 83:[65, 41, 34, 4]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-4=30. \nResulting numbers: [65, 41, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |41-83| + |30-83|)/3 = (18 + 42 + 53)/3 = 37.67\nGenerated Node #0,7: 83:[65, 41, 30] Operation: 34-4=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+30=71. \nResulting numbers: [65, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |71-83|)/2 = (18 + 12)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,0: 83:[65, 71] Operation: 41+30=71\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+71=136. \nResulting numbers: [136].\n136,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 83:[65, 41, 30]. Operations so far : ['34-4=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+30=95. \nResulting numbers: [41, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |95-83|)/2 = (42 + 12)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,1: 83:[41, 95] Operation: 65+30=95\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-41=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 83:[65, 41, 30]. Operations so far : ['34-4=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+41=106. \nResulting numbers: [30, 106].\nHeuristic score : (|30-83| + |106-83|)/2 = (53 + 23)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,2: 83:[30, 106] Operation: 65+41=106\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 106-30=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 83:[65, 41, 30]. Operations so far : ['34-4=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-30=35. \nResulting numbers: [41, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |35-83|)/2 = (42 + 48)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,3: 83:[41, 35] Operation: 65-30=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+35=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 83:[65, 41, 30]. Operations so far : ['34-4=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41-30=11. \nResulting numbers: [65, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |11-83|)/2 = (18 + 72)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,4: 83:[65, 11] Operation: 41-30=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+11=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 83:[65, 41, 30]. Operations so far : ['34-4=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-41=24. \nResulting numbers: [30, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|30-83| + |24-83|)/2 = (53 + 59)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,5: 83:[30, 24] Operation: 65-41=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+24=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 83:[65, 41, 30]. Operations so far : ['34-4=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41*30=1230. \nResulting numbers: [65, 1230].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |1230-83|)/2 = (18 + 1147)/2 = 582.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,6: 83:[65, 1230] Operation: 41*30=1230\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1230-65=1165. \nResulting numbers: [1165].\n1165,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 83:[65, 41, 30]. Operations so far : ['34-4=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*30=1950. \nResulting numbers: [41, 1950].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |1950-83|)/2 = (42 + 1867)/2 = 954.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,7: 83:[41, 1950] Operation: 65*30=1950\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1950-41=1909. \nResulting numbers: [1909].\n1909,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 83:[65, 41, 30]. Operations so far : ['34-4=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*41=2665. \nResulting numbers: [30, 2665].\nHeuristic score : (|30-83| + |2665-83|)/2 = (53 + 2582)/2 = 1317.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,8: 83:[30, 2665] Operation: 65*41=2665\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2665-30=2635. \nResulting numbers: [2635].\n2635,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0: 83:[65, 41, 34, 4]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+34=99. \nResulting numbers: [41, 4, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |4-83| + |99-83|)/3 = (42 + 79 + 16)/3 = 45.67\nGenerated Node #0,8: 83:[41, 4, 99] Operation: 65+34=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+4=45. \nResulting numbers: [99, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|99-83| + |45-83|)/2 = (16 + 38)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,0: 83:[99, 45] Operation: 41+4=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-45=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 45.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 83:[41, 4, 99]. Operations so far : ['65+34=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-4=95. \nResulting numbers: [41, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |95-83|)/2 = (42 + 12)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,1: 83:[41, 95] Operation: 99-4=95\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-41=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 45.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 83:[41, 4, 99]. Operations so far : ['65+34=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41-4=37. \nResulting numbers: [99, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|99-83| + |37-83|)/2 = (16 + 46)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,2: 83:[99, 37] Operation: 41-4=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-37=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 45.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 83:[41, 4, 99]. Operations so far : ['65+34=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+99=103. \nResulting numbers: [41, 103].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |103-83|)/2 = (42 + 20)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,3: 83:[41, 103] Operation: 4+99=103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 103-41=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 45.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 83:[41, 4, 99]. Operations so far : ['65+34=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41*4=164. \nResulting numbers: [99, 164].\nHeuristic score : (|99-83| + |164-83|)/2 = (16 + 81)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,4: 83:[99, 164] Operation: 41*4=164\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 164-99=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 45.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 83:[41, 4, 99]. Operations so far : ['65+34=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-41=58. \nResulting numbers: [4, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|4-83| + |58-83|)/2 = (79 + 25)/2 = 52.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,5: 83:[4, 58] Operation: 99-41=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+58=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 45.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 83:[41, 4, 99]. Operations so far : ['65+34=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+99=140. \nResulting numbers: [4, 140].\nHeuristic score : (|4-83| + |140-83|)/2 = (79 + 57)/2 = 68.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,6: 83:[4, 140] Operation: 41+99=140\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 140/4=35. \nResulting numbers: [35].\n35,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 45.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 83:[41, 4, 99]. Operations so far : ['65+34=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*99=396. \nResulting numbers: [41, 396].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |396-83|)/2 = (42 + 313)/2 = 177.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,7: 83:[41, 396] Operation: 4*99=396\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 396-41=355. \nResulting numbers: [355].\n355,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 45.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 83:[41, 4, 99]. Operations so far : ['65+34=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41*99=4059. \nResulting numbers: [4, 4059].\nHeuristic score : (|4-83| + |4059-83|)/2 = (79 + 3976)/2 = 2027.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,8: 83:[4, 4059] Operation: 41*99=4059\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4059-4=4055. \nResulting numbers: [4055].\n4055,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0: 83:[65, 41, 34, 4]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41*4=164. \nResulting numbers: [65, 34, 164].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |34-83| + |164-83|)/3 = (18 + 49 + 81)/3 = 49.33\nGenerated Node #0,9: 83:[65, 34, 164] Operation: 41*4=164\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 164-65=99. \nResulting numbers: [34, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |99-83|)/2 = (49 + 16)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,0: 83:[34, 99] Operation: 164-65=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-34=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 49.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 83:[65, 34, 164]. Operations so far : ['41*4=164'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 164-34=130. \nResulting numbers: [65, 130].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |130-83|)/2 = (18 + 47)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,1: 83:[65, 130] Operation: 164-34=130\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 130-65=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 49.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 83:[65, 34, 164]. Operations so far : ['41*4=164'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+34=99. \nResulting numbers: [164, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|164-83| + |99-83|)/2 = (81 + 16)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,2: 83:[164, 99] Operation: 65+34=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 164-99=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 49.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 83:[65, 34, 164]. Operations so far : ['41*4=164'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-34=31. \nResulting numbers: [164, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|164-83| + |31-83|)/2 = (81 + 52)/2 = 66.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,3: 83:[164, 31] Operation: 65-34=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 164-31=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 49.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 83:[65, 34, 164]. Operations so far : ['41*4=164'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+164=198. \nResulting numbers: [65, 198].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |198-83|)/2 = (18 + 115)/2 = 66.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,4: 83:[65, 198] Operation: 34+164=198\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 198-65=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 49.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 83:[65, 34, 164]. Operations so far : ['41*4=164'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+164=229. \nResulting numbers: [34, 229].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |229-83|)/2 = (49 + 146)/2 = 97.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,5: 83:[34, 229] Operation: 65+164=229\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 229-34=195. \nResulting numbers: [195].\n195,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 49.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 83:[65, 34, 164]. Operations so far : ['41*4=164'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*34=2210. \nResulting numbers: [164, 2210].\nHeuristic score : (|164-83| + |2210-83|)/2 = (81 + 2127)/2 = 1104.00\nGenerated Node #0,9,6: 83:[164, 2210] Operation: 65*34=2210\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2210-164=2046. \nResulting numbers: [2046].\n2046,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 49.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 83:[65, 34, 164]. Operations so far : ['41*4=164'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34*164=5576. \nResulting numbers: [65, 5576].\nHeuristic score : (|65-83| + |5576-83|)/2 = (18 + 5493)/2 = 2755.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,7: 83:[65, 5576] Operation: 34*164=5576\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5576-65=5511. \nResulting numbers: [5511].\n5511,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 49.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,9: 83:[65, 34, 164]. Operations so far : ['41*4=164'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65*164=10660. \nResulting numbers: [34, 10660].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |10660-83|)/2 = (49 + 10577)/2 = 5313.00\nGenerated Node #0,9,8: 83:[34, 10660] Operation: 65*164=10660\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 10660-34=10626. \nResulting numbers: [10626].\n10626,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0: 83:[65, 41, 34, 4]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 11th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+41=106. \nResulting numbers: [34, 4, 106].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |4-83| + |106-83|)/3 = (49 + 79 + 23)/3 = 50.33\nGenerated Node #0,10: 83:[34, 4, 106] Operation: 65+41=106\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+4=38. \nResulting numbers: [106, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|106-83| + |38-83|)/2 = (23 + 45)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,10,0: 83:[106, 38] Operation: 34+4=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 106-38=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 50.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 83:[34, 4, 106]. Operations so far : ['65+41=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 106-4=102. \nResulting numbers: [34, 102].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |102-83|)/2 = (49 + 19)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,10,1: 83:[34, 102] Operation: 106-4=102\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102-34=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 50.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 83:[34, 4, 106]. Operations so far : ['65+41=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34*4=136. \nResulting numbers: [106, 136].\nHeuristic score : (|106-83| + |136-83|)/2 = (23 + 53)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,10,2: 83:[106, 136] Operation: 34*4=136\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 136-106=30. \nResulting numbers: [30].\n30,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 50.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 83:[34, 4, 106]. Operations so far : ['65+41=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-4=30. \nResulting numbers: [106, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|106-83| + |30-83|)/2 = (23 + 53)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,10,3: 83:[106, 30] Operation: 34-4=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 106-30=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 50.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 83:[34, 4, 106]. Operations so far : ['65+41=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+106=110. \nResulting numbers: [34, 110].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |110-83|)/2 = (49 + 27)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,10,4: 83:[34, 110] Operation: 4+106=110\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 110-34=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 50.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 83:[34, 4, 106]. Operations so far : ['65+41=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 106-34=72. \nResulting numbers: [4, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|4-83| + |72-83|)/2 = (79 + 11)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,10,5: 83:[4, 72] Operation: 106-34=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+72=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 50.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 83:[34, 4, 106]. Operations so far : ['65+41=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+106=140. \nResulting numbers: [4, 140].\nHeuristic score : (|4-83| + |140-83|)/2 = (79 + 57)/2 = 68.00\nGenerated Node #0,10,6: 83:[4, 140] Operation: 34+106=140\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 140/4=35. \nResulting numbers: [35].\n35,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 50.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 83:[34, 4, 106]. Operations so far : ['65+41=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*106=424. \nResulting numbers: [34, 424].\nHeuristic score : (|34-83| + |424-83|)/2 = (49 + 341)/2 = 195.00\nGenerated Node #0,10,7: 83:[34, 424] Operation: 4*106=424\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 424-34=390. \nResulting numbers: [390].\n390,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,10 with lowest heuristic value 50.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,10: 83:[34, 4, 106]. Operations so far : ['65+41=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34*106=3604. \nResulting numbers: [4, 3604].\nHeuristic score : (|4-83| + |3604-83|)/2 = (79 + 3521)/2 = 1800.00\nGenerated Node #0,10,8: 83:[4, 3604] Operation: 34*106=3604\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3604/4=901. \nResulting numbers: [901].\n901,83 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0: 83:[65, 41, 34, 4]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 12th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-34=31. \nResulting numbers: [41, 4, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |4-83| + |31-83|)/3 = (42 + 79 + 52)/3 = 57.67\nGenerated Node #0,11: 83:[41, 4, 31] Operation: 65-34=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*31=124. \nResulting numbers: [41, 124].\nHeuristic score : (|41-83| + |124-83|)/2 = (42 + 41)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,11,0: 83:[41, 124] Operation: 4*31=124\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,11,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 124-41=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,83 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['65-34=31', '4*31=124', '124-41=83']\nRESULT: 83\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 23,577 |
[
89,
45,
76,
2
]
| 76 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [89, 45, 76, 2] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 76. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [89, 45, 76, 2]. Our goal is to produce 76. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 76:[89, 45, 76, 2]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45*2=90. \nResulting numbers: [89, 76, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|89-76| + |76-76| + |90-76|)/3 = (13 + 0 + 14)/3 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 76:[89, 76, 90] Operation: 45*2=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-89=1. \nResulting numbers: [76, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|76-76| + |1-76|)/2 = (0 + 75)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 76:[76, 1] Operation: 90-89=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*1=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,76 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['45*2=90', '90-89=1', '76*1=76']\nRESULT: 76\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 428 |
[
8,
75,
25,
6
]
| 50 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [8, 75, 25, 6] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 50. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [8, 75, 25, 6]. Our goal is to produce 50. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 50:[8, 75, 25, 6]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*6=48. \nResulting numbers: [75, 25, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|75-50| + |25-50| + |48-50|)/3 = (25 + 25 + 2)/3 = 17.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 50:[75, 25, 48] Operation: 8*6=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-8=67. \nResulting numbers: [25, 6, 67].\nHeuristic score : (|25-50| + |6-50| + |67-50|)/3 = (25 + 44 + 17)/3 = 28.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 50:[25, 6, 67] Operation: 75-8=67\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+6=14. \nResulting numbers: [75, 25, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|75-50| + |25-50| + |14-50|)/3 = (25 + 25 + 36)/3 = 28.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 50:[75, 25, 14] Operation: 8+6=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-25=50. \nResulting numbers: [8, 6, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|8-50| + |6-50| + |50-50|)/3 = (42 + 44 + 0)/3 = 28.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 50:[8, 6, 50] Operation: 75-25=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+25=33. \nResulting numbers: [75, 6, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|75-50| + |6-50| + |33-50|)/3 = (25 + 44 + 17)/3 = 28.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 50:[75, 6, 33] Operation: 8+25=33\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 50:[75, 25, 48]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-48=27. \nResulting numbers: [25, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|25-50| + |27-50|)/2 = (25 + 23)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 50:[25, 27] Operation: 75-48=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75/25=3. \nResulting numbers: [48, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|48-50| + |3-50|)/2 = (2 + 47)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 50:[48, 3] Operation: 75/25=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-25=50. \nResulting numbers: [48, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|48-50| + |50-50|)/2 = (2 + 0)/2 = 1.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 50:[48, 50] Operation: 75-25=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+48=73. \nResulting numbers: [75, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|75-50| + |73-50|)/2 = (25 + 23)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 50:[75, 73] Operation: 25+48=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+25=100. \nResulting numbers: [48, 100].\nHeuristic score : (|48-50| + |100-50|)/2 = (2 + 50)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 50:[48, 100] Operation: 75+25=100\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 50:[75, 25, 14]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-14=61. \nResulting numbers: [25, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|25-50| + |61-50|)/2 = (25 + 11)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 50:[25, 61] Operation: 75-14=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+14=89. \nResulting numbers: [25, 89].\nHeuristic score : (|25-50| + |89-50|)/2 = (25 + 39)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 50:[25, 89] Operation: 75+14=89\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+14=39. \nResulting numbers: [75, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|75-50| + |39-50|)/2 = (25 + 11)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 50:[75, 39] Operation: 25+14=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25-14=11. \nResulting numbers: [75, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|75-50| + |11-50|)/2 = (25 + 39)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 50:[75, 11] Operation: 25-14=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-25=50. \nResulting numbers: [14, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|14-50| + |50-50|)/2 = (36 + 0)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 50:[14, 50] Operation: 75-25=50\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 50:[75, 6, 33]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-6=27. \nResulting numbers: [75, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|75-50| + |27-50|)/2 = (25 + 23)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 50:[75, 27] Operation: 33-6=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-6=69. \nResulting numbers: [33, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|33-50| + |69-50|)/2 = (17 + 19)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 50:[33, 69] Operation: 75-6=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+6=81. \nResulting numbers: [33, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|33-50| + |81-50|)/2 = (17 + 31)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 50:[33, 81] Operation: 75+6=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+33=39. \nResulting numbers: [75, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|75-50| + |39-50|)/2 = (25 + 11)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 50:[75, 39] Operation: 6+33=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-33=42. \nResulting numbers: [6, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|6-50| + |42-50|)/2 = (44 + 8)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 50:[6, 42] Operation: 75-33=42\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 50:[25, 6, 67]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-25=42. \nResulting numbers: [6, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|6-50| + |42-50|)/2 = (44 + 8)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 50:[6, 42] Operation: 67-25=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-6=61. \nResulting numbers: [25, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|25-50| + |61-50|)/2 = (25 + 11)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 50:[25, 61] Operation: 67-6=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25-6=19. \nResulting numbers: [67, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|67-50| + |19-50|)/2 = (17 + 31)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 50:[67, 19] Operation: 25-6=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+6=31. \nResulting numbers: [67, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|67-50| + |31-50|)/2 = (17 + 19)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 50:[67, 31] Operation: 25+6=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+67=73. \nResulting numbers: [25, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|25-50| + |73-50|)/2 = (25 + 23)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 50:[25, 73] Operation: 6+67=73\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 50:[8, 6, 50]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+6=14. \nResulting numbers: [50, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|50-50| + |14-50|)/2 = (0 + 36)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 50:[50, 14] Operation: 8+6=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8-6=2. \nResulting numbers: [50, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|50-50| + |2-50|)/2 = (0 + 48)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 50:[50, 2] Operation: 8-6=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*6=48. \nResulting numbers: [50, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|50-50| + |48-50|)/2 = (0 + 2)/2 = 1.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 50:[50, 48] Operation: 8*6=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+50=56. \nResulting numbers: [8, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|8-50| + |56-50|)/2 = (42 + 6)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 50:[8, 56] Operation: 6+50=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-6=44. \nResulting numbers: [8, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|8-50| + |44-50|)/2 = (42 + 6)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 50:[8, 44] Operation: 50-6=44\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 1.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 50:[48, 50]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75-25=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+50=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-48=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48*50=2400. \nResulting numbers: [2400].\n2400,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 1.0\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 50:[50, 48]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8*6=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-48=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+48=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*48=2400. \nResulting numbers: [2400].\n2400,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 50:[25, 61]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '75-14=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-25=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+61=86. \nResulting numbers: [86].\n86,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*61=1525. \nResulting numbers: [1525].\n1525,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 50:[75, 39]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '25+14=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-39=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*39=2925. \nResulting numbers: [2925].\n2925,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+39=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 50:[75, 39]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '6+33=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+39=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*39=2925. \nResulting numbers: [2925].\n2925,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-39=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,2,0,0: 50:[36]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '75-14=61', '61-25=36'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,2,2,0: 50:[36]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '25+14=39', '75-39=36'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,4,3,2: 50:[36]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '6+33=39', '75-39=36'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 50:[14, 50]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '75-25=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+50=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14*50=700. \nResulting numbers: [700].\n700,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-14=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 50:[33, 69]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75-6=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33*69=2277. \nResulting numbers: [2277].\n2277,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-33=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+69=102. \nResulting numbers: [102].\n102,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,2,4,0: 50:[64]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '75-25=50', '14+50=64'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,2,4,2: 50:[36]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '75-25=50', '50-14=36'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,4,1,1: 50:[36]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75-6=69', '69-33=36'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 50:[50, 14]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8+6=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+14=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*14=700. \nResulting numbers: [700].\n700,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-14=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 50:[25, 61]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '67-6=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-25=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+61=86. \nResulting numbers: [86].\n86,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*61=1525. \nResulting numbers: [1525].\n1525,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,3,0,0: 50:[64]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8+6=14', '50+14=64'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,3,0,2: 50:[36]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8+6=14', '50-14=36'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,1,1,0: 50:[36]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '67-6=61', '61-25=36'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 50:[67, 31]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '25+6=31'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67+31=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67*31=2077. \nResulting numbers: [2077].\n2077,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-31=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 50:[8, 56]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '6+50=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*56=448. \nResulting numbers: [448].\n448,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+56=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56/8=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-8=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,3,3,3: 50:[48]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '6+50=56', '56-8=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,1,3,2: 50:[36]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '25+6=31', '67-31=36'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 50:[64]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '6+50=56', '8+56=64'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 50:[75, 27]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '33-6=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*27=2025. \nResulting numbers: [2025].\n2025,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+27=102. \nResulting numbers: [102].\n102,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-27=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 50:[8, 44]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '50-6=44'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+44=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-8=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*44=352. \nResulting numbers: [352].\n352,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,4,0,2: 50:[48]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '33-6=27', '75-27=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,3,4,0: 50:[52]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '50-6=44', '8+44=52'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,3,4,1: 50:[36]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '50-6=44', '44-8=36'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 50:[75, 73]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '25+48=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+73=148. \nResulting numbers: [148].\n148,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-73=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*73=5475. \nResulting numbers: [5475].\n5475,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 50:[33, 81]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75+6=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-33=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33*81=2673. \nResulting numbers: [2673].\n2673,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+81=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,4,2,0: 50:[48]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75+6=81', '81-33=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 50:[25, 73]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '6+67=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*73=1825. \nResulting numbers: [1825].\n1825,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-25=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+73=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 50:[50, 2]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8-6=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*2=100. \nResulting numbers: [100].\n100,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50/2=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+2=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-2=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 50:[67, 19]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '25-6=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-19=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67+19=86. \nResulting numbers: [86].\n86,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67*19=1273. \nResulting numbers: [1273].\n1273,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 50:[25, 27]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75-48=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27-25=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+27=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*27=675. \nResulting numbers: [675].\n675,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,1,4,1: 50:[48]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '6+67=73', '73-25=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,3,1,2: 50:[52]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8-6=2', '50+2=52'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,3,1,3: 50:[48]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8-6=2', '50-2=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,1,2,0: 50:[48]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '25-6=19', '67-19=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,0,0,1: 50:[52]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75-48=27', '25+27=52'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 24.5\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 50:[48, 3]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75/25=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48*3=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-3=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48/3=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+3=51. \nResulting numbers: [51].\n51,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 25\nCurrent State #0,3,1,1: 50:[25]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8-6=2', '50/2=25'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 50:[6, 42]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75-33=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-6=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42/6=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6*42=252. \nResulting numbers: [252].\n252,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+42=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 50:[48, 100]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75+25=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-48=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+100=148. \nResulting numbers: [148].\n148,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48*100=4800. \nResulting numbers: [4800].\n4800,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 50:[6, 42]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '67-25=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-6=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+42=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42/6=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6*42=252. \nResulting numbers: [252].\n252,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 1\nCurrent State #0,0,1,3: 50:[51]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75/25=3', '48+3=51'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,0,4,0: 50:[52]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75+25=100', '100-48=52'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 50:[48]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '67-25=42', '6+42=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,4,4,3: 50:[48]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75-33=42', '6+42=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 5\nCurrent State #0,0,1,1: 50:[45]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75/25=3', '48-3=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,1,0,0: 50:[36]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '67-25=42', '42-6=36'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,4,4,0: 50:[36]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75-33=42', '42-6=36'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 32.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 50:[75, 11]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '25-14=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*11=825. \nResulting numbers: [825].\n825,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-11=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+11=86. \nResulting numbers: [86].\n86,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 32.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 50:[25, 89]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '75+14=89'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*89=2225. \nResulting numbers: [2225].\n2225,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+89=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,50 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-25=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,50 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,0,1,2: 50:[16]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75/25=3', '48/3=16'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 50:[64]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '25-14=11', '75-11=64'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,2,1,2: 50:[64]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '75+14=89', '89-25=64'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 36\nCurrent State #0,2,0,1: 50:[86]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '75-14=61', '25+61=86'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 36\nCurrent State #0,1,2,1: 50:[86]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '25-6=19', '67+19=86'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 36\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 50:[86]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '25-14=11', '75+11=86'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 36\nCurrent State #0,1,1,1: 50:[86]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '67-6=61', '25+61=86'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 43\nCurrent State #0,1,0,2: 50:[7]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '67-25=42', '42/6=7'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 43\nCurrent State #0,4,4,1: 50:[7]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75-33=42', '42/6=7'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 43\nCurrent State #0,3,3,2: 50:[7]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '6+50=56', '56/8=7'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 48\nCurrent State #0,3,2,1: 50:[98]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8*6=48', '50+48=98'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 48\nCurrent State #0,3,2,0: 50:[2]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8*6=48', '50-48=2'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 48\nCurrent State #0,0,2,1: 50:[2]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75-25=50', '50-48=2'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 48\nCurrent State #0,0,2,0: 50:[98]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75-25=50', '48+50=98'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 48\nCurrent State #0,0,0,0: 50:[2]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75-48=27', '27-25=2'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 48\nCurrent State #0,1,4,2: 50:[98]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '6+67=73', '25+73=98'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 48\nCurrent State #0,0,3,1: 50:[2]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '25+48=73', '75-73=2'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 48\nCurrent State #0,1,3,0: 50:[98]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '25+6=31', '67+31=98'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 50\nCurrent State #0,3,1,0: 50:[100]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8-6=2', '50*2=100'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 52\nCurrent State #0,4,1,2: 50:[102]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75-6=69', '33+69=102'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 52\nCurrent State #0,4,0,1: 50:[102]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '33-6=27', '75+27=102'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 64\nCurrent State #0,2,2,2: 50:[114]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '25+14=39', '75+39=114'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 64\nCurrent State #0,2,1,1: 50:[114]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '75+14=89', '25+89=114'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 64\nCurrent State #0,4,2,2: 50:[114]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75+6=81', '33+81=114'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 64\nCurrent State #0,4,3,0: 50:[114]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '6+33=39', '75+39=114'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 94\nCurrent State #0,0,1,0: 50:[144]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75/25=3', '48*3=144'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 98\nCurrent State #0,0,3,0: 50:[148]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '25+48=73', '75+73=148'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 98\nCurrent State #0,0,4,1: 50:[148]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75+25=100', '48+100=148'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 202\nCurrent State #0,1,0,3: 50:[252]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '67-25=42', '6*42=252'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 202\nCurrent State #0,4,4,2: 50:[252]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75-33=42', '6*42=252'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 302\nCurrent State #0,3,4,2: 50:[352]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '50-6=44', '8*44=352'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 398\nCurrent State #0,3,3,0: 50:[448]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '6+50=56', '8*56=448'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 625\nCurrent State #0,0,0,2: 50:[675]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75-48=27', '25*27=675'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 650\nCurrent State #0,3,0,1: 50:[700]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8+6=14', '50*14=700'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 650\nCurrent State #0,2,4,1: 50:[700]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '75-25=50', '14*50=700'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 775\nCurrent State #0,2,3,0: 50:[825]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '25-14=11', '75*11=825'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 1223\nCurrent State #0,1,2,2: 50:[1273]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '25-6=19', '67*19=1273'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 1475\nCurrent State #0,2,0,2: 50:[1525]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '75-14=61', '25*61=1525'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 1475\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 50:[1525]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '67-6=61', '25*61=1525'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 1775\nCurrent State #0,1,4,0: 50:[1825]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '6+67=73', '25*73=1825'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 1975\nCurrent State #0,4,0,0: 50:[2025]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '33-6=27', '75*27=2025'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 2027\nCurrent State #0,1,3,1: 50:[2077]. Operations so far : ['75-8=67', '25+6=31', '67*31=2077'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 2175\nCurrent State #0,2,1,0: 50:[2225]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '75+14=89', '25*89=2225'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 2227\nCurrent State #0,4,1,0: 50:[2277]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75-6=69', '33*69=2277'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 2350\nCurrent State #0,3,2,2: 50:[2400]. Operations so far : ['75-25=50', '8*6=48', '50*48=2400'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 2350\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 50:[2400]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75-25=50', '48*50=2400'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 2623\nCurrent State #0,4,2,1: 50:[2673]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '75+6=81', '33*81=2673'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 2875\nCurrent State #0,4,3,1: 50:[2925]. Operations so far : ['8+25=33', '6+33=39', '75*39=2925'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 2875\nCurrent State #0,2,2,1: 50:[2925]. Operations so far : ['8+6=14', '25+14=39', '75*39=2925'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 4750\nCurrent State #0,0,4,2: 50:[4800]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '75+25=100', '48*100=4800'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 5425\nCurrent State #0,0,3,2: 50:[5475]. Operations so far : ['8*6=48', '25+48=73', '75*73=5475'].\n\n```\nSOLUTION: NO\nOPERATIONS: []\nRESULT: None\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 16,506 |
[
27,
81,
30,
30
]
| 71 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [27, 81, 30, 30] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 71. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [27, 81, 30, 30]. Our goal is to produce 71. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 71:[27, 81, 30, 30]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-30=51. \nResulting numbers: [27, 30, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|27-71| + |30-71| + |51-71|)/3 = (44 + 41 + 20)/3 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 71:[27, 30, 51] Operation: 81-30=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-27=54. \nResulting numbers: [30, 30, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|30-71| + |30-71| + |54-71|)/3 = (41 + 41 + 17)/3 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 71:[30, 30, 54] Operation: 81-27=54\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+30=57. \nResulting numbers: [81, 30, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|81-71| + |30-71| + |57-71|)/3 = (10 + 41 + 14)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 71:[81, 30, 57] Operation: 27+30=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+30=60. \nResulting numbers: [27, 81, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|27-71| + |81-71| + |60-71|)/3 = (44 + 10 + 11)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 71:[27, 81, 60] Operation: 30+30=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+30=57. \nResulting numbers: [81, 30, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|81-71| + |30-71| + |57-71|)/3 = (10 + 41 + 14)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 71:[81, 30, 57] Operation: 27+30=57\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 71:[81, 30, 57]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+30=111. \nResulting numbers: [57, 111].\nHeuristic score : (|57-71| + |111-71|)/2 = (14 + 40)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 71:[57, 111] Operation: 81+30=111\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-30=27. \nResulting numbers: [81, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|81-71| + |27-71|)/2 = (10 + 44)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 71:[81, 27] Operation: 57-30=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+57=87. \nResulting numbers: [81, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|81-71| + |87-71|)/2 = (10 + 16)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 71:[81, 87] Operation: 30+57=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-30=51. \nResulting numbers: [57, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|57-71| + |51-71|)/2 = (14 + 20)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 71:[57, 51] Operation: 81-30=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-57=24. \nResulting numbers: [30, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|30-71| + |24-71|)/2 = (41 + 47)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 71:[30, 24] Operation: 81-57=24\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 71:[81, 30, 57]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+57=87. \nResulting numbers: [81, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|81-71| + |87-71|)/2 = (10 + 16)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 71:[81, 87] Operation: 30+57=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-30=51. \nResulting numbers: [57, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|57-71| + |51-71|)/2 = (14 + 20)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 71:[57, 51] Operation: 81-30=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-30=27. \nResulting numbers: [81, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|81-71| + |27-71|)/2 = (10 + 44)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 71:[81, 27] Operation: 57-30=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+30=111. \nResulting numbers: [57, 111].\nHeuristic score : (|57-71| + |111-71|)/2 = (14 + 40)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 71:[57, 111] Operation: 81+30=111\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-57=24. \nResulting numbers: [30, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|30-71| + |24-71|)/2 = (41 + 47)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 71:[30, 24] Operation: 81-57=24\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 71:[27, 81, 60]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-27=54. \nResulting numbers: [60, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|60-71| + |54-71|)/2 = (11 + 17)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 71:[60, 54] Operation: 81-27=54\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-27=33. \nResulting numbers: [81, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|81-71| + |33-71|)/2 = (10 + 38)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 71:[81, 33] Operation: 60-27=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81/27=3. \nResulting numbers: [60, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|60-71| + |3-71|)/2 = (11 + 68)/2 = 39.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 71:[60, 3] Operation: 81/27=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+60=87. \nResulting numbers: [81, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|81-71| + |87-71|)/2 = (10 + 16)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 71:[81, 87] Operation: 27+60=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+81=108. \nResulting numbers: [60, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|60-71| + |108-71|)/2 = (11 + 37)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 71:[60, 108] Operation: 27+81=108\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 71:[30, 30, 54]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-30=0. \nResulting numbers: [54, 0].\nHeuristic score : (|54-71| + |0-71|)/2 = (17 + 71)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 71:[54, 0] Operation: 30-30=0\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+54=84. \nResulting numbers: [30, 84].\nHeuristic score : (|30-71| + |84-71|)/2 = (41 + 13)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 71:[30, 84] Operation: 30+54=84\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+54=84. \nResulting numbers: [30, 84].\nHeuristic score : (|30-71| + |84-71|)/2 = (41 + 13)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 71:[30, 84] Operation: 30+54=84\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+30=60. \nResulting numbers: [54, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|54-71| + |60-71|)/2 = (17 + 11)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 71:[54, 60] Operation: 30+30=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30/30=1. \nResulting numbers: [54, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|54-71| + |1-71|)/2 = (17 + 70)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 71:[54, 1] Operation: 30/30=1\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 71:[27, 30, 51]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+51=78. \nResulting numbers: [30, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|30-71| + |78-71|)/2 = (41 + 7)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 71:[30, 78] Operation: 27+51=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+30=57. \nResulting numbers: [51, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|51-71| + |57-71|)/2 = (20 + 14)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 71:[51, 57] Operation: 27+30=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-27=3. \nResulting numbers: [51, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|51-71| + |3-71|)/2 = (20 + 68)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 71:[51, 3] Operation: 30-27=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-27=24. \nResulting numbers: [30, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|30-71| + |24-71|)/2 = (41 + 47)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 71:[30, 24] Operation: 51-27=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+51=81. \nResulting numbers: [27, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|27-71| + |81-71|)/2 = (44 + 10)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 71:[27, 81] Operation: 30+51=81\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 71:[81, 87]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '30+57=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*87=7047. \nResulting numbers: [7047].\n7047,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-81=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+87=168. \nResulting numbers: [168].\n168,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 71:[81, 87]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '30+57=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-81=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*87=7047. \nResulting numbers: [7047].\n7047,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+87=168. \nResulting numbers: [168].\n168,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 71:[81, 87]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '27+60=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+87=168. \nResulting numbers: [168].\n168,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*87=7047. \nResulting numbers: [7047].\n7047,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-81=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 71:[60, 54]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '81-27=54'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+54=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-54=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*54=3240. \nResulting numbers: [3240].\n3240,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 71:[54, 60]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30+30=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54*60=3240. \nResulting numbers: [3240].\n3240,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-54=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+60=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 71:[57, 51]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-30=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*51=2907. \nResulting numbers: [2907].\n2907,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-51=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+51=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 71:[57, 51]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-30=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+51=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*51=2907. \nResulting numbers: [2907].\n2907,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-51=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 71:[51, 57]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '27+30=57'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-51=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+57=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*57=2907. \nResulting numbers: [2907].\n2907,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 71:[60, 108]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '27+81=108'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*108=6480. \nResulting numbers: [6480].\n6480,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+108=168. \nResulting numbers: [168].\n168,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-60=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 71:[81, 33]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '60-27=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+33=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*33=2673. \nResulting numbers: [2673].\n2673,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-33=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 23\nCurrent State #0,3,4,2: 71:[48]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '27+81=108', '108-60=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 23\nCurrent State #0,3,1,2: 71:[48]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '60-27=33', '81-33=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 71:[30, 78]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '27+51=78'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+78=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-30=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*78=2340. \nResulting numbers: [2340].\n2340,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 71:[27, 81]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '30+51=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81/27=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27*81=2187. \nResulting numbers: [2187].\n2187,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-27=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+81=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 71:[57, 111]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81+30=111'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+111=168. \nResulting numbers: [168].\n168,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 111-57=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*111=6327. \nResulting numbers: [6327].\n6327,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,0,4,2: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '30+51=81', '81-27=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,2,0,1: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81+30=111', '111-57=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 23\nCurrent State #0,0,0,1: 71:[48]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '27+51=78', '78-30=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 71:[57, 111]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81+30=111'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+111=168. \nResulting numbers: [168].\n168,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*111=6327. \nResulting numbers: [6327].\n6327,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 111-57=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 71:[30, 84]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30+54=84'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+84=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*84=2520. \nResulting numbers: [2520].\n2520,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-30=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,4,3,2: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81+30=111', '111-57=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,1,2,2: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30+54=84', '84-30=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 71:[81, 27]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '57-30=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*27=2187. \nResulting numbers: [2187].\n2187,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81/27=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+27=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-27=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 71:[30, 84]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30+54=84'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*84=2520. \nResulting numbers: [2520].\n2520,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+84=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-30=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 71:[81, 27]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '57-30=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81/27=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+27=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*27=2187. \nResulting numbers: [2187].\n2187,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-27=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,2,1,3: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '57-30=27', '81-27=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30+54=84', '84-30=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,4,2,3: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '57-30=27', '81-27=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,2,1,2: 71:[108]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '57-30=27', '81+27=108'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,4,2,1: 71:[108]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '57-30=27', '81+27=108'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,4,1,2: 71:[108]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-30=51', '57+51=108'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,0,4,3: 71:[108]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '30+51=81', '27+81=108'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,0,0,0: 71:[108]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '27+51=78', '30+78=108'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,0,1,1: 71:[108]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '27+30=57', '51+57=108'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,2,3,0: 71:[108]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-30=51', '57+51=108'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 39.5\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 71:[60, 3]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '81/27=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-3=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*3=180. \nResulting numbers: [180].\n180,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+3=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/3=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 43\nCurrent State #0,3,0,0: 71:[114]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '81-27=54', '60+54=114'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 43\nCurrent State #0,1,1,1: 71:[114]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30+54=84', '30+84=114'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 43\nCurrent State #0,1,3,2: 71:[114]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30+30=60', '54+60=114'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 43\nCurrent State #0,1,2,0: 71:[114]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30+54=84', '30+84=114'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 8\nCurrent State #0,3,2,2: 71:[63]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '81/27=3', '60+3=63'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,3,2,0: 71:[57]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '81/27=3', '60-3=57'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 43\nCurrent State #0,3,1,0: 71:[114]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '60-27=33', '81+33=114'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 43.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 71:[54, 1]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30/30=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54*1=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54/1=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+1=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-1=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 44.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 71:[30, 24]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-57=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*24=720. \nResulting numbers: [720].\n720,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+24=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-24=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,1,4,2: 71:[55]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30/30=1', '54+1=55'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,1,4,0: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30/30=1', '54*1=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,1,4,1: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30/30=1', '54/1=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,2,4,1: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-57=24', '30+24=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,1,4,3: 71:[53]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30/30=1', '54-1=53'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 44.0\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 71:[30, 24]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '51-27=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-24=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+24=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*24=720. \nResulting numbers: [720].\n720,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 44.0\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 71:[30, 24]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-57=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*24=720. \nResulting numbers: [720].\n720,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-24=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+24=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 44.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 71:[54, 0]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30-30=0'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54*0=0. \nResulting numbers: [0].\n0,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-0=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54+0=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 44.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 71:[51, 3]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '30-27=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-3=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51/3=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*3=153. \nResulting numbers: [153].\n153,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+3=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 51\nCurrent State #0,3,2,3: 71:[20]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '81/27=3', '60/3=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,0,3,1: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '51-27=24', '30+24=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,0,2,3: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '30-27=3', '51+3=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,4,4,2: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-57=24', '30+24=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30-30=0', '54-0=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,1,0,2: 71:[54]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30-30=0', '54+0=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 23\nCurrent State #0,0,2,0: 71:[48]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '30-27=3', '51-3=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 54\nCurrent State #0,0,2,1: 71:[17]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '30-27=3', '51/3=17'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,3,3,2: 71:[6]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '27+60=87', '87-81=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,4,0,0: 71:[6]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '30+57=87', '87-81=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,2,2,1: 71:[6]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '30+57=87', '87-81=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,1,3,1: 71:[6]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30+30=60', '60-54=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,4,4,1: 71:[6]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-57=24', '30-24=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,0,3,0: 71:[6]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '51-27=24', '30-24=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,2,4,2: 71:[6]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-57=24', '30-24=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,3,0,1: 71:[6]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '81-27=54', '60-54=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,0,1,0: 71:[6]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '27+30=57', '57-51=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 71:[6]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-30=51', '57-51=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,4,1,1: 71:[6]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-30=51', '57-51=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 68\nCurrent State #0,4,2,0: 71:[3]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '57-30=27', '81/27=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 68\nCurrent State #0,0,4,0: 71:[3]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '30+51=81', '81/27=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 68\nCurrent State #0,2,1,1: 71:[3]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '57-30=27', '81/27=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 71\nCurrent State #0,1,0,0: 71:[0]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30-30=0', '54*0=0'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 82\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 71:[153]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '30-27=3', '51*3=153'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 97\nCurrent State #0,3,3,0: 71:[168]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '27+60=87', '81+87=168'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 97\nCurrent State #0,4,0,2: 71:[168]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '30+57=87', '81+87=168'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 97\nCurrent State #0,2,2,2: 71:[168]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '30+57=87', '81+87=168'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 97\nCurrent State #0,4,3,0: 71:[168]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81+30=111', '57+111=168'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 97\nCurrent State #0,2,0,0: 71:[168]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81+30=111', '57+111=168'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 97\nCurrent State #0,3,4,1: 71:[168]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '27+81=108', '60+108=168'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 109\nCurrent State #0,3,2,1: 71:[180]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '81/27=3', '60*3=180'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 649\nCurrent State #0,4,4,0: 71:[720]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-57=24', '30*24=720'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 649\nCurrent State #0,0,3,2: 71:[720]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '51-27=24', '30*24=720'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 649\nCurrent State #0,2,4,0: 71:[720]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-57=24', '30*24=720'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 2116\nCurrent State #0,0,4,1: 71:[2187]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '30+51=81', '27*81=2187'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 2116\nCurrent State #0,2,1,0: 71:[2187]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '57-30=27', '81*27=2187'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 2116\nCurrent State #0,4,2,2: 71:[2187]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '57-30=27', '81*27=2187'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 2269\nCurrent State #0,0,0,2: 71:[2340]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '27+51=78', '30*78=2340'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 2449\nCurrent State #0,1,2,1: 71:[2520]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30+54=84', '30*84=2520'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 2449\nCurrent State #0,1,1,0: 71:[2520]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30+54=84', '30*84=2520'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 2602\nCurrent State #0,3,1,1: 71:[2673]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '60-27=33', '81*33=2673'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 2836\nCurrent State #0,0,1,2: 71:[2907]. Operations so far : ['81-30=51', '27+30=57', '51*57=2907'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 2836\nCurrent State #0,4,1,0: 71:[2907]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-30=51', '57*51=2907'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 2836\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 71:[2907]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81-30=51', '57*51=2907'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 3169\nCurrent State #0,1,3,0: 71:[3240]. Operations so far : ['81-27=54', '30+30=60', '54*60=3240'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 3169\nCurrent State #0,3,0,2: 71:[3240]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '81-27=54', '60*54=3240'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 6256\nCurrent State #0,4,3,1: 71:[6327]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81+30=111', '57*111=6327'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 6256\nCurrent State #0,2,0,2: 71:[6327]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '81+30=111', '57*111=6327'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 6409\nCurrent State #0,3,4,0: 71:[6480]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '27+81=108', '60*108=6480'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 6976\nCurrent State #0,4,0,1: 71:[7047]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '30+57=87', '81*87=7047'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 6976\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 71:[7047]. Operations so far : ['30+30=60', '27+60=87', '81*87=7047'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 6976\nCurrent State #0,2,2,0: 71:[7047]. Operations so far : ['27+30=57', '30+57=87', '81*87=7047'].\n\n```\nSOLUTION: NO\nOPERATIONS: []\nRESULT: None\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 16,649 |
[
9,
86,
14,
29
]
| 92 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [9, 86, 14, 29] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 92. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [9, 86, 14, 29]. Our goal is to produce 92. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 92:[9, 86, 14, 29]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9*14=126. \nResulting numbers: [86, 29, 126].\nHeuristic score : (|86-92| + |29-92| + |126-92|)/3 = (6 + 63 + 34)/3 = 34.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 92:[86, 29, 126] Operation: 9*14=126\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 126-29=97. \nResulting numbers: [86, 97].\nHeuristic score : (|86-92| + |97-92|)/2 = (6 + 5)/2 = 5.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 92:[86, 97] Operation: 126-29=97\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-86=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,92 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 92:[86, 29, 126]. Operations so far : ['9*14=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86+29=115. \nResulting numbers: [126, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|126-92| + |115-92|)/2 = (34 + 23)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 92:[126, 115] Operation: 86+29=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 126-115=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,92 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 92:[86, 29, 126]. Operations so far : ['9*14=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86-29=57. \nResulting numbers: [126, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|126-92| + |57-92|)/2 = (34 + 35)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 92:[126, 57] Operation: 86-29=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 126-57=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,92 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 92:[86, 29, 126]. Operations so far : ['9*14=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29+126=155. \nResulting numbers: [86, 155].\nHeuristic score : (|86-92| + |155-92|)/2 = (6 + 63)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 92:[86, 155] Operation: 29+126=155\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 155-86=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,92 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 92:[86, 29, 126]. Operations so far : ['9*14=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 126-86=40. \nResulting numbers: [29, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|29-92| + |40-92|)/2 = (63 + 52)/2 = 57.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 92:[29, 40] Operation: 126-86=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29+40=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,92 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 92:[86, 29, 126]. Operations so far : ['9*14=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86+126=212. \nResulting numbers: [29, 212].\nHeuristic score : (|29-92| + |212-92|)/2 = (63 + 120)/2 = 91.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 92:[29, 212] Operation: 86+126=212\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 212-29=183. \nResulting numbers: [183].\n183,92 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 92:[86, 29, 126]. Operations so far : ['9*14=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86*29=2494. \nResulting numbers: [126, 2494].\nHeuristic score : (|126-92| + |2494-92|)/2 = (34 + 2402)/2 = 1218.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 92:[126, 2494] Operation: 86*29=2494\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2494-126=2368. \nResulting numbers: [2368].\n2368,92 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 92:[86, 29, 126]. Operations so far : ['9*14=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29*126=3654. \nResulting numbers: [86, 3654].\nHeuristic score : (|86-92| + |3654-92|)/2 = (6 + 3562)/2 = 1784.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 92:[86, 3654] Operation: 29*126=3654\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3654-86=3568. \nResulting numbers: [3568].\n3568,92 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 92:[86, 29, 126]. Operations so far : ['9*14=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86*126=10836. \nResulting numbers: [29, 10836].\nHeuristic score : (|29-92| + |10836-92|)/2 = (63 + 10744)/2 = 5403.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 92:[29, 10836] Operation: 86*126=10836\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 10836-29=10807. \nResulting numbers: [10807].\n10807,92 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 57.5\nCurrent State #0: 92:[9, 86, 14, 29]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9+14=23. \nResulting numbers: [86, 29, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|86-92| + |29-92| + |23-92|)/3 = (6 + 63 + 69)/3 = 46.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 92:[86, 29, 23] Operation: 9+14=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29+23=52. \nResulting numbers: [86, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|86-92| + |52-92|)/2 = (6 + 40)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 92:[86, 52] Operation: 29+23=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86+52=138. \nResulting numbers: [138].\n138,92 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 46.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 92:[86, 29, 23]. Operations so far : ['9+14=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86+23=109. \nResulting numbers: [29, 109].\nHeuristic score : (|29-92| + |109-92|)/2 = (63 + 17)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 92:[29, 109] Operation: 86+23=109\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 109-29=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,92 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 46.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 92:[86, 29, 23]. Operations so far : ['9+14=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86+29=115. \nResulting numbers: [23, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|23-92| + |115-92|)/2 = (69 + 23)/2 = 46.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 92:[23, 115] Operation: 86+29=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-23=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,92 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['9+14=23', '86+29=115', '115-23=92']\nRESULT: 92\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 2,985 |
[
61,
40,
80,
78
]
| 22 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [61, 40, 80, 78] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 22. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [61, 40, 80, 78]. Our goal is to produce 22. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 22:[61, 40, 80, 78]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-61=19. \nResulting numbers: [40, 78, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |78-22| + |19-22|)/3 = (18 + 56 + 3)/3 = 25.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 22:[40, 78, 19] Operation: 80-61=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-40=38. \nResulting numbers: [19, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|19-22| + |38-22|)/2 = (3 + 16)/2 = 9.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 22:[19, 38] Operation: 78-40=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-19=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[40, 78, 19]. Operations so far : ['80-61=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-19=59. \nResulting numbers: [40, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |59-22|)/2 = (18 + 37)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 22:[40, 59] Operation: 78-19=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-40=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[40, 78, 19]. Operations so far : ['80-61=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-19=21. \nResulting numbers: [78, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|78-22| + |21-22|)/2 = (56 + 1)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 22:[78, 21] Operation: 40-19=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-21=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[40, 78, 19]. Operations so far : ['80-61=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+19=59. \nResulting numbers: [78, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|78-22| + |59-22|)/2 = (56 + 37)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 22:[78, 59] Operation: 40+19=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-59=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[40, 78, 19]. Operations so far : ['80-61=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+19=97. \nResulting numbers: [40, 97].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |97-22|)/2 = (18 + 75)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 22:[40, 97] Operation: 78+19=97\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-40=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[40, 78, 19]. Operations so far : ['80-61=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+78=118. \nResulting numbers: [19, 118].\nHeuristic score : (|19-22| + |118-22|)/2 = (3 + 96)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 22:[19, 118] Operation: 40+78=118\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 118-19=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[40, 78, 19]. Operations so far : ['80-61=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*19=760. \nResulting numbers: [78, 760].\nHeuristic score : (|78-22| + |760-22|)/2 = (56 + 738)/2 = 397.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 22:[78, 760] Operation: 40*19=760\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 760-78=682. \nResulting numbers: [682].\n682,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[40, 78, 19]. Operations so far : ['80-61=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*19=1482. \nResulting numbers: [40, 1482].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |1482-22|)/2 = (18 + 1460)/2 = 739.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 22:[40, 1482] Operation: 78*19=1482\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1482-40=1442. \nResulting numbers: [1442].\n1442,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[40, 78, 19]. Operations so far : ['80-61=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*78=3120. \nResulting numbers: [19, 3120].\nHeuristic score : (|19-22| + |3120-22|)/2 = (3 + 3098)/2 = 1550.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 22:[19, 3120] Operation: 40*78=3120\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3120-19=3101. \nResulting numbers: [3101].\n3101,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 42.75\nCurrent State #0: 22:[61, 40, 80, 78]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-78=2. \nResulting numbers: [61, 40, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |40-22| + |2-22|)/3 = (39 + 18 + 20)/3 = 25.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 22:[61, 40, 2] Operation: 80-78=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-40=21. \nResulting numbers: [2, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|2-22| + |21-22|)/2 = (20 + 1)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 22:[2, 21] Operation: 61-40=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2+21=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[61, 40, 2]. Operations so far : ['80-78=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40/2=20. \nResulting numbers: [61, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |20-22|)/2 = (39 + 2)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 22:[61, 20] Operation: 40/2=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-20=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[61, 40, 2]. Operations so far : ['80-78=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-2=59. \nResulting numbers: [40, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |59-22|)/2 = (18 + 37)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 22:[40, 59] Operation: 61-2=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-40=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[61, 40, 2]. Operations so far : ['80-78=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-2=38. \nResulting numbers: [61, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |38-22|)/2 = (39 + 16)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 22:[61, 38] Operation: 40-2=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-38=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[61, 40, 2]. Operations so far : ['80-78=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+2=63. \nResulting numbers: [40, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |63-22|)/2 = (18 + 41)/2 = 29.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 22:[40, 63] Operation: 61+2=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-40=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[61, 40, 2]. Operations so far : ['80-78=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+2=42. \nResulting numbers: [61, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |42-22|)/2 = (39 + 20)/2 = 29.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 22:[61, 42] Operation: 40+2=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-42=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[61, 40, 2]. Operations so far : ['80-78=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*2=80. \nResulting numbers: [61, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |80-22|)/2 = (39 + 58)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 22:[61, 80] Operation: 40*2=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-61=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[61, 40, 2]. Operations so far : ['80-78=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+40=101. \nResulting numbers: [2, 101].\nHeuristic score : (|2-22| + |101-22|)/2 = (20 + 79)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 22:[2, 101] Operation: 61+40=101\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-2=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[61, 40, 2]. Operations so far : ['80-78=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*2=122. \nResulting numbers: [40, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |122-22|)/2 = (18 + 100)/2 = 59.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 22:[40, 122] Operation: 61*2=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-40=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[61, 40, 2]. Operations so far : ['80-78=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*40=2440. \nResulting numbers: [2, 2440].\nHeuristic score : (|2-22| + |2440-22|)/2 = (20 + 2418)/2 = 1219.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,9: 22:[2, 2440] Operation: 61*40=2440\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2440/2=1220. \nResulting numbers: [1220].\n1220,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 42.75\nCurrent State #0: 22:[61, 40, 80, 78]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-61=17. \nResulting numbers: [40, 80, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |80-22| + |17-22|)/3 = (18 + 58 + 5)/3 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 22:[40, 80, 17] Operation: 78-61=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-40=40. \nResulting numbers: [17, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|17-22| + |40-22|)/2 = (5 + 18)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 22:[17, 40] Operation: 80-40=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-17=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 22:[40, 80, 17]. Operations so far : ['78-61=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/40=2. \nResulting numbers: [17, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|17-22| + |2-22|)/2 = (5 + 20)/2 = 12.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 22:[17, 2] Operation: 80/40=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+2=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 22:[40, 80, 17]. Operations so far : ['78-61=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-17=23. \nResulting numbers: [80, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|80-22| + |23-22|)/2 = (58 + 1)/2 = 29.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 22:[80, 23] Operation: 40-17=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-23=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 22:[40, 80, 17]. Operations so far : ['78-61=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-17=63. \nResulting numbers: [40, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |63-22|)/2 = (18 + 41)/2 = 29.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 22:[40, 63] Operation: 80-17=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-40=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 22:[40, 80, 17]. Operations so far : ['78-61=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+17=57. \nResulting numbers: [80, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|80-22| + |57-22|)/2 = (58 + 35)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 22:[80, 57] Operation: 40+17=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-57=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 22:[40, 80, 17]. Operations so far : ['78-61=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+17=97. \nResulting numbers: [40, 97].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |97-22|)/2 = (18 + 75)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 22:[40, 97] Operation: 80+17=97\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-40=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 22:[40, 80, 17]. Operations so far : ['78-61=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+80=120. \nResulting numbers: [17, 120].\nHeuristic score : (|17-22| + |120-22|)/2 = (5 + 98)/2 = 51.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 22:[17, 120] Operation: 40+80=120\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 120-17=103. \nResulting numbers: [103].\n103,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 22:[40, 80, 17]. Operations so far : ['78-61=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*17=680. \nResulting numbers: [80, 680].\nHeuristic score : (|80-22| + |680-22|)/2 = (58 + 658)/2 = 358.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 22:[80, 680] Operation: 40*17=680\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 680-80=600. \nResulting numbers: [600].\n600,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 22:[40, 80, 17]. Operations so far : ['78-61=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*17=1360. \nResulting numbers: [40, 1360].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |1360-22|)/2 = (18 + 1338)/2 = 678.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 22:[40, 1360] Operation: 80*17=1360\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1360/40=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 22:[40, 80, 17]. Operations so far : ['78-61=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*80=3200. \nResulting numbers: [17, 3200].\nHeuristic score : (|17-22| + |3200-22|)/2 = (5 + 3178)/2 = 1591.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,9: 22:[17, 3200] Operation: 40*80=3200\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3200-17=3183. \nResulting numbers: [3183].\n3183,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 42.75\nCurrent State #0: 22:[61, 40, 80, 78]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-40=40. \nResulting numbers: [61, 78, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |78-22| + |40-22|)/3 = (39 + 56 + 18)/3 = 37.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 22:[61, 78, 40] Operation: 80-40=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-61=17. \nResulting numbers: [40, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |17-22|)/2 = (18 + 5)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 22:[40, 17] Operation: 78-61=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-17=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 22:[61, 78, 40]. Operations so far : ['80-40=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-40=38. \nResulting numbers: [61, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |38-22|)/2 = (39 + 16)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 22:[61, 38] Operation: 78-40=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-38=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 22:[61, 78, 40]. Operations so far : ['80-40=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-40=21. \nResulting numbers: [78, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|78-22| + |21-22|)/2 = (56 + 1)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 22:[78, 21] Operation: 61-40=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-21=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 22:[61, 78, 40]. Operations so far : ['80-40=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+78=139. \nResulting numbers: [40, 139].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |139-22|)/2 = (18 + 117)/2 = 67.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 22:[40, 139] Operation: 61+78=139\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 139-40=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 22:[61, 78, 40]. Operations so far : ['80-40=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+40=101. \nResulting numbers: [78, 101].\nHeuristic score : (|78-22| + |101-22|)/2 = (56 + 79)/2 = 67.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 22:[78, 101] Operation: 61+40=101\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-78=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 22:[61, 78, 40]. Operations so far : ['80-40=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+40=118. \nResulting numbers: [61, 118].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |118-22|)/2 = (39 + 96)/2 = 67.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 22:[61, 118] Operation: 78+40=118\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 118-61=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 22:[61, 78, 40]. Operations so far : ['80-40=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*40=2440. \nResulting numbers: [78, 2440].\nHeuristic score : (|78-22| + |2440-22|)/2 = (56 + 2418)/2 = 1237.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 22:[78, 2440] Operation: 61*40=2440\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2440-78=2362. \nResulting numbers: [2362].\n2362,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 22:[61, 78, 40]. Operations so far : ['80-40=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*40=3120. \nResulting numbers: [61, 3120].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |3120-22|)/2 = (39 + 3098)/2 = 1568.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 22:[61, 3120] Operation: 78*40=3120\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3120-61=3059. \nResulting numbers: [3059].\n3059,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 22:[61, 78, 40]. Operations so far : ['80-40=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*78=4758. \nResulting numbers: [40, 4758].\nHeuristic score : (|40-22| + |4758-22|)/2 = (18 + 4736)/2 = 2377.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 22:[40, 4758] Operation: 61*78=4758\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4758-40=4718. \nResulting numbers: [4718].\n4718,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 42.75\nCurrent State #0: 22:[61, 40, 80, 78]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-40=38. \nResulting numbers: [61, 80, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |80-22| + |38-22|)/3 = (39 + 58 + 16)/3 = 37.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 22:[61, 80, 38] Operation: 78-40=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-61=19. \nResulting numbers: [38, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|38-22| + |19-22|)/2 = (16 + 3)/2 = 9.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 22:[38, 19] Operation: 80-61=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-19=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 22:[61, 80, 38]. Operations so far : ['78-40=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-38=23. \nResulting numbers: [80, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|80-22| + |23-22|)/2 = (58 + 1)/2 = 29.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 22:[80, 23] Operation: 61-38=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-23=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 22:[61, 80, 38]. Operations so far : ['78-40=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-38=42. \nResulting numbers: [61, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |42-22|)/2 = (39 + 20)/2 = 29.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 22:[61, 42] Operation: 80-38=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-42=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 22:[61, 80, 38]. Operations so far : ['78-40=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+80=141. \nResulting numbers: [38, 141].\nHeuristic score : (|38-22| + |141-22|)/2 = (16 + 119)/2 = 67.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 22:[38, 141] Operation: 61+80=141\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 141-38=103. \nResulting numbers: [103].\n103,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 22:[61, 80, 38]. Operations so far : ['78-40=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+38=99. \nResulting numbers: [80, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|80-22| + |99-22|)/2 = (58 + 77)/2 = 67.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 22:[80, 99] Operation: 61+38=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-80=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 22:[61, 80, 38]. Operations so far : ['78-40=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+38=118. \nResulting numbers: [61, 118].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |118-22|)/2 = (39 + 96)/2 = 67.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 22:[61, 118] Operation: 80+38=118\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 118-61=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 22:[61, 80, 38]. Operations so far : ['78-40=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*38=2318. \nResulting numbers: [80, 2318].\nHeuristic score : (|80-22| + |2318-22|)/2 = (58 + 2296)/2 = 1177.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 22:[80, 2318] Operation: 61*38=2318\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2318-80=2238. \nResulting numbers: [2238].\n2238,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 22:[61, 80, 38]. Operations so far : ['78-40=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*38=3040. \nResulting numbers: [61, 3040].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |3040-22|)/2 = (39 + 3018)/2 = 1528.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 22:[61, 3040] Operation: 80*38=3040\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3040-61=2979. \nResulting numbers: [2979].\n2979,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 22:[61, 80, 38]. Operations so far : ['78-40=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*80=4880. \nResulting numbers: [38, 4880].\nHeuristic score : (|38-22| + |4880-22|)/2 = (16 + 4858)/2 = 2437.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 22:[38, 4880] Operation: 61*80=4880\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4880-38=4842. \nResulting numbers: [4842].\n4842,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 42.75\nCurrent State #0: 22:[61, 40, 80, 78]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-40=21. \nResulting numbers: [80, 78, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|80-22| + |78-22| + |21-22|)/3 = (58 + 56 + 1)/3 = 38.33\nGenerated Node #0,5: 22:[80, 78, 21] Operation: 61-40=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-78=2. \nResulting numbers: [21, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|21-22| + |2-22|)/2 = (1 + 20)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 22:[21, 2] Operation: 80-78=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+2=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 38.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,5: 22:[80, 78, 21]. Operations so far : ['61-40=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-21=59. \nResulting numbers: [78, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|78-22| + |59-22|)/2 = (56 + 37)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 22:[78, 59] Operation: 80-21=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-59=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 38.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,5: 22:[80, 78, 21]. Operations so far : ['61-40=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-21=57. \nResulting numbers: [80, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|80-22| + |57-22|)/2 = (58 + 35)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 22:[80, 57] Operation: 78-21=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-57=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 38.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,5: 22:[80, 78, 21]. Operations so far : ['61-40=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+21=101. \nResulting numbers: [78, 101].\nHeuristic score : (|78-22| + |101-22|)/2 = (56 + 79)/2 = 67.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,3: 22:[78, 101] Operation: 80+21=101\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-78=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 38.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,5: 22:[80, 78, 21]. Operations so far : ['61-40=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+21=99. \nResulting numbers: [80, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|80-22| + |99-22|)/2 = (58 + 77)/2 = 67.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,4: 22:[80, 99] Operation: 78+21=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-80=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 38.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,5: 22:[80, 78, 21]. Operations so far : ['61-40=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+78=158. \nResulting numbers: [21, 158].\nHeuristic score : (|21-22| + |158-22|)/2 = (1 + 136)/2 = 68.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,5: 22:[21, 158] Operation: 80+78=158\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 158-21=137. \nResulting numbers: [137].\n137,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 38.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,5: 22:[80, 78, 21]. Operations so far : ['61-40=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*21=1638. \nResulting numbers: [80, 1638].\nHeuristic score : (|80-22| + |1638-22|)/2 = (58 + 1616)/2 = 837.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,6: 22:[80, 1638] Operation: 78*21=1638\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1638-80=1558. \nResulting numbers: [1558].\n1558,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 38.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,5: 22:[80, 78, 21]. Operations so far : ['61-40=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*21=1680. \nResulting numbers: [78, 1680].\nHeuristic score : (|78-22| + |1680-22|)/2 = (56 + 1658)/2 = 857.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,7: 22:[78, 1680] Operation: 80*21=1680\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1680-78=1602. \nResulting numbers: [1602].\n1602,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 38.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,5: 22:[80, 78, 21]. Operations so far : ['61-40=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*78=6240. \nResulting numbers: [21, 6240].\nHeuristic score : (|21-22| + |6240-22|)/2 = (1 + 6218)/2 = 3109.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,8: 22:[21, 6240] Operation: 80*78=6240\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6240-21=6219. \nResulting numbers: [6219].\n6219,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 42.75\nCurrent State #0: 22:[61, 40, 80, 78]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/40=2. \nResulting numbers: [61, 78, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |78-22| + |2-22|)/3 = (39 + 56 + 20)/3 = 38.33\nGenerated Node #0,6: 22:[61, 78, 2] Operation: 80/40=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-61=17. \nResulting numbers: [2, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|2-22| + |17-22|)/2 = (20 + 5)/2 = 12.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,0: 22:[2, 17] Operation: 78-61=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2+17=19. \nResulting numbers: [19].\n19,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 38.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,6: 22:[61, 78, 2]. Operations so far : ['80/40=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78/2=39. \nResulting numbers: [61, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|61-22| + |39-22|)/2 = (39 + 17)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,1: 22:[61, 39] Operation: 78/2=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-39=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,22 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['80/40=2', '78/2=39', '61-39=22']\nRESULT: 22\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 13,742 |
[
14,
47,
33,
94
]
| 93 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [14, 47, 33, 94] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 93. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [14, 47, 33, 94]. Our goal is to produce 93. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 93:[14, 47, 33, 94]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+47=61. \nResulting numbers: [33, 94, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|33-93| + |94-93| + |61-93|)/3 = (60 + 1 + 32)/3 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 93:[33, 94, 61] Operation: 14+47=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+61=94. \nResulting numbers: [94, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|94-93| + |94-93|)/2 = (1 + 1)/2 = 1.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 93:[94, 94] Operation: 33+61=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94/94=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[33, 94, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-33=61. \nResulting numbers: [61, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|61-93| + |61-93|)/2 = (32 + 32)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 93:[61, 61] Operation: 94-33=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+61=122. \nResulting numbers: [122].\n122,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[33, 94, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+94=127. \nResulting numbers: [61, 127].\nHeuristic score : (|61-93| + |127-93|)/2 = (32 + 34)/2 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 93:[61, 127] Operation: 33+94=127\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 127-61=66. \nResulting numbers: [66].\n66,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[33, 94, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-33=28. \nResulting numbers: [94, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|94-93| + |28-93|)/2 = (1 + 65)/2 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 93:[94, 28] Operation: 61-33=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-28=66. \nResulting numbers: [66].\n66,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[33, 94, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-61=33. \nResulting numbers: [33, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|33-93| + |33-93|)/2 = (60 + 60)/2 = 60.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 93:[33, 33] Operation: 94-61=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+33=66. \nResulting numbers: [66].\n66,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[33, 94, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94+61=155. \nResulting numbers: [33, 155].\nHeuristic score : (|33-93| + |155-93|)/2 = (60 + 62)/2 = 61.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 93:[33, 155] Operation: 94+61=155\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 155-33=122. \nResulting numbers: [122].\n122,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[33, 94, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33*61=2013. \nResulting numbers: [94, 2013].\nHeuristic score : (|94-93| + |2013-93|)/2 = (1 + 1920)/2 = 960.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 93:[94, 2013] Operation: 33*61=2013\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2013-94=1919. \nResulting numbers: [1919].\n1919,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[33, 94, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33*94=3102. \nResulting numbers: [61, 3102].\nHeuristic score : (|61-93| + |3102-93|)/2 = (32 + 3009)/2 = 1520.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 93:[61, 3102] Operation: 33*94=3102\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3102-61=3041. \nResulting numbers: [3041].\n3041,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 93:[33, 94, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94*61=5734. \nResulting numbers: [33, 5734].\nHeuristic score : (|33-93| + |5734-93|)/2 = (60 + 5641)/2 = 2850.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 93:[33, 5734] Operation: 94*61=5734\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5734-33=5701. \nResulting numbers: [5701].\n5701,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 46.5\nCurrent State #0: 93:[14, 47, 33, 94]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+33=47. \nResulting numbers: [47, 94, 47].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |94-93| + |47-93|)/3 = (46 + 1 + 46)/3 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 93:[47, 94, 47] Operation: 14+33=47\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+47=94. \nResulting numbers: [94, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|94-93| + |94-93|)/2 = (1 + 1)/2 = 1.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 93:[94, 94] Operation: 47+47=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94/94=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 93:[47, 94, 47]. Operations so far : ['14+33=47'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-47=47. \nResulting numbers: [47, 47].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |47-93|)/2 = (46 + 46)/2 = 46.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 93:[47, 47] Operation: 94-47=47\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+47=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 93:[47, 94, 47]. Operations so far : ['14+33=47'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-47=47. \nResulting numbers: [47, 47].\nHeuristic score : (|47-93| + |47-93|)/2 = (46 + 46)/2 = 46.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 93:[47, 47] Operation: 94-47=47\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+47=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,93 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 93:[47, 94, 47]. Operations so far : ['14+33=47'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47/47=1. \nResulting numbers: [94, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|94-93| + |1-93|)/2 = (1 + 92)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 93:[94, 1] Operation: 47/47=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-1=93. \nResulting numbers: [93].\n93,93 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['14+33=47', '47/47=1', '94-1=93']\nRESULT: 93\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 3,169 |
[
69,
81,
51,
84
]
| 58 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [69, 81, 51, 84] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 58. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [69, 81, 51, 84]. Our goal is to produce 58. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 58:[69, 81, 51, 84]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-69=15. \nResulting numbers: [81, 51, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|81-58| + |51-58| + |15-58|)/3 = (23 + 7 + 43)/3 = 24.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 58:[81, 51, 15] Operation: 84-69=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-51=30. \nResulting numbers: [69, 84, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|69-58| + |84-58| + |30-58|)/3 = (11 + 26 + 28)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 58:[69, 84, 30] Operation: 81-51=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-69=12. \nResulting numbers: [51, 84, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|51-58| + |84-58| + |12-58|)/3 = (7 + 26 + 46)/3 = 26.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 58:[51, 84, 12] Operation: 81-69=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-81=3. \nResulting numbers: [69, 51, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|69-58| + |51-58| + |3-58|)/3 = (11 + 7 + 55)/3 = 24.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 58:[69, 51, 3] Operation: 84-81=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-51=33. \nResulting numbers: [69, 81, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|69-58| + |81-58| + |33-58|)/3 = (11 + 23 + 25)/3 = 19.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 58:[69, 81, 33] Operation: 84-51=33\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 19.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 58:[69, 81, 33]. Operations so far : ['84-51=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-33=48. \nResulting numbers: [69, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|69-58| + |48-58|)/2 = (11 + 10)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 58:[69, 48] Operation: 81-33=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-33=36. \nResulting numbers: [81, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|81-58| + |36-58|)/2 = (23 + 22)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 58:[81, 36] Operation: 69-33=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-69=12. \nResulting numbers: [33, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|33-58| + |12-58|)/2 = (25 + 46)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 58:[33, 12] Operation: 81-69=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+33=114. \nResulting numbers: [69, 114].\nHeuristic score : (|69-58| + |114-58|)/2 = (11 + 56)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 58:[69, 114] Operation: 81+33=114\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+33=102. \nResulting numbers: [81, 102].\nHeuristic score : (|81-58| + |102-58|)/2 = (23 + 44)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 58:[81, 102] Operation: 69+33=102\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 58:[69, 84, 30]. Operations so far : ['81-51=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-30=39. \nResulting numbers: [84, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|84-58| + |39-58|)/2 = (26 + 19)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 58:[84, 39] Operation: 69-30=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-69=15. \nResulting numbers: [30, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|30-58| + |15-58|)/2 = (28 + 43)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 58:[30, 15] Operation: 84-69=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84+30=114. \nResulting numbers: [69, 114].\nHeuristic score : (|69-58| + |114-58|)/2 = (11 + 56)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 58:[69, 114] Operation: 84+30=114\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+30=99. \nResulting numbers: [84, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|84-58| + |99-58|)/2 = (26 + 41)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 58:[84, 99] Operation: 69+30=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-30=54. \nResulting numbers: [69, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|69-58| + |54-58|)/2 = (11 + 4)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 58:[69, 54] Operation: 84-30=54\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 24.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 58:[81, 51, 15]. Operations so far : ['84-69=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-15=36. \nResulting numbers: [81, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|81-58| + |36-58|)/2 = (23 + 22)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 58:[81, 36] Operation: 51-15=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+15=96. \nResulting numbers: [51, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|51-58| + |96-58|)/2 = (7 + 38)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 58:[51, 96] Operation: 81+15=96\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-51=30. \nResulting numbers: [15, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|15-58| + |30-58|)/2 = (43 + 28)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 58:[15, 30] Operation: 81-51=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-15=66. \nResulting numbers: [51, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|51-58| + |66-58|)/2 = (7 + 8)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 58:[51, 66] Operation: 81-15=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+15=66. \nResulting numbers: [81, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|81-58| + |66-58|)/2 = (23 + 8)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 58:[81, 66] Operation: 51+15=66\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 24.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 58:[69, 51, 3]. Operations so far : ['84-81=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69/3=23. \nResulting numbers: [51, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|51-58| + |23-58|)/2 = (7 + 35)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 58:[51, 23] Operation: 69/3=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+3=54. \nResulting numbers: [69, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|69-58| + |54-58|)/2 = (11 + 4)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 58:[69, 54] Operation: 51+3=54\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+3=72. \nResulting numbers: [51, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|51-58| + |72-58|)/2 = (7 + 14)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 58:[51, 72] Operation: 69+3=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-3=48. \nResulting numbers: [69, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|69-58| + |48-58|)/2 = (11 + 10)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 58:[69, 48] Operation: 51-3=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-3=66. \nResulting numbers: [51, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|51-58| + |66-58|)/2 = (7 + 8)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 58:[51, 66] Operation: 69-3=66\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 58:[51, 84, 12]. Operations so far : ['81-69=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+12=63. \nResulting numbers: [84, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|84-58| + |63-58|)/2 = (26 + 5)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 58:[84, 63] Operation: 51+12=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-12=39. \nResulting numbers: [84, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|84-58| + |39-58|)/2 = (26 + 19)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 58:[84, 39] Operation: 51-12=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-12=72. \nResulting numbers: [51, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|51-58| + |72-58|)/2 = (7 + 14)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 58:[51, 72] Operation: 84-12=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84+12=96. \nResulting numbers: [51, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|51-58| + |96-58|)/2 = (7 + 38)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 58:[51, 96] Operation: 84+12=96\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84/12=7. \nResulting numbers: [51, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|51-58| + |7-58|)/2 = (7 + 51)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 58:[51, 7] Operation: 84/12=7\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 58:[69, 54]. Operations so far : ['81-51=30', '84-30=54'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*54=3726. \nResulting numbers: [3726].\n3726,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-54=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+54=123. \nResulting numbers: [123].\n123,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 58:[51, 66]. Operations so far : ['84-69=15', '81-15=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-51=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*66=3366. \nResulting numbers: [3366].\n3366,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+66=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 58:[69, 54]. Operations so far : ['84-81=3', '51+3=54'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-54=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+54=123. \nResulting numbers: [123].\n123,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*54=3726. \nResulting numbers: [3726].\n3726,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 58:[51, 66]. Operations so far : ['84-81=3', '69-3=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+66=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*66=3366. \nResulting numbers: [3366].\n3366,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-51=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 58:[69, 48]. Operations so far : ['84-51=33', '81-33=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+48=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-48=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*48=3312. \nResulting numbers: [3312].\n3312,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 58:[51, 72]. Operations so far : ['81-69=12', '84-12=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+72=123. \nResulting numbers: [123].\n123,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*72=3672. \nResulting numbers: [3672].\n3672,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-51=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 58:[51, 72]. Operations so far : ['84-81=3', '69+3=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-51=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*72=3672. \nResulting numbers: [3672].\n3672,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+72=123. \nResulting numbers: [123].\n123,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 58:[69, 48]. Operations so far : ['84-81=3', '51-3=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-48=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+48=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*48=3312. \nResulting numbers: [3312].\n3312,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 15.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 58:[81, 66]. Operations so far : ['84-69=15', '51+15=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-66=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*66=5346. \nResulting numbers: [5346].\n5346,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+66=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 15.5\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 58:[84, 63]. Operations so far : ['81-69=12', '51+12=63'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-63=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84*63=5292. \nResulting numbers: [5292].\n5292,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84+63=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 58:[51, 23]. Operations so far : ['84-81=3', '69/3=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-23=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*23=1173. \nResulting numbers: [1173].\n1173,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+23=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 58:[84, 39]. Operations so far : ['81-51=30', '69-30=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-39=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84+39=123. \nResulting numbers: [123].\n123,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84*39=3276. \nResulting numbers: [3276].\n3276,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 58:[51, 96]. Operations so far : ['84-69=15', '81+15=96'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-51=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*96=4896. \nResulting numbers: [4896].\n4896,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+96=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 58:[81, 36]. Operations so far : ['84-69=15', '51-15=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*36=2916. \nResulting numbers: [2916].\n2916,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-36=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+36=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 58:[51, 96]. Operations so far : ['81-69=12', '84+12=96'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*96=4896. \nResulting numbers: [4896].\n4896,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-51=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+96=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13\nCurrent State #0,1,0,0: 58:[45]. Operations so far : ['81-51=30', '69-30=39', '84-39=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13\nCurrent State #0,0,0,1: 58:[45]. Operations so far : ['84-69=15', '51-15=36', '81-36=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 13\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 58:[45]. Operations so far : ['81-69=12', '84+12=96', '96-51=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 13\nCurrent State #0,0,1,0: 58:[45]. Operations so far : ['84-69=15', '81+15=96', '96-51=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,3,0,2: 58:[74]. Operations so far : ['84-81=3', '69/3=23', '51+23=74'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 58:[84, 39]. Operations so far : ['81-69=12', '51-12=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-39=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84*39=3276. \nResulting numbers: [3276].\n3276,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84+39=123. \nResulting numbers: [123].\n123,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 58:[81, 36]. Operations so far : ['84-51=33', '69-33=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+36=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*36=2916. \nResulting numbers: [2916].\n2916,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-36=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,58 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 58:[51, 7]. Operations so far : ['81-69=12', '84/12=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*7=357. \nResulting numbers: [357].\n357,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-7=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,58 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+7=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,58 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['81-69=12', '84/12=7', '51-7=44']\nRESULT: 44\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 8,344 |
[
96,
78,
3,
55
]
| 64 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [96, 78, 3, 55] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 64. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [96, 78, 3, 55]. Our goal is to produce 64. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 64:[96, 78, 3, 55]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-3=93. \nResulting numbers: [78, 55, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |55-64| + |93-64|)/3 = (14 + 9 + 29)/3 = 17.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 64:[78, 55, 93] Operation: 96-3=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-55=38. \nResulting numbers: [78, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |38-64|)/2 = (14 + 26)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 64:[78, 38] Operation: 93-55=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-38=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 64:[78, 55, 93]. Operations so far : ['96-3=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-78=15. \nResulting numbers: [55, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |15-64|)/2 = (9 + 49)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 64:[55, 15] Operation: 93-78=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+15=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 64:[78, 55, 93]. Operations so far : ['96-3=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-55=23. \nResulting numbers: [93, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|93-64| + |23-64|)/2 = (29 + 41)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 64:[93, 23] Operation: 78-55=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-23=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 64:[78, 55, 93]. Operations so far : ['96-3=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+55=133. \nResulting numbers: [93, 133].\nHeuristic score : (|93-64| + |133-64|)/2 = (29 + 69)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 64:[93, 133] Operation: 78+55=133\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 133-93=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 64:[78, 55, 93]. Operations so far : ['96-3=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+93=148. \nResulting numbers: [78, 148].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |148-64|)/2 = (14 + 84)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 64:[78, 148] Operation: 55+93=148\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 148-78=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 64:[78, 55, 93]. Operations so far : ['96-3=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+93=171. \nResulting numbers: [55, 171].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |171-64|)/2 = (9 + 107)/2 = 58.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 64:[55, 171] Operation: 78+93=171\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 171-55=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 64:[78, 55, 93]. Operations so far : ['96-3=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*55=4290. \nResulting numbers: [93, 4290].\nHeuristic score : (|93-64| + |4290-64|)/2 = (29 + 4226)/2 = 2127.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 64:[93, 4290] Operation: 78*55=4290\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4290-93=4197. \nResulting numbers: [4197].\n4197,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 64:[78, 55, 93]. Operations so far : ['96-3=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55*93=5115. \nResulting numbers: [78, 5115].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |5115-64|)/2 = (14 + 5051)/2 = 2532.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 64:[78, 5115] Operation: 55*93=5115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5115-78=5037. \nResulting numbers: [5037].\n5037,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 64:[78, 55, 93]. Operations so far : ['96-3=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*93=7254. \nResulting numbers: [55, 7254].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |7254-64|)/2 = (9 + 7190)/2 = 3599.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 64:[55, 7254] Operation: 78*93=7254\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7254-55=7199. \nResulting numbers: [7199].\n7199,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0: 64:[96, 78, 3, 55]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-3=75. \nResulting numbers: [96, 55, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |55-64| + |75-64|)/3 = (32 + 9 + 11)/3 = 17.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 64:[96, 55, 75] Operation: 78-3=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-55=41. \nResulting numbers: [75, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|75-64| + |41-64|)/2 = (11 + 23)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 64:[75, 41] Operation: 96-55=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-41=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 64:[96, 55, 75]. Operations so far : ['78-3=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-75=21. \nResulting numbers: [55, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |21-64|)/2 = (9 + 43)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 64:[55, 21] Operation: 96-75=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+21=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 64:[96, 55, 75]. Operations so far : ['78-3=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-55=20. \nResulting numbers: [96, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |20-64|)/2 = (32 + 44)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 64:[96, 20] Operation: 75-55=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-20=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 64:[96, 55, 75]. Operations so far : ['78-3=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+55=151. \nResulting numbers: [75, 151].\nHeuristic score : (|75-64| + |151-64|)/2 = (11 + 87)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 64:[75, 151] Operation: 96+55=151\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 151-75=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 64:[96, 55, 75]. Operations so far : ['78-3=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+75=130. \nResulting numbers: [96, 130].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |130-64|)/2 = (32 + 66)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 64:[96, 130] Operation: 55+75=130\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 130-96=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 64:[96, 55, 75]. Operations so far : ['78-3=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+75=171. \nResulting numbers: [55, 171].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |171-64|)/2 = (9 + 107)/2 = 58.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 64:[55, 171] Operation: 96+75=171\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 171-55=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 64:[96, 55, 75]. Operations so far : ['78-3=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55*75=4125. \nResulting numbers: [96, 4125].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |4125-64|)/2 = (32 + 4061)/2 = 2046.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 64:[96, 4125] Operation: 55*75=4125\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4125-96=4029. \nResulting numbers: [4029].\n4029,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 64:[96, 55, 75]. Operations so far : ['78-3=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*55=5280. \nResulting numbers: [75, 5280].\nHeuristic score : (|75-64| + |5280-64|)/2 = (11 + 5216)/2 = 2613.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 64:[75, 5280] Operation: 96*55=5280\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5280-75=5205. \nResulting numbers: [5205].\n5205,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 64:[96, 55, 75]. Operations so far : ['78-3=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*75=7200. \nResulting numbers: [55, 7200].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |7200-64|)/2 = (9 + 7136)/2 = 3572.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 64:[55, 7200] Operation: 96*75=7200\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7200-55=7145. \nResulting numbers: [7145].\n7145,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0: 64:[96, 78, 3, 55]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+55=58. \nResulting numbers: [96, 78, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |78-64| + |58-64|)/3 = (32 + 14 + 6)/3 = 17.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 64:[96, 78, 58] Operation: 3+55=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-58=38. \nResulting numbers: [78, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |38-64|)/2 = (14 + 26)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 64:[78, 38] Operation: 96-58=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-38=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 64:[96, 78, 58]. Operations so far : ['3+55=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-78=18. \nResulting numbers: [58, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|58-64| + |18-64|)/2 = (6 + 46)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 64:[58, 18] Operation: 96-78=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58+18=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 64:[96, 78, 58]. Operations so far : ['3+55=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-58=20. \nResulting numbers: [96, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |20-64|)/2 = (32 + 44)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 64:[96, 20] Operation: 78-58=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-20=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 64:[96, 78, 58]. Operations so far : ['3+55=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+58=154. \nResulting numbers: [78, 154].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |154-64|)/2 = (14 + 90)/2 = 52.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 64:[78, 154] Operation: 96+58=154\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 154-78=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 64:[96, 78, 58]. Operations so far : ['3+55=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+58=136. \nResulting numbers: [96, 136].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |136-64|)/2 = (32 + 72)/2 = 52.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 64:[96, 136] Operation: 78+58=136\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 136-96=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 64:[96, 78, 58]. Operations so far : ['3+55=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+78=174. \nResulting numbers: [58, 174].\nHeuristic score : (|58-64| + |174-64|)/2 = (6 + 110)/2 = 58.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 64:[58, 174] Operation: 96+78=174\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 174-58=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 64:[96, 78, 58]. Operations so far : ['3+55=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*58=4524. \nResulting numbers: [96, 4524].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |4524-64|)/2 = (32 + 4460)/2 = 2246.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 64:[96, 4524] Operation: 78*58=4524\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4524-96=4428. \nResulting numbers: [4428].\n4428,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 64:[96, 78, 58]. Operations so far : ['3+55=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*58=5568. \nResulting numbers: [78, 5568].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |5568-64|)/2 = (14 + 5504)/2 = 2759.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 64:[78, 5568] Operation: 96*58=5568\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5568-78=5490. \nResulting numbers: [5490].\n5490,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 64:[96, 78, 58]. Operations so far : ['3+55=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*78=7488. \nResulting numbers: [58, 7488].\nHeuristic score : (|58-64| + |7488-64|)/2 = (6 + 7424)/2 = 3715.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 64:[58, 7488] Operation: 96*78=7488\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7488-58=7430. \nResulting numbers: [7430].\n7430,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0: 64:[96, 78, 3, 55]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96/3=32. \nResulting numbers: [78, 55, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |55-64| + |32-64|)/3 = (14 + 9 + 32)/3 = 18.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 64:[78, 55, 32] Operation: 96/3=32\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-32=46. \nResulting numbers: [55, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |46-64|)/2 = (9 + 18)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 64:[55, 46] Operation: 78-32=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+46=101. \nResulting numbers: [101].\n101,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 64:[78, 55, 32]. Operations so far : ['96/3=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+32=87. \nResulting numbers: [78, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |87-64|)/2 = (14 + 23)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 64:[78, 87] Operation: 55+32=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-78=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 64:[78, 55, 32]. Operations so far : ['96/3=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+32=110. \nResulting numbers: [55, 110].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |110-64|)/2 = (9 + 46)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 64:[55, 110] Operation: 78+32=110\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 110-55=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 64:[78, 55, 32]. Operations so far : ['96/3=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-32=23. \nResulting numbers: [78, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |23-64|)/2 = (14 + 41)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 64:[78, 23] Operation: 55-32=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-23=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 64:[78, 55, 32]. Operations so far : ['96/3=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-55=23. \nResulting numbers: [32, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|32-64| + |23-64|)/2 = (32 + 41)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 64:[32, 23] Operation: 78-55=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+23=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 64:[78, 55, 32]. Operations so far : ['96/3=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+55=133. \nResulting numbers: [32, 133].\nHeuristic score : (|32-64| + |133-64|)/2 = (32 + 69)/2 = 50.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 64:[32, 133] Operation: 78+55=133\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 133-32=101. \nResulting numbers: [101].\n101,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 64:[78, 55, 32]. Operations so far : ['96/3=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55*32=1760. \nResulting numbers: [78, 1760].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |1760-64|)/2 = (14 + 1696)/2 = 855.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 64:[78, 1760] Operation: 55*32=1760\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1760-78=1682. \nResulting numbers: [1682].\n1682,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 64:[78, 55, 32]. Operations so far : ['96/3=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*32=2496. \nResulting numbers: [55, 2496].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |2496-64|)/2 = (9 + 2432)/2 = 1220.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 64:[55, 2496] Operation: 78*32=2496\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2496-55=2441. \nResulting numbers: [2441].\n2441,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 64:[78, 55, 32]. Operations so far : ['96/3=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*55=4290. \nResulting numbers: [32, 4290].\nHeuristic score : (|32-64| + |4290-64|)/2 = (32 + 4226)/2 = 2129.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 64:[32, 4290] Operation: 78*55=4290\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4290-32=4258. \nResulting numbers: [4258].\n4258,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0: 64:[96, 78, 3, 55]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+3=99. \nResulting numbers: [78, 55, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |55-64| + |99-64|)/3 = (14 + 9 + 35)/3 = 19.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 64:[78, 55, 99] Operation: 96+3=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-55=44. \nResulting numbers: [78, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |44-64|)/2 = (14 + 20)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 64:[78, 44] Operation: 99-55=44\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-44=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 64:[78, 55, 99]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-78=21. \nResulting numbers: [55, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |21-64|)/2 = (9 + 43)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 64:[55, 21] Operation: 99-78=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+21=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 64:[78, 55, 99]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-55=23. \nResulting numbers: [99, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|99-64| + |23-64|)/2 = (35 + 41)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 64:[99, 23] Operation: 78-55=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-23=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 64:[78, 55, 99]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+55=133. \nResulting numbers: [99, 133].\nHeuristic score : (|99-64| + |133-64|)/2 = (35 + 69)/2 = 52.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 64:[99, 133] Operation: 78+55=133\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 133-99=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 64:[78, 55, 99]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+99=154. \nResulting numbers: [78, 154].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |154-64|)/2 = (14 + 90)/2 = 52.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 64:[78, 154] Operation: 55+99=154\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 154-78=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 64:[78, 55, 99]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+99=177. \nResulting numbers: [55, 177].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |177-64|)/2 = (9 + 113)/2 = 61.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 64:[55, 177] Operation: 78+99=177\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 177-55=122. \nResulting numbers: [122].\n122,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 64:[78, 55, 99]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*55=4290. \nResulting numbers: [99, 4290].\nHeuristic score : (|99-64| + |4290-64|)/2 = (35 + 4226)/2 = 2130.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 64:[99, 4290] Operation: 78*55=4290\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4290-99=4191. \nResulting numbers: [4191].\n4191,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 64:[78, 55, 99]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55*99=5445. \nResulting numbers: [78, 5445].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |5445-64|)/2 = (14 + 5381)/2 = 2697.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 64:[78, 5445] Operation: 55*99=5445\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5445-78=5367. \nResulting numbers: [5367].\n5367,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 64:[78, 55, 99]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*99=7722. \nResulting numbers: [55, 7722].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |7722-64|)/2 = (9 + 7658)/2 = 3833.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 64:[55, 7722] Operation: 78*99=7722\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7722-55=7667. \nResulting numbers: [7667].\n7667,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0: 64:[96, 78, 3, 55]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+3=81. \nResulting numbers: [96, 55, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |55-64| + |81-64|)/3 = (32 + 9 + 17)/3 = 19.33\nGenerated Node #0,5: 64:[96, 55, 81] Operation: 78+3=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-55=41. \nResulting numbers: [81, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|81-64| + |41-64|)/2 = (17 + 23)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 64:[81, 41] Operation: 96-55=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-41=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 64:[96, 55, 81]. Operations so far : ['78+3=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-81=15. \nResulting numbers: [55, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |15-64|)/2 = (9 + 49)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 64:[55, 15] Operation: 96-81=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+15=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 64:[96, 55, 81]. Operations so far : ['78+3=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-55=26. \nResulting numbers: [96, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |26-64|)/2 = (32 + 38)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 64:[96, 26] Operation: 81-55=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-26=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 64:[96, 55, 81]. Operations so far : ['78+3=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+55=151. \nResulting numbers: [81, 151].\nHeuristic score : (|81-64| + |151-64|)/2 = (17 + 87)/2 = 52.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,3: 64:[81, 151] Operation: 96+55=151\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 151-81=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 64:[96, 55, 81]. Operations so far : ['78+3=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+81=136. \nResulting numbers: [96, 136].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |136-64|)/2 = (32 + 72)/2 = 52.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,4: 64:[96, 136] Operation: 55+81=136\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 136-96=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 64:[96, 55, 81]. Operations so far : ['78+3=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+81=177. \nResulting numbers: [55, 177].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |177-64|)/2 = (9 + 113)/2 = 61.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,5: 64:[55, 177] Operation: 96+81=177\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 177-55=122. \nResulting numbers: [122].\n122,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 64:[96, 55, 81]. Operations so far : ['78+3=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55*81=4455. \nResulting numbers: [96, 4455].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |4455-64|)/2 = (32 + 4391)/2 = 2211.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,6: 64:[96, 4455] Operation: 55*81=4455\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4455-96=4359. \nResulting numbers: [4359].\n4359,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 64:[96, 55, 81]. Operations so far : ['78+3=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*55=5280. \nResulting numbers: [81, 5280].\nHeuristic score : (|81-64| + |5280-64|)/2 = (17 + 5216)/2 = 2616.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,7: 64:[81, 5280] Operation: 96*55=5280\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5280-81=5199. \nResulting numbers: [5199].\n5199,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 64:[96, 55, 81]. Operations so far : ['78+3=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*81=7776. \nResulting numbers: [55, 7776].\nHeuristic score : (|55-64| + |7776-64|)/2 = (9 + 7712)/2 = 3860.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,8: 64:[55, 7776] Operation: 96*81=7776\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7776-55=7721. \nResulting numbers: [7721].\n7721,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0: 64:[96, 78, 3, 55]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-3=52. \nResulting numbers: [96, 78, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |78-64| + |52-64|)/3 = (32 + 14 + 12)/3 = 19.33\nGenerated Node #0,6: 64:[96, 78, 52] Operation: 55-3=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-52=44. \nResulting numbers: [78, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |44-64|)/2 = (14 + 20)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,0: 64:[78, 44] Operation: 96-52=44\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-44=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 64:[96, 78, 52]. Operations so far : ['55-3=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-78=18. \nResulting numbers: [52, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|52-64| + |18-64|)/2 = (12 + 46)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,1: 64:[52, 18] Operation: 96-78=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+18=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 64:[96, 78, 52]. Operations so far : ['55-3=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-52=26. \nResulting numbers: [96, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |26-64|)/2 = (32 + 38)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,2: 64:[96, 26] Operation: 78-52=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-26=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 64:[96, 78, 52]. Operations so far : ['55-3=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+52=148. \nResulting numbers: [78, 148].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |148-64|)/2 = (14 + 84)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,3: 64:[78, 148] Operation: 96+52=148\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 148-78=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 64:[96, 78, 52]. Operations so far : ['55-3=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+52=130. \nResulting numbers: [96, 130].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |130-64|)/2 = (32 + 66)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,4: 64:[96, 130] Operation: 78+52=130\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 130-96=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 64:[96, 78, 52]. Operations so far : ['55-3=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+78=174. \nResulting numbers: [52, 174].\nHeuristic score : (|52-64| + |174-64|)/2 = (12 + 110)/2 = 61.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,5: 64:[52, 174] Operation: 96+78=174\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 174-52=122. \nResulting numbers: [122].\n122,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 64:[96, 78, 52]. Operations so far : ['55-3=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*52=4056. \nResulting numbers: [96, 4056].\nHeuristic score : (|96-64| + |4056-64|)/2 = (32 + 3992)/2 = 2012.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,6: 64:[96, 4056] Operation: 78*52=4056\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4056-96=3960. \nResulting numbers: [3960].\n3960,64 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 64:[96, 78, 52]. Operations so far : ['55-3=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*52=4992. \nResulting numbers: [78, 4992].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |4992-64|)/2 = (14 + 4928)/2 = 2471.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,7: 64:[78, 4992] Operation: 96*52=4992\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4992/78=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,64 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['55-3=52', '96*52=4992', '4992/78=64']\nRESULT: 64\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 14,733 |
[
68,
8,
4,
77
]
| 43 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [68, 8, 4, 77] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 43. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [68, 8, 4, 77]. Our goal is to produce 43. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 43:[68, 8, 4, 77]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*4=32. \nResulting numbers: [68, 77, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |77-43| + |32-43|)/3 = (25 + 34 + 11)/3 = 23.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 43:[68, 77, 32] Operation: 8*4=32\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-32=45. \nResulting numbers: [68, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |45-43|)/2 = (25 + 2)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 43:[68, 45] Operation: 77-32=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-45=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 43:[68, 77, 32]. Operations so far : ['8*4=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-32=36. \nResulting numbers: [77, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |36-43|)/2 = (34 + 7)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 43:[77, 36] Operation: 68-32=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-36=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 43:[68, 77, 32]. Operations so far : ['8*4=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-68=9. \nResulting numbers: [32, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|32-43| + |9-43|)/2 = (11 + 34)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 43:[32, 9] Operation: 77-68=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+9=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 43:[68, 77, 32]. Operations so far : ['8*4=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+32=100. \nResulting numbers: [77, 100].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |100-43|)/2 = (34 + 57)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 43:[77, 100] Operation: 68+32=100\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-77=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 43:[68, 77, 32]. Operations so far : ['8*4=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+32=109. \nResulting numbers: [68, 109].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |109-43|)/2 = (25 + 66)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 43:[68, 109] Operation: 77+32=109\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 109-68=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 43:[68, 77, 32]. Operations so far : ['8*4=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+77=145. \nResulting numbers: [32, 145].\nHeuristic score : (|32-43| + |145-43|)/2 = (11 + 102)/2 = 56.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 43:[32, 145] Operation: 68+77=145\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 145-32=113. \nResulting numbers: [113].\n113,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 43:[68, 77, 32]. Operations so far : ['8*4=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*32=2176. \nResulting numbers: [77, 2176].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |2176-43|)/2 = (34 + 2133)/2 = 1083.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 43:[77, 2176] Operation: 68*32=2176\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2176-77=2099. \nResulting numbers: [2099].\n2099,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 43:[68, 77, 32]. Operations so far : ['8*4=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*32=2464. \nResulting numbers: [68, 2464].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |2464-43|)/2 = (25 + 2421)/2 = 1223.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 43:[68, 2464] Operation: 77*32=2464\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2464-68=2396. \nResulting numbers: [2396].\n2396,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 43:[68, 77, 32]. Operations so far : ['8*4=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*77=5236. \nResulting numbers: [32, 5236].\nHeuristic score : (|32-43| + |5236-43|)/2 = (11 + 5193)/2 = 2602.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 43:[32, 5236] Operation: 68*77=5236\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5236-32=5204. \nResulting numbers: [5204].\n5204,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 33.25\nCurrent State #0: 43:[68, 8, 4, 77]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-8=60. \nResulting numbers: [4, 77, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|4-43| + |77-43| + |60-43|)/3 = (39 + 34 + 17)/3 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 43:[4, 77, 60] Operation: 68-8=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-4=73. \nResulting numbers: [60, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|60-43| + |73-43|)/2 = (17 + 30)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 43:[60, 73] Operation: 77-4=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-60=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 43:[4, 77, 60]. Operations so far : ['68-8=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-4=56. \nResulting numbers: [77, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |56-43|)/2 = (34 + 13)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 43:[77, 56] Operation: 60-4=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-56=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 43:[4, 77, 60]. Operations so far : ['68-8=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+77=81. \nResulting numbers: [60, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|60-43| + |81-43|)/2 = (17 + 38)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 43:[60, 81] Operation: 4+77=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-60=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 43:[4, 77, 60]. Operations so far : ['68-8=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+60=64. \nResulting numbers: [77, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |64-43|)/2 = (34 + 21)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 43:[77, 64] Operation: 4+60=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-64=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 43:[4, 77, 60]. Operations so far : ['68-8=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/4=15. \nResulting numbers: [77, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |15-43|)/2 = (34 + 28)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 43:[77, 15] Operation: 60/4=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-15=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 43:[4, 77, 60]. Operations so far : ['68-8=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-60=17. \nResulting numbers: [4, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|4-43| + |17-43|)/2 = (39 + 26)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 43:[4, 17] Operation: 77-60=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+17=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 43:[4, 77, 60]. Operations so far : ['68-8=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+60=137. \nResulting numbers: [4, 137].\nHeuristic score : (|4-43| + |137-43|)/2 = (39 + 94)/2 = 66.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 43:[4, 137] Operation: 77+60=137\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 137-4=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 43:[4, 77, 60]. Operations so far : ['68-8=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*60=240. \nResulting numbers: [77, 240].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |240-43|)/2 = (34 + 197)/2 = 115.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 43:[77, 240] Operation: 4*60=240\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 240-77=163. \nResulting numbers: [163].\n163,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 43:[4, 77, 60]. Operations so far : ['68-8=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*77=308. \nResulting numbers: [60, 308].\nHeuristic score : (|60-43| + |308-43|)/2 = (17 + 265)/2 = 141.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 43:[60, 308] Operation: 4*77=308\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 308-60=248. \nResulting numbers: [248].\n248,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 43:[4, 77, 60]. Operations so far : ['68-8=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*60=4620. \nResulting numbers: [4, 4620].\nHeuristic score : (|4-43| + |4620-43|)/2 = (39 + 4577)/2 = 2308.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,9: 43:[4, 4620] Operation: 77*60=4620\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4620/4=1155. \nResulting numbers: [1155].\n1155,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 33.25\nCurrent State #0: 43:[68, 8, 4, 77]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-4=64. \nResulting numbers: [8, 77, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |77-43| + |64-43|)/3 = (35 + 34 + 21)/3 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 43:[8, 77, 64] Operation: 68-4=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-8=69. \nResulting numbers: [64, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|64-43| + |69-43|)/2 = (21 + 26)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 43:[64, 69] Operation: 77-8=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-64=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 43:[8, 77, 64]. Operations so far : ['68-4=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-8=56. \nResulting numbers: [77, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |56-43|)/2 = (34 + 13)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 43:[77, 56] Operation: 64-8=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-56=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 43:[8, 77, 64]. Operations so far : ['68-4=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+77=85. \nResulting numbers: [64, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|64-43| + |85-43|)/2 = (21 + 42)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 43:[64, 85] Operation: 8+77=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-64=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 43:[8, 77, 64]. Operations so far : ['68-4=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+64=72. \nResulting numbers: [77, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |72-43|)/2 = (34 + 29)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 43:[77, 72] Operation: 8+64=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-72=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 43:[8, 77, 64]. Operations so far : ['68-4=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-64=13. \nResulting numbers: [8, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |13-43|)/2 = (35 + 30)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 43:[8, 13] Operation: 77-64=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+13=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 43:[8, 77, 64]. Operations so far : ['68-4=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64/8=8. \nResulting numbers: [77, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |8-43|)/2 = (34 + 35)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 43:[77, 8] Operation: 64/8=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-8=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 43:[8, 77, 64]. Operations so far : ['68-4=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+64=141. \nResulting numbers: [8, 141].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |141-43|)/2 = (35 + 98)/2 = 66.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 43:[8, 141] Operation: 77+64=141\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 141-8=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 43:[8, 77, 64]. Operations so far : ['68-4=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*64=512. \nResulting numbers: [77, 512].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |512-43|)/2 = (34 + 469)/2 = 251.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 43:[77, 512] Operation: 8*64=512\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 512-77=435. \nResulting numbers: [435].\n435,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 43:[8, 77, 64]. Operations so far : ['68-4=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*77=616. \nResulting numbers: [64, 616].\nHeuristic score : (|64-43| + |616-43|)/2 = (21 + 573)/2 = 297.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 43:[64, 616] Operation: 8*77=616\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 616-64=552. \nResulting numbers: [552].\n552,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 43:[8, 77, 64]. Operations so far : ['68-4=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*64=4928. \nResulting numbers: [8, 4928].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |4928-43|)/2 = (35 + 4885)/2 = 2460.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,9: 43:[8, 4928] Operation: 77*64=4928\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4928/8=616. \nResulting numbers: [616].\n616,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 33.25\nCurrent State #0: 43:[68, 8, 4, 77]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+4=12. \nResulting numbers: [68, 77, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |77-43| + |12-43|)/3 = (25 + 34 + 31)/3 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 43:[68, 77, 12] Operation: 8+4=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-12=56. \nResulting numbers: [77, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |56-43|)/2 = (34 + 13)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 43:[77, 56] Operation: 68-12=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-56=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 43:[68, 77, 12]. Operations so far : ['8+4=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-12=65. \nResulting numbers: [68, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |65-43|)/2 = (25 + 22)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 43:[68, 65] Operation: 77-12=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-65=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 43:[68, 77, 12]. Operations so far : ['8+4=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-68=9. \nResulting numbers: [12, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|12-43| + |9-43|)/2 = (31 + 34)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 43:[12, 9] Operation: 77-68=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12+9=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 43:[68, 77, 12]. Operations so far : ['8+4=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+12=80. \nResulting numbers: [77, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |80-43|)/2 = (34 + 37)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 43:[77, 80] Operation: 68+12=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-77=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 43:[68, 77, 12]. Operations so far : ['8+4=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+12=89. \nResulting numbers: [68, 89].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |89-43|)/2 = (25 + 46)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 43:[68, 89] Operation: 77+12=89\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-68=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 43:[68, 77, 12]. Operations so far : ['8+4=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+77=145. \nResulting numbers: [12, 145].\nHeuristic score : (|12-43| + |145-43|)/2 = (31 + 102)/2 = 66.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 43:[12, 145] Operation: 68+77=145\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 145-12=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 43:[68, 77, 12]. Operations so far : ['8+4=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*12=816. \nResulting numbers: [77, 816].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |816-43|)/2 = (34 + 773)/2 = 403.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 43:[77, 816] Operation: 68*12=816\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 816-77=739. \nResulting numbers: [739].\n739,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 43:[68, 77, 12]. Operations so far : ['8+4=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*12=924. \nResulting numbers: [68, 924].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |924-43|)/2 = (25 + 881)/2 = 453.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 43:[68, 924] Operation: 77*12=924\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 924-68=856. \nResulting numbers: [856].\n856,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 43:[68, 77, 12]. Operations so far : ['8+4=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*77=5236. \nResulting numbers: [12, 5236].\nHeuristic score : (|12-43| + |5236-43|)/2 = (31 + 5193)/2 = 2612.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 43:[12, 5236] Operation: 68*77=5236\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5236-12=5224. \nResulting numbers: [5224].\n5224,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 33.25\nCurrent State #0: 43:[68, 8, 4, 77]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-8=69. \nResulting numbers: [68, 4, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |4-43| + |69-43|)/3 = (25 + 39 + 26)/3 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 43:[68, 4, 69] Operation: 77-8=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-4=64. \nResulting numbers: [69, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|69-43| + |64-43|)/2 = (26 + 21)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 43:[69, 64] Operation: 68-4=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-64=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 43:[68, 4, 69]. Operations so far : ['77-8=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-4=65. \nResulting numbers: [68, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |65-43|)/2 = (25 + 22)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 43:[68, 65] Operation: 69-4=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-65=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 43:[68, 4, 69]. Operations so far : ['77-8=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68/4=17. \nResulting numbers: [69, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|69-43| + |17-43|)/2 = (26 + 26)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 43:[69, 17] Operation: 68/4=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-17=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 43:[68, 4, 69]. Operations so far : ['77-8=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+4=72. \nResulting numbers: [69, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|69-43| + |72-43|)/2 = (26 + 29)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 43:[69, 72] Operation: 68+4=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-69=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 43:[68, 4, 69]. Operations so far : ['77-8=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+69=73. \nResulting numbers: [68, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |73-43|)/2 = (25 + 30)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 43:[68, 73] Operation: 4+69=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-68=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 43:[68, 4, 69]. Operations so far : ['77-8=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-68=1. \nResulting numbers: [4, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|4-43| + |1-43|)/2 = (39 + 42)/2 = 40.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 43:[4, 1] Operation: 69-68=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+1=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 43:[68, 4, 69]. Operations so far : ['77-8=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+69=137. \nResulting numbers: [4, 137].\nHeuristic score : (|4-43| + |137-43|)/2 = (39 + 94)/2 = 66.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 43:[4, 137] Operation: 68+69=137\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 137-4=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 43:[68, 4, 69]. Operations so far : ['77-8=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*4=272. \nResulting numbers: [69, 272].\nHeuristic score : (|69-43| + |272-43|)/2 = (26 + 229)/2 = 127.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 43:[69, 272] Operation: 68*4=272\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 272-69=203. \nResulting numbers: [203].\n203,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 43:[68, 4, 69]. Operations so far : ['77-8=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*69=276. \nResulting numbers: [68, 276].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |276-43|)/2 = (25 + 233)/2 = 129.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 43:[68, 276] Operation: 4*69=276\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 276-68=208. \nResulting numbers: [208].\n208,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 43:[68, 4, 69]. Operations so far : ['77-8=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*69=4692. \nResulting numbers: [4, 4692].\nHeuristic score : (|4-43| + |4692-43|)/2 = (39 + 4649)/2 = 2344.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,9: 43:[4, 4692] Operation: 68*69=4692\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4692/4=1173. \nResulting numbers: [1173].\n1173,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 33.25\nCurrent State #0: 43:[68, 8, 4, 77]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-4=73. \nResulting numbers: [68, 8, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |8-43| + |73-43|)/3 = (25 + 35 + 30)/3 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,5: 43:[68, 8, 73] Operation: 77-4=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-8=60. \nResulting numbers: [73, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|73-43| + |60-43|)/2 = (30 + 17)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 43:[73, 60] Operation: 68-8=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-60=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 43:[68, 8, 73]. Operations so far : ['77-4=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-8=65. \nResulting numbers: [68, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |65-43|)/2 = (25 + 22)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 43:[68, 65] Operation: 73-8=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-65=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 43:[68, 8, 73]. Operations so far : ['77-4=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+8=76. \nResulting numbers: [73, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|73-43| + |76-43|)/2 = (30 + 33)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 43:[73, 76] Operation: 68+8=76\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-73=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 43:[68, 8, 73]. Operations so far : ['77-4=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+73=81. \nResulting numbers: [68, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |81-43|)/2 = (25 + 38)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,3: 43:[68, 81] Operation: 8+73=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-68=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 43:[68, 8, 73]. Operations so far : ['77-4=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-68=5. \nResulting numbers: [8, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |5-43|)/2 = (35 + 38)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,4: 43:[8, 5] Operation: 73-68=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*5=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 43:[68, 8, 73]. Operations so far : ['77-4=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+73=141. \nResulting numbers: [8, 141].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |141-43|)/2 = (35 + 98)/2 = 66.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,5: 43:[8, 141] Operation: 68+73=141\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 141-8=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 43:[68, 8, 73]. Operations so far : ['77-4=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*8=544. \nResulting numbers: [73, 544].\nHeuristic score : (|73-43| + |544-43|)/2 = (30 + 501)/2 = 265.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,6: 43:[73, 544] Operation: 68*8=544\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 544-73=471. \nResulting numbers: [471].\n471,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 43:[68, 8, 73]. Operations so far : ['77-4=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*73=584. \nResulting numbers: [68, 584].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |584-43|)/2 = (25 + 541)/2 = 283.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,7: 43:[68, 584] Operation: 8*73=584\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 584-68=516. \nResulting numbers: [516].\n516,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 43:[68, 8, 73]. Operations so far : ['77-4=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*73=4964. \nResulting numbers: [8, 4964].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |4964-43|)/2 = (35 + 4921)/2 = 2478.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,8: 43:[8, 4964] Operation: 68*73=4964\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4964-8=4956. \nResulting numbers: [4956].\n4956,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 33.25\nCurrent State #0: 43:[68, 8, 4, 77]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68/4=17. \nResulting numbers: [8, 77, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |77-43| + |17-43|)/3 = (35 + 34 + 26)/3 = 31.67\nGenerated Node #0,6: 43:[8, 77, 17] Operation: 68/4=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-8=69. \nResulting numbers: [17, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|17-43| + |69-43|)/2 = (26 + 26)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,0: 43:[17, 69] Operation: 77-8=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-17=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 43:[8, 77, 17]. Operations so far : ['68/4=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+17=25. \nResulting numbers: [77, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |25-43|)/2 = (34 + 18)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,1: 43:[77, 25] Operation: 8+17=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-25=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 43:[8, 77, 17]. Operations so far : ['68/4=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-17=60. \nResulting numbers: [8, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |60-43|)/2 = (35 + 17)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,2: 43:[8, 60] Operation: 77-17=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-8=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 43:[8, 77, 17]. Operations so far : ['68/4=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+77=85. \nResulting numbers: [17, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|17-43| + |85-43|)/2 = (26 + 42)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,3: 43:[17, 85] Operation: 8+77=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-17=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 43:[8, 77, 17]. Operations so far : ['68/4=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17-8=9. \nResulting numbers: [77, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |9-43|)/2 = (34 + 34)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,4: 43:[77, 9] Operation: 17-8=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-9=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 43:[8, 77, 17]. Operations so far : ['68/4=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+17=94. \nResulting numbers: [8, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |94-43|)/2 = (35 + 51)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,5: 43:[8, 94] Operation: 77+17=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-8=86. \nResulting numbers: [86].\n86,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 43:[8, 77, 17]. Operations so far : ['68/4=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*17=136. \nResulting numbers: [77, 136].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |136-43|)/2 = (34 + 93)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,6: 43:[77, 136] Operation: 8*17=136\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 136-77=59. \nResulting numbers: [59].\n59,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 43:[8, 77, 17]. Operations so far : ['68/4=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*77=616. \nResulting numbers: [17, 616].\nHeuristic score : (|17-43| + |616-43|)/2 = (26 + 573)/2 = 299.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,7: 43:[17, 616] Operation: 8*77=616\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 616-17=599. \nResulting numbers: [599].\n599,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 43:[8, 77, 17]. Operations so far : ['68/4=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*17=1309. \nResulting numbers: [8, 1309].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |1309-43|)/2 = (35 + 1266)/2 = 650.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,8: 43:[8, 1309] Operation: 77*17=1309\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1309-8=1301. \nResulting numbers: [1301].\n1301,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 33.25\nCurrent State #0: 43:[68, 8, 4, 77]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+4=72. \nResulting numbers: [8, 77, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |77-43| + |72-43|)/3 = (35 + 34 + 29)/3 = 32.67\nGenerated Node #0,7: 43:[8, 77, 72] Operation: 68+4=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-8=69. \nResulting numbers: [72, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|72-43| + |69-43|)/2 = (29 + 26)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,0: 43:[72, 69] Operation: 77-8=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-69=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 43:[8, 77, 72]. Operations so far : ['68+4=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-8=64. \nResulting numbers: [77, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |64-43|)/2 = (34 + 21)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,1: 43:[77, 64] Operation: 72-8=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-64=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 43:[8, 77, 72]. Operations so far : ['68+4=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72/8=9. \nResulting numbers: [77, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |9-43|)/2 = (34 + 34)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,2: 43:[77, 9] Operation: 72/8=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-9=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 43:[8, 77, 72]. Operations so far : ['68+4=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+77=85. \nResulting numbers: [72, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|72-43| + |85-43|)/2 = (29 + 42)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,3: 43:[72, 85] Operation: 8+77=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-72=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 43:[8, 77, 72]. Operations so far : ['68+4=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+72=80. \nResulting numbers: [77, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |80-43|)/2 = (34 + 37)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,4: 43:[77, 80] Operation: 8+72=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-77=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 43:[8, 77, 72]. Operations so far : ['68+4=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-72=5. \nResulting numbers: [8, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |5-43|)/2 = (35 + 38)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,5: 43:[8, 5] Operation: 77-72=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*5=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 43:[8, 77, 72]. Operations so far : ['68+4=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+72=149. \nResulting numbers: [8, 149].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |149-43|)/2 = (35 + 106)/2 = 70.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,6: 43:[8, 149] Operation: 77+72=149\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 149-8=141. \nResulting numbers: [141].\n141,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 43:[8, 77, 72]. Operations so far : ['68+4=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*72=576. \nResulting numbers: [77, 576].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |576-43|)/2 = (34 + 533)/2 = 283.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,7: 43:[77, 576] Operation: 8*72=576\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 576-77=499. \nResulting numbers: [499].\n499,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 43:[8, 77, 72]. Operations so far : ['68+4=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*77=616. \nResulting numbers: [72, 616].\nHeuristic score : (|72-43| + |616-43|)/2 = (29 + 573)/2 = 301.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,8: 43:[72, 616] Operation: 8*77=616\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 616-72=544. \nResulting numbers: [544].\n544,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 43:[8, 77, 72]. Operations so far : ['68+4=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*72=5544. \nResulting numbers: [8, 5544].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |5544-43|)/2 = (35 + 5501)/2 = 2768.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,9: 43:[8, 5544] Operation: 77*72=5544\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5544/8=693. \nResulting numbers: [693].\n693,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 33.25\nCurrent State #0: 43:[68, 8, 4, 77]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8-4=4. \nResulting numbers: [68, 77, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |77-43| + |4-43|)/3 = (25 + 34 + 39)/3 = 32.67\nGenerated Node #0,8: 43:[68, 77, 4] Operation: 8-4=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-4=64. \nResulting numbers: [77, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |64-43|)/2 = (34 + 21)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,0: 43:[77, 64] Operation: 68-4=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-64=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 43:[68, 77, 4]. Operations so far : ['8-4=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-4=73. \nResulting numbers: [68, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |73-43|)/2 = (25 + 30)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,1: 43:[68, 73] Operation: 77-4=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-68=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 43:[68, 77, 4]. Operations so far : ['8-4=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68/4=17. \nResulting numbers: [77, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |17-43|)/2 = (34 + 26)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,2: 43:[77, 17] Operation: 68/4=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-17=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 43:[68, 77, 4]. Operations so far : ['8-4=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+4=72. \nResulting numbers: [77, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |72-43|)/2 = (34 + 29)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,3: 43:[77, 72] Operation: 68+4=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-72=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 43:[68, 77, 4]. Operations so far : ['8-4=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+4=81. \nResulting numbers: [68, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |81-43|)/2 = (25 + 38)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,4: 43:[68, 81] Operation: 77+4=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-68=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 43:[68, 77, 4]. Operations so far : ['8-4=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-68=9. \nResulting numbers: [4, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|4-43| + |9-43|)/2 = (39 + 34)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,5: 43:[4, 9] Operation: 77-68=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*9=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 43:[68, 77, 4]. Operations so far : ['8-4=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+77=145. \nResulting numbers: [4, 145].\nHeuristic score : (|4-43| + |145-43|)/2 = (39 + 102)/2 = 70.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,6: 43:[4, 145] Operation: 68+77=145\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 145-4=141. \nResulting numbers: [141].\n141,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 43:[68, 77, 4]. Operations so far : ['8-4=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*4=272. \nResulting numbers: [77, 272].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |272-43|)/2 = (34 + 229)/2 = 131.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,7: 43:[77, 272] Operation: 68*4=272\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 272-77=195. \nResulting numbers: [195].\n195,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 43:[68, 77, 4]. Operations so far : ['8-4=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*4=308. \nResulting numbers: [68, 308].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |308-43|)/2 = (25 + 265)/2 = 145.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,8: 43:[68, 308] Operation: 77*4=308\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 308-68=240. \nResulting numbers: [240].\n240,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 43:[68, 77, 4]. Operations so far : ['8-4=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*77=5236. \nResulting numbers: [4, 5236].\nHeuristic score : (|4-43| + |5236-43|)/2 = (39 + 5193)/2 = 2616.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,9: 43:[4, 5236] Operation: 68*77=5236\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5236/4=1309. \nResulting numbers: [1309].\n1309,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 33.25\nCurrent State #0: 43:[68, 8, 4, 77]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+77=81. \nResulting numbers: [68, 8, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |8-43| + |81-43|)/3 = (25 + 35 + 38)/3 = 32.67\nGenerated Node #0,9: 43:[68, 8, 81] Operation: 4+77=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-8=60. \nResulting numbers: [81, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|81-43| + |60-43|)/2 = (38 + 17)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,0: 43:[81, 60] Operation: 68-8=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-60=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,9: 43:[68, 8, 81]. Operations so far : ['4+77=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-8=73. \nResulting numbers: [68, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |73-43|)/2 = (25 + 30)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,1: 43:[68, 73] Operation: 81-8=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-68=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,9: 43:[68, 8, 81]. Operations so far : ['4+77=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-68=13. \nResulting numbers: [8, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |13-43|)/2 = (35 + 30)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,2: 43:[8, 13] Operation: 81-68=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+13=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,9: 43:[68, 8, 81]. Operations so far : ['4+77=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+8=76. \nResulting numbers: [81, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|81-43| + |76-43|)/2 = (38 + 33)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,3: 43:[81, 76] Operation: 68+8=76\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-76=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,9: 43:[68, 8, 81]. Operations so far : ['4+77=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+81=89. \nResulting numbers: [68, 89].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |89-43|)/2 = (25 + 46)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,4: 43:[68, 89] Operation: 8+81=89\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-68=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,9: 43:[68, 8, 81]. Operations so far : ['4+77=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+81=149. \nResulting numbers: [8, 149].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |149-43|)/2 = (35 + 106)/2 = 70.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,5: 43:[8, 149] Operation: 68+81=149\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 149-8=141. \nResulting numbers: [141].\n141,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,9: 43:[68, 8, 81]. Operations so far : ['4+77=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*8=544. \nResulting numbers: [81, 544].\nHeuristic score : (|81-43| + |544-43|)/2 = (38 + 501)/2 = 269.50\nGenerated Node #0,9,6: 43:[81, 544] Operation: 68*8=544\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 544-81=463. \nResulting numbers: [463].\n463,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,9: 43:[68, 8, 81]. Operations so far : ['4+77=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*81=648. \nResulting numbers: [68, 648].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |648-43|)/2 = (25 + 605)/2 = 315.00\nGenerated Node #0,9,7: 43:[68, 648] Operation: 8*81=648\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 648-68=580. \nResulting numbers: [580].\n580,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,9 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,9: 43:[68, 8, 81]. Operations so far : ['4+77=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68*81=5508. \nResulting numbers: [8, 5508].\nHeuristic score : (|8-43| + |5508-43|)/2 = (35 + 5465)/2 = 2750.00\nGenerated Node #0,9,8: 43:[8, 5508] Operation: 68*81=5508\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,9,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5508-8=5500. \nResulting numbers: [5500].\n5500,43 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 33.25\nCurrent State #0: 43:[68, 8, 4, 77]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 11th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8/4=2. \nResulting numbers: [68, 77, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|68-43| + |77-43| + |2-43|)/3 = (25 + 34 + 41)/3 = 33.33\nGenerated Node #0,10: 43:[68, 77, 2] Operation: 8/4=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68/2=34. \nResulting numbers: [77, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|77-43| + |34-43|)/2 = (34 + 9)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,10,0: 43:[77, 34] Operation: 68/2=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,10,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-34=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,43 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['8/4=2', '68/2=34', '77-34=43']\nRESULT: 43\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 22,386 |
[
25,
26,
30,
23
]
| 45 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [25, 26, 30, 23] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 45. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [25, 26, 30, 23]. Our goal is to produce 45. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 45:[25, 26, 30, 23]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+23=48. \nResulting numbers: [26, 30, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |30-45| + |48-45|)/3 = (19 + 15 + 3)/3 = 12.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 45:[26, 30, 48] Operation: 25+23=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+30=56. \nResulting numbers: [48, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|48-45| + |56-45|)/2 = (3 + 11)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 45:[48, 56] Operation: 26+30=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-48=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 45:[26, 30, 48]. Operations so far : ['25+23=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-26=22. \nResulting numbers: [30, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |22-45|)/2 = (15 + 23)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 45:[30, 22] Operation: 48-26=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+22=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 45:[26, 30, 48]. Operations so far : ['25+23=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-26=4. \nResulting numbers: [48, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|48-45| + |4-45|)/2 = (3 + 41)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 45:[48, 4] Operation: 30-26=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-4=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 45:[26, 30, 48]. Operations so far : ['25+23=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+48=74. \nResulting numbers: [30, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |74-45|)/2 = (15 + 29)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 45:[30, 74] Operation: 26+48=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-30=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 45:[26, 30, 48]. Operations so far : ['25+23=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-30=18. \nResulting numbers: [26, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |18-45|)/2 = (19 + 27)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 45:[26, 18] Operation: 48-30=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+18=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 45:[26, 30, 48]. Operations so far : ['25+23=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+48=78. \nResulting numbers: [26, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |78-45|)/2 = (19 + 33)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 45:[26, 78] Operation: 30+48=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-26=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 45:[26, 30, 48]. Operations so far : ['25+23=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26*30=780. \nResulting numbers: [48, 780].\nHeuristic score : (|48-45| + |780-45|)/2 = (3 + 735)/2 = 369.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 45:[48, 780] Operation: 26*30=780\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 780-48=732. \nResulting numbers: [732].\n732,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 45:[26, 30, 48]. Operations so far : ['25+23=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26*48=1248. \nResulting numbers: [30, 1248].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |1248-45|)/2 = (15 + 1203)/2 = 609.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 45:[30, 1248] Operation: 26*48=1248\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1248-30=1218. \nResulting numbers: [1218].\n1218,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 45:[26, 30, 48]. Operations so far : ['25+23=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*48=1440. \nResulting numbers: [26, 1440].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |1440-45|)/2 = (19 + 1395)/2 = 707.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 45:[26, 1440] Operation: 30*48=1440\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1440-26=1414. \nResulting numbers: [1414].\n1414,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0: 45:[25, 26, 30, 23]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+23=49. \nResulting numbers: [25, 30, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |30-45| + |49-45|)/3 = (20 + 15 + 4)/3 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 45:[25, 30, 49] Operation: 26+23=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+30=55. \nResulting numbers: [49, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|49-45| + |55-45|)/2 = (4 + 10)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 45:[49, 55] Operation: 25+30=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-49=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 45:[25, 30, 49]. Operations so far : ['26+23=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-25=24. \nResulting numbers: [30, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |24-45|)/2 = (15 + 21)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 45:[30, 24] Operation: 49-25=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+24=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 45:[25, 30, 49]. Operations so far : ['26+23=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-25=5. \nResulting numbers: [49, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|49-45| + |5-45|)/2 = (4 + 40)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 45:[49, 5] Operation: 30-25=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-5=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 45:[25, 30, 49]. Operations so far : ['26+23=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+49=74. \nResulting numbers: [30, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |74-45|)/2 = (15 + 29)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 45:[30, 74] Operation: 25+49=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-30=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 45:[25, 30, 49]. Operations so far : ['26+23=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-30=19. \nResulting numbers: [25, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |19-45|)/2 = (20 + 26)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 45:[25, 19] Operation: 49-30=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+19=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 45:[25, 30, 49]. Operations so far : ['26+23=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+49=79. \nResulting numbers: [25, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |79-45|)/2 = (20 + 34)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 45:[25, 79] Operation: 30+49=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-25=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 45:[25, 30, 49]. Operations so far : ['26+23=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*30=750. \nResulting numbers: [49, 750].\nHeuristic score : (|49-45| + |750-45|)/2 = (4 + 705)/2 = 354.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 45:[49, 750] Operation: 25*30=750\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 750-49=701. \nResulting numbers: [701].\n701,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 45:[25, 30, 49]. Operations so far : ['26+23=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*49=1225. \nResulting numbers: [30, 1225].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |1225-45|)/2 = (15 + 1180)/2 = 597.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 45:[30, 1225] Operation: 25*49=1225\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1225-30=1195. \nResulting numbers: [1195].\n1195,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 45:[25, 30, 49]. Operations so far : ['26+23=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*49=1470. \nResulting numbers: [25, 1470].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |1470-45|)/2 = (20 + 1425)/2 = 722.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 45:[25, 1470] Operation: 30*49=1470\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1470-25=1445. \nResulting numbers: [1445].\n1445,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0: 45:[25, 26, 30, 23]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+26=51. \nResulting numbers: [30, 23, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |23-45| + |51-45|)/3 = (15 + 22 + 6)/3 = 14.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 45:[30, 23, 51] Operation: 25+26=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+23=53. \nResulting numbers: [51, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|51-45| + |53-45|)/2 = (6 + 8)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 45:[51, 53] Operation: 30+23=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-51=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 45:[30, 23, 51]. Operations so far : ['25+26=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-23=28. \nResulting numbers: [30, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |28-45|)/2 = (15 + 17)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 45:[30, 28] Operation: 51-23=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+28=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 45:[30, 23, 51]. Operations so far : ['25+26=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-23=7. \nResulting numbers: [51, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|51-45| + |7-45|)/2 = (6 + 38)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 45:[51, 7] Operation: 30-23=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-7=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 45:[30, 23, 51]. Operations so far : ['25+26=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+51=74. \nResulting numbers: [30, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |74-45|)/2 = (15 + 29)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 45:[30, 74] Operation: 23+51=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-30=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 45:[30, 23, 51]. Operations so far : ['25+26=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-30=21. \nResulting numbers: [23, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|23-45| + |21-45|)/2 = (22 + 24)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 45:[23, 21] Operation: 51-30=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+21=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 45:[30, 23, 51]. Operations so far : ['25+26=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+51=81. \nResulting numbers: [23, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|23-45| + |81-45|)/2 = (22 + 36)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 45:[23, 81] Operation: 30+51=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-23=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 45:[30, 23, 51]. Operations so far : ['25+26=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*23=690. \nResulting numbers: [51, 690].\nHeuristic score : (|51-45| + |690-45|)/2 = (6 + 645)/2 = 325.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 45:[51, 690] Operation: 30*23=690\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 690-51=639. \nResulting numbers: [639].\n639,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 45:[30, 23, 51]. Operations so far : ['25+26=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23*51=1173. \nResulting numbers: [30, 1173].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |1173-45|)/2 = (15 + 1128)/2 = 571.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 45:[30, 1173] Operation: 23*51=1173\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1173-30=1143. \nResulting numbers: [1143].\n1143,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 45:[30, 23, 51]. Operations so far : ['25+26=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*51=1530. \nResulting numbers: [23, 1530].\nHeuristic score : (|23-45| + |1530-45|)/2 = (22 + 1485)/2 = 753.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 45:[23, 1530] Operation: 30*51=1530\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1530-23=1507. \nResulting numbers: [1507].\n1507,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0: 45:[25, 26, 30, 23]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+23=53. \nResulting numbers: [25, 26, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |26-45| + |53-45|)/3 = (20 + 19 + 8)/3 = 15.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 45:[25, 26, 53] Operation: 30+23=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+26=51. \nResulting numbers: [53, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|53-45| + |51-45|)/2 = (8 + 6)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 45:[53, 51] Operation: 25+26=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-51=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 15.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,3: 45:[25, 26, 53]. Operations so far : ['30+23=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-25=28. \nResulting numbers: [26, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |28-45|)/2 = (19 + 17)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 45:[26, 28] Operation: 53-25=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+28=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 15.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,3: 45:[25, 26, 53]. Operations so far : ['30+23=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-26=27. \nResulting numbers: [25, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |27-45|)/2 = (20 + 18)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 45:[25, 27] Operation: 53-26=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+27=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 15.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,3: 45:[25, 26, 53]. Operations so far : ['30+23=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26-25=1. \nResulting numbers: [53, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|53-45| + |1-45|)/2 = (8 + 44)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 45:[53, 1] Operation: 26-25=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-1=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 15.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,3: 45:[25, 26, 53]. Operations so far : ['30+23=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+53=78. \nResulting numbers: [26, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |78-45|)/2 = (19 + 33)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 45:[26, 78] Operation: 25+53=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-26=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 15.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,3: 45:[25, 26, 53]. Operations so far : ['30+23=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+53=79. \nResulting numbers: [25, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |79-45|)/2 = (20 + 34)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 45:[25, 79] Operation: 26+53=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-25=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 15.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,3: 45:[25, 26, 53]. Operations so far : ['30+23=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*26=650. \nResulting numbers: [53, 650].\nHeuristic score : (|53-45| + |650-45|)/2 = (8 + 605)/2 = 306.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 45:[53, 650] Operation: 25*26=650\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 650-53=597. \nResulting numbers: [597].\n597,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 15.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,3: 45:[25, 26, 53]. Operations so far : ['30+23=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*53=1325. \nResulting numbers: [26, 1325].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |1325-45|)/2 = (19 + 1280)/2 = 649.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 45:[26, 1325] Operation: 25*53=1325\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1325-26=1299. \nResulting numbers: [1299].\n1299,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 15.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,3: 45:[25, 26, 53]. Operations so far : ['30+23=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26*53=1378. \nResulting numbers: [25, 1378].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |1378-45|)/2 = (20 + 1333)/2 = 676.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 45:[25, 1378] Operation: 26*53=1378\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1378-25=1353. \nResulting numbers: [1353].\n1353,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0: 45:[25, 26, 30, 23]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+30=55. \nResulting numbers: [26, 23, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |23-45| + |55-45|)/3 = (19 + 22 + 10)/3 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 45:[26, 23, 55] Operation: 25+30=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+23=49. \nResulting numbers: [55, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|55-45| + |49-45|)/2 = (10 + 4)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 45:[55, 49] Operation: 26+23=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-49=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 45:[26, 23, 55]. Operations so far : ['25+30=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-23=32. \nResulting numbers: [26, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |32-45|)/2 = (19 + 13)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 45:[26, 32] Operation: 55-23=32\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+32=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 45:[26, 23, 55]. Operations so far : ['25+30=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-26=29. \nResulting numbers: [23, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|23-45| + |29-45|)/2 = (22 + 16)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 45:[23, 29] Operation: 55-26=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+29=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 45:[26, 23, 55]. Operations so far : ['25+30=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26-23=3. \nResulting numbers: [55, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|55-45| + |3-45|)/2 = (10 + 42)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 45:[55, 3] Operation: 26-23=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-3=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 45:[26, 23, 55]. Operations so far : ['25+30=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+55=78. \nResulting numbers: [26, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |78-45|)/2 = (19 + 33)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 45:[26, 78] Operation: 23+55=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-26=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 45:[26, 23, 55]. Operations so far : ['25+30=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+55=81. \nResulting numbers: [23, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|23-45| + |81-45|)/2 = (22 + 36)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 45:[23, 81] Operation: 26+55=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-23=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 45:[26, 23, 55]. Operations so far : ['25+30=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26*23=598. \nResulting numbers: [55, 598].\nHeuristic score : (|55-45| + |598-45|)/2 = (10 + 553)/2 = 281.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 45:[55, 598] Operation: 26*23=598\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 598-55=543. \nResulting numbers: [543].\n543,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 45:[26, 23, 55]. Operations so far : ['25+30=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23*55=1265. \nResulting numbers: [26, 1265].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |1265-45|)/2 = (19 + 1220)/2 = 619.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 45:[26, 1265] Operation: 23*55=1265\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1265-26=1239. \nResulting numbers: [1239].\n1239,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 45:[26, 23, 55]. Operations so far : ['25+30=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26*55=1430. \nResulting numbers: [23, 1430].\nHeuristic score : (|23-45| + |1430-45|)/2 = (22 + 1385)/2 = 703.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 45:[23, 1430] Operation: 26*55=1430\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1430-23=1407. \nResulting numbers: [1407].\n1407,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0: 45:[25, 26, 30, 23]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+30=56. \nResulting numbers: [25, 23, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |23-45| + |56-45|)/3 = (20 + 22 + 11)/3 = 17.67\nGenerated Node #0,5: 45:[25, 23, 56] Operation: 26+30=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+23=48. \nResulting numbers: [56, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|56-45| + |48-45|)/2 = (11 + 3)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 45:[56, 48] Operation: 25+23=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-48=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 45:[25, 23, 56]. Operations so far : ['26+30=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-23=33. \nResulting numbers: [25, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |33-45|)/2 = (20 + 12)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 45:[25, 33] Operation: 56-23=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+33=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 45:[25, 23, 56]. Operations so far : ['26+30=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-25=31. \nResulting numbers: [23, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|23-45| + |31-45|)/2 = (22 + 14)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 45:[23, 31] Operation: 56-25=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+31=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 45:[25, 23, 56]. Operations so far : ['26+30=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25-23=2. \nResulting numbers: [56, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|56-45| + |2-45|)/2 = (11 + 43)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,3: 45:[56, 2] Operation: 25-23=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-2=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 45:[25, 23, 56]. Operations so far : ['26+30=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+56=79. \nResulting numbers: [25, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |79-45|)/2 = (20 + 34)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,4: 45:[25, 79] Operation: 23+56=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-25=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 45:[25, 23, 56]. Operations so far : ['26+30=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+56=81. \nResulting numbers: [23, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|23-45| + |81-45|)/2 = (22 + 36)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,5: 45:[23, 81] Operation: 25+56=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-23=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 45:[25, 23, 56]. Operations so far : ['26+30=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*23=575. \nResulting numbers: [56, 575].\nHeuristic score : (|56-45| + |575-45|)/2 = (11 + 530)/2 = 270.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,6: 45:[56, 575] Operation: 25*23=575\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 575-56=519. \nResulting numbers: [519].\n519,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 45:[25, 23, 56]. Operations so far : ['26+30=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23*56=1288. \nResulting numbers: [25, 1288].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |1288-45|)/2 = (20 + 1243)/2 = 631.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,7: 45:[25, 1288] Operation: 23*56=1288\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1288-25=1263. \nResulting numbers: [1263].\n1263,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 45:[25, 23, 56]. Operations so far : ['26+30=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*56=1400. \nResulting numbers: [23, 1400].\nHeuristic score : (|23-45| + |1400-45|)/2 = (22 + 1355)/2 = 688.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,8: 45:[23, 1400] Operation: 25*56=1400\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1400-23=1377. \nResulting numbers: [1377].\n1377,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0: 45:[25, 26, 30, 23]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25-23=2. \nResulting numbers: [26, 30, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |30-45| + |2-45|)/3 = (19 + 15 + 43)/3 = 25.67\nGenerated Node #0,6: 45:[26, 30, 2] Operation: 25-23=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26*2=52. \nResulting numbers: [30, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |52-45|)/2 = (15 + 7)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,0: 45:[30, 52] Operation: 26*2=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-30=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 45:[26, 30, 2]. Operations so far : ['25-23=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+2=28. \nResulting numbers: [30, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |28-45|)/2 = (15 + 17)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,1: 45:[30, 28] Operation: 26+2=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+28=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 45:[26, 30, 2]. Operations so far : ['25-23=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+2=32. \nResulting numbers: [26, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |32-45|)/2 = (19 + 13)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,2: 45:[26, 32] Operation: 30+2=32\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+32=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 45:[26, 30, 2]. Operations so far : ['25-23=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*2=60. \nResulting numbers: [26, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |60-45|)/2 = (19 + 15)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,3: 45:[26, 60] Operation: 30*2=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-26=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 45:[26, 30, 2]. Operations so far : ['25-23=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26-2=24. \nResulting numbers: [30, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |24-45|)/2 = (15 + 21)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,4: 45:[30, 24] Operation: 26-2=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+24=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 45:[26, 30, 2]. Operations so far : ['25-23=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-2=28. \nResulting numbers: [26, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |28-45|)/2 = (19 + 17)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,5: 45:[26, 28] Operation: 30-2=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+28=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 45:[26, 30, 2]. Operations so far : ['25-23=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26/2=13. \nResulting numbers: [30, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |13-45|)/2 = (15 + 32)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,6: 45:[30, 13] Operation: 26/2=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+13=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 45:[26, 30, 2]. Operations so far : ['25-23=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30/2=15. \nResulting numbers: [26, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|26-45| + |15-45|)/2 = (19 + 30)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,7: 45:[26, 15] Operation: 30/2=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+15=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 45:[26, 30, 2]. Operations so far : ['25-23=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+30=56. \nResulting numbers: [2, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|2-45| + |56-45|)/2 = (43 + 11)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,8: 45:[2, 56] Operation: 26+30=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-2=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 45:[26, 30, 2]. Operations so far : ['25-23=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-26=4. \nResulting numbers: [2, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|2-45| + |4-45|)/2 = (43 + 41)/2 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,9: 45:[2, 4] Operation: 30-26=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2*4=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,6: 45:[26, 30, 2]. Operations so far : ['25-23=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 11th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26*30=780. \nResulting numbers: [2, 780].\nHeuristic score : (|2-45| + |780-45|)/2 = (43 + 735)/2 = 389.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,10: 45:[2, 780] Operation: 26*30=780\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,10’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 780/2=390. \nResulting numbers: [390].\n390,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0: 45:[25, 26, 30, 23]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26-23=3. \nResulting numbers: [25, 30, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |30-45| + |3-45|)/3 = (20 + 15 + 42)/3 = 25.67\nGenerated Node #0,7: 45:[25, 30, 3] Operation: 26-23=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+3=28. \nResulting numbers: [30, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |28-45|)/2 = (15 + 17)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,0: 45:[30, 28] Operation: 25+3=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+28=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,7: 45:[25, 30, 3]. Operations so far : ['26-23=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+3=33. \nResulting numbers: [25, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |33-45|)/2 = (20 + 12)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,1: 45:[25, 33] Operation: 30+3=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+33=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,7: 45:[25, 30, 3]. Operations so far : ['26-23=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25-3=22. \nResulting numbers: [30, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |22-45|)/2 = (15 + 23)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,2: 45:[30, 22] Operation: 25-3=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+22=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,7: 45:[25, 30, 3]. Operations so far : ['26-23=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-3=27. \nResulting numbers: [25, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|25-45| + |27-45|)/2 = (20 + 18)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,3: 45:[25, 27] Operation: 30-3=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+27=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,45 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,7: 45:[25, 30, 3]. Operations so far : ['26-23=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25*3=75. \nResulting numbers: [30, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|30-45| + |75-45|)/2 = (15 + 30)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,4: 45:[30, 75] Operation: 25*3=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-30=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,45 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['26-23=3', '25*3=75', '75-30=45']\nRESULT: 45\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 16,440 |
[
72,
76,
3,
2
]
| 84 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [72, 76, 3, 2] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 84. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [72, 76, 3, 2]. Our goal is to produce 84. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 84:[72, 76, 3, 2]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+3=75. \nResulting numbers: [76, 2, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|76-84| + |2-84| + |75-84|)/3 = (8 + 82 + 9)/3 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 84:[76, 2, 75] Operation: 72+3=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+2=74. \nResulting numbers: [76, 3, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|76-84| + |3-84| + |74-84|)/3 = (8 + 81 + 10)/3 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 84:[76, 3, 74] Operation: 72+2=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+3=79. \nResulting numbers: [72, 2, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|72-84| + |2-84| + |79-84|)/3 = (12 + 82 + 5)/3 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 84:[72, 2, 79] Operation: 76+3=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+2=78. \nResulting numbers: [72, 3, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|72-84| + |3-84| + |78-84|)/3 = (12 + 81 + 6)/3 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 84:[72, 3, 78] Operation: 76+2=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3*2=6. \nResulting numbers: [72, 76, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|72-84| + |76-84| + |6-84|)/3 = (12 + 8 + 78)/3 = 32.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 84:[72, 76, 6] Operation: 3*2=6\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 84:[72, 76, 6]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+6=78. \nResulting numbers: [76, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|76-84| + |78-84|)/2 = (8 + 6)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 84:[76, 78] Operation: 72+6=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+6=82. \nResulting numbers: [72, 82].\nHeuristic score : (|72-84| + |82-84|)/2 = (12 + 2)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 84:[72, 82] Operation: 76+6=82\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72/6=12. \nResulting numbers: [76, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|76-84| + |12-84|)/2 = (8 + 72)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 84:[76, 12] Operation: 72/6=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-6=66. \nResulting numbers: [76, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|76-84| + |66-84|)/2 = (8 + 18)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 84:[76, 66] Operation: 72-6=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-6=70. \nResulting numbers: [72, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|72-84| + |70-84|)/2 = (12 + 14)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 84:[72, 70] Operation: 76-6=70\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 84:[76, 3, 74]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+74=77. \nResulting numbers: [76, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|76-84| + |77-84|)/2 = (8 + 7)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 84:[76, 77] Operation: 3+74=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+3=79. \nResulting numbers: [74, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|74-84| + |79-84|)/2 = (10 + 5)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 84:[74, 79] Operation: 76+3=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-3=73. \nResulting numbers: [74, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|74-84| + |73-84|)/2 = (10 + 11)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 84:[74, 73] Operation: 76-3=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3*74=222. \nResulting numbers: [76, 222].\nHeuristic score : (|76-84| + |222-84|)/2 = (8 + 138)/2 = 73.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 84:[76, 222] Operation: 3*74=222\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-3=71. \nResulting numbers: [76, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|76-84| + |71-84|)/2 = (8 + 13)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 84:[76, 71] Operation: 74-3=71\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 33.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 84:[72, 3, 78]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+78=81. \nResulting numbers: [72, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|72-84| + |81-84|)/2 = (12 + 3)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 84:[72, 81] Operation: 3+78=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-3=75. \nResulting numbers: [72, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|72-84| + |75-84|)/2 = (12 + 9)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 84:[72, 75] Operation: 78-3=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+3=75. \nResulting numbers: [78, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|78-84| + |75-84|)/2 = (6 + 9)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 84:[78, 75] Operation: 72+3=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-3=69. \nResulting numbers: [78, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|78-84| + |69-84|)/2 = (6 + 15)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 84:[78, 69] Operation: 72-3=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72/3=24. \nResulting numbers: [78, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|78-84| + |24-84|)/2 = (6 + 60)/2 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 84:[78, 24] Operation: 72/3=24\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 33.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 84:[76, 2, 75]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-2=73. \nResulting numbers: [76, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|76-84| + |73-84|)/2 = (8 + 11)/2 = 9.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 84:[76, 73] Operation: 75-2=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2+75=77. \nResulting numbers: [76, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|76-84| + |77-84|)/2 = (8 + 7)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 84:[76, 77] Operation: 2+75=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76/2=38. \nResulting numbers: [75, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|75-84| + |38-84|)/2 = (9 + 46)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 84:[75, 38] Operation: 76/2=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-2=74. \nResulting numbers: [75, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|75-84| + |74-84|)/2 = (9 + 10)/2 = 9.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 84:[75, 74] Operation: 76-2=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+2=78. \nResulting numbers: [75, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|75-84| + |78-84|)/2 = (9 + 6)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 84:[75, 78] Operation: 76+2=78\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 84:[72, 2, 79]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-2=70. \nResulting numbers: [79, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|79-84| + |70-84|)/2 = (5 + 14)/2 = 9.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 84:[79, 70] Operation: 72-2=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+2=74. \nResulting numbers: [79, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|79-84| + |74-84|)/2 = (5 + 10)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 84:[79, 74] Operation: 72+2=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-2=77. \nResulting numbers: [72, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|72-84| + |77-84|)/2 = (12 + 7)/2 = 9.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 84:[72, 77] Operation: 79-2=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2+79=81. \nResulting numbers: [72, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|72-84| + |81-84|)/2 = (12 + 3)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 84:[72, 81] Operation: 2+79=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72/2=36. \nResulting numbers: [79, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|79-84| + |36-84|)/2 = (5 + 48)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 84:[79, 36] Operation: 72/2=36\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 84:[76, 78]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '72+6=78'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+78=154. \nResulting numbers: [154].\n154,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-76=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*78=5928. \nResulting numbers: [5928].\n5928,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 84:[72, 82]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '76+6=82'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+82=154. \nResulting numbers: [154].\n154,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-72=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72*82=5904. \nResulting numbers: [5904].\n5904,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 84:[76, 77]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '3+74=77'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*77=5852. \nResulting numbers: [5852].\n5852,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+77=153. \nResulting numbers: [153].\n153,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-76=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 84:[74, 79]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '76+3=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+79=153. \nResulting numbers: [153].\n153,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-74=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74*79=5846. \nResulting numbers: [5846].\n5846,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 84:[78, 75]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '72+3=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+75=153. \nResulting numbers: [153].\n153,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-75=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*75=5850. \nResulting numbers: [5850].\n5850,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 84:[72, 81]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '3+78=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+81=153. \nResulting numbers: [153].\n153,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72*81=5832. \nResulting numbers: [5832].\n5832,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-72=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 84:[72, 81]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '2+79=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-72=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+81=153. \nResulting numbers: [153].\n153,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72*81=5832. \nResulting numbers: [5832].\n5832,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 84:[79, 74]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '72+2=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*74=5846. \nResulting numbers: [5846].\n5846,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+74=153. \nResulting numbers: [153].\n153,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-74=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 84:[76, 77]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '2+75=77'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+77=153. \nResulting numbers: [153].\n153,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-76=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*77=5852. \nResulting numbers: [5852].\n5852,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 84:[75, 78]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '76+2=78'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+78=153. \nResulting numbers: [153].\n153,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*78=5850. \nResulting numbers: [5850].\n5850,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-75=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 9.5\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 84:[72, 77]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '79-2=77'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-72=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72*77=5544. \nResulting numbers: [5544].\n5544,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+77=149. \nResulting numbers: [149].\n149,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 9.5\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 84:[79, 70]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '72-2=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*70=5530. \nResulting numbers: [5530].\n5530,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-70=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+70=149. \nResulting numbers: [149].\n149,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 9.5\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 84:[76, 73]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '75-2=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*73=5548. \nResulting numbers: [5548].\n5548,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+73=149. \nResulting numbers: [149].\n149,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-73=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 9.5\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 84:[75, 74]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '76-2=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*74=5550. \nResulting numbers: [5550].\n5550,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+74=149. \nResulting numbers: [149].\n149,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-74=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 84:[78, 69]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '72-3=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*69=5382. \nResulting numbers: [5382].\n5382,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+69=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-69=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 84:[72, 75]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '78-3=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-72=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+75=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72*75=5400. \nResulting numbers: [5400].\n5400,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 84:[76, 71]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '74-3=71'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+71=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*71=5396. \nResulting numbers: [5396].\n5396,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-71=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 84:[74, 73]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '76-3=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74*73=5402. \nResulting numbers: [5402].\n5402,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-73=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+73=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 84:[76, 66]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '72-6=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-66=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+66=142. \nResulting numbers: [142].\n142,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*66=5016. \nResulting numbers: [5016].\n5016,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 84:[72, 70]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '76-6=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-70=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72*70=5040. \nResulting numbers: [5040].\n5040,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+70=142. \nResulting numbers: [142].\n142,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 26.5\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 84:[79, 36]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '72/2=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*36=2844. \nResulting numbers: [2844].\n2844,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-36=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+36=115. \nResulting numbers: [115].\n115,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 84:[75, 38]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '76/2=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-38=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+38=113. \nResulting numbers: [113].\n113,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*38=2850. \nResulting numbers: [2850].\n2850,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 33.0\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 84:[78, 24]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '72/3=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+24=102. \nResulting numbers: [102].\n102,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*24=1872. \nResulting numbers: [1872].\n1872,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-24=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 40.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 84:[76, 12]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '72/6=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+12=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-12=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*12=912. \nResulting numbers: [912].\n912,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 58\nCurrent State #0,4,3,1: 84:[142]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '72-6=66', '76+66=142'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,4,2,0: 84:[88]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '72/6=12', '76+12=88'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,3,4,0: 84:[102]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '72/3=24', '78+24=102'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 20\nCurrent State #0,4,2,1: 84:[64]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '72/6=12', '76-12=64'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 29\nCurrent State #0,0,2,1: 84:[113]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '76/2=38', '75+38=113'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,3,4,2: 84:[54]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '72/3=24', '78-24=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 31\nCurrent State #0,2,4,2: 84:[115]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '72/2=36', '79+36=115'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 41\nCurrent State #0,2,4,1: 84:[43]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '72/2=36', '79-36=43'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 47\nCurrent State #0,0,2,0: 84:[37]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '76/2=38', '75-38=37'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 58\nCurrent State #0,4,4,2: 84:[142]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '76-6=70', '72+70=142'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 63\nCurrent State #0,1,2,2: 84:[147]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '76-3=73', '74+73=147'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 63\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 84:[147]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '72-3=69', '78+69=147'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 63\nCurrent State #0,1,4,0: 84:[147]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '74-3=71', '76+71=147'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 63\nCurrent State #0,3,1,1: 84:[147]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '78-3=75', '72+75=147'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,0,3,1: 84:[149]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '76-2=74', '75+74=149'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,0,0,1: 84:[149]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '75-2=73', '76+73=149'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,2,2,2: 84:[149]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '79-2=77', '72+77=149'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 65\nCurrent State #0,2,0,2: 84:[149]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '72-2=70', '79+70=149'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 69\nCurrent State #0,1,1,0: 84:[153]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '76+3=79', '74+79=153'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 69\nCurrent State #0,3,0,0: 84:[153]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '3+78=81', '72+81=153'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 69\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 84:[153]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '3+74=77', '76+77=153'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 69\nCurrent State #0,0,4,0: 84:[153]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '76+2=78', '75+78=153'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 69\nCurrent State #0,0,1,0: 84:[153]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '2+75=77', '76+77=153'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 69\nCurrent State #0,2,1,1: 84:[153]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '72+2=74', '79+74=153'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 69\nCurrent State #0,3,2,0: 84:[153]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '72+3=75', '78+75=153'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 69\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 84:[153]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '2+79=81', '72+81=153'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 70\nCurrent State #0,4,1,0: 84:[154]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '76+6=82', '72+82=154'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 70\nCurrent State #0,4,0,0: 84:[154]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '72+6=78', '76+78=154'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 73.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 84:[76, 222]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '3*74=222'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76+222=298. \nResulting numbers: [298].\n298,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76*222=16872. \nResulting numbers: [16872].\n16872,84 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 222-76=146. \nResulting numbers: [146].\n146,84 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 74\nCurrent State #0,4,3,0: 84:[10]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '72-6=66', '76-66=10'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 74\nCurrent State #0,4,1,1: 84:[10]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '76+6=82', '82-72=10'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 62\nCurrent State #0,1,3,2: 84:[146]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '3*74=222', '222-76=146'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 75\nCurrent State #0,2,0,1: 84:[9]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '72-2=70', '79-70=9'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 75\nCurrent State #0,3,3,2: 84:[9]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '72-3=69', '78-69=9'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 75\nCurrent State #0,2,3,0: 84:[9]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '2+79=81', '81-72=9'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 75\nCurrent State #0,3,0,2: 84:[9]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '3+78=81', '81-72=9'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 79\nCurrent State #0,1,1,1: 84:[5]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '76+3=79', '79-74=5'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 79\nCurrent State #0,1,4,2: 84:[5]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '74-3=71', '76-71=5'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 79\nCurrent State #0,2,2,0: 84:[5]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '79-2=77', '77-72=5'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 79\nCurrent State #0,2,1,2: 84:[5]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '72+2=74', '79-74=5'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 81\nCurrent State #0,3,1,0: 84:[3]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '78-3=75', '75-72=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 81\nCurrent State #0,0,0,2: 84:[3]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '75-2=73', '76-73=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 81\nCurrent State #0,0,4,2: 84:[3]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '76+2=78', '78-75=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 81\nCurrent State #0,3,2,1: 84:[3]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '72+3=75', '78-75=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 82\nCurrent State #0,4,4,0: 84:[2]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '76-6=70', '72-70=2'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 82\nCurrent State #0,4,0,1: 84:[2]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '72+6=78', '78-76=2'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 83\nCurrent State #0,0,1,1: 84:[1]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '2+75=77', '77-76=1'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 83\nCurrent State #0,0,3,2: 84:[1]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '76-2=74', '75-74=1'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 83\nCurrent State #0,1,2,1: 84:[1]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '76-3=73', '74-73=1'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 83\nCurrent State #0,1,0,2: 84:[1]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '3+74=77', '77-76=1'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 214\nCurrent State #0,1,3,0: 84:[298]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '3*74=222', '76+222=298'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 828\nCurrent State #0,4,2,2: 84:[912]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '72/6=12', '76*12=912'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 1788\nCurrent State #0,3,4,1: 84:[1872]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '72/3=24', '78*24=1872'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 2760\nCurrent State #0,2,4,0: 84:[2844]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '72/2=36', '79*36=2844'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 2766\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 84:[2850]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '76/2=38', '75*38=2850'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 4932\nCurrent State #0,4,3,2: 84:[5016]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '72-6=66', '76*66=5016'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 4956\nCurrent State #0,4,4,1: 84:[5040]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '76-6=70', '72*70=5040'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 5298\nCurrent State #0,3,3,0: 84:[5382]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '72-3=69', '78*69=5382'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 5312\nCurrent State #0,1,4,1: 84:[5396]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '74-3=71', '76*71=5396'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 5316\nCurrent State #0,3,1,2: 84:[5400]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '78-3=75', '72*75=5400'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 5318\nCurrent State #0,1,2,0: 84:[5402]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '76-3=73', '74*73=5402'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 5446\nCurrent State #0,2,0,0: 84:[5530]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '72-2=70', '79*70=5530'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 5460\nCurrent State #0,2,2,1: 84:[5544]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '79-2=77', '72*77=5544'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 5464\nCurrent State #0,0,0,0: 84:[5548]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '75-2=73', '76*73=5548'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 5466\nCurrent State #0,0,3,0: 84:[5550]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '76-2=74', '75*74=5550'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 5748\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 84:[5832]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '2+79=81', '72*81=5832'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 5748\nCurrent State #0,3,0,1: 84:[5832]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '3+78=81', '72*81=5832'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 5762\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 84:[5846]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '76+3=79', '74*79=5846'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 5762\nCurrent State #0,2,1,0: 84:[5846]. Operations so far : ['76+3=79', '72+2=74', '79*74=5846'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 5766\nCurrent State #0,3,2,2: 84:[5850]. Operations so far : ['76+2=78', '72+3=75', '78*75=5850'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 5766\nCurrent State #0,0,4,1: 84:[5850]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '76+2=78', '75*78=5850'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 5768\nCurrent State #0,1,0,0: 84:[5852]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '3+74=77', '76*77=5852'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 5768\nCurrent State #0,0,1,2: 84:[5852]. Operations so far : ['72+3=75', '2+75=77', '76*77=5852'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 5820\nCurrent State #0,4,1,2: 84:[5904]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '76+6=82', '72*82=5904'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 5844\nCurrent State #0,4,0,2: 84:[5928]. Operations so far : ['3*2=6', '72+6=78', '76*78=5928'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 16788\nCurrent State #0,1,3,1: 84:[16872]. Operations so far : ['72+2=74', '3*74=222', '76*222=16872'].\n\n```\nSOLUTION: NO\nOPERATIONS: []\nRESULT: None\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 15,879 |
[
11,
29,
11,
56
]
| 49 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [11, 29, 11, 56] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 49. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [11, 29, 11, 56]. Our goal is to produce 49. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 49:[11, 29, 11, 56]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+29=40. \nResulting numbers: [11, 56, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|11-49| + |56-49| + |40-49|)/3 = (38 + 7 + 9)/3 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 49:[11, 56, 40] Operation: 11+29=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+40=51. \nResulting numbers: [56, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|56-49| + |51-49|)/2 = (7 + 2)/2 = 4.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 49:[56, 51] Operation: 11+40=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-51=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,49 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 49:[11, 56, 40]. Operations so far : ['11+29=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-11=45. \nResulting numbers: [40, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|40-49| + |45-49|)/2 = (9 + 4)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 49:[40, 45] Operation: 56-11=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+45=85. \nResulting numbers: [85].\n85,49 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 49:[11, 56, 40]. Operations so far : ['11+29=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+56=67. \nResulting numbers: [40, 67].\nHeuristic score : (|40-49| + |67-49|)/2 = (9 + 18)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 49:[40, 67] Operation: 11+56=67\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-40=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,49 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 49:[11, 56, 40]. Operations so far : ['11+29=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-11=29. \nResulting numbers: [56, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|56-49| + |29-49|)/2 = (7 + 20)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 49:[56, 29] Operation: 40-11=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-29=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,49 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 49:[11, 56, 40]. Operations so far : ['11+29=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-40=16. \nResulting numbers: [11, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|11-49| + |16-49|)/2 = (38 + 33)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 49:[11, 16] Operation: 56-40=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+16=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,49 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 49:[11, 56, 40]. Operations so far : ['11+29=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+40=96. \nResulting numbers: [11, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|11-49| + |96-49|)/2 = (38 + 47)/2 = 42.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 49:[11, 96] Operation: 56+40=96\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-11=85. \nResulting numbers: [85].\n85,49 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 49:[11, 56, 40]. Operations so far : ['11+29=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11*40=440. \nResulting numbers: [56, 440].\nHeuristic score : (|56-49| + |440-49|)/2 = (7 + 391)/2 = 199.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 49:[56, 440] Operation: 11*40=440\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 440-56=384. \nResulting numbers: [384].\n384,49 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 49:[11, 56, 40]. Operations so far : ['11+29=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11*56=616. \nResulting numbers: [40, 616].\nHeuristic score : (|40-49| + |616-49|)/2 = (9 + 567)/2 = 288.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 49:[40, 616] Operation: 11*56=616\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 616-40=576. \nResulting numbers: [576].\n576,49 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 49:[11, 56, 40]. Operations so far : ['11+29=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*40=2240. \nResulting numbers: [11, 2240].\nHeuristic score : (|11-49| + |2240-49|)/2 = (38 + 2191)/2 = 1114.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 49:[11, 2240] Operation: 56*40=2240\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2240-11=2229. \nResulting numbers: [2229].\n2229,49 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 25.75\nCurrent State #0: 49:[11, 29, 11, 56]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+11=22. \nResulting numbers: [29, 56, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|29-49| + |56-49| + |22-49|)/3 = (20 + 7 + 27)/3 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 49:[29, 56, 22] Operation: 11+11=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29+22=51. \nResulting numbers: [56, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|56-49| + |51-49|)/2 = (7 + 2)/2 = 4.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 49:[56, 51] Operation: 29+22=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-51=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,49 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 49:[29, 56, 22]. Operations so far : ['11+11=22'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-22=34. \nResulting numbers: [29, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|29-49| + |34-49|)/2 = (20 + 15)/2 = 17.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 49:[29, 34] Operation: 56-22=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29+34=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,49 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 49:[29, 56, 22]. Operations so far : ['11+11=22'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-29=27. \nResulting numbers: [22, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|22-49| + |27-49|)/2 = (27 + 22)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 49:[22, 27] Operation: 56-29=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+27=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,49 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['11+11=22', '56-29=27', '22+27=49']\nRESULT: 49\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 2,931 |
[
40,
89,
95,
36
]
| 10 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [40, 89, 95, 36] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 10. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [40, 89, 95, 36]. Our goal is to produce 10. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 10:[40, 89, 95, 36]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-89=6. \nResulting numbers: [40, 36, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|40-10| + |36-10| + |6-10|)/3 = (30 + 26 + 4)/3 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 10:[40, 36, 6] Operation: 95-89=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-36=59. \nResulting numbers: [40, 89, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|40-10| + |89-10| + |59-10|)/3 = (30 + 79 + 49)/3 = 52.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 10:[40, 89, 59] Operation: 95-36=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-40=49. \nResulting numbers: [95, 36, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|95-10| + |36-10| + |49-10|)/3 = (85 + 26 + 39)/3 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 10:[95, 36, 49] Operation: 89-40=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-40=55. \nResulting numbers: [89, 36, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|89-10| + |36-10| + |55-10|)/3 = (79 + 26 + 45)/3 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 10:[89, 36, 55] Operation: 95-40=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-36=53. \nResulting numbers: [40, 95, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|40-10| + |95-10| + |53-10|)/3 = (30 + 85 + 43)/3 = 52.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 10:[40, 95, 53] Operation: 89-36=53\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 10:[40, 36, 6]. Operations so far : ['95-89=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-6=34. \nResulting numbers: [36, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|36-10| + |34-10|)/2 = (26 + 24)/2 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 10:[36, 34] Operation: 40-6=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+6=46. \nResulting numbers: [36, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|36-10| + |46-10|)/2 = (26 + 36)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 10:[36, 46] Operation: 40+6=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-36=4. \nResulting numbers: [6, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|6-10| + |4-10|)/2 = (4 + 6)/2 = 5.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 10:[6, 4] Operation: 40-36=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36/6=6. \nResulting numbers: [40, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|40-10| + |6-10|)/2 = (30 + 4)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 10:[40, 6] Operation: 36/6=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-6=30. \nResulting numbers: [40, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|40-10| + |30-10|)/2 = (30 + 20)/2 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 10:[40, 30] Operation: 36-6=30\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 50.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 10:[89, 36, 55]. Operations so far : ['95-40=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-36=19. \nResulting numbers: [89, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|89-10| + |19-10|)/2 = (79 + 9)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 10:[89, 19] Operation: 55-36=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-55=34. \nResulting numbers: [36, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|36-10| + |34-10|)/2 = (26 + 24)/2 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 10:[36, 34] Operation: 89-55=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+55=144. \nResulting numbers: [36, 144].\nHeuristic score : (|36-10| + |144-10|)/2 = (26 + 134)/2 = 80.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 10:[36, 144] Operation: 89+55=144\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+36=125. \nResulting numbers: [55, 125].\nHeuristic score : (|55-10| + |125-10|)/2 = (45 + 115)/2 = 80.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 10:[55, 125] Operation: 89+36=125\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-36=53. \nResulting numbers: [55, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|55-10| + |53-10|)/2 = (45 + 43)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 10:[55, 53] Operation: 89-36=53\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 50.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 10:[95, 36, 49]. Operations so far : ['89-40=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-36=59. \nResulting numbers: [49, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|49-10| + |59-10|)/2 = (39 + 49)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 10:[49, 59] Operation: 95-36=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-49=46. \nResulting numbers: [36, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|36-10| + |46-10|)/2 = (26 + 36)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 10:[36, 46] Operation: 95-49=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-36=13. \nResulting numbers: [95, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|95-10| + |13-10|)/2 = (85 + 3)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 10:[95, 13] Operation: 49-36=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95+36=131. \nResulting numbers: [49, 131].\nHeuristic score : (|49-10| + |131-10|)/2 = (39 + 121)/2 = 80.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 10:[49, 131] Operation: 95+36=131\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95+49=144. \nResulting numbers: [36, 144].\nHeuristic score : (|36-10| + |144-10|)/2 = (26 + 134)/2 = 80.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 10:[36, 144] Operation: 95+49=144\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 52.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 10:[40, 89, 59]. Operations so far : ['95-36=59'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-40=49. \nResulting numbers: [59, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|59-10| + |49-10|)/2 = (49 + 39)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 10:[59, 49] Operation: 89-40=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-40=19. \nResulting numbers: [89, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|89-10| + |19-10|)/2 = (79 + 9)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 10:[89, 19] Operation: 59-40=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-59=30. \nResulting numbers: [40, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|40-10| + |30-10|)/2 = (30 + 20)/2 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 10:[40, 30] Operation: 89-59=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+89=129. \nResulting numbers: [59, 129].\nHeuristic score : (|59-10| + |129-10|)/2 = (49 + 119)/2 = 84.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 10:[59, 129] Operation: 40+89=129\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+59=99. \nResulting numbers: [89, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|89-10| + |99-10|)/2 = (79 + 89)/2 = 84.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 10:[89, 99] Operation: 40+59=99\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 52.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 10:[40, 95, 53]. Operations so far : ['89-36=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+53=93. \nResulting numbers: [95, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|95-10| + |93-10|)/2 = (85 + 83)/2 = 84.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 10:[95, 93] Operation: 40+53=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-40=55. \nResulting numbers: [53, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|53-10| + |55-10|)/2 = (43 + 45)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 10:[53, 55] Operation: 95-40=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-40=13. \nResulting numbers: [95, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|95-10| + |13-10|)/2 = (85 + 3)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 10:[95, 13] Operation: 53-40=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+95=135. \nResulting numbers: [53, 135].\nHeuristic score : (|53-10| + |135-10|)/2 = (43 + 125)/2 = 84.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 10:[53, 135] Operation: 40+95=135\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-53=42. \nResulting numbers: [40, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|40-10| + |42-10|)/2 = (30 + 32)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 10:[40, 42] Operation: 95-53=42\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 5.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 10:[6, 4]. Operations so far : ['95-89=6', '40-36=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6-4=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,10 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+4=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,10 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['95-89=6', '40-36=4', '6-4=2']\nRESULT: 2\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 3,787 |
[
66,
89,
14,
47
]
| 10 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [66, 89, 14, 47] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 10. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [66, 89, 14, 47]. Our goal is to produce 10. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 10:[66, 89, 14, 47]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-47=19. \nResulting numbers: [89, 14, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|89-10| + |14-10| + |19-10|)/3 = (79 + 4 + 9)/3 = 30.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 10:[89, 14, 19] Operation: 66-47=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-14=75. \nResulting numbers: [66, 47, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|66-10| + |47-10| + |75-10|)/3 = (56 + 37 + 65)/3 = 52.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 10:[66, 47, 75] Operation: 89-14=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-47=42. \nResulting numbers: [66, 14, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|66-10| + |14-10| + |42-10|)/3 = (56 + 4 + 32)/3 = 30.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 10:[66, 14, 42] Operation: 89-47=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-66=23. \nResulting numbers: [14, 47, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|14-10| + |47-10| + |23-10|)/3 = (4 + 37 + 13)/3 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 10:[14, 47, 23] Operation: 89-66=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-14=52. \nResulting numbers: [89, 47, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|89-10| + |47-10| + |52-10|)/3 = (79 + 37 + 42)/3 = 52.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 10:[89, 47, 52] Operation: 66-14=52\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 10:[14, 47, 23]. Operations so far : ['89-66=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+23=37. \nResulting numbers: [47, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|47-10| + |37-10|)/2 = (37 + 27)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 10:[47, 37] Operation: 14+23=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-14=33. \nResulting numbers: [23, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|23-10| + |33-10|)/2 = (13 + 23)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 10:[23, 33] Operation: 47-14=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+47=61. \nResulting numbers: [23, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|23-10| + |61-10|)/2 = (13 + 51)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 10:[23, 61] Operation: 14+47=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-23=24. \nResulting numbers: [14, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|14-10| + |24-10|)/2 = (4 + 14)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 10:[14, 24] Operation: 47-23=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23-14=9. \nResulting numbers: [47, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|47-10| + |9-10|)/2 = (37 + 1)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 10:[47, 9] Operation: 23-14=9\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 10:[66, 14, 42]. Operations so far : ['89-47=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+14=80. \nResulting numbers: [42, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|42-10| + |80-10|)/2 = (32 + 70)/2 = 51.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 10:[42, 80] Operation: 66+14=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-14=28. \nResulting numbers: [66, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|66-10| + |28-10|)/2 = (56 + 18)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 10:[66, 28] Operation: 42-14=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42/14=3. \nResulting numbers: [66, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|66-10| + |3-10|)/2 = (56 + 7)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 10:[66, 3] Operation: 42/14=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-42=24. \nResulting numbers: [14, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|14-10| + |24-10|)/2 = (4 + 14)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 10:[14, 24] Operation: 66-42=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-14=52. \nResulting numbers: [42, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|42-10| + |52-10|)/2 = (32 + 42)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 10:[42, 52] Operation: 66-14=52\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 10:[89, 14, 19]. Operations so far : ['66-47=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+14=103. \nResulting numbers: [19, 103].\nHeuristic score : (|19-10| + |103-10|)/2 = (9 + 93)/2 = 51.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 10:[19, 103] Operation: 89+14=103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-19=70. \nResulting numbers: [14, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|14-10| + |70-10|)/2 = (4 + 60)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 10:[14, 70] Operation: 89-19=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+19=108. \nResulting numbers: [14, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|14-10| + |108-10|)/2 = (4 + 98)/2 = 51.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 10:[14, 108] Operation: 89+19=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-14=75. \nResulting numbers: [19, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|19-10| + |75-10|)/2 = (9 + 65)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 10:[19, 75] Operation: 89-14=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 19-14=5. \nResulting numbers: [89, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|89-10| + |5-10|)/2 = (79 + 5)/2 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 10:[89, 5] Operation: 19-14=5\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 52.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 10:[66, 47, 75]. Operations so far : ['89-14=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-47=19. \nResulting numbers: [75, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|75-10| + |19-10|)/2 = (65 + 9)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 10:[75, 19] Operation: 66-47=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-66=9. \nResulting numbers: [47, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|47-10| + |9-10|)/2 = (37 + 1)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 10:[47, 9] Operation: 75-66=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+47=113. \nResulting numbers: [75, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|75-10| + |113-10|)/2 = (65 + 103)/2 = 84.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 10:[75, 113] Operation: 66+47=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+75=141. \nResulting numbers: [47, 141].\nHeuristic score : (|47-10| + |141-10|)/2 = (37 + 131)/2 = 84.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 10:[47, 141] Operation: 66+75=141\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-47=28. \nResulting numbers: [66, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|66-10| + |28-10|)/2 = (56 + 18)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 10:[66, 28] Operation: 75-47=28\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 52.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 10:[89, 47, 52]. Operations so far : ['66-14=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-47=42. \nResulting numbers: [52, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|52-10| + |42-10|)/2 = (42 + 32)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 10:[52, 42] Operation: 89-47=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-52=37. \nResulting numbers: [47, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|47-10| + |37-10|)/2 = (37 + 27)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 10:[47, 37] Operation: 89-52=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-47=5. \nResulting numbers: [89, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|89-10| + |5-10|)/2 = (79 + 5)/2 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 10:[89, 5] Operation: 52-47=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+47=136. \nResulting numbers: [52, 136].\nHeuristic score : (|52-10| + |136-10|)/2 = (42 + 126)/2 = 84.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 10:[52, 136] Operation: 89+47=136\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+52=141. \nResulting numbers: [47, 141].\nHeuristic score : (|47-10| + |141-10|)/2 = (37 + 131)/2 = 84.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 10:[47, 141] Operation: 89+52=141\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 10:[14, 24]. Operations so far : ['89-66=23', '47-23=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14*24=336. \nResulting numbers: [336].\n336,10 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24-14=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,10 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['89-66=23', '47-23=24', '24-14=10']\nRESULT: 10\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 3,795 |
[
97,
87,
98,
10
]
| 99 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [97, 87, 98, 10] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 99. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [97, 87, 98, 10]. Our goal is to produce 99. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 99:[97, 87, 98, 10]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87+10=97. \nResulting numbers: [97, 98, 97].\nHeuristic score : (|97-99| + |98-99| + |97-99|)/3 = (2 + 1 + 2)/3 = 1.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 99:[97, 98, 97] Operation: 87+10=97\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97+97=194. \nResulting numbers: [98, 194].\nHeuristic score : (|98-99| + |194-99|)/2 = (1 + 95)/2 = 48.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 99:[98, 194] Operation: 97+97=194\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 194-98=96. \nResulting numbers: [96].\n96,99 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 1.6666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,0: 99:[97, 98, 97]. Operations so far : ['87+10=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97+98=195. \nResulting numbers: [97, 195].\nHeuristic score : (|97-99| + |195-99|)/2 = (2 + 96)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 99:[97, 195] Operation: 97+98=195\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 195-97=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,99 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 1.6666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,0: 99:[97, 98, 97]. Operations so far : ['87+10=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+97=195. \nResulting numbers: [97, 195].\nHeuristic score : (|97-99| + |195-99|)/2 = (2 + 96)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 99:[97, 195] Operation: 98+97=195\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 195-97=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,99 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 1.6666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,0: 99:[97, 98, 97]. Operations so far : ['87+10=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97/97=1. \nResulting numbers: [98, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|98-99| + |1-99|)/2 = (1 + 98)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 99:[98, 1] Operation: 97/97=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+1=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,99 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['87+10=97', '97/97=1', '98+1=99']\nRESULT: 99\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 1,094 |
[
44,
32,
31,
92
]
| 47 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [44, 32, 31, 92] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 47. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [44, 32, 31, 92]. Our goal is to produce 47. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 47:[44, 32, 31, 92]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+31=63. \nResulting numbers: [44, 92, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|44-47| + |92-47| + |63-47|)/3 = (3 + 45 + 16)/3 = 21.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 47:[44, 92, 63] Operation: 32+31=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-32=60. \nResulting numbers: [44, 31, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|44-47| + |31-47| + |60-47|)/3 = (3 + 16 + 13)/3 = 10.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 47:[44, 31, 60] Operation: 92-32=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+31=75. \nResulting numbers: [32, 92, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|32-47| + |92-47| + |75-47|)/3 = (15 + 45 + 28)/3 = 29.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 47:[32, 92, 75] Operation: 44+31=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-44=48. \nResulting numbers: [32, 31, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|32-47| + |31-47| + |48-47|)/3 = (15 + 16 + 1)/3 = 10.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 47:[32, 31, 48] Operation: 92-44=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-31=61. \nResulting numbers: [44, 32, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|44-47| + |32-47| + |61-47|)/3 = (3 + 15 + 14)/3 = 10.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 47:[44, 32, 61] Operation: 92-31=61\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,1: 47:[44, 31, 60]. Operations so far : ['92-32=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-44=16. \nResulting numbers: [31, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|31-47| + |16-47|)/2 = (16 + 31)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 47:[31, 16] Operation: 60-44=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-31=13. \nResulting numbers: [60, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|60-47| + |13-47|)/2 = (13 + 34)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 47:[60, 13] Operation: 44-31=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31+60=91. \nResulting numbers: [44, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|44-47| + |91-47|)/2 = (3 + 44)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 47:[44, 91] Operation: 31+60=91\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+31=75. \nResulting numbers: [60, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|60-47| + |75-47|)/2 = (13 + 28)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 47:[60, 75] Operation: 44+31=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-31=29. \nResulting numbers: [44, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|44-47| + |29-47|)/2 = (3 + 18)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 47:[44, 29] Operation: 60-31=29\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,4: 47:[44, 32, 61]. Operations so far : ['92-31=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+61=93. \nResulting numbers: [44, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|44-47| + |93-47|)/2 = (3 + 46)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 47:[44, 93] Operation: 32+61=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-32=29. \nResulting numbers: [44, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|44-47| + |29-47|)/2 = (3 + 18)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 47:[44, 29] Operation: 61-32=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+32=76. \nResulting numbers: [61, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|61-47| + |76-47|)/2 = (14 + 29)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 47:[61, 76] Operation: 44+32=76\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-44=17. \nResulting numbers: [32, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|32-47| + |17-47|)/2 = (15 + 30)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 47:[32, 17] Operation: 61-44=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-32=12. \nResulting numbers: [61, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|61-47| + |12-47|)/2 = (14 + 35)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 47:[61, 12] Operation: 44-32=12\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,3: 47:[32, 31, 48]. Operations so far : ['92-44=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-31=1. \nResulting numbers: [48, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|48-47| + |1-47|)/2 = (1 + 46)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 47:[48, 1] Operation: 32-31=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+31=63. \nResulting numbers: [48, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|48-47| + |63-47|)/2 = (1 + 16)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 47:[48, 63] Operation: 32+31=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-31=17. \nResulting numbers: [32, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|32-47| + |17-47|)/2 = (15 + 30)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 47:[32, 17] Operation: 48-31=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31+48=79. \nResulting numbers: [32, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|32-47| + |79-47|)/2 = (15 + 32)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 47:[32, 79] Operation: 31+48=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-32=16. \nResulting numbers: [31, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|31-47| + |16-47|)/2 = (16 + 31)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 47:[31, 16] Operation: 48-32=16\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 47:[44, 92, 63]. Operations so far : ['32+31=63'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+63=107. \nResulting numbers: [92, 107].\nHeuristic score : (|92-47| + |107-47|)/2 = (45 + 60)/2 = 52.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 47:[92, 107] Operation: 44+63=107\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+92=136. \nResulting numbers: [63, 136].\nHeuristic score : (|63-47| + |136-47|)/2 = (16 + 89)/2 = 52.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 47:[63, 136] Operation: 44+92=136\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-44=48. \nResulting numbers: [63, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|63-47| + |48-47|)/2 = (16 + 1)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 47:[63, 48] Operation: 92-44=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-44=19. \nResulting numbers: [92, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|92-47| + |19-47|)/2 = (45 + 28)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 47:[92, 19] Operation: 63-44=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-63=29. \nResulting numbers: [44, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|44-47| + |29-47|)/2 = (3 + 18)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 47:[44, 29] Operation: 92-63=29\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 29.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 47:[32, 92, 75]. Operations so far : ['44+31=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+92=124. \nResulting numbers: [75, 124].\nHeuristic score : (|75-47| + |124-47|)/2 = (28 + 77)/2 = 52.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 47:[75, 124] Operation: 32+92=124\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+75=107. \nResulting numbers: [92, 107].\nHeuristic score : (|92-47| + |107-47|)/2 = (45 + 60)/2 = 52.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 47:[92, 107] Operation: 32+75=107\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-32=60. \nResulting numbers: [75, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|75-47| + |60-47|)/2 = (28 + 13)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 47:[75, 60] Operation: 92-32=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-75=17. \nResulting numbers: [32, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|32-47| + |17-47|)/2 = (15 + 30)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 47:[32, 17] Operation: 92-75=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-32=43. \nResulting numbers: [92, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|92-47| + |43-47|)/2 = (45 + 4)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 47:[92, 43] Operation: 75-32=43\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 8.5\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 47:[48, 63]. Operations so far : ['92-44=48', '32+31=63'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48*63=3024. \nResulting numbers: [3024].\n3024,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+63=111. \nResulting numbers: [111].\n111,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-48=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,47 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 8.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 47:[63, 48]. Operations so far : ['32+31=63', '92-44=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-48=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+48=111. \nResulting numbers: [111].\n111,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63*48=3024. \nResulting numbers: [3024].\n3024,47 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 47:[44, 29]. Operations so far : ['92-31=61', '61-32=29'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*29=1276. \nResulting numbers: [1276].\n1276,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-29=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+29=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,47 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 47:[44, 29]. Operations so far : ['92-32=60', '60-31=29'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*29=1276. \nResulting numbers: [1276].\n1276,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+29=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-29=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,47 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 47:[44, 29]. Operations so far : ['32+31=63', '92-63=29'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+29=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-29=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*29=1276. \nResulting numbers: [1276].\n1276,47 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 20.5\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 47:[60, 75]. Operations so far : ['92-32=60', '44+31=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+75=135. \nResulting numbers: [135].\n135,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-60=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*75=4500. \nResulting numbers: [4500].\n4500,47 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.5\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 47:[75, 60]. Operations so far : ['44+31=75', '92-32=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*60=4500. \nResulting numbers: [4500].\n4500,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+60=135. \nResulting numbers: [135].\n135,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-60=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,47 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 47:[61, 76]. Operations so far : ['92-31=61', '44+32=76'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+76=137. \nResulting numbers: [137].\n137,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-61=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*76=4636. \nResulting numbers: [4636].\n4636,47 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 47:[32, 17]. Operations so far : ['92-44=48', '48-31=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*17=544. \nResulting numbers: [544].\n544,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-17=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+17=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,47 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 47:[32, 17]. Operations so far : ['44+31=75', '92-75=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-17=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+17=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*17=544. \nResulting numbers: [544].\n544,47 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,3,2,2: 47:[49]. Operations so far : ['92-44=48', '48-31=17', '32+17=49'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 47:[49]. Operations so far : ['44+31=75', '92-75=17', '32+17=49'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 47:[32, 17]. Operations so far : ['92-31=61', '61-44=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-17=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*17=544. \nResulting numbers: [544].\n544,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+17=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,47 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 23.5\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 47:[31, 16]. Operations so far : ['92-44=48', '48-32=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31*16=496. \nResulting numbers: [496].\n496,47 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31+16=47. \nResulting numbers: [47].\n47,47 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['92-44=48', '48-32=16', '31-16=15']\nRESULT: 15\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 6,596 |
[
83,
50,
73,
69
]
| 80 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [83, 50, 73, 69] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 80. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [83, 50, 73, 69]. Our goal is to produce 80. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 80:[83, 50, 73, 69]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+69=119. \nResulting numbers: [83, 73, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|83-80| + |73-80| + |119-80|)/3 = (3 + 7 + 39)/3 = 16.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 80:[83, 73, 119] Operation: 50+69=119\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 119-73=46. \nResulting numbers: [83, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|83-80| + |46-80|)/2 = (3 + 34)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 80:[83, 46] Operation: 119-73=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-46=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 80:[83, 73, 119]. Operations so far : ['50+69=119'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 119-83=36. \nResulting numbers: [73, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|73-80| + |36-80|)/2 = (7 + 44)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 80:[73, 36] Operation: 119-83=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+36=109. \nResulting numbers: [109].\n109,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 80:[83, 73, 119]. Operations so far : ['50+69=119'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-73=10. \nResulting numbers: [119, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|119-80| + |10-80|)/2 = (39 + 70)/2 = 54.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 80:[119, 10] Operation: 83-73=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 119-10=109. \nResulting numbers: [109].\n109,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 80:[83, 73, 119]. Operations so far : ['50+69=119'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+73=156. \nResulting numbers: [119, 156].\nHeuristic score : (|119-80| + |156-80|)/2 = (39 + 76)/2 = 57.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 80:[119, 156] Operation: 83+73=156\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 156-119=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 80:[83, 73, 119]. Operations so far : ['50+69=119'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+119=192. \nResulting numbers: [83, 192].\nHeuristic score : (|83-80| + |192-80|)/2 = (3 + 112)/2 = 57.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 80:[83, 192] Operation: 73+119=192\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 192-83=109. \nResulting numbers: [109].\n109,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 80:[83, 73, 119]. Operations so far : ['50+69=119'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+119=202. \nResulting numbers: [73, 202].\nHeuristic score : (|73-80| + |202-80|)/2 = (7 + 122)/2 = 64.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 80:[73, 202] Operation: 83+119=202\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 202-73=129. \nResulting numbers: [129].\n129,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 80:[83, 73, 119]. Operations so far : ['50+69=119'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*73=6059. \nResulting numbers: [119, 6059].\nHeuristic score : (|119-80| + |6059-80|)/2 = (39 + 5979)/2 = 3009.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 80:[119, 6059] Operation: 83*73=6059\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6059-119=5940. \nResulting numbers: [5940].\n5940,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 80:[83, 73, 119]. Operations so far : ['50+69=119'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73*119=8687. \nResulting numbers: [83, 8687].\nHeuristic score : (|83-80| + |8687-80|)/2 = (3 + 8607)/2 = 4305.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 80:[83, 8687] Operation: 73*119=8687\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8687-83=8604. \nResulting numbers: [8604].\n8604,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 80:[83, 73, 119]. Operations so far : ['50+69=119'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*119=9877. \nResulting numbers: [73, 9877].\nHeuristic score : (|73-80| + |9877-80|)/2 = (7 + 9797)/2 = 4902.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 80:[73, 9877] Operation: 83*119=9877\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9877-73=9804. \nResulting numbers: [9804].\n9804,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 12.75\nCurrent State #0: 80:[83, 50, 73, 69]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+73=123. \nResulting numbers: [83, 69, 123].\nHeuristic score : (|83-80| + |69-80| + |123-80|)/3 = (3 + 11 + 43)/3 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 80:[83, 69, 123] Operation: 50+73=123\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 123-69=54. \nResulting numbers: [83, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|83-80| + |54-80|)/2 = (3 + 26)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 80:[83, 54] Operation: 123-69=54\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-54=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 80:[83, 69, 123]. Operations so far : ['50+73=123'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 123-83=40. \nResulting numbers: [69, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|69-80| + |40-80|)/2 = (11 + 40)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 80:[69, 40] Operation: 123-83=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+40=109. \nResulting numbers: [109].\n109,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 80:[83, 69, 123]. Operations so far : ['50+73=123'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-69=14. \nResulting numbers: [123, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|123-80| + |14-80|)/2 = (43 + 66)/2 = 54.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 80:[123, 14] Operation: 83-69=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 123-14=109. \nResulting numbers: [109].\n109,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 80:[83, 69, 123]. Operations so far : ['50+73=123'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+69=152. \nResulting numbers: [123, 152].\nHeuristic score : (|123-80| + |152-80|)/2 = (43 + 72)/2 = 57.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 80:[123, 152] Operation: 83+69=152\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 152-123=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 80:[83, 69, 123]. Operations so far : ['50+73=123'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+123=192. \nResulting numbers: [83, 192].\nHeuristic score : (|83-80| + |192-80|)/2 = (3 + 112)/2 = 57.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 80:[83, 192] Operation: 69+123=192\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 192-83=109. \nResulting numbers: [109].\n109,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 80:[83, 69, 123]. Operations so far : ['50+73=123'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+123=206. \nResulting numbers: [69, 206].\nHeuristic score : (|69-80| + |206-80|)/2 = (11 + 126)/2 = 68.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 80:[69, 206] Operation: 83+123=206\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 206-69=137. \nResulting numbers: [137].\n137,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 80:[83, 69, 123]. Operations so far : ['50+73=123'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*69=5727. \nResulting numbers: [123, 5727].\nHeuristic score : (|123-80| + |5727-80|)/2 = (43 + 5647)/2 = 2845.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 80:[123, 5727] Operation: 83*69=5727\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5727-123=5604. \nResulting numbers: [5604].\n5604,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 80:[83, 69, 123]. Operations so far : ['50+73=123'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*123=8487. \nResulting numbers: [83, 8487].\nHeuristic score : (|83-80| + |8487-80|)/2 = (3 + 8407)/2 = 4205.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 80:[83, 8487] Operation: 69*123=8487\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8487-83=8404. \nResulting numbers: [8404].\n8404,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 80:[83, 69, 123]. Operations so far : ['50+73=123'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*123=10209. \nResulting numbers: [69, 10209].\nHeuristic score : (|69-80| + |10209-80|)/2 = (11 + 10129)/2 = 5070.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 80:[69, 10209] Operation: 83*123=10209\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 10209-69=10140. \nResulting numbers: [10140].\n10140,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 12.75\nCurrent State #0: 80:[83, 50, 73, 69]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-50=33. \nResulting numbers: [73, 69, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|73-80| + |69-80| + |33-80|)/3 = (7 + 11 + 47)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 80:[73, 69, 33] Operation: 83-50=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+33=102. \nResulting numbers: [73, 102].\nHeuristic score : (|73-80| + |102-80|)/2 = (7 + 22)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 80:[73, 102] Operation: 69+33=102\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102-73=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 80:[73, 69, 33]. Operations so far : ['83-50=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+33=106. \nResulting numbers: [69, 106].\nHeuristic score : (|69-80| + |106-80|)/2 = (11 + 26)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 80:[69, 106] Operation: 73+33=106\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 106-69=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 80:[73, 69, 33]. Operations so far : ['83-50=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-33=40. \nResulting numbers: [69, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|69-80| + |40-80|)/2 = (11 + 40)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 80:[69, 40] Operation: 73-33=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+40=109. \nResulting numbers: [109].\n109,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 80:[73, 69, 33]. Operations so far : ['83-50=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-33=36. \nResulting numbers: [73, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|73-80| + |36-80|)/2 = (7 + 44)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 80:[73, 36] Operation: 69-33=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+36=109. \nResulting numbers: [109].\n109,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 80:[73, 69, 33]. Operations so far : ['83-50=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+69=142. \nResulting numbers: [33, 142].\nHeuristic score : (|33-80| + |142-80|)/2 = (47 + 62)/2 = 54.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 80:[33, 142] Operation: 73+69=142\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 142-33=109. \nResulting numbers: [109].\n109,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 80:[73, 69, 33]. Operations so far : ['83-50=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-69=4. \nResulting numbers: [33, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|33-80| + |4-80|)/2 = (47 + 76)/2 = 61.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 80:[33, 4] Operation: 73-69=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+4=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 80:[73, 69, 33]. Operations so far : ['83-50=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*33=2277. \nResulting numbers: [73, 2277].\nHeuristic score : (|73-80| + |2277-80|)/2 = (7 + 2197)/2 = 1102.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 80:[73, 2277] Operation: 69*33=2277\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2277-73=2204. \nResulting numbers: [2204].\n2204,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 80:[73, 69, 33]. Operations so far : ['83-50=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73*33=2409. \nResulting numbers: [69, 2409].\nHeuristic score : (|69-80| + |2409-80|)/2 = (11 + 2329)/2 = 1170.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 80:[69, 2409] Operation: 73*33=2409\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2409-69=2340. \nResulting numbers: [2340].\n2340,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 80:[73, 69, 33]. Operations so far : ['83-50=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73*69=5037. \nResulting numbers: [33, 5037].\nHeuristic score : (|33-80| + |5037-80|)/2 = (47 + 4957)/2 = 2502.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 80:[33, 5037] Operation: 73*69=5037\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5037-33=5004. \nResulting numbers: [5004].\n5004,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 12.75\nCurrent State #0: 80:[83, 50, 73, 69]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+50=133. \nResulting numbers: [73, 69, 133].\nHeuristic score : (|73-80| + |69-80| + |133-80|)/3 = (7 + 11 + 53)/3 = 23.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 80:[73, 69, 133] Operation: 83+50=133\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 133-69=64. \nResulting numbers: [73, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|73-80| + |64-80|)/2 = (7 + 16)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 80:[73, 64] Operation: 133-69=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+64=137. \nResulting numbers: [137].\n137,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 80:[73, 69, 133]. Operations so far : ['83+50=133'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 133-73=60. \nResulting numbers: [69, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|69-80| + |60-80|)/2 = (11 + 20)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 80:[69, 60] Operation: 133-73=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+60=129. \nResulting numbers: [129].\n129,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 80:[73, 69, 133]. Operations so far : ['83+50=133'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+69=142. \nResulting numbers: [133, 142].\nHeuristic score : (|133-80| + |142-80|)/2 = (53 + 62)/2 = 57.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 80:[133, 142] Operation: 73+69=142\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 142-133=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 80:[73, 69, 133]. Operations so far : ['83+50=133'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-69=4. \nResulting numbers: [133, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|133-80| + |4-80|)/2 = (53 + 76)/2 = 64.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 80:[133, 4] Operation: 73-69=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 133-4=129. \nResulting numbers: [129].\n129,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 80:[73, 69, 133]. Operations so far : ['83+50=133'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+133=202. \nResulting numbers: [73, 202].\nHeuristic score : (|73-80| + |202-80|)/2 = (7 + 122)/2 = 64.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 80:[73, 202] Operation: 69+133=202\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 202-73=129. \nResulting numbers: [129].\n129,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 80:[73, 69, 133]. Operations so far : ['83+50=133'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+133=206. \nResulting numbers: [69, 206].\nHeuristic score : (|69-80| + |206-80|)/2 = (11 + 126)/2 = 68.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 80:[69, 206] Operation: 73+133=206\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 206-69=137. \nResulting numbers: [137].\n137,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 80:[73, 69, 133]. Operations so far : ['83+50=133'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73*69=5037. \nResulting numbers: [133, 5037].\nHeuristic score : (|133-80| + |5037-80|)/2 = (53 + 4957)/2 = 2505.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 80:[133, 5037] Operation: 73*69=5037\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5037-133=4904. \nResulting numbers: [4904].\n4904,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 80:[73, 69, 133]. Operations so far : ['83+50=133'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*133=9177. \nResulting numbers: [73, 9177].\nHeuristic score : (|73-80| + |9177-80|)/2 = (7 + 9097)/2 = 4552.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 80:[73, 9177] Operation: 69*133=9177\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9177-73=9104. \nResulting numbers: [9104].\n9104,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 80:[73, 69, 133]. Operations so far : ['83+50=133'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73*133=9709. \nResulting numbers: [69, 9709].\nHeuristic score : (|69-80| + |9709-80|)/2 = (11 + 9629)/2 = 4820.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 80:[69, 9709] Operation: 73*133=9709\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9709-69=9640. \nResulting numbers: [9640].\n9640,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 12.75\nCurrent State #0: 80:[83, 50, 73, 69]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-50=23. \nResulting numbers: [83, 69, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|83-80| + |69-80| + |23-80|)/3 = (3 + 11 + 57)/3 = 23.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 80:[83, 69, 23] Operation: 73-50=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+23=92. \nResulting numbers: [83, 92].\nHeuristic score : (|83-80| + |92-80|)/2 = (3 + 12)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 80:[83, 92] Operation: 69+23=92\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-83=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 80:[83, 69, 23]. Operations so far : ['73-50=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-23=60. \nResulting numbers: [69, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|69-80| + |60-80|)/2 = (11 + 20)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 80:[69, 60] Operation: 83-23=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+60=129. \nResulting numbers: [129].\n129,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 80:[83, 69, 23]. Operations so far : ['73-50=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+23=106. \nResulting numbers: [69, 106].\nHeuristic score : (|69-80| + |106-80|)/2 = (11 + 26)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 80:[69, 106] Operation: 83+23=106\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 106-69=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 80:[83, 69, 23]. Operations so far : ['73-50=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-23=46. \nResulting numbers: [83, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|83-80| + |46-80|)/2 = (3 + 34)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 80:[83, 46] Operation: 69-23=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-46=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,80 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 80:[83, 69, 23]. Operations so far : ['73-50=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69/23=3. \nResulting numbers: [83, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|83-80| + |3-80|)/2 = (3 + 77)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 80:[83, 3] Operation: 69/23=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-3=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,80 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['73-50=23', '69/23=3', '83-3=80']\nRESULT: 80\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 9,772 |
[
59,
56,
66,
12
]
| 61 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [59, 56, 66, 12] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 61. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [59, 56, 66, 12]. Our goal is to produce 61. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 61:[59, 56, 66, 12]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+12=71. \nResulting numbers: [56, 66, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|56-61| + |66-61| + |71-61|)/3 = (5 + 5 + 10)/3 = 6.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 61:[56, 66, 71] Operation: 59+12=71\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-12=44. \nResulting numbers: [59, 66, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|59-61| + |66-61| + |44-61|)/3 = (2 + 5 + 17)/3 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 61:[59, 66, 44] Operation: 56-12=44\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-12=47. \nResulting numbers: [56, 66, 47].\nHeuristic score : (|56-61| + |66-61| + |47-61|)/3 = (5 + 5 + 14)/3 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 61:[56, 66, 47] Operation: 59-12=47\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-12=54. \nResulting numbers: [59, 56, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|59-61| + |56-61| + |54-61|)/3 = (2 + 5 + 7)/3 = 4.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 61:[59, 56, 54] Operation: 66-12=54\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+12=68. \nResulting numbers: [59, 66, 68].\nHeuristic score : (|59-61| + |66-61| + |68-61|)/3 = (2 + 5 + 7)/3 = 4.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 61:[59, 66, 68] Operation: 56+12=68\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 4.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,3: 61:[59, 56, 54]. Operations so far : ['66-12=54'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+54=113. \nResulting numbers: [56, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|56-61| + |113-61|)/2 = (5 + 52)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 61:[56, 113] Operation: 59+54=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+56=115. \nResulting numbers: [54, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|54-61| + |115-61|)/2 = (7 + 54)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 61:[54, 115] Operation: 59+56=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-54=2. \nResulting numbers: [59, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|59-61| + |2-61|)/2 = (2 + 59)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 61:[59, 2] Operation: 56-54=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+54=110. \nResulting numbers: [59, 110].\nHeuristic score : (|59-61| + |110-61|)/2 = (2 + 49)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 61:[59, 110] Operation: 56+54=110\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-54=5. \nResulting numbers: [56, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|56-61| + |5-61|)/2 = (5 + 56)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 61:[56, 5] Operation: 59-54=5\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 4.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,4: 61:[59, 66, 68]. Operations so far : ['56+12=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+68=127. \nResulting numbers: [66, 127].\nHeuristic score : (|66-61| + |127-61|)/2 = (5 + 66)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 61:[66, 127] Operation: 59+68=127\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-66=2. \nResulting numbers: [59, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|59-61| + |2-61|)/2 = (2 + 59)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 61:[59, 2] Operation: 68-66=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-59=7. \nResulting numbers: [68, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|68-61| + |7-61|)/2 = (7 + 54)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 61:[68, 7] Operation: 66-59=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+66=125. \nResulting numbers: [68, 125].\nHeuristic score : (|68-61| + |125-61|)/2 = (7 + 64)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 61:[68, 125] Operation: 59+66=125\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-59=9. \nResulting numbers: [66, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|66-61| + |9-61|)/2 = (5 + 52)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 61:[66, 9] Operation: 68-59=9\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 6.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,0: 61:[56, 66, 71]. Operations so far : ['59+12=71'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+66=122. \nResulting numbers: [71, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|71-61| + |122-61|)/2 = (10 + 61)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 61:[71, 122] Operation: 56+66=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-56=10. \nResulting numbers: [71, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|71-61| + |10-61|)/2 = (10 + 51)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 61:[71, 10] Operation: 66-56=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-56=15. \nResulting numbers: [66, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|66-61| + |15-61|)/2 = (5 + 46)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 61:[66, 15] Operation: 71-56=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-66=5. \nResulting numbers: [56, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|56-61| + |5-61|)/2 = (5 + 56)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 61:[56, 5] Operation: 71-66=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+71=127. \nResulting numbers: [66, 127].\nHeuristic score : (|66-61| + |127-61|)/2 = (5 + 66)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 61:[66, 127] Operation: 56+71=127\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 8.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 61:[59, 66, 44]. Operations so far : ['56-12=44'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-44=22. \nResulting numbers: [59, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|59-61| + |22-61|)/2 = (2 + 39)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 61:[59, 22] Operation: 66-44=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-44=15. \nResulting numbers: [66, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|66-61| + |15-61|)/2 = (5 + 46)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 61:[66, 15] Operation: 59-44=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-59=7. \nResulting numbers: [44, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|44-61| + |7-61|)/2 = (17 + 54)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 61:[44, 7] Operation: 66-59=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+44=103. \nResulting numbers: [66, 103].\nHeuristic score : (|66-61| + |103-61|)/2 = (5 + 42)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 61:[66, 103] Operation: 59+44=103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+44=110. \nResulting numbers: [59, 110].\nHeuristic score : (|59-61| + |110-61|)/2 = (2 + 49)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 61:[59, 110] Operation: 66+44=110\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 8.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 61:[56, 66, 47]. Operations so far : ['59-12=47'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-56=10. \nResulting numbers: [47, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|47-61| + |10-61|)/2 = (14 + 51)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 61:[47, 10] Operation: 66-56=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-47=9. \nResulting numbers: [66, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|66-61| + |9-61|)/2 = (5 + 52)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 61:[66, 9] Operation: 56-47=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+47=103. \nResulting numbers: [66, 103].\nHeuristic score : (|66-61| + |103-61|)/2 = (5 + 42)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 61:[66, 103] Operation: 56+47=103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-47=19. \nResulting numbers: [56, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|56-61| + |19-61|)/2 = (5 + 42)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 61:[56, 19] Operation: 66-47=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+47=113. \nResulting numbers: [56, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|56-61| + |113-61|)/2 = (5 + 52)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 61:[56, 113] Operation: 66+47=113\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.5\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 61:[59, 22]. Operations so far : ['56-12=44', '66-44=22'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+22=81. \nResulting numbers: [81].\n81,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-22=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59*22=1298. \nResulting numbers: [1298].\n1298,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.5\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 61:[66, 103]. Operations so far : ['56-12=44', '59+44=103'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+103=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66*103=6798. \nResulting numbers: [6798].\n6798,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 103-66=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 23.5\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 61:[66, 103]. Operations so far : ['59-12=47', '56+47=103'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 103-66=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+103=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66*103=6798. \nResulting numbers: [6798].\n6798,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.5\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 61:[56, 19]. Operations so far : ['59-12=47', '66-47=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-19=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+19=75. \nResulting numbers: [75].\n75,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*19=1064. \nResulting numbers: [1064].\n1064,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.5\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 61:[59, 110]. Operations so far : ['66-12=54', '56+54=110'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59*110=6490. \nResulting numbers: [6490].\n6490,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+110=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 110-59=51. \nResulting numbers: [51].\n51,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,3,3,2: 61:[51]. Operations so far : ['66-12=54', '56+54=110', '110-59=51'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 61:[75]. Operations so far : ['59-12=47', '66-47=19', '56+19=75'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20\nCurrent State #0,1,0,0: 61:[81]. Operations so far : ['56-12=44', '66-44=22', '59+22=81'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,1,3,2: 61:[37]. Operations so far : ['56-12=44', '59+44=103', '103-66=37'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,2,3,0: 61:[37]. Operations so far : ['59-12=47', '66-47=19', '56-19=37'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,2,2,0: 61:[37]. Operations so far : ['59-12=47', '56+47=103', '103-66=37'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 61:[37]. Operations so far : ['56-12=44', '66-44=22', '59-22=37'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 25.5\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 61:[66, 15]. Operations so far : ['56-12=44', '59-44=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66*15=990. \nResulting numbers: [990].\n990,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+15=81. \nResulting numbers: [81].\n81,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-15=51. \nResulting numbers: [51].\n51,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 61:[59, 110]. Operations so far : ['56-12=44', '66+44=110'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 110-59=51. \nResulting numbers: [51].\n51,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59*110=6490. \nResulting numbers: [6490].\n6490,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+110=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 61:[66, 15]. Operations so far : ['59+12=71', '71-56=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66*15=990. \nResulting numbers: [990].\n990,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-15=51. \nResulting numbers: [51].\n51,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+15=81. \nResulting numbers: [81].\n81,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 61:[51]. Operations so far : ['56-12=44', '59-44=15', '66-15=51'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,1,4,0: 61:[51]. Operations so far : ['56-12=44', '66+44=110', '110-59=51'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,0,2,1: 61:[51]. Operations so far : ['59+12=71', '71-56=15', '66-15=51'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 20\nCurrent State #0,1,1,1: 61:[81]. Operations so far : ['56-12=44', '59-44=15', '66+15=81'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 20\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 61:[81]. Operations so far : ['59+12=71', '71-56=15', '66+15=81'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.5\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 61:[66, 9]. Operations so far : ['56+12=68', '68-59=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+9=75. \nResulting numbers: [75].\n75,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66*9=594. \nResulting numbers: [594].\n594,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-9=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.5\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 61:[56, 113]. Operations so far : ['59-12=47', '66+47=113'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*113=6328. \nResulting numbers: [6328].\n6328,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-56=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+113=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 28.5\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 61:[56, 113]. Operations so far : ['66-12=54', '59+54=113'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-56=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+113=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*113=6328. \nResulting numbers: [6328].\n6328,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 28.5\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 61:[66, 9]. Operations so far : ['59-12=47', '56-47=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-9=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+9=75. \nResulting numbers: [75].\n75,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66*9=594. \nResulting numbers: [594].\n594,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.5\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 61:[59, 2]. Operations so far : ['56+12=68', '68-66=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+2=61. \nResulting numbers: [61].\n61,61 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['56+12=68', '68-66=2', '59-2=57']\nRESULT: 57\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,605 |
[
40,
9,
66,
1
]
| 17 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [40, 9, 66, 1] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 17. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [40, 9, 66, 1]. Our goal is to produce 17. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 17:[40, 9, 66, 1]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-40=26. \nResulting numbers: [9, 1, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|9-17| + |1-17| + |26-17|)/3 = (8 + 16 + 9)/3 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 17:[9, 1, 26] Operation: 66-40=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-9=57. \nResulting numbers: [40, 1, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|40-17| + |1-17| + |57-17|)/3 = (23 + 16 + 40)/3 = 26.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 17:[40, 1, 57] Operation: 66-9=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9+1=10. \nResulting numbers: [40, 66, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|40-17| + |66-17| + |10-17|)/3 = (23 + 49 + 7)/3 = 26.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 17:[40, 66, 10] Operation: 9+1=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-9=31. \nResulting numbers: [66, 1, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|66-17| + |1-17| + |31-17|)/3 = (49 + 16 + 14)/3 = 26.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 17:[66, 1, 31] Operation: 40-9=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-1=39. \nResulting numbers: [9, 66, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|9-17| + |66-17| + |39-17|)/3 = (8 + 49 + 22)/3 = 26.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 17:[9, 66, 39] Operation: 40-1=39\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 17:[9, 1, 26]. Operations so far : ['66-40=26'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9/1=9. \nResulting numbers: [26, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|26-17| + |9-17|)/2 = (9 + 8)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 17:[26, 9] Operation: 9/1=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26-9=17. \nResulting numbers: [1, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|1-17| + |17-17|)/2 = (16 + 0)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 17:[1, 17] Operation: 26-9=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26-1=25. \nResulting numbers: [9, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|9-17| + |25-17|)/2 = (8 + 8)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 17:[9, 25] Operation: 26-1=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9*1=9. \nResulting numbers: [26, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|26-17| + |9-17|)/2 = (9 + 8)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 17:[26, 9] Operation: 9*1=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9+1=10. \nResulting numbers: [26, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|26-17| + |10-17|)/2 = (9 + 7)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 17:[26, 10] Operation: 9+1=10\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 17:[40, 66, 10]. Operations so far : ['9+1=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40/10=4. \nResulting numbers: [66, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|66-17| + |4-17|)/2 = (49 + 13)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 17:[66, 4] Operation: 40/10=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-40=26. \nResulting numbers: [10, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|10-17| + |26-17|)/2 = (7 + 9)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 17:[10, 26] Operation: 66-40=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-10=30. \nResulting numbers: [66, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|66-17| + |30-17|)/2 = (49 + 13)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 17:[66, 30] Operation: 40-10=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-10=56. \nResulting numbers: [40, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|40-17| + |56-17|)/2 = (23 + 39)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 17:[40, 56] Operation: 66-10=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+10=50. \nResulting numbers: [66, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|66-17| + |50-17|)/2 = (49 + 33)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 17:[66, 50] Operation: 40+10=50\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 17:[9, 66, 39]. Operations so far : ['40-1=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-39=27. \nResulting numbers: [9, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|9-17| + |27-17|)/2 = (8 + 10)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 17:[9, 27] Operation: 66-39=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9+39=48. \nResulting numbers: [66, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|66-17| + |48-17|)/2 = (49 + 31)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 17:[66, 48] Operation: 9+39=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9+66=75. \nResulting numbers: [39, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|39-17| + |75-17|)/2 = (22 + 58)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 17:[39, 75] Operation: 9+66=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-9=30. \nResulting numbers: [66, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|66-17| + |30-17|)/2 = (49 + 13)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 17:[66, 30] Operation: 39-9=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-9=57. \nResulting numbers: [39, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|39-17| + |57-17|)/2 = (22 + 40)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 17:[39, 57] Operation: 66-9=57\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 17:[40, 1, 57]. Operations so far : ['66-9=57'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-1=56. \nResulting numbers: [40, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|40-17| + |56-17|)/2 = (23 + 39)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 17:[40, 56] Operation: 57-1=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*1=40. \nResulting numbers: [57, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|57-17| + |40-17|)/2 = (40 + 23)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 17:[57, 40] Operation: 40*1=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-40=17. \nResulting numbers: [1, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|1-17| + |17-17|)/2 = (16 + 0)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 17:[1, 17] Operation: 57-40=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40/1=40. \nResulting numbers: [57, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|57-17| + |40-17|)/2 = (40 + 23)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 17:[57, 40] Operation: 40/1=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-1=39. \nResulting numbers: [57, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|57-17| + |39-17|)/2 = (40 + 22)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 17:[57, 39] Operation: 40-1=39\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 17:[66, 1, 31]. Operations so far : ['40-9=31'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-31=35. \nResulting numbers: [1, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|1-17| + |35-17|)/2 = (16 + 18)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 17:[1, 35] Operation: 66-31=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-1=65. \nResulting numbers: [31, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|31-17| + |65-17|)/2 = (14 + 48)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 17:[31, 65] Operation: 66-1=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66/1=66. \nResulting numbers: [31, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|31-17| + |66-17|)/2 = (14 + 49)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 17:[31, 66] Operation: 66/1=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66*1=66. \nResulting numbers: [31, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|31-17| + |66-17|)/2 = (14 + 49)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 17:[31, 66] Operation: 66*1=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31-1=30. \nResulting numbers: [66, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|66-17| + |30-17|)/2 = (49 + 13)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 17:[66, 30] Operation: 31-1=30\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 8.0\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 17:[1, 17]. Operations so far : ['66-40=26', '26-9=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17-1=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,17 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17/1=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,17 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['66-40=26', '26-9=17', '17/1=17']\nRESULT: 17\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 3,795 |
[
56,
41,
60,
74
]
| 70 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [56, 41, 60, 74] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 70. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [56, 41, 60, 74]. Our goal is to produce 70. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 70:[56, 41, 60, 74]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+41=97. \nResulting numbers: [60, 74, 97].\nHeuristic score : (|60-70| + |74-70| + |97-70|)/3 = (10 + 4 + 27)/3 = 13.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 70:[60, 74, 97] Operation: 56+41=97\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-60=37. \nResulting numbers: [74, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|74-70| + |37-70|)/2 = (4 + 33)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 70:[74, 37] Operation: 97-60=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-37=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 70:[60, 74, 97]. Operations so far : ['56+41=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-74=23. \nResulting numbers: [60, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|60-70| + |23-70|)/2 = (10 + 47)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 70:[60, 23] Operation: 97-74=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+23=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 70:[60, 74, 97]. Operations so far : ['56+41=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-60=14. \nResulting numbers: [97, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|97-70| + |14-70|)/2 = (27 + 56)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 70:[97, 14] Operation: 74-60=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-14=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 70:[60, 74, 97]. Operations so far : ['56+41=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+74=134. \nResulting numbers: [97, 134].\nHeuristic score : (|97-70| + |134-70|)/2 = (27 + 64)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 70:[97, 134] Operation: 60+74=134\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 134-97=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 70:[60, 74, 97]. Operations so far : ['56+41=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+97=157. \nResulting numbers: [74, 157].\nHeuristic score : (|74-70| + |157-70|)/2 = (4 + 87)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 70:[74, 157] Operation: 60+97=157\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 157-74=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 70:[60, 74, 97]. Operations so far : ['56+41=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+97=171. \nResulting numbers: [60, 171].\nHeuristic score : (|60-70| + |171-70|)/2 = (10 + 101)/2 = 55.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 70:[60, 171] Operation: 74+97=171\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 171-60=111. \nResulting numbers: [111].\n111,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 70:[60, 74, 97]. Operations so far : ['56+41=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*74=4440. \nResulting numbers: [97, 4440].\nHeuristic score : (|97-70| + |4440-70|)/2 = (27 + 4370)/2 = 2198.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 70:[97, 4440] Operation: 60*74=4440\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4440-97=4343. \nResulting numbers: [4343].\n4343,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 70:[60, 74, 97]. Operations so far : ['56+41=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*97=5820. \nResulting numbers: [74, 5820].\nHeuristic score : (|74-70| + |5820-70|)/2 = (4 + 5750)/2 = 2877.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 70:[74, 5820] Operation: 60*97=5820\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5820-74=5746. \nResulting numbers: [5746].\n5746,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 70:[60, 74, 97]. Operations so far : ['56+41=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74*97=7178. \nResulting numbers: [60, 7178].\nHeuristic score : (|60-70| + |7178-70|)/2 = (10 + 7108)/2 = 3559.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 70:[60, 7178] Operation: 74*97=7178\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7178-60=7118. \nResulting numbers: [7118].\n7118,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 14.25\nCurrent State #0: 70:[56, 41, 60, 74]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+60=101. \nResulting numbers: [56, 74, 101].\nHeuristic score : (|56-70| + |74-70| + |101-70|)/3 = (14 + 4 + 31)/3 = 16.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 70:[56, 74, 101] Operation: 41+60=101\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-56=45. \nResulting numbers: [74, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|74-70| + |45-70|)/2 = (4 + 25)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 70:[74, 45] Operation: 101-56=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-45=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 70:[56, 74, 101]. Operations so far : ['41+60=101'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-74=27. \nResulting numbers: [56, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|56-70| + |27-70|)/2 = (14 + 43)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 70:[56, 27] Operation: 101-74=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+27=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 70:[56, 74, 101]. Operations so far : ['41+60=101'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-56=18. \nResulting numbers: [101, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|101-70| + |18-70|)/2 = (31 + 52)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 70:[101, 18] Operation: 74-56=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-18=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 70:[56, 74, 101]. Operations so far : ['41+60=101'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+74=130. \nResulting numbers: [101, 130].\nHeuristic score : (|101-70| + |130-70|)/2 = (31 + 60)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 70:[101, 130] Operation: 56+74=130\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 130-101=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 70:[56, 74, 101]. Operations so far : ['41+60=101'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+101=157. \nResulting numbers: [74, 157].\nHeuristic score : (|74-70| + |157-70|)/2 = (4 + 87)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 70:[74, 157] Operation: 56+101=157\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 157-74=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 70:[56, 74, 101]. Operations so far : ['41+60=101'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+101=175. \nResulting numbers: [56, 175].\nHeuristic score : (|56-70| + |175-70|)/2 = (14 + 105)/2 = 59.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 70:[56, 175] Operation: 74+101=175\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 175-56=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 70:[56, 74, 101]. Operations so far : ['41+60=101'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*74=4144. \nResulting numbers: [101, 4144].\nHeuristic score : (|101-70| + |4144-70|)/2 = (31 + 4074)/2 = 2052.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 70:[101, 4144] Operation: 56*74=4144\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4144-101=4043. \nResulting numbers: [4043].\n4043,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 70:[56, 74, 101]. Operations so far : ['41+60=101'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*101=5656. \nResulting numbers: [74, 5656].\nHeuristic score : (|74-70| + |5656-70|)/2 = (4 + 5586)/2 = 2795.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 70:[74, 5656] Operation: 56*101=5656\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5656-74=5582. \nResulting numbers: [5582].\n5582,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 70:[56, 74, 101]. Operations so far : ['41+60=101'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74*101=7474. \nResulting numbers: [56, 7474].\nHeuristic score : (|56-70| + |7474-70|)/2 = (14 + 7404)/2 = 3709.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 70:[56, 7474] Operation: 74*101=7474\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7474-56=7418. \nResulting numbers: [7418].\n7418,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 14.25\nCurrent State #0: 70:[56, 41, 60, 74]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-41=33. \nResulting numbers: [56, 60, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|56-70| + |60-70| + |33-70|)/3 = (14 + 10 + 37)/3 = 20.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 70:[56, 60, 33] Operation: 74-41=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+33=89. \nResulting numbers: [60, 89].\nHeuristic score : (|60-70| + |89-70|)/2 = (10 + 19)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 70:[60, 89] Operation: 56+33=89\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-60=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 70:[56, 60, 33]. Operations so far : ['74-41=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+33=93. \nResulting numbers: [56, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|56-70| + |93-70|)/2 = (14 + 23)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 70:[56, 93] Operation: 60+33=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-56=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 70:[56, 60, 33]. Operations so far : ['74-41=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-33=23. \nResulting numbers: [60, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|60-70| + |23-70|)/2 = (10 + 47)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 70:[60, 23] Operation: 56-33=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+23=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 70:[56, 60, 33]. Operations so far : ['74-41=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-33=27. \nResulting numbers: [56, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|56-70| + |27-70|)/2 = (14 + 43)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 70:[56, 27] Operation: 60-33=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+27=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 70:[56, 60, 33]. Operations so far : ['74-41=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+60=116. \nResulting numbers: [33, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|33-70| + |116-70|)/2 = (37 + 46)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 70:[33, 116] Operation: 56+60=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-33=83. \nResulting numbers: [83].\n83,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 70:[56, 60, 33]. Operations so far : ['74-41=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-56=4. \nResulting numbers: [33, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|33-70| + |4-70|)/2 = (37 + 66)/2 = 51.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 70:[33, 4] Operation: 60-56=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+4=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 70:[56, 60, 33]. Operations so far : ['74-41=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*33=1848. \nResulting numbers: [60, 1848].\nHeuristic score : (|60-70| + |1848-70|)/2 = (10 + 1778)/2 = 894.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 70:[60, 1848] Operation: 56*33=1848\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1848-60=1788. \nResulting numbers: [1788].\n1788,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 70:[56, 60, 33]. Operations so far : ['74-41=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*33=1980. \nResulting numbers: [56, 1980].\nHeuristic score : (|56-70| + |1980-70|)/2 = (14 + 1910)/2 = 962.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 70:[56, 1980] Operation: 60*33=1980\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1980-56=1924. \nResulting numbers: [1924].\n1924,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 70:[56, 60, 33]. Operations so far : ['74-41=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*60=3360. \nResulting numbers: [33, 3360].\nHeuristic score : (|33-70| + |3360-70|)/2 = (37 + 3290)/2 = 1663.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 70:[33, 3360] Operation: 56*60=3360\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3360-33=3327. \nResulting numbers: [3327].\n3327,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 14.25\nCurrent State #0: 70:[56, 41, 60, 74]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-41=15. \nResulting numbers: [60, 74, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|60-70| + |74-70| + |15-70|)/3 = (10 + 4 + 55)/3 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 70:[60, 74, 15] Operation: 56-41=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+15=75. \nResulting numbers: [74, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|74-70| + |75-70|)/2 = (4 + 5)/2 = 4.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 70:[74, 75] Operation: 60+15=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-74=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 70:[60, 74, 15]. Operations so far : ['56-41=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-15=59. \nResulting numbers: [60, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|60-70| + |59-70|)/2 = (10 + 11)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 70:[60, 59] Operation: 74-15=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+59=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 70:[60, 74, 15]. Operations so far : ['56-41=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-15=45. \nResulting numbers: [74, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|74-70| + |45-70|)/2 = (4 + 25)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 70:[74, 45] Operation: 60-15=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-45=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 70:[60, 74, 15]. Operations so far : ['56-41=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+15=89. \nResulting numbers: [60, 89].\nHeuristic score : (|60-70| + |89-70|)/2 = (10 + 19)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 70:[60, 89] Operation: 74+15=89\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-60=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,70 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 70:[60, 74, 15]. Operations so far : ['56-41=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/15=4. \nResulting numbers: [74, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|74-70| + |4-70|)/2 = (4 + 66)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 70:[74, 4] Operation: 60/15=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-4=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,70 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['56-41=15', '60/15=4', '74-4=70']\nRESULT: 70\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,663 |
[
80,
36,
11,
83
]
| 40 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [80, 36, 11, 83] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 40. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [80, 36, 11, 83]. Our goal is to produce 40. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 40:[80, 36, 11, 83]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-36=47. \nResulting numbers: [80, 11, 47].\nHeuristic score : (|80-40| + |11-40| + |47-40|)/3 = (40 + 29 + 7)/3 = 25.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 40:[80, 11, 47] Operation: 83-36=47\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-80=3. \nResulting numbers: [36, 11, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|36-40| + |11-40| + |3-40|)/3 = (4 + 29 + 37)/3 = 23.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 40:[36, 11, 3] Operation: 83-80=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-11=72. \nResulting numbers: [80, 36, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|80-40| + |36-40| + |72-40|)/3 = (40 + 4 + 32)/3 = 25.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 40:[80, 36, 72] Operation: 83-11=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-11=69. \nResulting numbers: [36, 83, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|36-40| + |83-40| + |69-40|)/3 = (4 + 43 + 29)/3 = 25.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 40:[36, 83, 69] Operation: 80-11=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-36=44. \nResulting numbers: [11, 83, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|11-40| + |83-40| + |44-40|)/3 = (29 + 43 + 4)/3 = 25.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 40:[11, 83, 44] Operation: 80-36=44\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 40:[36, 11, 3]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+3=39. \nResulting numbers: [11, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|11-40| + |39-40|)/2 = (29 + 1)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 40:[11, 39] Operation: 36+3=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11-3=8. \nResulting numbers: [36, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|36-40| + |8-40|)/2 = (4 + 32)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 40:[36, 8] Operation: 11-3=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+3=14. \nResulting numbers: [36, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|36-40| + |14-40|)/2 = (4 + 26)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 40:[36, 14] Operation: 11+3=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-3=33. \nResulting numbers: [11, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|11-40| + |33-40|)/2 = (29 + 7)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 40:[11, 33] Operation: 36-3=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11*3=33. \nResulting numbers: [36, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|36-40| + |33-40|)/2 = (4 + 7)/2 = 5.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 40:[36, 33] Operation: 11*3=33\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 40:[80, 36, 72]. Operations so far : ['83-11=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72/36=2. \nResulting numbers: [80, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|80-40| + |2-40|)/2 = (40 + 38)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 40:[80, 2] Operation: 72/36=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-72=8. \nResulting numbers: [36, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|36-40| + |8-40|)/2 = (4 + 32)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 40:[36, 8] Operation: 80-72=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-36=44. \nResulting numbers: [72, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|72-40| + |44-40|)/2 = (32 + 4)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 40:[72, 44] Operation: 80-36=44\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-36=36. \nResulting numbers: [80, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|80-40| + |36-40|)/2 = (40 + 4)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 40:[80, 36] Operation: 72-36=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+36=116. \nResulting numbers: [72, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|72-40| + |116-40|)/2 = (32 + 76)/2 = 54.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 40:[72, 116] Operation: 80+36=116\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 40:[11, 83, 44]. Operations so far : ['80-36=44'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+44=55. \nResulting numbers: [83, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|83-40| + |55-40|)/2 = (43 + 15)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 40:[83, 55] Operation: 11+44=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-11=72. \nResulting numbers: [44, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|44-40| + |72-40|)/2 = (4 + 32)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 40:[44, 72] Operation: 83-11=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-44=39. \nResulting numbers: [11, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|11-40| + |39-40|)/2 = (29 + 1)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 40:[11, 39] Operation: 83-44=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-11=33. \nResulting numbers: [83, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|83-40| + |33-40|)/2 = (43 + 7)/2 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 40:[83, 33] Operation: 44-11=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+83=94. \nResulting numbers: [44, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|44-40| + |94-40|)/2 = (4 + 54)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 40:[44, 94] Operation: 11+83=94\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 40:[80, 11, 47]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-47=33. \nResulting numbers: [11, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|11-40| + |33-40|)/2 = (29 + 7)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 40:[11, 33] Operation: 80-47=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-11=36. \nResulting numbers: [80, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|80-40| + |36-40|)/2 = (40 + 4)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 40:[80, 36] Operation: 47-11=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-11=69. \nResulting numbers: [47, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |69-40|)/2 = (7 + 29)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 40:[47, 69] Operation: 80-11=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+47=58. \nResulting numbers: [80, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|80-40| + |58-40|)/2 = (40 + 18)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 40:[80, 58] Operation: 11+47=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+11=91. \nResulting numbers: [47, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |91-40|)/2 = (7 + 51)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 40:[47, 91] Operation: 80+11=91\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 40:[36, 83, 69]. Operations so far : ['80-11=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+83=119. \nResulting numbers: [69, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|69-40| + |119-40|)/2 = (29 + 79)/2 = 54.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 40:[69, 119] Operation: 36+83=119\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-36=33. \nResulting numbers: [83, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|83-40| + |33-40|)/2 = (43 + 7)/2 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 40:[83, 33] Operation: 69-36=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-36=47. \nResulting numbers: [69, 47].\nHeuristic score : (|69-40| + |47-40|)/2 = (29 + 7)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 40:[69, 47] Operation: 83-36=47\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-69=14. \nResulting numbers: [36, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|36-40| + |14-40|)/2 = (4 + 26)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 40:[36, 14] Operation: 83-69=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+69=105. \nResulting numbers: [83, 105].\nHeuristic score : (|83-40| + |105-40|)/2 = (43 + 65)/2 = 54.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 40:[83, 105] Operation: 36+69=105\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 5.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 40:[36, 33]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '11*3=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-33=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+33=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*33=1188. \nResulting numbers: [1188].\n1188,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 40:[36, 14]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '11+3=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*14=504. \nResulting numbers: [504].\n504,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+14=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-14=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 40:[11, 39]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '36+3=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-11=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11*39=429. \nResulting numbers: [429].\n429,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+39=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 40:[11, 39]. Operations so far : ['80-36=44', '83-44=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+39=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11*39=429. \nResulting numbers: [429].\n429,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-11=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 40:[36, 14]. Operations so far : ['80-11=69', '83-69=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*14=504. \nResulting numbers: [504].\n504,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+14=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-14=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,1,2,1: 40:[50]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '11+3=14', '36+14=50'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,1,0,2: 40:[50]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '36+3=39', '11+39=50'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,4,2,0: 40:[50]. Operations so far : ['80-36=44', '83-44=39', '11+39=50'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 40:[50]. Operations so far : ['80-11=69', '83-69=14', '36+14=50'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,1,0,0: 40:[28]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '36+3=39', '39-11=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,4,2,2: 40:[28]. Operations so far : ['80-36=44', '83-44=39', '39-11=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,3,3,2: 40:[22]. Operations so far : ['80-11=69', '83-69=14', '36-14=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 40:[72, 44]. Operations so far : ['83-11=72', '80-36=44'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-44=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+44=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72*44=3168. \nResulting numbers: [3168].\n3168,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 40:[36, 8]. Operations so far : ['83-11=72', '80-72=8'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+8=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-8=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*8=288. \nResulting numbers: [288].\n288,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 40:[44, 72]. Operations so far : ['80-36=44', '83-11=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-44=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*72=3168. \nResulting numbers: [3168].\n3168,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+72=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,1,0: 40:[44]. Operations so far : ['83-11=72', '80-72=8', '36+8=44'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,2,2,0: 40:[28]. Operations so far : ['83-11=72', '80-36=44', '72-44=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,2,1,1: 40:[28]. Operations so far : ['83-11=72', '80-72=8', '36-8=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,4,1,0: 40:[28]. Operations so far : ['80-36=44', '83-11=72', '72-44=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,1,2,2: 40:[22]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '11+3=14', '36-14=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 40:[69, 47]. Operations so far : ['80-11=69', '83-36=47'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+47=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-47=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*47=3243. \nResulting numbers: [3243].\n3243,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 40:[11, 33]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '36-3=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11*33=363. \nResulting numbers: [363].\n363,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-11=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+33=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33/11=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 40:[47, 69]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47', '80-11=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+69=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*69=3243. \nResulting numbers: [3243].\n3243,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-47=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 40:[11, 33]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47', '80-47=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33/11=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-11=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11*33=363. \nResulting numbers: [363].\n363,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 11+33=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 18.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 40:[36, 8]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '11-3=8'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*8=288. \nResulting numbers: [288].\n288,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+8=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-8=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,1,3,2: 40:[44]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '36-3=33', '11+33=44'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,0,0,3: 40:[44]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47', '80-47=33', '11+33=44'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,1,1,1: 40:[44]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '11-3=8', '36+8=44'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 40:[28]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '11-3=8', '36-8=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,3,2,1: 40:[22]. Operations so far : ['80-11=69', '83-36=47', '69-47=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,1,3,1: 40:[22]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '36-3=33', '33-11=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 40:[22]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47', '80-11=69', '69-47=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,0,0,1: 40:[22]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47', '80-47=33', '33-11=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 40:[80, 36]. Operations so far : ['83-11=72', '72-36=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*36=2880. \nResulting numbers: [2880].\n2880,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+36=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-36=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 40:[80, 36]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47', '47-11=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*36=2880. \nResulting numbers: [2880].\n2880,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+36=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-36=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 40:[44]. Operations so far : ['83-11=72', '72-36=36', '80-36=44'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,0,1,2: 40:[44]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47', '47-11=36', '80-36=44'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 40:[83, 33]. Operations so far : ['80-36=44', '44-11=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-33=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*33=2739. \nResulting numbers: [2739].\n2739,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+33=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 40:[83, 33]. Operations so far : ['80-11=69', '69-36=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+33=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*33=2739. \nResulting numbers: [2739].\n2739,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-33=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 40:[44, 94]. Operations so far : ['80-36=44', '11+83=94'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*94=4136. \nResulting numbers: [4136].\n4136,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+94=138. \nResulting numbers: [138].\n138,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-44=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,4,3,0: 40:[50]. Operations so far : ['80-36=44', '44-11=33', '83-33=50'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,3,1,2: 40:[50]. Operations so far : ['80-11=69', '69-36=33', '83-33=50'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,4,4,2: 40:[50]. Operations so far : ['80-36=44', '11+83=94', '94-44=50'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 40:[47, 91]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47', '80+11=91'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+91=138. \nResulting numbers: [138].\n138,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*91=4277. \nResulting numbers: [4277].\n4277,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-47=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 40:[83, 55]. Operations so far : ['80-36=44', '11+44=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*55=4565. \nResulting numbers: [4565].\n4565,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-55=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+55=138. \nResulting numbers: [138].\n138,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,0,4,2: 40:[44]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47', '80+11=91', '91-47=44'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,4,0,1: 40:[28]. Operations so far : ['80-36=44', '11+44=55', '83-55=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 29\nCurrent State #0,1,4,1: 40:[69]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '11*3=33', '36+33=69'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 40:[80, 58]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47', '11+47=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+58=138. \nResulting numbers: [138].\n138,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*58=4640. \nResulting numbers: [4640].\n4640,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-58=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,40 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,1,3,3: 40:[3]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '36-3=33', '33/11=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,0,3,2: 40:[22]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47', '11+47=58', '80-58=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,1,4,0: 40:[3]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '11*3=33', '36-33=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,0,0,0: 40:[3]. Operations so far : ['83-36=47', '80-47=33', '33/11=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 39.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 40:[80, 2]. Operations so far : ['83-11=72', '72/36=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+2=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-2=78. \nResulting numbers: [78].\n78,40 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/2=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,40 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['83-11=72', '72/36=2', '80/2=40']\nRESULT: 40\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 11,621 |
[
96,
17,
53,
3
]
| 98 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [96, 17, 53, 3] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 98. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [96, 17, 53, 3]. Our goal is to produce 98. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 98:[96, 17, 53, 3]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+53=70. \nResulting numbers: [96, 3, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|96-98| + |3-98| + |70-98|)/3 = (2 + 95 + 28)/3 = 41.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 98:[96, 3, 70] Operation: 17+53=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17*3=51. \nResulting numbers: [96, 53, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|96-98| + |53-98| + |51-98|)/3 = (2 + 45 + 47)/3 = 31.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 98:[96, 53, 51] Operation: 17*3=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+3=99. \nResulting numbers: [17, 53, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|17-98| + |53-98| + |99-98|)/3 = (81 + 45 + 1)/3 = 42.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 98:[17, 53, 99] Operation: 96+3=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+3=20. \nResulting numbers: [96, 53, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|96-98| + |53-98| + |20-98|)/3 = (2 + 45 + 78)/3 = 41.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 98:[96, 53, 20] Operation: 17+3=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+3=56. \nResulting numbers: [96, 17, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|96-98| + |17-98| + |56-98|)/3 = (2 + 81 + 42)/3 = 41.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 98:[96, 17, 56] Operation: 53+3=56\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 31.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[96, 53, 51]. Operations so far : ['17*3=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+51=104. \nResulting numbers: [96, 104].\nHeuristic score : (|96-98| + |104-98|)/2 = (2 + 6)/2 = 4.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 98:[96, 104] Operation: 53+51=104\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-51=2. \nResulting numbers: [96, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|96-98| + |2-98|)/2 = (2 + 96)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 98:[96, 2] Operation: 53-51=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+53=149. \nResulting numbers: [51, 149].\nHeuristic score : (|51-98| + |149-98|)/2 = (47 + 51)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 98:[51, 149] Operation: 96+53=149\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-51=45. \nResulting numbers: [53, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|53-98| + |45-98|)/2 = (45 + 53)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 98:[53, 45] Operation: 96-51=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+51=147. \nResulting numbers: [53, 147].\nHeuristic score : (|53-98| + |147-98|)/2 = (45 + 49)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 98:[53, 147] Operation: 96+51=147\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 41.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 98:[96, 53, 20]. Operations so far : ['17+3=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+20=73. \nResulting numbers: [96, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|96-98| + |73-98|)/2 = (2 + 25)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 98:[96, 73] Operation: 53+20=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-20=33. \nResulting numbers: [96, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|96-98| + |33-98|)/2 = (2 + 65)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 98:[96, 33] Operation: 53-20=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-20=76. \nResulting numbers: [53, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|53-98| + |76-98|)/2 = (45 + 22)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 98:[53, 76] Operation: 96-20=76\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+20=116. \nResulting numbers: [53, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|53-98| + |116-98|)/2 = (45 + 18)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 98:[53, 116] Operation: 96+20=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+53=149. \nResulting numbers: [20, 149].\nHeuristic score : (|20-98| + |149-98|)/2 = (78 + 51)/2 = 64.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 98:[20, 149] Operation: 96+53=149\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 41.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[96, 3, 70]. Operations so far : ['17+53=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+3=99. \nResulting numbers: [70, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |99-98|)/2 = (28 + 1)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 98:[70, 99] Operation: 96+3=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96/3=32. \nResulting numbers: [70, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |32-98|)/2 = (28 + 66)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 98:[70, 32] Operation: 96/3=32\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-3=93. \nResulting numbers: [70, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |93-98|)/2 = (28 + 5)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 98:[70, 93] Operation: 96-3=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-3=67. \nResulting numbers: [96, 67].\nHeuristic score : (|96-98| + |67-98|)/2 = (2 + 31)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 98:[96, 67] Operation: 70-3=67\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+70=73. \nResulting numbers: [96, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|96-98| + |73-98|)/2 = (2 + 25)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 98:[96, 73] Operation: 3+70=73\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 41.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 98:[96, 17, 56]. Operations so far : ['53+3=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+56=152. \nResulting numbers: [17, 152].\nHeuristic score : (|17-98| + |152-98|)/2 = (81 + 54)/2 = 67.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 98:[17, 152] Operation: 96+56=152\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+56=73. \nResulting numbers: [96, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|96-98| + |73-98|)/2 = (2 + 25)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 98:[96, 73] Operation: 17+56=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-17=79. \nResulting numbers: [56, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |79-98|)/2 = (42 + 19)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 98:[56, 79] Operation: 96-17=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-17=39. \nResulting numbers: [96, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|96-98| + |39-98|)/2 = (2 + 59)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 98:[96, 39] Operation: 56-17=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+17=113. \nResulting numbers: [56, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |113-98|)/2 = (42 + 15)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 98:[56, 113] Operation: 96+17=113\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 42.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 98:[17, 53, 99]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+99=116. \nResulting numbers: [53, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|53-98| + |116-98|)/2 = (45 + 18)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 98:[53, 116] Operation: 17+99=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-53=46. \nResulting numbers: [17, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|17-98| + |46-98|)/2 = (81 + 52)/2 = 66.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 98:[17, 46] Operation: 99-53=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-17=82. \nResulting numbers: [53, 82].\nHeuristic score : (|53-98| + |82-98|)/2 = (45 + 16)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 98:[53, 82] Operation: 99-17=82\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-17=36. \nResulting numbers: [99, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|99-98| + |36-98|)/2 = (1 + 62)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 98:[99, 36] Operation: 53-17=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+53=70. \nResulting numbers: [99, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|99-98| + |70-98|)/2 = (1 + 28)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 98:[99, 70] Operation: 17+53=70\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 4.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 98:[96, 104]. Operations so far : ['17*3=51', '53+51=104'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+104=200. \nResulting numbers: [200].\n200,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*104=9984. \nResulting numbers: [9984].\n9984,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104-96=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.5\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 98:[96, 73]. Operations so far : ['17+3=20', '53+20=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+73=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-73=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*73=7008. \nResulting numbers: [7008].\n7008,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 13.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 98:[96, 73]. Operations so far : ['17+53=70', '3+70=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*73=7008. \nResulting numbers: [7008].\n7008,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+73=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-73=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.5\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 98:[96, 73]. Operations so far : ['53+3=56', '17+56=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-73=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+73=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*73=7008. \nResulting numbers: [7008].\n7008,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 14.5\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 98:[70, 99]. Operations so far : ['17+53=70', '96+3=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+99=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*99=6930. \nResulting numbers: [6930].\n6930,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-70=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 14.5\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 98:[99, 70]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99', '17+53=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99+70=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-70=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99*70=6930. \nResulting numbers: [6930].\n6930,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 16.5\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 98:[96, 67]. Operations so far : ['17+53=70', '70-3=67'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*67=6432. \nResulting numbers: [6432].\n6432,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+67=163. \nResulting numbers: [163].\n163,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-67=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 16.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 98:[70, 93]. Operations so far : ['17+53=70', '96-3=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-70=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+93=163. \nResulting numbers: [163].\n163,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*93=6510. \nResulting numbers: [6510].\n6510,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.5\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 98:[56, 113]. Operations so far : ['53+3=56', '96+17=113'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+113=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*113=6328. \nResulting numbers: [6328].\n6328,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-56=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.5\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 98:[53, 82]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99', '99-17=82'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+82=135. \nResulting numbers: [135].\n135,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53*82=4346. \nResulting numbers: [4346].\n4346,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-53=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.5\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 98:[56, 79]. Operations so far : ['53+3=56', '96-17=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+79=135. \nResulting numbers: [135].\n135,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-56=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*79=4424. \nResulting numbers: [4424].\n4424,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 30.5\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 98:[96, 39]. Operations so far : ['53+3=56', '56-17=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+39=135. \nResulting numbers: [135].\n135,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*39=3744. \nResulting numbers: [3744].\n3744,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-39=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 31.5\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 98:[53, 116]. Operations so far : ['17+3=20', '96+20=116'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53*116=6148. \nResulting numbers: [6148].\n6148,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-53=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+116=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 31.5\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 98:[99, 36]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99', '53-17=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99+36=135. \nResulting numbers: [135].\n135,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99*36=3564. \nResulting numbers: [3564].\n3564,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-36=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.5\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 98:[53, 116]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99', '17+99=116'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53*116=6148. \nResulting numbers: [6148].\n6148,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-53=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+116=169. \nResulting numbers: [169].\n169,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.5\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 98:[96, 33]. Operations so far : ['17+3=20', '53-20=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+33=129. \nResulting numbers: [129].\n129,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*33=3168. \nResulting numbers: [3168].\n3168,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-33=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.5\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 98:[53, 76]. Operations so far : ['17+3=20', '96-20=76'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-53=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53*76=4028. \nResulting numbers: [4028].\n4028,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+76=129. \nResulting numbers: [129].\n129,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 35\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 98:[63]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99', '53-17=36', '99-36=63'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 35\nCurrent State #0,2,0,1: 98:[63]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99', '17+99=116', '116-53=63'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 35\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 98:[63]. Operations so far : ['17+3=20', '96+20=116', '116-53=63'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 31\nCurrent State #0,3,1,0: 98:[129]. Operations so far : ['17+3=20', '53-20=33', '96+33=129'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 31\nCurrent State #0,3,2,2: 98:[129]. Operations so far : ['17+3=20', '96-20=76', '53+76=129'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 35\nCurrent State #0,3,1,2: 98:[63]. Operations so far : ['17+3=20', '53-20=33', '96-33=63'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,2,3,0: 98:[135]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99', '53-17=36', '99+36=135'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,2,2,0: 98:[135]. Operations so far : ['96+3=99', '99-17=82', '53+82=135'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,4,3,0: 98:[135]. Operations so far : ['53+3=56', '56-17=39', '96+39=135'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 37\nCurrent State #0,4,2,0: 98:[135]. Operations so far : ['53+3=56', '96-17=79', '56+79=135'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 41\nCurrent State #0,4,3,2: 98:[57]. Operations so far : ['53+3=56', '56-17=39', '96-39=57'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 41\nCurrent State #0,4,4,2: 98:[57]. Operations so far : ['53+3=56', '96+17=113', '113-56=57'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 98:[70, 32]. Operations so far : ['17+53=70', '96/3=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*32=2240. \nResulting numbers: [2240].\n2240,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-32=38. \nResulting numbers: [38].\n38,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+32=102. \nResulting numbers: [102].\n102,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,0,1,2: 98:[102]. Operations so far : ['17+53=70', '96/3=32', '70+32=102'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 98:[53, 147]. Operations so far : ['17*3=51', '96+51=147'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 147-53=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+147=200. \nResulting numbers: [200].\n200,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53*147=7791. \nResulting numbers: [7791].\n7791,98 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 49.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 98:[53, 45]. Operations so far : ['17*3=51', '96-51=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53*45=2385. \nResulting numbers: [2385].\n2385,98 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+45=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,98 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['17*3=51', '96-51=45', '53-45=8']\nRESULT: 8\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 9,441 |
[
13,
60,
5,
56
]
| 98 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [13, 60, 5, 56] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 98. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [13, 60, 5, 56]. Our goal is to produce 98. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 98:[13, 60, 5, 56]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13*5=65. \nResulting numbers: [60, 56, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|60-98| + |56-98| + |65-98|)/3 = (38 + 42 + 33)/3 = 37.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 98:[60, 56, 65] Operation: 13*5=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+56=116. \nResulting numbers: [65, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|65-98| + |116-98|)/2 = (33 + 18)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 98:[65, 116] Operation: 60+56=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-65=51. \nResulting numbers: [51].\n51,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[60, 56, 65]. Operations so far : ['13*5=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+65=121. \nResulting numbers: [60, 121].\nHeuristic score : (|60-98| + |121-98|)/2 = (38 + 23)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 98:[60, 121] Operation: 56+65=121\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 121-60=61. \nResulting numbers: [61].\n61,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[60, 56, 65]. Operations so far : ['13*5=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+65=125. \nResulting numbers: [56, 125].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |125-98|)/2 = (42 + 27)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 98:[56, 125] Operation: 60+65=125\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 125-56=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[60, 56, 65]. Operations so far : ['13*5=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-56=4. \nResulting numbers: [65, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|65-98| + |4-98|)/2 = (33 + 94)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 98:[65, 4] Operation: 60-56=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+4=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[60, 56, 65]. Operations so far : ['13*5=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-56=9. \nResulting numbers: [60, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|60-98| + |9-98|)/2 = (38 + 89)/2 = 63.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 98:[60, 9] Operation: 65-56=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+9=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[60, 56, 65]. Operations so far : ['13*5=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-60=5. \nResulting numbers: [56, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |5-98|)/2 = (42 + 93)/2 = 67.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 98:[56, 5] Operation: 65-60=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+5=61. \nResulting numbers: [61].\n61,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[60, 56, 65]. Operations so far : ['13*5=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*56=3360. \nResulting numbers: [65, 3360].\nHeuristic score : (|65-98| + |3360-98|)/2 = (33 + 3262)/2 = 1647.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 98:[65, 3360] Operation: 60*56=3360\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3360-65=3295. \nResulting numbers: [3295].\n3295,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[60, 56, 65]. Operations so far : ['13*5=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*65=3640. \nResulting numbers: [60, 3640].\nHeuristic score : (|60-98| + |3640-98|)/2 = (38 + 3542)/2 = 1790.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 98:[60, 3640] Operation: 56*65=3640\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3640-60=3580. \nResulting numbers: [3580].\n3580,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[60, 56, 65]. Operations so far : ['13*5=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*65=3900. \nResulting numbers: [56, 3900].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |3900-98|)/2 = (42 + 3802)/2 = 1922.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 98:[56, 3900] Operation: 60*65=3900\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3900-56=3844. \nResulting numbers: [3844].\n3844,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 64.5\nCurrent State #0: 98:[13, 60, 5, 56]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13+60=73. \nResulting numbers: [5, 56, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|5-98| + |56-98| + |73-98|)/3 = (93 + 42 + 25)/3 = 53.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 98:[5, 56, 73] Operation: 13+60=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5+56=61. \nResulting numbers: [73, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|73-98| + |61-98|)/2 = (25 + 37)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 98:[73, 61] Operation: 5+56=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+61=134. \nResulting numbers: [134].\n134,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[5, 56, 73]. Operations so far : ['13+60=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5+73=78. \nResulting numbers: [56, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |78-98|)/2 = (42 + 20)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 98:[56, 78] Operation: 5+73=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+78=134. \nResulting numbers: [134].\n134,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[5, 56, 73]. Operations so far : ['13+60=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-5=51. \nResulting numbers: [73, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|73-98| + |51-98|)/2 = (25 + 47)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 98:[73, 51] Operation: 56-5=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+51=124. \nResulting numbers: [124].\n124,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[5, 56, 73]. Operations so far : ['13+60=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-5=68. \nResulting numbers: [56, 68].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |68-98|)/2 = (42 + 30)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 98:[56, 68] Operation: 73-5=68\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+68=124. \nResulting numbers: [124].\n124,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[5, 56, 73]. Operations so far : ['13+60=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+73=129. \nResulting numbers: [5, 129].\nHeuristic score : (|5-98| + |129-98|)/2 = (93 + 31)/2 = 62.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 98:[5, 129] Operation: 56+73=129\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 129-5=124. \nResulting numbers: [124].\n124,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[5, 56, 73]. Operations so far : ['13+60=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-56=17. \nResulting numbers: [5, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|5-98| + |17-98|)/2 = (93 + 81)/2 = 87.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 98:[5, 17] Operation: 73-56=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5*17=85. \nResulting numbers: [85].\n85,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[5, 56, 73]. Operations so far : ['13+60=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5*56=280. \nResulting numbers: [73, 280].\nHeuristic score : (|73-98| + |280-98|)/2 = (25 + 182)/2 = 103.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 98:[73, 280] Operation: 5*56=280\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 280-73=207. \nResulting numbers: [207].\n207,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[5, 56, 73]. Operations so far : ['13+60=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5*73=365. \nResulting numbers: [56, 365].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |365-98|)/2 = (42 + 267)/2 = 154.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 98:[56, 365] Operation: 5*73=365\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 365-56=309. \nResulting numbers: [309].\n309,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[5, 56, 73]. Operations so far : ['13+60=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*73=4088. \nResulting numbers: [5, 4088].\nHeuristic score : (|5-98| + |4088-98|)/2 = (93 + 3990)/2 = 2041.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 98:[5, 4088] Operation: 56*73=4088\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4088-5=4083. \nResulting numbers: [4083].\n4083,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 64.5\nCurrent State #0: 98:[13, 60, 5, 56]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13+5=18. \nResulting numbers: [60, 56, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|60-98| + |56-98| + |18-98|)/3 = (38 + 42 + 80)/3 = 53.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 98:[60, 56, 18] Operation: 13+5=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+18=78. \nResulting numbers: [56, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |78-98|)/2 = (42 + 20)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 98:[56, 78] Operation: 60+18=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+78=134. \nResulting numbers: [134].\n134,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 98:[60, 56, 18]. Operations so far : ['13+5=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+18=74. \nResulting numbers: [60, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|60-98| + |74-98|)/2 = (38 + 24)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 98:[60, 74] Operation: 56+18=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+74=134. \nResulting numbers: [134].\n134,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 53.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 98:[60, 56, 18]. Operations so far : ['13+5=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+56=116. \nResulting numbers: [18, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|18-98| + |116-98|)/2 = (80 + 18)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 98:[18, 116] Operation: 60+56=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-18=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,98 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['13+5=18', '60+56=116', '116-18=98']\nRESULT: 98\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 5,094 |
[
78,
20,
92,
59
]
| 46 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [78, 20, 92, 59] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 46. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [78, 20, 92, 59]. Our goal is to produce 46. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 46:[78, 20, 92, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-20=58. \nResulting numbers: [92, 59, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|92-46| + |59-46| + |58-46|)/3 = (46 + 13 + 12)/3 = 23.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 46:[92, 59, 58] Operation: 78-20=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-59=33. \nResulting numbers: [58, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|58-46| + |33-46|)/2 = (12 + 13)/2 = 12.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 46:[58, 33] Operation: 92-59=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58-33=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 46:[92, 59, 58]. Operations so far : ['78-20=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-58=34. \nResulting numbers: [59, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|59-46| + |34-46|)/2 = (13 + 12)/2 = 12.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 46:[59, 34] Operation: 92-58=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-34=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 46:[92, 59, 58]. Operations so far : ['78-20=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-58=1. \nResulting numbers: [92, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|92-46| + |1-46|)/2 = (46 + 45)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 46:[92, 1] Operation: 59-58=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-1=91. \nResulting numbers: [91].\n91,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 46:[92, 59, 58]. Operations so far : ['78-20=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92+59=151. \nResulting numbers: [58, 151].\nHeuristic score : (|58-46| + |151-46|)/2 = (12 + 105)/2 = 58.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 46:[58, 151] Operation: 92+59=151\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 151-58=93. \nResulting numbers: [93].\n93,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 46:[92, 59, 58]. Operations so far : ['78-20=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92+58=150. \nResulting numbers: [59, 150].\nHeuristic score : (|59-46| + |150-46|)/2 = (13 + 104)/2 = 58.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 46:[59, 150] Operation: 92+58=150\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 150-59=91. \nResulting numbers: [91].\n91,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 46:[92, 59, 58]. Operations so far : ['78-20=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+58=117. \nResulting numbers: [92, 117].\nHeuristic score : (|92-46| + |117-46|)/2 = (46 + 71)/2 = 58.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 46:[92, 117] Operation: 59+58=117\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 117-92=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 46:[92, 59, 58]. Operations so far : ['78-20=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59*58=3422. \nResulting numbers: [92, 3422].\nHeuristic score : (|92-46| + |3422-46|)/2 = (46 + 3376)/2 = 1711.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 46:[92, 3422] Operation: 59*58=3422\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3422-92=3330. \nResulting numbers: [3330].\n3330,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 46:[92, 59, 58]. Operations so far : ['78-20=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92*58=5336. \nResulting numbers: [59, 5336].\nHeuristic score : (|59-46| + |5336-46|)/2 = (13 + 5290)/2 = 2651.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 46:[59, 5336] Operation: 92*58=5336\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5336-59=5277. \nResulting numbers: [5277].\n5277,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 46:[92, 59, 58]. Operations so far : ['78-20=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92*59=5428. \nResulting numbers: [58, 5428].\nHeuristic score : (|58-46| + |5428-46|)/2 = (12 + 5382)/2 = 2697.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 46:[58, 5428] Operation: 92*59=5428\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5428-58=5370. \nResulting numbers: [5370].\n5370,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.25\nCurrent State #0: 46:[78, 20, 92, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-78=14. \nResulting numbers: [20, 59, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|20-46| + |59-46| + |14-46|)/3 = (26 + 13 + 32)/3 = 23.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 46:[20, 59, 14] Operation: 92-78=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+14=34. \nResulting numbers: [59, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|59-46| + |34-46|)/2 = (13 + 12)/2 = 12.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 46:[59, 34] Operation: 20+14=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-34=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 46:[20, 59, 14]. Operations so far : ['92-78=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-14=45. \nResulting numbers: [20, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|20-46| + |45-46|)/2 = (26 + 1)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 46:[20, 45] Operation: 59-14=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+45=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 46:[20, 59, 14]. Operations so far : ['92-78=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-20=39. \nResulting numbers: [14, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|14-46| + |39-46|)/2 = (32 + 7)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 46:[14, 39] Operation: 59-20=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+39=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 46:[20, 59, 14]. Operations so far : ['92-78=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20-14=6. \nResulting numbers: [59, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|59-46| + |6-46|)/2 = (13 + 40)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 46:[59, 6] Operation: 20-14=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-6=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 46:[20, 59, 14]. Operations so far : ['92-78=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+14=73. \nResulting numbers: [20, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|20-46| + |73-46|)/2 = (26 + 27)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 46:[20, 73] Operation: 59+14=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-20=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 46:[20, 59, 14]. Operations so far : ['92-78=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+59=79. \nResulting numbers: [14, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|14-46| + |79-46|)/2 = (32 + 33)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 46:[14, 79] Operation: 20+59=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-14=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 46:[20, 59, 14]. Operations so far : ['92-78=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20*14=280. \nResulting numbers: [59, 280].\nHeuristic score : (|59-46| + |280-46|)/2 = (13 + 234)/2 = 123.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 46:[59, 280] Operation: 20*14=280\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 280-59=221. \nResulting numbers: [221].\n221,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 46:[20, 59, 14]. Operations so far : ['92-78=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59*14=826. \nResulting numbers: [20, 826].\nHeuristic score : (|20-46| + |826-46|)/2 = (26 + 780)/2 = 403.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 46:[20, 826] Operation: 59*14=826\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 826-20=806. \nResulting numbers: [806].\n806,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 46:[20, 59, 14]. Operations so far : ['92-78=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20*59=1180. \nResulting numbers: [14, 1180].\nHeuristic score : (|14-46| + |1180-46|)/2 = (32 + 1134)/2 = 583.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 46:[14, 1180] Operation: 20*59=1180\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1180-14=1166. \nResulting numbers: [1166].\n1166,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.25\nCurrent State #0: 46:[78, 20, 92, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-20=72. \nResulting numbers: [78, 59, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|78-46| + |59-46| + |72-46|)/3 = (32 + 13 + 26)/3 = 23.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 46:[78, 59, 72] Operation: 92-20=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-59=19. \nResulting numbers: [72, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|72-46| + |19-46|)/2 = (26 + 27)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 46:[72, 19] Operation: 78-59=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-19=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 46:[78, 59, 72]. Operations so far : ['92-20=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-72=6. \nResulting numbers: [59, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|59-46| + |6-46|)/2 = (13 + 40)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 46:[59, 6] Operation: 78-72=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-6=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 46:[78, 59, 72]. Operations so far : ['92-20=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-59=13. \nResulting numbers: [78, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|78-46| + |13-46|)/2 = (32 + 33)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 46:[78, 13] Operation: 72-59=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-13=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 46:[78, 59, 72]. Operations so far : ['92-20=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+59=137. \nResulting numbers: [72, 137].\nHeuristic score : (|72-46| + |137-46|)/2 = (26 + 91)/2 = 58.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 46:[72, 137] Operation: 78+59=137\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 137-72=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 46:[78, 59, 72]. Operations so far : ['92-20=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+72=150. \nResulting numbers: [59, 150].\nHeuristic score : (|59-46| + |150-46|)/2 = (13 + 104)/2 = 58.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 46:[59, 150] Operation: 78+72=150\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 150-59=91. \nResulting numbers: [91].\n91,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 46:[78, 59, 72]. Operations so far : ['92-20=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+72=131. \nResulting numbers: [78, 131].\nHeuristic score : (|78-46| + |131-46|)/2 = (32 + 85)/2 = 58.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 46:[78, 131] Operation: 59+72=131\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 131-78=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 46:[78, 59, 72]. Operations so far : ['92-20=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59*72=4248. \nResulting numbers: [78, 4248].\nHeuristic score : (|78-46| + |4248-46|)/2 = (32 + 4202)/2 = 2117.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 46:[78, 4248] Operation: 59*72=4248\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4248-78=4170. \nResulting numbers: [4170].\n4170,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 46:[78, 59, 72]. Operations so far : ['92-20=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*59=4602. \nResulting numbers: [72, 4602].\nHeuristic score : (|72-46| + |4602-46|)/2 = (26 + 4556)/2 = 2291.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 46:[72, 4602] Operation: 78*59=4602\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4602-72=4530. \nResulting numbers: [4530].\n4530,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 46:[78, 59, 72]. Operations so far : ['92-20=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*72=5616. \nResulting numbers: [59, 5616].\nHeuristic score : (|59-46| + |5616-46|)/2 = (13 + 5570)/2 = 2791.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 46:[59, 5616] Operation: 78*72=5616\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5616-59=5557. \nResulting numbers: [5557].\n5557,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.25\nCurrent State #0: 46:[78, 20, 92, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-59=33. \nResulting numbers: [78, 20, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|78-46| + |20-46| + |33-46|)/3 = (32 + 26 + 13)/3 = 23.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 46:[78, 20, 33] Operation: 92-59=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-20=58. \nResulting numbers: [33, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|33-46| + |58-46|)/2 = (13 + 12)/2 = 12.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 46:[33, 58] Operation: 78-20=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58-33=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 46:[78, 20, 33]. Operations so far : ['92-59=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-33=45. \nResulting numbers: [20, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|20-46| + |45-46|)/2 = (26 + 1)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 46:[20, 45] Operation: 78-33=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+45=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 46:[78, 20, 33]. Operations so far : ['92-59=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+33=53. \nResulting numbers: [78, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|78-46| + |53-46|)/2 = (32 + 7)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 46:[78, 53] Operation: 20+33=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-53=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 46:[78, 20, 33]. Operations so far : ['92-59=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+20=98. \nResulting numbers: [33, 98].\nHeuristic score : (|33-46| + |98-46|)/2 = (13 + 52)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 46:[33, 98] Operation: 78+20=98\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-33=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 46:[78, 20, 33]. Operations so far : ['92-59=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-20=13. \nResulting numbers: [78, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|78-46| + |13-46|)/2 = (32 + 33)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 46:[78, 13] Operation: 33-20=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-13=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 46:[78, 20, 33]. Operations so far : ['92-59=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+33=111. \nResulting numbers: [20, 111].\nHeuristic score : (|20-46| + |111-46|)/2 = (26 + 65)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 46:[20, 111] Operation: 78+33=111\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 111-20=91. \nResulting numbers: [91].\n91,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 46:[78, 20, 33]. Operations so far : ['92-59=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20*33=660. \nResulting numbers: [78, 660].\nHeuristic score : (|78-46| + |660-46|)/2 = (32 + 614)/2 = 323.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 46:[78, 660] Operation: 20*33=660\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 660-78=582. \nResulting numbers: [582].\n582,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 46:[78, 20, 33]. Operations so far : ['92-59=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*20=1560. \nResulting numbers: [33, 1560].\nHeuristic score : (|33-46| + |1560-46|)/2 = (13 + 1514)/2 = 763.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 46:[33, 1560] Operation: 78*20=1560\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1560-33=1527. \nResulting numbers: [1527].\n1527,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 46:[78, 20, 33]. Operations so far : ['92-59=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*33=2574. \nResulting numbers: [20, 2574].\nHeuristic score : (|20-46| + |2574-46|)/2 = (26 + 2528)/2 = 1277.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 46:[20, 2574] Operation: 78*33=2574\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2574-20=2554. \nResulting numbers: [2554].\n2554,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.25\nCurrent State #0: 46:[78, 20, 92, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-20=39. \nResulting numbers: [78, 92, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|78-46| + |92-46| + |39-46|)/3 = (32 + 46 + 7)/3 = 28.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 46:[78, 92, 39] Operation: 59-20=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-78=14. \nResulting numbers: [39, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|39-46| + |14-46|)/2 = (7 + 32)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 46:[39, 14] Operation: 92-78=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+14=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 46:[78, 92, 39]. Operations so far : ['59-20=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-39=53. \nResulting numbers: [78, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|78-46| + |53-46|)/2 = (32 + 7)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 46:[78, 53] Operation: 92-39=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-53=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 46:[78, 92, 39]. Operations so far : ['59-20=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-39=39. \nResulting numbers: [92, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|92-46| + |39-46|)/2 = (46 + 7)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 46:[92, 39] Operation: 78-39=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-39=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,46 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 46:[78, 92, 39]. Operations so far : ['59-20=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78/39=2. \nResulting numbers: [92, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|92-46| + |2-46|)/2 = (46 + 44)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 46:[92, 2] Operation: 78/39=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92/2=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,46 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['59-20=39', '78/39=2', '92/2=46']\nRESULT: 46\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 9,548 |
[
70,
56,
52,
59
]
| 98 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [70, 56, 52, 59] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 98. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [70, 56, 52, 59]. Our goal is to produce 98. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 98:[70, 56, 52, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+52=108. \nResulting numbers: [70, 59, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |59-98| + |108-98|)/3 = (28 + 39 + 10)/3 = 25.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 98:[70, 59, 108] Operation: 56+52=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+59=129. \nResulting numbers: [108, 129].\nHeuristic score : (|108-98| + |129-98|)/2 = (10 + 31)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 98:[108, 129] Operation: 70+59=129\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 129-108=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[70, 59, 108]. Operations so far : ['56+52=108'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-59=49. \nResulting numbers: [70, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |49-98|)/2 = (28 + 49)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 98:[70, 49] Operation: 108-59=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+49=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[70, 59, 108]. Operations so far : ['56+52=108'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-59=11. \nResulting numbers: [108, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|108-98| + |11-98|)/2 = (10 + 87)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 98:[108, 11] Operation: 70-59=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-11=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[70, 59, 108]. Operations so far : ['56+52=108'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+108=167. \nResulting numbers: [70, 167].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |167-98|)/2 = (28 + 69)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 98:[70, 167] Operation: 59+108=167\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 167-70=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[70, 59, 108]. Operations so far : ['56+52=108'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108-70=38. \nResulting numbers: [59, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |38-98|)/2 = (39 + 60)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 98:[59, 38] Operation: 108-70=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+38=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[70, 59, 108]. Operations so far : ['56+52=108'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+108=178. \nResulting numbers: [59, 178].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |178-98|)/2 = (39 + 80)/2 = 59.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 98:[59, 178] Operation: 70+108=178\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 178-59=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[70, 59, 108]. Operations so far : ['56+52=108'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*59=4130. \nResulting numbers: [108, 4130].\nHeuristic score : (|108-98| + |4130-98|)/2 = (10 + 4032)/2 = 2021.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 98:[108, 4130] Operation: 70*59=4130\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4130-108=4022. \nResulting numbers: [4022].\n4022,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[70, 59, 108]. Operations so far : ['56+52=108'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59*108=6372. \nResulting numbers: [70, 6372].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |6372-98|)/2 = (28 + 6274)/2 = 3151.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 98:[70, 6372] Operation: 59*108=6372\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6372-70=6302. \nResulting numbers: [6302].\n6302,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[70, 59, 108]. Operations so far : ['56+52=108'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*108=7560. \nResulting numbers: [59, 7560].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |7560-98|)/2 = (39 + 7462)/2 = 3750.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 98:[59, 7560] Operation: 70*108=7560\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7560-59=7501. \nResulting numbers: [7501].\n7501,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 38.75\nCurrent State #0: 98:[70, 56, 52, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+59=111. \nResulting numbers: [70, 56, 111].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |56-98| + |111-98|)/3 = (28 + 42 + 13)/3 = 27.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 98:[70, 56, 111] Operation: 52+59=111\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+56=126. \nResulting numbers: [111, 126].\nHeuristic score : (|111-98| + |126-98|)/2 = (13 + 28)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 98:[111, 126] Operation: 70+56=126\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 126-111=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[70, 56, 111]. Operations so far : ['52+59=111'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 111-56=55. \nResulting numbers: [70, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |55-98|)/2 = (28 + 43)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 98:[70, 55] Operation: 111-56=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+55=125. \nResulting numbers: [125].\n125,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[70, 56, 111]. Operations so far : ['52+59=111'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-56=14. \nResulting numbers: [111, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|111-98| + |14-98|)/2 = (13 + 84)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 98:[111, 14] Operation: 70-56=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 111-14=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[70, 56, 111]. Operations so far : ['52+59=111'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+111=167. \nResulting numbers: [70, 167].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |167-98|)/2 = (28 + 69)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 98:[70, 167] Operation: 56+111=167\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 167-70=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[70, 56, 111]. Operations so far : ['52+59=111'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 111-70=41. \nResulting numbers: [56, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |41-98|)/2 = (42 + 57)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 98:[56, 41] Operation: 111-70=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+41=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[70, 56, 111]. Operations so far : ['52+59=111'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+111=181. \nResulting numbers: [56, 181].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |181-98|)/2 = (42 + 83)/2 = 62.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 98:[56, 181] Operation: 70+111=181\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 181-56=125. \nResulting numbers: [125].\n125,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[70, 56, 111]. Operations so far : ['52+59=111'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*56=3920. \nResulting numbers: [111, 3920].\nHeuristic score : (|111-98| + |3920-98|)/2 = (13 + 3822)/2 = 1917.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 98:[111, 3920] Operation: 70*56=3920\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3920-111=3809. \nResulting numbers: [3809].\n3809,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[70, 56, 111]. Operations so far : ['52+59=111'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*111=6216. \nResulting numbers: [70, 6216].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |6216-98|)/2 = (28 + 6118)/2 = 3073.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 98:[70, 6216] Operation: 56*111=6216\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6216-70=6146. \nResulting numbers: [6146].\n6146,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 98:[70, 56, 111]. Operations so far : ['52+59=111'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*111=7770. \nResulting numbers: [56, 7770].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |7770-98|)/2 = (42 + 7672)/2 = 3857.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 98:[56, 7770] Operation: 70*111=7770\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7770-56=7714. \nResulting numbers: [7714].\n7714,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 38.75\nCurrent State #0: 98:[70, 56, 52, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+59=115. \nResulting numbers: [70, 52, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |52-98| + |115-98|)/3 = (28 + 46 + 17)/3 = 30.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 98:[70, 52, 115] Operation: 56+59=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+52=122. \nResulting numbers: [115, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|115-98| + |122-98|)/2 = (17 + 24)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 98:[115, 122] Operation: 70+52=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-115=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 98:[70, 52, 115]. Operations so far : ['56+59=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-52=63. \nResulting numbers: [70, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |63-98|)/2 = (28 + 35)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 98:[70, 63] Operation: 115-52=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+63=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 98:[70, 52, 115]. Operations so far : ['56+59=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-52=18. \nResulting numbers: [115, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|115-98| + |18-98|)/2 = (17 + 80)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 98:[115, 18] Operation: 70-52=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-18=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 98:[70, 52, 115]. Operations so far : ['56+59=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+115=167. \nResulting numbers: [70, 167].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |167-98|)/2 = (28 + 69)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 98:[70, 167] Operation: 52+115=167\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 167-70=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 98:[70, 52, 115]. Operations so far : ['56+59=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-70=45. \nResulting numbers: [52, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|52-98| + |45-98|)/2 = (46 + 53)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 98:[52, 45] Operation: 115-70=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+45=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 98:[70, 52, 115]. Operations so far : ['56+59=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+115=185. \nResulting numbers: [52, 185].\nHeuristic score : (|52-98| + |185-98|)/2 = (46 + 87)/2 = 66.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 98:[52, 185] Operation: 70+115=185\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 185-52=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 98:[70, 52, 115]. Operations so far : ['56+59=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*52=3640. \nResulting numbers: [115, 3640].\nHeuristic score : (|115-98| + |3640-98|)/2 = (17 + 3542)/2 = 1779.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 98:[115, 3640] Operation: 70*52=3640\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3640-115=3525. \nResulting numbers: [3525].\n3525,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 98:[70, 52, 115]. Operations so far : ['56+59=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*115=5980. \nResulting numbers: [70, 5980].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |5980-98|)/2 = (28 + 5882)/2 = 2955.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 98:[70, 5980] Operation: 52*115=5980\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5980-70=5910. \nResulting numbers: [5910].\n5910,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 98:[70, 52, 115]. Operations so far : ['56+59=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*115=8050. \nResulting numbers: [52, 8050].\nHeuristic score : (|52-98| + |8050-98|)/2 = (46 + 7952)/2 = 3999.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 98:[52, 8050] Operation: 70*115=8050\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8050-52=7998. \nResulting numbers: [7998].\n7998,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 38.75\nCurrent State #0: 98:[70, 56, 52, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+52=122. \nResulting numbers: [56, 59, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |59-98| + |122-98|)/3 = (42 + 39 + 24)/3 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 98:[56, 59, 122] Operation: 70+52=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+59=115. \nResulting numbers: [122, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|122-98| + |115-98|)/2 = (24 + 17)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 98:[122, 115] Operation: 56+59=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-115=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 98:[56, 59, 122]. Operations so far : ['70+52=122'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-56=66. \nResulting numbers: [59, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |66-98|)/2 = (39 + 32)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 98:[59, 66] Operation: 122-56=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+66=125. \nResulting numbers: [125].\n125,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 98:[56, 59, 122]. Operations so far : ['70+52=122'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-59=63. \nResulting numbers: [56, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |63-98|)/2 = (42 + 35)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 98:[56, 63] Operation: 122-59=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+63=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 98:[56, 59, 122]. Operations so far : ['70+52=122'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-56=3. \nResulting numbers: [122, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|122-98| + |3-98|)/2 = (24 + 95)/2 = 59.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 98:[122, 3] Operation: 59-56=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-3=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 98:[56, 59, 122]. Operations so far : ['70+52=122'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+122=178. \nResulting numbers: [59, 178].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |178-98|)/2 = (39 + 80)/2 = 59.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 98:[59, 178] Operation: 56+122=178\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 178-59=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 98:[56, 59, 122]. Operations so far : ['70+52=122'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+122=181. \nResulting numbers: [56, 181].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |181-98|)/2 = (42 + 83)/2 = 62.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 98:[56, 181] Operation: 59+122=181\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 181-56=125. \nResulting numbers: [125].\n125,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 98:[56, 59, 122]. Operations so far : ['70+52=122'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*59=3304. \nResulting numbers: [122, 3304].\nHeuristic score : (|122-98| + |3304-98|)/2 = (24 + 3206)/2 = 1615.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 98:[122, 3304] Operation: 56*59=3304\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3304-122=3182. \nResulting numbers: [3182].\n3182,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 98:[56, 59, 122]. Operations so far : ['70+52=122'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*122=6832. \nResulting numbers: [59, 6832].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |6832-98|)/2 = (39 + 6734)/2 = 3386.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 98:[59, 6832] Operation: 56*122=6832\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6832-59=6773. \nResulting numbers: [6773].\n6773,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 98:[56, 59, 122]. Operations so far : ['70+52=122'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59*122=7198. \nResulting numbers: [56, 7198].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |7198-98|)/2 = (42 + 7100)/2 = 3571.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 98:[56, 7198] Operation: 59*122=7198\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7198-56=7142. \nResulting numbers: [7142].\n7142,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 38.75\nCurrent State #0: 98:[70, 56, 52, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+56=126. \nResulting numbers: [52, 59, 126].\nHeuristic score : (|52-98| + |59-98| + |126-98|)/3 = (46 + 39 + 28)/3 = 37.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 98:[52, 59, 126] Operation: 70+56=126\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+59=111. \nResulting numbers: [126, 111].\nHeuristic score : (|126-98| + |111-98|)/2 = (28 + 13)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 98:[126, 111] Operation: 52+59=111\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 126-111=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 98:[52, 59, 126]. Operations so far : ['70+56=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 126-52=74. \nResulting numbers: [59, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |74-98|)/2 = (39 + 24)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 98:[59, 74] Operation: 126-52=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+74=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 98:[52, 59, 126]. Operations so far : ['70+56=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 126-59=67. \nResulting numbers: [52, 67].\nHeuristic score : (|52-98| + |67-98|)/2 = (46 + 31)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 98:[52, 67] Operation: 126-59=67\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+67=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 98:[52, 59, 126]. Operations so far : ['70+56=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-52=7. \nResulting numbers: [126, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|126-98| + |7-98|)/2 = (28 + 91)/2 = 59.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 98:[126, 7] Operation: 59-52=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 126-7=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 98:[52, 59, 126]. Operations so far : ['70+56=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+126=178. \nResulting numbers: [59, 178].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |178-98|)/2 = (39 + 80)/2 = 59.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 98:[59, 178] Operation: 52+126=178\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 178-59=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 98:[52, 59, 126]. Operations so far : ['70+56=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+126=185. \nResulting numbers: [52, 185].\nHeuristic score : (|52-98| + |185-98|)/2 = (46 + 87)/2 = 66.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 98:[52, 185] Operation: 59+126=185\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 185-52=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 98:[52, 59, 126]. Operations so far : ['70+56=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*59=3068. \nResulting numbers: [126, 3068].\nHeuristic score : (|126-98| + |3068-98|)/2 = (28 + 2970)/2 = 1499.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 98:[126, 3068] Operation: 52*59=3068\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3068-126=2942. \nResulting numbers: [2942].\n2942,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 98:[52, 59, 126]. Operations so far : ['70+56=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*126=6552. \nResulting numbers: [59, 6552].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |6552-98|)/2 = (39 + 6454)/2 = 3246.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 98:[59, 6552] Operation: 52*126=6552\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6552-59=6493. \nResulting numbers: [6493].\n6493,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 98:[52, 59, 126]. Operations so far : ['70+56=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59*126=7434. \nResulting numbers: [52, 7434].\nHeuristic score : (|52-98| + |7434-98|)/2 = (46 + 7336)/2 = 3691.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 98:[52, 7434] Operation: 59*126=7434\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7434-52=7382. \nResulting numbers: [7382].\n7382,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 38.75\nCurrent State #0: 98:[70, 56, 52, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+59=129. \nResulting numbers: [56, 52, 129].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |52-98| + |129-98|)/3 = (42 + 46 + 31)/3 = 39.67\nGenerated Node #0,5: 98:[56, 52, 129] Operation: 70+59=129\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+52=108. \nResulting numbers: [129, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|129-98| + |108-98|)/2 = (31 + 10)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 98:[129, 108] Operation: 56+52=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 129-108=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 39.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 98:[56, 52, 129]. Operations so far : ['70+59=129'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 129-52=77. \nResulting numbers: [56, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |77-98|)/2 = (42 + 21)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 98:[56, 77] Operation: 129-52=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+77=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 39.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 98:[56, 52, 129]. Operations so far : ['70+59=129'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 129-56=73. \nResulting numbers: [52, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|52-98| + |73-98|)/2 = (46 + 25)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 98:[52, 73] Operation: 129-56=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+73=125. \nResulting numbers: [125].\n125,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 39.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 98:[56, 52, 129]. Operations so far : ['70+59=129'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-52=4. \nResulting numbers: [129, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|129-98| + |4-98|)/2 = (31 + 94)/2 = 62.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,3: 98:[129, 4] Operation: 56-52=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 129-4=125. \nResulting numbers: [125].\n125,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 39.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 98:[56, 52, 129]. Operations so far : ['70+59=129'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+129=181. \nResulting numbers: [56, 181].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |181-98|)/2 = (42 + 83)/2 = 62.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,4: 98:[56, 181] Operation: 52+129=181\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 181-56=125. \nResulting numbers: [125].\n125,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 39.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 98:[56, 52, 129]. Operations so far : ['70+59=129'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+129=185. \nResulting numbers: [52, 185].\nHeuristic score : (|52-98| + |185-98|)/2 = (46 + 87)/2 = 66.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,5: 98:[52, 185] Operation: 56+129=185\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 185-52=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 39.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 98:[56, 52, 129]. Operations so far : ['70+59=129'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*52=2912. \nResulting numbers: [129, 2912].\nHeuristic score : (|129-98| + |2912-98|)/2 = (31 + 2814)/2 = 1422.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,6: 98:[129, 2912] Operation: 56*52=2912\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2912-129=2783. \nResulting numbers: [2783].\n2783,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 39.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 98:[56, 52, 129]. Operations so far : ['70+59=129'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*129=6708. \nResulting numbers: [56, 6708].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |6708-98|)/2 = (42 + 6610)/2 = 3326.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,7: 98:[56, 6708] Operation: 52*129=6708\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6708-56=6652. \nResulting numbers: [6652].\n6652,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 39.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,5: 98:[56, 52, 129]. Operations so far : ['70+59=129'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*129=7224. \nResulting numbers: [52, 7224].\nHeuristic score : (|52-98| + |7224-98|)/2 = (46 + 7126)/2 = 3586.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,8: 98:[52, 7224] Operation: 56*129=7224\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7224-52=7172. \nResulting numbers: [7172].\n7172,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 38.75\nCurrent State #0: 98:[70, 56, 52, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-52=18. \nResulting numbers: [56, 59, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |59-98| + |18-98|)/3 = (42 + 39 + 80)/3 = 53.67\nGenerated Node #0,6: 98:[56, 59, 18] Operation: 70-52=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+18=74. \nResulting numbers: [59, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |74-98|)/2 = (39 + 24)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,0: 98:[59, 74] Operation: 56+18=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+74=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 98:[56, 59, 18]. Operations so far : ['70-52=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+18=77. \nResulting numbers: [56, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |77-98|)/2 = (42 + 21)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,1: 98:[56, 77] Operation: 59+18=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+77=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 98:[56, 59, 18]. Operations so far : ['70-52=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+59=115. \nResulting numbers: [18, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|18-98| + |115-98|)/2 = (80 + 17)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,2: 98:[18, 115] Operation: 56+59=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-18=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 98:[56, 59, 18]. Operations so far : ['70-52=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-18=38. \nResulting numbers: [59, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |38-98|)/2 = (39 + 60)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,3: 98:[59, 38] Operation: 56-18=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+38=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 98:[56, 59, 18]. Operations so far : ['70-52=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-18=41. \nResulting numbers: [56, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |41-98|)/2 = (42 + 57)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,4: 98:[56, 41] Operation: 59-18=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+41=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 98:[56, 59, 18]. Operations so far : ['70-52=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-56=3. \nResulting numbers: [18, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|18-98| + |3-98|)/2 = (80 + 95)/2 = 87.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,5: 98:[18, 3] Operation: 59-56=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 18*3=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 98:[56, 59, 18]. Operations so far : ['70-52=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*18=1008. \nResulting numbers: [59, 1008].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |1008-98|)/2 = (39 + 910)/2 = 474.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,6: 98:[59, 1008] Operation: 56*18=1008\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1008-59=949. \nResulting numbers: [949].\n949,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 98:[56, 59, 18]. Operations so far : ['70-52=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59*18=1062. \nResulting numbers: [56, 1062].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |1062-98|)/2 = (42 + 964)/2 = 503.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,7: 98:[56, 1062] Operation: 59*18=1062\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1062-56=1006. \nResulting numbers: [1006].\n1006,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,6: 98:[56, 59, 18]. Operations so far : ['70-52=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56*59=3304. \nResulting numbers: [18, 3304].\nHeuristic score : (|18-98| + |3304-98|)/2 = (80 + 3206)/2 = 1643.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,8: 98:[18, 3304] Operation: 56*59=3304\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3304-18=3286. \nResulting numbers: [3286].\n3286,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 38.75\nCurrent State #0: 98:[70, 56, 52, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-52=4. \nResulting numbers: [70, 59, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |59-98| + |4-98|)/3 = (28 + 39 + 94)/3 = 53.67\nGenerated Node #0,7: 98:[70, 59, 4] Operation: 56-52=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+4=74. \nResulting numbers: [59, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |74-98|)/2 = (39 + 24)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,0: 98:[59, 74] Operation: 70+4=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+74=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 98:[70, 59, 4]. Operations so far : ['56-52=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+4=63. \nResulting numbers: [70, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |63-98|)/2 = (28 + 35)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,1: 98:[70, 63] Operation: 59+4=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+63=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 98:[70, 59, 4]. Operations so far : ['56-52=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-4=66. \nResulting numbers: [59, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |66-98|)/2 = (39 + 32)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,2: 98:[59, 66] Operation: 70-4=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+66=125. \nResulting numbers: [125].\n125,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 98:[70, 59, 4]. Operations so far : ['56-52=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-4=55. \nResulting numbers: [70, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |55-98|)/2 = (28 + 43)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,3: 98:[70, 55] Operation: 59-4=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+55=125. \nResulting numbers: [125].\n125,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 98:[70, 59, 4]. Operations so far : ['56-52=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+59=129. \nResulting numbers: [4, 129].\nHeuristic score : (|4-98| + |129-98|)/2 = (94 + 31)/2 = 62.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,4: 98:[4, 129] Operation: 70+59=129\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 129-4=125. \nResulting numbers: [125].\n125,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 98:[70, 59, 4]. Operations so far : ['56-52=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59*4=236. \nResulting numbers: [70, 236].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |236-98|)/2 = (28 + 138)/2 = 83.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,5: 98:[70, 236] Operation: 59*4=236\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 236-70=166. \nResulting numbers: [166].\n166,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 98:[70, 59, 4]. Operations so far : ['56-52=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-59=11. \nResulting numbers: [4, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|4-98| + |11-98|)/2 = (94 + 87)/2 = 90.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,6: 98:[4, 11] Operation: 70-59=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*11=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 98:[70, 59, 4]. Operations so far : ['56-52=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*4=280. \nResulting numbers: [59, 280].\nHeuristic score : (|59-98| + |280-98|)/2 = (39 + 182)/2 = 110.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,7: 98:[59, 280] Operation: 70*4=280\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 280-59=221. \nResulting numbers: [221].\n221,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,7: 98:[70, 59, 4]. Operations so far : ['56-52=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*59=4130. \nResulting numbers: [4, 4130].\nHeuristic score : (|4-98| + |4130-98|)/2 = (94 + 4032)/2 = 2063.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,8: 98:[4, 4130] Operation: 70*59=4130\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4130-4=4126. \nResulting numbers: [4126].\n4126,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 38.75\nCurrent State #0: 98:[70, 56, 52, 59]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-52=7. \nResulting numbers: [70, 56, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |56-98| + |7-98|)/3 = (28 + 42 + 91)/3 = 53.67\nGenerated Node #0,8: 98:[70, 56, 7] Operation: 59-52=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+7=77. \nResulting numbers: [56, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |77-98|)/2 = (42 + 21)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,0: 98:[56, 77] Operation: 70+7=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+77=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 98:[70, 56, 7]. Operations so far : ['59-52=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+7=63. \nResulting numbers: [70, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |63-98|)/2 = (28 + 35)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,1: 98:[70, 63] Operation: 56+7=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+63=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 98:[70, 56, 7]. Operations so far : ['59-52=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-7=63. \nResulting numbers: [56, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |63-98|)/2 = (42 + 35)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,2: 98:[56, 63] Operation: 70-7=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+63=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 98:[70, 56, 7]. Operations so far : ['59-52=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-7=49. \nResulting numbers: [70, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |49-98|)/2 = (28 + 49)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,3: 98:[70, 49] Operation: 56-7=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+49=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 98:[70, 56, 7]. Operations so far : ['59-52=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56/7=8. \nResulting numbers: [70, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|70-98| + |8-98|)/2 = (28 + 90)/2 = 59.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,4: 98:[70, 8] Operation: 56/7=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+8=78. \nResulting numbers: [78].\n78,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 98:[70, 56, 7]. Operations so far : ['59-52=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+56=126. \nResulting numbers: [7, 126].\nHeuristic score : (|7-98| + |126-98|)/2 = (91 + 28)/2 = 59.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,5: 98:[7, 126] Operation: 70+56=126\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 126-7=119. \nResulting numbers: [119].\n119,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 98:[70, 56, 7]. Operations so far : ['59-52=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70/7=10. \nResulting numbers: [56, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|56-98| + |10-98|)/2 = (42 + 88)/2 = 65.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,6: 98:[56, 10] Operation: 70/7=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56+10=66. \nResulting numbers: [66].\n66,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 53.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,8: 98:[70, 56, 7]. Operations so far : ['59-52=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-56=14. \nResulting numbers: [7, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|7-98| + |14-98|)/2 = (91 + 84)/2 = 87.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,7: 98:[7, 14] Operation: 70-56=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*14=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,98 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['59-52=7', '70-56=14', '7*14=98']\nRESULT: 98\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 18,898 |
[
32,
30,
39,
54
]
| 31 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [32, 30, 39, 54] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 31. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [32, 30, 39, 54]. Our goal is to produce 31. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 31:[32, 30, 39, 54]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-30=24. \nResulting numbers: [32, 39, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|32-31| + |39-31| + |24-31|)/3 = (1 + 8 + 7)/3 = 5.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 31:[32, 39, 24] Operation: 54-30=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-24=15. \nResulting numbers: [32, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|32-31| + |15-31|)/2 = (1 + 16)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 31:[32, 15] Operation: 39-24=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-15=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,31 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 5.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,0: 31:[32, 39, 24]. Operations so far : ['54-30=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-32=7. \nResulting numbers: [24, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|24-31| + |7-31|)/2 = (7 + 24)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 31:[24, 7] Operation: 39-32=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+7=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,31 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['54-30=24', '39-32=7', '24+7=31']\nRESULT: 31\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 649 |
[
37,
79,
9,
43
]
| 25 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [37, 79, 9, 43] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 25. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [37, 79, 9, 43]. Our goal is to produce 25. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 25:[37, 79, 9, 43]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-43=36. \nResulting numbers: [37, 9, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |9-25| + |36-25|)/3 = (12 + 16 + 11)/3 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 25:[37, 9, 36] Operation: 79-43=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-9=28. \nResulting numbers: [36, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|36-25| + |28-25|)/2 = (11 + 3)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 25:[36, 28] Operation: 37-9=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-28=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 25:[37, 9, 36]. Operations so far : ['79-43=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-9=27. \nResulting numbers: [37, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |27-25|)/2 = (12 + 2)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 25:[37, 27] Operation: 36-9=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-27=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 25:[37, 9, 36]. Operations so far : ['79-43=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+9=46. \nResulting numbers: [36, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|36-25| + |46-25|)/2 = (11 + 21)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 25:[36, 46] Operation: 37+9=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46-36=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 25:[37, 9, 36]. Operations so far : ['79-43=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9+36=45. \nResulting numbers: [37, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |45-25|)/2 = (12 + 20)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 25:[37, 45] Operation: 9+36=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-37=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 25:[37, 9, 36]. Operations so far : ['79-43=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36/9=4. \nResulting numbers: [37, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |4-25|)/2 = (12 + 21)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 25:[37, 4] Operation: 36/9=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-4=33. \nResulting numbers: [33].\n33,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 25:[37, 9, 36]. Operations so far : ['79-43=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-36=1. \nResulting numbers: [9, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|9-25| + |1-25|)/2 = (16 + 24)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 25:[9, 1] Operation: 37-36=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9+1=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 25:[37, 9, 36]. Operations so far : ['79-43=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+36=73. \nResulting numbers: [9, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|9-25| + |73-25|)/2 = (16 + 48)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 25:[9, 73] Operation: 37+36=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-9=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 25:[37, 9, 36]. Operations so far : ['79-43=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9*36=324. \nResulting numbers: [37, 324].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |324-25|)/2 = (12 + 299)/2 = 155.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 25:[37, 324] Operation: 9*36=324\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 324-37=287. \nResulting numbers: [287].\n287,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 25:[37, 9, 36]. Operations so far : ['79-43=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*9=333. \nResulting numbers: [36, 333].\nHeuristic score : (|36-25| + |333-25|)/2 = (11 + 308)/2 = 159.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 25:[36, 333] Operation: 37*9=333\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 333-36=297. \nResulting numbers: [297].\n297,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 25:[37, 9, 36]. Operations so far : ['79-43=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*36=1332. \nResulting numbers: [9, 1332].\nHeuristic score : (|9-25| + |1332-25|)/2 = (16 + 1307)/2 = 661.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,9: 25:[9, 1332] Operation: 37*36=1332\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1332/9=148. \nResulting numbers: [148].\n148,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0: 25:[37, 79, 9, 43]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-37=42. \nResulting numbers: [9, 43, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|9-25| + |43-25| + |42-25|)/3 = (16 + 18 + 17)/3 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 25:[9, 43, 42] Operation: 79-37=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-9=34. \nResulting numbers: [42, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|42-25| + |34-25|)/2 = (17 + 9)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 25:[42, 34] Operation: 43-9=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-34=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 25:[9, 43, 42]. Operations so far : ['79-37=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-9=33. \nResulting numbers: [43, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|43-25| + |33-25|)/2 = (18 + 8)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 25:[43, 33] Operation: 42-9=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-33=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 25:[9, 43, 42]. Operations so far : ['79-37=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-42=1. \nResulting numbers: [9, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|9-25| + |1-25|)/2 = (16 + 24)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 25:[9, 1] Operation: 43-42=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9+1=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 25:[9, 43, 42]. Operations so far : ['79-37=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9+43=52. \nResulting numbers: [42, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|42-25| + |52-25|)/2 = (17 + 27)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 25:[42, 52] Operation: 9+43=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-42=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 25:[9, 43, 42]. Operations so far : ['79-37=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9+42=51. \nResulting numbers: [43, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|43-25| + |51-25|)/2 = (18 + 26)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 25:[43, 51] Operation: 9+42=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-43=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 25:[9, 43, 42]. Operations so far : ['79-37=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+42=85. \nResulting numbers: [9, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|9-25| + |85-25|)/2 = (16 + 60)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 25:[9, 85] Operation: 43+42=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-9=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 25:[9, 43, 42]. Operations so far : ['79-37=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9*42=378. \nResulting numbers: [43, 378].\nHeuristic score : (|43-25| + |378-25|)/2 = (18 + 353)/2 = 185.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 25:[43, 378] Operation: 9*42=378\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 378-43=335. \nResulting numbers: [335].\n335,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 25:[9, 43, 42]. Operations so far : ['79-37=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9*43=387. \nResulting numbers: [42, 387].\nHeuristic score : (|42-25| + |387-25|)/2 = (17 + 362)/2 = 189.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 25:[42, 387] Operation: 9*43=387\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 387-42=345. \nResulting numbers: [345].\n345,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 25:[9, 43, 42]. Operations so far : ['79-37=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43*42=1806. \nResulting numbers: [9, 1806].\nHeuristic score : (|9-25| + |1806-25|)/2 = (16 + 1781)/2 = 898.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 25:[9, 1806] Operation: 43*42=1806\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1806-9=1797. \nResulting numbers: [1797].\n1797,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0: 25:[37, 79, 9, 43]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-9=28. \nResulting numbers: [79, 43, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|79-25| + |43-25| + |28-25|)/3 = (54 + 18 + 3)/3 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 25:[79, 43, 28] Operation: 37-9=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-43=36. \nResulting numbers: [28, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|28-25| + |36-25|)/2 = (3 + 11)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 25:[28, 36] Operation: 79-43=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-28=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 25:[79, 43, 28]. Operations so far : ['37-9=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-28=51. \nResulting numbers: [43, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|43-25| + |51-25|)/2 = (18 + 26)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 25:[43, 51] Operation: 79-28=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-43=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 25:[79, 43, 28]. Operations so far : ['37-9=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-28=15. \nResulting numbers: [79, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|79-25| + |15-25|)/2 = (54 + 10)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 25:[79, 15] Operation: 43-28=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-15=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 25:[79, 43, 28]. Operations so far : ['37-9=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+43=122. \nResulting numbers: [28, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|28-25| + |122-25|)/2 = (3 + 97)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 25:[28, 122] Operation: 79+43=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-28=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 25:[79, 43, 28]. Operations so far : ['37-9=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+28=107. \nResulting numbers: [43, 107].\nHeuristic score : (|43-25| + |107-25|)/2 = (18 + 82)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 25:[43, 107] Operation: 79+28=107\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 107-43=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 25:[79, 43, 28]. Operations so far : ['37-9=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+28=71. \nResulting numbers: [79, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|79-25| + |71-25|)/2 = (54 + 46)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 25:[79, 71] Operation: 43+28=71\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-71=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 25:[79, 43, 28]. Operations so far : ['37-9=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43*28=1204. \nResulting numbers: [79, 1204].\nHeuristic score : (|79-25| + |1204-25|)/2 = (54 + 1179)/2 = 616.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 25:[79, 1204] Operation: 43*28=1204\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1204-79=1125. \nResulting numbers: [1125].\n1125,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 25:[79, 43, 28]. Operations so far : ['37-9=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*28=2212. \nResulting numbers: [43, 2212].\nHeuristic score : (|43-25| + |2212-25|)/2 = (18 + 2187)/2 = 1102.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 25:[43, 2212] Operation: 79*28=2212\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2212-43=2169. \nResulting numbers: [2169].\n2169,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 25:[79, 43, 28]. Operations so far : ['37-9=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*43=3397. \nResulting numbers: [28, 3397].\nHeuristic score : (|28-25| + |3397-25|)/2 = (3 + 3372)/2 = 1687.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 25:[28, 3397] Operation: 79*43=3397\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3397-28=3369. \nResulting numbers: [3369].\n3369,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0: 25:[37, 79, 9, 43]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-9=70. \nResulting numbers: [37, 43, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |43-25| + |70-25|)/3 = (12 + 18 + 45)/3 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 25:[37, 43, 70] Operation: 79-9=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-43=27. \nResulting numbers: [37, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |27-25|)/2 = (12 + 2)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 25:[37, 27] Operation: 70-43=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-27=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 25:[37, 43, 70]. Operations so far : ['79-9=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-37=33. \nResulting numbers: [43, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|43-25| + |33-25|)/2 = (18 + 8)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 25:[43, 33] Operation: 70-37=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-33=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 25:[37, 43, 70]. Operations so far : ['79-9=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-37=6. \nResulting numbers: [70, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|70-25| + |6-25|)/2 = (45 + 19)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 25:[70, 6] Operation: 43-37=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-6=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 25:[37, 43, 70]. Operations so far : ['79-9=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+43=80. \nResulting numbers: [70, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|70-25| + |80-25|)/2 = (45 + 55)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 25:[70, 80] Operation: 37+43=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-70=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 25:[37, 43, 70]. Operations so far : ['79-9=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+70=107. \nResulting numbers: [43, 107].\nHeuristic score : (|43-25| + |107-25|)/2 = (18 + 82)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 25:[43, 107] Operation: 37+70=107\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 107-43=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 25:[37, 43, 70]. Operations so far : ['79-9=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+70=113. \nResulting numbers: [37, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |113-25|)/2 = (12 + 88)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 25:[37, 113] Operation: 43+70=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-37=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 25:[37, 43, 70]. Operations so far : ['79-9=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*43=1591. \nResulting numbers: [70, 1591].\nHeuristic score : (|70-25| + |1591-25|)/2 = (45 + 1566)/2 = 805.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 25:[70, 1591] Operation: 37*43=1591\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1591-70=1521. \nResulting numbers: [1521].\n1521,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 25:[37, 43, 70]. Operations so far : ['79-9=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*70=2590. \nResulting numbers: [43, 2590].\nHeuristic score : (|43-25| + |2590-25|)/2 = (18 + 2565)/2 = 1291.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 25:[43, 2590] Operation: 37*70=2590\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2590-43=2547. \nResulting numbers: [2547].\n2547,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 25:[37, 43, 70]. Operations so far : ['79-9=70'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43*70=3010. \nResulting numbers: [37, 3010].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |3010-25|)/2 = (12 + 2985)/2 = 1498.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 25:[37, 3010] Operation: 43*70=3010\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3010-37=2973. \nResulting numbers: [2973].\n2973,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0: 25:[37, 79, 9, 43]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-9=34. \nResulting numbers: [37, 79, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |79-25| + |34-25|)/3 = (12 + 54 + 9)/3 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 25:[37, 79, 34] Operation: 43-9=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-37=42. \nResulting numbers: [34, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|34-25| + |42-25|)/2 = (9 + 17)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 25:[34, 42] Operation: 79-37=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-34=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 25:[37, 79, 34]. Operations so far : ['43-9=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-34=45. \nResulting numbers: [37, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |45-25|)/2 = (12 + 20)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 25:[37, 45] Operation: 79-34=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-37=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 25:[37, 79, 34]. Operations so far : ['43-9=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-34=3. \nResulting numbers: [79, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|79-25| + |3-25|)/2 = (54 + 22)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 25:[79, 3] Operation: 37-34=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-3=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 25:[37, 79, 34]. Operations so far : ['43-9=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+79=116. \nResulting numbers: [34, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|34-25| + |116-25|)/2 = (9 + 91)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 25:[34, 116] Operation: 37+79=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-34=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 25:[37, 79, 34]. Operations so far : ['43-9=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+34=71. \nResulting numbers: [79, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|79-25| + |71-25|)/2 = (54 + 46)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 25:[79, 71] Operation: 37+34=71\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-71=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 25:[37, 79, 34]. Operations so far : ['43-9=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+34=113. \nResulting numbers: [37, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |113-25|)/2 = (12 + 88)/2 = 50.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 25:[37, 113] Operation: 79+34=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-37=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 25:[37, 79, 34]. Operations so far : ['43-9=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*34=1258. \nResulting numbers: [79, 1258].\nHeuristic score : (|79-25| + |1258-25|)/2 = (54 + 1233)/2 = 643.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 25:[79, 1258] Operation: 37*34=1258\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1258-79=1179. \nResulting numbers: [1179].\n1179,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 25:[37, 79, 34]. Operations so far : ['43-9=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*34=2686. \nResulting numbers: [37, 2686].\nHeuristic score : (|37-25| + |2686-25|)/2 = (12 + 2661)/2 = 1336.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 25:[37, 2686] Operation: 79*34=2686\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2686-37=2649. \nResulting numbers: [2649].\n2649,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 25:[37, 79, 34]. Operations so far : ['43-9=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*79=2923. \nResulting numbers: [34, 2923].\nHeuristic score : (|34-25| + |2923-25|)/2 = (9 + 2898)/2 = 1453.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 25:[34, 2923] Operation: 37*79=2923\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2923-34=2889. \nResulting numbers: [2889].\n2889,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0: 25:[37, 79, 9, 43]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-37=6. \nResulting numbers: [79, 9, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|79-25| + |9-25| + |6-25|)/3 = (54 + 16 + 19)/3 = 29.67\nGenerated Node #0,5: 25:[79, 9, 6] Operation: 43-37=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-9=70. \nResulting numbers: [6, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|6-25| + |70-25|)/2 = (19 + 45)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 25:[6, 70] Operation: 79-9=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-6=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 29.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 25:[79, 9, 6]. Operations so far : ['43-37=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-6=73. \nResulting numbers: [9, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|9-25| + |73-25|)/2 = (16 + 48)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 25:[9, 73] Operation: 79-6=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-9=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 29.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 25:[79, 9, 6]. Operations so far : ['43-37=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9+6=15. \nResulting numbers: [79, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|79-25| + |15-25|)/2 = (54 + 10)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 25:[79, 15] Operation: 9+6=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-15=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 29.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 25:[79, 9, 6]. Operations so far : ['43-37=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+6=85. \nResulting numbers: [9, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|9-25| + |85-25|)/2 = (16 + 60)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,3: 25:[9, 85] Operation: 79+6=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-9=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 29.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 25:[79, 9, 6]. Operations so far : ['43-37=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9-6=3. \nResulting numbers: [79, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|79-25| + |3-25|)/2 = (54 + 22)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,4: 25:[79, 3] Operation: 9-6=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-3=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 29.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 25:[79, 9, 6]. Operations so far : ['43-37=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+9=88. \nResulting numbers: [6, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|6-25| + |88-25|)/2 = (19 + 63)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,5: 25:[6, 88] Operation: 79+9=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-6=82. \nResulting numbers: [82].\n82,25 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 29.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,5: 25:[79, 9, 6]. Operations so far : ['43-37=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9*6=54. \nResulting numbers: [79, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|79-25| + |54-25|)/2 = (54 + 29)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,6: 25:[79, 54] Operation: 9*6=54\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-54=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,25 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['43-37=6', '9*6=54', '79-54=25']\nRESULT: 25\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 12,374 |
[
98,
91,
38,
98
]
| 52 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [98, 91, 38, 98] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 52. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [98, 91, 38, 98]. Our goal is to produce 52. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 52:[98, 91, 38, 98]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-38=60. \nResulting numbers: [91, 98, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|91-52| + |98-52| + |60-52|)/3 = (39 + 46 + 8)/3 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 52:[91, 98, 60] Operation: 98-38=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-38=60. \nResulting numbers: [98, 91, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|98-52| + |91-52| + |60-52|)/3 = (46 + 39 + 8)/3 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 52:[98, 91, 60] Operation: 98-38=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-38=53. \nResulting numbers: [98, 98, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|98-52| + |98-52| + |53-52|)/3 = (46 + 46 + 1)/3 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 52:[98, 98, 53] Operation: 91-38=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-91=7. \nResulting numbers: [38, 98, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|38-52| + |98-52| + |7-52|)/3 = (14 + 46 + 45)/3 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 52:[38, 98, 7] Operation: 98-91=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98/98=1. \nResulting numbers: [91, 38, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|91-52| + |38-52| + |1-52|)/3 = (39 + 14 + 51)/3 = 34.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 52:[91, 38, 1] Operation: 98/98=1\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 52:[91, 98, 60]. Operations so far : ['98-38=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-60=31. \nResulting numbers: [98, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|98-52| + |31-52|)/2 = (46 + 21)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 52:[98, 31] Operation: 91-60=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+60=151. \nResulting numbers: [98, 151].\nHeuristic score : (|98-52| + |151-52|)/2 = (46 + 99)/2 = 72.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 52:[98, 151] Operation: 91+60=151\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+98=189. \nResulting numbers: [60, 189].\nHeuristic score : (|60-52| + |189-52|)/2 = (8 + 137)/2 = 72.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 52:[60, 189] Operation: 91+98=189\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-60=38. \nResulting numbers: [91, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|91-52| + |38-52|)/2 = (39 + 14)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 52:[91, 38] Operation: 98-60=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-91=7. \nResulting numbers: [60, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|60-52| + |7-52|)/2 = (8 + 45)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 52:[60, 7] Operation: 98-91=7\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 52:[98, 98, 53]. Operations so far : ['91-38=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-53=45. \nResulting numbers: [98, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|98-52| + |45-52|)/2 = (46 + 7)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 52:[98, 45] Operation: 98-53=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-53=45. \nResulting numbers: [98, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|98-52| + |45-52|)/2 = (46 + 7)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 52:[98, 45] Operation: 98-53=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-98=0. \nResulting numbers: [53, 0].\nHeuristic score : (|53-52| + |0-52|)/2 = (1 + 52)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 52:[53, 0] Operation: 98-98=0\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+98=196. \nResulting numbers: [53, 196].\nHeuristic score : (|53-52| + |196-52|)/2 = (1 + 144)/2 = 72.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 52:[53, 196] Operation: 98+98=196\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98/98=1. \nResulting numbers: [53, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|53-52| + |1-52|)/2 = (1 + 51)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 52:[53, 1] Operation: 98/98=1\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 52:[98, 91, 60]. Operations so far : ['98-38=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-60=31. \nResulting numbers: [98, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|98-52| + |31-52|)/2 = (46 + 21)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 52:[98, 31] Operation: 91-60=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+60=158. \nResulting numbers: [91, 158].\nHeuristic score : (|91-52| + |158-52|)/2 = (39 + 106)/2 = 72.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 52:[91, 158] Operation: 98+60=158\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+91=189. \nResulting numbers: [60, 189].\nHeuristic score : (|60-52| + |189-52|)/2 = (8 + 137)/2 = 72.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 52:[60, 189] Operation: 98+91=189\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-91=7. \nResulting numbers: [60, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|60-52| + |7-52|)/2 = (8 + 45)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 52:[60, 7] Operation: 98-91=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-60=38. \nResulting numbers: [91, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|91-52| + |38-52|)/2 = (39 + 14)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 52:[91, 38] Operation: 98-60=38\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 34.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,4: 52:[91, 38, 1]. Operations so far : ['98/98=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91/1=91. \nResulting numbers: [38, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|38-52| + |91-52|)/2 = (14 + 39)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 52:[38, 91] Operation: 91/1=91\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91*1=91. \nResulting numbers: [38, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|38-52| + |91-52|)/2 = (14 + 39)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 52:[38, 91] Operation: 91*1=91\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-1=90. \nResulting numbers: [38, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|38-52| + |90-52|)/2 = (14 + 38)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 52:[38, 90] Operation: 91-1=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-38=53. \nResulting numbers: [1, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|1-52| + |53-52|)/2 = (51 + 1)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 52:[1, 53] Operation: 91-38=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+1=39. \nResulting numbers: [91, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|91-52| + |39-52|)/2 = (39 + 13)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 52:[91, 39] Operation: 38+1=39\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 52:[38, 98, 7]. Operations so far : ['98-91=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98/7=14. \nResulting numbers: [38, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|38-52| + |14-52|)/2 = (14 + 38)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 52:[38, 14] Operation: 98/7=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-7=31. \nResulting numbers: [98, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|98-52| + |31-52|)/2 = (46 + 21)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 52:[98, 31] Operation: 38-7=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-7=91. \nResulting numbers: [38, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|38-52| + |91-52|)/2 = (14 + 39)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 52:[38, 91] Operation: 98-7=91\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+7=45. \nResulting numbers: [98, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|98-52| + |45-52|)/2 = (46 + 7)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 52:[98, 45] Operation: 38+7=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-38=60. \nResulting numbers: [7, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|7-52| + |60-52|)/2 = (45 + 8)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 52:[7, 60] Operation: 98-38=60\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 52:[53, 1]. Operations so far : ['91-38=53', '98/98=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53/1=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,52 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53*1=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,52 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+1=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,52 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53-1=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,52 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['91-38=53', '98/98=1', '53/1=53']\nRESULT: 53\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 3,883 |
[
43,
29,
52,
55
]
| 69 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [43, 29, 52, 55] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 69. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [43, 29, 52, 55]. Our goal is to produce 69. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 69:[43, 29, 52, 55]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+52=95. \nResulting numbers: [29, 55, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|29-69| + |55-69| + |95-69|)/3 = (40 + 14 + 26)/3 = 26.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 69:[29, 55, 95] Operation: 43+52=95\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29+55=84. \nResulting numbers: [43, 52, 84].\nHeuristic score : (|43-69| + |52-69| + |84-69|)/3 = (26 + 17 + 15)/3 = 19.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 69:[43, 52, 84] Operation: 29+55=84\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29+52=81. \nResulting numbers: [43, 55, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|43-69| + |55-69| + |81-69|)/3 = (26 + 14 + 12)/3 = 17.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 69:[43, 55, 81] Operation: 29+52=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-29=14. \nResulting numbers: [52, 55, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|52-69| + |55-69| + |14-69|)/3 = (17 + 14 + 55)/3 = 28.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 69:[52, 55, 14] Operation: 43-29=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+29=72. \nResulting numbers: [52, 55, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|52-69| + |55-69| + |72-69|)/3 = (17 + 14 + 3)/3 = 11.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 69:[52, 55, 72] Operation: 43+29=72\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,4: 69:[52, 55, 72]. Operations so far : ['43+29=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-52=3. \nResulting numbers: [72, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|72-69| + |3-69|)/2 = (3 + 66)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 69:[72, 3] Operation: 55-52=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-52=20. \nResulting numbers: [55, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|55-69| + |20-69|)/2 = (14 + 49)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 69:[55, 20] Operation: 72-52=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+55=107. \nResulting numbers: [72, 107].\nHeuristic score : (|72-69| + |107-69|)/2 = (3 + 38)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 69:[72, 107] Operation: 52+55=107\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-55=17. \nResulting numbers: [52, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|52-69| + |17-69|)/2 = (17 + 52)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 69:[52, 17] Operation: 72-55=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+72=124. \nResulting numbers: [55, 124].\nHeuristic score : (|55-69| + |124-69|)/2 = (14 + 55)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 69:[55, 124] Operation: 52+72=124\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 69:[43, 55, 81]. Operations so far : ['29+52=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+55=98. \nResulting numbers: [81, 98].\nHeuristic score : (|81-69| + |98-69|)/2 = (12 + 29)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 69:[81, 98] Operation: 43+55=98\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-43=38. \nResulting numbers: [55, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|55-69| + |38-69|)/2 = (14 + 31)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 69:[55, 38] Operation: 81-43=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-55=26. \nResulting numbers: [43, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|43-69| + |26-69|)/2 = (26 + 43)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 69:[43, 26] Operation: 81-55=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-43=12. \nResulting numbers: [81, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|81-69| + |12-69|)/2 = (12 + 57)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 69:[81, 12] Operation: 55-43=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+81=124. \nResulting numbers: [55, 124].\nHeuristic score : (|55-69| + |124-69|)/2 = (14 + 55)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 69:[55, 124] Operation: 43+81=124\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 69:[43, 52, 84]. Operations so far : ['29+55=84'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+84=127. \nResulting numbers: [52, 127].\nHeuristic score : (|52-69| + |127-69|)/2 = (17 + 58)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 69:[52, 127] Operation: 43+84=127\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-43=41. \nResulting numbers: [52, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|52-69| + |41-69|)/2 = (17 + 28)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 69:[52, 41] Operation: 84-43=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-43=9. \nResulting numbers: [84, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|84-69| + |9-69|)/2 = (15 + 60)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 69:[84, 9] Operation: 52-43=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+52=95. \nResulting numbers: [84, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|84-69| + |95-69|)/2 = (15 + 26)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 69:[84, 95] Operation: 43+52=95\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-52=32. \nResulting numbers: [43, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|43-69| + |32-69|)/2 = (26 + 37)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 69:[43, 32] Operation: 84-52=32\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 26.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 69:[29, 55, 95]. Operations so far : ['43+52=95'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29+95=124. \nResulting numbers: [55, 124].\nHeuristic score : (|55-69| + |124-69|)/2 = (14 + 55)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 69:[55, 124] Operation: 29+95=124\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-29=66. \nResulting numbers: [55, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|55-69| + |66-69|)/2 = (14 + 3)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 69:[55, 66] Operation: 95-29=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29+55=84. \nResulting numbers: [95, 84].\nHeuristic score : (|95-69| + |84-69|)/2 = (26 + 15)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 69:[95, 84] Operation: 29+55=84\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-29=26. \nResulting numbers: [95, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|95-69| + |26-69|)/2 = (26 + 43)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 69:[95, 26] Operation: 55-29=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-55=40. \nResulting numbers: [29, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|29-69| + |40-69|)/2 = (40 + 29)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 69:[29, 40] Operation: 95-55=40\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 69:[52, 55, 14]. Operations so far : ['43-29=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+14=66. \nResulting numbers: [55, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|55-69| + |66-69|)/2 = (14 + 3)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 69:[55, 66] Operation: 52+14=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-14=38. \nResulting numbers: [55, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|55-69| + |38-69|)/2 = (14 + 31)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 69:[55, 38] Operation: 52-14=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-14=41. \nResulting numbers: [52, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|52-69| + |41-69|)/2 = (17 + 28)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 69:[52, 41] Operation: 55-14=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+55=107. \nResulting numbers: [14, 107].\nHeuristic score : (|14-69| + |107-69|)/2 = (55 + 38)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 69:[14, 107] Operation: 52+55=107\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+14=69. \nResulting numbers: [52, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|52-69| + |69-69|)/2 = (17 + 0)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 69:[52, 69] Operation: 55+14=69\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 8.5\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 69:[55, 66]. Operations so far : ['43+52=95', '95-29=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+66=121. \nResulting numbers: [121].\n121,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55*66=3630. \nResulting numbers: [3630].\n3630,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-55=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 8.5\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 69:[55, 66]. Operations so far : ['43-29=14', '52+14=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-55=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+66=121. \nResulting numbers: [121].\n121,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55*66=3630. \nResulting numbers: [3630].\n3630,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 8.5\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 69:[52, 69]. Operations so far : ['43-29=14', '55+14=69'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*69=3588. \nResulting numbers: [3588].\n3588,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-52=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+69=121. \nResulting numbers: [121].\n121,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.5\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 69:[81, 98]. Operations so far : ['29+52=81', '43+55=98'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+98=179. \nResulting numbers: [179].\n179,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*98=7938. \nResulting numbers: [7938].\n7938,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-81=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.5\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 69:[72, 107]. Operations so far : ['43+29=72', '52+55=107'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72+107=179. \nResulting numbers: [179].\n179,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72*107=7704. \nResulting numbers: [7704].\n7704,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 107-72=35. \nResulting numbers: [35].\n35,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 20.5\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 69:[84, 95]. Operations so far : ['29+55=84', '43+52=95'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84*95=7980. \nResulting numbers: [7980].\n7980,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84+95=179. \nResulting numbers: [179].\n179,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-84=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 69:[95, 84]. Operations so far : ['43+52=95', '29+55=84'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-84=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95*84=7980. \nResulting numbers: [7980].\n7980,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95+84=179. \nResulting numbers: [179].\n179,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 69:[55, 38]. Operations so far : ['29+52=81', '81-43=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55*38=2090. \nResulting numbers: [2090].\n2090,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-38=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+38=93. \nResulting numbers: [93].\n93,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 69:[52, 41]. Operations so far : ['29+55=84', '84-43=41'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*41=2132. \nResulting numbers: [2132].\n2132,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-41=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+41=93. \nResulting numbers: [93].\n93,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 69:[52, 41]. Operations so far : ['43-29=14', '55-14=41'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*41=2132. \nResulting numbers: [2132].\n2132,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+41=93. \nResulting numbers: [93].\n93,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-41=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 69:[55, 38]. Operations so far : ['43-29=14', '52-14=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55*38=2090. \nResulting numbers: [2090].\n2090,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+38=93. \nResulting numbers: [93].\n93,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-38=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,2,1,2: 69:[93]. Operations so far : ['29+52=81', '81-43=38', '55+38=93'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 69:[93]. Operations so far : ['29+55=84', '84-43=41', '52+41=93'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,3,2,1: 69:[93]. Operations so far : ['43-29=14', '55-14=41', '52+41=93'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 69:[43, 32]. Operations so far : ['29+55=84', '84-52=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-32=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+32=75. \nResulting numbers: [75].\n75,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43*32=1376. \nResulting numbers: [1376].\n1376,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 6\nCurrent State #0,1,4,1: 69:[75]. Operations so far : ['29+55=84', '84-52=32', '43+32=75'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,3,1,1: 69:[93]. Operations so far : ['43-29=14', '52-14=38', '55+38=93'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 31.5\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 69:[55, 20]. Operations so far : ['43+29=72', '72-52=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55*20=1100. \nResulting numbers: [1100].\n1100,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-20=35. \nResulting numbers: [35].\n35,69 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+20=75. \nResulting numbers: [75].\n75,69 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,4,2,2: 69:[35]. Operations so far : ['43+29=72', '52+55=107', '107-72=35'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 69:[43, 26]. Operations so far : ['29+52=81', '81-55=26'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+26=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,69 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['29+52=81', '81-55=26', '43-26=17']\nRESULT: 17\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,367 |
[
98,
83,
62,
45
]
| 65 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [98, 83, 62, 45] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 65. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [98, 83, 62, 45]. Our goal is to produce 65. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 65:[98, 83, 62, 45]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-45=53. \nResulting numbers: [83, 62, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|83-65| + |62-65| + |53-65|)/3 = (18 + 3 + 12)/3 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 65:[83, 62, 53] Operation: 98-45=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-53=30. \nResulting numbers: [62, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|62-65| + |30-65|)/2 = (3 + 35)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 65:[62, 30] Operation: 83-53=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+30=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 65:[83, 62, 53]. Operations so far : ['98-45=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-62=21. \nResulting numbers: [53, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|53-65| + |21-65|)/2 = (12 + 44)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 65:[53, 21] Operation: 83-62=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 53+21=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 65:[83, 62, 53]. Operations so far : ['98-45=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+53=115. \nResulting numbers: [83, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|83-65| + |115-65|)/2 = (18 + 50)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 65:[83, 115] Operation: 62+53=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-83=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 65:[83, 62, 53]. Operations so far : ['98-45=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+53=136. \nResulting numbers: [62, 136].\nHeuristic score : (|62-65| + |136-65|)/2 = (3 + 71)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 65:[62, 136] Operation: 83+53=136\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 136-62=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 65:[83, 62, 53]. Operations so far : ['98-45=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-53=9. \nResulting numbers: [83, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|83-65| + |9-65|)/2 = (18 + 56)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 65:[83, 9] Operation: 62-53=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-9=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 65:[83, 62, 53]. Operations so far : ['98-45=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+62=145. \nResulting numbers: [53, 145].\nHeuristic score : (|53-65| + |145-65|)/2 = (12 + 80)/2 = 46.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 65:[53, 145] Operation: 83+62=145\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 145-53=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 65:[83, 62, 53]. Operations so far : ['98-45=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62*53=3286. \nResulting numbers: [83, 3286].\nHeuristic score : (|83-65| + |3286-65|)/2 = (18 + 3221)/2 = 1619.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 65:[83, 3286] Operation: 62*53=3286\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3286-83=3203. \nResulting numbers: [3203].\n3203,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 65:[83, 62, 53]. Operations so far : ['98-45=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*53=4399. \nResulting numbers: [62, 4399].\nHeuristic score : (|62-65| + |4399-65|)/2 = (3 + 4334)/2 = 2168.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 65:[62, 4399] Operation: 83*53=4399\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4399-62=4337. \nResulting numbers: [4337].\n4337,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 65:[83, 62, 53]. Operations so far : ['98-45=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*62=5146. \nResulting numbers: [53, 5146].\nHeuristic score : (|53-65| + |5146-65|)/2 = (12 + 5081)/2 = 2546.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 65:[53, 5146] Operation: 83*62=5146\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5146-53=5093. \nResulting numbers: [5093].\n5093,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 18.5\nCurrent State #0: 65:[98, 83, 62, 45]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-45=38. \nResulting numbers: [98, 62, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|98-65| + |62-65| + |38-65|)/3 = (33 + 3 + 27)/3 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 65:[98, 62, 38] Operation: 83-45=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-38=60. \nResulting numbers: [62, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|62-65| + |60-65|)/2 = (3 + 5)/2 = 4.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 65:[62, 60] Operation: 98-38=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+60=122. \nResulting numbers: [122].\n122,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 65:[98, 62, 38]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-62=36. \nResulting numbers: [38, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|38-65| + |36-65|)/2 = (27 + 29)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 65:[38, 36] Operation: 98-62=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+36=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 65:[98, 62, 38]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+38=100. \nResulting numbers: [98, 100].\nHeuristic score : (|98-65| + |100-65|)/2 = (33 + 35)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 65:[98, 100] Operation: 62+38=100\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-98=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 65:[98, 62, 38]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+38=136. \nResulting numbers: [62, 136].\nHeuristic score : (|62-65| + |136-65|)/2 = (3 + 71)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 65:[62, 136] Operation: 98+38=136\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 136-62=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 65:[98, 62, 38]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-38=24. \nResulting numbers: [98, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|98-65| + |24-65|)/2 = (33 + 41)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 65:[98, 24] Operation: 62-38=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-24=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 65:[98, 62, 38]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+62=160. \nResulting numbers: [38, 160].\nHeuristic score : (|38-65| + |160-65|)/2 = (27 + 95)/2 = 61.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 65:[38, 160] Operation: 98+62=160\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 160-38=122. \nResulting numbers: [122].\n122,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 65:[98, 62, 38]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62*38=2356. \nResulting numbers: [98, 2356].\nHeuristic score : (|98-65| + |2356-65|)/2 = (33 + 2291)/2 = 1162.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 65:[98, 2356] Operation: 62*38=2356\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2356-98=2258. \nResulting numbers: [2258].\n2258,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 65:[98, 62, 38]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98*38=3724. \nResulting numbers: [62, 3724].\nHeuristic score : (|62-65| + |3724-65|)/2 = (3 + 3659)/2 = 1831.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 65:[62, 3724] Operation: 98*38=3724\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3724-62=3662. \nResulting numbers: [3662].\n3662,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 65:[98, 62, 38]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98*62=6076. \nResulting numbers: [38, 6076].\nHeuristic score : (|38-65| + |6076-65|)/2 = (27 + 6011)/2 = 3019.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 65:[38, 6076] Operation: 98*62=6076\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6076-38=6038. \nResulting numbers: [6038].\n6038,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 18.5\nCurrent State #0: 65:[98, 83, 62, 45]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-62=36. \nResulting numbers: [83, 45, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|83-65| + |45-65| + |36-65|)/3 = (18 + 20 + 29)/3 = 22.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 65:[83, 45, 36] Operation: 98-62=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+36=81. \nResulting numbers: [83, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|83-65| + |81-65|)/2 = (18 + 16)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 65:[83, 81] Operation: 45+36=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-81=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 65:[83, 45, 36]. Operations so far : ['98-62=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-36=47. \nResulting numbers: [45, 47].\nHeuristic score : (|45-65| + |47-65|)/2 = (20 + 18)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 65:[45, 47] Operation: 83-36=47\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+47=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 65:[83, 45, 36]. Operations so far : ['98-62=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-45=38. \nResulting numbers: [36, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|36-65| + |38-65|)/2 = (29 + 27)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 65:[36, 38] Operation: 83-45=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+38=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 65:[83, 45, 36]. Operations so far : ['98-62=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+36=119. \nResulting numbers: [45, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|45-65| + |119-65|)/2 = (20 + 54)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 65:[45, 119] Operation: 83+36=119\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 119-45=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 65:[83, 45, 36]. Operations so far : ['98-62=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-36=9. \nResulting numbers: [83, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|83-65| + |9-65|)/2 = (18 + 56)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 65:[83, 9] Operation: 45-36=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-9=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 65:[83, 45, 36]. Operations so far : ['98-62=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+45=128. \nResulting numbers: [36, 128].\nHeuristic score : (|36-65| + |128-65|)/2 = (29 + 63)/2 = 46.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 65:[36, 128] Operation: 83+45=128\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 128-36=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 65:[83, 45, 36]. Operations so far : ['98-62=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45*36=1620. \nResulting numbers: [83, 1620].\nHeuristic score : (|83-65| + |1620-65|)/2 = (18 + 1555)/2 = 786.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 65:[83, 1620] Operation: 45*36=1620\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1620-83=1537. \nResulting numbers: [1537].\n1537,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 65:[83, 45, 36]. Operations so far : ['98-62=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*36=2988. \nResulting numbers: [45, 2988].\nHeuristic score : (|45-65| + |2988-65|)/2 = (20 + 2923)/2 = 1471.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 65:[45, 2988] Operation: 83*36=2988\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2988-45=2943. \nResulting numbers: [2943].\n2943,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 65:[83, 45, 36]. Operations so far : ['98-62=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*45=3735. \nResulting numbers: [36, 3735].\nHeuristic score : (|36-65| + |3735-65|)/2 = (29 + 3670)/2 = 1849.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 65:[36, 3735] Operation: 83*45=3735\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3735-36=3699. \nResulting numbers: [3699].\n3699,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 18.5\nCurrent State #0: 65:[98, 83, 62, 45]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-83=15. \nResulting numbers: [62, 45, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|62-65| + |45-65| + |15-65|)/3 = (3 + 20 + 50)/3 = 24.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 65:[62, 45, 15] Operation: 98-83=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+15=60. \nResulting numbers: [62, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|62-65| + |60-65|)/2 = (3 + 5)/2 = 4.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 65:[62, 60] Operation: 45+15=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+60=122. \nResulting numbers: [122].\n122,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 24.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 65:[62, 45, 15]. Operations so far : ['98-83=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+15=77. \nResulting numbers: [45, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|45-65| + |77-65|)/2 = (20 + 12)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 65:[45, 77] Operation: 62+15=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-45=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 24.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 65:[62, 45, 15]. Operations so far : ['98-83=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-15=47. \nResulting numbers: [45, 47].\nHeuristic score : (|45-65| + |47-65|)/2 = (20 + 18)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 65:[45, 47] Operation: 62-15=47\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+47=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 24.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 65:[62, 45, 15]. Operations so far : ['98-83=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-15=30. \nResulting numbers: [62, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|62-65| + |30-65|)/2 = (3 + 35)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 65:[62, 30] Operation: 45-15=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+30=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,65 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 24.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 65:[62, 45, 15]. Operations so far : ['98-83=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45/15=3. \nResulting numbers: [62, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|62-65| + |3-65|)/2 = (3 + 62)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 65:[62, 3] Operation: 45/15=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+3=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,65 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['98-83=15', '45/15=3', '62+3=65']\nRESULT: 65\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,616 |
[
14,
52,
47,
22
]
| 40 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [14, 52, 47, 22] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 40. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [14, 52, 47, 22]. Our goal is to produce 40. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 40:[14, 52, 47, 22]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+22=36. \nResulting numbers: [52, 47, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |47-40| + |36-40|)/3 = (12 + 7 + 4)/3 = 7.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 40:[52, 47, 36] Operation: 14+22=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-36=16. \nResulting numbers: [47, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |16-40|)/2 = (7 + 24)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 40:[47, 16] Operation: 52-36=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-16=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,0: 40:[52, 47, 36]. Operations so far : ['14+22=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-47=5. \nResulting numbers: [36, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|36-40| + |5-40|)/2 = (4 + 35)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 40:[36, 5] Operation: 52-47=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+5=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,0: 40:[52, 47, 36]. Operations so far : ['14+22=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-36=11. \nResulting numbers: [52, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |11-40|)/2 = (12 + 29)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 40:[52, 11] Operation: 47-36=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-11=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,0: 40:[52, 47, 36]. Operations so far : ['14+22=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+36=88. \nResulting numbers: [47, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |88-40|)/2 = (7 + 48)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 40:[47, 88] Operation: 52+36=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-47=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,0: 40:[52, 47, 36]. Operations so far : ['14+22=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+36=83. \nResulting numbers: [52, 83].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |83-40|)/2 = (12 + 43)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 40:[52, 83] Operation: 47+36=83\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-52=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,0: 40:[52, 47, 36]. Operations so far : ['14+22=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+47=99. \nResulting numbers: [36, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|36-40| + |99-40|)/2 = (4 + 59)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 40:[36, 99] Operation: 52+47=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-36=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,0: 40:[52, 47, 36]. Operations so far : ['14+22=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*36=1692. \nResulting numbers: [52, 1692].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |1692-40|)/2 = (12 + 1652)/2 = 832.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 40:[52, 1692] Operation: 47*36=1692\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1692-52=1640. \nResulting numbers: [1640].\n1640,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,0: 40:[52, 47, 36]. Operations so far : ['14+22=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*36=1872. \nResulting numbers: [47, 1872].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |1872-40|)/2 = (7 + 1832)/2 = 919.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 40:[47, 1872] Operation: 52*36=1872\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1872-47=1825. \nResulting numbers: [1825].\n1825,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,0: 40:[52, 47, 36]. Operations so far : ['14+22=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*47=2444. \nResulting numbers: [36, 2444].\nHeuristic score : (|36-40| + |2444-40|)/2 = (4 + 2404)/2 = 1204.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 40:[36, 2444] Operation: 52*47=2444\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2444-36=2408. \nResulting numbers: [2408].\n2408,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 15.75\nCurrent State #0: 40:[14, 52, 47, 22]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-14=38. \nResulting numbers: [47, 22, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |22-40| + |38-40|)/3 = (7 + 18 + 2)/3 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 40:[47, 22, 38] Operation: 52-14=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-22=25. \nResulting numbers: [38, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|38-40| + |25-40|)/2 = (2 + 15)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 40:[38, 25] Operation: 47-22=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+25=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 40:[47, 22, 38]. Operations so far : ['52-14=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+38=60. \nResulting numbers: [47, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |60-40|)/2 = (7 + 20)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 40:[47, 60] Operation: 22+38=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-47=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 40:[47, 22, 38]. Operations so far : ['52-14=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+22=69. \nResulting numbers: [38, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|38-40| + |69-40|)/2 = (2 + 29)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 40:[38, 69] Operation: 47+22=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-38=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 40:[47, 22, 38]. Operations so far : ['52-14=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-22=16. \nResulting numbers: [47, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |16-40|)/2 = (7 + 24)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 40:[47, 16] Operation: 38-22=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-16=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 40:[47, 22, 38]. Operations so far : ['52-14=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-38=9. \nResulting numbers: [22, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|22-40| + |9-40|)/2 = (18 + 31)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 40:[22, 9] Operation: 47-38=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+9=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 40:[47, 22, 38]. Operations so far : ['52-14=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+38=85. \nResulting numbers: [22, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|22-40| + |85-40|)/2 = (18 + 45)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 40:[22, 85] Operation: 47+38=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-22=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 40:[47, 22, 38]. Operations so far : ['52-14=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22*38=836. \nResulting numbers: [47, 836].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |836-40|)/2 = (7 + 796)/2 = 401.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 40:[47, 836] Operation: 22*38=836\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 836-47=789. \nResulting numbers: [789].\n789,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 40:[47, 22, 38]. Operations so far : ['52-14=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*22=1034. \nResulting numbers: [38, 1034].\nHeuristic score : (|38-40| + |1034-40|)/2 = (2 + 994)/2 = 498.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 40:[38, 1034] Operation: 47*22=1034\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1034-38=996. \nResulting numbers: [996].\n996,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 40:[47, 22, 38]. Operations so far : ['52-14=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*38=1786. \nResulting numbers: [22, 1786].\nHeuristic score : (|22-40| + |1786-40|)/2 = (18 + 1746)/2 = 882.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 40:[22, 1786] Operation: 47*38=1786\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1786-22=1764. \nResulting numbers: [1764].\n1764,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 15.75\nCurrent State #0: 40:[14, 52, 47, 22]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-14=33. \nResulting numbers: [52, 22, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |22-40| + |33-40|)/3 = (12 + 18 + 7)/3 = 12.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 40:[52, 22, 33] Operation: 47-14=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-22=30. \nResulting numbers: [33, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|33-40| + |30-40|)/2 = (7 + 10)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 40:[33, 30] Operation: 52-22=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+30=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 40:[52, 22, 33]. Operations so far : ['47-14=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+33=55. \nResulting numbers: [52, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |55-40|)/2 = (12 + 15)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 40:[52, 55] Operation: 22+33=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-52=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 40:[52, 22, 33]. Operations so far : ['47-14=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-33=19. \nResulting numbers: [22, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|22-40| + |19-40|)/2 = (18 + 21)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 40:[22, 19] Operation: 52-33=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+19=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 40:[52, 22, 33]. Operations so far : ['47-14=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+22=74. \nResulting numbers: [33, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|33-40| + |74-40|)/2 = (7 + 34)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 40:[33, 74] Operation: 52+22=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-33=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 40:[52, 22, 33]. Operations so far : ['47-14=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-22=11. \nResulting numbers: [52, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |11-40|)/2 = (12 + 29)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 40:[52, 11] Operation: 33-22=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-11=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 40:[52, 22, 33]. Operations so far : ['47-14=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+33=85. \nResulting numbers: [22, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|22-40| + |85-40|)/2 = (18 + 45)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 40:[22, 85] Operation: 52+33=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-22=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 40:[52, 22, 33]. Operations so far : ['47-14=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22*33=726. \nResulting numbers: [52, 726].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |726-40|)/2 = (12 + 686)/2 = 349.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 40:[52, 726] Operation: 22*33=726\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 726-52=674. \nResulting numbers: [674].\n674,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 40:[52, 22, 33]. Operations so far : ['47-14=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*22=1144. \nResulting numbers: [33, 1144].\nHeuristic score : (|33-40| + |1144-40|)/2 = (7 + 1104)/2 = 555.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 40:[33, 1144] Operation: 52*22=1144\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1144-33=1111. \nResulting numbers: [1111].\n1111,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 40:[52, 22, 33]. Operations so far : ['47-14=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*33=1716. \nResulting numbers: [22, 1716].\nHeuristic score : (|22-40| + |1716-40|)/2 = (18 + 1676)/2 = 847.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 40:[22, 1716] Operation: 52*33=1716\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1716/22=78. \nResulting numbers: [78].\n78,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 15.75\nCurrent State #0: 40:[14, 52, 47, 22]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-22=30. \nResulting numbers: [14, 47, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|14-40| + |47-40| + |30-40|)/3 = (26 + 7 + 10)/3 = 14.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 40:[14, 47, 30] Operation: 52-22=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+30=44. \nResulting numbers: [47, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |44-40|)/2 = (7 + 4)/2 = 5.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 40:[47, 44] Operation: 14+30=44\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-44=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,3: 40:[14, 47, 30]. Operations so far : ['52-22=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-14=33. \nResulting numbers: [30, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|30-40| + |33-40|)/2 = (10 + 7)/2 = 8.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 40:[30, 33] Operation: 47-14=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+33=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,3: 40:[14, 47, 30]. Operations so far : ['52-22=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+47=61. \nResulting numbers: [30, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|30-40| + |61-40|)/2 = (10 + 21)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 40:[30, 61] Operation: 14+47=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-30=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,3: 40:[14, 47, 30]. Operations so far : ['52-22=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-14=16. \nResulting numbers: [47, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |16-40|)/2 = (7 + 24)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 40:[47, 16] Operation: 30-14=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-16=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,3: 40:[14, 47, 30]. Operations so far : ['52-22=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-30=17. \nResulting numbers: [14, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|14-40| + |17-40|)/2 = (26 + 23)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 40:[14, 17] Operation: 47-30=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+17=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,3: 40:[14, 47, 30]. Operations so far : ['52-22=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+30=77. \nResulting numbers: [14, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|14-40| + |77-40|)/2 = (26 + 37)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 40:[14, 77] Operation: 47+30=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-14=63. \nResulting numbers: [63].\n63,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,3: 40:[14, 47, 30]. Operations so far : ['52-22=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14*30=420. \nResulting numbers: [47, 420].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |420-40|)/2 = (7 + 380)/2 = 193.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 40:[47, 420] Operation: 14*30=420\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 420-47=373. \nResulting numbers: [373].\n373,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,3: 40:[14, 47, 30]. Operations so far : ['52-22=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14*47=658. \nResulting numbers: [30, 658].\nHeuristic score : (|30-40| + |658-40|)/2 = (10 + 618)/2 = 314.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 40:[30, 658] Operation: 14*47=658\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 658-30=628. \nResulting numbers: [628].\n628,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,3: 40:[14, 47, 30]. Operations so far : ['52-22=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*30=1410. \nResulting numbers: [14, 1410].\nHeuristic score : (|14-40| + |1410-40|)/2 = (26 + 1370)/2 = 698.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 40:[14, 1410] Operation: 47*30=1410\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1410-14=1396. \nResulting numbers: [1396].\n1396,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 15.75\nCurrent State #0: 40:[14, 52, 47, 22]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+52=66. \nResulting numbers: [47, 22, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |22-40| + |66-40|)/3 = (7 + 18 + 26)/3 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 40:[47, 22, 66] Operation: 14+52=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-22=44. \nResulting numbers: [47, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |44-40|)/2 = (7 + 4)/2 = 5.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 40:[47, 44] Operation: 66-22=44\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-44=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 40:[47, 22, 66]. Operations so far : ['14+52=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-47=19. \nResulting numbers: [22, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|22-40| + |19-40|)/2 = (18 + 21)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 40:[22, 19] Operation: 66-47=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+19=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 40:[47, 22, 66]. Operations so far : ['14+52=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-22=25. \nResulting numbers: [66, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|66-40| + |25-40|)/2 = (26 + 15)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 40:[66, 25] Operation: 47-22=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-25=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 40:[47, 22, 66]. Operations so far : ['14+52=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66/22=3. \nResulting numbers: [47, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |3-40|)/2 = (7 + 37)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 40:[47, 3] Operation: 66/22=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-3=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 40:[47, 22, 66]. Operations so far : ['14+52=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+22=69. \nResulting numbers: [66, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|66-40| + |69-40|)/2 = (26 + 29)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 40:[66, 69] Operation: 47+22=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-66=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 40:[47, 22, 66]. Operations so far : ['14+52=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+66=88. \nResulting numbers: [47, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |88-40|)/2 = (7 + 48)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 40:[47, 88] Operation: 22+66=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-47=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 40:[47, 22, 66]. Operations so far : ['14+52=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+66=113. \nResulting numbers: [22, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|22-40| + |113-40|)/2 = (18 + 73)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 40:[22, 113] Operation: 47+66=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-22=91. \nResulting numbers: [91].\n91,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 40:[47, 22, 66]. Operations so far : ['14+52=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*22=1034. \nResulting numbers: [66, 1034].\nHeuristic score : (|66-40| + |1034-40|)/2 = (26 + 994)/2 = 510.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 40:[66, 1034] Operation: 47*22=1034\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1034-66=968. \nResulting numbers: [968].\n968,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 40:[47, 22, 66]. Operations so far : ['14+52=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22*66=1452. \nResulting numbers: [47, 1452].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |1452-40|)/2 = (7 + 1412)/2 = 709.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 40:[47, 1452] Operation: 22*66=1452\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1452-47=1405. \nResulting numbers: [1405].\n1405,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 40:[47, 22, 66]. Operations so far : ['14+52=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*66=3102. \nResulting numbers: [22, 3102].\nHeuristic score : (|22-40| + |3102-40|)/2 = (18 + 3062)/2 = 1540.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,9: 40:[22, 3102] Operation: 47*66=3102\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3102/22=141. \nResulting numbers: [141].\n141,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 15.75\nCurrent State #0: 40:[14, 52, 47, 22]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+47=61. \nResulting numbers: [52, 22, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |22-40| + |61-40|)/3 = (12 + 18 + 21)/3 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,5: 40:[52, 22, 61] Operation: 14+47=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-22=39. \nResulting numbers: [52, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |39-40|)/2 = (12 + 1)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 40:[52, 39] Operation: 61-22=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-39=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 40:[52, 22, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-22=30. \nResulting numbers: [61, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|61-40| + |30-40|)/2 = (21 + 10)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 40:[61, 30] Operation: 52-22=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-30=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 40:[52, 22, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-52=9. \nResulting numbers: [22, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|22-40| + |9-40|)/2 = (18 + 31)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 40:[22, 9] Operation: 61-52=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+9=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 40:[52, 22, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+22=74. \nResulting numbers: [61, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|61-40| + |74-40|)/2 = (21 + 34)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,3: 40:[61, 74] Operation: 52+22=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-61=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 40:[52, 22, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+61=83. \nResulting numbers: [52, 83].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |83-40|)/2 = (12 + 43)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,4: 40:[52, 83] Operation: 22+61=83\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-52=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 40:[52, 22, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+61=113. \nResulting numbers: [22, 113].\nHeuristic score : (|22-40| + |113-40|)/2 = (18 + 73)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,5: 40:[22, 113] Operation: 52+61=113\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 113-22=91. \nResulting numbers: [91].\n91,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 40:[52, 22, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*22=1144. \nResulting numbers: [61, 1144].\nHeuristic score : (|61-40| + |1144-40|)/2 = (21 + 1104)/2 = 562.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,6: 40:[61, 1144] Operation: 52*22=1144\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1144-61=1083. \nResulting numbers: [1083].\n1083,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 40:[52, 22, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22*61=1342. \nResulting numbers: [52, 1342].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |1342-40|)/2 = (12 + 1302)/2 = 657.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,7: 40:[52, 1342] Operation: 22*61=1342\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1342-52=1290. \nResulting numbers: [1290].\n1290,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,5: 40:[52, 22, 61]. Operations so far : ['14+47=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52*61=3172. \nResulting numbers: [22, 3172].\nHeuristic score : (|22-40| + |3172-40|)/2 = (18 + 3132)/2 = 1575.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,8: 40:[22, 3172] Operation: 52*61=3172\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3172-22=3150. \nResulting numbers: [3150].\n3150,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 15.75\nCurrent State #0: 40:[14, 52, 47, 22]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22-14=8. \nResulting numbers: [52, 47, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |47-40| + |8-40|)/3 = (12 + 7 + 32)/3 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,6: 40:[52, 47, 8] Operation: 22-14=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-8=44. \nResulting numbers: [47, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |44-40|)/2 = (7 + 4)/2 = 5.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,0: 40:[47, 44] Operation: 52-8=44\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-44=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,6: 40:[52, 47, 8]. Operations so far : ['22-14=8'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-8=39. \nResulting numbers: [52, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |39-40|)/2 = (12 + 1)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,1: 40:[52, 39] Operation: 47-8=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-39=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,6: 40:[52, 47, 8]. Operations so far : ['22-14=8'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+8=60. \nResulting numbers: [47, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|47-40| + |60-40|)/2 = (7 + 20)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,2: 40:[47, 60] Operation: 52+8=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-47=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,6: 40:[52, 47, 8]. Operations so far : ['22-14=8'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+8=55. \nResulting numbers: [52, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|52-40| + |55-40|)/2 = (12 + 15)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,3: 40:[52, 55] Operation: 47+8=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-52=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,40 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,6: 40:[52, 47, 8]. Operations so far : ['22-14=8'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-47=5. \nResulting numbers: [8, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|8-40| + |5-40|)/2 = (32 + 35)/2 = 33.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,4: 40:[8, 5] Operation: 52-47=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*5=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,40 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['22-14=8', '52-47=5', '8*5=40']\nRESULT: 40\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 14,086 |
[
80,
73,
37,
95
]
| 95 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [80, 73, 37, 95] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 95. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [80, 73, 37, 95]. Our goal is to produce 95. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 95:[80, 73, 37, 95]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+37=110. \nResulting numbers: [80, 95, 110].\nHeuristic score : (|80-95| + |95-95| + |110-95|)/3 = (15 + 0 + 15)/3 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 95:[80, 95, 110] Operation: 73+37=110\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 110-80=30. \nResulting numbers: [95, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|95-95| + |30-95|)/2 = (0 + 65)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 95:[95, 30] Operation: 110-80=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95+30=125. \nResulting numbers: [125].\n125,95 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 95:[80, 95, 110]. Operations so far : ['73+37=110'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+95=175. \nResulting numbers: [110, 175].\nHeuristic score : (|110-95| + |175-95|)/2 = (15 + 80)/2 = 47.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 95:[110, 175] Operation: 80+95=175\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 175-110=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,95 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 95:[80, 95, 110]. Operations so far : ['73+37=110'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-80=15. \nResulting numbers: [110, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|110-95| + |15-95|)/2 = (15 + 80)/2 = 47.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 95:[110, 15] Operation: 95-80=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 110-15=95. \nResulting numbers: [95].\n95,95 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['73+37=110', '95-80=15', '110-15=95']\nRESULT: 95\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 862 |
[
62,
71,
28,
16
]
| 21 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [62, 71, 28, 16] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 21. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [62, 71, 28, 16]. Our goal is to produce 21. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 21:[62, 71, 28, 16]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-16=55. \nResulting numbers: [62, 28, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|62-21| + |28-21| + |55-21|)/3 = (41 + 7 + 34)/3 = 27.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 21:[62, 28, 55] Operation: 71-16=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-16=46. \nResulting numbers: [71, 28, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|71-21| + |28-21| + |46-21|)/3 = (50 + 7 + 25)/3 = 27.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 21:[71, 28, 46] Operation: 62-16=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-62=9. \nResulting numbers: [28, 16, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|28-21| + |16-21| + |9-21|)/3 = (7 + 5 + 12)/3 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 21:[28, 16, 9] Operation: 71-62=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-28=34. \nResulting numbers: [71, 16, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|71-21| + |16-21| + |34-21|)/3 = (50 + 5 + 13)/3 = 22.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 21:[71, 16, 34] Operation: 62-28=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-28=43. \nResulting numbers: [62, 16, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|62-21| + |16-21| + |43-21|)/3 = (41 + 5 + 22)/3 = 22.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 21:[62, 16, 43] Operation: 71-28=43\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 8.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 21:[28, 16, 9]. Operations so far : ['71-62=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16-9=7. \nResulting numbers: [28, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|28-21| + |7-21|)/2 = (7 + 14)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 21:[28, 7] Operation: 16-9=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-9=19. \nResulting numbers: [16, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|16-21| + |19-21|)/2 = (5 + 2)/2 = 3.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 21:[16, 19] Operation: 28-9=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+9=37. \nResulting numbers: [16, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|16-21| + |37-21|)/2 = (5 + 16)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 21:[16, 37] Operation: 28+9=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16+9=25. \nResulting numbers: [28, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|28-21| + |25-21|)/2 = (7 + 4)/2 = 5.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 21:[28, 25] Operation: 16+9=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-16=12. \nResulting numbers: [9, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|9-21| + |12-21|)/2 = (12 + 9)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 21:[9, 12] Operation: 28-16=12\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 22.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 21:[62, 16, 43]. Operations so far : ['71-28=43'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-16=27. \nResulting numbers: [62, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|62-21| + |27-21|)/2 = (41 + 6)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 21:[62, 27] Operation: 43-16=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16+43=59. \nResulting numbers: [62, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|62-21| + |59-21|)/2 = (41 + 38)/2 = 39.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 21:[62, 59] Operation: 16+43=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-16=46. \nResulting numbers: [43, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|43-21| + |46-21|)/2 = (22 + 25)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 21:[43, 46] Operation: 62-16=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-43=19. \nResulting numbers: [16, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|16-21| + |19-21|)/2 = (5 + 2)/2 = 3.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 21:[16, 19] Operation: 62-43=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+16=78. \nResulting numbers: [43, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|43-21| + |78-21|)/2 = (22 + 57)/2 = 39.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 21:[43, 78] Operation: 62+16=78\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 22.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 21:[71, 16, 34]. Operations so far : ['62-28=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-34=37. \nResulting numbers: [16, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|16-21| + |37-21|)/2 = (5 + 16)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 21:[16, 37] Operation: 71-34=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16+34=50. \nResulting numbers: [71, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|71-21| + |50-21|)/2 = (50 + 29)/2 = 39.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 21:[71, 50] Operation: 16+34=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-16=18. \nResulting numbers: [71, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|71-21| + |18-21|)/2 = (50 + 3)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 21:[71, 18] Operation: 34-16=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+16=87. \nResulting numbers: [34, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|34-21| + |87-21|)/2 = (13 + 66)/2 = 39.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 21:[34, 87] Operation: 71+16=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-16=55. \nResulting numbers: [34, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|34-21| + |55-21|)/2 = (13 + 34)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 21:[34, 55] Operation: 71-16=55\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 21:[62, 28, 55]. Operations so far : ['71-16=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-55=7. \nResulting numbers: [28, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|28-21| + |7-21|)/2 = (7 + 14)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 21:[28, 7] Operation: 62-55=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-28=34. \nResulting numbers: [55, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|55-21| + |34-21|)/2 = (34 + 13)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 21:[55, 34] Operation: 62-28=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+55=117. \nResulting numbers: [28, 117].\nHeuristic score : (|28-21| + |117-21|)/2 = (7 + 96)/2 = 51.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 21:[28, 117] Operation: 62+55=117\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+28=90. \nResulting numbers: [55, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|55-21| + |90-21|)/2 = (34 + 69)/2 = 51.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 21:[55, 90] Operation: 62+28=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-28=27. \nResulting numbers: [62, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|62-21| + |27-21|)/2 = (41 + 6)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 21:[62, 27] Operation: 55-28=27\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 21:[71, 28, 46]. Operations so far : ['62-16=46'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+28=99. \nResulting numbers: [46, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|46-21| + |99-21|)/2 = (25 + 78)/2 = 51.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 21:[46, 99] Operation: 71+28=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+46=117. \nResulting numbers: [28, 117].\nHeuristic score : (|28-21| + |117-21|)/2 = (7 + 96)/2 = 51.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 21:[28, 117] Operation: 71+46=117\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46-28=18. \nResulting numbers: [71, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|71-21| + |18-21|)/2 = (50 + 3)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 21:[71, 18] Operation: 46-28=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-28=43. \nResulting numbers: [46, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|46-21| + |43-21|)/2 = (25 + 22)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 21:[46, 43] Operation: 71-28=43\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-46=25. \nResulting numbers: [28, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|28-21| + |25-21|)/2 = (7 + 4)/2 = 5.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 21:[28, 25] Operation: 71-46=25\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 3.5\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 21:[16, 19]. Operations so far : ['71-62=9', '28-9=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16+19=35. \nResulting numbers: [35].\n35,21 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16*19=304. \nResulting numbers: [304].\n304,21 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 19-16=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,21 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 3.5\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 21:[16, 19]. Operations so far : ['71-28=43', '62-43=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16+19=35. \nResulting numbers: [35].\n35,21 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16*19=304. \nResulting numbers: [304].\n304,21 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 19-16=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,21 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 5.5\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 21:[28, 25]. Operations so far : ['71-62=9', '16+9=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-25=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,21 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28*25=700. \nResulting numbers: [700].\n700,21 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+25=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,21 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 5.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 21:[28, 25]. Operations so far : ['62-16=46', '71-46=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+25=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,21 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28*25=700. \nResulting numbers: [700].\n700,21 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-25=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,21 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 21:[28, 7]. Operations so far : ['71-62=9', '16-9=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28/7=4. \nResulting numbers: [4].\n4,21 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+7=35. \nResulting numbers: [35].\n35,21 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-7=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,21 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['71-62=9', '16-9=7', '28/7=4']\nRESULT: 4\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 4,793 |
[
75,
48,
74,
46
]
| 94 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [75, 48, 74, 46] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 94. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [75, 48, 74, 46]. Our goal is to produce 94. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 94:[75, 48, 74, 46]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+46=94. \nResulting numbers: [75, 74, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|75-94| + |74-94| + |94-94|)/3 = (19 + 20 + 0)/3 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 94:[75, 74, 94] Operation: 48+46=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+48=123. \nResulting numbers: [74, 46, 123].\nHeuristic score : (|74-94| + |46-94| + |123-94|)/3 = (20 + 48 + 29)/3 = 32.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 94:[74, 46, 123] Operation: 75+48=123\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+46=120. \nResulting numbers: [75, 48, 120].\nHeuristic score : (|75-94| + |48-94| + |120-94|)/3 = (19 + 46 + 26)/3 = 30.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 94:[75, 48, 120] Operation: 74+46=120\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+74=122. \nResulting numbers: [75, 46, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|75-94| + |46-94| + |122-94|)/3 = (19 + 48 + 28)/3 = 31.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 94:[75, 46, 122] Operation: 48+74=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+46=121. \nResulting numbers: [48, 74, 121].\nHeuristic score : (|48-94| + |74-94| + |121-94|)/3 = (46 + 20 + 27)/3 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 94:[48, 74, 121] Operation: 75+46=121\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 94:[75, 74, 94]. Operations so far : ['48+46=94'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-74=1. \nResulting numbers: [94, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|94-94| + |1-94|)/2 = (0 + 93)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 94:[94, 1] Operation: 75-74=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+94=169. \nResulting numbers: [74, 169].\nHeuristic score : (|74-94| + |169-94|)/2 = (20 + 75)/2 = 47.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 94:[74, 169] Operation: 75+94=169\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-74=20. \nResulting numbers: [75, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|75-94| + |20-94|)/2 = (19 + 74)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 94:[75, 20] Operation: 94-74=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+94=168. \nResulting numbers: [75, 168].\nHeuristic score : (|75-94| + |168-94|)/2 = (19 + 74)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 94:[75, 168] Operation: 74+94=168\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+74=149. \nResulting numbers: [94, 149].\nHeuristic score : (|94-94| + |149-94|)/2 = (0 + 55)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 94:[94, 149] Operation: 75+74=149\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 94:[75, 48, 120]. Operations so far : ['74+46=120'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+48=123. \nResulting numbers: [120, 123].\nHeuristic score : (|120-94| + |123-94|)/2 = (26 + 29)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 94:[120, 123] Operation: 75+48=123\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 120-75=45. \nResulting numbers: [48, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|48-94| + |45-94|)/2 = (46 + 49)/2 = 47.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 94:[48, 45] Operation: 120-75=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-48=27. \nResulting numbers: [120, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|120-94| + |27-94|)/2 = (26 + 67)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 94:[120, 27] Operation: 75-48=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+120=168. \nResulting numbers: [75, 168].\nHeuristic score : (|75-94| + |168-94|)/2 = (19 + 74)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 94:[75, 168] Operation: 48+120=168\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 120-48=72. \nResulting numbers: [75, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|75-94| + |72-94|)/2 = (19 + 22)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 94:[75, 72] Operation: 120-48=72\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 94:[48, 74, 121]. Operations so far : ['75+46=121'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 121-74=47. \nResulting numbers: [48, 47].\nHeuristic score : (|48-94| + |47-94|)/2 = (46 + 47)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 94:[48, 47] Operation: 121-74=47\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+74=122. \nResulting numbers: [121, 122].\nHeuristic score : (|121-94| + |122-94|)/2 = (27 + 28)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 94:[121, 122] Operation: 48+74=122\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 121-48=73. \nResulting numbers: [74, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|74-94| + |73-94|)/2 = (20 + 21)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 94:[74, 73] Operation: 121-48=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+121=169. \nResulting numbers: [74, 169].\nHeuristic score : (|74-94| + |169-94|)/2 = (20 + 75)/2 = 47.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 94:[74, 169] Operation: 48+121=169\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-48=26. \nResulting numbers: [121, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|121-94| + |26-94|)/2 = (27 + 68)/2 = 47.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 94:[121, 26] Operation: 74-48=26\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 94:[75, 46, 122]. Operations so far : ['48+74=122'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+122=168. \nResulting numbers: [75, 168].\nHeuristic score : (|75-94| + |168-94|)/2 = (19 + 74)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 94:[75, 168] Operation: 46+122=168\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-75=47. \nResulting numbers: [46, 47].\nHeuristic score : (|46-94| + |47-94|)/2 = (48 + 47)/2 = 47.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 94:[46, 47] Operation: 122-75=47\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+46=121. \nResulting numbers: [122, 121].\nHeuristic score : (|122-94| + |121-94|)/2 = (28 + 27)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 94:[122, 121] Operation: 75+46=121\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-46=29. \nResulting numbers: [122, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|122-94| + |29-94|)/2 = (28 + 65)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 94:[122, 29] Operation: 75-46=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-46=76. \nResulting numbers: [75, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|75-94| + |76-94|)/2 = (19 + 18)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 94:[75, 76] Operation: 122-46=76\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 94:[74, 46, 123]. Operations so far : ['75+48=123'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+123=169. \nResulting numbers: [74, 169].\nHeuristic score : (|74-94| + |169-94|)/2 = (20 + 75)/2 = 47.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 94:[74, 169] Operation: 46+123=169\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 123-46=77. \nResulting numbers: [74, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|74-94| + |77-94|)/2 = (20 + 17)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 94:[74, 77] Operation: 123-46=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 123-74=49. \nResulting numbers: [46, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|46-94| + |49-94|)/2 = (48 + 45)/2 = 46.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 94:[46, 49] Operation: 123-74=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+46=120. \nResulting numbers: [123, 120].\nHeuristic score : (|123-94| + |120-94|)/2 = (29 + 26)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 94:[123, 120] Operation: 74+46=120\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-46=28. \nResulting numbers: [123, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|123-94| + |28-94|)/2 = (29 + 66)/2 = 47.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 94:[123, 28] Operation: 74-46=28\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 18.5\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 94:[75, 76]. Operations so far : ['48+74=122', '122-46=76'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+76=151. \nResulting numbers: [151].\n151,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-75=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*76=5700. \nResulting numbers: [5700].\n5700,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 18.5\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 94:[74, 77]. Operations so far : ['75+48=123', '123-46=77'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74*77=5698. \nResulting numbers: [5698].\n5698,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-74=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+77=151. \nResulting numbers: [151].\n151,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 20.5\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 94:[75, 72]. Operations so far : ['74+46=120', '120-48=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+72=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-72=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*72=5400. \nResulting numbers: [5400].\n5400,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.5\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 94:[74, 73]. Operations so far : ['75+46=121', '121-48=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-73=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74*73=5402. \nResulting numbers: [5402].\n5402,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+73=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 27.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 94:[94, 149]. Operations so far : ['48+46=94', '75+74=149'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94+149=243. \nResulting numbers: [243].\n243,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 149-94=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94*149=14006. \nResulting numbers: [14006].\n14006,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 27.5\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 94:[120, 123]. Operations so far : ['74+46=120', '75+48=123'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 120+123=243. \nResulting numbers: [243].\n243,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 123-120=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 120*123=14760. \nResulting numbers: [14760].\n14760,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 27.5\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 94:[121, 122]. Operations so far : ['75+46=121', '48+74=122'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 121+122=243. \nResulting numbers: [243].\n243,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 121*122=14762. \nResulting numbers: [14762].\n14762,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-121=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.5\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 94:[123, 120]. Operations so far : ['75+48=123', '74+46=120'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 123+120=243. \nResulting numbers: [243].\n243,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 123-120=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 123*120=14760. \nResulting numbers: [14760].\n14760,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.5\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 94:[122, 121]. Operations so far : ['48+74=122', '75+46=121'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122*121=14762. \nResulting numbers: [14762].\n14762,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122+121=243. \nResulting numbers: [243].\n243,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 122-121=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 39\nCurrent State #0,0,4,1: 94:[55]. Operations so far : ['48+46=94', '75+74=149', '149-94=55'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 46.5\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 94:[48, 47]. Operations so far : ['75+46=121', '121-74=47'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-47=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+47=95. \nResulting numbers: [95].\n95,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48*47=2256. \nResulting numbers: [2256].\n2256,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 46.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 94:[75, 20]. Operations so far : ['48+46=94', '94-74=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+20=95. \nResulting numbers: [95].\n95,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-20=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75*20=1500. \nResulting numbers: [1500].\n1500,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 46.5\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 94:[46, 49]. Operations so far : ['75+48=123', '123-74=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-46=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46*49=2254. \nResulting numbers: [2254].\n2254,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+49=95. \nResulting numbers: [95].\n95,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 46.5\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 94:[94, 1]. Operations so far : ['48+46=94', '75-74=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94+1=95. \nResulting numbers: [95].\n95,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94-1=93. \nResulting numbers: [93].\n93,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 94*1=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,94 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['48+46=94', '75-74=1', '94/1=94']\nRESULT: 94\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 6,804 |
[
73,
5,
69,
43
]
| 44 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [73, 5, 69, 43] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 44. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [73, 5, 69, 43]. Our goal is to produce 44. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 44:[73, 5, 69, 43]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-5=68. \nResulting numbers: [69, 43, 68].\nHeuristic score : (|69-44| + |43-44| + |68-44|)/3 = (25 + 1 + 24)/3 = 16.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 44:[69, 43, 68] Operation: 73-5=68\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-43=26. \nResulting numbers: [68, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|68-44| + |26-44|)/2 = (24 + 18)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 44:[68, 26] Operation: 69-43=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-26=42. \nResulting numbers: [42].\n42,44 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 44:[69, 43, 68]. Operations so far : ['73-5=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-68=1. \nResulting numbers: [43, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|43-44| + |1-44|)/2 = (1 + 43)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 44:[43, 1] Operation: 69-68=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43+1=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,44 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['73-5=68', '69-68=1', '43+1=44']\nRESULT: 44\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 649 |
[
37,
2,
89,
23
]
| 95 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [37, 2, 89, 23] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 95. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [37, 2, 89, 23]. Our goal is to produce 95. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 95:[37, 2, 89, 23]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+2=39. \nResulting numbers: [89, 23, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|89-95| + |23-95| + |39-95|)/3 = (6 + 72 + 56)/3 = 44.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 95:[89, 23, 39] Operation: 37+2=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2*23=46. \nResulting numbers: [37, 89, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|37-95| + |89-95| + |46-95|)/3 = (58 + 6 + 49)/3 = 37.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 95:[37, 89, 46] Operation: 2*23=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2+89=91. \nResulting numbers: [37, 23, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|37-95| + |23-95| + |91-95|)/3 = (58 + 72 + 4)/3 = 44.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 95:[37, 23, 91] Operation: 2+89=91\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+23=60. \nResulting numbers: [2, 89, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|2-95| + |89-95| + |60-95|)/3 = (93 + 6 + 35)/3 = 44.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 95:[2, 89, 60] Operation: 37+23=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*2=74. \nResulting numbers: [89, 23, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|89-95| + |23-95| + |74-95|)/3 = (6 + 72 + 21)/3 = 33.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 95:[89, 23, 74] Operation: 37*2=74\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 33.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 95:[89, 23, 74]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+23=112. \nResulting numbers: [74, 112].\nHeuristic score : (|74-95| + |112-95|)/2 = (21 + 17)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 95:[74, 112] Operation: 89+23=112\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-23=66. \nResulting numbers: [74, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|74-95| + |66-95|)/2 = (21 + 29)/2 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 95:[74, 66] Operation: 89-23=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+74=163. \nResulting numbers: [23, 163].\nHeuristic score : (|23-95| + |163-95|)/2 = (72 + 68)/2 = 70.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 95:[23, 163] Operation: 89+74=163\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-23=51. \nResulting numbers: [89, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|89-95| + |51-95|)/2 = (6 + 44)/2 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 95:[89, 51] Operation: 74-23=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+74=97. \nResulting numbers: [89, 97].\nHeuristic score : (|89-95| + |97-95|)/2 = (6 + 2)/2 = 4.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 95:[89, 97] Operation: 23+74=97\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 37.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 95:[37, 89, 46]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-37=52. \nResulting numbers: [46, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|46-95| + |52-95|)/2 = (49 + 43)/2 = 46.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 95:[46, 52] Operation: 89-37=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46-37=9. \nResulting numbers: [89, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|89-95| + |9-95|)/2 = (6 + 86)/2 = 46.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 95:[89, 9] Operation: 46-37=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+89=126. \nResulting numbers: [46, 126].\nHeuristic score : (|46-95| + |126-95|)/2 = (49 + 31)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 95:[46, 126] Operation: 37+89=126\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+46=135. \nResulting numbers: [37, 135].\nHeuristic score : (|37-95| + |135-95|)/2 = (58 + 40)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 95:[37, 135] Operation: 89+46=135\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+46=83. \nResulting numbers: [89, 83].\nHeuristic score : (|89-95| + |83-95|)/2 = (6 + 12)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 95:[89, 83] Operation: 37+46=83\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 44.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,0: 95:[89, 23, 39]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+39=128. \nResulting numbers: [23, 128].\nHeuristic score : (|23-95| + |128-95|)/2 = (72 + 33)/2 = 52.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 95:[23, 128] Operation: 89+39=128\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+39=62. \nResulting numbers: [89, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|89-95| + |62-95|)/2 = (6 + 33)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 95:[89, 62] Operation: 23+39=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+23=112. \nResulting numbers: [39, 112].\nHeuristic score : (|39-95| + |112-95|)/2 = (56 + 17)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 95:[39, 112] Operation: 89+23=112\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-23=66. \nResulting numbers: [39, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|39-95| + |66-95|)/2 = (56 + 29)/2 = 42.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 95:[39, 66] Operation: 89-23=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-23=16. \nResulting numbers: [89, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|89-95| + |16-95|)/2 = (6 + 79)/2 = 42.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 95:[89, 16] Operation: 39-23=16\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 44.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,2: 95:[37, 23, 91]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+23=60. \nResulting numbers: [91, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|91-95| + |60-95|)/2 = (4 + 35)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 95:[91, 60] Operation: 37+23=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-23=68. \nResulting numbers: [37, 68].\nHeuristic score : (|37-95| + |68-95|)/2 = (58 + 27)/2 = 42.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 95:[37, 68] Operation: 91-23=68\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-23=14. \nResulting numbers: [91, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|91-95| + |14-95|)/2 = (4 + 81)/2 = 42.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 95:[91, 14] Operation: 37-23=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+91=128. \nResulting numbers: [23, 128].\nHeuristic score : (|23-95| + |128-95|)/2 = (72 + 33)/2 = 52.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 95:[23, 128] Operation: 37+91=128\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+91=114. \nResulting numbers: [37, 114].\nHeuristic score : (|37-95| + |114-95|)/2 = (58 + 19)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 95:[37, 114] Operation: 23+91=114\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 44.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 95:[2, 89, 60]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2*60=120. \nResulting numbers: [89, 120].\nHeuristic score : (|89-95| + |120-95|)/2 = (6 + 25)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 95:[89, 120] Operation: 2*60=120\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-2=87. \nResulting numbers: [60, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|60-95| + |87-95|)/2 = (35 + 8)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 95:[60, 87] Operation: 89-2=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-2=58. \nResulting numbers: [89, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|89-95| + |58-95|)/2 = (6 + 37)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 95:[89, 58] Operation: 60-2=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2+60=62. \nResulting numbers: [89, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|89-95| + |62-95|)/2 = (6 + 33)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 95:[89, 62] Operation: 2+60=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2+89=91. \nResulting numbers: [60, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|60-95| + |91-95|)/2 = (35 + 4)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 95:[60, 91] Operation: 2+89=91\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 4.0\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 95:[89, 97]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '23+74=97'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 97-89=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+97=186. \nResulting numbers: [186].\n186,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89*97=8633. \nResulting numbers: [8633].\n8633,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 95:[89, 83]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '37+46=83'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89*83=7387. \nResulting numbers: [7387].\n7387,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-83=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+83=172. \nResulting numbers: [172].\n172,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 15.5\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 95:[89, 120]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '2*60=120'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+120=209. \nResulting numbers: [209].\n209,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 120-89=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89*120=10680. \nResulting numbers: [10680].\n10680,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 19.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 95:[74, 112]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '89+23=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74*112=8288. \nResulting numbers: [8288].\n8288,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112-74=38. \nResulting numbers: [38].\n38,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+112=186. \nResulting numbers: [186].\n186,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 19.5\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 95:[89, 62]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '2+60=62'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+62=151. \nResulting numbers: [151].\n151,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89*62=5518. \nResulting numbers: [5518].\n5518,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-62=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 19.5\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 95:[60, 91]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '2+89=91'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-60=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*91=5460. \nResulting numbers: [5460].\n5460,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+91=151. \nResulting numbers: [151].\n151,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 19.5\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 95:[89, 62]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '23+39=62'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89*62=5518. \nResulting numbers: [5518].\n5518,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+62=151. \nResulting numbers: [151].\n151,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-62=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 19.5\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 95:[91, 60]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '37+23=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+60=151. \nResulting numbers: [151].\n151,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-60=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91*60=5460. \nResulting numbers: [5460].\n5460,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 95:[60, 87]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '89-2=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-60=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+87=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*87=5220. \nResulting numbers: [5220].\n5220,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 95:[89, 58]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '60-2=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89*58=5162. \nResulting numbers: [5162].\n5162,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+58=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-58=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 95:[74, 66]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '89-23=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+66=140. \nResulting numbers: [140].\n140,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-66=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74*66=4884. \nResulting numbers: [4884].\n4884,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 95:[89, 51]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '74-23=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89*51=4539. \nResulting numbers: [4539].\n4539,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-51=38. \nResulting numbers: [38].\n38,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+51=140. \nResulting numbers: [140].\n140,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 36.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 95:[39, 112]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '89+23=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39*112=4368. \nResulting numbers: [4368].\n4368,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+112=151. \nResulting numbers: [151].\n151,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112-39=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 38.5\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 95:[37, 114]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '23+91=114'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 114-37=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*114=4218. \nResulting numbers: [4218].\n4218,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+114=151. \nResulting numbers: [151].\n151,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 40.0\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 95:[46, 126]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '37+89=126'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46*126=5796. \nResulting numbers: [5796].\n5796,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+126=172. \nResulting numbers: [172].\n172,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 126-46=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 15\nCurrent State #0,1,2,2: 95:[80]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '37+89=126', '126-46=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,2,4,0: 95:[77]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '23+91=114', '114-37=77'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 22\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 95:[73]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '89+23=112', '112-39=73'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 42.5\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 95:[39, 66]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '89-23=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+66=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39*66=2574. \nResulting numbers: [2574].\n2574,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-39=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 42.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 95:[89, 16]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '39-23=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-16=73. \nResulting numbers: [73].\n73,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89*16=1424. \nResulting numbers: [1424].\n1424,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+16=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,0,3,0: 95:[105]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '89-23=66', '39+66=105'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,0,4,2: 95:[105]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '39-23=16', '89+16=105'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 22\nCurrent State #0,0,4,0: 95:[73]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '39-23=16', '89-16=73'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 42.5\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 95:[37, 68]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '91-23=68'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-37=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*68=2516. \nResulting numbers: [2516].\n2516,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+68=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 42.5\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 95:[91, 14]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '37-23=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-14=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91+14=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91*14=1274. \nResulting numbers: [1274].\n1274,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,2,1,2: 95:[105]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '91-23=68', '37+68=105'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,2,2,1: 95:[105]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '37-23=14', '91+14=105'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 18\nCurrent State #0,2,2,0: 95:[77]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '37-23=14', '91-14=77'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 45\nCurrent State #0,4,1,0: 95:[140]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '89-23=66', '74+66=140'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 45\nCurrent State #0,4,3,2: 95:[140]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '74-23=51', '89+51=140'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 46.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 95:[89, 9]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '46-37=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89+9=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89*9=801. \nResulting numbers: [801].\n801,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-9=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 46.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 95:[46, 52]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '89-37=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+52=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-46=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46*52=2392. \nResulting numbers: [2392].\n2392,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 49.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 95:[37, 135]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '89+46=135'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*135=4995. \nResulting numbers: [4995].\n4995,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+135=172. \nResulting numbers: [172].\n172,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 135-37=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 52\nCurrent State #0,3,2,1: 95:[147]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '60-2=58', '89+58=147'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 52\nCurrent State #0,3,1,1: 95:[147]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '89-2=87', '60+87=147'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 3\nCurrent State #0,1,1,0: 95:[98]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '46-37=9', '89+9=98'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 3\nCurrent State #0,1,0,0: 95:[98]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '89-37=52', '46+52=98'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 3\nCurrent State #0,1,3,2: 95:[98]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '89+46=135', '135-37=98'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 15\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 95:[80]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '46-37=9', '89-9=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 52.5\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 95:[23, 128]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '89+39=128'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+128=151. \nResulting numbers: [151].\n151,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23*128=2944. \nResulting numbers: [2944].\n2944,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 128-23=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,0,0,2: 95:[105]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '89+39=128', '128-23=105'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 52.5\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 95:[23, 128]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '37+91=128'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23*128=2944. \nResulting numbers: [2944].\n2944,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+128=151. \nResulting numbers: [151].\n151,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 128-23=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 56\nCurrent State #0,3,4,2: 95:[151]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '2+89=91', '60+91=151'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 56\nCurrent State #0,0,2,1: 95:[151]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '89+23=112', '39+112=151'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 56\nCurrent State #0,0,0,0: 95:[151]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '89+39=128', '23+128=151'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 10\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 95:[105]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '37+91=128', '128-23=105'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 56\nCurrent State #0,2,4,2: 95:[151]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '23+91=114', '37+114=151'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 56\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 95:[151]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '37+91=128', '23+128=151'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 56\nCurrent State #0,2,0,0: 95:[151]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '37+23=60', '91+60=151'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 56\nCurrent State #0,0,1,1: 95:[151]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '23+39=62', '89+62=151'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 56\nCurrent State #0,3,3,0: 95:[151]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '2+60=62', '89+62=151'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 57\nCurrent State #0,4,0,1: 95:[38]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '89+23=112', '112-74=38'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 57\nCurrent State #0,4,3,1: 95:[38]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '74-23=51', '89-51=38'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 64\nCurrent State #0,2,1,0: 95:[31]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '91-23=68', '68-37=31'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 64\nCurrent State #0,3,0,1: 95:[31]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '2*60=120', '120-89=31'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 64\nCurrent State #0,3,2,2: 95:[31]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '60-2=58', '89-58=31'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 64\nCurrent State #0,2,0,1: 95:[31]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '37+23=60', '91-60=31'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 64\nCurrent State #0,3,4,0: 95:[31]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '2+89=91', '91-60=31'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 68\nCurrent State #0,3,1,0: 95:[27]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '89-2=87', '87-60=27'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 68\nCurrent State #0,0,3,2: 95:[27]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '89-23=66', '66-39=27'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 68\nCurrent State #0,0,1,2: 95:[27]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '23+39=62', '89-62=27'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 68\nCurrent State #0,3,3,2: 95:[27]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '2+60=62', '89-62=27'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 70.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 95:[23, 163]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '89+74=163'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+163=186. \nResulting numbers: [186].\n186,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23*163=3749. \nResulting numbers: [3749].\n3749,95 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 163-23=140. \nResulting numbers: [140].\n140,95 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 77\nCurrent State #0,1,3,1: 95:[172]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '89+46=135', '37+135=172'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 77\nCurrent State #0,1,2,1: 95:[172]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '37+89=126', '46+126=172'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 45\nCurrent State #0,4,2,2: 95:[140]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '89+74=163', '163-23=140'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 77\nCurrent State #0,1,4,2: 95:[172]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '37+46=83', '89+83=172'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 87\nCurrent State #0,4,4,0: 95:[8]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '23+74=97', '97-89=8'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 87\nCurrent State #0,4,1,1: 95:[8]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '89-23=66', '74-66=8'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 89\nCurrent State #0,1,4,1: 95:[6]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '37+46=83', '89-83=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 89\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 95:[6]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '89-37=52', '52-46=6'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 91\nCurrent State #0,4,0,2: 95:[186]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '89+23=112', '74+112=186'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 91\nCurrent State #0,4,4,1: 95:[186]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '23+74=97', '89+97=186'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 91\nCurrent State #0,4,2,0: 95:[186]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '89+74=163', '23+163=186'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 114\nCurrent State #0,3,0,0: 95:[209]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '2*60=120', '89+120=209'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 706\nCurrent State #0,1,1,1: 95:[801]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '46-37=9', '89*9=801'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 1179\nCurrent State #0,2,2,2: 95:[1274]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '37-23=14', '91*14=1274'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 1329\nCurrent State #0,0,4,1: 95:[1424]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '39-23=16', '89*16=1424'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 2297\nCurrent State #0,1,0,2: 95:[2392]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '89-37=52', '46*52=2392'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 2421\nCurrent State #0,2,1,1: 95:[2516]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '91-23=68', '37*68=2516'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 2479\nCurrent State #0,0,3,1: 95:[2574]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '89-23=66', '39*66=2574'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 2849\nCurrent State #0,0,0,1: 95:[2944]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '89+39=128', '23*128=2944'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 2849\nCurrent State #0,2,3,0: 95:[2944]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '37+91=128', '23*128=2944'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 3654\nCurrent State #0,4,2,1: 95:[3749]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '89+74=163', '23*163=3749'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 4123\nCurrent State #0,2,4,1: 95:[4218]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '23+91=114', '37*114=4218'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 4273\nCurrent State #0,0,2,0: 95:[4368]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '89+23=112', '39*112=4368'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 4444\nCurrent State #0,4,3,0: 95:[4539]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '74-23=51', '89*51=4539'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 4789\nCurrent State #0,4,1,2: 95:[4884]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '89-23=66', '74*66=4884'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 4900\nCurrent State #0,1,3,0: 95:[4995]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '89+46=135', '37*135=4995'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 5067\nCurrent State #0,3,2,0: 95:[5162]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '60-2=58', '89*58=5162'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 5125\nCurrent State #0,3,1,2: 95:[5220]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '89-2=87', '60*87=5220'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 5365\nCurrent State #0,2,0,2: 95:[5460]. Operations so far : ['2+89=91', '37+23=60', '91*60=5460'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 5365\nCurrent State #0,3,4,1: 95:[5460]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '2+89=91', '60*91=5460'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 5423\nCurrent State #0,0,1,0: 95:[5518]. Operations so far : ['37+2=39', '23+39=62', '89*62=5518'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 5423\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 95:[5518]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '2+60=62', '89*62=5518'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 5701\nCurrent State #0,1,2,0: 95:[5796]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '37+89=126', '46*126=5796'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 7292\nCurrent State #0,1,4,0: 95:[7387]. Operations so far : ['2*23=46', '37+46=83', '89*83=7387'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 8193\nCurrent State #0,4,0,0: 95:[8288]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '89+23=112', '74*112=8288'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 8538\nCurrent State #0,4,4,2: 95:[8633]. Operations so far : ['37*2=74', '23+74=97', '89*97=8633'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 10585\nCurrent State #0,3,0,2: 95:[10680]. Operations so far : ['37+23=60', '2*60=120', '89*120=10680'].\n\n```\nSOLUTION: NO\nOPERATIONS: []\nRESULT: None\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 15,891 |
[
72,
69,
31,
64
]
| 36 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [72, 69, 31, 64] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 36. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [72, 69, 31, 64]. Our goal is to produce 36. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 36:[72, 69, 31, 64]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-69=3. \nResulting numbers: [31, 64, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|31-36| + |64-36| + |3-36|)/3 = (5 + 28 + 33)/3 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 36:[31, 64, 3] Operation: 72-69=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31+3=34. \nResulting numbers: [64, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|64-36| + |34-36|)/2 = (28 + 2)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 36:[64, 34] Operation: 31+3=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-34=30. \nResulting numbers: [30].\n30,36 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 36:[31, 64, 3]. Operations so far : ['72-69=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-3=61. \nResulting numbers: [31, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|31-36| + |61-36|)/2 = (5 + 25)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 36:[31, 61] Operation: 64-3=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-31=30. \nResulting numbers: [30].\n30,36 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 36:[31, 64, 3]. Operations so far : ['72-69=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-31=33. \nResulting numbers: [3, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|3-36| + |33-36|)/2 = (33 + 3)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 36:[3, 33] Operation: 64-31=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+33=36. \nResulting numbers: [36].\n36,36 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['72-69=3', '64-31=33', '3+33=36']\nRESULT: 36\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 862 |
[
8,
48,
57,
40
]
| 11 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [8, 48, 57, 40] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 11. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [8, 48, 57, 40]. Our goal is to produce 11. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 11:[8, 48, 57, 40]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-48=9. \nResulting numbers: [8, 40, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|8-11| + |40-11| + |9-11|)/3 = (3 + 29 + 2)/3 = 11.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 11:[8, 40, 9] Operation: 57-48=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40/8=5. \nResulting numbers: [9, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|9-11| + |5-11|)/2 = (2 + 6)/2 = 4.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 11:[9, 5] Operation: 40/8=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9+5=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,11 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 11:[8, 40, 9]. Operations so far : ['57-48=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-8=32. \nResulting numbers: [9, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|9-11| + |32-11|)/2 = (2 + 21)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 11:[9, 32] Operation: 40-8=32\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-9=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,11 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 11:[8, 40, 9]. Operations so far : ['57-48=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-9=31. \nResulting numbers: [8, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|8-11| + |31-11|)/2 = (3 + 20)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 11:[8, 31] Operation: 40-9=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31-8=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,11 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 11:[8, 40, 9]. Operations so far : ['57-48=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+9=17. \nResulting numbers: [40, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|40-11| + |17-11|)/2 = (29 + 6)/2 = 17.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 11:[40, 17] Operation: 8+9=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-17=23. \nResulting numbers: [23].\n23,11 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 11:[8, 40, 9]. Operations so far : ['57-48=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8+40=48. \nResulting numbers: [9, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|9-11| + |48-11|)/2 = (2 + 37)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 11:[9, 48] Operation: 8+40=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-9=39. \nResulting numbers: [39].\n39,11 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 11:[8, 40, 9]. Operations so far : ['57-48=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 9-8=1. \nResulting numbers: [40, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|40-11| + |1-11|)/2 = (29 + 10)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 11:[40, 1] Operation: 9-8=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-1=39. \nResulting numbers: [39].\n39,11 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 11:[8, 40, 9]. Operations so far : ['57-48=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+9=49. \nResulting numbers: [8, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|8-11| + |49-11|)/2 = (3 + 38)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 11:[8, 49] Operation: 40+9=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-8=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,11 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 11:[8, 40, 9]. Operations so far : ['57-48=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*9=72. \nResulting numbers: [40, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|40-11| + |72-11|)/2 = (29 + 61)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 11:[40, 72] Operation: 8*9=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-40=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,11 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 11:[8, 40, 9]. Operations so far : ['57-48=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 8*40=320. \nResulting numbers: [9, 320].\nHeuristic score : (|9-11| + |320-11|)/2 = (2 + 309)/2 = 155.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 11:[9, 320] Operation: 8*40=320\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 320-9=311. \nResulting numbers: [311].\n311,11 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,0: 11:[8, 40, 9]. Operations so far : ['57-48=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*9=360. \nResulting numbers: [8, 360].\nHeuristic score : (|8-11| + |360-11|)/2 = (3 + 349)/2 = 176.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,9: 11:[8, 360] Operation: 40*9=360\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 360/8=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,11 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 28.75\nCurrent State #0: 11:[8, 48, 57, 40]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-40=17. \nResulting numbers: [8, 48, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|8-11| + |48-11| + |17-11|)/3 = (3 + 37 + 6)/3 = 15.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 11:[8, 48, 17] Operation: 57-40=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48/8=6. \nResulting numbers: [17, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|17-11| + |6-11|)/2 = (6 + 5)/2 = 5.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 11:[17, 6] Operation: 48/8=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17-6=11. \nResulting numbers: [11].\n11,11 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['57-40=17', '48/8=6', '17-6=11']\nRESULT: 11\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 2,739 |
[
90,
80,
30,
95
]
| 46 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [90, 80, 30, 95] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 46. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [90, 80, 30, 95]. Our goal is to produce 46. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 46:[90, 80, 30, 95]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-30=60. \nResulting numbers: [80, 95, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|80-46| + |95-46| + |60-46|)/3 = (34 + 49 + 14)/3 = 32.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 46:[80, 95, 60] Operation: 90-30=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-90=5. \nResulting numbers: [80, 30, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|80-46| + |30-46| + |5-46|)/3 = (34 + 16 + 41)/3 = 30.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 46:[80, 30, 5] Operation: 95-90=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-30=65. \nResulting numbers: [90, 80, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|90-46| + |80-46| + |65-46|)/3 = (44 + 34 + 19)/3 = 32.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 46:[90, 80, 65] Operation: 95-30=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-30=50. \nResulting numbers: [90, 95, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|90-46| + |95-46| + |50-46|)/3 = (44 + 49 + 4)/3 = 32.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 46:[90, 95, 50] Operation: 80-30=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-80=15. \nResulting numbers: [90, 30, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|90-46| + |30-46| + |15-46|)/3 = (44 + 16 + 31)/3 = 30.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 46:[90, 30, 15] Operation: 95-80=15\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 46:[80, 30, 5]. Operations so far : ['95-90=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-30=50. \nResulting numbers: [5, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|5-46| + |50-46|)/2 = (41 + 4)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 46:[5, 50] Operation: 80-30=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+5=85. \nResulting numbers: [30, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|30-46| + |85-46|)/2 = (16 + 39)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 46:[30, 85] Operation: 80+5=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+5=35. \nResulting numbers: [80, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|80-46| + |35-46|)/2 = (34 + 11)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 46:[80, 35] Operation: 30+5=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/5=16. \nResulting numbers: [30, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|30-46| + |16-46|)/2 = (16 + 30)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 46:[30, 16] Operation: 80/5=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-5=75. \nResulting numbers: [30, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|30-46| + |75-46|)/2 = (16 + 29)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 46:[30, 75] Operation: 80-5=75\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 46:[90, 30, 15]. Operations so far : ['95-80=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-15=75. \nResulting numbers: [30, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|30-46| + |75-46|)/2 = (16 + 29)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 46:[30, 75] Operation: 90-15=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90/30=3. \nResulting numbers: [15, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|15-46| + |3-46|)/2 = (31 + 43)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 46:[15, 3] Operation: 90/30=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-30=60. \nResulting numbers: [15, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|15-46| + |60-46|)/2 = (31 + 14)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 46:[15, 60] Operation: 90-30=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+15=45. \nResulting numbers: [90, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|90-46| + |45-46|)/2 = (44 + 1)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 46:[90, 45] Operation: 30+15=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90/15=6. \nResulting numbers: [30, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|30-46| + |6-46|)/2 = (16 + 40)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 46:[30, 6] Operation: 90/15=6\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 46:[80, 95, 60]. Operations so far : ['90-30=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-60=35. \nResulting numbers: [80, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|80-46| + |35-46|)/2 = (34 + 11)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 46:[80, 35] Operation: 95-60=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+95=175. \nResulting numbers: [60, 175].\nHeuristic score : (|60-46| + |175-46|)/2 = (14 + 129)/2 = 71.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 46:[60, 175] Operation: 80+95=175\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-80=15. \nResulting numbers: [60, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|60-46| + |15-46|)/2 = (14 + 31)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 46:[60, 15] Operation: 95-80=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-60=20. \nResulting numbers: [95, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|95-46| + |20-46|)/2 = (49 + 26)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 46:[95, 20] Operation: 80-60=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+60=140. \nResulting numbers: [95, 140].\nHeuristic score : (|95-46| + |140-46|)/2 = (49 + 94)/2 = 71.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 46:[95, 140] Operation: 80+60=140\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 46:[90, 80, 65]. Operations so far : ['95-30=65'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-80=10. \nResulting numbers: [65, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|65-46| + |10-46|)/2 = (19 + 36)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 46:[65, 10] Operation: 90-80=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90+65=155. \nResulting numbers: [80, 155].\nHeuristic score : (|80-46| + |155-46|)/2 = (34 + 109)/2 = 71.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 46:[80, 155] Operation: 90+65=155\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-65=15. \nResulting numbers: [90, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|90-46| + |15-46|)/2 = (44 + 31)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 46:[90, 15] Operation: 80-65=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-65=25. \nResulting numbers: [80, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|80-46| + |25-46|)/2 = (34 + 21)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 46:[80, 25] Operation: 90-65=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90+80=170. \nResulting numbers: [65, 170].\nHeuristic score : (|65-46| + |170-46|)/2 = (19 + 124)/2 = 71.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 46:[65, 170] Operation: 90+80=170\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,3: 46:[90, 95, 50]. Operations so far : ['80-30=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90+50=140. \nResulting numbers: [95, 140].\nHeuristic score : (|95-46| + |140-46|)/2 = (49 + 94)/2 = 71.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 46:[95, 140] Operation: 90+50=140\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-50=40. \nResulting numbers: [95, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|95-46| + |40-46|)/2 = (49 + 6)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 46:[95, 40] Operation: 90-50=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-50=45. \nResulting numbers: [90, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|90-46| + |45-46|)/2 = (44 + 1)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 46:[90, 45] Operation: 95-50=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-90=5. \nResulting numbers: [50, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|50-46| + |5-46|)/2 = (4 + 41)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 46:[50, 5] Operation: 95-90=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90+95=185. \nResulting numbers: [50, 185].\nHeuristic score : (|50-46| + |185-46|)/2 = (4 + 139)/2 = 71.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 46:[50, 185] Operation: 90+95=185\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 46:[5, 50]. Operations so far : ['95-90=5', '80-30=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5+50=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50/5=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-5=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5*50=250. \nResulting numbers: [250].\n250,46 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 46:[30, 75]. Operations so far : ['95-90=5', '80-5=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+75=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*75=2250. \nResulting numbers: [2250].\n2250,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-30=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,46 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 46:[15, 60]. Operations so far : ['95-80=15', '90-30=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-15=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 15*60=900. \nResulting numbers: [900].\n900,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/15=4. \nResulting numbers: [4].\n4,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 15+60=75. \nResulting numbers: [75].\n75,46 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 46:[30, 75]. Operations so far : ['95-80=15', '90-15=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-30=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*75=2250. \nResulting numbers: [2250].\n2250,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+75=105. \nResulting numbers: [105].\n105,46 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 46:[60, 15]. Operations so far : ['90-30=60', '95-80=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-15=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*15=900. \nResulting numbers: [900].\n900,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/15=4. \nResulting numbers: [4].\n4,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+15=75. \nResulting numbers: [75].\n75,46 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 1\nCurrent State #0,1,0,2: 46:[45]. Operations so far : ['95-90=5', '80-30=50', '50-5=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 1\nCurrent State #0,1,4,2: 46:[45]. Operations so far : ['95-90=5', '80-5=75', '75-30=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 1\nCurrent State #0,4,2,0: 46:[45]. Operations so far : ['95-80=15', '90-30=60', '60-15=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 1\nCurrent State #0,4,0,0: 46:[45]. Operations so far : ['95-80=15', '90-15=75', '75-30=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 1\nCurrent State #0,0,2,0: 46:[45]. Operations so far : ['90-30=60', '95-80=15', '60-15=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 9\nCurrent State #0,1,0,0: 46:[55]. Operations so far : ['95-90=5', '80-30=50', '5+50=55'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 46:[80, 35]. Operations so far : ['95-90=5', '30+5=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [115].\n115,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*35=2800. \nResulting numbers: [2800].\n2800,46 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 46:[80, 35]. Operations so far : ['90-30=60', '95-60=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [115].\n115,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*35=2800. \nResulting numbers: [2800].\n2800,46 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 46:[50, 5]. Operations so far : ['80-30=50', '95-90=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*5=250. \nResulting numbers: [250].\n250,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+5=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-5=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50/5=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,46 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 46:[90, 45]. Operations so far : ['80-30=50', '95-50=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90/45=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90*45=4050. \nResulting numbers: [4050].\n4050,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90+45=135. \nResulting numbers: [135].\n135,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-45=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,46 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 1\nCurrent State #0,1,2,0: 46:[45]. Operations so far : ['95-90=5', '30+5=35', '80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 1\nCurrent State #0,0,0,0: 46:[45]. Operations so far : ['90-30=60', '95-60=35', '80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 1\nCurrent State #0,3,3,2: 46:[45]. Operations so far : ['80-30=50', '95-90=5', '50-5=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 1\nCurrent State #0,3,2,3: 46:[45]. Operations so far : ['80-30=50', '95-50=45', '90-45=45'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 9\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 46:[55]. Operations so far : ['80-30=50', '95-90=5', '50+5=55'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 22.5\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 46:[90, 45]. Operations so far : ['95-80=15', '30+15=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90/45=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90*45=4050. \nResulting numbers: [4050].\n4050,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90+45=135. \nResulting numbers: [135].\n135,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-45=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,46 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 46:[30, 16]. Operations so far : ['95-90=5', '80/5=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-16=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*16=480. \nResulting numbers: [480].\n480,46 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+16=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,46 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['95-90=5', '80/5=16', '30-16=14']\nRESULT: 14\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,450 |
[
50,
44,
38,
11
]
| 44 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [50, 44, 38, 11] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 44. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [50, 44, 38, 11]. Our goal is to produce 44. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 44:[50, 44, 38, 11]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-11=39. \nResulting numbers: [44, 38, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|44-44| + |38-44| + |39-44|)/3 = (0 + 6 + 5)/3 = 3.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 44:[44, 38, 39] Operation: 50-11=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+11=49. \nResulting numbers: [50, 44, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|50-44| + |44-44| + |49-44|)/3 = (6 + 0 + 5)/3 = 3.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 44:[50, 44, 49] Operation: 38+11=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+11=61. \nResulting numbers: [44, 38, 61].\nHeuristic score : (|44-44| + |38-44| + |61-44|)/3 = (0 + 6 + 17)/3 = 7.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 44:[44, 38, 61] Operation: 50+11=61\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+11=55. \nResulting numbers: [50, 38, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|50-44| + |38-44| + |55-44|)/3 = (6 + 6 + 11)/3 = 7.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 44:[50, 38, 55] Operation: 44+11=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-11=33. \nResulting numbers: [50, 38, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|50-44| + |38-44| + |33-44|)/3 = (6 + 6 + 11)/3 = 7.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 44:[50, 38, 33] Operation: 44-11=33\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 3.6666666666666665\nCurrent State #0,0: 44:[44, 38, 39]. Operations so far : ['50-11=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-38=1. \nResulting numbers: [44, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|44-44| + |1-44|)/2 = (0 + 43)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 44:[44, 1] Operation: 39-38=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+39=83. \nResulting numbers: [38, 83].\nHeuristic score : (|38-44| + |83-44|)/2 = (6 + 39)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 44:[38, 83] Operation: 44+39=83\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+38=82. \nResulting numbers: [39, 82].\nHeuristic score : (|39-44| + |82-44|)/2 = (5 + 38)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 44:[39, 82] Operation: 44+38=82\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-38=6. \nResulting numbers: [39, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|39-44| + |6-44|)/2 = (5 + 38)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 44:[39, 6] Operation: 44-38=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+39=77. \nResulting numbers: [44, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|44-44| + |77-44|)/2 = (0 + 33)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 44:[44, 77] Operation: 38+39=77\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 3.6666666666666665\nCurrent State #0,1: 44:[50, 44, 49]. Operations so far : ['38+11=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-44=6. \nResulting numbers: [49, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|49-44| + |6-44|)/2 = (5 + 38)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 44:[49, 6] Operation: 50-44=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-49=1. \nResulting numbers: [44, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|44-44| + |1-44|)/2 = (0 + 43)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 44:[44, 1] Operation: 50-49=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-44=5. \nResulting numbers: [50, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|50-44| + |5-44|)/2 = (6 + 39)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 44:[50, 5] Operation: 49-44=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+44=94. \nResulting numbers: [49, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|49-44| + |94-44|)/2 = (5 + 50)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 44:[49, 94] Operation: 50+44=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+49=99. \nResulting numbers: [44, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|44-44| + |99-44|)/2 = (0 + 55)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 44:[44, 99] Operation: 50+49=99\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 7.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,2: 44:[44, 38, 61]. Operations so far : ['50+11=61'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+38=82. \nResulting numbers: [61, 82].\nHeuristic score : (|61-44| + |82-44|)/2 = (17 + 38)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 44:[61, 82] Operation: 44+38=82\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-44=17. \nResulting numbers: [38, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|38-44| + |17-44|)/2 = (6 + 27)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 44:[38, 17] Operation: 61-44=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-38=23. \nResulting numbers: [44, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|44-44| + |23-44|)/2 = (0 + 21)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 44:[44, 23] Operation: 61-38=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+61=99. \nResulting numbers: [44, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|44-44| + |99-44|)/2 = (0 + 55)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 44:[44, 99] Operation: 38+61=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-38=6. \nResulting numbers: [61, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|61-44| + |6-44|)/2 = (17 + 38)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 44:[61, 6] Operation: 44-38=6\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 7.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,3: 44:[50, 38, 55]. Operations so far : ['44+11=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+38=88. \nResulting numbers: [55, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|55-44| + |88-44|)/2 = (11 + 44)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 44:[55, 88] Operation: 50+38=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-38=17. \nResulting numbers: [50, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|50-44| + |17-44|)/2 = (6 + 27)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 44:[50, 17] Operation: 55-38=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+55=93. \nResulting numbers: [50, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|50-44| + |93-44|)/2 = (6 + 49)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 44:[50, 93] Operation: 38+55=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-38=12. \nResulting numbers: [55, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|55-44| + |12-44|)/2 = (11 + 32)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 44:[55, 12] Operation: 50-38=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-50=5. \nResulting numbers: [38, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|38-44| + |5-44|)/2 = (6 + 39)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 44:[38, 5] Operation: 55-50=5\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 7.666666666666667\nCurrent State #0,4: 44:[50, 38, 33]. Operations so far : ['44-11=33'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-38=12. \nResulting numbers: [33, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|33-44| + |12-44|)/2 = (11 + 32)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 44:[33, 12] Operation: 50-38=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+33=83. \nResulting numbers: [38, 83].\nHeuristic score : (|38-44| + |83-44|)/2 = (6 + 39)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 44:[38, 83] Operation: 50+33=83\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+33=71. \nResulting numbers: [50, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|50-44| + |71-44|)/2 = (6 + 27)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 44:[50, 71] Operation: 38+33=71\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-33=17. \nResulting numbers: [38, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|38-44| + |17-44|)/2 = (6 + 27)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 44:[38, 17] Operation: 50-33=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-33=5. \nResulting numbers: [50, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|50-44| + |5-44|)/2 = (6 + 39)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 44:[50, 5] Operation: 38-33=5\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 44:[44, 23]. Operations so far : ['50+11=61', '61-38=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*23=1012. \nResulting numbers: [1012].\n1012,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-23=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+23=67. \nResulting numbers: [67].\n67,44 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.5\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 44:[38, 17]. Operations so far : ['50+11=61', '61-44=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38*17=646. \nResulting numbers: [646].\n646,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-17=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+17=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,44 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 16.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 44:[44, 77]. Operations so far : ['50-11=39', '38+39=77'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+77=121. \nResulting numbers: [121].\n121,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-44=33. \nResulting numbers: [33].\n33,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*77=3388. \nResulting numbers: [3388].\n3388,44 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 16.5\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 44:[50, 71]. Operations so far : ['44-11=33', '38+33=71'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-50=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*71=3550. \nResulting numbers: [3550].\n3550,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+71=121. \nResulting numbers: [121].\n121,44 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 16.5\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 44:[38, 17]. Operations so far : ['44-11=33', '50-33=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-17=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+17=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38*17=646. \nResulting numbers: [646].\n646,44 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 11\nCurrent State #0,2,1,2: 44:[55]. Operations so far : ['50+11=61', '61-44=17', '38+17=55'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 11\nCurrent State #0,0,4,1: 44:[33]. Operations so far : ['50-11=39', '38+39=77', '77-44=33'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 11\nCurrent State #0,4,3,1: 44:[55]. Operations so far : ['44-11=33', '50-33=17', '38+17=55'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.5\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 44:[50, 17]. Operations so far : ['44+11=55', '55-38=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*17=850. \nResulting numbers: [850].\n850,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+17=67. \nResulting numbers: [67].\n67,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-17=33. \nResulting numbers: [33].\n33,44 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 44:[44, 1]. Operations so far : ['38+11=49', '50-49=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-1=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,44 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*1=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,44 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['38+11=49', '50-49=1', '44/1=44']\nRESULT: 44\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 5,481 |
[
61,
27,
50,
24
]
| 61 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [61, 27, 50, 24] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 61. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [61, 27, 50, 24]. Our goal is to produce 61. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 61:[61, 27, 50, 24]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+24=51. \nResulting numbers: [61, 50, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|61-61| + |50-61| + |51-61|)/3 = (0 + 11 + 10)/3 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 61:[61, 50, 51] Operation: 27+24=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+24=85. \nResulting numbers: [27, 50, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|27-61| + |50-61| + |85-61|)/3 = (34 + 11 + 24)/3 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 61:[27, 50, 85] Operation: 61+24=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+24=74. \nResulting numbers: [61, 27, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|61-61| + |27-61| + |74-61|)/3 = (0 + 34 + 13)/3 = 15.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 61:[61, 27, 74] Operation: 50+24=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-24=37. \nResulting numbers: [27, 50, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|27-61| + |50-61| + |37-61|)/3 = (34 + 11 + 24)/3 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 61:[27, 50, 37] Operation: 61-24=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+50=77. \nResulting numbers: [61, 24, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|61-61| + |24-61| + |77-61|)/3 = (0 + 37 + 16)/3 = 17.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 61:[61, 24, 77] Operation: 27+50=77\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 61:[61, 50, 51]. Operations so far : ['27+24=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+50=111. \nResulting numbers: [51, 111].\nHeuristic score : (|51-61| + |111-61|)/2 = (10 + 50)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 61:[51, 111] Operation: 61+50=111\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+51=112. \nResulting numbers: [50, 112].\nHeuristic score : (|50-61| + |112-61|)/2 = (11 + 51)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 61:[50, 112] Operation: 61+51=112\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-50=11. \nResulting numbers: [51, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|51-61| + |11-61|)/2 = (10 + 50)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 61:[51, 11] Operation: 61-50=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+51=101. \nResulting numbers: [61, 101].\nHeuristic score : (|61-61| + |101-61|)/2 = (0 + 40)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 61:[61, 101] Operation: 50+51=101\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-50=1. \nResulting numbers: [61, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|61-61| + |1-61|)/2 = (0 + 60)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 61:[61, 1] Operation: 51-50=1\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 15.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,2: 61:[61, 27, 74]. Operations so far : ['50+24=74'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+74=101. \nResulting numbers: [61, 101].\nHeuristic score : (|61-61| + |101-61|)/2 = (0 + 40)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 61:[61, 101] Operation: 27+74=101\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+27=88. \nResulting numbers: [74, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|74-61| + |88-61|)/2 = (13 + 27)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 61:[74, 88] Operation: 61+27=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-61=13. \nResulting numbers: [27, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|27-61| + |13-61|)/2 = (34 + 48)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 61:[27, 13] Operation: 74-61=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-27=47. \nResulting numbers: [61, 47].\nHeuristic score : (|61-61| + |47-61|)/2 = (0 + 14)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 61:[61, 47] Operation: 74-27=47\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-27=34. \nResulting numbers: [74, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|74-61| + |34-61|)/2 = (13 + 27)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 61:[74, 34] Operation: 61-27=34\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 61:[61, 24, 77]. Operations so far : ['27+50=77'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+77=101. \nResulting numbers: [61, 101].\nHeuristic score : (|61-61| + |101-61|)/2 = (0 + 40)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 61:[61, 101] Operation: 24+77=101\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+24=85. \nResulting numbers: [77, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|77-61| + |85-61|)/2 = (16 + 24)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 61:[77, 85] Operation: 61+24=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-24=53. \nResulting numbers: [61, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|61-61| + |53-61|)/2 = (0 + 8)/2 = 4.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 61:[61, 53] Operation: 77-24=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-24=37. \nResulting numbers: [77, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|77-61| + |37-61|)/2 = (16 + 24)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 61:[77, 37] Operation: 61-24=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-61=16. \nResulting numbers: [24, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|24-61| + |16-61|)/2 = (37 + 45)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 61:[24, 16] Operation: 77-61=16\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 23.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 61:[27, 50, 85]. Operations so far : ['61+24=85'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-27=58. \nResulting numbers: [50, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|50-61| + |58-61|)/2 = (11 + 3)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 61:[50, 58] Operation: 85-27=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-27=23. \nResulting numbers: [85, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|85-61| + |23-61|)/2 = (24 + 38)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 61:[85, 23] Operation: 50-27=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-50=35. \nResulting numbers: [27, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|27-61| + |35-61|)/2 = (34 + 26)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 61:[27, 35] Operation: 85-50=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+85=112. \nResulting numbers: [50, 112].\nHeuristic score : (|50-61| + |112-61|)/2 = (11 + 51)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 61:[50, 112] Operation: 27+85=112\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+50=77. \nResulting numbers: [85, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|85-61| + |77-61|)/2 = (24 + 16)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 61:[85, 77] Operation: 27+50=77\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 61:[27, 50, 37]. Operations so far : ['61-24=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-27=23. \nResulting numbers: [37, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|37-61| + |23-61|)/2 = (24 + 38)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 61:[37, 23] Operation: 50-27=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+50=77. \nResulting numbers: [37, 77].\nHeuristic score : (|37-61| + |77-61|)/2 = (24 + 16)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 61:[37, 77] Operation: 27+50=77\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+37=87. \nResulting numbers: [27, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|27-61| + |87-61|)/2 = (34 + 26)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 61:[27, 87] Operation: 50+37=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37-27=10. \nResulting numbers: [50, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|50-61| + |10-61|)/2 = (11 + 51)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 61:[50, 10] Operation: 37-27=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+37=64. \nResulting numbers: [50, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|50-61| + |64-61|)/2 = (11 + 3)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 61:[50, 64] Operation: 27+37=64\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 4.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 61:[61, 53]. Operations so far : ['27+50=77', '77-24=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-53=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+53=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*53=3233. \nResulting numbers: [3233].\n3233,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 61:[61, 47]. Operations so far : ['50+24=74', '74-27=47'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*47=2867. \nResulting numbers: [2867].\n2867,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+47=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-47=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 61:[50, 64]. Operations so far : ['61-24=37', '27+37=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-50=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*64=3200. \nResulting numbers: [3200].\n3200,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+64=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 61:[50, 58]. Operations so far : ['61+24=85', '85-27=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*58=2900. \nResulting numbers: [2900].\n2900,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+58=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58-50=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 61:[61, 101]. Operations so far : ['27+24=51', '50+51=101'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*101=6161. \nResulting numbers: [6161].\n6161,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+101=162. \nResulting numbers: [162].\n162,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-61=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 61:[61, 101]. Operations so far : ['50+24=74', '27+74=101'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*101=6161. \nResulting numbers: [6161].\n6161,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+101=162. \nResulting numbers: [162].\n162,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-61=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 61:[77, 37]. Operations so far : ['27+50=77', '61-24=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+37=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*37=2849. \nResulting numbers: [2849].\n2849,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-37=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 61:[61, 101]. Operations so far : ['27+50=77', '24+77=101'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+101=162. \nResulting numbers: [162].\n162,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-61=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*101=6161. \nResulting numbers: [6161].\n6161,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 61:[77, 85]. Operations so far : ['27+50=77', '61+24=85'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77+85=162. \nResulting numbers: [162].\n162,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-77=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77*85=6545. \nResulting numbers: [6545].\n6545,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 61:[37, 77]. Operations so far : ['61-24=37', '27+50=77'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+77=114. \nResulting numbers: [114].\n114,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 77-37=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37*77=2849. \nResulting numbers: [2849].\n2849,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 61:[74, 88]. Operations so far : ['50+24=74', '61+27=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-74=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74*88=6512. \nResulting numbers: [6512].\n6512,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+88=162. \nResulting numbers: [162].\n162,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 61:[74, 34]. Operations so far : ['50+24=74', '61-27=34'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74*34=2516. \nResulting numbers: [2516].\n2516,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74+34=108. \nResulting numbers: [108].\n108,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-34=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 61:[85, 77]. Operations so far : ['61+24=85', '27+50=77'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+77=162. \nResulting numbers: [162].\n162,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-77=8. \nResulting numbers: [8].\n8,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*77=6545. \nResulting numbers: [6545].\n6545,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21\nCurrent State #0,2,0,2: 61:[40]. Operations so far : ['50+24=74', '27+74=101', '101-61=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 21\nCurrent State #0,3,1,1: 61:[40]. Operations so far : ['61-24=37', '27+50=77', '77-37=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21\nCurrent State #0,4,0,1: 61:[40]. Operations so far : ['27+50=77', '24+77=101', '101-61=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 21\nCurrent State #0,0,3,2: 61:[40]. Operations so far : ['27+24=51', '50+51=101', '101-61=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 21\nCurrent State #0,2,4,2: 61:[40]. Operations so far : ['50+24=74', '61-27=34', '74-34=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 21\nCurrent State #0,4,3,2: 61:[40]. Operations so far : ['27+50=77', '61-24=37', '77-37=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 61:[51, 11]. Operations so far : ['27+24=51', '61-50=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51*11=561. \nResulting numbers: [561].\n561,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+11=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,61 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-11=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,61 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 1\nCurrent State #0,0,2,1: 61:[62]. Operations so far : ['27+24=51', '61-50=11', '51+11=62'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 21\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 61:[40]. Operations so far : ['27+24=51', '61-50=11', '51-11=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 61:[61, 1]. Operations so far : ['27+24=51', '51-50=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*1=61. \nResulting numbers: [61].\n61,61 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['27+24=51', '51-50=1', '61/1=61']\nRESULT: 61\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,758 |
[
44,
81,
82,
73
]
| 53 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [44, 81, 82, 73] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 53. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [44, 81, 82, 73]. Our goal is to produce 53. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 53:[44, 81, 82, 73]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-81=1. \nResulting numbers: [44, 73, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|44-53| + |73-53| + |1-53|)/3 = (9 + 20 + 52)/3 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 53:[44, 73, 1] Operation: 82-81=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-44=37. \nResulting numbers: [82, 73, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|82-53| + |73-53| + |37-53|)/3 = (29 + 20 + 16)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 53:[82, 73, 37] Operation: 81-44=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-73=9. \nResulting numbers: [44, 81, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|44-53| + |81-53| + |9-53|)/3 = (9 + 28 + 44)/3 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 53:[44, 81, 9] Operation: 82-73=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-44=38. \nResulting numbers: [81, 73, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|81-53| + |73-53| + |38-53|)/3 = (28 + 20 + 15)/3 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 53:[81, 73, 38] Operation: 82-44=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-44=29. \nResulting numbers: [81, 82, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|81-53| + |82-53| + |29-53|)/3 = (28 + 29 + 24)/3 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 53:[81, 82, 29] Operation: 73-44=29\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 53:[81, 73, 38]. Operations so far : ['82-44=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-73=8. \nResulting numbers: [38, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|38-53| + |8-53|)/2 = (15 + 45)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 53:[38, 8] Operation: 81-73=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+38=119. \nResulting numbers: [73, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|73-53| + |119-53|)/2 = (20 + 66)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 53:[73, 119] Operation: 81+38=119\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-38=43. \nResulting numbers: [73, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|73-53| + |43-53|)/2 = (20 + 10)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 53:[73, 43] Operation: 81-38=43\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-38=35. \nResulting numbers: [81, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|81-53| + |35-53|)/2 = (28 + 18)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 53:[81, 35] Operation: 73-38=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+38=111. \nResulting numbers: [81, 111].\nHeuristic score : (|81-53| + |111-53|)/2 = (28 + 58)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 53:[81, 111] Operation: 73+38=111\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 53:[82, 73, 37]. Operations so far : ['81-44=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-37=36. \nResulting numbers: [82, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|82-53| + |36-53|)/2 = (29 + 17)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 53:[82, 36] Operation: 73-37=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-73=9. \nResulting numbers: [37, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|37-53| + |9-53|)/2 = (16 + 44)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 53:[37, 9] Operation: 82-73=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+37=110. \nResulting numbers: [82, 110].\nHeuristic score : (|82-53| + |110-53|)/2 = (29 + 57)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 53:[82, 110] Operation: 73+37=110\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-37=45. \nResulting numbers: [73, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|73-53| + |45-53|)/2 = (20 + 8)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 53:[73, 45] Operation: 82-37=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+37=119. \nResulting numbers: [73, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|73-53| + |119-53|)/2 = (20 + 66)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 53:[73, 119] Operation: 82+37=119\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 53:[44, 73, 1]. Operations so far : ['82-81=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-1=72. \nResulting numbers: [44, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|44-53| + |72-53|)/2 = (9 + 19)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 53:[44, 72] Operation: 73-1=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+1=45. \nResulting numbers: [73, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|73-53| + |45-53|)/2 = (20 + 8)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 53:[73, 45] Operation: 44+1=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44/1=44. \nResulting numbers: [73, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|73-53| + |44-53|)/2 = (20 + 9)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 53:[73, 44] Operation: 44/1=44\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73*1=73. \nResulting numbers: [44, 73].\nHeuristic score : (|44-53| + |73-53|)/2 = (9 + 20)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 53:[44, 73] Operation: 73*1=73\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*1=44. \nResulting numbers: [73, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|73-53| + |44-53|)/2 = (20 + 9)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 53:[73, 44] Operation: 44*1=44\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 53:[44, 81, 9]. Operations so far : ['82-73=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-9=35. \nResulting numbers: [81, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|81-53| + |35-53|)/2 = (28 + 18)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 53:[81, 35] Operation: 44-9=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81/9=9. \nResulting numbers: [44, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|44-53| + |9-53|)/2 = (9 + 44)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 53:[44, 9] Operation: 81/9=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-9=72. \nResulting numbers: [44, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|44-53| + |72-53|)/2 = (9 + 19)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 53:[44, 72] Operation: 81-9=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+9=90. \nResulting numbers: [44, 90].\nHeuristic score : (|44-53| + |90-53|)/2 = (9 + 37)/2 = 23.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 53:[44, 90] Operation: 81+9=90\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+9=53. \nResulting numbers: [81, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|81-53| + |53-53|)/2 = (28 + 0)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 53:[81, 53] Operation: 44+9=53\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 53:[81, 82, 29]. Operations so far : ['73-44=29'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-29=53. \nResulting numbers: [81, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|81-53| + |53-53|)/2 = (28 + 0)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 53:[81, 53] Operation: 82-29=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+29=110. \nResulting numbers: [82, 110].\nHeuristic score : (|82-53| + |110-53|)/2 = (29 + 57)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 53:[82, 110] Operation: 81+29=110\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-29=52. \nResulting numbers: [82, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|82-53| + |52-53|)/2 = (29 + 1)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 53:[82, 52] Operation: 81-29=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+29=111. \nResulting numbers: [81, 111].\nHeuristic score : (|81-53| + |111-53|)/2 = (28 + 58)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 53:[81, 111] Operation: 82+29=111\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-81=1. \nResulting numbers: [29, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|29-53| + |1-53|)/2 = (24 + 52)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 53:[29, 1] Operation: 82-81=1\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 53:[73, 45]. Operations so far : ['81-44=37', '82-37=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+45=118. \nResulting numbers: [118].\n118,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73*45=3285. \nResulting numbers: [3285].\n3285,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-45=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 53:[73, 45]. Operations so far : ['82-81=1', '44+1=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73*45=3285. \nResulting numbers: [3285].\n3285,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-45=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+45=118. \nResulting numbers: [118].\n118,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 53:[44, 72]. Operations so far : ['82-81=1', '73-1=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-44=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+72=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*72=3168. \nResulting numbers: [3168].\n3168,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 53:[81, 53]. Operations so far : ['73-44=29', '82-29=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-53=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*53=4293. \nResulting numbers: [4293].\n4293,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+53=134. \nResulting numbers: [134].\n134,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 53:[44, 72]. Operations so far : ['82-73=9', '81-9=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-44=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+72=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*72=3168. \nResulting numbers: [3168].\n3168,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 53:[81, 53]. Operations so far : ['82-73=9', '44+9=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-53=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+53=134. \nResulting numbers: [134].\n134,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*53=4293. \nResulting numbers: [4293].\n4293,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 14.5\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 53:[44, 73]. Operations so far : ['82-81=1', '73*1=73'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+73=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-44=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*73=3212. \nResulting numbers: [3212].\n3212,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 14.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 53:[73, 44]. Operations so far : ['82-81=1', '44*1=44'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-44=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+44=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73*44=3212. \nResulting numbers: [3212].\n3212,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 53:[73, 44]. Operations so far : ['82-81=1', '44/1=44'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-44=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73*44=3212. \nResulting numbers: [3212].\n3212,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+44=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 53:[73, 43]. Operations so far : ['82-44=38', '81-38=43'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73-43=30. \nResulting numbers: [30].\n30,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73*43=3139. \nResulting numbers: [3139].\n3139,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 73+43=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 53:[82, 52]. Operations so far : ['73-44=29', '81-29=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+52=134. \nResulting numbers: [134].\n134,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-52=30. \nResulting numbers: [30].\n30,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82*52=4264. \nResulting numbers: [4264].\n4264,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 53:[82, 36]. Operations so far : ['81-44=37', '73-37=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+36=118. \nResulting numbers: [118].\n118,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-36=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82*36=2952. \nResulting numbers: [2952].\n2952,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 53:[81, 35]. Operations so far : ['82-44=38', '73-38=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*35=2835. \nResulting numbers: [2835].\n2835,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-35=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+35=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 23\nCurrent State #0,3,2,0: 53:[30]. Operations so far : ['82-44=38', '81-38=43', '73-43=30'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 23.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 53:[81, 35]. Operations so far : ['82-73=9', '44-9=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+35=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-35=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*35=2835. \nResulting numbers: [2835].\n2835,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 7\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 53:[46]. Operations so far : ['81-44=37', '73-37=36', '82-36=46'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 7\nCurrent State #0,2,0,1: 53:[46]. Operations so far : ['82-73=9', '44-9=35', '81-35=46'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 7\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 53:[46]. Operations so far : ['82-44=38', '73-38=35', '81-35=46'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 53:[44, 90]. Operations so far : ['82-73=9', '81+9=90'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44*90=3960. \nResulting numbers: [3960].\n3960,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 90-44=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+90=134. \nResulting numbers: [134].\n134,53 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 23\nCurrent State #0,4,2,1: 53:[30]. Operations so far : ['73-44=29', '81-29=52', '82-52=30'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 7\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 53:[46]. Operations so far : ['82-73=9', '81+9=90', '90-44=46'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,0,2,0: 53:[29]. Operations so far : ['82-81=1', '44/1=44', '73-44=29'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,0,4,0: 53:[29]. Operations so far : ['82-81=1', '44*1=44', '73-44=29'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,0,3,1: 53:[29]. Operations so far : ['82-81=1', '73*1=73', '73-44=29'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 25\nCurrent State #0,2,4,0: 53:[28]. Operations so far : ['82-73=9', '44+9=53', '81-53=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25\nCurrent State #0,4,0,0: 53:[28]. Operations so far : ['73-44=29', '82-29=53', '81-53=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 25\nCurrent State #0,0,1,1: 53:[28]. Operations so far : ['82-81=1', '44+1=45', '73-45=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 25\nCurrent State #0,0,0,0: 53:[28]. Operations so far : ['82-81=1', '73-1=72', '72-44=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 25\nCurrent State #0,1,3,2: 53:[28]. Operations so far : ['81-44=37', '82-37=45', '73-45=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 25\nCurrent State #0,2,2,0: 53:[28]. Operations so far : ['82-73=9', '81-9=72', '72-44=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 26.5\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 53:[44, 9]. Operations so far : ['82-73=9', '81/9=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44-9=35. \nResulting numbers: [35].\n35,53 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 44+9=53. \nResulting numbers: [53].\n53,53 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['82-73=9', '81/9=9', '44-9=35']\nRESULT: 35\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 8,628 |
[
92,
62,
45,
34
]
| 49 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [92, 62, 45, 34] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 49. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [92, 62, 45, 34]. Our goal is to produce 49. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 49:[92, 62, 45, 34]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-34=58. \nResulting numbers: [62, 45, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|62-49| + |45-49| + |58-49|)/3 = (13 + 4 + 9)/3 = 8.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 49:[62, 45, 58] Operation: 92-34=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-45=17. \nResulting numbers: [58, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|58-49| + |17-49|)/2 = (9 + 32)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 49:[58, 17] Operation: 62-45=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58-17=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,49 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 8.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 49:[62, 45, 58]. Operations so far : ['92-34=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-58=4. \nResulting numbers: [45, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|45-49| + |4-49|)/2 = (4 + 45)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 49:[45, 4] Operation: 62-58=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+4=49. \nResulting numbers: [49].\n49,49 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['92-34=58', '62-58=4', '45+4=49']\nRESULT: 49\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 649 |
[
34,
34,
5,
32
]
| 12 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [34, 34, 5, 32] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 12. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [34, 34, 5, 32]. Our goal is to produce 12. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 12:[34, 34, 5, 32]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-34=0. \nResulting numbers: [5, 32, 0].\nHeuristic score : (|5-12| + |32-12| + |0-12|)/3 = (7 + 20 + 12)/3 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 12:[5, 32, 0] Operation: 34-34=0\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-32=2. \nResulting numbers: [34, 5, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|34-12| + |5-12| + |2-12|)/3 = (22 + 7 + 10)/3 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 12:[34, 5, 2] Operation: 34-32=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34/34=1. \nResulting numbers: [5, 32, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|5-12| + |32-12| + |1-12|)/3 = (7 + 20 + 11)/3 = 12.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 12:[5, 32, 1] Operation: 34/34=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-5=29. \nResulting numbers: [34, 32, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|34-12| + |32-12| + |29-12|)/3 = (22 + 20 + 17)/3 = 19.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 12:[34, 32, 29] Operation: 34-5=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-32=2. \nResulting numbers: [34, 5, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|34-12| + |5-12| + |2-12|)/3 = (22 + 7 + 10)/3 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 12:[34, 5, 2] Operation: 34-32=2\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,2: 12:[5, 32, 1]. Operations so far : ['34/34=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5+1=6. \nResulting numbers: [32, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|32-12| + |6-12|)/2 = (20 + 6)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 12:[32, 6] Operation: 5+1=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5*1=5. \nResulting numbers: [32, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|32-12| + |5-12|)/2 = (20 + 7)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 12:[32, 5] Operation: 5*1=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5/1=5. \nResulting numbers: [32, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|32-12| + |5-12|)/2 = (20 + 7)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 12:[32, 5] Operation: 5/1=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-1=31. \nResulting numbers: [5, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|5-12| + |31-12|)/2 = (7 + 19)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 12:[5, 31] Operation: 32-1=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-5=27. \nResulting numbers: [1, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|1-12| + |27-12|)/2 = (11 + 15)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 12:[1, 27] Operation: 32-5=27\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 12:[34, 5, 2]. Operations so far : ['34-32=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-5=29. \nResulting numbers: [2, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|2-12| + |29-12|)/2 = (10 + 17)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 12:[2, 29] Operation: 34-5=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-2=32. \nResulting numbers: [5, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|5-12| + |32-12|)/2 = (7 + 20)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 12:[5, 32] Operation: 34-2=32\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5*2=10. \nResulting numbers: [34, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|34-12| + |10-12|)/2 = (22 + 2)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 12:[34, 10] Operation: 5*2=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5+2=7. \nResulting numbers: [34, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|34-12| + |7-12|)/2 = (22 + 5)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 12:[34, 7] Operation: 5+2=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34/2=17. \nResulting numbers: [5, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|5-12| + |17-12|)/2 = (7 + 5)/2 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 12:[5, 17] Operation: 34/2=17\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 12:[5, 32, 0]. Operations so far : ['34-34=0'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-5=27. \nResulting numbers: [0, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|0-12| + |27-12|)/2 = (12 + 15)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 12:[0, 27] Operation: 32-5=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5+0=5. \nResulting numbers: [32, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|32-12| + |5-12|)/2 = (20 + 7)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 12:[32, 5] Operation: 5+0=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5-0=5. \nResulting numbers: [32, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|32-12| + |5-12|)/2 = (20 + 7)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 12:[32, 5] Operation: 5-0=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*0=0. \nResulting numbers: [5, 0].\nHeuristic score : (|5-12| + |0-12|)/2 = (7 + 12)/2 = 9.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 12:[5, 0] Operation: 32*0=0\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+0=32. \nResulting numbers: [5, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|5-12| + |32-12|)/2 = (7 + 20)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 12:[5, 32] Operation: 32+0=32\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 13.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 12:[34, 5, 2]. Operations so far : ['34-32=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34/2=17. \nResulting numbers: [5, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|5-12| + |17-12|)/2 = (7 + 5)/2 = 6.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 12:[5, 17] Operation: 34/2=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5+2=7. \nResulting numbers: [34, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|34-12| + |7-12|)/2 = (22 + 5)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 12:[34, 7] Operation: 5+2=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-2=32. \nResulting numbers: [5, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|5-12| + |32-12|)/2 = (7 + 20)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 12:[5, 32] Operation: 34-2=32\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5*2=10. \nResulting numbers: [34, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|34-12| + |10-12|)/2 = (22 + 2)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 12:[34, 10] Operation: 5*2=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-5=29. \nResulting numbers: [2, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|2-12| + |29-12|)/2 = (10 + 17)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 12:[2, 29] Operation: 34-5=29\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 19.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 12:[34, 32, 29]. Operations so far : ['34-5=29'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+29=63. \nResulting numbers: [32, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|32-12| + |63-12|)/2 = (20 + 51)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 12:[32, 63] Operation: 34+29=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-32=2. \nResulting numbers: [29, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|29-12| + |2-12|)/2 = (17 + 10)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 12:[29, 2] Operation: 34-32=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-29=3. \nResulting numbers: [34, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|34-12| + |3-12|)/2 = (22 + 9)/2 = 15.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 12:[34, 3] Operation: 32-29=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34+32=66. \nResulting numbers: [29, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|29-12| + |66-12|)/2 = (17 + 54)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 12:[29, 66] Operation: 34+32=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 34-29=5. \nResulting numbers: [32, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|32-12| + |5-12|)/2 = (20 + 7)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 12:[32, 5] Operation: 34-29=5\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 6.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 12:[5, 17]. Operations so far : ['34-32=2', '34/2=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5*17=85. \nResulting numbers: [85].\n85,12 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5+17=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,12 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17-5=12. \nResulting numbers: [12].\n12,12 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['34-32=2', '34/2=17', '17-5=12']\nRESULT: 12\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 3,837 |
[
55,
69,
45,
38
]
| 97 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [55, 69, 45, 38] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 97. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [55, 69, 45, 38]. Our goal is to produce 97. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 97:[55, 69, 45, 38]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+45=100. \nResulting numbers: [69, 38, 100].\nHeuristic score : (|69-97| + |38-97| + |100-97|)/3 = (28 + 59 + 3)/3 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 97:[69, 38, 100] Operation: 55+45=100\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+38=107. \nResulting numbers: [55, 45, 107].\nHeuristic score : (|55-97| + |45-97| + |107-97|)/3 = (42 + 52 + 10)/3 = 34.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 97:[55, 45, 107] Operation: 69+38=107\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+45=114. \nResulting numbers: [55, 38, 114].\nHeuristic score : (|55-97| + |38-97| + |114-97|)/3 = (42 + 59 + 17)/3 = 39.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 97:[55, 38, 114] Operation: 69+45=114\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+38=83. \nResulting numbers: [55, 69, 83].\nHeuristic score : (|55-97| + |69-97| + |83-97|)/3 = (42 + 28 + 14)/3 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 97:[55, 69, 83] Operation: 45+38=83\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+38=93. \nResulting numbers: [69, 45, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|69-97| + |45-97| + |93-97|)/3 = (28 + 52 + 4)/3 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 97:[69, 45, 93] Operation: 55+38=93\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 97:[55, 69, 83]. Operations so far : ['45+38=83'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+83=152. \nResulting numbers: [55, 152].\nHeuristic score : (|55-97| + |152-97|)/2 = (42 + 55)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 97:[55, 152] Operation: 69+83=152\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+69=124. \nResulting numbers: [83, 124].\nHeuristic score : (|83-97| + |124-97|)/2 = (14 + 27)/2 = 20.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 97:[83, 124] Operation: 55+69=124\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-55=28. \nResulting numbers: [69, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|69-97| + |28-97|)/2 = (28 + 69)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 97:[69, 28] Operation: 83-55=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+83=138. \nResulting numbers: [69, 138].\nHeuristic score : (|69-97| + |138-97|)/2 = (28 + 41)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 97:[69, 138] Operation: 55+83=138\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-55=14. \nResulting numbers: [83, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|83-97| + |14-97|)/2 = (14 + 83)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 97:[83, 14] Operation: 69-55=14\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 97:[69, 45, 93]. Operations so far : ['55+38=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-45=48. \nResulting numbers: [69, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|69-97| + |48-97|)/2 = (28 + 49)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 97:[69, 48] Operation: 93-45=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+45=114. \nResulting numbers: [93, 114].\nHeuristic score : (|93-97| + |114-97|)/2 = (4 + 17)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 97:[93, 114] Operation: 69+45=114\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+93=162. \nResulting numbers: [45, 162].\nHeuristic score : (|45-97| + |162-97|)/2 = (52 + 65)/2 = 58.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 97:[45, 162] Operation: 69+93=162\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-45=24. \nResulting numbers: [93, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|93-97| + |24-97|)/2 = (4 + 73)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 97:[93, 24] Operation: 69-45=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+93=138. \nResulting numbers: [69, 138].\nHeuristic score : (|69-97| + |138-97|)/2 = (28 + 41)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 97:[69, 138] Operation: 45+93=138\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 97:[69, 38, 100]. Operations so far : ['55+45=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-38=62. \nResulting numbers: [69, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|69-97| + |62-97|)/2 = (28 + 35)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 97:[69, 62] Operation: 100-38=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-69=31. \nResulting numbers: [38, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|38-97| + |31-97|)/2 = (59 + 66)/2 = 62.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 97:[38, 31] Operation: 100-69=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-38=31. \nResulting numbers: [100, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|100-97| + |31-97|)/2 = (3 + 66)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 97:[100, 31] Operation: 69-38=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+38=107. \nResulting numbers: [100, 107].\nHeuristic score : (|100-97| + |107-97|)/2 = (3 + 10)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 97:[100, 107] Operation: 69+38=107\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+100=138. \nResulting numbers: [69, 138].\nHeuristic score : (|69-97| + |138-97|)/2 = (28 + 41)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 97:[69, 138] Operation: 38+100=138\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 34.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 97:[55, 45, 107]. Operations so far : ['69+38=107'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-45=10. \nResulting numbers: [107, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|107-97| + |10-97|)/2 = (10 + 87)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 97:[107, 10] Operation: 55-45=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 107-45=62. \nResulting numbers: [55, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|55-97| + |62-97|)/2 = (42 + 35)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 97:[55, 62] Operation: 107-45=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+107=152. \nResulting numbers: [55, 152].\nHeuristic score : (|55-97| + |152-97|)/2 = (42 + 55)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 97:[55, 152] Operation: 45+107=152\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+45=100. \nResulting numbers: [107, 100].\nHeuristic score : (|107-97| + |100-97|)/2 = (10 + 3)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 97:[107, 100] Operation: 55+45=100\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 107-55=52. \nResulting numbers: [45, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|45-97| + |52-97|)/2 = (52 + 45)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 97:[45, 52] Operation: 107-55=52\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 39.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 97:[55, 38, 114]. Operations so far : ['69+45=114'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+114=152. \nResulting numbers: [55, 152].\nHeuristic score : (|55-97| + |152-97|)/2 = (42 + 55)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 97:[55, 152] Operation: 38+114=152\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-38=17. \nResulting numbers: [114, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|114-97| + |17-97|)/2 = (17 + 80)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 97:[114, 17] Operation: 55-38=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+38=93. \nResulting numbers: [114, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|114-97| + |93-97|)/2 = (17 + 4)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 97:[114, 93] Operation: 55+38=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 114-38=76. \nResulting numbers: [55, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|55-97| + |76-97|)/2 = (42 + 21)/2 = 31.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 97:[55, 76] Operation: 114-38=76\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 114-55=59. \nResulting numbers: [38, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|38-97| + |59-97|)/2 = (59 + 38)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 97:[38, 59] Operation: 114-55=59\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 6.5\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 97:[100, 107]. Operations so far : ['55+45=100', '69+38=107'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 107-100=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100+107=207. \nResulting numbers: [207].\n207,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100*107=10700. \nResulting numbers: [10700].\n10700,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 6.5\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 97:[107, 100]. Operations so far : ['69+38=107', '55+45=100'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 107*100=10700. \nResulting numbers: [10700].\n10700,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 107+100=207. \nResulting numbers: [207].\n207,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 107-100=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 97:[114, 93]. Operations so far : ['69+45=114', '55+38=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 114-93=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 114*93=10602. \nResulting numbers: [10602].\n10602,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 114+93=207. \nResulting numbers: [207].\n207,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 97:[93, 114]. Operations so far : ['55+38=93', '69+45=114'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+114=207. \nResulting numbers: [207].\n207,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93*114=10602. \nResulting numbers: [10602].\n10602,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 114-93=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 20.5\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 97:[83, 124]. Operations so far : ['45+38=83', '55+69=124'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 124-83=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*124=10292. \nResulting numbers: [10292].\n10292,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+124=207. \nResulting numbers: [207].\n207,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.5\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 97:[69, 62]. Operations so far : ['55+45=100', '100-38=62'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*62=4278. \nResulting numbers: [4278].\n4278,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-62=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+62=131. \nResulting numbers: [131].\n131,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 31.5\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 97:[55, 76]. Operations so far : ['69+45=114', '114-38=76'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-55=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+76=131. \nResulting numbers: [131].\n131,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55*76=4180. \nResulting numbers: [4180].\n4180,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 97:[69, 138]. Operations so far : ['55+38=93', '45+93=138'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+138=207. \nResulting numbers: [207].\n207,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*138=9522. \nResulting numbers: [9522].\n9522,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 138/69=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 138-69=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 97:[69, 138]. Operations so far : ['55+45=100', '38+100=138'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 138-69=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*138=9522. \nResulting numbers: [9522].\n9522,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 138/69=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+138=207. \nResulting numbers: [207].\n207,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 97:[100, 31]. Operations so far : ['55+45=100', '69-38=31'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100-31=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100*31=3100. \nResulting numbers: [3100].\n3100,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 100+31=131. \nResulting numbers: [131].\n131,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 28\nCurrent State #0,4,4,3: 97:[69]. Operations so far : ['55+38=93', '45+93=138', '138-69=69'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 28\nCurrent State #0,0,4,0: 97:[69]. Operations so far : ['55+45=100', '38+100=138', '138-69=69'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 28\nCurrent State #0,0,2,0: 97:[69]. Operations so far : ['55+45=100', '69-38=31', '100-31=69'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,0,0,2: 97:[131]. Operations so far : ['55+45=100', '100-38=62', '69+62=131'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 97:[131]. Operations so far : ['55+45=100', '69-38=31', '100+31=131'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 97:[131]. Operations so far : ['69+45=114', '114-38=76', '55+76=131'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 97:[69, 138]. Operations so far : ['45+38=83', '55+83=138'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 138/69=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+138=207. \nResulting numbers: [207].\n207,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*138=9522. \nResulting numbers: [9522].\n9522,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 138-69=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 38.5\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 97:[93, 24]. Operations so far : ['55+38=93', '69-45=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93*24=2232. \nResulting numbers: [2232].\n2232,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+24=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-24=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 38.5\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 97:[69, 48]. Operations so far : ['55+38=93', '93-45=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69+48=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69*48=3312. \nResulting numbers: [3312].\n3312,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 69-48=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 38.5\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 97:[55, 62]. Operations so far : ['69+38=107', '107-45=62'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55*62=3410. \nResulting numbers: [3410].\n3410,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-55=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55+62=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,97 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 20\nCurrent State #0,4,3,1: 97:[117]. Operations so far : ['55+38=93', '69-45=24', '93+24=117'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 20\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 97:[117]. Operations so far : ['69+38=107', '107-45=62', '55+62=117'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20\nCurrent State #0,4,0,0: 97:[117]. Operations so far : ['55+38=93', '93-45=48', '69+48=117'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 28\nCurrent State #0,3,3,3: 97:[69]. Operations so far : ['45+38=83', '55+83=138', '138-69=69'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 28\nCurrent State #0,4,3,2: 97:[69]. Operations so far : ['55+38=93', '69-45=24', '93-24=69'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 48.5\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 97:[83, 14]. Operations so far : ['45+38=83', '69-55=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-14=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*14=1162. \nResulting numbers: [1162].\n1162,97 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+14=97. \nResulting numbers: [97].\n97,97 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['45+38=83', '69-55=14', '83-14=69']\nRESULT: 69\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 8,263 |
[
27,
21,
57,
85
]
| 64 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [27, 21, 57, 85] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 64. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [27, 21, 57, 85]. Our goal is to produce 64. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 64:[27, 21, 57, 85]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+21=48. \nResulting numbers: [57, 85, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|57-64| + |85-64| + |48-64|)/3 = (7 + 21 + 16)/3 = 14.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 64:[57, 85, 48] Operation: 27+21=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+57=84. \nResulting numbers: [21, 85, 84].\nHeuristic score : (|21-64| + |85-64| + |84-64|)/3 = (43 + 21 + 20)/3 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 64:[21, 85, 84] Operation: 27+57=84\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-21=64. \nResulting numbers: [27, 57, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|27-64| + |57-64| + |64-64|)/3 = (37 + 7 + 0)/3 = 14.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 64:[27, 57, 64] Operation: 85-21=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-27=58. \nResulting numbers: [21, 57, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|21-64| + |57-64| + |58-64|)/3 = (43 + 7 + 6)/3 = 18.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 64:[21, 57, 58] Operation: 85-27=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+57=78. \nResulting numbers: [27, 85, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|27-64| + |85-64| + |78-64|)/3 = (37 + 21 + 14)/3 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 64:[27, 85, 78] Operation: 21+57=78\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 14.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 64:[57, 85, 48]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-48=9. \nResulting numbers: [85, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|85-64| + |9-64|)/2 = (21 + 55)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 64:[85, 9] Operation: 57-48=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-57=28. \nResulting numbers: [48, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|48-64| + |28-64|)/2 = (16 + 36)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 64:[48, 28] Operation: 85-57=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+48=105. \nResulting numbers: [85, 105].\nHeuristic score : (|85-64| + |105-64|)/2 = (21 + 41)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 64:[85, 105] Operation: 57+48=105\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-48=37. \nResulting numbers: [57, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|57-64| + |37-64|)/2 = (7 + 27)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 64:[57, 37] Operation: 85-48=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+48=133. \nResulting numbers: [57, 133].\nHeuristic score : (|57-64| + |133-64|)/2 = (7 + 69)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 64:[57, 133] Operation: 85+48=133\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,2: 64:[27, 57, 64]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+57=84. \nResulting numbers: [64, 84].\nHeuristic score : (|64-64| + |84-64|)/2 = (0 + 20)/2 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 64:[64, 84] Operation: 27+57=84\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+64=121. \nResulting numbers: [27, 121].\nHeuristic score : (|27-64| + |121-64|)/2 = (37 + 57)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 64:[27, 121] Operation: 57+64=121\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+64=91. \nResulting numbers: [57, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|57-64| + |91-64|)/2 = (7 + 27)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 64:[57, 91] Operation: 27+64=91\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-27=30. \nResulting numbers: [64, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|64-64| + |30-64|)/2 = (0 + 34)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 64:[64, 30] Operation: 57-27=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-27=37. \nResulting numbers: [57, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|57-64| + |37-64|)/2 = (7 + 27)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 64:[57, 37] Operation: 64-27=37\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 18.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 64:[21, 57, 58]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+57=78. \nResulting numbers: [58, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|58-64| + |78-64|)/2 = (6 + 14)/2 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 64:[58, 78] Operation: 21+57=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-21=36. \nResulting numbers: [58, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|58-64| + |36-64|)/2 = (6 + 28)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 64:[58, 36] Operation: 57-21=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+58=115. \nResulting numbers: [21, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|21-64| + |115-64|)/2 = (43 + 51)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 64:[21, 115] Operation: 57+58=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+58=79. \nResulting numbers: [57, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|57-64| + |79-64|)/2 = (7 + 15)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 64:[57, 79] Operation: 21+58=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58-21=37. \nResulting numbers: [57, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|57-64| + |37-64|)/2 = (7 + 27)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 64:[57, 37] Operation: 58-21=37\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 64:[27, 85, 78]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+78=105. \nResulting numbers: [85, 105].\nHeuristic score : (|85-64| + |105-64|)/2 = (21 + 41)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 64:[85, 105] Operation: 27+78=105\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-27=51. \nResulting numbers: [85, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|85-64| + |51-64|)/2 = (21 + 13)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 64:[85, 51] Operation: 78-27=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+85=112. \nResulting numbers: [78, 112].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |112-64|)/2 = (14 + 48)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 64:[78, 112] Operation: 27+85=112\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-27=58. \nResulting numbers: [78, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|78-64| + |58-64|)/2 = (14 + 6)/2 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 64:[78, 58] Operation: 85-27=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-78=7. \nResulting numbers: [27, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|27-64| + |7-64|)/2 = (37 + 57)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 64:[27, 7] Operation: 85-78=7\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 64:[21, 85, 84]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84/21=4. \nResulting numbers: [85, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|85-64| + |4-64|)/2 = (21 + 60)/2 = 40.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 64:[85, 4] Operation: 84/21=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-21=64. \nResulting numbers: [84, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|84-64| + |64-64|)/2 = (20 + 0)/2 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 64:[84, 64] Operation: 85-21=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+85=106. \nResulting numbers: [84, 106].\nHeuristic score : (|84-64| + |106-64|)/2 = (20 + 42)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 64:[84, 106] Operation: 21+85=106\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+84=105. \nResulting numbers: [85, 105].\nHeuristic score : (|85-64| + |105-64|)/2 = (21 + 41)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 64:[85, 105] Operation: 21+84=105\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-21=63. \nResulting numbers: [85, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|85-64| + |63-64|)/2 = (21 + 1)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 64:[85, 63] Operation: 84-21=63\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 64:[64, 84]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '27+57=84'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64+84=148. \nResulting numbers: [148].\n148,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64*84=5376. \nResulting numbers: [5376].\n5376,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-64=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 64:[58, 78]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '21+57=78'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58+78=136. \nResulting numbers: [136].\n136,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-58=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58*78=4524. \nResulting numbers: [4524].\n4524,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 64:[84, 64]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '85-21=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-64=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84*64=5376. \nResulting numbers: [5376].\n5376,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84+64=148. \nResulting numbers: [148].\n148,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 64:[78, 58]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '85-27=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*58=4524. \nResulting numbers: [4524].\n4524,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78-58=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+58=136. \nResulting numbers: [136].\n136,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 64:[57, 79]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '21+58=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+79=136. \nResulting numbers: [136].\n136,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-57=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*79=4503. \nResulting numbers: [4503].\n4503,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 64:[85, 63]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '84-21=63'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-63=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*63=5355. \nResulting numbers: [5355].\n5355,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+63=148. \nResulting numbers: [148].\n148,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 64:[57, 91]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '27+64=91'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*91=5187. \nResulting numbers: [5187].\n5187,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-57=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+91=148. \nResulting numbers: [148].\n148,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 64:[57, 37]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '58-21=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+37=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*37=2109. \nResulting numbers: [2109].\n2109,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-37=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 64:[57, 37]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '85-48=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-37=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*37=2109. \nResulting numbers: [2109].\n2109,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+37=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 64:[58, 36]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '57-21=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58*36=2088. \nResulting numbers: [2088].\n2088,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58+36=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 58-36=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 64:[64, 30]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '57-27=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64*30=1920. \nResulting numbers: [1920].\n1920,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-30=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64+30=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 64:[57, 37]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '64-27=37'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-37=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+37=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*37=2109. \nResulting numbers: [2109].\n2109,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 64:[85, 51]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '78-27=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-51=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+51=136. \nResulting numbers: [136].\n136,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*51=4335. \nResulting numbers: [4335].\n4335,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 64:[48, 28]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '85-57=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-28=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48*28=1344. \nResulting numbers: [1344].\n1344,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48+28=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,0,3,2: 64:[94]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '85-48=37', '57+37=94'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,0,1,2: 64:[76]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '85-57=28', '48+28=76'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,3,1,1: 64:[94]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '57-21=36', '58+36=94'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,3,4,0: 64:[94]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '58-21=37', '57+37=94'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 64:[34]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '57-27=30', '64-30=34'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,2,4,1: 64:[94]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '64-27=37', '57+37=94'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,4,1,0: 64:[34]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '78-27=51', '85-51=34'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 64:[94]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '57-27=30', '64+30=94'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,2,2,1: 64:[34]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '27+64=91', '91-57=34'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 64:[85, 105]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '57+48=105'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 105-85=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*105=8925. \nResulting numbers: [8925].\n8925,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+105=190. \nResulting numbers: [190].\n190,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 64:[84, 106]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '21+85=106'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84+106=190. \nResulting numbers: [190].\n190,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 106-84=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84*106=8904. \nResulting numbers: [8904].\n8904,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 64:[78, 112]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '27+85=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78*112=8736. \nResulting numbers: [8736].\n8736,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112-78=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 78+112=190. \nResulting numbers: [190].\n190,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 64:[85, 105]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '27+78=105'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+105=190. \nResulting numbers: [190].\n190,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*105=8925. \nResulting numbers: [8925].\n8925,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 105-85=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 64:[85, 105]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '21+84=105'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+105=190. \nResulting numbers: [190].\n190,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*105=8925. \nResulting numbers: [8925].\n8925,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 105-85=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 38.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 64:[57, 133]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '85+48=133'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 133-57=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+133=190. \nResulting numbers: [190].\n190,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*133=7581. \nResulting numbers: [7581].\n7581,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 38.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 64:[85, 9]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '57-48=9'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+9=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*9=765. \nResulting numbers: [765].\n765,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-9=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,0,4,0: 64:[76]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '85+48=133', '133-57=76'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,0,0,2: 64:[76]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '57-48=9', '85-9=76'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,4,2,1: 64:[34]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '27+85=112', '112-78=34'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,0,0,0: 64:[94]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '57-48=9', '85+9=94'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 40.5\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 64:[85, 4]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '84/21=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-4=81. \nResulting numbers: [81].\n81,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*4=340. \nResulting numbers: [340].\n340,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+4=89. \nResulting numbers: [89].\n89,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 17\nCurrent State #0,1,0,0: 64:[81]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '84/21=4', '85-4=81'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 25\nCurrent State #0,1,0,2: 64:[89]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '84/21=4', '85+4=89'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 42\nCurrent State #0,1,4,0: 64:[22]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '84-21=63', '85-63=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 42\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 64:[22]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '21+58=79', '79-57=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 42\nCurrent State #0,3,1,2: 64:[22]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '57-21=36', '58-36=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 42\nCurrent State #0,1,2,1: 64:[22]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '21+85=106', '106-84=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,4,3,1: 64:[20]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '85-27=58', '78-58=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,1,1,0: 64:[20]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '85-21=64', '84-64=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,3,0,1: 64:[20]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '21+57=78', '78-58=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,0,1,0: 64:[20]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '85-57=28', '48-28=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,1,3,2: 64:[20]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '21+84=105', '105-85=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,4,0,2: 64:[20]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '27+78=105', '105-85=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,2,4,0: 64:[20]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '64-27=37', '57-37=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,2,0,2: 64:[20]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '27+57=84', '84-64=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,0,2,0: 64:[20]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '57+48=105', '105-85=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,0,3,0: 64:[20]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '85-48=37', '57-37=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,3,4,2: 64:[20]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '58-21=37', '57-37=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 64:[21, 115]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '57+58=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21*115=2415. \nResulting numbers: [2415].\n2415,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-21=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+115=136. \nResulting numbers: [136].\n136,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 64:[27, 7]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '85-78=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27-7=20. \nResulting numbers: [20].\n20,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+7=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27*7=189. \nResulting numbers: [189].\n189,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 64:[27, 121]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '57+64=121'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27*121=3267. \nResulting numbers: [3267].\n3267,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27+121=148. \nResulting numbers: [148].\n148,64 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 121-27=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,64 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,3,2,1: 64:[94]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '57+58=115', '115-21=94'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,4,4,1: 64:[34]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '85-78=7', '27+7=34'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 30\nCurrent State #0,2,1,2: 64:[94]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '57+64=121', '121-27=94'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,4,4,0: 64:[20]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '85-78=7', '27-7=20'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 72\nCurrent State #0,3,3,0: 64:[136]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '21+58=79', '57+79=136'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 72\nCurrent State #0,4,1,1: 64:[136]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '78-27=51', '85+51=136'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 72\nCurrent State #0,3,0,0: 64:[136]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '21+57=78', '58+78=136'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 72\nCurrent State #0,4,3,2: 64:[136]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '85-27=58', '78+58=136'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 72\nCurrent State #0,3,2,2: 64:[136]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '57+58=115', '21+115=136'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 84\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 64:[148]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '85-21=64', '84+64=148'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 84\nCurrent State #0,2,1,1: 64:[148]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '57+64=121', '27+121=148'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 84\nCurrent State #0,2,0,0: 64:[148]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '27+57=84', '64+84=148'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 84\nCurrent State #0,2,2,2: 64:[148]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '27+64=91', '57+91=148'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 84\nCurrent State #0,1,4,2: 64:[148]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '84-21=63', '85+63=148'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 125\nCurrent State #0,4,4,2: 64:[189]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '85-78=7', '27*7=189'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 126\nCurrent State #0,0,4,1: 64:[190]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '85+48=133', '57+133=190'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 126\nCurrent State #0,1,3,0: 64:[190]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '21+84=105', '85+105=190'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 126\nCurrent State #0,4,0,0: 64:[190]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '27+78=105', '85+105=190'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 126\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 64:[190]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '57+48=105', '85+105=190'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 126\nCurrent State #0,4,2,2: 64:[190]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '27+85=112', '78+112=190'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 126\nCurrent State #0,1,2,0: 64:[190]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '21+85=106', '84+106=190'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 276\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 64:[340]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '84/21=4', '85*4=340'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 701\nCurrent State #0,0,0,1: 64:[765]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '57-48=9', '85*9=765'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 1280\nCurrent State #0,0,1,1: 64:[1344]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '85-57=28', '48*28=1344'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 1856\nCurrent State #0,2,3,0: 64:[1920]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '57-27=30', '64*30=1920'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 2024\nCurrent State #0,3,1,0: 64:[2088]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '57-21=36', '58*36=2088'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 2045\nCurrent State #0,2,4,2: 64:[2109]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '64-27=37', '57*37=2109'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 2045\nCurrent State #0,0,3,1: 64:[2109]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '85-48=37', '57*37=2109'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 2045\nCurrent State #0,3,4,1: 64:[2109]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '58-21=37', '57*37=2109'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 2351\nCurrent State #0,3,2,0: 64:[2415]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '57+58=115', '21*115=2415'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 3203\nCurrent State #0,2,1,0: 64:[3267]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '57+64=121', '27*121=3267'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 4271\nCurrent State #0,4,1,2: 64:[4335]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '78-27=51', '85*51=4335'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 4439\nCurrent State #0,3,3,2: 64:[4503]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '21+58=79', '57*79=4503'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 4460\nCurrent State #0,3,0,2: 64:[4524]. Operations so far : ['85-27=58', '21+57=78', '58*78=4524'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 4460\nCurrent State #0,4,3,0: 64:[4524]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '85-27=58', '78*58=4524'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 5123\nCurrent State #0,2,2,0: 64:[5187]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '27+64=91', '57*91=5187'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 5291\nCurrent State #0,1,4,1: 64:[5355]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '84-21=63', '85*63=5355'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 5312\nCurrent State #0,2,0,1: 64:[5376]. Operations so far : ['85-21=64', '27+57=84', '64*84=5376'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 5312\nCurrent State #0,1,1,1: 64:[5376]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '85-21=64', '84*64=5376'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 7517\nCurrent State #0,0,4,2: 64:[7581]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '85+48=133', '57*133=7581'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 8672\nCurrent State #0,4,2,0: 64:[8736]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '27+85=112', '78*112=8736'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 8840\nCurrent State #0,1,2,2: 64:[8904]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '21+85=106', '84*106=8904'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 8861\nCurrent State #0,0,2,1: 64:[8925]. Operations so far : ['27+21=48', '57+48=105', '85*105=8925'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 8861\nCurrent State #0,1,3,1: 64:[8925]. Operations so far : ['27+57=84', '21+84=105', '85*105=8925'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 8861\nCurrent State #0,4,0,1: 64:[8925]. Operations so far : ['21+57=78', '27+78=105', '85*105=8925'].\n\n```\nSOLUTION: NO\nOPERATIONS: []\nRESULT: None\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 15,875 |
[
62,
25,
75,
63
]
| 99 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [62, 25, 75, 63] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 99. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [62, 25, 75, 63]. Our goal is to produce 99. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 99:[62, 25, 75, 63]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+25=87. \nResulting numbers: [75, 63, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|75-99| + |63-99| + |87-99|)/3 = (24 + 36 + 12)/3 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 99:[75, 63, 87] Operation: 62+25=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+63=138. \nResulting numbers: [87, 138].\nHeuristic score : (|87-99| + |138-99|)/2 = (12 + 39)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 99:[87, 138] Operation: 75+63=138\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 138-87=51. \nResulting numbers: [51].\n51,99 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 99:[75, 63, 87]. Operations so far : ['62+25=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+87=150. \nResulting numbers: [75, 150].\nHeuristic score : (|75-99| + |150-99|)/2 = (24 + 51)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 99:[75, 150] Operation: 63+87=150\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 150-75=75. \nResulting numbers: [75].\n75,99 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 99:[75, 63, 87]. Operations so far : ['62+25=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75-63=12. \nResulting numbers: [87, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|87-99| + |12-99|)/2 = (12 + 87)/2 = 49.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 99:[87, 12] Operation: 75-63=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87+12=99. \nResulting numbers: [99].\n99,99 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['62+25=87', '75-63=12', '87+12=99']\nRESULT: 99\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 862 |
[
83,
45,
80,
20
]
| 34 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [83, 45, 80, 20] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 34. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [83, 45, 80, 20]. Our goal is to produce 34. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 34:[83, 45, 80, 20]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-45=35. \nResulting numbers: [83, 20, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|83-34| + |20-34| + |35-34|)/3 = (49 + 14 + 1)/3 = 21.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 34:[83, 20, 35] Operation: 80-45=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-20=63. \nResulting numbers: [45, 80, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|45-34| + |80-34| + |63-34|)/3 = (11 + 46 + 29)/3 = 28.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 34:[45, 80, 63] Operation: 83-20=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-20=60. \nResulting numbers: [83, 45, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|83-34| + |45-34| + |60-34|)/3 = (49 + 11 + 26)/3 = 28.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 34:[83, 45, 60] Operation: 80-20=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-45=38. \nResulting numbers: [80, 20, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|80-34| + |20-34| + |38-34|)/3 = (46 + 14 + 4)/3 = 21.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 34:[80, 20, 38] Operation: 83-45=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-80=3. \nResulting numbers: [45, 20, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|45-34| + |20-34| + |3-34|)/3 = (11 + 14 + 31)/3 = 18.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 34:[45, 20, 3] Operation: 83-80=3\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 18.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 34:[45, 20, 3]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45/3=15. \nResulting numbers: [20, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|20-34| + |15-34|)/2 = (14 + 19)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 34:[20, 15] Operation: 45/3=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20-3=17. \nResulting numbers: [45, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|45-34| + |17-34|)/2 = (11 + 17)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 34:[45, 17] Operation: 20-3=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-3=42. \nResulting numbers: [20, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|20-34| + |42-34|)/2 = (14 + 8)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 34:[20, 42] Operation: 45-3=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+3=23. \nResulting numbers: [45, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|45-34| + |23-34|)/2 = (11 + 11)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 34:[45, 23] Operation: 20+3=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+3=48. \nResulting numbers: [20, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|20-34| + |48-34|)/2 = (14 + 14)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 34:[20, 48] Operation: 45+3=48\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 34:[80, 20, 38]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+20=100. \nResulting numbers: [38, 100].\nHeuristic score : (|38-34| + |100-34|)/2 = (4 + 66)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 34:[38, 100] Operation: 80+20=100\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-20=60. \nResulting numbers: [38, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|38-34| + |60-34|)/2 = (4 + 26)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 34:[38, 60] Operation: 80-20=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80/20=4. \nResulting numbers: [38, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|38-34| + |4-34|)/2 = (4 + 30)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 34:[38, 4] Operation: 80/20=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-38=42. \nResulting numbers: [20, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|20-34| + |42-34|)/2 = (14 + 8)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 34:[20, 42] Operation: 80-38=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-20=18. \nResulting numbers: [80, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|80-34| + |18-34|)/2 = (46 + 16)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 34:[80, 18] Operation: 38-20=18\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 34:[83, 20, 35]. Operations so far : ['80-45=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+35=55. \nResulting numbers: [83, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|83-34| + |55-34|)/2 = (49 + 21)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 34:[83, 55] Operation: 20+35=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-20=15. \nResulting numbers: [83, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|83-34| + |15-34|)/2 = (49 + 19)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 34:[83, 15] Operation: 35-20=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-35=48. \nResulting numbers: [20, 48].\nHeuristic score : (|20-34| + |48-34|)/2 = (14 + 14)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 34:[20, 48] Operation: 83-35=48\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+20=103. \nResulting numbers: [35, 103].\nHeuristic score : (|35-34| + |103-34|)/2 = (1 + 69)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 34:[35, 103] Operation: 83+20=103\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-20=63. \nResulting numbers: [35, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|35-34| + |63-34|)/2 = (1 + 29)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 34:[35, 63] Operation: 83-20=63\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 34:[45, 80, 63]. Operations so far : ['83-20=63'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-63=17. \nResulting numbers: [45, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|45-34| + |17-34|)/2 = (11 + 17)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 34:[45, 17] Operation: 80-63=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-45=35. \nResulting numbers: [63, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|63-34| + |35-34|)/2 = (29 + 1)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 34:[63, 35] Operation: 80-45=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+80=125. \nResulting numbers: [63, 125].\nHeuristic score : (|63-34| + |125-34|)/2 = (29 + 91)/2 = 60.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 34:[63, 125] Operation: 45+80=125\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-45=18. \nResulting numbers: [80, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|80-34| + |18-34|)/2 = (46 + 16)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 34:[80, 18] Operation: 63-45=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+63=108. \nResulting numbers: [80, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|80-34| + |108-34|)/2 = (46 + 74)/2 = 60.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 34:[80, 108] Operation: 45+63=108\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 28.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 34:[83, 45, 60]. Operations so far : ['80-20=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-45=38. \nResulting numbers: [60, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|60-34| + |38-34|)/2 = (26 + 4)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 34:[60, 38] Operation: 83-45=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-45=15. \nResulting numbers: [83, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|83-34| + |15-34|)/2 = (49 + 19)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 34:[83, 15] Operation: 60-45=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+45=128. \nResulting numbers: [60, 128].\nHeuristic score : (|60-34| + |128-34|)/2 = (26 + 94)/2 = 60.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 34:[60, 128] Operation: 83+45=128\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-60=23. \nResulting numbers: [45, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|45-34| + |23-34|)/2 = (11 + 11)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 34:[45, 23] Operation: 83-60=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+60=143. \nResulting numbers: [45, 143].\nHeuristic score : (|45-34| + |143-34|)/2 = (11 + 109)/2 = 60.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 34:[45, 143] Operation: 83+60=143\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 34:[20, 42]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '45-3=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20*42=840. \nResulting numbers: [840].\n840,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-20=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+42=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 34:[20, 42]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38', '80-38=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+42=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-20=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20*42=840. \nResulting numbers: [840].\n840,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 34:[45, 23]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '20+3=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+23=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-23=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45*23=1035. \nResulting numbers: [1035].\n1035,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 34:[45, 23]. Operations so far : ['80-20=60', '83-60=23'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45*23=1035. \nResulting numbers: [1035].\n1035,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+23=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-23=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 34:[45, 17]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '20-3=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-17=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+17=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45*17=765. \nResulting numbers: [765].\n765,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 6\nCurrent State #0,4,1,0: 34:[28]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '20-3=17', '45-17=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 34:[22]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38', '80-38=42', '42-20=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 34:[22]. Operations so far : ['80-20=60', '83-60=23', '45-23=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,4,3,1: 34:[22]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '20+3=23', '45-23=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,4,2,1: 34:[22]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '45-3=42', '42-20=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 34:[20, 48]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '45+3=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+48=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20*48=960. \nResulting numbers: [960].\n960,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-20=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 34:[20, 48]. Operations so far : ['80-45=35', '83-35=48'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20*48=960. \nResulting numbers: [960].\n960,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+48=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 48-20=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 14.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 34:[45, 17]. Operations so far : ['83-20=63', '80-63=17'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45*17=765. \nResulting numbers: [765].\n765,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-17=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+17=62. \nResulting numbers: [62].\n62,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 34:[38, 60]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38', '80-20=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38*60=2280. \nResulting numbers: [2280].\n2280,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-38=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+60=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 34:[35, 63]. Operations so far : ['80-45=35', '83-20=63'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*63=2205. \nResulting numbers: [2205].\n2205,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-35=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+63=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 6\nCurrent State #0,4,4,2: 34:[28]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '45+3=48', '48-20=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 6\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 34:[28]. Operations so far : ['80-45=35', '83-35=48', '48-20=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 6\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 34:[28]. Operations so far : ['83-20=63', '80-63=17', '45-17=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 6\nCurrent State #0,0,4,1: 34:[28]. Operations so far : ['80-45=35', '83-20=63', '63-35=28'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 12\nCurrent State #0,3,1,1: 34:[22]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38', '80-20=60', '60-38=22'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 34:[60, 38]. Operations so far : ['80-20=60', '83-45=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+38=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*38=2280. \nResulting numbers: [2280].\n2280,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-38=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 15.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 34:[63, 35]. Operations so far : ['83-20=63', '80-45=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-35=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63*35=2205. \nResulting numbers: [2205].\n2205,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+35=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.5\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 34:[20, 15]. Operations so far : ['83-80=3', '45/3=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20-15=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20+15=35. \nResulting numbers: [35].\n35,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 20*15=300. \nResulting numbers: [300].\n300,34 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 17.0\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 34:[38, 4]. Operations so far : ['83-45=38', '80/20=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+4=42. \nResulting numbers: [42].\n42,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38*4=152. \nResulting numbers: [152].\n152,34 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-4=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,34 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['83-45=38', '80/20=4', '38-4=34']\nRESULT: 34\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,778 |
[
34,
93,
15,
58
]
| 15 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [34, 93, 15, 58] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 15. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [34, 93, 15, 58]. Our goal is to produce 15. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 15:[34, 93, 15, 58]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-58=35. \nResulting numbers: [34, 15, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|34-15| + |15-15| + |35-15|)/3 = (19 + 0 + 20)/3 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 15:[34, 15, 35] Operation: 93-58=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-34=1. \nResulting numbers: [15, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|15-15| + |1-15|)/2 = (0 + 14)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 15:[15, 1] Operation: 35-34=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 15*1=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,15 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['93-58=35', '35-34=1', '15*1=15']\nRESULT: 15\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 428 |
[
46,
63,
71,
33
]
| 71 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [46, 63, 71, 33] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 71. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [46, 63, 71, 33]. Our goal is to produce 71. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 71:[46, 63, 71, 33]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+33=96. \nResulting numbers: [46, 71, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|46-71| + |71-71| + |96-71|)/3 = (25 + 0 + 25)/3 = 16.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 71:[46, 71, 96] Operation: 63+33=96\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-33=30. \nResulting numbers: [46, 71, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|46-71| + |71-71| + |30-71|)/3 = (25 + 0 + 41)/3 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 71:[46, 71, 30] Operation: 63-33=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+33=104. \nResulting numbers: [46, 63, 104].\nHeuristic score : (|46-71| + |63-71| + |104-71|)/3 = (25 + 8 + 33)/3 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 71:[46, 63, 104] Operation: 71+33=104\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46-33=13. \nResulting numbers: [63, 71, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|63-71| + |71-71| + |13-71|)/3 = (8 + 0 + 58)/3 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 71:[63, 71, 13] Operation: 46-33=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+33=79. \nResulting numbers: [63, 71, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|63-71| + |71-71| + |79-71|)/3 = (8 + 0 + 8)/3 = 5.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 71:[63, 71, 79] Operation: 46+33=79\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 5.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,4: 71:[63, 71, 79]. Operations so far : ['46+33=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+71=134. \nResulting numbers: [79, 134].\nHeuristic score : (|79-71| + |134-71|)/2 = (8 + 63)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 71:[79, 134] Operation: 63+71=134\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+79=142. \nResulting numbers: [71, 142].\nHeuristic score : (|71-71| + |142-71|)/2 = (0 + 71)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 71:[71, 142] Operation: 63+79=142\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-63=16. \nResulting numbers: [71, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|71-71| + |16-71|)/2 = (0 + 55)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 71:[71, 16] Operation: 79-63=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-71=8. \nResulting numbers: [63, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|63-71| + |8-71|)/2 = (8 + 63)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 71:[63, 8] Operation: 79-71=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-63=8. \nResulting numbers: [79, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|79-71| + |8-71|)/2 = (8 + 63)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 71:[79, 8] Operation: 71-63=8\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 71:[46, 71, 96]. Operations so far : ['63+33=96'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-46=25. \nResulting numbers: [96, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|96-71| + |25-71|)/2 = (25 + 46)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 71:[96, 25] Operation: 71-46=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+96=142. \nResulting numbers: [71, 142].\nHeuristic score : (|71-71| + |142-71|)/2 = (0 + 71)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 71:[71, 142] Operation: 46+96=142\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-46=50. \nResulting numbers: [71, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|71-71| + |50-71|)/2 = (0 + 21)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 71:[71, 50] Operation: 96-46=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-71=25. \nResulting numbers: [46, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|46-71| + |25-71|)/2 = (25 + 46)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 71:[46, 25] Operation: 96-71=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+71=117. \nResulting numbers: [96, 117].\nHeuristic score : (|96-71| + |117-71|)/2 = (25 + 46)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 71:[96, 117] Operation: 46+71=117\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 71:[46, 71, 30]. Operations so far : ['63-33=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46-30=16. \nResulting numbers: [71, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|71-71| + |16-71|)/2 = (0 + 55)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 71:[71, 16] Operation: 46-30=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+71=117. \nResulting numbers: [30, 117].\nHeuristic score : (|30-71| + |117-71|)/2 = (41 + 46)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 71:[30, 117] Operation: 46+71=117\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+30=101. \nResulting numbers: [46, 101].\nHeuristic score : (|46-71| + |101-71|)/2 = (25 + 30)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 71:[46, 101] Operation: 71+30=101\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-30=41. \nResulting numbers: [46, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|46-71| + |41-71|)/2 = (25 + 30)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 71:[46, 41] Operation: 71-30=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+30=76. \nResulting numbers: [71, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|71-71| + |76-71|)/2 = (0 + 5)/2 = 2.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 71:[71, 76] Operation: 46+30=76\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 71:[46, 63, 104]. Operations so far : ['71+33=104'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104-46=58. \nResulting numbers: [63, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|63-71| + |58-71|)/2 = (8 + 13)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 71:[63, 58] Operation: 104-46=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+63=109. \nResulting numbers: [104, 109].\nHeuristic score : (|104-71| + |109-71|)/2 = (33 + 38)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 71:[104, 109] Operation: 46+63=109\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-46=17. \nResulting numbers: [104, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|104-71| + |17-71|)/2 = (33 + 54)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 71:[104, 17] Operation: 63-46=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104-63=41. \nResulting numbers: [46, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|46-71| + |41-71|)/2 = (25 + 30)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 71:[46, 41] Operation: 104-63=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+104=150. \nResulting numbers: [63, 150].\nHeuristic score : (|63-71| + |150-71|)/2 = (8 + 79)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 71:[63, 150] Operation: 46+104=150\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 71:[63, 71, 13]. Operations so far : ['46-33=13'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-13=58. \nResulting numbers: [63, 58].\nHeuristic score : (|63-71| + |58-71|)/2 = (8 + 13)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 71:[63, 58] Operation: 71-13=58\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-13=50. \nResulting numbers: [71, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|71-71| + |50-71|)/2 = (0 + 21)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 71:[71, 50] Operation: 63-13=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+71=134. \nResulting numbers: [13, 134].\nHeuristic score : (|13-71| + |134-71|)/2 = (58 + 63)/2 = 60.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 71:[13, 134] Operation: 63+71=134\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+13=76. \nResulting numbers: [71, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|71-71| + |76-71|)/2 = (0 + 5)/2 = 2.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 71:[71, 76] Operation: 63+13=76\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+13=84. \nResulting numbers: [63, 84].\nHeuristic score : (|63-71| + |84-71|)/2 = (8 + 13)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 71:[63, 84] Operation: 71+13=84\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 2.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 71:[71, 76]. Operations so far : ['63-33=30', '46+30=76'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+76=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-71=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71*76=5396. \nResulting numbers: [5396].\n5396,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 2.5\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 71:[71, 76]. Operations so far : ['46-33=13', '63+13=76'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-71=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+76=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71*76=5396. \nResulting numbers: [5396].\n5396,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 71:[63, 84]. Operations so far : ['46-33=13', '71+13=84'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-63=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+84=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63*84=5292. \nResulting numbers: [5292].\n5292,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 71:[71, 50]. Operations so far : ['63+33=96', '96-46=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71*50=3550. \nResulting numbers: [3550].\n3550,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-50=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+50=121. \nResulting numbers: [121].\n121,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 71:[63, 58]. Operations so far : ['46-33=13', '71-13=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-58=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+58=121. \nResulting numbers: [121].\n121,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63*58=3654. \nResulting numbers: [3654].\n3654,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 71:[71, 50]. Operations so far : ['46-33=13', '63-13=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71*50=3550. \nResulting numbers: [3550].\n3550,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+50=121. \nResulting numbers: [121].\n121,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-50=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 71:[63, 58]. Operations so far : ['71+33=104', '104-46=58'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63+58=121. \nResulting numbers: [121].\n121,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63*58=3654. \nResulting numbers: [3654].\n3654,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-58=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.5\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 71:[46, 41]. Operations so far : ['63-33=30', '71-30=41'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+41=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46-41=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46*41=1886. \nResulting numbers: [1886].\n1886,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.5\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 71:[71, 16]. Operations so far : ['46+33=79', '79-63=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+16=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-16=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71*16=1136. \nResulting numbers: [1136].\n1136,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 27.5\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 71:[46, 101]. Operations so far : ['63-33=30', '71+30=101'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+101=147. \nResulting numbers: [147].\n147,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46*101=4646. \nResulting numbers: [4646].\n4646,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-46=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,1,3,0: 71:[87]. Operations so far : ['63-33=30', '71-30=41', '46+41=87'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,4,2,0: 71:[87]. Operations so far : ['46+33=79', '79-63=16', '71+16=87'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,4,2,1: 71:[55]. Operations so far : ['46+33=79', '79-63=16', '71-16=55'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,1,2,2: 71:[55]. Operations so far : ['63-33=30', '71+30=101', '101-46=55'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 27.5\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 71:[71, 16]. Operations so far : ['63-33=30', '46-30=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-16=55. \nResulting numbers: [55].\n55,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+16=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71*16=1136. \nResulting numbers: [1136].\n1136,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,1,0,0: 71:[55]. Operations so far : ['63-33=30', '46-30=16', '71-16=55'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 71:[87]. Operations so far : ['63-33=30', '46-30=16', '71+16=87'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 27.5\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 71:[46, 41]. Operations so far : ['71+33=104', '104-63=41'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46*41=1886. \nResulting numbers: [1886].\n1886,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46+41=87. \nResulting numbers: [87].\n87,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46-41=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,71 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 35.5\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 71:[96, 25]. Operations so far : ['63+33=96', '71-46=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96*25=2400. \nResulting numbers: [2400].\n2400,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96+25=121. \nResulting numbers: [121].\n121,71 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-25=71. \nResulting numbers: [71].\n71,71 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['63+33=96', '71-46=25', '96-25=71']\nRESULT: 71\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,218 |
[
30,
60,
33,
13
]
| 22 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [30, 60, 33, 13] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 22. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [30, 60, 33, 13]. Our goal is to produce 22. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 22:[30, 60, 33, 13]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-33=27. \nResulting numbers: [30, 13, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|30-22| + |13-22| + |27-22|)/3 = (8 + 9 + 5)/3 = 7.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 22:[30, 13, 27] Operation: 60-33=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-13=17. \nResulting numbers: [27, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|27-22| + |17-22|)/2 = (5 + 5)/2 = 5.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 22:[27, 17] Operation: 30-13=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27-17=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[30, 13, 27]. Operations so far : ['60-33=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27-13=14. \nResulting numbers: [30, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|30-22| + |14-22|)/2 = (8 + 8)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 22:[30, 14] Operation: 27-13=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-14=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[30, 13, 27]. Operations so far : ['60-33=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+13=43. \nResulting numbers: [27, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|27-22| + |43-22|)/2 = (5 + 21)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 22:[27, 43] Operation: 30+13=43\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-27=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[30, 13, 27]. Operations so far : ['60-33=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13+27=40. \nResulting numbers: [30, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|30-22| + |40-22|)/2 = (8 + 18)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 22:[30, 40] Operation: 13+27=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-30=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[30, 13, 27]. Operations so far : ['60-33=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-27=3. \nResulting numbers: [13, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|13-22| + |3-22|)/2 = (9 + 19)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 22:[13, 3] Operation: 30-27=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13+3=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[30, 13, 27]. Operations so far : ['60-33=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+27=57. \nResulting numbers: [13, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|13-22| + |57-22|)/2 = (9 + 35)/2 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 22:[13, 57] Operation: 30+27=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-13=44. \nResulting numbers: [44].\n44,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[30, 13, 27]. Operations so far : ['60-33=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13*27=351. \nResulting numbers: [30, 351].\nHeuristic score : (|30-22| + |351-22|)/2 = (8 + 329)/2 = 168.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 22:[30, 351] Operation: 13*27=351\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 351-30=321. \nResulting numbers: [321].\n321,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[30, 13, 27]. Operations so far : ['60-33=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*13=390. \nResulting numbers: [27, 390].\nHeuristic score : (|27-22| + |390-22|)/2 = (5 + 368)/2 = 186.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 22:[27, 390] Operation: 30*13=390\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 390-27=363. \nResulting numbers: [363].\n363,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,0: 22:[30, 13, 27]. Operations so far : ['60-33=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30*27=810. \nResulting numbers: [13, 810].\nHeuristic score : (|13-22| + |810-22|)/2 = (9 + 788)/2 = 398.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 22:[13, 810] Operation: 30*27=810\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 810-13=797. \nResulting numbers: [797].\n797,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 16.5\nCurrent State #0: 22:[30, 60, 33, 13]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-30=30. \nResulting numbers: [33, 13, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|33-22| + |13-22| + |30-22|)/3 = (11 + 9 + 8)/3 = 9.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 22:[33, 13, 30] Operation: 60-30=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-13=20. \nResulting numbers: [30, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|30-22| + |20-22|)/2 = (8 + 2)/2 = 5.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 22:[30, 20] Operation: 33-13=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-20=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[33, 13, 30]. Operations so far : ['60-30=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-13=17. \nResulting numbers: [33, 17].\nHeuristic score : (|33-22| + |17-22|)/2 = (11 + 5)/2 = 8.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 22:[33, 17] Operation: 30-13=17\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-17=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[33, 13, 30]. Operations so far : ['60-30=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-30=3. \nResulting numbers: [13, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|13-22| + |3-22|)/2 = (9 + 19)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 22:[13, 3] Operation: 33-30=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13+3=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[33, 13, 30]. Operations so far : ['60-30=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+13=46. \nResulting numbers: [30, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|30-22| + |46-22|)/2 = (8 + 24)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 22:[30, 46] Operation: 33+13=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 46-30=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[33, 13, 30]. Operations so far : ['60-30=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13+30=43. \nResulting numbers: [33, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|33-22| + |43-22|)/2 = (11 + 21)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 22:[33, 43] Operation: 13+30=43\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 43-33=10. \nResulting numbers: [10].\n10,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[33, 13, 30]. Operations so far : ['60-30=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+30=63. \nResulting numbers: [13, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|13-22| + |63-22|)/2 = (9 + 41)/2 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 22:[13, 63] Operation: 33+30=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-13=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[33, 13, 30]. Operations so far : ['60-30=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13*30=390. \nResulting numbers: [33, 390].\nHeuristic score : (|33-22| + |390-22|)/2 = (11 + 368)/2 = 189.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 22:[33, 390] Operation: 13*30=390\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 390-33=357. \nResulting numbers: [357].\n357,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[33, 13, 30]. Operations so far : ['60-30=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33*13=429. \nResulting numbers: [30, 429].\nHeuristic score : (|30-22| + |429-22|)/2 = (8 + 407)/2 = 207.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 22:[30, 429] Operation: 33*13=429\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 429-30=399. \nResulting numbers: [399].\n399,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 9.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 22:[33, 13, 30]. Operations so far : ['60-30=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33*30=990. \nResulting numbers: [13, 990].\nHeuristic score : (|13-22| + |990-22|)/2 = (9 + 968)/2 = 488.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 22:[13, 990] Operation: 33*30=990\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 990-13=977. \nResulting numbers: [977].\n977,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 16.5\nCurrent State #0: 22:[30, 60, 33, 13]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/30=2. \nResulting numbers: [33, 13, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|33-22| + |13-22| + |2-22|)/3 = (11 + 9 + 20)/3 = 13.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 22:[33, 13, 2] Operation: 60/30=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13*2=26. \nResulting numbers: [33, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|33-22| + |26-22|)/2 = (11 + 4)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 22:[33, 26] Operation: 13*2=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-26=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 13.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 22:[33, 13, 2]. Operations so far : ['60/30=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-2=31. \nResulting numbers: [13, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|13-22| + |31-22|)/2 = (9 + 9)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 22:[13, 31] Operation: 33-2=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 31-13=18. \nResulting numbers: [18].\n18,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 13.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 22:[33, 13, 2]. Operations so far : ['60/30=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13+2=15. \nResulting numbers: [33, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|33-22| + |15-22|)/2 = (11 + 7)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 22:[33, 15] Operation: 13+2=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-15=18. \nResulting numbers: [18].\n18,22 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 13.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,2: 22:[33, 13, 2]. Operations so far : ['60/30=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-13=20. \nResulting numbers: [2, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|2-22| + |20-22|)/2 = (20 + 2)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 22:[2, 20] Operation: 33-13=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2+20=22. \nResulting numbers: [22].\n22,22 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['60/30=2', '33-13=20', '2+20=22']\nRESULT: 22\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 5,271 |
[
68,
89,
6,
87
]
| 37 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [68, 89, 6, 87] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 37. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [68, 89, 6, 87]. Our goal is to produce 37. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 37:[68, 89, 6, 87]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-68=21. \nResulting numbers: [6, 87, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|6-37| + |87-37| + |21-37|)/3 = (31 + 50 + 16)/3 = 32.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 37:[6, 87, 21] Operation: 89-68=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-6=81. \nResulting numbers: [21, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|21-37| + |81-37|)/2 = (16 + 44)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 37:[21, 81] Operation: 87-6=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-21=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 37:[6, 87, 21]. Operations so far : ['89-68=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+21=27. \nResulting numbers: [87, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|87-37| + |27-37|)/2 = (50 + 10)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 37:[87, 27] Operation: 6+21=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-27=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 37:[6, 87, 21]. Operations so far : ['89-68=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-21=66. \nResulting numbers: [6, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|6-37| + |66-37|)/2 = (31 + 29)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 37:[6, 66] Operation: 87-21=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-6=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 37:[6, 87, 21]. Operations so far : ['89-68=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+87=93. \nResulting numbers: [21, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|21-37| + |93-37|)/2 = (16 + 56)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 37:[21, 93] Operation: 6+87=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-21=72. \nResulting numbers: [72].\n72,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 37:[6, 87, 21]. Operations so far : ['89-68=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21-6=15. \nResulting numbers: [87, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|87-37| + |15-37|)/2 = (50 + 22)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 37:[87, 15] Operation: 21-6=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-15=72. \nResulting numbers: [72].\n72,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 37:[6, 87, 21]. Operations so far : ['89-68=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87+21=108. \nResulting numbers: [6, 108].\nHeuristic score : (|6-37| + |108-37|)/2 = (31 + 71)/2 = 51.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 37:[6, 108] Operation: 87+21=108\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 108/6=18. \nResulting numbers: [18].\n18,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 37:[6, 87, 21]. Operations so far : ['89-68=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6*21=126. \nResulting numbers: [87, 126].\nHeuristic score : (|87-37| + |126-37|)/2 = (50 + 89)/2 = 69.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 37:[87, 126] Operation: 6*21=126\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 126-87=39. \nResulting numbers: [39].\n39,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 37:[6, 87, 21]. Operations so far : ['89-68=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6*87=522. \nResulting numbers: [21, 522].\nHeuristic score : (|21-37| + |522-37|)/2 = (16 + 485)/2 = 250.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 37:[21, 522] Operation: 6*87=522\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 522-21=501. \nResulting numbers: [501].\n501,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 37:[6, 87, 21]. Operations so far : ['89-68=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87*21=1827. \nResulting numbers: [6, 1827].\nHeuristic score : (|6-37| + |1827-37|)/2 = (31 + 1790)/2 = 910.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 37:[6, 1827] Operation: 87*21=1827\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1827-6=1821. \nResulting numbers: [1821].\n1821,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 41.0\nCurrent State #0: 37:[68, 89, 6, 87]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-87=2. \nResulting numbers: [68, 6, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|68-37| + |6-37| + |2-37|)/3 = (31 + 31 + 35)/3 = 32.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 37:[68, 6, 2] Operation: 89-87=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68/2=34. \nResulting numbers: [6, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|6-37| + |34-37|)/2 = (31 + 3)/2 = 17.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 37:[6, 34] Operation: 68/2=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+34=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 37:[68, 6, 2]. Operations so far : ['89-87=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6*2=12. \nResulting numbers: [68, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|68-37| + |12-37|)/2 = (31 + 25)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 37:[68, 12] Operation: 6*2=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-12=56. \nResulting numbers: [56].\n56,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 37:[68, 6, 2]. Operations so far : ['89-87=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-6=62. \nResulting numbers: [2, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|2-37| + |62-37|)/2 = (35 + 25)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 37:[2, 62] Operation: 68-6=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62/2=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 37:[68, 6, 2]. Operations so far : ['89-87=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-2=66. \nResulting numbers: [6, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|6-37| + |66-37|)/2 = (31 + 29)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 37:[6, 66] Operation: 68-2=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-6=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 37:[68, 6, 2]. Operations so far : ['89-87=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6+2=8. \nResulting numbers: [68, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|68-37| + |8-37|)/2 = (31 + 29)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 37:[68, 8] Operation: 6+2=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-8=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 37:[68, 6, 2]. Operations so far : ['89-87=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+2=70. \nResulting numbers: [6, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|6-37| + |70-37|)/2 = (31 + 33)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 37:[6, 70] Operation: 68+2=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-6=64. \nResulting numbers: [64].\n64,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 37:[68, 6, 2]. Operations so far : ['89-87=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6-2=4. \nResulting numbers: [68, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|68-37| + |4-37|)/2 = (31 + 33)/2 = 32.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 37:[68, 4] Operation: 6-2=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68/4=17. \nResulting numbers: [17].\n17,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 37:[68, 6, 2]. Operations so far : ['89-87=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 6/2=3. \nResulting numbers: [68, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|68-37| + |3-37|)/2 = (31 + 34)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 37:[68, 3] Operation: 6/2=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68-3=65. \nResulting numbers: [65].\n65,37 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 32.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 37:[68, 6, 2]. Operations so far : ['89-87=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 68+6=74. \nResulting numbers: [2, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|2-37| + |74-37|)/2 = (35 + 37)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 37:[2, 74] Operation: 68+6=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74/2=37. \nResulting numbers: [37].\n37,37 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['89-87=2', '68+6=74', '74/2=37']\nRESULT: 37\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 4,296 |
[
72,
88,
86,
10
]
| 31 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [72, 88, 86, 10] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 31. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [72, 88, 86, 10]. Our goal is to produce 31. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 31:[72, 88, 86, 10]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-72=16. \nResulting numbers: [86, 10, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|86-31| + |10-31| + |16-31|)/3 = (55 + 21 + 15)/3 = 30.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 31:[86, 10, 16] Operation: 88-72=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86-10=76. \nResulting numbers: [16, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|16-31| + |76-31|)/2 = (15 + 45)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 31:[16, 76] Operation: 86-10=76\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 76-16=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,31 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 31:[86, 10, 16]. Operations so far : ['88-72=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86-16=70. \nResulting numbers: [10, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|10-31| + |70-31|)/2 = (21 + 39)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 31:[10, 70] Operation: 86-16=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70/10=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,31 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 31:[86, 10, 16]. Operations so far : ['88-72=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 10+16=26. \nResulting numbers: [86, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|86-31| + |26-31|)/2 = (55 + 5)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 31:[86, 26] Operation: 10+16=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86-26=60. \nResulting numbers: [60].\n60,31 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 31:[86, 10, 16]. Operations so far : ['88-72=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86+10=96. \nResulting numbers: [16, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|16-31| + |96-31|)/2 = (15 + 65)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 31:[16, 96] Operation: 86+10=96\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96/16=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,31 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 31:[86, 10, 16]. Operations so far : ['88-72=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16-10=6. \nResulting numbers: [86, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|86-31| + |6-31|)/2 = (55 + 25)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 31:[86, 6] Operation: 16-10=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86-6=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,31 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 31:[86, 10, 16]. Operations so far : ['88-72=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86+16=102. \nResulting numbers: [10, 102].\nHeuristic score : (|10-31| + |102-31|)/2 = (21 + 71)/2 = 46.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 31:[10, 102] Operation: 86+16=102\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 102-10=92. \nResulting numbers: [92].\n92,31 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 31:[86, 10, 16]. Operations so far : ['88-72=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 10*16=160. \nResulting numbers: [86, 160].\nHeuristic score : (|86-31| + |160-31|)/2 = (55 + 129)/2 = 92.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 31:[86, 160] Operation: 10*16=160\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 160-86=74. \nResulting numbers: [74].\n74,31 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 31:[86, 10, 16]. Operations so far : ['88-72=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86*10=860. \nResulting numbers: [16, 860].\nHeuristic score : (|16-31| + |860-31|)/2 = (15 + 829)/2 = 422.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 31:[16, 860] Operation: 86*10=860\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 860-16=844. \nResulting numbers: [844].\n844,31 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 31:[86, 10, 16]. Operations so far : ['88-72=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86*16=1376. \nResulting numbers: [10, 1376].\nHeuristic score : (|10-31| + |1376-31|)/2 = (21 + 1345)/2 = 683.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 31:[10, 1376] Operation: 86*16=1376\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1376-10=1366. \nResulting numbers: [1366].\n1366,31 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 43.5\nCurrent State #0: 31:[72, 88, 86, 10]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-86=2. \nResulting numbers: [72, 10, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|72-31| + |10-31| + |2-31|)/3 = (41 + 21 + 29)/3 = 30.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 31:[72, 10, 2] Operation: 88-86=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72/2=36. \nResulting numbers: [10, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|10-31| + |36-31|)/2 = (21 + 5)/2 = 13.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 31:[10, 36] Operation: 72/2=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-10=26. \nResulting numbers: [26].\n26,31 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 31:[72, 10, 2]. Operations so far : ['88-86=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 10*2=20. \nResulting numbers: [72, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|72-31| + |20-31|)/2 = (41 + 11)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 31:[72, 20] Operation: 10*2=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-20=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,31 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 31:[72, 10, 2]. Operations so far : ['88-86=2'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-10=62. \nResulting numbers: [2, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|2-31| + |62-31|)/2 = (29 + 31)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 31:[2, 62] Operation: 72-10=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62/2=31. \nResulting numbers: [31].\n31,31 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['88-86=2', '72-10=62', '62/2=31']\nRESULT: 31\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 2,970 |
[
24,
60,
60,
64
]
| 36 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [24, 60, 60, 64] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 36. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [24, 60, 60, 64]. Our goal is to produce 36. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 36:[24, 60, 60, 64]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-60=4. \nResulting numbers: [24, 60, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|24-36| + |60-36| + |4-36|)/3 = (12 + 24 + 32)/3 = 22.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 36:[24, 60, 4] Operation: 64-60=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-24=40. \nResulting numbers: [60, 60, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|60-36| + |60-36| + |40-36|)/3 = (24 + 24 + 4)/3 = 17.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 36:[60, 60, 40] Operation: 64-24=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-24=36. \nResulting numbers: [60, 64, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|60-36| + |64-36| + |36-36|)/3 = (24 + 28 + 0)/3 = 17.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 36:[60, 64, 36] Operation: 60-24=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-24=36. \nResulting numbers: [60, 64, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|60-36| + |64-36| + |36-36|)/3 = (24 + 28 + 0)/3 = 17.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 36:[60, 64, 36] Operation: 60-24=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-60=4. \nResulting numbers: [24, 60, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|24-36| + |60-36| + |4-36|)/3 = (12 + 24 + 32)/3 = 22.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 36:[24, 60, 4] Operation: 64-60=4\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 36:[60, 60, 40]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+60=120. \nResulting numbers: [40, 120].\nHeuristic score : (|40-36| + |120-36|)/2 = (4 + 84)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 36:[40, 120] Operation: 60+60=120\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-40=20. \nResulting numbers: [60, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|60-36| + |20-36|)/2 = (24 + 16)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 36:[60, 20] Operation: 60-40=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-40=20. \nResulting numbers: [60, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|60-36| + |20-36|)/2 = (24 + 16)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 36:[60, 20] Operation: 60-40=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/60=1. \nResulting numbers: [40, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|40-36| + |1-36|)/2 = (4 + 35)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 36:[40, 1] Operation: 60/60=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-60=0. \nResulting numbers: [40, 0].\nHeuristic score : (|40-36| + |0-36|)/2 = (4 + 36)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 36:[40, 0] Operation: 60-60=0\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 36:[60, 64, 36]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-60=4. \nResulting numbers: [36, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|36-36| + |4-36|)/2 = (0 + 32)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 36:[36, 4] Operation: 64-60=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-36=28. \nResulting numbers: [60, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|60-36| + |28-36|)/2 = (24 + 8)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 36:[60, 28] Operation: 64-36=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-36=24. \nResulting numbers: [64, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|64-36| + |24-36|)/2 = (28 + 12)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 36:[64, 24] Operation: 60-36=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+36=96. \nResulting numbers: [64, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|64-36| + |96-36|)/2 = (28 + 60)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 36:[64, 96] Operation: 60+36=96\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+64=124. \nResulting numbers: [36, 124].\nHeuristic score : (|36-36| + |124-36|)/2 = (0 + 88)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 36:[36, 124] Operation: 60+64=124\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 17.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 36:[60, 64, 36]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-60=4. \nResulting numbers: [36, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|36-36| + |4-36|)/2 = (0 + 32)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 36:[36, 4] Operation: 64-60=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+64=124. \nResulting numbers: [36, 124].\nHeuristic score : (|36-36| + |124-36|)/2 = (0 + 88)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 36:[36, 124] Operation: 60+64=124\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-36=24. \nResulting numbers: [64, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|64-36| + |24-36|)/2 = (28 + 12)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 36:[64, 24] Operation: 60-36=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-36=28. \nResulting numbers: [60, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|60-36| + |28-36|)/2 = (24 + 8)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 36:[60, 28] Operation: 64-36=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+36=96. \nResulting numbers: [64, 96].\nHeuristic score : (|64-36| + |96-36|)/2 = (28 + 60)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 36:[64, 96] Operation: 60+36=96\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 22.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 36:[24, 60, 4]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+4=28. \nResulting numbers: [60, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|60-36| + |28-36|)/2 = (24 + 8)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 36:[60, 28] Operation: 24+4=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/4=15. \nResulting numbers: [24, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|24-36| + |15-36|)/2 = (12 + 21)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 36:[24, 15] Operation: 60/4=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-24=36. \nResulting numbers: [4, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|4-36| + |36-36|)/2 = (32 + 0)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 36:[4, 36] Operation: 60-24=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-4=56. \nResulting numbers: [24, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|24-36| + |56-36|)/2 = (12 + 20)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 36:[24, 56] Operation: 60-4=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24-4=20. \nResulting numbers: [60, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|60-36| + |20-36|)/2 = (24 + 16)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 36:[60, 20] Operation: 24-4=20\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 22.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 36:[24, 60, 4]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-4=56. \nResulting numbers: [24, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|24-36| + |56-36|)/2 = (12 + 20)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 36:[24, 56] Operation: 60-4=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+4=28. \nResulting numbers: [60, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|60-36| + |28-36|)/2 = (24 + 8)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 36:[60, 28] Operation: 24+4=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24-4=20. \nResulting numbers: [60, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|60-36| + |20-36|)/2 = (24 + 16)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 36:[60, 20] Operation: 24-4=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-24=36. \nResulting numbers: [4, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|4-36| + |36-36|)/2 = (32 + 0)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 36:[4, 36] Operation: 60-24=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/4=15. \nResulting numbers: [24, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|24-36| + |15-36|)/2 = (12 + 21)/2 = 16.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 36:[24, 15] Operation: 60/4=15\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 36:[36, 4]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-60=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36/4=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*4=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+4=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-4=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 36:[60, 28]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-36=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+28=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-28=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*28=1680. \nResulting numbers: [1680].\n1680,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 36:[60, 28]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-36=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-28=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+28=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*28=1680. \nResulting numbers: [1680].\n1680,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 36:[36, 4]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-60=4'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36/4=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-4=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*4=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+4=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 36:[24, 56]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-4=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-24=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+56=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24*56=1344. \nResulting numbers: [1344].\n1344,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,3,0,2: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-60=4', '36+4=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,3,1,1: 36:[32]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-36=28', '60-28=32'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,3,0: 36:[32]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-36=28', '60-28=32'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,0,1: 36:[32]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-60=4', '36-4=32'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,3,0,3: 36:[32]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-60=4', '36-4=32'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,0,3: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-60=4', '36+4=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,4,0,0: 36:[32]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-4=56', '56-24=32'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 36:[60, 28]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24+4=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*28=1680. \nResulting numbers: [1680].\n1680,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+28=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-28=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 36:[4, 36]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-24=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+36=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*36=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36/4=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-4=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 36:[24, 56]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-4=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+56=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-24=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24*56=1344. \nResulting numbers: [1344].\n1344,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,4,1,2: 36:[32]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24+4=28', '60-28=32'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,4,3,0: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-24=36', '4+36=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,4,3,3: 36:[32]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-24=36', '36-4=32'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,0,3,1: 36:[32]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-4=56', '56-24=32'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 36:[60, 28]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24+4=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*28=1680. \nResulting numbers: [1680].\n1680,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-28=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+28=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,0,0,1: 36:[32]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24+4=28', '60-28=32'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 36:[4, 36]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-24=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36/4=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-4=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+36=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*36=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 16.5\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 36:[24, 15]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60/4=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+15=39. \nResulting numbers: [39].\n39,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24*15=360. \nResulting numbers: [360].\n360,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24-15=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 16.5\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 36:[24, 15]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60/4=15'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24*15=360. \nResulting numbers: [360].\n360,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24-15=9. \nResulting numbers: [9].\n9,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+15=39. \nResulting numbers: [39].\n39,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 19.5\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 36:[40, 1]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60/60=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40/1=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-1=39. \nResulting numbers: [39].\n39,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+1=41. \nResulting numbers: [41].\n41,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*1=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 3\nCurrent State #0,4,4,0: 36:[39]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60/4=15', '24+15=39'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 3\nCurrent State #0,0,1,2: 36:[39]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60/4=15', '24+15=39'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 3\nCurrent State #0,1,3,1: 36:[39]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60/60=1', '40-1=39'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,1,3,0: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60/60=1', '40/1=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,1,3,3: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60/60=1', '40*1=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,0,2,1: 36:[32]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-24=36', '36-4=32'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,0,2,2: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-24=36', '4+36=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 5\nCurrent State #0,1,3,2: 36:[41]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60/60=1', '40+1=41'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 36:[60, 20]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24-4=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+20=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/20=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*20=1200. \nResulting numbers: [1200].\n1200,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-20=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 36:[40, 0]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-60=0'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+0=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*0=0. \nResulting numbers: [0].\n0,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-0=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,4,2,3: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24-4=20', '60-20=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,1,4,0: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-60=0', '40+0=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,1,4,2: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-60=0', '40-0=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 36:[60, 20]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-40=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+20=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/20=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-20=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*20=1200. \nResulting numbers: [1200].\n1200,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 36:[60, 20]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24-4=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*20=1200. \nResulting numbers: [1200].\n1200,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/20=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+20=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-20=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,1,2,2: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-40=20', '60-20=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,0,4,3: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24-4=20', '60-20=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 36:[64, 24]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60-36=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64+24=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64*24=1536. \nResulting numbers: [1536].\n1536,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-24=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 36:[60, 20]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-40=20'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60/20=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-20=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60+20=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60*20=1200. \nResulting numbers: [1200].\n1200,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 20.0\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 36:[64, 24]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60-36=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64*24=1536. \nResulting numbers: [1536].\n1536,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64+24=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-24=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,2,2: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60-36=24', '64-24=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,1,1,1: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-40=20', '60-20=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,3,2,2: 36:[40]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60-36=24', '64-24=40'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 27\nCurrent State #0,0,1,1: 36:[9]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60/4=15', '24-15=9'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 27\nCurrent State #0,3,0,0: 36:[9]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-60=4', '36/4=9'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 27\nCurrent State #0,4,4,2: 36:[9]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60/4=15', '24-15=9'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 27\nCurrent State #0,2,0,0: 36:[9]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-60=4', '36/4=9'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 27\nCurrent State #0,4,3,2: 36:[9]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-24=36', '36/4=9'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 27\nCurrent State #0,0,2,0: 36:[9]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-24=36', '36/4=9'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 33\nCurrent State #0,1,1,0: 36:[3]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-40=20', '60/20=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 33\nCurrent State #0,0,4,1: 36:[3]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24-4=20', '60/20=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 33\nCurrent State #0,1,2,1: 36:[3]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-40=20', '60/20=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 33\nCurrent State #0,4,2,1: 36:[3]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24-4=20', '60/20=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 36\nCurrent State #0,1,4,1: 36:[0]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-60=0', '40*0=0'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 44.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 36:[64, 96]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+36=96'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-64=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64*96=6144. \nResulting numbers: [6144].\n6144,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64+96=160. \nResulting numbers: [160].\n160,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,2,4,0: 36:[32]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+36=96', '96-64=32'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 44.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 36:[64, 96]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+36=96'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-64=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64*96=6144. \nResulting numbers: [6144].\n6144,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64+96=160. \nResulting numbers: [160].\n160,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 44.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 36:[36, 124]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+64=124'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*124=4464. \nResulting numbers: [4464].\n4464,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 124-36=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+124=160. \nResulting numbers: [160].\n160,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 36:[80]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-40=20', '60+20=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,0,4,2: 36:[80]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24-4=20', '60+20=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 4\nCurrent State #0,3,3,0: 36:[32]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+36=96', '96-64=32'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 44.0\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 36:[36, 124]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+64=124'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36+124=160. \nResulting numbers: [160].\n160,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36*124=4464. \nResulting numbers: [4464].\n4464,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 124-36=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,4,2,0: 36:[80]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24-4=20', '60+20=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,4,0,1: 36:[80]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-4=56', '24+56=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 44.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 36:[40, 120]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60+60=120'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 120-40=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*120=4800. \nResulting numbers: [4800].\n4800,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+120=160. \nResulting numbers: [160].\n160,36 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 120/40=3. \nResulting numbers: [3].\n3,36 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 33\nCurrent State #0,1,0,3: 36:[3]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60+60=120', '120/40=3'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,0,3,0: 36:[80]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-4=56', '24+56=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,1,2,0: 36:[80]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-40=20', '60+20=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 44\nCurrent State #0,1,0,0: 36:[80]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60+60=120', '120-40=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 52\nCurrent State #0,0,0,2: 36:[88]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24+4=28', '60+28=88'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 52\nCurrent State #0,4,1,1: 36:[88]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24+4=28', '60+28=88'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 52\nCurrent State #0,3,1,0: 36:[88]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-36=28', '60+28=88'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 52\nCurrent State #0,3,2,1: 36:[88]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60-36=24', '64+24=88'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 52\nCurrent State #0,2,2,0: 36:[88]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60-36=24', '64+24=88'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 52\nCurrent State #0,2,1,1: 36:[88]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+64=124', '124-36=88'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 52\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 36:[88]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-36=28', '60+28=88'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 52\nCurrent State #0,3,4,2: 36:[88]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+64=124', '124-36=88'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 108\nCurrent State #0,4,3,1: 36:[144]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-24=36', '4*36=144'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 108\nCurrent State #0,3,0,1: 36:[144]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-60=4', '36*4=144'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 108\nCurrent State #0,0,2,3: 36:[144]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-24=36', '4*36=144'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 108\nCurrent State #0,2,0,2: 36:[144]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-60=4', '36*4=144'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 124\nCurrent State #0,3,3,2: 36:[160]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+36=96', '64+96=160'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 124\nCurrent State #0,3,4,0: 36:[160]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+64=124', '36+124=160'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 124\nCurrent State #0,1,0,2: 36:[160]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60+60=120', '40+120=160'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 124\nCurrent State #0,2,1,2: 36:[160]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+64=124', '36+124=160'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 124\nCurrent State #0,2,4,2: 36:[160]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+36=96', '64+96=160'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 324\nCurrent State #0,4,4,1: 36:[360]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60/4=15', '24*15=360'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 324\nCurrent State #0,0,1,0: 36:[360]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60/4=15', '24*15=360'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 1164\nCurrent State #0,1,2,3: 36:[1200]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-40=20', '60*20=1200'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 1164\nCurrent State #0,0,4,0: 36:[1200]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24-4=20', '60*20=1200'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 1164\nCurrent State #0,1,1,3: 36:[1200]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60-40=20', '60*20=1200'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 1164\nCurrent State #0,4,2,2: 36:[1200]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24-4=20', '60*20=1200'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 1308\nCurrent State #0,0,3,2: 36:[1344]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-4=56', '24*56=1344'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 1308\nCurrent State #0,4,0,2: 36:[1344]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '60-4=56', '24*56=1344'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 1500\nCurrent State #0,2,2,1: 36:[1536]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60-36=24', '64*24=1536'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 1500\nCurrent State #0,3,2,0: 36:[1536]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60-36=24', '64*24=1536'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 1644\nCurrent State #0,3,1,2: 36:[1680]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-36=28', '60*28=1680'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 1644\nCurrent State #0,4,1,0: 36:[1680]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24+4=28', '60*28=1680'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 1644\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 36:[1680]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '64-36=28', '60*28=1680'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 1644\nCurrent State #0,0,0,0: 36:[1680]. Operations so far : ['64-60=4', '24+4=28', '60*28=1680'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 4428\nCurrent State #0,3,4,1: 36:[4464]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+64=124', '36*124=4464'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 4428\nCurrent State #0,2,1,0: 36:[4464]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+64=124', '36*124=4464'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 4764\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 36:[4800]. Operations so far : ['64-24=40', '60+60=120', '40*120=4800'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 6108\nCurrent State #0,2,4,1: 36:[6144]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+36=96', '64*96=6144'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 6108\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 36:[6144]. Operations so far : ['60-24=36', '60+36=96', '64*96=6144'].\n\n```\nSOLUTION: NO\nOPERATIONS: []\nRESULT: None\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 17,183 |
[
4,
83,
22,
33
]
| 76 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [4, 83, 22, 33] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 76. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [4, 83, 22, 33]. Our goal is to produce 76. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 76:[4, 83, 22, 33]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4*22=88. \nResulting numbers: [83, 33, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|83-76| + |33-76| + |88-76|)/3 = (7 + 43 + 12)/3 = 20.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 76:[83, 33, 88] Operation: 4*22=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-33=55. \nResulting numbers: [83, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|83-76| + |55-76|)/2 = (7 + 21)/2 = 14.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 76:[83, 55] Operation: 88-33=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-55=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 76:[83, 33, 88]. Operations so far : ['4*22=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-33=50. \nResulting numbers: [88, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|88-76| + |50-76|)/2 = (12 + 26)/2 = 19.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 76:[88, 50] Operation: 83-33=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-50=38. \nResulting numbers: [38].\n38,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 76:[83, 33, 88]. Operations so far : ['4*22=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+33=116. \nResulting numbers: [88, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|88-76| + |116-76|)/2 = (12 + 40)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 76:[88, 116] Operation: 83+33=116\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-88=28. \nResulting numbers: [28].\n28,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 76:[83, 33, 88]. Operations so far : ['4*22=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+88=121. \nResulting numbers: [83, 121].\nHeuristic score : (|83-76| + |121-76|)/2 = (7 + 45)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 76:[83, 121] Operation: 33+88=121\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 121-83=38. \nResulting numbers: [38].\n38,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 76:[83, 33, 88]. Operations so far : ['4*22=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-83=5. \nResulting numbers: [33, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|33-76| + |5-76|)/2 = (43 + 71)/2 = 57.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 76:[33, 5] Operation: 88-83=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+5=38. \nResulting numbers: [38].\n38,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 76:[83, 33, 88]. Operations so far : ['4*22=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+88=171. \nResulting numbers: [33, 171].\nHeuristic score : (|33-76| + |171-76|)/2 = (43 + 95)/2 = 69.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 76:[33, 171] Operation: 83+88=171\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 171-33=138. \nResulting numbers: [138].\n138,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 76:[83, 33, 88]. Operations so far : ['4*22=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*33=2739. \nResulting numbers: [88, 2739].\nHeuristic score : (|88-76| + |2739-76|)/2 = (12 + 2663)/2 = 1337.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 76:[88, 2739] Operation: 83*33=2739\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2739-88=2651. \nResulting numbers: [2651].\n2651,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 76:[83, 33, 88]. Operations so far : ['4*22=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33*88=2904. \nResulting numbers: [83, 2904].\nHeuristic score : (|83-76| + |2904-76|)/2 = (7 + 2828)/2 = 1417.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 76:[83, 2904] Operation: 33*88=2904\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2904-83=2821. \nResulting numbers: [2821].\n2821,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 20.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 76:[83, 33, 88]. Operations so far : ['4*22=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*88=7304. \nResulting numbers: [33, 7304].\nHeuristic score : (|33-76| + |7304-76|)/2 = (43 + 7228)/2 = 3635.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 76:[33, 7304] Operation: 83*88=7304\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7304-33=7271. \nResulting numbers: [7271].\n7271,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 44.0\nCurrent State #0: 76:[4, 83, 22, 33]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-4=79. \nResulting numbers: [22, 33, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|22-76| + |33-76| + |79-76|)/3 = (54 + 43 + 3)/3 = 33.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 76:[22, 33, 79] Operation: 83-4=79\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+33=55. \nResulting numbers: [79, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|79-76| + |55-76|)/2 = (3 + 21)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 76:[79, 55] Operation: 22+33=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-55=24. \nResulting numbers: [24].\n24,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 76:[22, 33, 79]. Operations so far : ['83-4=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-22=57. \nResulting numbers: [33, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|33-76| + |57-76|)/2 = (43 + 19)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 76:[33, 57] Operation: 79-22=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+57=90. \nResulting numbers: [90].\n90,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 76:[22, 33, 79]. Operations so far : ['83-4=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-22=11. \nResulting numbers: [79, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|79-76| + |11-76|)/2 = (3 + 65)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 76:[79, 11] Operation: 33-22=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-11=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 76:[22, 33, 79]. Operations so far : ['83-4=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+79=101. \nResulting numbers: [33, 101].\nHeuristic score : (|33-76| + |101-76|)/2 = (43 + 25)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 76:[33, 101] Operation: 22+79=101\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 101-33=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 76:[22, 33, 79]. Operations so far : ['83-4=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-33=46. \nResulting numbers: [22, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|22-76| + |46-76|)/2 = (54 + 30)/2 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 76:[22, 46] Operation: 79-33=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22+46=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 76:[22, 33, 79]. Operations so far : ['83-4=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+79=112. \nResulting numbers: [22, 112].\nHeuristic score : (|22-76| + |112-76|)/2 = (54 + 36)/2 = 45.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 76:[22, 112] Operation: 33+79=112\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112-22=90. \nResulting numbers: [90].\n90,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 76:[22, 33, 79]. Operations so far : ['83-4=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22*33=726. \nResulting numbers: [79, 726].\nHeuristic score : (|79-76| + |726-76|)/2 = (3 + 650)/2 = 326.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 76:[79, 726] Operation: 22*33=726\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 726-79=647. \nResulting numbers: [647].\n647,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 76:[22, 33, 79]. Operations so far : ['83-4=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 22*79=1738. \nResulting numbers: [33, 1738].\nHeuristic score : (|33-76| + |1738-76|)/2 = (43 + 1662)/2 = 852.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 76:[33, 1738] Operation: 22*79=1738\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1738-33=1705. \nResulting numbers: [1705].\n1705,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 76:[22, 33, 79]. Operations so far : ['83-4=79'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33*79=2607. \nResulting numbers: [22, 2607].\nHeuristic score : (|22-76| + |2607-76|)/2 = (54 + 2531)/2 = 1292.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 76:[22, 2607] Operation: 33*79=2607\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 2607-22=2585. \nResulting numbers: [2585].\n2585,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 44.0\nCurrent State #0: 76:[4, 83, 22, 33]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 4+22=26. \nResulting numbers: [83, 33, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|83-76| + |33-76| + |26-76|)/3 = (7 + 43 + 50)/3 = 33.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 76:[83, 33, 26] Operation: 4+22=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+26=59. \nResulting numbers: [83, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|83-76| + |59-76|)/2 = (7 + 17)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 76:[83, 59] Operation: 33+26=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-59=24. \nResulting numbers: [24].\n24,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 76:[83, 33, 26]. Operations so far : ['4+22=26'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-26=57. \nResulting numbers: [33, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|33-76| + |57-76|)/2 = (43 + 19)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 76:[33, 57] Operation: 83-26=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+57=90. \nResulting numbers: [90].\n90,76 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 33.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 76:[83, 33, 26]. Operations so far : ['4+22=26'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-33=50. \nResulting numbers: [26, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|26-76| + |50-76|)/2 = (50 + 26)/2 = 38.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 76:[26, 50] Operation: 83-33=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26+50=76. \nResulting numbers: [76].\n76,76 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['4+22=26', '83-33=50', '26+50=76']\nRESULT: 76\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 5,104 |
[
24,
35,
45,
16
]
| 18 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [24, 35, 45, 16] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 18. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [24, 35, 45, 16]. Our goal is to produce 18. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 18:[24, 35, 45, 16]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-24=11. \nResulting numbers: [45, 16, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|45-18| + |16-18| + |11-18|)/3 = (27 + 2 + 7)/3 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 18:[45, 16, 11] Operation: 35-24=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-16=29. \nResulting numbers: [24, 35, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|24-18| + |35-18| + |29-18|)/3 = (6 + 17 + 11)/3 = 11.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 18:[24, 35, 29] Operation: 45-16=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-35=10. \nResulting numbers: [24, 16, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|24-18| + |16-18| + |10-18|)/3 = (6 + 2 + 8)/3 = 5.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 18:[24, 16, 10] Operation: 45-35=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-16=19. \nResulting numbers: [24, 45, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|24-18| + |45-18| + |19-18|)/3 = (6 + 27 + 1)/3 = 11.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 18:[24, 45, 19] Operation: 35-16=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-24=21. \nResulting numbers: [35, 16, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|35-18| + |16-18| + |21-18|)/3 = (17 + 2 + 3)/3 = 7.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 18:[35, 16, 21] Operation: 45-24=21\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 5.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,2: 18:[24, 16, 10]. Operations so far : ['45-35=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24-16=8. \nResulting numbers: [10, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|10-18| + |8-18|)/2 = (8 + 10)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 18:[10, 8] Operation: 24-16=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16-10=6. \nResulting numbers: [24, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|24-18| + |6-18|)/2 = (6 + 12)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 18:[24, 6] Operation: 16-10=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24-10=14. \nResulting numbers: [16, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|16-18| + |14-18|)/2 = (2 + 4)/2 = 3.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 18:[16, 14] Operation: 24-10=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16+10=26. \nResulting numbers: [24, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|24-18| + |26-18|)/2 = (6 + 8)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 18:[24, 26] Operation: 16+10=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+10=34. \nResulting numbers: [16, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|16-18| + |34-18|)/2 = (2 + 16)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 18:[16, 34] Operation: 24+10=34\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 7.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,4: 18:[35, 16, 21]. Operations so far : ['45-24=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16+21=37. \nResulting numbers: [35, 37].\nHeuristic score : (|35-18| + |37-18|)/2 = (17 + 19)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 18:[35, 37] Operation: 16+21=37\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-16=19. \nResulting numbers: [21, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|21-18| + |19-18|)/2 = (3 + 1)/2 = 2.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 18:[21, 19] Operation: 35-16=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-21=14. \nResulting numbers: [16, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|16-18| + |14-18|)/2 = (2 + 4)/2 = 3.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 18:[16, 14] Operation: 35-21=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+16=51. \nResulting numbers: [21, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|21-18| + |51-18|)/2 = (3 + 33)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 18:[21, 51] Operation: 35+16=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21-16=5. \nResulting numbers: [35, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|35-18| + |5-18|)/2 = (17 + 13)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 18:[35, 5] Operation: 21-16=5\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 18:[24, 35, 29]. Operations so far : ['45-16=29'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+35=59. \nResulting numbers: [29, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|29-18| + |59-18|)/2 = (11 + 41)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 18:[29, 59] Operation: 24+35=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-24=11. \nResulting numbers: [29, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|29-18| + |11-18|)/2 = (11 + 7)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 18:[29, 11] Operation: 35-24=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-29=6. \nResulting numbers: [24, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|24-18| + |6-18|)/2 = (6 + 12)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 18:[24, 6] Operation: 35-29=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+29=53. \nResulting numbers: [35, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|35-18| + |53-18|)/2 = (17 + 35)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 18:[35, 53] Operation: 24+29=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29-24=5. \nResulting numbers: [35, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|35-18| + |5-18|)/2 = (17 + 13)/2 = 15.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 18:[35, 5] Operation: 29-24=5\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,3: 18:[24, 45, 19]. Operations so far : ['35-16=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-19=26. \nResulting numbers: [24, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|24-18| + |26-18|)/2 = (6 + 8)/2 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 18:[24, 26] Operation: 45-19=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+45=69. \nResulting numbers: [19, 69].\nHeuristic score : (|19-18| + |69-18|)/2 = (1 + 51)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 18:[19, 69] Operation: 24+45=69\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24-19=5. \nResulting numbers: [45, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|45-18| + |5-18|)/2 = (27 + 13)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 18:[45, 5] Operation: 24-19=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-24=21. \nResulting numbers: [19, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|19-18| + |21-18|)/2 = (1 + 3)/2 = 2.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 18:[19, 21] Operation: 45-24=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+19=43. \nResulting numbers: [45, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|45-18| + |43-18|)/2 = (27 + 25)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 18:[45, 43] Operation: 24+19=43\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 18:[45, 16, 11]. Operations so far : ['35-24=11'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-16=29. \nResulting numbers: [11, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|11-18| + |29-18|)/2 = (7 + 11)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 18:[11, 29] Operation: 45-16=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-11=34. \nResulting numbers: [16, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|16-18| + |34-18|)/2 = (2 + 16)/2 = 9.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 18:[16, 34] Operation: 45-11=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16+11=27. \nResulting numbers: [45, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|45-18| + |27-18|)/2 = (27 + 9)/2 = 18.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 18:[45, 27] Operation: 16+11=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16-11=5. \nResulting numbers: [45, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|45-18| + |5-18|)/2 = (27 + 13)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 18:[45, 5] Operation: 16-11=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45+11=56. \nResulting numbers: [16, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|16-18| + |56-18|)/2 = (2 + 38)/2 = 20.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 18:[16, 56] Operation: 45+11=56\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 2.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 18:[21, 19]. Operations so far : ['45-24=21', '35-16=19'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21*19=399. \nResulting numbers: [399].\n399,18 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21+19=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,18 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21-19=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,18 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 2.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 18:[19, 21]. Operations so far : ['35-16=19', '45-24=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 21-19=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,18 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 19+21=40. \nResulting numbers: [40].\n40,18 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 19*21=399. \nResulting numbers: [399].\n399,18 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 3.0\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 18:[16, 14]. Operations so far : ['45-35=10', '24-10=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16+14=30. \nResulting numbers: [30].\n30,18 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16-14=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,18 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16*14=224. \nResulting numbers: [224].\n224,18 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 3.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 18:[16, 14]. Operations so far : ['45-24=21', '35-21=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16-14=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,18 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16*14=224. \nResulting numbers: [224].\n224,18 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 16+14=30. \nResulting numbers: [30].\n30,18 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 18:[24, 26]. Operations so far : ['45-35=10', '16+10=26'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26-24=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,18 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+26=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,18 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24*26=624. \nResulting numbers: [624].\n624,18 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 18:[24, 26]. Operations so far : ['35-16=19', '45-19=26'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 26-24=2. \nResulting numbers: [2].\n2,18 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24*26=624. \nResulting numbers: [624].\n624,18 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+26=50. \nResulting numbers: [50].\n50,18 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 9.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 18:[10, 8]. Operations so far : ['45-35=10', '24-16=8'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 10+8=18. \nResulting numbers: [18].\n18,18 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['45-35=10', '24-16=8', '10-8=2']\nRESULT: 2\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 5,167 |
[
47,
17,
40,
24
]
| 94 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [47, 17, 40, 24] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 94. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [47, 17, 40, 24]. Our goal is to produce 94. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 94:[47, 17, 40, 24]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+24=41. \nResulting numbers: [47, 40, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|47-94| + |40-94| + |41-94|)/3 = (47 + 54 + 53)/3 = 51.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 94:[47, 40, 41] Operation: 17+24=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+40=87. \nResulting numbers: [17, 24, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|17-94| + |24-94| + |87-94|)/3 = (77 + 70 + 7)/3 = 51.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 94:[17, 24, 87] Operation: 47+40=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+24=71. \nResulting numbers: [17, 40, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|17-94| + |40-94| + |71-94|)/3 = (77 + 54 + 23)/3 = 51.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 94:[17, 40, 71] Operation: 47+24=71\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+40=57. \nResulting numbers: [47, 24, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|47-94| + |24-94| + |57-94|)/3 = (47 + 70 + 37)/3 = 51.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 94:[47, 24, 57] Operation: 17+40=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+17=64. \nResulting numbers: [40, 24, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|40-94| + |24-94| + |64-94|)/3 = (54 + 70 + 30)/3 = 51.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 94:[40, 24, 64] Operation: 47+17=64\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 51.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 94:[47, 40, 41]. Operations so far : ['17+24=41'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+41=88. \nResulting numbers: [40, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|40-94| + |88-94|)/2 = (54 + 6)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 94:[40, 88] Operation: 47+41=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+41=81. \nResulting numbers: [47, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|47-94| + |81-94|)/2 = (47 + 13)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 94:[47, 81] Operation: 40+41=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-40=7. \nResulting numbers: [41, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|41-94| + |7-94|)/2 = (53 + 87)/2 = 70.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 94:[41, 7] Operation: 47-40=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41-40=1. \nResulting numbers: [47, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|47-94| + |1-94|)/2 = (47 + 93)/2 = 70.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 94:[47, 1] Operation: 41-40=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+40=87. \nResulting numbers: [41, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|41-94| + |87-94|)/2 = (53 + 7)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 94:[41, 87] Operation: 47+40=87\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 51.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 94:[17, 40, 71]. Operations so far : ['47+24=71'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+71=111. \nResulting numbers: [17, 111].\nHeuristic score : (|17-94| + |111-94|)/2 = (77 + 17)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 94:[17, 111] Operation: 40+71=111\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+71=88. \nResulting numbers: [40, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|40-94| + |88-94|)/2 = (54 + 6)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 94:[40, 88] Operation: 17+71=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-17=23. \nResulting numbers: [71, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|71-94| + |23-94|)/2 = (23 + 71)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 94:[71, 23] Operation: 40-17=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+40=57. \nResulting numbers: [71, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|71-94| + |57-94|)/2 = (23 + 37)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 94:[71, 57] Operation: 17+40=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-17=54. \nResulting numbers: [40, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|40-94| + |54-94|)/2 = (54 + 40)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 94:[40, 54] Operation: 71-17=54\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 51.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,4: 94:[40, 24, 64]. Operations so far : ['47+17=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+24=64. \nResulting numbers: [64, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|64-94| + |64-94|)/2 = (30 + 30)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 94:[64, 64] Operation: 40+24=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-24=40. \nResulting numbers: [40, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|40-94| + |40-94|)/2 = (54 + 54)/2 = 54.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 94:[40, 40] Operation: 64-24=40\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+64=88. \nResulting numbers: [40, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|40-94| + |88-94|)/2 = (54 + 6)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 94:[40, 88] Operation: 24+64=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+64=104. \nResulting numbers: [24, 104].\nHeuristic score : (|24-94| + |104-94|)/2 = (70 + 10)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 94:[24, 104] Operation: 40+64=104\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-24=16. \nResulting numbers: [64, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|64-94| + |16-94|)/2 = (30 + 78)/2 = 54.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 94:[64, 16] Operation: 40-24=16\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 51.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,1: 94:[17, 24, 87]. Operations so far : ['47+40=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+24=41. \nResulting numbers: [87, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|87-94| + |41-94|)/2 = (7 + 53)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 94:[87, 41] Operation: 17+24=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-17=70. \nResulting numbers: [24, 70].\nHeuristic score : (|24-94| + |70-94|)/2 = (70 + 24)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 94:[24, 70] Operation: 87-17=70\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24-17=7. \nResulting numbers: [87, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|87-94| + |7-94|)/2 = (7 + 87)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 94:[87, 7] Operation: 24-17=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+87=111. \nResulting numbers: [17, 111].\nHeuristic score : (|17-94| + |111-94|)/2 = (77 + 17)/2 = 47.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 94:[17, 111] Operation: 24+87=111\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+87=104. \nResulting numbers: [24, 104].\nHeuristic score : (|24-94| + |104-94|)/2 = (70 + 10)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 94:[24, 104] Operation: 17+87=104\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 51.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,3: 94:[47, 24, 57]. Operations so far : ['17+40=57'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+57=104. \nResulting numbers: [24, 104].\nHeuristic score : (|24-94| + |104-94|)/2 = (70 + 10)/2 = 40.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 94:[24, 104] Operation: 47+57=104\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57-24=33. \nResulting numbers: [47, 33].\nHeuristic score : (|47-94| + |33-94|)/2 = (47 + 61)/2 = 54.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 94:[47, 33] Operation: 57-24=33\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47-24=23. \nResulting numbers: [57, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|57-94| + |23-94|)/2 = (37 + 71)/2 = 54.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 94:[57, 23] Operation: 47-24=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+57=81. \nResulting numbers: [47, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|47-94| + |81-94|)/2 = (47 + 13)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 94:[47, 81] Operation: 24+57=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+24=71. \nResulting numbers: [57, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|57-94| + |71-94|)/2 = (37 + 23)/2 = 30.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 94:[57, 71] Operation: 47+24=71\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 94:[40, 88]. Operations so far : ['17+24=41', '47+41=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-40=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*88=3520. \nResulting numbers: [3520].\n3520,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+88=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 94:[41, 87]. Operations so far : ['17+24=41', '47+40=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-41=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41*87=3567. \nResulting numbers: [3567].\n3567,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41+87=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 94:[71, 57]. Operations so far : ['47+24=71', '17+40=57'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-57=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71*57=4047. \nResulting numbers: [4047].\n4047,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71+57=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 94:[40, 88]. Operations so far : ['47+24=71', '17+71=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-40=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*88=3520. \nResulting numbers: [3520].\n3520,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+88=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 94:[40, 88]. Operations so far : ['47+17=64', '24+64=88'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+88=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-40=48. \nResulting numbers: [48].\n48,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*88=3520. \nResulting numbers: [3520].\n3520,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 94:[47, 81]. Operations so far : ['17+24=41', '40+41=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+81=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*81=3807. \nResulting numbers: [3807].\n3807,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-47=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 94:[64, 64]. Operations so far : ['47+17=64', '40+24=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-64=0. \nResulting numbers: [0].\n0,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64*64=4096. \nResulting numbers: [4096].\n4096,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64+64=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64/64=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 94:[57, 71]. Operations so far : ['17+40=57', '47+24=71'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57*71=4047. \nResulting numbers: [4047].\n4047,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 71-57=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 57+71=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 94:[47, 81]. Operations so far : ['17+40=57', '24+57=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47*81=3807. \nResulting numbers: [3807].\n3807,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-47=34. \nResulting numbers: [34].\n34,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 47+81=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 30.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 94:[87, 41]. Operations so far : ['47+40=87', '17+24=41'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87*41=3567. \nResulting numbers: [3567].\n3567,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-41=46. \nResulting numbers: [46].\n46,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87+41=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,0,4,2: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['17+24=41', '47+40=87', '41+87=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,2,1,2: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['47+24=71', '17+71=88', '40+88=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,0,1,0: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['17+24=41', '40+41=81', '47+81=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,2,3,2: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['47+24=71', '17+40=57', '71+57=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,0,0,2: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['17+24=41', '47+41=88', '40+88=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,3,3,2: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['17+40=57', '24+57=81', '47+81=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,1,0,2: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['47+40=87', '17+24=41', '87+41=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,4,2,0: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['47+17=64', '24+64=88', '40+88=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,3,4,2: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['17+40=57', '47+24=71', '57+71=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,4,0,2: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['47+17=64', '40+24=64', '64+64=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 40.0\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 94:[24, 104]. Operations so far : ['47+17=64', '40+64=104'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+104=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24*104=2496. \nResulting numbers: [2496].\n2496,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104-24=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 40.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 94:[24, 104]. Operations so far : ['17+40=57', '47+57=104'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+104=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104-24=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24*104=2496. \nResulting numbers: [2496].\n2496,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 40.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 94:[24, 104]. Operations so far : ['47+40=87', '17+87=104'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24*104=2496. \nResulting numbers: [2496].\n2496,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104-24=80. \nResulting numbers: [80].\n80,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+104=128. \nResulting numbers: [128].\n128,94 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 46\nCurrent State #0,2,1,0: 94:[48]. Operations so far : ['47+24=71', '17+71=88', '88-40=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 46\nCurrent State #0,0,0,0: 94:[48]. Operations so far : ['17+24=41', '47+41=88', '88-40=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,4,3,2: 94:[80]. Operations so far : ['47+17=64', '40+64=104', '104-24=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,3,0,1: 94:[80]. Operations so far : ['17+40=57', '47+57=104', '104-24=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 14\nCurrent State #0,1,4,1: 94:[80]. Operations so far : ['47+40=87', '17+87=104', '104-24=80'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,4,3,0: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['47+17=64', '40+64=104', '24+104=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,3,0,0: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['17+40=57', '47+57=104', '24+104=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,1,4,2: 94:[128]. Operations so far : ['47+40=87', '17+87=104', '24+104=128'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 46\nCurrent State #0,4,2,1: 94:[48]. Operations so far : ['47+17=64', '24+64=88', '88-40=48'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 47.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 94:[40, 54]. Operations so far : ['47+24=71', '71-17=54'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*54=2160. \nResulting numbers: [2160].\n2160,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 54-40=14. \nResulting numbers: [14].\n14,94 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+54=94. \nResulting numbers: [94].\n94,94 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['47+24=71', '71-17=54', '54-40=14']\nRESULT: 14\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 8,599 |
[
32,
35,
17,
7
]
| 52 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [32, 35, 17, 7] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 52. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [32, 35, 17, 7]. Our goal is to produce 52. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 52:[32, 35, 17, 7]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+17=49. \nResulting numbers: [35, 7, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |7-52| + |49-52|)/3 = (17 + 45 + 3)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 52:[35, 7, 49] Operation: 32+17=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+7=42. \nResulting numbers: [49, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|49-52| + |42-52|)/2 = (3 + 10)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 52:[49, 42] Operation: 35+7=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49+42=91. \nResulting numbers: [91].\n91,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 52:[35, 7, 49]. Operations so far : ['32+17=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+49=56. \nResulting numbers: [35, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |56-52|)/2 = (17 + 4)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 52:[35, 56] Operation: 7+49=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-35=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 52:[35, 7, 49]. Operations so far : ['32+17=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-7=28. \nResulting numbers: [49, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|49-52| + |28-52|)/2 = (3 + 24)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 52:[49, 28] Operation: 35-7=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49+28=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 52:[35, 7, 49]. Operations so far : ['32+17=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-7=42. \nResulting numbers: [35, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |42-52|)/2 = (17 + 10)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 52:[35, 42] Operation: 49-7=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+42=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 52:[35, 7, 49]. Operations so far : ['32+17=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35/7=5. \nResulting numbers: [49, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|49-52| + |5-52|)/2 = (3 + 47)/2 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 52:[49, 5] Operation: 35/7=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49+5=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 52:[35, 7, 49]. Operations so far : ['32+17=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49/7=7. \nResulting numbers: [35, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |7-52|)/2 = (17 + 45)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 52:[35, 7] Operation: 49/7=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+7=42. \nResulting numbers: [42].\n42,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 52:[35, 7, 49]. Operations so far : ['32+17=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+49=84. \nResulting numbers: [7, 84].\nHeuristic score : (|7-52| + |84-52|)/2 = (45 + 32)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 52:[7, 84] Operation: 35+49=84\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-7=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 52:[35, 7, 49]. Operations so far : ['32+17=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-35=14. \nResulting numbers: [7, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|7-52| + |14-52|)/2 = (45 + 38)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 52:[7, 14] Operation: 49-35=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+14=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 52:[35, 7, 49]. Operations so far : ['32+17=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*7=245. \nResulting numbers: [49, 245].\nHeuristic score : (|49-52| + |245-52|)/2 = (3 + 193)/2 = 98.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 52:[49, 245] Operation: 35*7=245\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 245/49=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 52:[35, 7, 49]. Operations so far : ['32+17=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 10th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*49=343. \nResulting numbers: [35, 343].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |343-52|)/2 = (17 + 291)/2 = 154.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,9: 52:[35, 343] Operation: 7*49=343\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,9’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 343-35=308. \nResulting numbers: [308].\n308,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,0: 52:[35, 7, 49]. Operations so far : ['32+17=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 11th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*49=1715. \nResulting numbers: [7, 1715].\nHeuristic score : (|7-52| + |1715-52|)/2 = (45 + 1663)/2 = 854.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,10: 52:[7, 1715] Operation: 35*49=1715\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,10’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1715/7=245. \nResulting numbers: [245].\n245,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.25\nCurrent State #0: 52:[32, 35, 17, 7]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+7=39. \nResulting numbers: [35, 17, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |17-52| + |39-52|)/3 = (17 + 35 + 13)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 52:[35, 17, 39] Operation: 32+7=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+17=52. \nResulting numbers: [39, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|39-52| + |52-52|)/2 = (13 + 0)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 52:[39, 52] Operation: 35+17=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+52=91. \nResulting numbers: [91].\n91,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 52:[35, 17, 39]. Operations so far : ['32+7=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+39=56. \nResulting numbers: [35, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |56-52|)/2 = (17 + 4)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 52:[35, 56] Operation: 17+39=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-35=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 52:[35, 17, 39]. Operations so far : ['32+7=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-17=18. \nResulting numbers: [39, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|39-52| + |18-52|)/2 = (13 + 34)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 52:[39, 18] Operation: 35-17=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39+18=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 52:[35, 17, 39]. Operations so far : ['32+7=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-17=22. \nResulting numbers: [35, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |22-52|)/2 = (17 + 30)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 52:[35, 22] Operation: 39-17=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+22=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 52:[35, 17, 39]. Operations so far : ['32+7=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+39=74. \nResulting numbers: [17, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |74-52|)/2 = (35 + 22)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 52:[17, 74] Operation: 35+39=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-17=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 52:[35, 17, 39]. Operations so far : ['32+7=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 39-35=4. \nResulting numbers: [17, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |4-52|)/2 = (35 + 48)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,5: 52:[17, 4] Operation: 39-35=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17*4=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 52:[35, 17, 39]. Operations so far : ['32+7=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*17=595. \nResulting numbers: [39, 595].\nHeuristic score : (|39-52| + |595-52|)/2 = (13 + 543)/2 = 278.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,6: 52:[39, 595] Operation: 35*17=595\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 595-39=556. \nResulting numbers: [556].\n556,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 52:[35, 17, 39]. Operations so far : ['32+7=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17*39=663. \nResulting numbers: [35, 663].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |663-52|)/2 = (17 + 611)/2 = 314.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,7: 52:[35, 663] Operation: 17*39=663\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 663-35=628. \nResulting numbers: [628].\n628,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,1: 52:[35, 17, 39]. Operations so far : ['32+7=39'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*39=1365. \nResulting numbers: [17, 1365].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |1365-52|)/2 = (35 + 1313)/2 = 674.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,8: 52:[17, 1365] Operation: 35*39=1365\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1365-17=1348. \nResulting numbers: [1348].\n1348,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.25\nCurrent State #0: 52:[32, 35, 17, 7]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+17=52. \nResulting numbers: [32, 7, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |7-52| + |52-52|)/3 = (20 + 45 + 0)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 52:[32, 7, 52] Operation: 35+17=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+7=39. \nResulting numbers: [52, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|52-52| + |39-52|)/2 = (0 + 13)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 52:[52, 39] Operation: 32+7=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+39=91. \nResulting numbers: [91].\n91,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 52:[32, 7, 52]. Operations so far : ['35+17=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-7=25. \nResulting numbers: [52, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|52-52| + |25-52|)/2 = (0 + 27)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 52:[52, 25] Operation: 32-7=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52+25=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 52:[32, 7, 52]. Operations so far : ['35+17=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+52=59. \nResulting numbers: [32, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |59-52|)/2 = (20 + 7)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 52:[32, 59] Operation: 7+52=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-32=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 52:[32, 7, 52]. Operations so far : ['35+17=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-7=45. \nResulting numbers: [32, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |45-52|)/2 = (20 + 7)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 52:[32, 45] Operation: 52-7=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+45=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 52:[32, 7, 52]. Operations so far : ['35+17=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+52=84. \nResulting numbers: [7, 84].\nHeuristic score : (|7-52| + |84-52|)/2 = (45 + 32)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 52:[7, 84] Operation: 32+52=84\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-7=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 52:[32, 7, 52]. Operations so far : ['35+17=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 52-32=20. \nResulting numbers: [7, 20].\nHeuristic score : (|7-52| + |20-52|)/2 = (45 + 32)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,5: 52:[7, 20] Operation: 52-32=20\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+20=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 52:[32, 7, 52]. Operations so far : ['35+17=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*7=224. \nResulting numbers: [52, 224].\nHeuristic score : (|52-52| + |224-52|)/2 = (0 + 172)/2 = 86.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,6: 52:[52, 224] Operation: 32*7=224\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 224-52=172. \nResulting numbers: [172].\n172,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 52:[32, 7, 52]. Operations so far : ['35+17=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*52=364. \nResulting numbers: [32, 364].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |364-52|)/2 = (20 + 312)/2 = 166.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,7: 52:[32, 364] Operation: 7*52=364\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 364-32=332. \nResulting numbers: [332].\n332,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 52:[32, 7, 52]. Operations so far : ['35+17=52'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*52=1664. \nResulting numbers: [7, 1664].\nHeuristic score : (|7-52| + |1664-52|)/2 = (45 + 1612)/2 = 828.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,8: 52:[7, 1664] Operation: 32*52=1664\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1664-7=1657. \nResulting numbers: [1657].\n1657,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.25\nCurrent State #0: 52:[32, 35, 17, 7]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+7=42. \nResulting numbers: [32, 17, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |17-52| + |42-52|)/3 = (20 + 35 + 10)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 52:[32, 17, 42] Operation: 35+7=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+17=49. \nResulting numbers: [42, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|42-52| + |49-52|)/2 = (10 + 3)/2 = 6.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 52:[42, 49] Operation: 32+17=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42+49=91. \nResulting numbers: [91].\n91,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 52:[32, 17, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+42=59. \nResulting numbers: [32, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |59-52|)/2 = (20 + 7)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 52:[32, 59] Operation: 17+42=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-32=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 52:[32, 17, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-17=15. \nResulting numbers: [42, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|42-52| + |15-52|)/2 = (10 + 37)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 52:[42, 15] Operation: 32-17=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42+15=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 52:[32, 17, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-17=25. \nResulting numbers: [32, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |25-52|)/2 = (20 + 27)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 52:[32, 25] Operation: 42-17=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+25=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 52:[32, 17, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+42=74. \nResulting numbers: [17, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |74-52|)/2 = (35 + 22)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 52:[17, 74] Operation: 32+42=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-17=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 52:[32, 17, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-32=10. \nResulting numbers: [17, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |10-52|)/2 = (35 + 42)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,5: 52:[17, 10] Operation: 42-32=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+10=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 52:[32, 17, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*17=544. \nResulting numbers: [42, 544].\nHeuristic score : (|42-52| + |544-52|)/2 = (10 + 492)/2 = 251.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,6: 52:[42, 544] Operation: 32*17=544\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 544-42=502. \nResulting numbers: [502].\n502,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 52:[32, 17, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17*42=714. \nResulting numbers: [32, 714].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |714-52|)/2 = (20 + 662)/2 = 341.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,7: 52:[32, 714] Operation: 17*42=714\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 714-32=682. \nResulting numbers: [682].\n682,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,3: 52:[32, 17, 42]. Operations so far : ['35+7=42'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*42=1344. \nResulting numbers: [17, 1344].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |1344-52|)/2 = (35 + 1292)/2 = 663.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,8: 52:[17, 1344] Operation: 32*42=1344\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1344-17=1327. \nResulting numbers: [1327].\n1327,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.25\nCurrent State #0: 52:[32, 35, 17, 7]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+7=24. \nResulting numbers: [32, 35, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |35-52| + |24-52|)/3 = (20 + 17 + 28)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 52:[32, 35, 24] Operation: 17+7=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+24=56. \nResulting numbers: [35, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |56-52|)/2 = (17 + 4)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 52:[35, 56] Operation: 32+24=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 56-35=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 52:[32, 35, 24]. Operations so far : ['17+7=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+24=59. \nResulting numbers: [32, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |59-52|)/2 = (20 + 7)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 52:[32, 59] Operation: 35+24=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-32=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 52:[32, 35, 24]. Operations so far : ['17+7=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+35=67. \nResulting numbers: [24, 67].\nHeuristic score : (|24-52| + |67-52|)/2 = (28 + 15)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 52:[24, 67] Operation: 32+35=67\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-24=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 52:[32, 35, 24]. Operations so far : ['17+7=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-24=8. \nResulting numbers: [35, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |8-52|)/2 = (17 + 44)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 52:[35, 8] Operation: 32-24=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+8=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 52:[32, 35, 24]. Operations so far : ['17+7=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-24=11. \nResulting numbers: [32, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |11-52|)/2 = (20 + 41)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 52:[32, 11] Operation: 35-24=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+11=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 52:[32, 35, 24]. Operations so far : ['17+7=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-32=3. \nResulting numbers: [24, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|24-52| + |3-52|)/2 = (28 + 49)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,5: 52:[24, 3] Operation: 35-32=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24*3=72. \nResulting numbers: [72].\n72,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 52:[32, 35, 24]. Operations so far : ['17+7=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*24=768. \nResulting numbers: [35, 768].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |768-52|)/2 = (17 + 716)/2 = 366.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,6: 52:[35, 768] Operation: 32*24=768\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 768-35=733. \nResulting numbers: [733].\n733,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 52:[32, 35, 24]. Operations so far : ['17+7=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*24=840. \nResulting numbers: [32, 840].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |840-52|)/2 = (20 + 788)/2 = 404.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,7: 52:[32, 840] Operation: 35*24=840\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 840-32=808. \nResulting numbers: [808].\n808,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 52:[32, 35, 24]. Operations so far : ['17+7=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*35=1120. \nResulting numbers: [24, 1120].\nHeuristic score : (|24-52| + |1120-52|)/2 = (28 + 1068)/2 = 548.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,8: 52:[24, 1120] Operation: 32*35=1120\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1120-24=1096. \nResulting numbers: [1096].\n1096,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.25\nCurrent State #0: 52:[32, 35, 17, 7]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-7=25. \nResulting numbers: [35, 17, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |17-52| + |25-52|)/3 = (17 + 35 + 27)/3 = 26.33\nGenerated Node #0,5: 52:[35, 17, 25] Operation: 32-7=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+17=52. \nResulting numbers: [25, 52].\nHeuristic score : (|25-52| + |52-52|)/2 = (27 + 0)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,0: 52:[25, 52] Operation: 35+17=52\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+52=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 52:[35, 17, 25]. Operations so far : ['32-7=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+25=42. \nResulting numbers: [35, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |42-52|)/2 = (17 + 10)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,1: 52:[35, 42] Operation: 17+25=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+42=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 52:[35, 17, 25]. Operations so far : ['32-7=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+25=60. \nResulting numbers: [17, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |60-52|)/2 = (35 + 8)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,2: 52:[17, 60] Operation: 35+25=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-17=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 52:[35, 17, 25]. Operations so far : ['32-7=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-17=18. \nResulting numbers: [25, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|25-52| + |18-52|)/2 = (27 + 34)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,3: 52:[25, 18] Operation: 35-17=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25+18=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 52:[35, 17, 25]. Operations so far : ['32-7=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 25-17=8. \nResulting numbers: [35, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |8-52|)/2 = (17 + 44)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,4: 52:[35, 8] Operation: 25-17=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+8=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 52:[35, 17, 25]. Operations so far : ['32-7=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-25=10. \nResulting numbers: [17, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |10-52|)/2 = (35 + 42)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,5,5: 52:[17, 10] Operation: 35-25=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+10=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 52:[35, 17, 25]. Operations so far : ['32-7=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17*25=425. \nResulting numbers: [35, 425].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |425-52|)/2 = (17 + 373)/2 = 195.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,6: 52:[35, 425] Operation: 17*25=425\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 425-35=390. \nResulting numbers: [390].\n390,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 52:[35, 17, 25]. Operations so far : ['32-7=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*17=595. \nResulting numbers: [25, 595].\nHeuristic score : (|25-52| + |595-52|)/2 = (27 + 543)/2 = 285.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,7: 52:[25, 595] Operation: 35*17=595\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 595-25=570. \nResulting numbers: [570].\n570,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,5 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,5: 52:[35, 17, 25]. Operations so far : ['32-7=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*25=875. \nResulting numbers: [17, 875].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |875-52|)/2 = (35 + 823)/2 = 429.00\nGenerated Node #0,5,8: 52:[17, 875] Operation: 35*25=875\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,5,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 875-17=858. \nResulting numbers: [858].\n858,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.25\nCurrent State #0: 52:[32, 35, 17, 7]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-7=28. \nResulting numbers: [32, 17, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |17-52| + |28-52|)/3 = (20 + 35 + 24)/3 = 26.33\nGenerated Node #0,6: 52:[32, 17, 28] Operation: 35-7=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+17=49. \nResulting numbers: [28, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|28-52| + |49-52|)/2 = (24 + 3)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,0: 52:[28, 49] Operation: 32+17=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+49=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 52:[32, 17, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+28=45. \nResulting numbers: [32, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |45-52|)/2 = (20 + 7)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,1: 52:[32, 45] Operation: 17+28=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+45=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 52:[32, 17, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+28=60. \nResulting numbers: [17, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |60-52|)/2 = (35 + 8)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,2: 52:[17, 60] Operation: 32+28=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-17=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 52:[32, 17, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-17=15. \nResulting numbers: [28, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|28-52| + |15-52|)/2 = (24 + 37)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,3: 52:[28, 15] Operation: 32-17=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+15=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 52:[32, 17, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-17=11. \nResulting numbers: [32, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |11-52|)/2 = (20 + 41)/2 = 30.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,4: 52:[32, 11] Operation: 28-17=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+11=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 52:[32, 17, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-28=4. \nResulting numbers: [17, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |4-52|)/2 = (35 + 48)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,5: 52:[17, 4] Operation: 32-28=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17*4=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 52:[32, 17, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17*28=476. \nResulting numbers: [32, 476].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |476-52|)/2 = (20 + 424)/2 = 222.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,6: 52:[32, 476] Operation: 17*28=476\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 476-32=444. \nResulting numbers: [444].\n444,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 52:[32, 17, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*17=544. \nResulting numbers: [28, 544].\nHeuristic score : (|28-52| + |544-52|)/2 = (24 + 492)/2 = 258.00\nGenerated Node #0,6,7: 52:[28, 544] Operation: 32*17=544\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 544-28=516. \nResulting numbers: [516].\n516,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,6 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,6: 52:[32, 17, 28]. Operations so far : ['35-7=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*28=896. \nResulting numbers: [17, 896].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |896-52|)/2 = (35 + 844)/2 = 439.50\nGenerated Node #0,6,8: 52:[17, 896] Operation: 32*28=896\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,6,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 896-17=879. \nResulting numbers: [879].\n879,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.25\nCurrent State #0: 52:[32, 35, 17, 7]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17-7=10. \nResulting numbers: [32, 35, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |35-52| + |10-52|)/3 = (20 + 17 + 42)/3 = 26.33\nGenerated Node #0,7: 52:[32, 35, 10] Operation: 17-7=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+10=42. \nResulting numbers: [35, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |42-52|)/2 = (17 + 10)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,0: 52:[35, 42] Operation: 32+10=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+42=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,7: 52:[32, 35, 10]. Operations so far : ['17-7=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+10=45. \nResulting numbers: [32, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |45-52|)/2 = (20 + 7)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,1: 52:[32, 45] Operation: 35+10=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+45=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,7: 52:[32, 35, 10]. Operations so far : ['17-7=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32-10=22. \nResulting numbers: [35, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |22-52|)/2 = (17 + 30)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,2: 52:[35, 22] Operation: 32-10=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35+22=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,7: 52:[32, 35, 10]. Operations so far : ['17-7=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-10=25. \nResulting numbers: [32, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |25-52|)/2 = (20 + 27)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,3: 52:[32, 25] Operation: 35-10=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+25=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,7: 52:[32, 35, 10]. Operations so far : ['17-7=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+35=67. \nResulting numbers: [10, 67].\nHeuristic score : (|10-52| + |67-52|)/2 = (42 + 15)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,4: 52:[10, 67] Operation: 32+35=67\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-10=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,7: 52:[32, 35, 10]. Operations so far : ['17-7=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-32=3. \nResulting numbers: [10, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|10-52| + |3-52|)/2 = (42 + 49)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,5: 52:[10, 3] Operation: 35-32=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 10*3=30. \nResulting numbers: [30].\n30,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,7: 52:[32, 35, 10]. Operations so far : ['17-7=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*10=320. \nResulting numbers: [35, 320].\nHeuristic score : (|35-52| + |320-52|)/2 = (17 + 268)/2 = 142.50\nGenerated Node #0,7,6: 52:[35, 320] Operation: 32*10=320\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 320-35=285. \nResulting numbers: [285].\n285,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,7: 52:[32, 35, 10]. Operations so far : ['17-7=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35*10=350. \nResulting numbers: [32, 350].\nHeuristic score : (|32-52| + |350-52|)/2 = (20 + 298)/2 = 159.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,7: 52:[32, 350] Operation: 35*10=350\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 350-32=318. \nResulting numbers: [318].\n318,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,7 with lowest heuristic value 26.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,7: 52:[32, 35, 10]. Operations so far : ['17-7=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32*35=1120. \nResulting numbers: [10, 1120].\nHeuristic score : (|10-52| + |1120-52|)/2 = (42 + 1068)/2 = 555.00\nGenerated Node #0,7,8: 52:[10, 1120] Operation: 32*35=1120\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,7,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1120/10=112. \nResulting numbers: [112].\n112,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 29.25\nCurrent State #0: 52:[32, 35, 17, 7]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 32+35=67. \nResulting numbers: [17, 7, 67].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |7-52| + |67-52|)/3 = (35 + 45 + 15)/3 = 31.67\nGenerated Node #0,8: 52:[17, 7, 67] Operation: 32+35=67\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+7=24. \nResulting numbers: [67, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|67-52| + |24-52|)/2 = (15 + 28)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,0: 52:[67, 24] Operation: 17+7=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-24=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,8: 52:[17, 7, 67]. Operations so far : ['32+35=67'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-7=60. \nResulting numbers: [17, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |60-52|)/2 = (35 + 8)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,1: 52:[17, 60] Operation: 67-7=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 60-17=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,8: 52:[17, 7, 67]. Operations so far : ['32+35=67'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-17=50. \nResulting numbers: [7, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|7-52| + |50-52|)/2 = (45 + 2)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,2: 52:[7, 50] Operation: 67-17=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+50=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,8: 52:[17, 7, 67]. Operations so far : ['32+35=67'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17-7=10. \nResulting numbers: [67, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|67-52| + |10-52|)/2 = (15 + 42)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,3: 52:[67, 10] Operation: 17-7=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-10=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,8: 52:[17, 7, 67]. Operations so far : ['32+35=67'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+67=74. \nResulting numbers: [17, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|17-52| + |74-52|)/2 = (35 + 22)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,4: 52:[17, 74] Operation: 7+67=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-17=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,8: 52:[17, 7, 67]. Operations so far : ['32+35=67'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17+67=84. \nResulting numbers: [7, 84].\nHeuristic score : (|7-52| + |84-52|)/2 = (45 + 32)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,8,5: 52:[7, 84] Operation: 17+67=84\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 84-7=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,52 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,8 with lowest heuristic value 31.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,8: 52:[17, 7, 67]. Operations so far : ['32+35=67'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 17*7=119. \nResulting numbers: [67, 119].\nHeuristic score : (|67-52| + |119-52|)/2 = (15 + 67)/2 = 41.00\nGenerated Node #0,8,6: 52:[67, 119] Operation: 17*7=119\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,8,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 119-67=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,52 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['32+35=67', '17*7=119', '119-67=52']\nRESULT: 52\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 18,970 |
[
28,
79,
38,
12
]
| 77 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [28, 79, 38, 12] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 77. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [28, 79, 38, 12]. Our goal is to produce 77. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 77:[28, 79, 38, 12]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+38=66. \nResulting numbers: [79, 12, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|79-77| + |12-77| + |66-77|)/3 = (2 + 65 + 11)/3 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 77:[79, 12, 66] Operation: 28+38=66\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+12=50. \nResulting numbers: [28, 79, 50].\nHeuristic score : (|28-77| + |79-77| + |50-77|)/3 = (49 + 2 + 27)/3 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 77:[28, 79, 50] Operation: 38+12=50\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28-12=16. \nResulting numbers: [79, 38, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|79-77| + |38-77| + |16-77|)/3 = (2 + 39 + 61)/3 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 77:[79, 38, 16] Operation: 28-12=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-12=67. \nResulting numbers: [28, 38, 67].\nHeuristic score : (|28-77| + |38-77| + |67-77|)/3 = (49 + 39 + 10)/3 = 32.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 77:[28, 38, 67] Operation: 79-12=67\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+12=40. \nResulting numbers: [79, 38, 40].\nHeuristic score : (|79-77| + |38-77| + |40-77|)/3 = (2 + 39 + 37)/3 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 77:[79, 38, 40] Operation: 28+12=40\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 77:[79, 12, 66]. Operations so far : ['28+38=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66-12=54. \nResulting numbers: [79, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|79-77| + |54-77|)/2 = (2 + 23)/2 = 12.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 77:[79, 54] Operation: 66-12=54\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 12+66=78. \nResulting numbers: [79, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|79-77| + |78-77|)/2 = (2 + 1)/2 = 1.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 77:[79, 78] Operation: 12+66=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-12=67. \nResulting numbers: [66, 67].\nHeuristic score : (|66-77| + |67-77|)/2 = (11 + 10)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 77:[66, 67] Operation: 79-12=67\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+12=91. \nResulting numbers: [66, 91].\nHeuristic score : (|66-77| + |91-77|)/2 = (11 + 14)/2 = 12.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 77:[66, 91] Operation: 79+12=91\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-66=13. \nResulting numbers: [12, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|12-77| + |13-77|)/2 = (65 + 64)/2 = 64.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 77:[12, 13] Operation: 79-66=13\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 77:[79, 38, 40]. Operations so far : ['28+12=40'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40-38=2. \nResulting numbers: [79, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|79-77| + |2-77|)/2 = (2 + 75)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 77:[79, 2] Operation: 40-38=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-38=41. \nResulting numbers: [40, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|40-77| + |41-77|)/2 = (37 + 36)/2 = 36.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 77:[40, 41] Operation: 79-38=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-40=39. \nResulting numbers: [38, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|38-77| + |39-77|)/2 = (39 + 38)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 77:[38, 39] Operation: 79-40=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+38=117. \nResulting numbers: [40, 117].\nHeuristic score : (|40-77| + |117-77|)/2 = (37 + 40)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 77:[40, 117] Operation: 79+38=117\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+40=78. \nResulting numbers: [79, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|79-77| + |78-77|)/2 = (2 + 1)/2 = 1.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 77:[79, 78] Operation: 38+40=78\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 77:[28, 79, 50]. Operations so far : ['38+12=50'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50-28=22. \nResulting numbers: [79, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|79-77| + |22-77|)/2 = (2 + 55)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 77:[79, 22] Operation: 50-28=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-28=51. \nResulting numbers: [50, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|50-77| + |51-77|)/2 = (27 + 26)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 77:[50, 51] Operation: 79-28=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-50=29. \nResulting numbers: [28, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|28-77| + |29-77|)/2 = (49 + 48)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 77:[28, 29] Operation: 79-50=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+50=78. \nResulting numbers: [79, 78].\nHeuristic score : (|79-77| + |78-77|)/2 = (2 + 1)/2 = 1.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 77:[79, 78] Operation: 28+50=78\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+79=107. \nResulting numbers: [50, 107].\nHeuristic score : (|50-77| + |107-77|)/2 = (27 + 30)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 77:[50, 107] Operation: 28+79=107\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 32.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 77:[28, 38, 67]. Operations so far : ['79-12=67'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+67=95. \nResulting numbers: [38, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|38-77| + |95-77|)/2 = (39 + 18)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 77:[38, 95] Operation: 28+67=95\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-28=39. \nResulting numbers: [38, 39].\nHeuristic score : (|38-77| + |39-77|)/2 = (39 + 38)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 77:[38, 39] Operation: 67-28=39\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-28=10. \nResulting numbers: [67, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|67-77| + |10-77|)/2 = (10 + 67)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 77:[67, 10] Operation: 38-28=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+67=105. \nResulting numbers: [28, 105].\nHeuristic score : (|28-77| + |105-77|)/2 = (49 + 28)/2 = 38.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 77:[28, 105] Operation: 38+67=105\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 28+38=66. \nResulting numbers: [67, 66].\nHeuristic score : (|67-77| + |66-77|)/2 = (10 + 11)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 77:[67, 66] Operation: 28+38=66\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 34.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 77:[79, 38, 16]. Operations so far : ['28-12=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+16=95. \nResulting numbers: [38, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|38-77| + |95-77|)/2 = (39 + 18)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 77:[38, 95] Operation: 79+16=95\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+16=54. \nResulting numbers: [79, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|79-77| + |54-77|)/2 = (2 + 23)/2 = 12.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 77:[79, 54] Operation: 38+16=54\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-38=41. \nResulting numbers: [16, 41].\nHeuristic score : (|16-77| + |41-77|)/2 = (61 + 36)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 77:[16, 41] Operation: 79-38=41\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-16=63. \nResulting numbers: [38, 63].\nHeuristic score : (|38-77| + |63-77|)/2 = (39 + 14)/2 = 26.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 77:[38, 63] Operation: 79-16=63\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38-16=22. \nResulting numbers: [79, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|79-77| + |22-77|)/2 = (2 + 55)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 77:[79, 22] Operation: 38-16=22\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 1.5\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 77:[79, 78]. Operations so far : ['28+38=66', '12+66=78'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-78=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*78=6162. \nResulting numbers: [6162].\n6162,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+78=157. \nResulting numbers: [157].\n157,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 1.5\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 77:[79, 78]. Operations so far : ['28+12=40', '38+40=78'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*78=6162. \nResulting numbers: [6162].\n6162,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-78=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+78=157. \nResulting numbers: [157].\n157,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 1.5\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 77:[79, 78]. Operations so far : ['38+12=50', '28+50=78'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-78=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*78=6162. \nResulting numbers: [6162].\n6162,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+78=157. \nResulting numbers: [157].\n157,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 77:[66, 67]. Operations so far : ['28+38=66', '79-12=67'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-66=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+67=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66*67=4422. \nResulting numbers: [4422].\n4422,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,4 with lowest heuristic value 10.5\nCurrent State #0,3,4: 77:[67, 66]. Operations so far : ['79-12=67', '28+38=66'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67*66=4422. \nResulting numbers: [4422].\n4422,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67+66=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-66=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 12.5\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 77:[79, 54]. Operations so far : ['28+38=66', '66-12=54'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*54=4266. \nResulting numbers: [4266].\n4266,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+54=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-54=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 12.5\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 77:[79, 54]. Operations so far : ['28-12=16', '38+16=54'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-54=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*54=4266. \nResulting numbers: [4266].\n4266,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+54=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 12.5\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 77:[66, 91]. Operations so far : ['28+38=66', '79+12=91'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 91-66=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66+91=157. \nResulting numbers: [157].\n157,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 66*91=6006. \nResulting numbers: [6006].\n6006,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 26.5\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 77:[50, 51]. Operations so far : ['38+12=50', '79-28=51'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+51=101. \nResulting numbers: [101].\n101,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*51=2550. \nResulting numbers: [2550].\n2550,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-50=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 26.5\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 77:[38, 63]. Operations so far : ['28-12=16', '79-16=63'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+63=101. \nResulting numbers: [101].\n101,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 63-38=25. \nResulting numbers: [25].\n25,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38*63=2394. \nResulting numbers: [2394].\n2394,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,1,1,0: 77:[101]. Operations so far : ['38+12=50', '79-28=51', '50+51=101'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,2,3,0: 77:[101]. Operations so far : ['28-12=16', '79-16=63', '38+63=101'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 28.5\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 77:[79, 22]. Operations so far : ['38+12=50', '50-28=22'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*22=1738. \nResulting numbers: [1738].\n1738,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+22=101. \nResulting numbers: [101].\n101,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-22=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.5\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 77:[79, 22]. Operations so far : ['28-12=16', '38-16=22'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+22=101. \nResulting numbers: [101].\n101,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*22=1738. \nResulting numbers: [1738].\n1738,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-22=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 77:[50, 107]. Operations so far : ['38+12=50', '28+79=107'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50*107=5350. \nResulting numbers: [5350].\n5350,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 107-50=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 50+107=157. \nResulting numbers: [157].\n157,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 20\nCurrent State #0,1,0,2: 77:[57]. Operations so far : ['38+12=50', '50-28=22', '79-22=57'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 20\nCurrent State #0,2,4,2: 77:[57]. Operations so far : ['28-12=16', '38-16=22', '79-22=57'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 20\nCurrent State #0,1,4,1: 77:[57]. Operations so far : ['38+12=50', '28+79=107', '107-50=57'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 77:[101]. Operations so far : ['38+12=50', '50-28=22', '79+22=101'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,2,4,0: 77:[101]. Operations so far : ['28-12=16', '38-16=22', '79+22=101'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 28.5\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 77:[38, 95]. Operations so far : ['79-12=67', '28+67=95'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-38=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+95=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38*95=3610. \nResulting numbers: [3610].\n3610,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 28.5\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 77:[38, 95]. Operations so far : ['28-12=16', '79+16=95'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 95-38=57. \nResulting numbers: [57].\n57,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38*95=3610. \nResulting numbers: [3610].\n3610,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+95=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 36.5\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 77:[40, 41]. Operations so far : ['28+12=40', '79-38=41'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 41-40=1. \nResulting numbers: [1].\n1,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*41=1640. \nResulting numbers: [1640].\n1640,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+41=81. \nResulting numbers: [81].\n81,77 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,3 with lowest heuristic value 38.5\nCurrent State #0,4,3: 77:[40, 117]. Operations so far : ['28+12=40', '79+38=117'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40*117=4680. \nResulting numbers: [4680].\n4680,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 40+117=157. \nResulting numbers: [157].\n157,77 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 117-40=77. \nResulting numbers: [77].\n77,77 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['28+12=40', '79+38=117', '117-40=77']\nRESULT: 77\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 8,257 |
[
59,
88,
24,
80
]
| 91 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [59, 88, 24, 80] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 91. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [59, 88, 24, 80]. Our goal is to produce 91. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 91:[59, 88, 24, 80]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+24=83. \nResulting numbers: [88, 80, 83].\nHeuristic score : (|88-91| + |80-91| + |83-91|)/3 = (3 + 11 + 8)/3 = 7.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 91:[88, 80, 83] Operation: 59+24=83\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+24=112. \nResulting numbers: [59, 80, 112].\nHeuristic score : (|59-91| + |80-91| + |112-91|)/3 = (32 + 11 + 21)/3 = 21.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 91:[59, 80, 112] Operation: 88+24=112\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59-24=35. \nResulting numbers: [88, 80, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|88-91| + |80-91| + |35-91|)/3 = (3 + 11 + 56)/3 = 23.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 91:[88, 80, 35] Operation: 59-24=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-24=64. \nResulting numbers: [59, 80, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|59-91| + |80-91| + |64-91|)/3 = (32 + 11 + 27)/3 = 23.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 91:[59, 80, 64] Operation: 88-24=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+80=104. \nResulting numbers: [59, 88, 104].\nHeuristic score : (|59-91| + |88-91| + |104-91|)/3 = (32 + 3 + 13)/3 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 91:[59, 88, 104] Operation: 24+80=104\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.333333333333333\nCurrent State #0,0: 91:[88, 80, 83]. Operations so far : ['59+24=83'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-80=8. \nResulting numbers: [83, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|83-91| + |8-91|)/2 = (8 + 83)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 91:[83, 8] Operation: 88-80=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+83=163. \nResulting numbers: [88, 163].\nHeuristic score : (|88-91| + |163-91|)/2 = (3 + 72)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 91:[88, 163] Operation: 80+83=163\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+83=171. \nResulting numbers: [80, 171].\nHeuristic score : (|80-91| + |171-91|)/2 = (11 + 80)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 91:[80, 171] Operation: 88+83=171\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83-80=3. \nResulting numbers: [88, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|88-91| + |3-91|)/2 = (3 + 88)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 91:[88, 3] Operation: 83-80=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+80=168. \nResulting numbers: [83, 168].\nHeuristic score : (|83-91| + |168-91|)/2 = (8 + 77)/2 = 42.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 91:[83, 168] Operation: 88+80=168\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 16.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 91:[59, 88, 104]. Operations so far : ['24+80=104'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-59=29. \nResulting numbers: [104, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|104-91| + |29-91|)/2 = (13 + 62)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 91:[104, 29] Operation: 88-59=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104-59=45. \nResulting numbers: [88, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|88-91| + |45-91|)/2 = (3 + 46)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 91:[88, 45] Operation: 104-59=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+88=147. \nResulting numbers: [104, 147].\nHeuristic score : (|104-91| + |147-91|)/2 = (13 + 56)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 91:[104, 147] Operation: 59+88=147\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104-88=16. \nResulting numbers: [59, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|59-91| + |16-91|)/2 = (32 + 75)/2 = 53.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 91:[59, 16] Operation: 104-88=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+104=163. \nResulting numbers: [88, 163].\nHeuristic score : (|88-91| + |163-91|)/2 = (3 + 72)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 91:[88, 163] Operation: 59+104=163\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 91:[59, 80, 112]. Operations so far : ['88+24=112'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112-80=32. \nResulting numbers: [59, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|59-91| + |32-91|)/2 = (32 + 59)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 91:[59, 32] Operation: 112-80=32\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112-59=53. \nResulting numbers: [80, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|80-91| + |53-91|)/2 = (11 + 38)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 91:[80, 53] Operation: 112-59=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-59=21. \nResulting numbers: [112, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|112-91| + |21-91|)/2 = (21 + 70)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 91:[112, 21] Operation: 80-59=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+80=139. \nResulting numbers: [112, 139].\nHeuristic score : (|112-91| + |139-91|)/2 = (21 + 48)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 91:[112, 139] Operation: 59+80=139\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+112=171. \nResulting numbers: [80, 171].\nHeuristic score : (|80-91| + |171-91|)/2 = (11 + 80)/2 = 45.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 91:[80, 171] Operation: 59+112=171\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 91:[88, 80, 35]. Operations so far : ['59-24=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+80=168. \nResulting numbers: [35, 168].\nHeuristic score : (|35-91| + |168-91|)/2 = (56 + 77)/2 = 66.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 91:[35, 168] Operation: 88+80=168\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-35=53. \nResulting numbers: [80, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|80-91| + |53-91|)/2 = (11 + 38)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 91:[80, 53] Operation: 88-35=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+35=123. \nResulting numbers: [80, 123].\nHeuristic score : (|80-91| + |123-91|)/2 = (11 + 32)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 91:[80, 123] Operation: 88+35=123\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+35=115. \nResulting numbers: [88, 115].\nHeuristic score : (|88-91| + |115-91|)/2 = (3 + 24)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 91:[88, 115] Operation: 80+35=115\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-35=45. \nResulting numbers: [88, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|88-91| + |45-91|)/2 = (3 + 46)/2 = 24.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 91:[88, 45] Operation: 80-35=45\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 91:[59, 80, 64]. Operations so far : ['88-24=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-59=21. \nResulting numbers: [64, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|64-91| + |21-91|)/2 = (27 + 70)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 91:[64, 21] Operation: 80-59=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+80=139. \nResulting numbers: [64, 139].\nHeuristic score : (|64-91| + |139-91|)/2 = (27 + 48)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 91:[64, 139] Operation: 59+80=139\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+64=144. \nResulting numbers: [59, 144].\nHeuristic score : (|59-91| + |144-91|)/2 = (32 + 53)/2 = 42.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 91:[59, 144] Operation: 80+64=144\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+64=123. \nResulting numbers: [80, 123].\nHeuristic score : (|80-91| + |123-91|)/2 = (11 + 32)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 91:[80, 123] Operation: 59+64=123\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-59=5. \nResulting numbers: [80, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|80-91| + |5-91|)/2 = (11 + 86)/2 = 48.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 91:[80, 5] Operation: 64-59=5\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 13.5\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 91:[88, 115]. Operations so far : ['59-24=35', '80+35=115'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88*115=10120. \nResulting numbers: [10120].\n10120,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+115=203. \nResulting numbers: [203].\n203,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 115-88=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 91:[80, 123]. Operations so far : ['59-24=35', '88+35=123'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+123=203. \nResulting numbers: [203].\n203,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 123-80=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*123=9840. \nResulting numbers: [9840].\n9840,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.5\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 91:[80, 123]. Operations so far : ['88-24=64', '59+64=123'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+123=203. \nResulting numbers: [203].\n203,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 123-80=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*123=9840. \nResulting numbers: [9840].\n9840,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 24.5\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 91:[88, 45]. Operations so far : ['24+80=104', '104-59=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88*45=3960. \nResulting numbers: [3960].\n3960,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+45=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-45=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 24.5\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 91:[80, 53]. Operations so far : ['59-24=35', '88-35=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+53=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-53=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*53=4240. \nResulting numbers: [4240].\n4240,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 24.5\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 91:[88, 45]. Operations so far : ['59-24=35', '80-35=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88*45=3960. \nResulting numbers: [3960].\n3960,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+45=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-45=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 24.5\nCurrent State #0,1,1: 91:[80, 53]. Operations so far : ['88+24=112', '112-59=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80*53=4240. \nResulting numbers: [4240].\n4240,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-53=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+53=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 91:[104, 147]. Operations so far : ['24+80=104', '59+88=147'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104+147=251. \nResulting numbers: [251].\n251,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 147-104=43. \nResulting numbers: [43].\n43,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104*147=15288. \nResulting numbers: [15288].\n15288,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 91:[112, 139]. Operations so far : ['88+24=112', '59+80=139'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 139-112=27. \nResulting numbers: [27].\n27,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112*139=15568. \nResulting numbers: [15568].\n15568,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 112+139=251. \nResulting numbers: [251].\n251,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 37.5\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 91:[88, 163]. Operations so far : ['59+24=83', '80+83=163'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 163-88=75. \nResulting numbers: [75].\n75,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88*163=14344. \nResulting numbers: [14344].\n14344,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+163=251. \nResulting numbers: [251].\n251,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,0,1,0: 91:[75]. Operations so far : ['59+24=83', '80+83=163', '163-88=75'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 37.5\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 91:[64, 139]. Operations so far : ['88-24=64', '59+80=139'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64*139=8896. \nResulting numbers: [8896].\n8896,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 139-64=75. \nResulting numbers: [75].\n75,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64+139=203. \nResulting numbers: [203].\n203,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 37.5\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 91:[104, 29]. Operations so far : ['24+80=104', '88-59=29'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104*29=3016. \nResulting numbers: [3016].\n3016,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104-29=75. \nResulting numbers: [75].\n75,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 104+29=133. \nResulting numbers: [133].\n133,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 37.5\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 91:[88, 163]. Operations so far : ['24+80=104', '59+104=163'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88*163=14344. \nResulting numbers: [14344].\n14344,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 163-88=75. \nResulting numbers: [75].\n75,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+163=251. \nResulting numbers: [251].\n251,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 42\nCurrent State #0,4,1,1: 91:[133]. Operations so far : ['24+80=104', '104-59=45', '88+45=133'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1,1 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,3,1,1: 91:[75]. Operations so far : ['88-24=64', '59+80=139', '139-64=75'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,4,0,1: 91:[75]. Operations so far : ['24+80=104', '88-59=29', '104-29=75'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 16\nCurrent State #0,4,4,1: 91:[75]. Operations so far : ['24+80=104', '59+104=163', '163-88=75'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 42\nCurrent State #0,2,4,1: 91:[133]. Operations so far : ['59-24=35', '80-35=45', '88+45=133'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 42\nCurrent State #0,2,1,0: 91:[133]. Operations so far : ['59-24=35', '88-35=53', '80+53=133'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 42\nCurrent State #0,4,0,2: 91:[133]. Operations so far : ['24+80=104', '88-59=29', '104+29=133'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 42\nCurrent State #0,1,1,2: 91:[133]. Operations so far : ['88+24=112', '112-59=53', '80+53=133'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 42.5\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 91:[59, 144]. Operations so far : ['88-24=64', '80+64=144'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59+144=203. \nResulting numbers: [203].\n203,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 59*144=8496. \nResulting numbers: [8496].\n8496,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 144-59=85. \nResulting numbers: [85].\n85,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 42.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 91:[83, 168]. Operations so far : ['59+24=83', '88+80=168'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83+168=251. \nResulting numbers: [251].\n251,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 83*168=13944. \nResulting numbers: [13944].\n13944,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 168-83=85. \nResulting numbers: [85].\n85,91 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 45.5\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 91:[80, 171]. Operations so far : ['88+24=112', '59+112=171'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80+171=251. \nResulting numbers: [251].\n251,91 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 171-80=91. \nResulting numbers: [91].\n91,91 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['88+24=112', '59+112=171', '171-80=91']\nRESULT: 91\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 8,142 |
[
65,
51,
30,
29
]
| 15 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [65, 51, 30, 29] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 15. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [65, 51, 30, 29]. Our goal is to produce 15. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 15:[65, 51, 30, 29]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-51=14. \nResulting numbers: [30, 29, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|30-15| + |29-15| + |14-15|)/3 = (15 + 14 + 1)/3 = 10.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 15:[30, 29, 14] Operation: 65-51=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-30=35. \nResulting numbers: [51, 29, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|51-15| + |29-15| + |35-15|)/3 = (36 + 14 + 20)/3 = 23.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 15:[51, 29, 35] Operation: 65-30=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-29=22. \nResulting numbers: [65, 30, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|65-15| + |30-15| + |22-15|)/3 = (50 + 15 + 7)/3 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 15:[65, 30, 22] Operation: 51-29=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-30=21. \nResulting numbers: [65, 29, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|65-15| + |29-15| + |21-15|)/3 = (50 + 14 + 6)/3 = 23.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 15:[65, 29, 21] Operation: 51-30=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-29=36. \nResulting numbers: [51, 30, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|51-15| + |30-15| + |36-15|)/3 = (36 + 15 + 21)/3 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 15:[51, 30, 36] Operation: 65-29=36\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 15:[30, 29, 14]. Operations so far : ['65-51=14'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29+14=43. \nResulting numbers: [30, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|30-15| + |43-15|)/2 = (15 + 28)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 15:[30, 43] Operation: 29+14=43\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30+14=44. \nResulting numbers: [29, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|29-15| + |44-15|)/2 = (14 + 29)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 15:[29, 44] Operation: 30+14=44\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-14=16. \nResulting numbers: [29, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|29-15| + |16-15|)/2 = (14 + 1)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 15:[29, 16] Operation: 30-14=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29-14=15. \nResulting numbers: [30, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|30-15| + |15-15|)/2 = (15 + 0)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 15:[30, 15] Operation: 29-14=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-29=1. \nResulting numbers: [14, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|14-15| + |1-15|)/2 = (1 + 14)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 15:[14, 1] Operation: 30-29=1\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 15:[65, 29, 21]. Operations so far : ['51-30=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-29=36. \nResulting numbers: [21, 36].\nHeuristic score : (|21-15| + |36-15|)/2 = (6 + 21)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 15:[21, 36] Operation: 65-29=36\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+21=86. \nResulting numbers: [29, 86].\nHeuristic score : (|29-15| + |86-15|)/2 = (14 + 71)/2 = 42.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 15:[29, 86] Operation: 65+21=86\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29-21=8. \nResulting numbers: [65, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|65-15| + |8-15|)/2 = (50 + 7)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 15:[65, 8] Operation: 29-21=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+29=94. \nResulting numbers: [21, 94].\nHeuristic score : (|21-15| + |94-15|)/2 = (6 + 79)/2 = 42.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 15:[21, 94] Operation: 65+29=94\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-21=44. \nResulting numbers: [29, 44].\nHeuristic score : (|29-15| + |44-15|)/2 = (14 + 29)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 15:[29, 44] Operation: 65-21=44\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 23.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 15:[51, 29, 35]. Operations so far : ['65-30=35'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+35=86. \nResulting numbers: [29, 86].\nHeuristic score : (|29-15| + |86-15|)/2 = (14 + 71)/2 = 42.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 15:[29, 86] Operation: 51+35=86\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 35-29=6. \nResulting numbers: [51, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|51-15| + |6-15|)/2 = (36 + 9)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 15:[51, 6] Operation: 35-29=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-35=16. \nResulting numbers: [29, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|29-15| + |16-15|)/2 = (14 + 1)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 15:[29, 16] Operation: 51-35=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-29=22. \nResulting numbers: [35, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |22-15|)/2 = (20 + 7)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 15:[35, 22] Operation: 51-29=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+29=80. \nResulting numbers: [35, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|35-15| + |80-15|)/2 = (20 + 65)/2 = 42.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 15:[35, 80] Operation: 51+29=80\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 15:[65, 30, 22]. Operations so far : ['51-29=22'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-22=43. \nResulting numbers: [30, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|30-15| + |43-15|)/2 = (15 + 28)/2 = 21.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 15:[30, 43] Operation: 65-22=43\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-22=8. \nResulting numbers: [65, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|65-15| + |8-15|)/2 = (50 + 7)/2 = 28.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 15:[65, 8] Operation: 30-22=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+22=87. \nResulting numbers: [30, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|30-15| + |87-15|)/2 = (15 + 72)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 15:[30, 87] Operation: 65+22=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65-30=35. \nResulting numbers: [22, 35].\nHeuristic score : (|22-15| + |35-15|)/2 = (7 + 20)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 15:[22, 35] Operation: 65-30=35\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 65+30=95. \nResulting numbers: [22, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|22-15| + |95-15|)/2 = (7 + 80)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 15:[22, 95] Operation: 65+30=95\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 24.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 15:[51, 30, 36]. Operations so far : ['65-29=36'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+30=81. \nResulting numbers: [36, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|36-15| + |81-15|)/2 = (21 + 66)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 15:[36, 81] Operation: 51+30=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 36-30=6. \nResulting numbers: [51, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|51-15| + |6-15|)/2 = (36 + 9)/2 = 22.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 15:[51, 6] Operation: 36-30=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-30=21. \nResulting numbers: [36, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|36-15| + |21-15|)/2 = (21 + 6)/2 = 13.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 15:[36, 21] Operation: 51-30=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51+36=87. \nResulting numbers: [30, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|30-15| + |87-15|)/2 = (15 + 72)/2 = 43.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 15:[30, 87] Operation: 51+36=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-36=15. \nResulting numbers: [30, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|30-15| + |15-15|)/2 = (15 + 0)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 15:[30, 15] Operation: 51-36=15\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 15:[29, 16]. Operations so far : ['65-51=14', '30-14=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29-16=13. \nResulting numbers: [13].\n13,15 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29*16=464. \nResulting numbers: [464].\n464,15 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 29+16=45. \nResulting numbers: [45].\n45,15 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 7.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 15:[14, 1]. Operations so far : ['65-51=14', '30-29=1'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 14+1=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,15 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['65-51=14', '30-29=1', '14/1=14']\nRESULT: 14\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 3,974 |
[
7,
87,
23,
15
]
| 42 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [7, 87, 23, 15] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 42. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [7, 87, 23, 15]. Our goal is to produce 42. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 42:[7, 87, 23, 15]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-23=64. \nResulting numbers: [7, 15, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|7-42| + |15-42| + |64-42|)/3 = (35 + 27 + 22)/3 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 42:[7, 15, 64] Operation: 87-23=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+23=30. \nResulting numbers: [87, 15, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|87-42| + |15-42| + |30-42|)/3 = (45 + 27 + 12)/3 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 42:[87, 15, 30] Operation: 7+23=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-7=80. \nResulting numbers: [23, 15, 80].\nHeuristic score : (|23-42| + |15-42| + |80-42|)/3 = (19 + 27 + 38)/3 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 42:[23, 15, 80] Operation: 87-7=80\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+15=22. \nResulting numbers: [87, 23, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|87-42| + |23-42| + |22-42|)/3 = (45 + 19 + 20)/3 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,3: 42:[87, 23, 22] Operation: 7+15=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-15=72. \nResulting numbers: [7, 23, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|7-42| + |23-42| + |72-42|)/3 = (35 + 19 + 30)/3 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,4: 42:[7, 23, 72] Operation: 87-15=72\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 42:[7, 15, 64]. Operations so far : ['87-23=64'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-15=49. \nResulting numbers: [7, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|7-42| + |49-42|)/2 = (35 + 7)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 42:[7, 49] Operation: 64-15=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 64-7=57. \nResulting numbers: [15, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|15-42| + |57-42|)/2 = (27 + 15)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 42:[15, 57] Operation: 64-7=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 15-7=8. \nResulting numbers: [64, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|64-42| + |8-42|)/2 = (22 + 34)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 42:[64, 8] Operation: 15-7=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+15=22. \nResulting numbers: [64, 22].\nHeuristic score : (|64-42| + |22-42|)/2 = (22 + 20)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 42:[64, 22] Operation: 7+15=22\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+64=71. \nResulting numbers: [15, 71].\nHeuristic score : (|15-42| + |71-42|)/2 = (27 + 29)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 42:[15, 71] Operation: 7+64=71\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 42:[23, 15, 80]. Operations so far : ['87-7=80'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23-15=8. \nResulting numbers: [80, 8].\nHeuristic score : (|80-42| + |8-42|)/2 = (38 + 34)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 42:[80, 8] Operation: 23-15=8\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-23=57. \nResulting numbers: [15, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|15-42| + |57-42|)/2 = (27 + 15)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 42:[15, 57] Operation: 80-23=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 80-15=65. \nResulting numbers: [23, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|23-42| + |65-42|)/2 = (19 + 23)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 42:[23, 65] Operation: 80-15=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 15+80=95. \nResulting numbers: [23, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|23-42| + |95-42|)/2 = (19 + 53)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 42:[23, 95] Operation: 15+80=95\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+15=38. \nResulting numbers: [80, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|80-42| + |38-42|)/2 = (38 + 4)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 42:[80, 38] Operation: 23+15=38\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,4: 42:[7, 23, 72]. Operations so far : ['87-15=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23-7=16. \nResulting numbers: [72, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|72-42| + |16-42|)/2 = (30 + 26)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 42:[72, 16] Operation: 23-7=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-23=49. \nResulting numbers: [7, 49].\nHeuristic score : (|7-42| + |49-42|)/2 = (35 + 7)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 42:[7, 49] Operation: 72-23=49\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+23=30. \nResulting numbers: [72, 30].\nHeuristic score : (|72-42| + |30-42|)/2 = (30 + 12)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 42:[72, 30] Operation: 7+23=30\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-7=65. \nResulting numbers: [23, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|23-42| + |65-42|)/2 = (19 + 23)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 42:[23, 65] Operation: 72-7=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+72=79. \nResulting numbers: [23, 79].\nHeuristic score : (|23-42| + |79-42|)/2 = (19 + 37)/2 = 28.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 42:[23, 79] Operation: 7+72=79\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 42:[87, 15, 30]. Operations so far : ['7+23=30'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-15=72. \nResulting numbers: [30, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|30-42| + |72-42|)/2 = (12 + 30)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 42:[30, 72] Operation: 87-15=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87+15=102. \nResulting numbers: [30, 102].\nHeuristic score : (|30-42| + |102-42|)/2 = (12 + 60)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 42:[30, 102] Operation: 87+15=102\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 30-15=15. \nResulting numbers: [87, 15].\nHeuristic score : (|87-42| + |15-42|)/2 = (45 + 27)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 42:[87, 15] Operation: 30-15=15\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-30=57. \nResulting numbers: [15, 57].\nHeuristic score : (|15-42| + |57-42|)/2 = (27 + 15)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 42:[15, 57] Operation: 87-30=57\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 15+30=45. \nResulting numbers: [87, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|87-42| + |45-42|)/2 = (45 + 3)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 42:[87, 45] Operation: 15+30=45\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 28.0\nCurrent State #0,3: 42:[87, 23, 22]. Operations so far : ['7+15=22'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23+22=45. \nResulting numbers: [87, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|87-42| + |45-42|)/2 = (45 + 3)/2 = 24.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 42:[87, 45] Operation: 23+22=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87+22=109. \nResulting numbers: [23, 109].\nHeuristic score : (|23-42| + |109-42|)/2 = (19 + 67)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 42:[23, 109] Operation: 87+22=109\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-22=65. \nResulting numbers: [23, 65].\nHeuristic score : (|23-42| + |65-42|)/2 = (19 + 23)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 42:[23, 65] Operation: 87-22=65\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 87-23=64. \nResulting numbers: [22, 64].\nHeuristic score : (|22-42| + |64-42|)/2 = (20 + 22)/2 = 21.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 42:[22, 64] Operation: 87-23=64\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 23-22=1. \nResulting numbers: [87, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|87-42| + |1-42|)/2 = (45 + 41)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 42:[87, 1] Operation: 23-22=1\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.0\nCurrent State #0,0,0: 42:[7, 49]. Operations so far : ['87-23=64', '64-15=49'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49/7=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,42 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+49=56. \nResulting numbers: [56].\n56,42 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7*49=343. \nResulting numbers: [343].\n343,42 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 49-7=42. \nResulting numbers: [42].\n42,42 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['87-23=64', '64-15=49', '49/7=7']\nRESULT: 7\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 3,879 |
[
52,
79,
18,
24
]
| 16 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [52, 79, 18, 24] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 16. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [52, 79, 18, 24]. Our goal is to produce 16. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 16:[52, 79, 18, 24]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-52=27. \nResulting numbers: [18, 24, 27].\nHeuristic score : (|18-16| + |24-16| + |27-16|)/3 = (2 + 8 + 11)/3 = 7.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 16:[18, 24, 27] Operation: 79-52=27\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27-18=9. \nResulting numbers: [24, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|24-16| + |9-16|)/2 = (8 + 7)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 16:[24, 9] Operation: 27-18=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24-9=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,16 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 16:[18, 24, 27]. Operations so far : ['79-52=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27-24=3. \nResulting numbers: [18, 3].\nHeuristic score : (|18-16| + |3-16|)/2 = (2 + 13)/2 = 7.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 16:[18, 3] Operation: 27-24=3\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 18-3=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,16 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 16:[18, 24, 27]. Operations so far : ['79-52=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24-18=6. \nResulting numbers: [27, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|27-16| + |6-16|)/2 = (11 + 10)/2 = 10.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 16:[27, 6] Operation: 24-18=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 27-6=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,16 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 16:[18, 24, 27]. Operations so far : ['79-52=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 18+24=42. \nResulting numbers: [27, 42].\nHeuristic score : (|27-16| + |42-16|)/2 = (11 + 26)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 16:[27, 42] Operation: 18+24=42\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 42-27=15. \nResulting numbers: [15].\n15,16 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 16:[18, 24, 27]. Operations so far : ['79-52=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 18+27=45. \nResulting numbers: [24, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|24-16| + |45-16|)/2 = (8 + 29)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 16:[24, 45] Operation: 18+27=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 45-24=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,16 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 16:[18, 24, 27]. Operations so far : ['79-52=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 24+27=51. \nResulting numbers: [18, 51].\nHeuristic score : (|18-16| + |51-16|)/2 = (2 + 35)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 16:[18, 51] Operation: 24+27=51\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 51-18=33. \nResulting numbers: [33].\n33,16 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 7.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 16:[18, 24, 27]. Operations so far : ['79-52=27'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 18*24=432. \nResulting numbers: [27, 432].\nHeuristic score : (|27-16| + |432-16|)/2 = (11 + 416)/2 = 213.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 16:[27, 432] Operation: 18*24=432\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 432/27=16. \nResulting numbers: [16].\n16,16 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['79-52=27', '18*24=432', '432/27=16']\nRESULT: 16\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 1,730 |
[
99,
70,
98,
17
]
| 86 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [99, 70, 98, 17] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 86. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [99, 70, 98, 17]. Our goal is to produce 86. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 86:[99, 70, 98, 17]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-17=82. \nResulting numbers: [70, 98, 82].\nHeuristic score : (|70-86| + |98-86| + |82-86|)/3 = (16 + 12 + 4)/3 = 10.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 86:[70, 98, 82] Operation: 99-17=82\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-17=81. \nResulting numbers: [99, 70, 81].\nHeuristic score : (|99-86| + |70-86| + |81-86|)/3 = (13 + 16 + 5)/3 = 11.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 86:[99, 70, 81] Operation: 98-17=81\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-17=53. \nResulting numbers: [99, 98, 53].\nHeuristic score : (|99-86| + |98-86| + |53-86|)/3 = (13 + 12 + 33)/3 = 19.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 86:[99, 98, 53] Operation: 70-17=53\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+17=87. \nResulting numbers: [99, 98, 87].\nHeuristic score : (|99-86| + |98-86| + |87-86|)/3 = (13 + 12 + 1)/3 = 8.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 86:[99, 98, 87] Operation: 70+17=87\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99+17=116. \nResulting numbers: [70, 98, 116].\nHeuristic score : (|70-86| + |98-86| + |116-86|)/3 = (16 + 12 + 30)/3 = 19.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 86:[70, 98, 116] Operation: 99+17=116\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 8.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,3: 86:[99, 98, 87]. Operations so far : ['70+17=87'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-87=12. \nResulting numbers: [98, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|98-86| + |12-86|)/2 = (12 + 74)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 86:[98, 12] Operation: 99-87=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-87=11. \nResulting numbers: [99, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|99-86| + |11-86|)/2 = (13 + 75)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 86:[99, 11] Operation: 98-87=11\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99+98=197. \nResulting numbers: [87, 197].\nHeuristic score : (|87-86| + |197-86|)/2 = (1 + 111)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 86:[87, 197] Operation: 99+98=197\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99+87=186. \nResulting numbers: [98, 186].\nHeuristic score : (|98-86| + |186-86|)/2 = (12 + 100)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 86:[98, 186] Operation: 99+87=186\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-98=1. \nResulting numbers: [87, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|87-86| + |1-86|)/2 = (1 + 85)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 86:[87, 1] Operation: 99-98=1\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 10.666666666666666\nCurrent State #0,0: 86:[70, 98, 82]. Operations so far : ['99-17=82'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-70=12. \nResulting numbers: [98, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|98-86| + |12-86|)/2 = (12 + 74)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 86:[98, 12] Operation: 82-70=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+98=168. \nResulting numbers: [82, 168].\nHeuristic score : (|82-86| + |168-86|)/2 = (4 + 82)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 86:[82, 168] Operation: 70+98=168\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-82=16. \nResulting numbers: [70, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|70-86| + |16-86|)/2 = (16 + 70)/2 = 43.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 86:[70, 16] Operation: 98-82=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+82=152. \nResulting numbers: [98, 152].\nHeuristic score : (|98-86| + |152-86|)/2 = (12 + 66)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 86:[98, 152] Operation: 70+82=152\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-70=28. \nResulting numbers: [82, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|82-86| + |28-86|)/2 = (4 + 58)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 86:[82, 28] Operation: 98-70=28\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 11.333333333333334\nCurrent State #0,1: 86:[99, 70, 81]. Operations so far : ['98-17=81'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-81=18. \nResulting numbers: [70, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|70-86| + |18-86|)/2 = (16 + 68)/2 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 86:[70, 18] Operation: 99-81=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99+70=169. \nResulting numbers: [81, 169].\nHeuristic score : (|81-86| + |169-86|)/2 = (5 + 83)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 86:[81, 169] Operation: 99+70=169\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+81=151. \nResulting numbers: [99, 151].\nHeuristic score : (|99-86| + |151-86|)/2 = (13 + 65)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 86:[99, 151] Operation: 70+81=151\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-70=29. \nResulting numbers: [81, 29].\nHeuristic score : (|81-86| + |29-86|)/2 = (5 + 57)/2 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 86:[81, 29] Operation: 99-70=29\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-70=11. \nResulting numbers: [99, 11].\nHeuristic score : (|99-86| + |11-86|)/2 = (13 + 75)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 86:[99, 11] Operation: 81-70=11\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,2: 86:[99, 98, 53]. Operations so far : ['70-17=53'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-53=45. \nResulting numbers: [99, 45].\nHeuristic score : (|99-86| + |45-86|)/2 = (13 + 41)/2 = 27.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 86:[99, 45] Operation: 98-53=45\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-53=46. \nResulting numbers: [98, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|98-86| + |46-86|)/2 = (12 + 40)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 86:[98, 46] Operation: 99-53=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-98=1. \nResulting numbers: [53, 1].\nHeuristic score : (|53-86| + |1-86|)/2 = (33 + 85)/2 = 59.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 86:[53, 1] Operation: 99-98=1\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+53=151. \nResulting numbers: [99, 151].\nHeuristic score : (|99-86| + |151-86|)/2 = (13 + 65)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 86:[99, 151] Operation: 98+53=151\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99+53=152. \nResulting numbers: [98, 152].\nHeuristic score : (|98-86| + |152-86|)/2 = (12 + 66)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 86:[98, 152] Operation: 99+53=152\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 19.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 86:[70, 98, 116]. Operations so far : ['99+17=116'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-70=28. \nResulting numbers: [116, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|116-86| + |28-86|)/2 = (30 + 58)/2 = 44.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 86:[116, 28] Operation: 98-70=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-70=46. \nResulting numbers: [98, 46].\nHeuristic score : (|98-86| + |46-86|)/2 = (12 + 40)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 86:[98, 46] Operation: 116-70=46\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 116-98=18. \nResulting numbers: [70, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|70-86| + |18-86|)/2 = (16 + 68)/2 = 42.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 86:[70, 18] Operation: 116-98=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+116=186. \nResulting numbers: [98, 186].\nHeuristic score : (|98-86| + |186-86|)/2 = (12 + 100)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 86:[98, 186] Operation: 70+116=186\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+98=168. \nResulting numbers: [116, 168].\nHeuristic score : (|116-86| + |168-86|)/2 = (30 + 82)/2 = 56.00\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 86:[116, 168] Operation: 70+98=168\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 86:[98, 46]. Operations so far : ['70-17=53', '99-53=46'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-46=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+46=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98*46=4508. \nResulting numbers: [4508].\n4508,86 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 86:[98, 46]. Operations so far : ['99+17=116', '116-70=46'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+46=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98*46=4508. \nResulting numbers: [4508].\n4508,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-46=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,86 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 27.0\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 86:[99, 45]. Operations so far : ['70-17=53', '98-53=45'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99*45=4455. \nResulting numbers: [4455].\n4455,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-45=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99+45=144. \nResulting numbers: [144].\n144,86 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 86:[82, 28]. Operations so far : ['99-17=82', '98-70=28'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82+28=110. \nResulting numbers: [110].\n110,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82*28=2296. \nResulting numbers: [2296].\n2296,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 82-28=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,86 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 86:[81, 29]. Operations so far : ['98-17=81', '99-70=29'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*29=2349. \nResulting numbers: [2349].\n2349,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-29=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+29=110. \nResulting numbers: [110].\n110,86 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,0,4,0: 86:[110]. Operations so far : ['99-17=82', '98-70=28', '82+28=110'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 24\nCurrent State #0,1,3,2: 86:[110]. Operations so far : ['98-17=81', '99-70=29', '81+29=110'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 32\nCurrent State #0,2,0,1: 86:[54]. Operations so far : ['70-17=53', '98-53=45', '99-45=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 32\nCurrent State #0,0,4,2: 86:[54]. Operations so far : ['99-17=82', '98-70=28', '82-28=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,2,1,0: 86:[52]. Operations so far : ['70-17=53', '99-53=46', '98-46=52'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,4,1,2: 86:[52]. Operations so far : ['99+17=116', '116-70=46', '98-46=52'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,1,3,1: 86:[52]. Operations so far : ['98-17=81', '99-70=29', '81-29=52'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 39.0\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 86:[99, 151]. Operations so far : ['98-17=81', '70+81=151'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 151-99=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99+151=250. \nResulting numbers: [250].\n250,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99*151=14949. \nResulting numbers: [14949].\n14949,86 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 39.0\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 86:[99, 151]. Operations so far : ['70-17=53', '98+53=151'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99+151=250. \nResulting numbers: [250].\n250,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 151-99=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99*151=14949. \nResulting numbers: [14949].\n14949,86 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 39.0\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 86:[98, 152]. Operations so far : ['99-17=82', '70+82=152'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 152-98=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98*152=14896. \nResulting numbers: [14896].\n14896,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+152=250. \nResulting numbers: [250].\n250,86 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 32\nCurrent State #0,0,3,0: 86:[54]. Operations so far : ['99-17=82', '70+82=152', '152-98=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,2,3,1: 86:[52]. Operations so far : ['70-17=53', '98+53=151', '151-99=52'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,1,2,0: 86:[52]. Operations so far : ['98-17=81', '70+81=151', '151-99=52'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4 with lowest heuristic value 39.0\nCurrent State #0,2,4: 86:[98, 152]. Operations so far : ['70-17=53', '99+53=152'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98+152=250. \nResulting numbers: [250].\n250,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98*152=14896. \nResulting numbers: [14896].\n14896,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 152-98=54. \nResulting numbers: [54].\n54,86 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 42.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 86:[70, 18]. Operations so far : ['98-17=81', '99-81=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*18=1260. \nResulting numbers: [1260].\n1260,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-18=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+18=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,86 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,1,0,2: 86:[88]. Operations so far : ['98-17=81', '99-81=18', '70+18=88'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 32\nCurrent State #0,2,4,2: 86:[54]. Operations so far : ['70-17=53', '99+53=152', '152-98=54'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 34\nCurrent State #0,1,0,1: 86:[52]. Operations so far : ['98-17=81', '99-81=18', '70-18=52'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 42.0\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 86:[70, 18]. Operations so far : ['99+17=116', '116-98=18'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70-18=52. \nResulting numbers: [52].\n52,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70*18=1260. \nResulting numbers: [1260].\n1260,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 70+18=88. \nResulting numbers: [88].\n88,86 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 43.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 86:[98, 12]. Operations so far : ['70+17=87', '99-87=12'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98*12=1176. \nResulting numbers: [1176].\n1176,86 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-12=86. \nResulting numbers: [86].\n86,86 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['70+17=87', '99-87=12', '98-12=86']\nRESULT: 86\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 7,521 |
[
88,
93,
67,
33
]
| 29 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [88, 93, 67, 33] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 29. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [88, 93, 67, 33]. Our goal is to produce 29. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 29:[88, 93, 67, 33]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-67=26. \nResulting numbers: [88, 33, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|88-29| + |33-29| + |26-29|)/3 = (59 + 4 + 3)/3 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 29:[88, 33, 26] Operation: 93-67=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-33=55. \nResulting numbers: [93, 67, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|93-29| + |67-29| + |55-29|)/3 = (64 + 38 + 26)/3 = 42.67\nGenerated Node #0,1: 29:[93, 67, 55] Operation: 88-33=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-88=5. \nResulting numbers: [67, 33, 5].\nHeuristic score : (|67-29| + |33-29| + |5-29|)/3 = (38 + 4 + 24)/3 = 22.00\nGenerated Node #0,2: 29:[67, 33, 5] Operation: 93-88=5\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-33=60. \nResulting numbers: [88, 67, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|88-29| + |67-29| + |60-29|)/3 = (59 + 38 + 31)/3 = 42.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 29:[88, 67, 60] Operation: 93-33=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-67=21. \nResulting numbers: [93, 33, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|93-29| + |33-29| + |21-29|)/3 = (64 + 4 + 8)/3 = 25.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 29:[93, 33, 21] Operation: 88-67=21\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 29:[88, 33, 26]. Operations so far : ['93-67=26'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+26=114. \nResulting numbers: [33, 114].\nHeuristic score : (|33-29| + |114-29|)/2 = (4 + 85)/2 = 44.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 29:[33, 114] Operation: 88+26=114\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-33=55. \nResulting numbers: [26, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|26-29| + |55-29|)/2 = (3 + 26)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 29:[26, 55] Operation: 88-33=55\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-26=62. \nResulting numbers: [33, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|33-29| + |62-29|)/2 = (4 + 33)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 29:[33, 62] Operation: 88-26=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+26=59. \nResulting numbers: [88, 59].\nHeuristic score : (|88-29| + |59-29|)/2 = (59 + 30)/2 = 44.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 29:[88, 59] Operation: 33+26=59\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-26=7. \nResulting numbers: [88, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|88-29| + |7-29|)/2 = (59 + 22)/2 = 40.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 29:[88, 7] Operation: 33-26=7\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 22.0\nCurrent State #0,2: 29:[67, 33, 5]. Operations so far : ['93-88=5'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-5=62. \nResulting numbers: [33, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|33-29| + |62-29|)/2 = (4 + 33)/2 = 18.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 29:[33, 62] Operation: 67-5=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-5=28. \nResulting numbers: [67, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|67-29| + |28-29|)/2 = (38 + 1)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 29:[67, 28] Operation: 33-5=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67+5=72. \nResulting numbers: [33, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|33-29| + |72-29|)/2 = (4 + 43)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 29:[33, 72] Operation: 67+5=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-33=34. \nResulting numbers: [5, 34].\nHeuristic score : (|5-29| + |34-29|)/2 = (24 + 5)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 29:[5, 34] Operation: 67-33=34\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+5=38. \nResulting numbers: [67, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|67-29| + |38-29|)/2 = (38 + 9)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 29:[67, 38] Operation: 33+5=38\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,4: 29:[93, 33, 21]. Operations so far : ['88-67=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-21=72. \nResulting numbers: [33, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|33-29| + |72-29|)/2 = (4 + 43)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 29:[33, 72] Operation: 93-21=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-33=60. \nResulting numbers: [21, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|21-29| + |60-29|)/2 = (8 + 31)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 29:[21, 60] Operation: 93-33=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+21=54. \nResulting numbers: [93, 54].\nHeuristic score : (|93-29| + |54-29|)/2 = (64 + 25)/2 = 44.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 29:[93, 54] Operation: 33+21=54\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+21=114. \nResulting numbers: [33, 114].\nHeuristic score : (|33-29| + |114-29|)/2 = (4 + 85)/2 = 44.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 29:[33, 114] Operation: 93+21=114\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-21=12. \nResulting numbers: [93, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|93-29| + |12-29|)/2 = (64 + 17)/2 = 40.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 29:[93, 12] Operation: 33-21=12\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,1: 29:[93, 67, 55]. Operations so far : ['88-33=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-55=12. \nResulting numbers: [93, 12].\nHeuristic score : (|93-29| + |12-29|)/2 = (64 + 17)/2 = 40.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 29:[93, 12] Operation: 67-55=12\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-55=38. \nResulting numbers: [67, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|67-29| + |38-29|)/2 = (38 + 9)/2 = 23.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 29:[67, 38] Operation: 93-55=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+55=148. \nResulting numbers: [67, 148].\nHeuristic score : (|67-29| + |148-29|)/2 = (38 + 119)/2 = 78.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 29:[67, 148] Operation: 93+55=148\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-67=26. \nResulting numbers: [55, 26].\nHeuristic score : (|55-29| + |26-29|)/2 = (26 + 3)/2 = 14.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 29:[55, 26] Operation: 93-67=26\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+67=160. \nResulting numbers: [55, 160].\nHeuristic score : (|55-29| + |160-29|)/2 = (26 + 131)/2 = 78.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 29:[55, 160] Operation: 93+67=160\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 42.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 29:[88, 67, 60]. Operations so far : ['93-33=60'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+67=155. \nResulting numbers: [60, 155].\nHeuristic score : (|60-29| + |155-29|)/2 = (31 + 126)/2 = 78.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 29:[60, 155] Operation: 88+67=155\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-60=7. \nResulting numbers: [88, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|88-29| + |7-29|)/2 = (59 + 22)/2 = 40.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 29:[88, 7] Operation: 67-60=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-67=21. \nResulting numbers: [60, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|60-29| + |21-29|)/2 = (31 + 8)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 29:[60, 21] Operation: 88-67=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-60=28. \nResulting numbers: [67, 28].\nHeuristic score : (|67-29| + |28-29|)/2 = (38 + 1)/2 = 19.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 29:[67, 28] Operation: 88-60=28\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88+60=148. \nResulting numbers: [67, 148].\nHeuristic score : (|67-29| + |148-29|)/2 = (38 + 119)/2 = 78.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 29:[67, 148] Operation: 88+60=148\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,1 with lowest heuristic value 14.5\nCurrent State #0,0,1: 29:[26, 55]. Operations so far : ['93-67=26', '88-33=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 55-26=29. \nResulting numbers: [29].\n29,29 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['93-67=26', '88-33=55', '55-26=29']\nRESULT: 29\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 3,741 |
[
79,
86,
67,
81
]
| 38 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [79, 86, 67, 81] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 38. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [79, 86, 67, 81]. Our goal is to produce 38. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 38:[79, 86, 67, 81]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86-79=7. \nResulting numbers: [67, 81, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|67-38| + |81-38| + |7-38|)/3 = (29 + 43 + 31)/3 = 34.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 38:[67, 81, 7] Operation: 86-79=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-67=14. \nResulting numbers: [7, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|7-38| + |14-38|)/2 = (31 + 24)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 38:[7, 14] Operation: 81-67=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 7+14=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,38 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 38:[67, 81, 7]. Operations so far : ['86-79=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67-7=60. \nResulting numbers: [81, 60].\nHeuristic score : (|81-38| + |60-38|)/2 = (43 + 22)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 38:[81, 60] Operation: 67-7=60\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-60=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,38 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 38:[67, 81, 7]. Operations so far : ['86-79=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-7=74. \nResulting numbers: [67, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|67-38| + |74-38|)/2 = (29 + 36)/2 = 32.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 38:[67, 74] Operation: 81-7=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 74-67=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,38 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 38:[67, 81, 7]. Operations so far : ['86-79=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67+7=74. \nResulting numbers: [81, 74].\nHeuristic score : (|81-38| + |74-38|)/2 = (43 + 36)/2 = 39.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 38:[81, 74] Operation: 67+7=74\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-74=7. \nResulting numbers: [7].\n7,38 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 38:[67, 81, 7]. Operations so far : ['86-79=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81+7=88. \nResulting numbers: [67, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|67-38| + |88-38|)/2 = (29 + 50)/2 = 39.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 38:[67, 88] Operation: 81+7=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 88-67=21. \nResulting numbers: [21].\n21,38 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 38:[67, 81, 7]. Operations so far : ['86-79=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 6th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67+81=148. \nResulting numbers: [7, 148].\nHeuristic score : (|7-38| + |148-38|)/2 = (31 + 110)/2 = 70.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,5: 38:[7, 148] Operation: 67+81=148\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,5’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 148-7=141. \nResulting numbers: [141].\n141,38 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 38:[67, 81, 7]. Operations so far : ['86-79=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 7th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67*7=469. \nResulting numbers: [81, 469].\nHeuristic score : (|81-38| + |469-38|)/2 = (43 + 431)/2 = 237.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,6: 38:[81, 469] Operation: 67*7=469\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,6’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 469-81=388. \nResulting numbers: [388].\n388,38 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 38:[67, 81, 7]. Operations so far : ['86-79=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 8th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81*7=567. \nResulting numbers: [67, 567].\nHeuristic score : (|67-38| + |567-38|)/2 = (29 + 529)/2 = 279.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,7: 38:[67, 567] Operation: 81*7=567\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,7’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 567-67=500. \nResulting numbers: [500].\n500,38 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,0: 38:[67, 81, 7]. Operations so far : ['86-79=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 9th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 67*81=5427. \nResulting numbers: [7, 5427].\nHeuristic score : (|7-38| + |5427-38|)/2 = (31 + 5389)/2 = 2710.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,8: 38:[7, 5427] Operation: 67*81=5427\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,8’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 5427-7=5420. \nResulting numbers: [5420].\n5420,38 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0 with lowest heuristic value 40.25\nCurrent State #0: 38:[79, 86, 67, 81]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 86-67=19. \nResulting numbers: [79, 81, 19].\nHeuristic score : (|79-38| + |81-38| + |19-38|)/3 = (41 + 43 + 19)/3 = 34.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 38:[79, 81, 19] Operation: 86-67=19\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 81-79=2. \nResulting numbers: [19, 2].\nHeuristic score : (|19-38| + |2-38|)/2 = (19 + 36)/2 = 27.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 38:[19, 2] Operation: 81-79=2\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 19*2=38. \nResulting numbers: [38].\n38,38 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['86-67=19', '81-79=2', '19*2=38']\nRESULT: 38\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 2,529 |
[
10,
15,
33,
5
]
| 98 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [10, 15, 33, 5] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 98. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [10, 15, 33, 5]. Our goal is to produce 98. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 98:[10, 15, 33, 5]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 15*5=75. \nResulting numbers: [10, 33, 75].\nHeuristic score : (|10-98| + |33-98| + |75-98|)/3 = (88 + 65 + 23)/3 = 58.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 98:[10, 33, 75] Operation: 15*5=75\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 10+33=43. \nResulting numbers: [75, 43].\nHeuristic score : (|75-98| + |43-98|)/2 = (23 + 55)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 98:[75, 43] Operation: 10+33=43\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+43=118. \nResulting numbers: [118].\n118,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 58.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[10, 33, 75]. Operations so far : ['15*5=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 10+75=85. \nResulting numbers: [33, 85].\nHeuristic score : (|33-98| + |85-98|)/2 = (65 + 13)/2 = 39.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 98:[33, 85] Operation: 10+75=85\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33+85=118. \nResulting numbers: [118].\n118,98 unequal: No Solution ... backtracking\n\nThought : Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 58.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,0: 98:[10, 33, 75]. Operations so far : ['15*5=75'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 33-10=23. \nResulting numbers: [75, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|75-98| + |23-98|)/2 = (23 + 75)/2 = 49.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 98:[75, 23] Operation: 33-10=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 75+23=98. \nResulting numbers: [98].\n98,98 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['15*5=75', '33-10=23', '75+23=98']\nRESULT: 98\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 870 |
[
81,
82,
99,
96
]
| 32 | dfs | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [81, 82, 99, 96] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 32. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [81, 82, 99, 96]. Our goal is to produce 32. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Depth-First Search (DFS) guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 32:[81, 82, 99, 96]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-81=18. \nResulting numbers: [82, 96, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|82-32| + |96-32| + |18-32|)/3 = (50 + 64 + 14)/3 = 42.67\nGenerated Node #0,0: 32:[82, 96, 18] Operation: 99-81=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 96-82=14. \nResulting numbers: [18, 14].\nHeuristic score : (|18-32| + |14-32|)/2 = (14 + 18)/2 = 16.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 32:[18, 14] Operation: 96-82=14\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 18+14=32. \nResulting numbers: [32].\n32,32 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['99-81=18', '96-82=14', '18+14=32']\nRESULT: 32\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 428 |
[
1,
93,
61,
37
]
| 70 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [1, 93, 61, 37] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 70. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [1, 93, 61, 37]. Our goal is to produce 70. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 70:[1, 93, 61, 37]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1+37=38. \nResulting numbers: [93, 61, 38].\nHeuristic score : (|93-70| + |61-70| + |38-70|)/3 = (23 + 9 + 32)/3 = 21.33\nGenerated Node #0,0: 70:[93, 61, 38] Operation: 1+37=38\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-1=92. \nResulting numbers: [61, 37, 92].\nHeuristic score : (|61-70| + |37-70| + |92-70|)/3 = (9 + 33 + 22)/3 = 21.33\nGenerated Node #0,1: 70:[61, 37, 92] Operation: 93-1=92\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93/1=93. \nResulting numbers: [61, 37, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|61-70| + |37-70| + |93-70|)/3 = (9 + 33 + 23)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,2: 70:[61, 37, 93] Operation: 93/1=93\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1+61=62. \nResulting numbers: [93, 37, 62].\nHeuristic score : (|93-70| + |37-70| + |62-70|)/3 = (23 + 33 + 8)/3 = 21.33\nGenerated Node #0,3: 70:[93, 37, 62] Operation: 1+61=62\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 1*93=93. \nResulting numbers: [61, 37, 93].\nHeuristic score : (|61-70| + |37-70| + |93-70|)/3 = (9 + 33 + 23)/3 = 21.67\nGenerated Node #0,4: 70:[61, 37, 93] Operation: 1*93=93\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,0: 70:[93, 61, 38]. Operations so far : ['1+37=38'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+38=131. \nResulting numbers: [61, 131].\nHeuristic score : (|61-70| + |131-70|)/2 = (9 + 61)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 70:[61, 131] Operation: 93+38=131\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-38=23. \nResulting numbers: [93, 23].\nHeuristic score : (|93-70| + |23-70|)/2 = (23 + 47)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 70:[93, 23] Operation: 61-38=23\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-61=32. \nResulting numbers: [38, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|38-70| + |32-70|)/2 = (32 + 38)/2 = 35.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 70:[38, 32] Operation: 93-61=32\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+38=99. \nResulting numbers: [93, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|93-70| + |99-70|)/2 = (23 + 29)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 70:[93, 99] Operation: 61+38=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-38=55. \nResulting numbers: [61, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|61-70| + |55-70|)/2 = (9 + 15)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 70:[61, 55] Operation: 93-38=55\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,3: 70:[93, 37, 62]. Operations so far : ['1+61=62'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-37=25. \nResulting numbers: [93, 25].\nHeuristic score : (|93-70| + |25-70|)/2 = (23 + 45)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 70:[93, 25] Operation: 62-37=25\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-37=56. \nResulting numbers: [62, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|62-70| + |56-70|)/2 = (8 + 14)/2 = 11.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 70:[62, 56] Operation: 93-37=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+62=99. \nResulting numbers: [93, 99].\nHeuristic score : (|93-70| + |99-70|)/2 = (23 + 29)/2 = 26.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 70:[93, 99] Operation: 37+62=99\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+37=130. \nResulting numbers: [62, 130].\nHeuristic score : (|62-70| + |130-70|)/2 = (8 + 60)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 70:[62, 130] Operation: 93+37=130\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-62=31. \nResulting numbers: [37, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|37-70| + |31-70|)/2 = (33 + 39)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 70:[37, 31] Operation: 93-62=31\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 21.333333333333332\nCurrent State #0,1: 70:[61, 37, 92]. Operations so far : ['93-1=92'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+37=98. \nResulting numbers: [92, 98].\nHeuristic score : (|92-70| + |98-70|)/2 = (22 + 28)/2 = 25.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 70:[92, 98] Operation: 61+37=98\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-61=31. \nResulting numbers: [37, 31].\nHeuristic score : (|37-70| + |31-70|)/2 = (33 + 39)/2 = 36.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 70:[37, 31] Operation: 92-61=31\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+92=129. \nResulting numbers: [61, 129].\nHeuristic score : (|61-70| + |129-70|)/2 = (9 + 59)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 70:[61, 129] Operation: 37+92=129\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-37=24. \nResulting numbers: [92, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|92-70| + |24-70|)/2 = (22 + 46)/2 = 34.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 70:[92, 24] Operation: 61-37=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-37=55. \nResulting numbers: [61, 55].\nHeuristic score : (|61-70| + |55-70|)/2 = (9 + 15)/2 = 12.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 70:[61, 55] Operation: 92-37=55\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,2: 70:[61, 37, 93]. Operations so far : ['93/1=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+37=98. \nResulting numbers: [93, 98].\nHeuristic score : (|93-70| + |98-70|)/2 = (23 + 28)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 70:[93, 98] Operation: 61+37=98\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-37=24. \nResulting numbers: [93, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|93-70| + |24-70|)/2 = (23 + 46)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 70:[93, 24] Operation: 61-37=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-37=56. \nResulting numbers: [61, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|61-70| + |56-70|)/2 = (9 + 14)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 70:[61, 56] Operation: 93-37=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+93=130. \nResulting numbers: [61, 130].\nHeuristic score : (|61-70| + |130-70|)/2 = (9 + 60)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 70:[61, 130] Operation: 37+93=130\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-61=32. \nResulting numbers: [37, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|37-70| + |32-70|)/2 = (33 + 38)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 70:[37, 32] Operation: 93-61=32\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 21.666666666666668\nCurrent State #0,4: 70:[61, 37, 93]. Operations so far : ['1*93=93'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-37=56. \nResulting numbers: [61, 56].\nHeuristic score : (|61-70| + |56-70|)/2 = (9 + 14)/2 = 11.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 70:[61, 56] Operation: 93-37=56\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-37=24. \nResulting numbers: [93, 24].\nHeuristic score : (|93-70| + |24-70|)/2 = (23 + 46)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 70:[93, 24] Operation: 61-37=24\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 37+93=130. \nResulting numbers: [61, 130].\nHeuristic score : (|61-70| + |130-70|)/2 = (9 + 60)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 70:[61, 130] Operation: 37+93=130\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-61=32. \nResulting numbers: [37, 32].\nHeuristic score : (|37-70| + |32-70|)/2 = (33 + 38)/2 = 35.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 70:[37, 32] Operation: 93-61=32\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+37=98. \nResulting numbers: [93, 98].\nHeuristic score : (|93-70| + |98-70|)/2 = (23 + 28)/2 = 25.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 70:[93, 98] Operation: 61+37=98\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 11.0\nCurrent State #0,3,1: 70:[62, 56]. Operations so far : ['1+61=62', '93-37=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62*56=3472. \nResulting numbers: [3472].\n3472,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62-56=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+56=118. \nResulting numbers: [118].\n118,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 11.5\nCurrent State #0,2,2: 70:[61, 56]. Operations so far : ['93/1=93', '93-37=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*56=3416. \nResulting numbers: [3416].\n3416,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-56=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+56=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,0 with lowest heuristic value 11.5\nCurrent State #0,4,0: 70:[61, 56]. Operations so far : ['1*93=93', '93-37=56'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+56=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-56=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*56=3416. \nResulting numbers: [3416].\n3416,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 12.0\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 70:[61, 55]. Operations so far : ['1+37=38', '93-38=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-55=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+55=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*55=3355. \nResulting numbers: [3355].\n3355,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,4 with lowest heuristic value 12.0\nCurrent State #0,1,4: 70:[61, 55]. Operations so far : ['93-1=92', '92-37=55'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+55=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61-55=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*55=3355. \nResulting numbers: [3355].\n3355,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.0\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 70:[92, 98]. Operations so far : ['93-1=92', '61+37=98'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92*98=9016. \nResulting numbers: [9016].\n9016,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-92=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92+98=190. \nResulting numbers: [190].\n190,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,4 with lowest heuristic value 25.5\nCurrent State #0,4,4: 70:[93, 98]. Operations so far : ['1*93=93', '61+37=98'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+98=191. \nResulting numbers: [191].\n191,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93*98=9114. \nResulting numbers: [9114].\n9114,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-93=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 25.5\nCurrent State #0,2,0: 70:[93, 98]. Operations so far : ['93/1=93', '61+37=98'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 98-93=5. \nResulting numbers: [5].\n5,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93*98=9114. \nResulting numbers: [9114].\n9114,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+98=191. \nResulting numbers: [191].\n191,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,2 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,3,2: 70:[93, 99]. Operations so far : ['1+61=62', '37+62=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+99=192. \nResulting numbers: [192].\n192,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-93=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93*99=9207. \nResulting numbers: [9207].\n9207,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,3 with lowest heuristic value 26.0\nCurrent State #0,0,3: 70:[93, 99]. Operations so far : ['1+37=38', '61+38=99'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+99=192. \nResulting numbers: [192].\n192,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 99-93=6. \nResulting numbers: [6].\n6,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93*99=9207. \nResulting numbers: [9207].\n9207,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 34.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 70:[92, 24]. Operations so far : ['93-1=92', '61-37=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-24=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92+24=116. \nResulting numbers: [116].\n116,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92*24=2208. \nResulting numbers: [2208].\n2208,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2 with lowest heuristic value 34.0\nCurrent State #0,1,2: 70:[61, 129]. Operations so far : ['93-1=92', '37+92=129'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 129-61=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+129=190. \nResulting numbers: [190].\n190,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*129=7869. \nResulting numbers: [7869].\n7869,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3 with lowest heuristic value 34.0\nCurrent State #0,3,3: 70:[62, 130]. Operations so far : ['1+61=62', '93+37=130'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62*130=8060. \nResulting numbers: [8060].\n8060,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 130-62=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 62+130=192. \nResulting numbers: [192].\n192,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.0\nCurrent State #0,3,0: 70:[93, 25]. Operations so far : ['1+61=62', '62-37=25'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+25=118. \nResulting numbers: [118].\n118,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93*25=2325. \nResulting numbers: [2325].\n2325,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-25=68. \nResulting numbers: [68].\n68,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,4,2: 70:[61, 130]. Operations so far : ['1*93=93', '37+93=130'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+130=191. \nResulting numbers: [191].\n191,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*130=7930. \nResulting numbers: [7930].\n7930,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 130-61=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,2,2 with lowest heuristic value 1\nCurrent State #0,4,2,2: 70:[69]. Operations so far : ['1*93=93', '37+93=130', '130-61=69'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3,0 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,1,3,0: 70:[68]. Operations so far : ['93-1=92', '61-37=24', '92-24=68'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,3,0,2: 70:[68]. Operations so far : ['1+61=62', '62-37=25', '93-25=68'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,2,0 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,1,2,0: 70:[68]. Operations so far : ['93-1=92', '37+92=129', '129-61=68'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3,3,1 with lowest heuristic value 2\nCurrent State #0,3,3,1: 70:[68]. Operations so far : ['1+61=62', '93+37=130', '130-62=68'].\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4,1 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,4,1: 70:[93, 24]. Operations so far : ['1*93=93', '61-37=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-24=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93*24=2232. \nResulting numbers: [2232].\n2232,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+24=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,3 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,2,3: 70:[61, 130]. Operations so far : ['93/1=93', '37+93=130'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61+130=191. \nResulting numbers: [191].\n191,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 130-61=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 61*130=7930. \nResulting numbers: [7930].\n7930,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2,1 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,2,1: 70:[93, 24]. Operations so far : ['93/1=93', '61-37=24'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93*24=2232. \nResulting numbers: [2232].\n2232,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93-24=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,70 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 93+24=117. \nResulting numbers: [117].\n117,70 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 35.0\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 70:[38, 32]. Operations so far : ['1+37=38', '93-61=32'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 38+32=70. \nResulting numbers: [70].\n70,70 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['1+37=38', '93-61=32', '38-32=6']\nRESULT: 6\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 8,484 |
[
92,
3,
79,
85
]
| 24 | bfs_5 | sum_heuristic | [
{
"content": "Combine these initial numbers [92, 3, 79, 85] using only arithmetic operations (+, -, *, /) to reach the target value 24. All initial numbers must be used exactly once.\nConclude with the final result in EXACTLY this format:\n```\nSOLUTION: YES/NO\nOPERATIONS: list of string of operations performed, each string involving only 1 operation. For example, ['A+B=C','C+D=E'] is allowed, ['A+B+D=E'] is not allowed\nRESULT: final_value\n```\n",
"role": "user"
},
{
"content": "We have these numbers [92, 3, 79, 85]. Our goal is to produce 24. Let's show the search process step by step:\nOne possible strategy is to use a Breadth-First Search (BFS) with Beam Size 5 guided by a **sum-based** heuristic, which computes the average of the absolute differences between each number and the target number.\nLower scores indicate that, on average, the numbers are closer to the target, making the state more promising for reaching the target via additive operations.\n\n\nCurrent State #0: 24:[92, 3, 79, 85]. Operations so far : [].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-79=13. \nResulting numbers: [3, 85, 13].\nHeuristic score : (|3-24| + |85-24| + |13-24|)/3 = (21 + 61 + 11)/3 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,0: 24:[3, 85, 13] Operation: 92-79=13\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-85=7. \nResulting numbers: [3, 79, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|3-24| + |79-24| + |7-24|)/3 = (21 + 55 + 17)/3 = 31.00\nGenerated Node #0,1: 24:[3, 79, 7] Operation: 92-85=7\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-3=76. \nResulting numbers: [92, 85, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|92-24| + |85-24| + |76-24|)/3 = (68 + 61 + 52)/3 = 60.33\nGenerated Node #0,2: 24:[92, 85, 76] Operation: 79-3=76\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-79=6. \nResulting numbers: [92, 3, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|92-24| + |3-24| + |6-24|)/3 = (68 + 21 + 18)/3 = 35.67\nGenerated Node #0,3: 24:[92, 3, 6] Operation: 85-79=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-3=89. \nResulting numbers: [79, 85, 89].\nHeuristic score : (|79-24| + |85-24| + |89-24|)/3 = (55 + 61 + 65)/3 = 60.33\nGenerated Node #0,4: 24:[79, 85, 89] Operation: 92-3=89\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,0: 24:[3, 85, 13]. Operations so far : ['92-79=13'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 13-3=10. \nResulting numbers: [85, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|85-24| + |10-24|)/2 = (61 + 14)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,0: 24:[85, 10] Operation: 13-3=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+85=88. \nResulting numbers: [13, 88].\nHeuristic score : (|13-24| + |88-24|)/2 = (11 + 64)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,1: 24:[13, 88] Operation: 3+85=88\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+13=16. \nResulting numbers: [85, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|85-24| + |16-24|)/2 = (61 + 8)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,2: 24:[85, 16] Operation: 3+13=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-3=82. \nResulting numbers: [13, 82].\nHeuristic score : (|13-24| + |82-24|)/2 = (11 + 58)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,3: 24:[13, 82] Operation: 85-3=82\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-13=72. \nResulting numbers: [3, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|3-24| + |72-24|)/2 = (21 + 48)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,0,4: 24:[3, 72] Operation: 85-13=72\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1 with lowest heuristic value 31.0\nCurrent State #0,1: 24:[3, 79, 7]. Operations so far : ['92-85=7'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+7=10. \nResulting numbers: [79, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|79-24| + |10-24|)/2 = (55 + 14)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,0: 24:[79, 10] Operation: 3+7=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-7=72. \nResulting numbers: [3, 72].\nHeuristic score : (|3-24| + |72-24|)/2 = (21 + 48)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,1: 24:[3, 72] Operation: 79-7=72\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+79=82. \nResulting numbers: [7, 82].\nHeuristic score : (|7-24| + |82-24|)/2 = (17 + 58)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,2: 24:[7, 82] Operation: 3+79=82\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3*7=21. \nResulting numbers: [79, 21].\nHeuristic score : (|79-24| + |21-24|)/2 = (55 + 3)/2 = 29.00\nGenerated Node #0,1,3: 24:[79, 21] Operation: 3*7=21\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-3=76. \nResulting numbers: [7, 76].\nHeuristic score : (|7-24| + |76-24|)/2 = (17 + 52)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,1,4: 24:[7, 76] Operation: 79-3=76\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,3 with lowest heuristic value 35.666666666666664\nCurrent State #0,3: 24:[92, 3, 6]. Operations so far : ['85-79=6'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3+6=9. \nResulting numbers: [92, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|92-24| + |9-24|)/2 = (68 + 15)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,0: 24:[92, 9] Operation: 3+6=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 3*6=18. \nResulting numbers: [92, 18].\nHeuristic score : (|92-24| + |18-24|)/2 = (68 + 6)/2 = 37.00\nGenerated Node #0,3,1: 24:[92, 18] Operation: 3*6=18\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-6=86. \nResulting numbers: [3, 86].\nHeuristic score : (|3-24| + |86-24|)/2 = (21 + 62)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,2: 24:[3, 86] Operation: 92-6=86\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-3=89. \nResulting numbers: [6, 89].\nHeuristic score : (|6-24| + |89-24|)/2 = (18 + 65)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,3: 24:[6, 89] Operation: 92-3=89\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,3’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92+3=95. \nResulting numbers: [6, 95].\nHeuristic score : (|6-24| + |95-24|)/2 = (18 + 71)/2 = 44.50\nGenerated Node #0,3,4: 24:[6, 95] Operation: 92+3=95\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,2 with lowest heuristic value 60.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,2: 24:[92, 85, 76]. Operations so far : ['79-3=76'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92+85=177. \nResulting numbers: [76, 177].\nHeuristic score : (|76-24| + |177-24|)/2 = (52 + 153)/2 = 102.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,0: 24:[76, 177] Operation: 92+85=177\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92+76=168. \nResulting numbers: [85, 168].\nHeuristic score : (|85-24| + |168-24|)/2 = (61 + 144)/2 = 102.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,1: 24:[85, 168] Operation: 92+76=168\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-76=9. \nResulting numbers: [92, 9].\nHeuristic score : (|92-24| + |9-24|)/2 = (68 + 15)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,2: 24:[92, 9] Operation: 85-76=9\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-76=16. \nResulting numbers: [85, 16].\nHeuristic score : (|85-24| + |16-24|)/2 = (61 + 8)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,3: 24:[85, 16] Operation: 92-76=16\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,2’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 92-85=7. \nResulting numbers: [76, 7].\nHeuristic score : (|76-24| + |7-24|)/2 = (52 + 17)/2 = 34.50\nGenerated Node #0,2,4: 24:[76, 7] Operation: 92-85=7\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,4 with lowest heuristic value 60.333333333333336\nCurrent State #0,4: 24:[79, 85, 89]. Operations so far : ['92-3=89'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-79=10. \nResulting numbers: [85, 10].\nHeuristic score : (|85-24| + |10-24|)/2 = (61 + 14)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,0: 24:[85, 10] Operation: 89-79=10\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+89=168. \nResulting numbers: [85, 168].\nHeuristic score : (|85-24| + |168-24|)/2 = (61 + 144)/2 = 102.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,1: 24:[85, 168] Operation: 79+89=168\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-79=6. \nResulting numbers: [89, 6].\nHeuristic score : (|89-24| + |6-24|)/2 = (65 + 18)/2 = 41.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,2: 24:[89, 6] Operation: 85-79=6\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 4th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 89-85=4. \nResulting numbers: [79, 4].\nHeuristic score : (|79-24| + |4-24|)/2 = (55 + 20)/2 = 37.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,3: 24:[79, 4] Operation: 89-85=4\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,4’s 5th child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+85=164. \nResulting numbers: [89, 164].\nHeuristic score : (|89-24| + |164-24|)/2 = (65 + 140)/2 = 102.50\nGenerated Node #0,4,4: 24:[89, 164] Operation: 79+85=164\n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,3 with lowest heuristic value 29.0\nCurrent State #0,1,3: 24:[79, 21]. Operations so far : ['92-85=7', '3*7=21'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-21=58. \nResulting numbers: [58].\n58,24 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*21=1659. \nResulting numbers: [1659].\n1659,24 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,3’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+21=100. \nResulting numbers: [100].\n100,24 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,2 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,0,2: 24:[85, 16]. Operations so far : ['92-79=13', '3+13=16'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85-16=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,24 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85*16=1360. \nResulting numbers: [1360].\n1360,24 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,2’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 85+16=101. \nResulting numbers: [101].\n101,24 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,1,0 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,1,0: 24:[79, 10]. Operations so far : ['92-85=7', '3+7=10'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79*10=790. \nResulting numbers: [790].\n790,24 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79+10=89. \nResulting numbers: [89].\n89,24 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,1,0’s 3rd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 79-10=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,24 unequal: No solution after expanding all children at current level ... backtracking \n\nThought : Completed expansion of previous level. Selecting next node to expand based on heuristic value\nAction : Moving to Node #0,0,4 with lowest heuristic value 34.5\nCurrent State #0,0,4: 24:[3, 72]. Operations so far : ['92-79=13', '85-13=72'].\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 1st child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72-3=69. \nResulting numbers: [69].\n69,24 unequal: No Solution\n\nThought : Expand Node #0,0,4’s 2nd child to build next frontier.\nAction : Exploring operation 72/3=24. \nResulting numbers: [24].\n24,24 equal: Goal Reached\n\n```\nSOLUTION: YES\nOPERATIONS: ['92-79=13', '85-13=72', '72/3=24']\nRESULT: 24\n```\n",
"role": "assistant"
}
]
| 4,508 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.